We absolutely loved our stay in Josef’s home. The apartment was roomy, the beds were incredibly comfortable, and 2 bathrooms? Perfect. Oh and for Americans or other cold beverage inclined folks, the fridge even had an ice maker.
As for location, it is perfectly situated with a short walk to Plaka for sites or for a number of cool neighborhoods with great food and nightlife and close to a metro stop, but just outside of both so you don’t want straight out your door into anything overwhelming. Bonus for being on a through way road so taxis come often and quickly, but by no means a busy street/heavy traffic.
In all, I would happily stay here again if we find ourselves in Athens again and needing the extra space.