We LOVED the Cozy Casa! It is located close to everything exciting on Caye Caulker. The Split is right around the corner and it is a short walk to get to a free taxi to Koko King (as long as you spend $25bz pp on food or drinks). Wish Willy’s is a really fun experience and Maurice is a GREAT chef.
The walk from the water taxi is quick and you will run into a lot of fun restaurants/bars and street vendors. We highly recommend getting lobster at Chef Kareem’s or a meal with key lime pie at Chef Juan’s (when not dining at Wish Willy’s, of course).
We enjoyed the Lazy Lizard and the Sip ‘n Dip at the Split, but found them to be a little loud and pricy. We really loved the day we spent at Koko King and felt like the prices were reasonable. Plus you get the full beach experience you’d expect being on an island as well as plenty of free chairs and shade.
Also we recommend doing a snorkel tour with Caveman. We did the full day tour, which included 8 stops and lunch! The staff was very knowledgeable and friendly.
Overall, the Cozy Casa is a great value that is close to everything worth doing on Caye Caulker!