Tall house offers exactly what we were looking for. It's in a truly quiet location near the end of the road, and an easy 5 minute walk to the (rocky) beach. Pretty much everything else is in North Pender somewhere, which is about a 20 minute drive away. The house is a very open concept, so no privacy really, but very comfortable and homey.
Gloria is a great host and gave us some advice on day trips to other islands (ferries really only work for Victoria) and where to find blackberries. She also supplied us with a welcome package that included excellent coffee, and homemade scones and jam. :)