My wife and I had a nice stay at Sophia’s place.
We loved the neighborhood / location and would gladly return. This was our main concern before coming to Athens and Exarcheia and couldn’t have been happier. The neighborhood was lively and we enjoyed spending time at various cafes / bars / restaurants. This spot is close to the main touristy parts of town, we walked everywhere.
We found Sophia to be a kind and responsive host. The apartment is large and we loved the terrace. The only cons we experienced were that the apartment was not the cleanest and a variety of minor things in the apartment were kind of broken: the toilet seat being loose, washing machine handle broken off (still works but tricky to open), door knob coming out, door curtain coming off, etc.
I still recommend a stay here because of the location and communication with the host but wanted to share the above as we were surprised considering the really high reviews previously given.