Mélanie's place was great for us-- we stayed here four nights. I've always enjoyed the 14th district of Paris, so the location was a plus. It is not far from two different metro lines. Mélanie is super sweet and responsive. She has a cat Romeo who you won't see much of-- he's really shy. He's every well behaved and he mostly just does his own thing. The shower and toilet are small but that's typical of any Parisian apartment. Everything was very clean. The bed was comfortable and we both slept very well.
Only annoying thing was the neighbors were loud at night but that's also typical of Paris and not something Mélanie has control of.
Apartment is tucked away in a courtyard- I felt very safe. I definitely would stay here again!