Wow! what an outstanding experience. I dare say this might have been one of the best Air Bnb's we've ever stayed at.
What stood out for us were the small details. For instance, the towels were extra fluffy, the kitchen knives were sharp!!! and there were spices and condiments that we could use.
As others have said, the location is outstanding. You get the "money" shot of the city. We recently saw a documentary about astronauts going out into the space. One of the astronauts commented on how different the experience was when they realized they were only a handful of people to have the opportunity to see the world from that perspective. It's something very similar for us. I had really never had the opportunity to see the city from the island's point of view throughout the day and it was super refreshing to have that.
Finally, while the rates are high I do not think they are anything out of the ordinary for a downtown hotel. In fact, I think the experience of taking the ferry, being part of a small community and having the island to yourself at night makes this an experience well worth taking. It's truly special if you value these things.
Bennett is a great host. He clearly takes his responsibility seriously. I would highly recommend booking this gem. It's a perfect trip to get away and decompress.