We (5 of us) had the most perfect stay at Agora Suites! It was in the centre of town (but totally silent at night), surrounded by lovely restaurants and bars and 5 minutes from the old harbour. It was absolutely spotless and the beds were super comfortable. We spent every evening on the balcony drinking beer after a day on the beach/wandering around the town - heaven.
Vagelis made us feel so welcome. He was always available, he sent us loads of recommendations for what to do while we were there and his Dad met us from our taxi and showed us the local area surrounding the apartment.