We stayed at Paradise on the Caye to celebrate our 10 year anniversary - It was so beautiful. By far the best place we stayed during our entire 12 day trip. The water was warm and crystal clear and the sunsets were amazing. There is a kitchen and bar onsite, with the best coconut mojito I've ever had. The beach was not busy at all during our stay (we went in October) and the majority of the day we had the beach to ourselves. You'll definitely need a golf cart rental as Paradise on the Caye is out of town and there are no amenities onsite after 6pm. Joe and Leslie were great hosts and all the folks working at Paradise on the Caye were so friendly and helpful.