Full marks for Antoine's. Every bit of his place, neighborhood, and hospitality made us feel at home.
A 10 minute climb up any of the nearby streets puts you near sacré-coeur and the tourist crowds, but his street has a local vibe and some amazing cheese, meat, veggie and cheese shops. Cross the street and you have a small but complete grocery. A block away is the Metro 12 station with a manned booth if you need help buying a Paris Visite pass.
Though the street is busy, the apartment has courtyards on two sides and is quiet, full of light and fresh air.
This was our 2nd stay in Paris, and next time we'd want to return to Montmartre and ideally Antoine's.