Five Stars! Don't hesitate to book! I think we stayed "home" more than going out not just due to the winds but because this fine apartment was meticulously renovated and decorated and made to feel idyllic!!!
The square is very close and there was a band and hours of Greek dancing our first night there. But note, you won't hear any of that since the apartment is tucked far enough away. My husband and I rented a motorbike for 22€ a day from the port and it took us about 45 minutes to an hour to drive there because the winds were so strong. (It was a bit scary). We had spent time in Santorini and Mykonos before going to Andros and in comparison, Andros is super relaxed and much greener! Food is AMAZING and far less expensive!