Staying with Manolis was great. The villa has is a perfect choice for those looking for privacy, no neighbours nearby, private beach, very close to the main road. The villa has a great terrase and offers a picturesque view of Telendos. Myrthies can be reached in app. 15 mins.
As for the host, Manolis did a great job. They picked us up from the ferry at 5 am, when we arrived, drove us all the way to the villa where some freshly baked croissants, cold water and wine waited for us. It all was nothing short of the renowned Greek hospitality. The host offered us tips regarding transportation and various local events and helped us rent a car for very good fees!
On our return, this villa will definitely be our choice.
The only drawback is that you need a car/moto to get around, but if you plan to get one anyway, it won't be an issue.