Super cute and very clean. I am giving five stars, because Heide was very responsive, the apartment was great, and everything was exactly as described. I would just caution that this is indeed on the far edge of Paris. Getting to more central parts was very easy--5 minutes' walk to the Metro--but we did kind of wish we were in a more picturesque neighborhood. This is not the sweet, winding, narrow streets of the Monmarte near the Sacre Coeur. It is also much less touristy, and more neighborhoody. Use your judgment, depending on your needs and wants. It is cute, comfortable and quiet, but out of the way and in a less pretty neighborhood. Also, while it is a fairly short walk from Gare du Nord train station I would not recommend it--walking down Barbes with our luggage was definitely not a great idea. Nothing happened to us, but we felt very conspicuous and nervous walking down the busy street.