Overall I had an excellent stay! However, I will say a few things to potential guests. Laef's place is definitely more suited to a certain type of traveler.

If you like:

an eclectic selection of records
some of the best food in Montreal steps away
a nice kitchen
tons of space
traveling with a big group

Then great! It's a spot for you.

If you need:

New bedding/furniture
proximity to Plateau/Downtown/tourist spots
clubs on the block
something romantic
the airbnb version of a hotel

then maybe not!

This place is best for larger groups who don't mind a quirky loft space that hasn't been decorated a la suburbs with Ikea matchiness. It's a little rough around the edges but great if you've got a bunch of people who like to explore, cook, and hang out in a cool place.

Laef was really easy to get in touch with and he answered all our questions. Picking up the keys was a cinch and I definitely love this part of Montreal.