We had a fantastic time staying in Santorini with Natasha and Stefanos. We were initially concerned with the location being further away from Oia, but once in Finikia we did not have any regrets. The neighborhood is wonderful and is next to a few great and affordable restaurants. The walk to Oia is around 20 minutes, so we still walked there during the day. However, we thought it was much nicer to stay in Finikia, away from the hordes of tourists and overpriced restaurants in Oia.
The cave itself was fantastic. Very cute place that's well decorated and has everything you need for your stay. We especially enjoyed the mini-pool, which was great to relax in during the heat of summer. Natasha also helped us arrange a shuttle from the airport and book a rental car for our last day to explore the island before heading to the port to leave. Would highly recommend this place to anybody looking to stay near Oia.