This place is great. We would have stayed a few days longer but it was already booked by someone else. Magical area of the city, beautiful house. Everything (furniture, linens, etc) is good quality and the house is extremely clean. It really makes it a wonderful place to stay.
I will also note, for anyone who, like me, didn't know this before arriving in Naxos: there aren't addresses here. Apparently it's like this all over the island, not just in the old city. It's easy to find in the labyrinth of walkways using google maps and the name of the house.