I recently stayed at Otter Shores with my brother and snl -- 3 adults for two nights, and primarily on the island for business. We were slightly disappointed with the stay due to dirty dishes, no instructions for a confusing induction hotplate (and we are techies). Also note, the second bed, although comfortable enough, is a convertible futon chair (with sheets/comforter provided to make it up for bed). We had no on-site host to promptly resolve any issues. Solid pluses though: it is within walking distance of the ferry, quaint/simple, and would make for gorgeous summer evenings on it's bluff over the sound.