Caye Caulker is not a cheap place to stay, so we can't say how the value compares to other places in Caye Caulker. To us, the place seemed a bit overpriced: the furnishings were a bit tacky, there was no air-conditioning, the door was difficult to close, the water smelled strongly of sulphur, and one of the bathroom windows didn't have a screen (mosquitoes at night!). The plus side was the proximity to the Split, the size, the speed of the wifi, the front patio (shady by 10am with a nice little couch), and the kitchen set-up.
Hilda herself was a lovely host and gave us some great recommendations for restaurants and things to do (tarpons and seahorses on the back docks!) She also came and fixed a light when it wasn't working, and dealt with a problem with the shower head - very responsive!