We stayed in the basement apartment. It suited our needs and we enjoyed using the hot tub. The only part I did not enjoy was the other guests walking above our heads, but that was out of the hosts control. Karen was very quick to respond to any request or question immediately. My only advice would be to have up stairs guests reminded there are people below them and maybe ask them to step a little lighter :)
We would go back and do recommend this place. I’d love to go back in the summer and use the pool. It’s has a beautiful view of the river and lovely walking trail.