Cathy (and her husband) is an excellent host. Everything is as listed. Cathy is responsive with communication, her apartment is in a fabulous location in Paris, clean, safe and very convenient for most Paris attractions. Cathy provided me with a list of lesser known attractions and I enjoyed visiting those which appealed to me. Transport options are many and very close to the apartment. Very convenient access from Gare du Nord. I enjoyed staying with her family very much.