When you stay in Athens with Lilly, Giannis, and Mimis, you are staying with friends. They do whatever they can to make sure you are comfortable and feel welcome in their amazing home. You have access to all the beautifully​ quirky rooms and everything is super clean. It was a sanctuary among the busy city. I felt comfortable and safe the entire time I stayed there. Plus, as an added bonus, you have the best company you could ask for.
It was also situated within walking distance to all the major tourist sites, and just a short walk to Plaka. Lilly even curated a great little book of recommendations for food and some other local places. Go to some of them, you will not be disappointed.
For the few complaints about privacy in the yellow room, while I was staying there they put up a beautiful curtain! Plus a curtain that blocks out a little bit of the street noise at night, but to be honest the noise never bothered me, it is all a part of the experience!