We are so happy with our choice to stay at Yiannis's place in Pyrgos. It was the perfect location. Very authentic and far less touristy than Thira and Oia. We rented a car and could easily and quickly navigate the island. The view from the terrace are unreal in person and the photos surely do not compare.
If you are considering this property I would give it a 2 thumbs up and highly recommend it.