If you’re looking at reviews and trying to decide where to book... just book this house already!
There are a few things to know going in and as long as you understand these, you’ll have a great time. First, you need a car to get to the house. It doesn’t have to be a 4 wheel drive, but that helps for getting to some more secluded beaches. This house is one of only -~6 in the area so you’ll need the car to go out, get groceries, dinner, etc. Still, you won’t be more than 15 minutes from any populated part of the island. Second, the pool is smaller than some of the photos make it look (actually maybe 8 ft wide by 25 ft long and 4 ft deep), but this likely doesn’t matter because there are SO MANY beautiful beaches around the island you can get to. Lastly, the host (Ele) is great. She corresponded via Airbnb 5 or 6 times before we arrived to make sure we were set for check in and helped arrange a rental car (which ended up being cheaper than booking online ahead of time). She even offered to get us to the port for our ferry free of charge.
I wouldn’t hesitate to rent this house or with Ele again. Thanks for a memorable vacation!