The apartment is well located, right in the centre of Rhodes and a 5-minute walk away from the gates to the fortified city. It is also very easy to reach with the bus from the airport (it stops in front of the building) and the bus terminal with buses going to beaches such as Falikari is very close. The host seems also nice and very easy to reach.
However, we found the apartment disappointing considering that it had such good reviews. It is okay, but it isn't particularly clean or well-equipped. The furnishings are definitely not new. The towels looked dirty (hopefully just stained), so it is better to bring your own. The bathroom shower curtain fits badly so the entire bathroom gets filled with water. The toilet does not flush well, and it also has the same warning of not throwing paper that most bathrooms have on the island. The AC unit was not functioning well, and there is only one AC unit in the apartment, so it isn't really suitable for people to use the living room as a bedroom in the summer because it gets too hot. Besides, the windows do not have any nets so leaving the window open is not really a possibility. Finally, the neighbourhood is very noisy, so if you would like some peace and quiet at night, this is not the right location. And while there is a balcony, it is overlooking a busy street and a dirty park, and it is too sunny to sit comfortable in the morning.
All in all, not consistent with the reviews (i've seen 5-star reviewed airbnb before and they were much better), and suitable probably for young people that are not picky and that spend most of their time outside. Not suitable for more than 2 people or for people with children (to be fair, the not-suitable-for-infants part was initially mentioned in the posting, but we reserved despite it).