if you are looking for a sign to stay at this place... THIS IS IT. My husband and I stayed here during our honeymoon in Novemeber and had the best time.
Of course, the private jacuzzi, cute room, cave bathroom, and stellar view make the house worth it in itself... but this place really is top notch because of the host Katarina. She literally booked/placed reservations for everything for us on our trip (dinner reservations, airport transfer, ATV rentals, Catamaran, etc...) I didn't have to call any of these rentals and worry about getting scammed. You do pay the rental companys in cash, so be ready to have some euros on hand the moment you get here.
++ they offer breakfast each morning and bring it to your door. It is SO yummy.
We came in offseason, so the town was definitely empty- I would maybe consider staying in Oia or Fira in the winter since more things are open, because where this place is in the winter is DEAD. Very little restaurants and stores open, but was perfect for us honeymooners. There is a road in front that is open to the public, which might get crowded in the summer, but like I said.. we never had an issue with people passing by in the off-season.