Caroline and her husband have a beautiful home, they are very generous to share it; and I had a wonderful trip. The bed was very comfortable, the bedroom lovely and quiet, and having sole use of the bathroom and shower on the upper floor by my bedroom made it feel like a private suite. Being able to help myself to breakfast was super, with loads of choice. The location of the apartment is fantastic, and it is very safe and secure; I would definitely ask to stay with Caroline again if I have the opportunity to return to Paris. She was a super host, very relaxed. and has already posted the perfume that I forgot when I left...like others have said she went the extra mile, and I really appreciated it. A wonderful place to stay.