I can't say enough good things about La Maison. First of all Amalia is the most helpful host. Having her was like having a personal concierge. She booked everything from massages to airport transfers for us. She even helped us get supplies and cake for my niece's birthday party!
The location of the villa is perfect. You might think it's noisy because of the proximity to the airport, but it's a very small airport and we never noticed the planes. In fact I would highly recommend this location over the busy touristy areas like oia. You're close to the best beaches and you can still come home to your oasis after visiting the touristy areas.
As far as the villa itself, it had everything you need from board games to cooking supplies to a huge amazing pool.
If you're still searching, you should stop now. La Maison is the perfect villa and Amalia is the perfect host!