LOOK NO FURTHER!
This is the best place to stay on the island. Hands down.
I spent a lot of time researching all of the listed Caye Caulker air bnbs online and because the island is so small, I was able to see a lot of the places I looked at in person while just biking around the island. Let me tell you, this is the place. GREAT environment- it feels secluded but is nearby everything on the island. Air conditioning in the room works well and is a necessity! The bed and pillows are comfy. The bathroom is large, and the shower pressure is reasonable. One major plus is that there was a ton of storage. I like to keep the house tidy while I travel, and there was no shortage of nice cabinets and drawers to stash your stuff. I would be willing to bet money that this is the only establishment on the island with a fresh coat of paint. It is clean, homey and the view can't be beat. I mean... an over-the-water hammock?? The new owner, Carrie, was an unexpected pleasure. She has a lovely, kind energy which must be contagious because the staff are all very sweet and seem genuinely happy to be there. Overall, we had a great time on the islands and Colinda's Cabins made the trip even better!