We absolutely enjoyed the stay (family with two kids ages 5 and 9). Good to have a rental car to get around since options in rye village are limited. However, we took a hike of 30 min over to the next town for dinner and also had dinner in town once thanks to the reservation the hostess made for us. Asi was super responsive and forthcoming with all requests and recommendations.
The cave is very “artsy” as the name suggests and that means also that things are a bit improvised or less updated than other places which was fine with us.
I think it’s good to know for other travelers that the airport is 7 minutes away and you can watch the airplanes land and depart from the terrace. It’s not distributing or loud though but noticeable.
It’s a great place and unforgettable memories!