Gaby's place is wonderful. It's at the top of a hill with incredible views (we quickly learned fog is common in the mornings but do not fret - it clears!). We particularly liked that it was on the grounds of a resort, so we had all the amenities, including access to the pool, while feeling like we were still in our private space. The Wi-Fi is a bit spotty in the cabin, but it works perfectly well at the resort itself. You can easily walk down to San Ignacio town and get a $5 cab ride back.
One word of caution is that the lower bunk has a very old mattress, so make sure someone young and lithe is assigned to that one!