The apartment is clean and looks just like in the pictures. I would say the views are very nice and open--better than just the sunset pictured, which is amazing. Also, the balcony is quite spacious, which is also not shown. Theodora is very speedy with responses, accommodating and has the traditional Greek hospitality. So, definitely a five-star place, considering the reasonable price.
Some small things to be aware of. As the review states, it would be quite difficult to walk to the main town, so we used taxis (15 Euros per trip) and also rented a car for the days we wanted to explore the island (highly recommended to visit some of the villages and beaches further away). Please note that when you go to town to eat, parking is only available outside of the old town, so you will have to walk 10 minutes or so from the parking lot to many of the restaurants you may want eat at. Even taxis can't drive through the old town, which makes it a nice place for strolling.
The bed is very firm, which is typical for Greece, and the showers are open on both sides, so you have to take care not get water onto the floor. The shower head is low for someone who is six feet tall, but all this is typical for Greece and no big deal. The water pressure is good and there is hot water all day long, and these are not always to be counted on in Greece, so worth noting.
We did not cook in the kitchen--it had enough of the basics for simple cooking though. It was nice to have a washing machine, and Theodora also provided detergent. She also provided local advice cheerfully, and the place is easy to find on Google Maps. The AC worked well and it was quite quiet for being near the road. If you rent a car, you might want to pick an agency that delivers your car here and picks it up from here at the end.