This is going to be a long review, but detailed information.
PROS:
The location is close to the ferry, nice view of the port, and quick responses from the hosts.
CONS:
It's not close to the resorts nor the places most people come to visit. The premises (internally and externally) are in dire need of fixing up! The pictures are a lie and outdated! There's marks along the walls, cabinets that don't close, and the building itself isn't in its best shape. If you look up in the shower there's mold growing. Also, the host told me I could check-in 5 hrs early and I arrived 2 hrs 15 minutes early and it wasn't ready...their response was to call the cleaning lady and then reply to me saying that check-in is still until 3 pm. Also, there was hair throughout the airbnb (on the bedding & towels), I think the cleaning lady should wear a hairnet.
For me the worst part was that the wifi doesn't really work. Their response "oh its due to the storm..." this was FALSE! Everywhere I ate, etc., the wifi was excellent!