Dave’s place was very second-rate - a dusty stuffy room with no air flow and old bars of soap in bathroom. In general, the common spaces and room could use a good deep cleaning.
I’m really surprised that he gets a super-host rating. His outgoing personality and the non-stop history commentary must be the reason. Just don’t call him with a question about the WIFI code at 7 pm, or you will be scolded as if you were an empty-headed teenager. I would never go back and I would never recommend it. Even with free parking!