My daughter and I had a great stay at Noelle's 1 bedroom apartment. The location is fantastic- a 7 minute walk to St. Paul's metro station (on Line 1) as well as being close to 2 other stations, a great bakery on the corner, 10 min walk to rue du Roisiers (falafels!), right behind Place des Vosges. Noelle responded to inquires immediately. The 1 bedroom apartment is in very safe building. It is an older apartment, and along with that come some quirks - tiny kitchen and odd bathroom, older furnishings, somewhat cluttered. The apartment was not spotless but certainly clean enough. I would stay here again.