We absolutely LOVED staying here. The views from the balcony were amazing. And the hosts were incredibly hospitable. They had lots of recommendations and helped us plan a boat trip. Always with a big smile! The small private beach downstairs is beautiful. We wanted to stay away from the crowds and this was the perfect place for that. But it's still a short and beautiful car ride from tons of other beaches, restaurants, shops, etc. I would recommend staying here if you want peace, great hosts and an open water view :)
Of course, since you are away from town, you need some form of transportation (car, atv, motorcycle) But i would recommend you get that anywhere you stay in Milos so you can enjoy the entire Island.