Overall: This home and host are amazing. I would definitely recommend/stay again! Our stay included three couples and it was the perfect size.
Pros: The view from the top balcony is out of this world. The entire apartment is clean and inviting. There is plenty of hot water for showers as well as A/C to cool the apartment. The host is responsive and helpful, even going out of his way to provide an extra fan when we expressed a need for added ventilation in the basement bedroom. The local town of Pyrgos is charming, with plenty of cafes and restaurants within walking distance of the house. Pyrgos is not as crowded as other parts of the island and is positioned so you can explore other areas easily. We rented a car and would recommend this to others.
Cons: The walk from local parking to the house is roughly 7-10 minutes directly uphill. This was not a huge problem but is something to consider if you anticipate having multiple pieces of sizable luggage. Additionally, the basement cave bedroom is fantastic, but not the best fit for someone who disagrees with tight spaces.