My stay here did not take away from my trip as Caye Caulker is such a special place, but I wish I stayed at a hostel where I would have had similar quality for a lower price. This is my 15th stay at an Airbnb and this is the first time I gave less than 5 stars, so I am not usually the complaining type.
Pros: very comfy bed, the inside of the apartment is very clean and appealing, great communication, easy to find, great location.
Cons: the wifi does not reach the apartment, there was no toilet paper (wasn't great when my girlfriend realized that in the middle of the night and had to take an impromptu 4 am shower), no trash can (pretty surprising considering they use septic so you are supposed to throw out toilet paper on Caye Caulker rather than flushing it), various broken appliances and other minor inconveniences.