We love, love, loved our stay at Dallas & Sarah's. We rented out both suites, and it was perfect for our family situation (travelling with our two kids and a set of grandparents). The two suites have shared laundry, so we left both doors open to create an adjoining suite - the kids loved being able to go back and forth between us and Grandma & Grandpa! It might have been a different vibe if we had in fact had neighbours in the suite next door.
The hosts live on site (upstairs), but they give you free roaming of their backyard and dock area - including the hot tub, kayaks and paddle boards. The location is absolutely stunning and the ocean in the area is 100% swimmable. The bay itself is filled with sailboats, kayakers and paddle boarders, and there are a ton of restaurants within walking distance. The ferry to Mill Bay is also right next door.
We will certainly return in the future! Thank you!