Okay, let's just get right to it: If you were standing at the Castle wall, looking out at the gorgeousness of the Ammoudi steps and windmills and the cliffside, you'd say, "Ooh, look at that patio! I want to stay THERE!" Well, that's the Fishermans' Cave House! We could not believe it. This is a total dream stay. The Fishermans' Cave House is in the best location, with the best patio and the best view of all the places to stay on this side of the Caldera, (which in our opinion is the preferred side, since you have the view of the sunset). Around sunset, we'd watch as hundreds of people would flock to the castle wall and stairs all around the cliffside, and there we'd be, drinking wine and enjoying the gorgeous sunset from the privacy of our own patio and hot tub. Plus, the cave house itself is lovely. Spacious, immaculately clean, and decorated beautifully. Panos was a doll and left a bottle of wine which we promptly enjoyed. And just when we didn't think it could get any better, a perfect, delicious breakfast was delivered each morning at 9. (Plus, Panos was so friendly and helpful and gave us great tips for restaurants and things to do -- his advice was so on point! We also really appreciated the wonderful porter Panos works with who helped us with our bags and got us settled. We were so well taken care of while staying here!) While in Oia, we spent some time visiting family at other resorts on the Caldera such as Canaves, and in all honesty, we'd choose to stay at The Fishermans' Cave House over any of them, again and again.