Uncle John's was amazing. A wonderful experience. The drive up the hill might be a little scary, but the killer view is worth it. The air conditioning worked great (I'm from Texas, need the cool), the wifi was amazing, the snacks provided were a lovely touch, and it even has a laundry machine and garage to park an ATV. I recommend booking an ATV before you get to the island because the last minute markup is a bit much, and Nikos can help you arrange this.
From waking up to the sound of the local crows to falling asleep under the beautiful Grecian moon, and being near the beautiful pomegranate trees and grape vines, I got a 5 star Milos experience at Uncle John's.
Must do advice: Rent an atv or buggy, just do it.
Thanks, Nikos and team!