I had an excellent time at Pike's and Hilary's place. Pike picked me up from the Water Taxi station and gave me a tour of the island before check-in. The place itself was beautiful; it's tucked away in the local community instead of the touristy side of the island but it's only a 5 minute bike ride away.
The place was just as described. It had everything I needed for a comfortable stay, and had some little touches that made a whole lot of difference-ice in the freezer, books to borrow, a free bike, extra towels, usb sockets, bug spray at the porch, true blackout curtains. Highly recommended.