We really enjoyed our stay in Caye Caulker at Hilary & Pike's place.
The studio was much more spacious than we were expecting, and was super clean! Pike gave us a really warm welcome, collecting us from the water taxi dock, and our hosts were always on hand if we needed them.
Caye Caulker is an amazing little island and we definitely think we chose the right place to stay. It was nice to be staying with a local family rather than in a resort type place. The island is perfectly safe, but we felt especially secure staying within this private residence. The location is just the right distance away from the busier areas - and although the mosquitos were really bad we think it was like this pretty much everywhere on the island.
The bikes are a real god-send. If you are choosing between this apartment and another one that doesn't have bikes included.. choose this one! It was so great being able to get up every morning and hop on the bikes to go for breakfast or visit the split, or to get to the water taxis.
Overall we would definitely recommend staying with Hilary and Pike. Their communication was excellent, and they will really look after you and make sure you are enjoying your stay on the island.