Summary: Stay here.
Great warm greeting, Host took plenty of time and made several great recommendations for things to do, wineries, and food. Helped with transfers to & from airport and port. Room was stocked with coffee, tea, water. Communication was quick, we received responses immediately every time we asked.
Oh, and the location! One reviewer mentioned there was foot traffic during the day - much of that foot traffic stopped and took pictures on the main path in front of the rental because the view was just that amazing. And there was foot traffic as this was the path to go places on the island. The noise to us was not a problem because we immediately left the room to go to all the places that were recommended. Several restaurants were close by, but again, not too close as to be noisy.
Plenty of outlets, room was VERY clean, well stocked with bathroom supplies, kitchen had cooking utensils - although the great food on the island kept us from needing to use it. Had a wonderful time.