We stayed in Maddalena’s apartment in February 2019 and it was warm, very clean, well-stocked, and the bed was extremely comfortable. The location was so convenient (a five minute walk to the Colosseum) and all the buses outside the door took us wherever we wanted to go. It made our trip to Rome even better. Maddalena was extreme helpful and very responsive.
A small downside is that the hall of the apartment block is very echoing so you will hear noises of people going in and out. However it didn’t bother us and we slept like logs in the comfortable bed. I think it might only be an issue if you have a baby with you.