We booked our trip relatively last minute and didn't have a lot of choices on where to stay. This is hands down the best place we could've stayed. All the ammeneties of a hotel. A FANTASTIC view of the sunset from a private balcony. It's a 10 minute walk to Oia, which we found to be more than ideal. Vaggelis hooked us up at reception and basically planned our whole stay on the island. The restaurants he recommended were great, activities fantastic, everything top notch. Flora is the sweetest and they keep the property pristine.
The hiking path from Oia to Fira is right outside your front door. We already started planning our next stay at Alonistra before we left the island. Would stay here every single time. I would give hem 10 stars if I could.