Generally excellent trip. Michael is a great guy, very helpful. We loved the location as we prefer quieter surroundings. We give it a 5-star rating but with one caveat: we had the pool to ourselves all week. And that made our stay perfect. Keep in mind Caye Caulker is an island without a real beach. There are sandy areas by the water but you can really only go into the water via stairs/docks/piers.
As MIchael confirmed, it could be required to share the pool with up to 6 more people in the adjacent house. And it's frankly not big enough for that. To be completely honest, it would have ruined our trip had we not had unfettered access to that pool. If there's one thing I can't stand when traveling it's fighting for pool/beach chairs. The pier that you get to share with the occupants of the other 6 or 7 houses in this complex is simply not up to it either. Insufficient chairs, insufficient sun or shade depending on the time of day. It's physically too small an area for this many people. And that's before you get into the rude people who try and hog multiple chairs at once.....unbelievable.
So we give 5 stars because that was our actual experience. But it could have just as easily been disappointing.