A++++. Andrew and his wife were both very accommodating, relaxed, and comfortable to be around. I travel often and this was one of the best trips I've enjoyed the past couple years - some of the suggestions like the market, certain spots for food, a free concert downtown, and especially going to the islands (probably my favorite part of the 4 days I spent in Toronto) were all as described. For each of these Andrew would provide detailed directions and a description. He made it easy to hit these spots and get around in the city without a car. Usually drove but opted not to and had no use for a car since the address is right off Spadina and a streetcar stop.
Bed was good and cozy. Room was more than what I needed, with a strong AC unit. Outside had the usual sounds of city traffic which for me was kind of cool. Had access to the kitchen and fridge no problem and enjoyed the small porch out back. The cat was very cool to be around also, and seemed to enjoy hanging out as I read my book on the couch or what not. It was easy to feel at home.
I honestly can't think of a drawback for my entire experience. I guess the water pressure in the shower could be a bit better but I always felt refreshed after one. It was above and beyond what I expected. When it came time for me to leave and stay in a 4 star hotel I was actually disappointed to go...