Colin and Stella's place is in a beautiful location on Paros, right in the picturesque old town of Parikia and near a ton of shops and restaurants, but on a quiet street where you would never know you're near the town center.
However, unfortunately we were a bit disappointed with the place, as it turned out that the toilet didn't work for our entire 9-day stay. There was no water pressure so we had to pour a bucket of water down the toilet every time we wanted to flush. The host apologized for this when we arrived (she was aware of the problem), but instead of an apology we would have preferred that they have someone come out and fix it while we were there. We felt bad making a big deal about it so we just dealt with it, but having a working toilet is a basic need for any vacation rental. The host said that sometimes this just happens on the island, but we didn't have any problems with any other toilets on the island, and we compared notes with other travelers and neither did they.
Plus, the WiFi didn't work for nearly our entire stay :( It's because the router is located in Colin & Stella's house across the street and doesn't reliably reach the apartment.
It's too bad because it's a cute place with potential, but having basic amenities as listed on the Airbnb listing is really critical.