Pros:
Luca, though we never saw him in person, was a very responsive and helpful host. He was always available by phone and gave us tips and answered all of our questions. The bed was comfortable enough and the area was quiet and seemed safe enough, we had a good nights sleep.
Cons:
Nowhere in the listing tells you that the bathroom is shared. We were not told about this until the day before our stay, when it was too late to cancel. We would not have stayed here if we’d known that we’d be sharing a bathroom with strangers. Also, the shower is teeny tiny and the water temperature is impossible to control. There were also ants crawling around the bathroom floor. And, while we were taking a nap around 4pm in our room, with the door locked, a woman (presumably a maid) unlocked our door and came into our room (extra awkward because we were naked, since it was a boiling hot August day.)
If none of these are dealbreakers for you, it’s a good deal. But I would not be able to stay here again.