We stayed at Gianni's for our honeymoon and loved every minute of our stay. Gianni and his wife even had a bottle of prosecco chilling for us when we arrived!
We booked the location without much knowledge of the terrain and without a vehicle so getting down to the beach involved a bit of a hike but we're both fairly active and really enjoyed hiking down after the great breakfast that was provided. Getting a taxi back to the location was fairly successful but involves detailed instruction to the driver. The views in the morning and private pool more than made up for any hassle getting around and we were happy to enjoy a couple glasses of wine at dinner without needing to drive back.
We would love to return someday to enjoy the beautiful views and excellent hospitality!
Also, we would highly recommend grabbing dinner at Elia in Cellia. One of the best meals we've had in Greece!