Alain's place was the perfect stay for my first trip to Paris. Montmartre, from what I could see, had the best markets for bread, cheese, meat, fruits/veg...and is the one of the best night life locations.
The apartment was very clean, quiet and Alain even went out of his way to accommodate my coffee/tea, wine preferences leaving me a fantastic welcome basket to arrive to. He was very available for any questions/concerns I had and was completely reliable.
I would not hesitate to stay at Alain's again when I return to Paris.