3 of us stayed with Carole in the snow in March '13 for 3 nights. Carole deserves the 5 star rating because her studio delivers as described. Carole is welcoming, personal and helpful but there is no infringement on your privacy, a rare combination.
The arrondissement is superb and for repeat visitors to Paris it offers a refreshing view.
We would not hesitate to stay here again and will recommend it to our friends. Airbnb is fantastic.