We stayed at Anna and Eva's place for two nights.
We were picked up from the port by Eva, who was very friendly and approachable. The house is not reachable by bus, so Eva drove us to and from Mykonos Town several times. She really made us feel welcome.
The room was spacious, clean, and comfortable. As another reviewer said, there was no shower curtain so the bathroom floor would get wet, but it wasn't a big deal.
We would definitely stay here again :-)