We really enjoyed staying at the cave house! It is in a location that is away from the touristy scenes in Fira and Oia but just a short drive away. Best of both worlds! The house is unique—it is an actual cave—and a great, authentic experience. Vaggelis was a great host and even arranged car rental with transportation from the airport for us which made the trip really easy.
The two restaurants within walking distance from the house, Metaxi Mas and Anemeloos are not to be missed.
A note on logistics: like many buildings in Santorini, you cannot park right next to the house. You will have to carry your bags from the parking area and down some steps. Also, the shower was a bit challenging for my husband who is 6’1. Not a deterrent to stay here though! Just something to keep in mind. We would definitely stay here again!