We loved the Tall House! It was so easy to secure the booking and check in/out because Gloria was so quick to communicate. She met us at the house, which seemed above and beyond. The house was a close walk to a beach, which our son loved - it's nice to be in a location where you can walk to something scenic in the evenings, and not have to use the car. So, the location was just what we love - scenic, quiet and in the middle of nature.
The details in the house were what made it such a nice stay. The wood stove was all ready to start (paper and kindling in place - box already full of wood), Gloria had left fresh-baked scones and jam, and the house had everything you needed for the next morning, right down to the coffee beans and milk/cream in the fridge! I certainly appreciated the art throughout the house, it felt so homey and comfy, but with a real attention to esthetics and detail. Gloria had even put wild flower bouquets in a couple of places in the house. The architecture of the house was also really cool! I can't say enough about it, and would definitely recommend it.
Pender Island is also very fun. It feels remote (which means it stays special), but it's so reachable as a retreat from Victoria or Vancouver. It has great eats too, and grocery stores. And tons of coastline to explore!