We stayed five nights at the Artist Garden - 3 nights in the Wild Orchid Room and 2 nights in Silver Birch. Please see our complete review of wild orchid/overall experience. The Silver Birch room is comfortable and clean with the great kitchen as well and a nice view - it's on the first floor with lots of Windows for a garden and bay view. It doesn't feel as private as the rooms upstairs because the porch, deck get used a lot by guest, however just close the curtains and your quite fine.
We did not stay in the star gazer room on 2nd floor next to the wild orchid room. I wish we got to do that too! Took a peek in that room and it was just as lovely as Wild Orchid with added bonus of going up in the peak to gaze at the stars.!