I was comfortable here, and all the basics were totally fine. It was quiet and I slept great, everything worked, location was excellent, Gordon responds to any messages almost instantly. If you've booked this place, I'd be confident your stay will be totally ok.
At the same time I've been so privileged to stay at so many amazing airbnbs that went beyond fine, where the host was truly dedicated, and I noticed the difference. I could list a dozen things off the top of my head that could make the place better: the walls and bathtub caulking/grout are looking pretty bad, fix the blinds, parse the cupboards of half-eaten food so that there's some room for my own groceries and organize the cleaning stuff better so there's room for my bag in the closet, a dish towel would have been nice. On arrival there was an overwhelming, cloying smell of some sort of perfumey product, not sure but possibly an air freshener, that took days to dissipate. The check-in is anonymous at a lock box, so an info sheet about the apartment/building would be nice upon arrival. The check-in/check-out info is very detailed, but I'd be even happier receiving slightly personalized messages rather than a cut and paste, and perhaps, if you're going to let me know the night before that the building will be sending a workman into the unit at an unknown time the following day, an apology for the disruption rather than a "heads-up" might have been nice. And I'd have found it nicer to thank me for going to the trouble of dropping off the keys down the street at a lockbox, rather than ordering me to do so by the checkout time.
I could list more, but again, these are all small things, and I had a comfortable week here. If I hadn't been so lucky with the dozens of fabulous airbnbs I've stayed at, maybe I would have noticed the differences less.