The reason for the three star review was that the apartment was not clean, there were no clean linens, and there was barely any soap on the bar left with hair on it. Additionally, it smelled heavily of cigarette smoke and there was a strange sewer like smell coming from the basement level/bathroom at our arrival and the duration of our visit. Although the description says up to a family of four, it is definitely better for one to two guests due to the small size and coziness. Had the apartment been a little cleaner and fresh linens and soap were provided, we would have had a much better experience.
Other than that, it was a great location with many hidden gems nearby. We really appreciate Eric for being so flexible and hospitable, allowing us to use the flat earlier than the check-in time and with the convenience of a key lock box. Just minor improvements could make this the perfect and ideal AirBnB stay in Paris! Thank you, Eric!