Nicoletta's place was perfect!
Communication with Nicoletta before arrival was great and she always replied quickly. She even organised airport pickup for us in the middle of the night. Once we arrived at the apartment her daughter was there to greet us and show us everything. Her daughter also organised taxis for us whenever we needed them and was there to answer any questions. The apartment itself was beautiful and exactly as pictured with stunning views of Ammoudi bay. There is a bit of a hike to get to Oia about 15-20 mins uphill or you can easily take a taxi for about 10 euro. There are also nice spots for swimming and some great restaurants right next to the apartment.
Would definitely recommend staying at Nicoletta's and wouldn't hesitate to stay there again.