I want to put an honest open review so others will know what they are getting. First off, the host Monique was awesome. She was super responsive, friendly, helpful and had so much knowledge of the island and could answer so many questions. She was great, as was her amazing husband Maurice who operates his own restaurant on their property. The food and company were without compare!
The property was exactly as listed, but not what I expected. I guess I knew it wouldn't be fancy, and I didn't want that, but I didn't expect it to be quite so rustic. (Never having traveled much, this place was actually probably nicer than most of the resident's homes on the island) There are visible openings in the walls, you can see under the house where the porch and house meet at the front door, and there is duct tape under the faucets in the shower. And there are resident geckos living inside the house (didn't bother us at all, but could get kind of noisy in the mornings). The bed is very firm; comfortable but I would wake up around 3am every day unable to get comfortable any more.
What it did have that was great though was A/C, wifi, Roku TV, a very complete kitchen set up (only thing we wished it would have had was pepper), plenty of towels, patio with clothes line and hamock/chairs, hot water in the shower and the fridge/freezer worked great. We also appreciated the use of two bikes, which we rode every day. They aren't newer bikes; the seats are torn and the pedals need some grease pretty bad - but when one got a flat, they got it fixed right away. The property is also located in a very quiet spot. We loved hearing the breeze in the trees and the animals and birds outside. The host also had a private dock we had access to and we were there almost every day and loved it.
Ultimately, the longer we stayed (we were there for 7 nights) the less any of the negatives mattered. The Sunny Cabana ended up feeling like our home away from home, and we would stay there again in a heartbeat and recommend it to anyone wanting an authentic island experience!