We stayed at Agnanti last week and loved it! The location is perfect; a 5-10 minute walk to the beach (even if it is uphill on the way home!!)
The views were beautiful and the beach at Lygaria was peaceful with crystal clear water. We even had plans to go elsewhere but didn't as this beach was so nice!
The apartment was cosy and George was a great host; always trying to help us wherever he could.
We highly recommend Kri Kri restaurant in Aghia Pelagia and also the bar at the west end of Lygaria with the colourful umbrellas- great atmosphere, cocktails and food.
As for car hire, it was convenient and although the car was a bit older than we had expected, the company was reliable and didn't have any extra costs unlike other hire companies