We had a lovely time here, despite some rainy October weather! I think this a great home-base if you plan on doing lots of exploring the island. I imagine you might spend more time in the actual accommodations if you came during the warmer months, we weren't able to take advantage of the deck which I imagine would be lovely on a warm day. It's not super secluded if that's what you're looking for, but even though this is on a street with other houses, it was very quiet and we even saw several deer and bunnies on the nearby properties hanging out in the early evening. And being so close to the town (5 minute drive) made it very convenient for going out to restaurants, locals tours etc.
The rolling ladder to the loft bedroom was neat, but sometimes felt a little unstable. Just make sure you have your wits about you when climbing up and down and maybe just leave your luggage on the main floor.
Amanda was great to communicate with and suggested our favourite part of our trip- whale watching with Adventures by Hip. She also made great restaurant suggestions and they even left a bottle of wine for us when we arrived which was such a nice touch.
Overall a great stay with all the amenities you might need, and a really unique spot!