Pierre's apartment was clean, VERY STYLISH and comfortable. We loved staying there. The neighborhood was quiet and lovely and Pierre was very responsive to all our needs. A couple of notes - the elevator is VERY small - I have stayed in Paris before and stayed in places with small elevators but this takes small to a new level - it is about 20" deep by about 48" - it really was beyond small!! But we persevered. Also - the metro stops are not that close - particularly if you want to travel to the same side of the river - this stop is a good 15-minute walk. The restaurant on the first floor can be loud but honestly, it adds to the Parisian atmosphere. Afterall you are in Paris - what is there really to complain about??