Overall we had a great time in Megalochori.
The airbnb was clean and we really enjoyed sitting in the outside area.
But a few warnings about Casa Yemeli:
The bunk bed is actually a double loft bed that is INSIDE a bathroom.
One of the double rooms has a partition wall shared with the living room, which has two windows into the living room. There are no curtains, meaning light shines in directly in your face and there is very little privacy.
The final double room is en-suite, but there is no door separating the bedroom from the bathroom (which is down a short corridor).
Sharing bathrooms means you will need to use the toilet inside someone’s bedroom.
Perhaps these are quirks of a cave house or the reason Yemeli is quite reasonably priced - but it wasn’t clear from the photos this was the case and we weren’t expecting it. I think it would make sharing Casa Yemeli with a large group quite awkward.
The town is beautiful - not quite as busy as Fira or Oia, but filled with excellent restaurants and independent shops. In particular we recommend the restaurants Alisachni Art & Wine Gallery and Raku and grabbing a breakfast of greek yoghurt and honey at the Traditional Kafeneio. The house is set right in the middle of the town and a short walk away from a bus stop that will take you to Fira or Akotiri, or there are parking areas nearby.