The stay at Elias was a great experience - starting from the flexible pick-up at the port, over staying at the very new, spacious apartment, to being treated as a real house guest by Elias and his entire family (rather than AirBnB customer). Highlights include the supply with home grown fruits, like figs and water melon as well some delicious home made Greek Pastitsio.
At booking time, we've been not sure about the location since it's a bit away form the city center, but we found this is not a problem since it's only a sort walk (~13min) and we got a rental scooter anyway.