If you'd like to stay in Paradise On Earth, stay here. The accomodations are super comfortable, the pier, with its lofted hammock, is the perfect place to read or nap. It's quiet. It's cozy. It's. Just. Lovely. Jose attended to our every need, including plucking a coconut from the tree for the best water I had all trip brought to me by the cutest 6 year old helper.
I did not want to leave.
The only "cons" are that it's a little pricier than some of the other listings (but see paradise on earth) and a solid 10-15 minute car ride into town, which is not at all a lot, but if you want to walk everywhere, this might be a bit far for that.
Again, could not rave more about this place and cannot wait to go back and stay in one of the ocean-side cabanas.