I planned a surprise visit for my dad to Mayne Island and I saw Dorothy's place was a rare find, and available.
I fell sick the night before I arrived, however, Dorothy and Greg were excellent hosts, and made me feel comfortable nevertheless.
I went there with no expectations or preparations, and I was taken aback by how serene, tranquil and comfortable Dorothy & Greg's place was. It is conveniently located close to the ferry terminal, and a short drive away from the seaplane dock (which was my preferred mode of travel). The Japanese Gardens are a short stroll away.
Dorothy makes some really delicious homemade jam that pairs so well with her fresh baked bread. You might also want to try her frittatas for breakfast.
I went kayaking with my dad in their 2-person kayak, and that was a memorable experience for my father and I. The views around there are amazing, and you're probably going to see some seals if you're kayaking.
I highly recommend staying with them!