Our stay in Katerina's dovecote was perfect in every way! The house itself is in a great location, you can see the sea and the town, and all the grounds with fig and olive trees (amazing smell too). Katerina's husband, Damianos, was a great host and not only picked us up from the ferry, he was so kind to always respond to our texts to give us recommendations on beaches and restaurants in Tinos. It definitely made our stay even better, because all the places he sent us to were incredible. They left some "welcome gifts" in the fridge (some preserves and local liquor) that were much appreciated as well. Please note that you *will* need a car to get there - it is pretty isolated (which for us was a huge plus). Also, there is no wifi and phone signal is pretty weak.
Tinos is a lovely island, but I do think that we liked it so much because we stayed in such an incredible house. I strongly strongly recommend it!