I highly recommend staying at Counting Sheep. Rooms #2 and #3 are large, stylish, have all the amenities you need and spectacular views of the "Chocolate" River. The beds are uber comfortable, the hosts are welcoming and helpful and the area is stunning. The friendly farm animals and the walking trails are a bonus. If you are visiting Hillsborough or Hopewell Rocks I would highly recommend staying at Counting Sheep.