We had a great stay at Nicholas' place. The hotel is small which is very nice, we always had the (massive) pool for ourselves, the room is very clean and beds are comfortable.
Be aware though that the bar in front of the hotel can make noise until 1AM, bring good earplugs if you cannot sleep with noise.
The best thing about the hotel is Nicholas: he takes plenty of time to explain where to go on the island, with plenty of good recommendations and tips. He was wonderful with our late late flight and did everything he could so that it would be less unpleasant. We truly felt welcomed.
The hotel is a 5 minutes walk to the beach: I would suggest as an amazing experience to grab a breakfast where Nicholas recommends it, go to the beach for sunrise, swim in the ocean while the sun goes up, we did it 2 times and that was perfect.