We've stayed in quite a few airbnb's in US and Europe and Andre's rooftop is top of the list. So much character and so many windows which really adds to the experience as you get incredible views of the surrounding rooftops and the sky above. And it really delivers the airbnb experience -- you are embedded in a real neighborhood in someone's real apartment in a real city. The buildings in this area date from the mid 1800s, and these rooftop apartments used to be the quarters for the servant class, now converted to some of the most interesting apartments in Paris. The location is great with access to both the 4 and 8 metro line right out the door. Plenty of shops and cafe's and even an organic co-op down the street like a Whole Foods.
Andre was a very responsive host, reaching out to us even when we booked the apartment to make sure we were fully aware of the conditions of the apartment (which he probably feels is needed given the incredibly unfair and malicious review of a previous guest). Upon arrival, Andre was very responsive via Whatsapp and we the flat is easy to find, easy to access. Andre provided detailed information for the flat and a helpful document for local attractions, restaurants, rooftop views, etc.
We had our children (11 and 7) and they loved the apartment and the location. The piano is amazing and in tune and our kids played throughout our stay. We were there six days and the kids really enjoyed mapping out our days on the metro and the buses and they became quite confident and adept at venturing into the city. From this location you can to most anywhere in the city in 20-25 minutes.
The utilities are serviceable (microwave, fridge, bath, toilet), the kitchen is small and there is no oven so not ideal if you want to cook anything more than a basic meal. The flat is "lived in" with some paint chipping off the wall and some broken tiles on the floor but it is clean and safe. If you demand an orderly and predictable "hospitality experience" like a Marriott Courtyard or a Hilton Garden Inn, then this is not the place for you. If you are uncomfortable with the unseemly realities of a world-class city then this is not the airbnb & neighborhood for you. However, if you are looking to minimize the "tourist" experience in your Paris getaway, this is a good neighborhood and an amazing apartment experience. Highly recommended.