Apostolos was a great host. He was waiting for us at the port when we arrived and drove us right to the home. He also spent time pointing out on a map his favourite restaurants. This place is actually a very beautiful hotel called the Pelican. It was not what was advertised but it was equal if not better. Lovely staff, clean space, large balcony with a view of old town and the water. There was a free breakfast available as well. I would stay here again for sure! It is close to many restaurants/grocery stores/shops, but enough out of the way that it is very quiet.
My only complaints are minor, and that it was not what is advertised in the photos (I'm not a fan of surprises) and that there is a place nearby with many dogs who love to bark during the sunset each night. The hotel is also at the top of a steep hill which gave us quite a workout, but that's probably good for us :)