Plus points:
Excellent location, good communication. Apartment as described and a good price for the area and time of year.
Towels and clean bedding.
Negative points:
Lift was broken but host provided a €40 discount, although 11 flights with or without bags was not great. it happens!
Clearly lived in, which we have not experienced before, but finding mouldy and out of date food in the fridge and mouldy coffee grounds in both coffee makers was not great. Also balconies had full ashtrays and a lot of pigeon poo! Also toilet not very clean.
On balance, ok for the money, decent spacious apartment ,great view , good host and if the lift had been working the minor issues would have felt like less of a problem. Hopefully minor cleanliness issues will be fixed by host.