We enjoyed our stay at Andreas's place, but we couldn't award a 4- or 5-star rating for a few reasons.
First, the good:
- Great overall location for Rome visitors
- Nice patio area for those who enjoy relaxing outdoors
- Nice big comfy bed!
- Overall, comfy aesthetic
The not-so-good:
- In our case, the check-in procedure didn't go so well. We eventually had to gain access via a neighbor.
- The elevator is pretty sketchy. I got stuck in it the first time we used it (my wife had to set me free by calling it back down the first floor). We didn't use it again...
- Many things in the apartment felt "cheap" including the bathroom shower and faucet. We also didn't receive ample amounts of shampoo and body soap to last us our stay (3 nights)
Overall, I believe we had a more negative experience than most due to the check-in issues. We just couldn't justify a high rating given that the value didn't seem entirely there for us and the photos were slightly misleading.
That said, we certainly had a lovely stay in Rome, and our AirBNB didn't detract at all from our visit.