I was on Caye Caulker for a couple of weeks and saw the entire island (you can walk around it in about an hour) and checked out every possible place to stay and without a doubt Colinda's was by far the best place to stay on the island.

It's on the south side so you get the quiet and a nice 10m walk up to the split if you want to see civilization. The cabanas are cleaner than any of the hotels on the island and the rest of the guests have a tight and friendly community and Colin will help you out with whatever you need.

I wish I could have stayed longer here but it books up fast so grab a few days early.