On the one hand, the hosts Maria and Gabriel were fantastic. Very kind, always responsive and extremely helpful. On the other hand, our stay at the house was not quite what we expected.
The Wifi didn't work, so we had to find our own solution to get any internet access at all. The hosts later arranged for a new solution but we didn't try it out, so I can't say whether the Wifi is now fixed or not.
The house is situated near the center of Milos, which was definitely nice because we could get everywhere with our car (which you definitely need!) rather quickly, especially the northern/northwestern beaches. But the house sits at the end of a cul-de-sac on the edge of town.
The house offers a basic level of comfort, so don't expect any luxury or extras. We got a lot of groceries but ended up not cooking because the kitchen lacks a good stovetop and full equipment which made preparing food difficult.
You should also know that the house sits right next to another house with a rather loud neighbor.
I'd say that this house is not for everyone. Honeymooners and couples looking for their romantic farm house fantasy should be aware. For people who are comfortable with the rustic charm this could be the right fit and good value.