Pros: Great location! Clearest water and best swimming on the Caye - no sea grass! On site bar and restaurant provides high quality drinks, food, service at fair prices. The Belizean people are very friendly and helpful. In the morning and night the whole site is yours plus maybe a couple other guests. There are plenty of lounge chairs and tables near the water. At night the stars are amazing. There are 4 other bar/restaurants within a short walk. We never felt this location was crowded but did meet a number of very nice people.
Cons: All bars/restaurants at Secret Beach close at 5:30pm! So you choose to eat dinner very early or deal with a 30+ minutes drive on a desolate, very bumpy road in complete darkness. It could be done but a bit risky and my wife said “no way”! The cabana is quite small with spare furnishings. There is no door or curtain separating the toilet from bedroom. The mattress is extra thick and comfortable but they have the wrong sheets that absolutely will not stay on. You will be sleeping on the mattress cover! Water pressure is weak and you’re asked to shut off shower while washing. Breakfast was pretty good but bring your own fruit and juice. There is some construction going on nearby lots so the sounds of machinery can disrupt the beautiful nature of this sight.
Summary: Think of this as glamping and you’ll be happy. If you expect a 3 - 4 star hotel experience, you’ll be disappointed. On the whole, we enjoyed it very much and may return in the future.