My partner and I had the pleasure of staying at both Blue Art Cave properties, the Stellar Sun and Starry Sky for 2 nights each. The properties are next door to each other and I would highly recommend each one for different reasons! The Stellar Sun had an awesome indoor/outdoor jacuzzi which we really enjoyed gorgeous Caldera views from. The Starry Sky was a much larger room with a private indoor jacuzzi and it truly felt like we were staying in a Greek Cave. It is totally up to you on what you prefer - bigger room + indoor jacuzzi or smaller room + outdoor jacuzzi, but you won't go wrong with either choice!
We were delighted when we arrived to find out that our stay included breakfast and dinner. There were many choices on each menu and the food was good. Catherine was truly the best airbnb host we've ever had and would coordinate our meals with us in a timely manner each day.
Oia is known for its sunsets and many tourists come to take pictures. We were so happy that our property was located further down from the touristy spots. It felt private as we did spend lots of time enjoying the outside area. It is a steep but short 5 minute walk up to the main Oia street with shops, restaurants and bars. The location was perfect!
I would definitely recommend either property to travelers visiting Oia.
Also posting my review on Catherine below :)
Catherine is the best Airbnb host I've ever had! If I could give her 10 stars I would. She was extremely helpful, punctual, and went out of her way to accommodate us during our stay. At the beginning of our trip we had a ferry cancellation on our way to Santorini and Catherine was already tracking our arrival and changed our taxi bookings with no hassle. She even booked a taxi for our family members staying elsewhere, making the entire arrival experience seamless for all. Each day she would follow up with our breakfast and dinner orders which came with our Airbnb stay, provided us ample recommendations of things to do around the island, and even booked every excursion, reservation, tour for us throughout the trip. It felt as if we had a concierge in real-time and this was greatly appreciated. She was warm, friendly, kind, knowledgeable and is truly great at her job!