This place is pretty beautiful and while some of the other reviewers complain about the skylight, I enjoyed it! The penthouse had great views to montreal and was in a great area. It was walking distance to a lot of things and in a prime location. The airbnb was clean and the place was as described for the most part. However, the washer is held up by tape because it seems to be broken. There was also an ant trap behind the couch, which makes sense because I did see an ant and spider during my time there. The balcony door is also bolted shut which is unfortunate because the weather was so nice and so was the view. The other reason why I am giving this a 4 star is because of the communication. The host was so pushy, asking me if I read the rules 3 times before giving me the check in rules. Some of their house rules are unreasonable as well. The host messaged me on my first night also that quiet hours was at 8pm, on the dot. They messaged me to remind me. They also messaged me on my last night at midnight that check out time was 11. I understand this; remember? I read the rules. They seemed really pushy and while the place was nice, the host made it a little uncomfortable as I felt like I was being monitored constantly. They reminded me they had cameras in the building.