Okay, where do I start with this one? First off, I am an Airbnb host myself so I always try to be objective. There are positives about my 3 day stay but the negatives outweigh them.
The Positives
Aleksandr is a very friendly guy and offers a lot of info and recommendations about the island. This is really useful. He can book you on tours and let you know what places to explore.
The apartments and pool areas are very clean and look great. You're a 3 minute walk to the beach. Warning if you have kids: if you head down to the end of the beach it's clothing optional. My laundry was washed for me and that was great. Fresh towels and bedding available when you want them.
But.... there are some pretty major things that mean I won't return.
Gunshots. On Sunday and the early hours of Monday (7am) someone was using a shotgun (hunting) in the hills behind the property. They were so close at one point I had rocks ricochet near the wall. I was staying in the last apartment of the complex.
I was also told the running water was from a well and was clean, but not to drink it as it smelled. No issue with this at all, you're on an island. Bottled water was provided. But, the water was salty for the first two days. Day 3 it was fine.
My apartment was so close to my neighbor that when they walked out of their door they were staring straight through my window and I could see straight into theirs.
I took Aleksandr up on the recommendation to try his friends Tavern (Demitris), but I recommend you don't go.I was told he bought his fish straight from the harbour every day. Mine definitely wasn't. Fresh fish doesn't smell of fish, mine did. If you want great fresh fish, go to the tavern nextdoor where you get to choose it in the kitchen and it's perfectly cooked.
Would I return, no.