Our experience at Jay’s was good. The pool was very beautiful and the location was good (near Paradise Beach).
A few negatives include: difficulty communicating at check-in about the house (greeter didn’t speak English); no AC (to be fair we knew this, but just want to note it was very warm at night); the bathrooms essentially flood when you take a shower (due to the type of bathroom and the shower head being broken); the apartment was a bit dirty (the drinking glasses were very dirty); the iron and a few of the drawers in the bedrooms were broken.
Overall we had a nice time in Mykonos. For the same price point we had much more value in Santorini which may have raised our expectations.
Jay was very responsive via message to our questions and concerns.