We really enjoyed our stay in The Gatsby! It was a different theme when we booked, but the switch was actually an upgrade, in our opinion! Bed was super soft, good water pressure and heat in the shower (a little poorly designed, so be careful of water spilling out of the door!), and hosts were VERY responsive. Would definitely stay here again.
This location was awesome for a stay in Le Plateau, close to St Laurent but insulated from all the late night bustle. There is an orange metro line stop super close as well as multiple bus options, so easy to head to other areas. The patisserie/boulangerie a couple doors down was perfect to get the morning started and the dive bar nearby the best way to calmly end the day.
The best part about The Gatsby was that it was the most well appointed kitchen we've ever had in an AirBnB. We spent a day up at Jean-Talon Market (highly recommend) and we had everything we needed to make a meal from our winnings.
Lastly, don't miss the roof deck -- get a bottle of wine, some fromage et charcuterie, and have a lovely evening in too!