Pros: This is like staying on Park Avenue in New York City. You can look out the window and you're about 75 yards from the Big Wheel. There is coffee, a coffee maker, dishes, extra sheets, laundry--everything you could possibly want. The apartment itself is clean and nicely decorated. It was exactly as pictured. Jay is very quick to respond to questions and gave us recommendations on places to eat, etc. Oscar is fantastic--you won't find a friendlier guy. There is some street noise but not as much as you would think given the great location, frankly.
Cons: Very minor cons, but I'll give future travelers a heads up. First we had a little confusion about the location. Our cab dropped us off on the correct block and we looked for the exact address. There was a deli where we thought the apartment should be. We asked the woman at the deli and she looked confused and said "Follow me" and took us down two doors. She told us there were two buildings with the same number? The building numbers seemed out of order. Anyway, my point is that we were a little confused initially about the address but it all worked out. Second, the apartment is located at the end of a long, dark hallway and the lights were often off, so it was pitch black. We just used our phones as flashlights, and eventually we figured out where the light switch to the hallway was. It wasn't really a huge deal to me because I was traveling with my 2 teenage sons and husband, but if I were a woman by myself I might have been uncomfortable.
All in all, I would definitely rent from Jay again! He's great, Oscar is great, the apartment is great--Book it!