We loved staying at Elisavet's place. The beds were the most comfortable we stayed in, the view of the Temple of Apollo and the sound of the sea (and its breeze) were heavenly. And the location: Beyond the view and being right next to the beach, Elisavet's place is an easy walk from the port, right above a wonderful restaurant (Kozi) where we had *many* meals, and a grocery market is right across the street. It was the ultimate in convenience, even if there was a bit of street noise (the windows are perfectly insulated, and the A/C is amazing, so easy to shut that out at night).
Elisavet greeted us post-ferry with a couple of chicken pies, which were delicious and very welcome after the long trip from Athens. We used Maria's huge tub with jets ("hydro") and lounged in the living room and on the porch and watched the sun set multiple nights. There's also a swimming area at the base of the temple (with steps and a small public shower), and we swam there as soon as we arrived, since it's just a two-minute walk from Elisavet's.
(We rented ATVs from Maria at Akrogiali, who was great, and toured the island's beaches and went up to the villages -- highly recommend.)