If we return to Caye Caulker, we will absolutely look to stay again with Hilary and Pike. Picololo is tucked away from the active main streets of CC, but not too far so you can quickly walk or bike (as we did) to all the activities on the island. The apartment was clean and had a well equipped kitchen. They took care of many details such as beach towels, coffee maker with coffee, sun lotion, shampoo and soap, etc. Pike was kind enough to pick us up and drop us off at the water taxi. We really liked the location and the bikes they provided made experiencing CC even more fun. On our last day there, we learned about a little restaurant named the "Suggestion Gourmet" just 2 doors away from Picololo going away from town. It has an idyllic garden eating area. We had breakfast there, but the owner also serves dinner. The french pastries were just outstanding. So, if you stay at Picololo, which we highly recommend, then consider dropping by the Suggestion Gourmet.