If you're rating on a scale of 10, this place is a 15. It's incomparable to anything in the USA in terms of the view, remoteness, and hospitality.
The whole time I was there with my new wife we could not stop being blown away by it all.
Christos helped get us set up with a car and a boat tour around the island, and was just so generous at every turn.
If you're coming to Greece, you gotta stay here.