You absolutely cannot ask for anything more. Perfect place, amazing hosts, and a lovely island. If you plan to do a trip to a Greek island, I recommend that you do not look any further.
Tonia and Vangelis were great. We were met at the port by Vangelis, who had arranged a car rental for us (as we failed to book in advance). At the place, we were welcomed with Tonia'a amazing snacks, fruits, and wine. The hospitality did not stop flowing throughout the time we were there, and Vangelis' restaurant suggestions afforded him our best compliments even when he was away.
Stay at this place. You will not regret it.