Definitely stay in Imerovilgi!! This Airbnb has beautiful views and it’s quite private so you get peace and quiet! Our family of 5 stayed here and it was spacious enough- we didn’t feel cramped at all.
We stayed 2 nights near oia in finika but preferred Imerovilgi as it is way less crowded and feels more peaceful/relaxed. Stunning views!!
Lots of steps to go down and up to the house just FYI for people who have a hard time walking. The host can arrange a porter to help bring down luggage for a fee, which is helpful!