First of all the major positives are that the views are genuinely spectacular and the infinity pool is wonderful. The apartment itself is large and airy, the hosts are mostly responsive and as we were there for 2 weeks they kindly had it cleaned for us half way through (free of charge). The approach to the house is via an unasphalted road, and we would recommend hiring a car to see the island. You can walk to nearby Gialiskari and Vourkari via the steps and road which are quite steep.
Our minor criticisms (but ones we feel worth making) are as follows: we found it difficult to be enthusiastic about the quality of the apartment and amenities. For example lightbulbs missing and other lightbulbs not working, broken coffee machine, i.e. things you would expect to have been checked before our arrival. We would also suggest upgrading the travel kettle and providing sharp knives for cooking. We appreciate that these are minor issues but the cumulative effect is such that they detract from what could be a top quality rental. We have stayed in a number of air bnbs in Greece over the last few years and by comparison this one is lacking the “home from home” touches and high quality amenities we would expect from this price bracket. It is very much a self service apartment but just a little more care and attention could create a really special and memorable place for guests.