I can definitely recommend this AirBnB! It is a rebuilt garage I think but feels just like a mini home. Especially liked the little terrace and the garden around it. The room is quite spacious, kitchen and bathroom are small but totally fine. The accommodation is not directly in the city or at the beach but you can rent bikes for 4€ a day just 450m further. Really enjoyed the 5-10min bike tours to the beach, the city center or the local supermarket. A lot of people also walk the distances, depends on your preferences.
Malamateni was a good host, she even helped us getting a taxi to the airport on our last day. Note that the taxi situation on the island is quite difficult, so be sure to take care of it a few days in advance.
There is a hostel across the street that can be a bit louder at night, but we didn’t mind as we had our windows closed. The bed was a bit too hard for my taste but that is also a personal preference.
All in all it was a very good experience!