If you are going to stay in Caye Caulker, Hilary and Pike's place is where you want to be. They have amazing accommodations that are PERFECT for island living. Their place is off the beaten path in a quiet part of the already relatively quiet island. Communication fast and helpful throughout the trip. They picked us up and dropped us off for our water taxis as well. Could not say more good things about our experience. We loved Caye Caulker and a big part of that was Hilary and Pike and their place for us!