Apartment was sparkling clean and well stocked with all that we needed for our 4 night stay - kitchenware, coffee, towels, shower gel, dishwasher pods, etc. View of the Seine was great - we could pull the dining room chairs up to the window to watch the boats go by while we sipped our wine. Catherine was a welcoming and responsive host. We appreciated the sparkling water and orange juice she left. The hike up 5 flights of stairs got a little tiring. The primary reservation I'd have about returning was noise from the neighbors. I think it's just that the walls of this building transmit sound too easily and we could hear them even when they were just having conversations at normal volume.