All in all, the location is perfect! We were close enough to walk all of Rome but also on a street that was quiet enough to get sleep.
The apartment itself was cute and comfy. It is old and outdated, we had a few issues with the front door not locking and the bathroom door not locking however Rome is an old city and we somewhat expected that.
The main issue is that clean towels were not brought to us and when I reached out to Gaetano to request them he didn't respond until the night before checkout when it was already pointless. We also had to buy our own toilet paper throughout or stay which is strange.
Note that the hair dryer basically does not work so do not rely on that and there are no products of any kind that you are able to use.
Gaetano was very kind and friendly and I had no concerns with him personally. I would actually stay in his apartment again if the few things mentioned above could be fixed as the location is perfect.
Thanks Gaetano !