The Ocean Island Inn's staff was friendly and helpful.
The cost of the room was quite affordable and they offer good options for breakfast on the go. The room I stayed in (34) was close to one of the bathrooms on the 3rd floor. Cleanliness was good, as was the noise level after 23h00. The hotel's proximity to the downtown core & plenty of restaurants, coffee spots and shopping was a big advantage.

On the downside, the bed's mattress was due to be replaced, as were the pillows; comfort was lacking for both. Also, be aware that the rooms are not well insulated for sound. I.e. if someone drops anything on the floor above or below your room, you'll hear it clearly.

All in all, the room is well-suited to travellers looking to save money on accommodations and don't mind sharing a bathroom.