I stayed at Phillip's place for a month in August. Below are the pros/cons from my perspective. Please read before booking. I wish someone had listed out these issues before I booked so I could make a more informed decision.
PROS
1. Great location with tons of things walking distance. A real neighborhood, not the tourist area.
2. Reserved parking with an EV plug. Huge win because parking in Quebec city is a nightmare.
3. Good TV and cooking setup.
CONS
X The place was not clean up to my standards. It was surfaced cleaned only. Crumbs in corners, a bit of a grimy fridge, the towels were left in the dryer for us to take out and fold. This was the biggest issue I had with the place.
X There was confusion at check-in with the host being on paternity leave but then not really. I was worried about not being able to get a hold of anyone as we were directed to call a rental agency that didn't have a record of the listing.
X No personal touches. No list of places to go or good manual. This is an in/out bachelor type rental.
NEUTRAL
I'm not listing this in the cons since this was as described but the basement felt claustrophobic with very tiny windows (no egress). The water pump is also down there so its noisy. Again, not the host fault, just my preference as to sleeping arrangement.