I can 110% recommend Thodoris's place! It is very comfortable and stylish, and really well thought through. The bedroom is spacious and the bed and pillows are comfortable. There are even blackout blinds so the light doesn't wake you in the morning. The kitchen is well equipped with everything you need to make a meal. The bathroom is really big and has very good hot water with good pressure (not guaranteed on the islands!). The communal garden space is so pretty and feels really private. The location of the property is also excellent - Plakes is a nice quiet place to stay but still walking distance to busier Plaka, where there are good restaurants. Ideally, you need a car or a scooter to explore the island, but this would be the case anywhere you stayed.
The best thing about our stay, however, was Thodoris and Ms Flora's hospitality! Thodoris was so responsive to my messages, even when he was away in Athens. And Ms Flora brought us the most delicious sweet treats to try! All in all, a fantastic experience.