Everything was perfect! George made the booking process easy and informative, and Valeria met us at the accommodation when we arrived. She was friendly and extremely helpful, full of suggestions for restaurants, things to do, how to get around the island etc.
The place itself was spotlessly clean, and offers excellent views of the port, the sea and the castle along with some of the back streets of the old town, not only from the top floor but also from the patio at the foot of the windmill. The views are amazing and cannot be accurately represented in photos, especially when cruise ships dock at night with all their glittering lights on display! The bathroom is modern and well-appointed, the kitchen is enough to cook decent meals if you don't want to spend on dining out all the time (though you will, as there are some amazing restaurants nearby), the bedroom is bright, comfortable and fresh, and the top floor is extremely comfortable, with the aforementioned great views and catches a good sea breeze to keep you cool on warm summer days!
The location is also excellent, just a few minutes' walk from the splendour of the Old Town with its medieval architecture, museums, restaurants, bars and castle, a few more minutes to take you to Mandraki Harbour where day trip boats leave on island excursions and where the Colossus of Rhodes once stood, and a few more minutes form there are some incredible beaches including Elli, where you can find beach bars, sun loungers, free beach areas, quiet parts, party parts, calm parts and windy parts, whatever you're in the mood for.
And despite being so close to all this good stuff, it's just far enough removed that you don't get disturbed by the thrum of the nightlife, and can happily get a quiet night's sleep. You couldn't ask for anything more for your holiday.
Thank you very much!