If you want the Santorini experience but not just the touristy bit, Maria’s place is the best in town. Located just 30 minutes from Thia and 40 minutes from Oia, we find this place to be a nice and quiet escape from all the tourist. But just 5 min down the road, we have the best beaches ever for sunbathing and a relaxing swim. The place is good for 3/4 people, and you have literally everything you need, from comfortable beds to AC to balcony and a garden. It’s a bit different from the fancy hotel you could find in Thia, but me and my friends spent some quality time in Maria’s place. On site parking is easy and handy, and it’s just convenient.
P.S. there’s 2 stray cat hanging around the area so maybe it’s a good idea to give them some food as well !