Was pretty much as advertised/expected.
Pros: Very clean, roomy, well-furnished/supplied. Quiet location, very suburban. Enough pillows and towels. Two backroom beds were firm, the master front room one was kinda saggy and soft, but some may prefer that.
Only Cons were minor:
1. We made a point that parking in the driveway was important, and it was promised, but another neighboring tenant of the host parked in the middle of the driveway, so our first night we parked on the street (was worried about snow-cleaning vehicles, but they went around us as host said they would). Rest of the time, the other car stayed on his side. Just not a great start.
2. Plumbing had some minor issues (slooow-draining shower tub, toilet tank not filling reliably), but host offered to get someone in to address, even though it was a holiday weekend. We managed around the problems, and I'm confident they will fix them very soon.
In summary, I'd stay here again. Host was responsive. Really a 4.5.