Nice, airy, clean apt in a access secure building. Family friendly neighborhood. Apt was just as shown in photos. All basic amenities available and working. Sophie is a generous host and she welcomed us in person. Overall, this apt is better than most 3 star properties in Paris so I would give it a 4 rating. Only dowside is that this apt is on the east edge of Paris city so many main attraction are 30+ min by metro. I would definately come back to stay here again..