Pros
Great location
Mini fridge
Washer/dryer
Cons
The front door is a fire hazard. It requires the key in order to unlock the door from the inside.
Extremely loud stairs. Normally I don't care about this sort of thing, but none of us could use the bathroom in the middle of the night without waking up the people in the basement bedroom. These stairs are comically creaky.
No a/c. Again, normally I don't care about this, but there's a hotel next door and opening the windows wasn't possible at night without hearing people literally yelling at 3 am. I live in a loud city, but even earplugs did not help with how loud the back of the building amplified the sound. With the windows closed, the sound level was perfect, so we sweltered at night instead.
Extremely hard beds. I've slept on floor futons that were softer.
Weird bare walls. I knew that this would be the case before we rented, but there isn't even a mirror other than the one in the small bathroom. It would've been nice to have something in the living area or hallway so that if the bathroom is occupied, someone else can do their makeup or brush their hair.
The following doesn't impact my rating since I don't expect these items, but I'm listing it for future renters: there were no toiletries other than shampoo. Usually Airbnbs have soap or other things left behind by renters, but this location has nothing other than nut-scented shampoo, which gave me a mild allergic reaction. It didn't even have laundry soap for the machine.