My husband and I came to Caye Caulker for our honeymoon. He is a pretty seasoned global traveler, so when I picked Belize (where I had been before) I was nervous it wouldn't be worth the hype in his opinion. But he loved it! We loved it. If you want to relax, Weezie's is perfect. We also go to meet travelers from all over the world. After we caught up on sleep from a stress-filled wedding week, we got to explore the island (seriously, the only way to do it is by bike) and scope out activities and restaurants to enjoy. Excursions like snorkeling and fishing trips are honestly all almost the exact same price with each company. We loved Jay's Adventures (close to the Fantasy restaurant). We did a day trip to the mainland with VIV Tours and did Cave Kayaking and we were the only people with our guide and you get to explore way more with kayaks than inner tubes. This was our favorite part of the trip. There's also a free water taxi you can take to a little island past the split called KoKo King beach...more of a club/party setting there, but made for a fun afternoon and evening. Literally the only place I found that made a good cocktail was Rose's Grill. Everywhere else, just expect to order beer and mixed rum drinks...seriously so much rum on this island. The best lobster we had was Fran's Beachside Cafe, but get there before 7:00 unless you want to wait an hour. But it's pretty delicious. We loved Crepes and Dreams (the owners are really neat people) and the pasta place was one of our other favorites. All in all, we will be back.