Highly recommended! The apartment was exactly as described and pictured, very clean, with lots of amenities to make us feel very welcome. We also used the sofabed - seemed new, totally functioning and comfortable. The contact with Charles and the check-in with his friend was prompt and easy as can be. Charles generously allowed a late check-out which we appreciated very much. The apartment is in a great area - Montmarte - well connected by public transport but also easy to walk to lots of interesting places. We will be back.