We chose Giuliana's place based on the strength of all the reviews and the picture of the roof terrace. We loved the apartment and agreed it definitely justified all the 5* ratings. The terrace was a huge bonus and the location was perfect. We had dinner at Capo de Fero (4 min walk away) based on Giuliana's recommendation and it was amazing! Also would recommend breakfast at Giselda (a few minutes walk away)
We were waking up early in the morning so didn't find this too much of an issue, but the curtains are quite thin and don't cover the windows fully so you do wake up with the sun in the morning. Not too much of an issue if you are planning to be out and about early though!