My husband and I had a wonderful stay at the Cozy Cabana. The pictures were very accurate. The location is nice being so close to the Split. We were able to find Wish Willy's and the Cabana with ease and our hosts were welcoming.
One thing I did not realize is there is no hot water for showering. There are instructions on how to boil water and such but we just took cold showers. This may be for all of Caye Caulker- I'm not sure. The weather was nice enough so this was a minor drawback.
Also the noise level... the Cabana is in the backyard of Wish Willy's Restaurant, and there was loud music playing at night. My husband asked to have it turned down one time so he could sleep, and the host was very polite to do so. Also a minor drawback as we enjoyed the music most of the time!
The price was great and overall we had a wonderful stay. We enjoyed the atmosphere and laid back culture of Caye Caulker!