We had a lovely time in Julie and David's place. Highly recommended! It's very charming and the tub was a HUGE plus. I have never really taken a bath before and that was one of the most relaxing things I've done on a trip. It's especially great because it's right by a huge window so all the light is coming through in the morning. It's a unique experience.
I will say make sure you're close to whoever you are staying with because you not only bathe in front of them but the bathroom is almost right next to the bed so you are able to hear everything in there. Other than that I think everything about this place was fantastic. You can also shower downstairs if you're really opposed to bathing or using that bathroom.
Location: I thought the location was perfect. It's less than 20 minutes from the really touristy parts of the city. You're in a very nice neighborhood with plenty of restaurants, grocery stores, and bakeries. There's also a Bixi bike rental literally around the corner. It's only $5-6CAD to bike the entire day!
Amenities: There's a mini-fridge, TV, hairdryer, shampoos, soap, wifi, work desk, and a separate entrance. You have pretty much everything you need and there's no need to go into the rest of the house if you want privacy. The doors are not soundproof so you can hear what's going on in the hallway but it wasn't a big deal. The back entrance was a nice touch. Be aware that the staircases are a little narrow in case you're a bit larger or you have really big luggage.
Tips:
To lock the sliding door to your room you must lock it before you slide it shut. It wont work if you close it and then try to lock it. Make sure you hold down the toilet lever for a couple seconds in order to completely flush.
The touristy stuff is great but don't be afraid to explore your own neighborhood and talk to the locals. Have breakfast at a local spot instead of going to just the bagel shops (although they are delicious and you should try them).
We will definitely be back to Julie and David's place next time we come to Montreal!