Dimitri's place was perfect for us. Near the necessary shops and lovely restaurants and not too far from Rhodes city or some really nice beaches if you use buss or car/scooter.
The appartment was spacious and gave the authentic greece feel from inside out. The place is in a quiet (well the church is right next to it so expect some even hour bell tolls during day time and sunday morning masses) neighborhood where you can see how the local people live and take care of their daily things.
We really enjoyed our stay in this appartment at Rhodes island. Wouldn't change this experience for a cheesy hotel room in a city full of tourists.