It's a really really spectacular setting. Sitting out on the dock with a coffee, or taking a SUP out on the pristine water were highlights of our summer, for sure. Because no boats are allowed on the lake, it's just so peaceful and relaxing. Honestly, we thought we'd spend more time at the beaches on the island, but the lake and dock were just too great.
Neil's communication and flexibility around checking in/out (accommodating our ferry schedule on either end) were really great. He also offered some helpful tips (like SUP out past the dock a little bit before you jump into the lake).
Our only knock was the place was not particularly clean when we arrived and thus we spent our first hour doing some unexpected cleaning. Neil had let us know that he had just hired a new cleaner, so I'm sure that these wrinkles will be sorted out by the time the next guests arrive.
Certainly, not enough of an issue to discourage us from returning.