Plus points for this apartment: it's very clean, the air conditioning and balcony area are great on hot days, and it's in a quiet part of the New Town with good amenities nearby, close to the train and bus stations.
Negative points: there's no living room as advertised (there's a dining table in the kitchen area, and a hallway with a sofa). The shower has no barrier, so the water washes straight out onto the bathroom floor unless you lay several towels down to block it. The main bed is two singles pushed together, and these tend to come apart during the night.
Also, there's no dustpan, condiments, teaspoons, kettle, tea towel, coffee or kitchen roll. Every other Airbnb apartment we've stayed in has had all or most of these; seems such an easy fix.
Finally, a cleaner comes every day, but we weren't informed about this. Mentioning so others know.