I would have given 4.5 stars if that had been an option because overall Nathalie's place was comfortable for my week long stay. My two favorite features are how quiet it was despite the hustle and bustle of the streets outside and the soaking tub.
Please be advised, that this place is not as close to the Old City as one might think. Distance wise it is a little over a mile. However, once you account for all of the hills - you will be tired and sore after a day's outing - and I am a fairly fit person. I ended up spending a lot of money in taxi fairs and eventually rented a car.
On the flip side, if you stay in this part of town you will have a more "authentic" experience as there are not a ton of other tourists, at least that I saw. I was ultimately glad that I was not staying in the heart of Old Town as there were swarms and swarms of tourists and I was not even there during peak season. So while it was a bit more challenging to come and go from the Old City - there are still plenty of great restaurants to enjoy and a large lovely park a few blocks away.
While I was extremely grateful for the peace and quiet and a nice soak after a long day of walking, Nathalie's place could use some updating to the amenities, the peeling paint on the light fixtures, and an overall deep clean.