We stayed in Anatoli cave house for 2 nights. the place is very quiet and a bit out of nowhere. I personally believe that Oia and its surrounding is a bit over hyped but the stay was pleasant and hoise had everything you need. House did require a bit of maintenance because there was leeches after it rained. But these things are also unavoidable when you book a "cave house". Thanks to Theodore, he was very accommodating and gave us extra blanket. There are 3 over priced restaurants nearby.