The Naftilos Cave Houses were perfect! I agree with all of the other reviewers that said Finikia is the best location. The walk to Oía is quick and lovely, taking myself and my husband about 20 mins, 30 to get into the heart of the town (the only tough steps are in Finikia itself- about 5-10 mins of a walk). It’s quite nice to be out of the hustle and bustle of Oía proper, but still close to restaurants and a market. we had no problem getting what we needed, and always felt safe getting back “home” at night.
Margarita’s place was clean and comfortable, and she was prompt with messages including setting up taxi transfers from the airport and sending us options for a sunset cruise.
I highly recommend Spiridakos Sailing for a sunset cruise and Lefke (right by the cave house) for dinner.
We would absolutely recommend Margarita’s place for anyone visiting the area, and would stay there all over again!