My husband and I spent two weeks at the villa in May. The entire experience was fantastic.
It was very clean, and Giorgos and his family showed us wonderful hospitality. For example, he and his wife picked us up from the Rhodes airport even though we arrived late at night, rather than us getting a taxi. His wife also left us marmalade in the refrigerator for toast with breakfast (which was fantastic), and his family gave us fresh lemons and berries from their garden.
Gioros was also incredibly responsive - the water was off one morning and he contacted the water service within a few minutes of recieving our email (water was back on within an hour - it was an area problem with the water service).
The view of the Mediterranean Sea from the balcony is second to none (especially with the gardens full of flowers). And the villa is located within walking distance of Plakia Beach and also restaurants and Pefkos (which is maybe a quarter of a mile, so a little bit farther if you're not used to walking - maybe a 5 minute walk to get there, but a nice one).
All in all 10 out of 10.