Pluses:
- It's close to the train station (from where you can get to Pompeii) and close to where the airport bus takes you
- The description of the place is accurate and what you see is what you get
- The hosts are thoughtful (we got some nice Napoletan desserts before we left) and the responses are almost instant
- In the hallway you have a selection of books in Italian if you can read Italian
Minuses (for us these were minor):
- Arriving at night near the train station is a bit dodgy and quite dirty
- The walk to the center is not very pleasant as the areas you pass through aren't very nice
- The information about getting to Pompeii that they offer is not very comprehensive as there are quite a few ways of getting there that the hosts didn't tell us about (cheap and comfortable by train - Circumvesuviana line to Pompeii Scavi)
Overall, a good deal for a short stay
Other observations (on Pompeii):
- The information available in the ruins of Pompeii is pretty scarce, so be sure to either do a guided tour (if you enjoy that sort of thing) or get the audioguide (8 EUR). Pay special attention to the numbers 101 - 124 where you get more information about the destruction of the city, the administration, the elections, the water works etc. Those proved to be more interesting generally than the descriptions of the buildings but there is no list of these audio explanations. I just pressed all the 3 digit numbers in order and decided whether I'm interested or not.
- If you have headphones with a classic jack two people can listen with the same audioguide.