I would rate at 4.5. The location is great, the access instructions good. The bedding very comfortable. The kitchen well outfitted. The only thing was the smell in the bathroom was pretty rank if you let the door stay closed while away or overnight. I think mold or just old plumbing may be issue. I was told by a local friend when they saw the place they thought it was a fabulous deal and that smell was just a fact of life in the old buildings that everyone gets used to dealing with anywhere in the city. We enjoyed our stay very much.