Don't even think about staying in Oia or Fira! Anna's place in Megalochori is exactly the Santorini experience that you want. It's right in the center of a lovely village with great restaurants and shops right outside the door (literarally). The place itself is beautifully designed for privacy on the lower level and great views on the second level, and the interior is lovely, spacious, and comfortable. The king-sized bed was wonderful, as was the great shower and separate toilet area. Kostas met us and gave us extremely good advice about taking the bus to Oia and Fira instead of driving. He also helped us find a sailing cruise, which we loved, and helped us navigate our way around the town and the island. In all, Anna's place was a five-star experience without the tourist hordes. I would stay here again.