I want to preface this by saying that overall, and, in different circumstances, I may be able to give a better score, however, there were a few circumstances which prevented me from doing so, as follows:
1. Communication. The hosts were either quick to reply (same day) or unresponsive. Some initial messages went unanswered for extended periods of time, and, others, when we were on the island, were not handled as immediately as should be (see below).
2. NO WATER in the evenings. We were never notified that there would be NO running water from about 10 PM to 4 AM, every day. There was a water shortage, so we are not sure if that is the case always, but, it would have been great to know. That means no showers and no toilet flushing during those hours. In speaking with others, it is not the case everywhere on the island, as many other guests/visitors had water at all times. As well, the water pressure the entire time was minimal at best.
3. We put the plug provided in the bathroom sink to get some water there to rinse off some beach clothing. The plug got stuck and the water could not drain. It took the hosts 2 days to come to unplug the sink.
4. The hosts were kind enough to rent a golf cart for us, at a local rate, and, told us if anything went wrong, to call and they could come help immediately. The cart broke down on the north part of the island one night (around 10-10:30), we called several times (at $3/minute on our plan), and they never responded until the next day. We had to pay someone $20 to get us back to our rental, and, they ended up taking $15 off our bill.
5. Gary took us on a nice tour of the main city area when we arrived, but, afterwards, there was nothing in the rental unit that told you things like where to shop, whether they recycled, recommended things to do, etc. It is always nice to have a local guide book/folder put together for guests. Most people renting AirBnBs want to live like a local, so, it would be great to give them recommendations on how to do so and tips they should know to feel at home, that they can refer to at all times.
Otherwise, I have nothing but positive things to say about the unit itself. AC that works, great furnishings, location that can't be beat, and fully stocked. I did not find anything lacking other than the above, which, unfortunately, were fairly major things, but, again, could be circumstantial. I still ended up having a fantastic vacation, formed some incredible memories, and, was quite happy overall.