Our two stays in France were truly a tale of two cities, well, at least of hosts. Alexis was brilliant. We had a bit of bad luck - the water heater was dead and Alexis worked hard to make it right. He came immediately. Because he couldn't get manufacturer support and knew getting professional installation would take too long, he bought a new heater and replaced it himself. It took 1 1/2 days to repair - not optimal for our stay of 3 days - but we completely understand. The fact that he moved heaven and earth goes beyond words. In contrast, our Paris host had us buy our own toilet paper and was effectively MIA.
The apartment is very nice and clean and nicely appointed. It is in a quieter part of Vieux Lyon, but within a few minutes of the cathedral and the "north" of Vieux Lyon where there are many shops, bouchons, and bars. Presqu'ile is about a 10-15 min walk.
I gave 5 stars, even with the major inconvenience, because Alexis worked so hard and was so caring.