I really enjoyed my time at Emma's place. She was a very good communicative host, and I wish I had the opportunity to meet her in person as she was very kind (and meets most if not almost all of her guests) but I came during Easter weekend so the timing just didn't work out. Due to that she was very accommodating about how I got the key and me checking out. I think the location is very good if you're not trying to do all the super touristy things/have been to Paris before/want to see Paris in more of a local light. I personally preferred this, also if you're into sewing it is like a 6 minute walk to Saint-Pierre where all the fabric stores are. I would definitely stay here again and recommend it.
If you're like me, I did book it for the location/price but also the bathtub--and it was 100% worth it.