We had a positive experience at Pierre's place. It's a little bit of a walk from the train station, especially carrying luggage, but not a big problem. We enjoyed the quiet neighborhood, especially considering how many tourists flood Paris during the summer season. The place was clean, though since it appears that the tenants still live there when not AirBnB'ing it, it feels more like visiting a friend's home who made sure the place was nice and clean. If we had any suggestions, it would be to offer a document with local recommendations, tips on transportation, etc. Additionally, a couple extra pillows would have been nice, as the 2 pillows (1 per person) provided were pretty thin and we had to fold them in half to raise our head up more. This is just our opinion of course and some people may be fine with this. Overall, good value and no major complaints.