We had a prefect stay in the Palazzo Greco Villa. It was exactly what we hoped for: quiet and peaceful. The house is not far from the sea (by car) or from the supermarket. You can get everything you need in Agios Galini (5min from the villa).
It is very clean with few but enough decoration and nice details. I would say it would also be nice to come in "winter" since there is a chimney.
All in all we enjoyed our stay and would definitely come back and stay longer!
Thank you!