We loved Hilary and Pike's place. They made arrangements for us to get to the island easily (It was a surprisingly long water taxi ride on the way there. On the trip back it seemed to fly by, probably because we were aware of the distance to the island.) Pike picked us up at the dock and gave us a tour of the town on their golf cart. It's a perfectly quaint little island. Their property is perfectly quaint as well.
We had loads of privacy and everything we needed. The kitchen was great. The purified drinking water was a big value. There was plenty of hot water for showering. We were far enough away from the center of town that it was quiet and peaceful most of the time. We spent a lot of time on the porch in the hammock or one of their great incan chairs (that's what I know them as. Might be called something else in Belize) It doesn't take long to walk anywhere, and the bikes that they provide are great for getting around if you have a need for speed.
They were very helpful with any questions we had. One great suggestion was to use Raggamuffin Tours for our snorkeling trip. They had a full day sailboat tour with incredible food and drink provided. The guides were a blast to spend the day with.
Bottom line, I would highly suggest Hilary and Pike's place for a fun and relaxing good time.