If you're still not sure which place to book, think no more - just book this one. We booked it almost instantly once we saw the amazing photos, and in real life it looks even better! Turns out we were lucky it was available at all, since usually it is booked a year ago for the whole season and next time we will have to plan it much more in advance, since we definitely plan on returning.
Georgia and her husband were amazing hosts and made sure to make us feel like at home. On arrival there was plenty of fresh fruit, some beer, wine and homemade raki in the kitchen, and throughout our stay they'd give us fresh fruits and vegetables straight from their garden, and made sure we have everything we need. The house has absolutely everything you could possibly need. The garden with the pool is such a paradise that we were sad to leave it every day and go explore the beaches. It's not just any house with a pool - usually the pools are surrounded with a hot concrete and there is no shade in sight - but this pool is in such a cozy garden that's full of natural shade in any time of the day. It's also perfect for a night swim since the water is not too cold (but still refreshing during the hot days).
The location is perfect for exploring the west side of the island. Make sure to rent a car because it's not easy to explore without it, and it would be a shame to miss all the beautiful nature and beaches in the area if you stay only in the village. The island itself offers so much that it's impossible to explore it all in one stay. We definitely plan to come back.
And a cherry on the top of everything was a kitten Mala! She was the first to greet us and it's the most cuddly kitten I've ever met. She's also very disciplined, and doesn't come into the house, but is very happy anytime you give her some attention and love. Future guests, please take care of her, she's just the best :-)