We had an excellent time here. The location is perfect, very close to the main strip of restaurants and shops, and only a two minute walk from the best beach spot on the South Island. Tucked away just off the main road, we had privacy but always felt very safe. We loved laying out on the porch to escape the sun.
Note that there are no street signs, and the taxis know the hotels by name. Since we took a random taxi, we had a bit of a hard time finding it initially. I would recommend you let Hilda know what water taxi you are taking and she can help you arrange transport. She was very responsive and gave great recommendations.
Be sure to catch a boat up to Caye Caulker north for an afternoon, and we loved snorkeling with Ragamuffin tours! Wish we would have done some day-trip island hopping, other than that it was a perfect trip.