While the location, scenery, and spaciousness were wonderful (and as advertised), I saw no reference in the list of features that the house would be shared with a person living in the above-level part of the house. The furniture appeared to be left-overs and at least one rug in the bedroom on the right was stained and filthy. At least one of the mattresses (where we tried to sleep), was so old and soft tht it was unsleepable (other reviewers have noted this). Two different couples tried to sleep on it, and none of the four people were able to. When I shot a note to Jack (who was pretty responsive to our needs), he went upstairs and brought down a mattress (not sure if he had been sleeping on it). Not a way to run a rental.
Since 4 couples were staying in the house, we need to have at least 2 keys. Jack noted that the owners generally don't provide a second key, although he brought one down. Only one key for 8 people?...really?
Lastly, there were worn-out, tacky notes all over the house. Certainly would have been better to have a fact-sheet with reference information to everything visitors need. This place has a lot of potential, but it is in need of significant improvements to make it worth the money.