Overall, we were happy with this place. I've been spoiled and delighted with previous Air BnB's that I've used, so I was a little surprised when I first arrived at this place...but it grew on me. Maybe it's just a Rome thing? (older and a bit rundown, and it looked nicer on the pictures than it did in person).
First the good things:
1. LOCATION. We were looking for something very close to the colosseum and it was indeed very close, 5 minute walk. Also very close to plenty of restaurants, convenience stores, etc.
2. RESPONSIVENESS: We arrived early, and they let us store our luggage in the apartment while they cleaned it, so that was much appreciated. They were very friendly and responsive.
3. SPACIOUSNESS AND PRIVACY: This apartment is really like two separate rooms with their own baths and and a shared kitchen, so it does provide a lot of privacy, which we all appreciated. It is also quite spacious for the 3 of us.
4. AN ELEVATOR THAT WORKS: The flat is on the first floor, one level up from the street, so it was nice (and surprising) that they had a small working elevator here.
5. CAFE(S) BELOW: It was nice that there are two cafes right below the building where you can grab a drink or buy something to take up to the apartment.
6. AS ADVERISED: The apartment does indeed have 2 TVs, decent high speed Wi-Fi connection, air conditioning, 2 bedrooms (very private), living area (more like a small room between the bedrooms), 2 bathrooms and kitchen. We really liked that the window in the front bedroom overlooked the plaza below. The bedroom is the back is a little on the dark side, but still was comfortable with it's own full bathroom.
Now the bad things... (really only one):
1. POOR CONDITION OF THE BUILDING'S ENTRYWAY: This apartment is in an old Roman building and, as such, things are a big run down (they call it "classic" but to an American it will seem run down) Scuff marks on the walls, floors that look like they have been clean and swept in years, etc. etc. A fresh coat of paint and a good cleaning in the building's entry way would do wonders for a good first impression.
Like I said, overall we were happy with this place and it grew on us. I would consider it 3 star accommodations by American standards.