Emmanuel's place was superior in terms of location in the city. at the edge of the Marais but close to the Bastille made getting around very easy. Lots of places to walk to, but an abundance of options in terms of public transportation. I would describe the apartment as charmingly quirky. It has all the basics that you need, though. The bed is comfortable, and the water gets hot. The kitchen is functional. Just beware that there are stairs. Leave your very heavy bags at home.
I can't say enough though about Emmanuel's communication as a host. I've stayed in many Paris Airbnb's, but sometimes the communication in English can be difficult. Emmanuel communicates in English very easily. All in all a wonderful stay.