Catherine's place was a wonderful place to stay. We would particularly note the location and Catherine's prompt communications, responsiveness to questions, and helpfulness. Other's have noted the cigarette smell and Catherine clearly says smoking is allowed. We really only noticed the smell when we returned from being outside, it was not very strong, and it quickly was no longer noticeable. Regarding her helpfulness, my wife actually needed to see a doctor, and Catherine gave us a number to call and followed up with her by email and phone to check on her condition to make sure everything was ok. We really appreciated her concern and help.