We haven’t stayed anywhere else on Caye Caulker but we definitely felt like we had the best accommodations on the island! We used our bikes daily and used the free snorkel gear and kayak while we stayed. The staff were extremely helpful with all our needs. Even when we told people in town when asked that we were staying in Colinda Cabanas they would nod and say “ahhh, that’s the best” :) it was the perfect go slow island life locale! Oh and nightly we would go out to the end of the pier and swing on the hammocks in the strong sea breeze and look at the AMAZING stars—so peaceful and perfect! Would definitely stay again!