We had a lovely stay at Kelly's place. There were three of us total (long-time college friends) and we each took a separate bedroom. It was very nice to have a grown-up vacation with room to spread out, and the heaters in each room were perfect for us since we all have very different heating needs.
The house had really everything we possibly could have needed, with maybe the exception of decaf coffee. But there was an extensive tea collection that included decaf choices, so I wasn't totally left out!
We all enjoyed the board games, fireplace and the soaking tub. The noise downstairs was pretty loud once the people upstairs started moving around for the day, but since the house description was so thorough, that was expected and not a problem at all. The showers were hot and the water pressure was nice. Local soaps were provided.
The only real negative is that the living room sofa was small and uncomfortable, but that is really splitting hairs. The hosts, amenities, and location were all fantastic and we wouldn't hesitate to stay again. Salt Spring Island and its residents were delightful, even in the rain and cold. Enjoy!