Our five night stay at Anthousa's was absolutely amazing. While it is more expensive than most hotels in town, it is worth every penny. We had a really friendly pick up by Charis (a local travel agency owner, who gave us a fantastic intro to the island and what one can do there) and Anthousa's father. The place itself is amazing. A minute from the central place but also secluded from it, while seeing the ocean, monastery and the whole town from the garden. indeed the garden is much nicer and bigger than what you see on the pictures. There is a huge table for alle guests (two other stone houses on the compound) to use, with a hammock and a swing. There were ripe tomatoes, onions, garlic, grapes, mulberries, figs, and even fresh eggs from the garden. We loved that. The house itself was wonderful. Literally, one of the coolest places on the island, much appreciated during the summer. also, two fridges and all you need in the kitchen. also a very clever mosquito protection, which is actually worth gold. The bed frame is a bit hard, but we slept well (also because it is super quiet up there). The bath is gorgeously designed. It is effectively part of the bathroom, so good if you know your travel partner well - or you'll get to know them quiet well ;)
Overall, a fantastic experience. We're were very sad to go. Could have stayed on the compound lying in the hammock looking over the sea and village and eating fruit forever. So best stay a couple of days at least.