We really enjoyed our stay at the Pigeon House. Mary was a terrific host. She made us feel very welcome. Our ferry to Andros was delayed and we were unable to pick up the Andros hiking map before we got to the house. We we told her this, her husband went out and got one for us! We hiked down to a small, quiet beach for the sunrise on one of the official hiking trails. There were other hiking trails just a short distance from the door, too. The patio decks were lovely, private, and very relaxing. One consideration is that the parking lot below the house could be a bit noisy at night (our stay was on a weekend). We live in a noisy big city and this didn't bother us—or keep us awake— but if you are a light sleeper you may want to consider closing the windows (or earplugs) at night. She was also very flexible with checking in/out. We had a fantastic experience here.