Pros and cons listed below.
Cons first - the apartment is railroad style with no doors or curtains between the bedroom and living room. We were a couple and an extra guest, and none of us got any privacy. The apartment gets so much light in the living room area (no curtains) that you cannot sleep properly. After paying almost $300 per night, we did not even get a bath soap for the stay (let alone shampoo or conditioner) - on asking the host the only response I got was that they do not provide soap. I am a host myself and I provide soaps and snacks and breakfast and more, for much cheaper price in the middle of Manhattan. A soap costs a couple of euros - I do not see why that cannot be provided. Also, the listing fails to mention that the toilet is outside the apartment and that you have to step out in the middle of the night to go to the bathroom. The porter and cleaning service, while efficient, are extremely pushy. Every single day we got multiple knocks on the door to wake us up to clean - it was ridiculous to be disturbed when you have been up till 5 in the morning to enjoy the island's beauty. There was no "please don't disturb" to hang outside the door and we had no clue that 2 or 3 different groups of people would come to wake us up to clean and to check out. The porter said right after check-in that he would get us a cheaper taxi if we go through him. When we checked out he took us to the main city area to take our "taxi" - instead he quickly dumped our bags into a BUS and asked us to sit inside quickly as it was leaving right away. The bus cost the three of us 35 euros, instead of a private taxi for 40 euros. The bus made multiple stops, stayed there forever to pick up more people, and we almost missed our ferry ride to Mykonos (the ferry left an hour late; if it left on time we would have missed it). This is not how Airbnb experience is supposed to be. If I need this experience, I would much rather stay in a hotel. Please leave the guests alone unless they ask for your help, and please do not shortchange them with this bus/taxi shenanigans.
Pros - the apartment was clean and the view is incredible. The host has many other listings and luckily we had booked another apartment for one day, which was incredible and far fairly-priced than this one. Be careful which listing you are going for and read carefully. Most people are awestruck by the beauty of the island and ignore the listing's shortcoming; I thought I should point it out.