As a traveller with some experience with air bnb here are some thoughts on this place:
Pros:
1) location! I like to walk and it is within walking distance to Oia where you can enjoy the amenities of Oia without the crowds or noise of busy tourist season
2) the hot tub (which was luke warm) was a great addition and experience after a long day of walking. It was very relaxing
3) there is a good deal of space in the villa with a separate living room and kitchen
4) finikia had some very good authentic restaurants and has a nice and quiet ambiance
5) host was attentive and gave good suggestions to activities and restaurants in oia and finikia
Cons:
1) there are families that live directly below the villas. There are small children there that cry and scream at various times of day including late at night. If this is something you can get past then it’s the place for you-however- the sound proofing is non existent and I could hear them at all hours. This is not the fault of the host whatsoever and out of his control but it would have been nice to have been informed about this prior to booking.