What a great stay at The Three Sisters Villa. The villa was super clean, bright, spacious and comfortable, and had fantastic kitchen amenities, including appliances, plenty of utensils, pots pans and plenty of glassware and dishes (not always true in other vacation rentals!)
The pool area was terrific and would have been much more utilized had the weather been a bit warmer during our stay. The gentleman responsible for keeping the pool clean was in and out most mornings before we got up, so the pool was always ready for a splash. (One thing to note if you have kids that are not swimmers - there is no "shallow" end.)
The location of the villa was also central for exploring the entire east coast (20 minutes to Rhodes Town, 25 minutes to Lindos, etc.). There were lots of great beaches just 5-15 minutes away, too.
Our only (minor) complaint was the position of the villa next to a road that got quite a bit of traffic. Motorbikes are common on the island and so for the light sleeper, the sound of the bikes zipping by was a bit disruptive at night.
Perhaps the best thing about the villa - as others have noted - was the warm welcome from Tina. Not only did she greet us with a smile and TONS of information about restaurants and beaches on the island, but she also had fresh treats from the local bakery, cold water/beverages, a fruit basket, chilled wine, etc. She was fully available during our stay and was quick to answer the few questions we had.
After exploring a lot of other towns during our stay, we felt that The Three Sisters Villa was of good value in terms of the location, condition and overall amenities.