Like many reviewers, we ended up staying longer than we thought we would. Hilda's place is perfect place to base yourself on a Caye Caulker holiday that might just be longer than you think. The AC is good, and the apartment is far enough away from the main part of town to be a bit more private and relaxed, without being too far (5 mins walk).
There is a fantastic tour operator (West Coast Tours) 20 metres from the house, toward the west side. There's also a great falafel place up the road, near the split.