Pros:
-Great location! Many wonderful restaurants just a stones throw away. A short walk to the city's main attractions. We mostly rode the buses to save our feet and the bus stops were very close. There one of the city's water springs right by the apartment.
-Cute brick arches in the apartment. It's fun to wonder how old those date back.
-The bathtub is gorgeous and the statue spigot on it is a replica of the fountain in the Vatican under the 2000 yr old pinecone sculpture. -Can't really use the bathtub well, but more on that below.
-The apartment has everything you could need and the garden terrace is an absolute dream in the middle of the city!
-The place was clean and the bed and pillows were soft (a rare thing in Italy we discovered).
Cons:
-The water gets hot enough to shower in comfort but not very hot for a bath. We tried having a bath and the hot/warm water only made it about 4 inches high before turning cold. Also the water pressure to fill the tub was very little and took a LONG time to fill it even a little. We ended up heating pots and kettles of water on the stove to get the tub warm and water level high enough to enjoy. It took forever and water wasn't hot enough to really enjoy it. So don't count on using the bath unless they say they replace the water heater.
-The stairs got to be a bit much as this apartment is layed out on 4 different levels. If you sleep upstairs, you need to traverse the three stair cases down and then back up in order to get to the bathroom.
-No central lighting and so sometimes the lighting is a bit of a trick. Some lamps turn on by a switch and some you must flip the switch on their cord. Also some of the plugs don't work.
-The toilet is in the shower. Maybe there was no room for it anywhere else and there is still room to stand in the shower, but it's just something to note.