Our stay started a bit rocky at the Cave house. We took Christos up on his offer to setup a transfer service from the port to the house. Unfortunately, our driver dropped us off at a completely different part of the Island, which we only realized after arriving to a hotel that was obviously not ours.
After 20 minutes of waiting, we were finally able to get a ride to our actual destination. Upon arrival, Christos was waiting for us in the parking lot, though wasn't apologetic at all.
Inside, the house is very similar to the pictures; it's quaint and feels authentic. However, we were disappointed as the floor in the shower and bathroom would literally chip off AS you were showering. There is a lack of privacy in the house since the door to the bathroom does not close at all and the shower has no hot water if that's important to you.
PROS
- Functioning washing machine
- About a 10 minute (partially uphill) walk to Oia. Perfect if you don't want to stay in the middle of the craziness and want more of a local feel.
- Authentic cave house, quiet neighborhood of Finikia. Local feel away from craziness of Oia (but very close and accessible to town and buses)_
CONS
- No air conditioning. While it's cooler in the cave than outside, staying in the middle of August with no air conditioning is not recommended.
- There is one fan provided, though it was dusty and not very powerful (we had to put it right next to us while we slept to not sweat all night)
- Floor is chipping and peeling. House generally seemed a little unkempt
- No hot water (at least not for our trip)
- Door to the bathroom does not close
- Price - we paid $250+/night. Seems like luxury but very far from it
The bottom line: If you're looking for a quiet stay within walking distance to Oia and don't need a pristine home with luxuries such as hot water and air conditioning, this is your spot. If you're on your honeymoon or are expecting a "refined" stay, I'd steer clear of this place.