Our stay at the Cozy Cabana was wonderful. Monique is extremely fast to respond to any inquiries and is very hospitable. The place was both cozy and charming.
The pros:
Very affordable, amazing/convenient location (3 minute walk to The Split), central to many convenience stores and great eateries, and the hosts are wonderful people. Also, they provide you with a journal that lists many of the top tour services, restaurants, bank locations, store locations, laundry locations, etc.
The cons:
Since it's on a restaurant property sometimes it can be louder than one would ideally like (I simply closed the wooden blinds, but not everyone is enduring); mosquitos (no one's fault - just bring plenty of bug spray). That's it for the negatives.
Would I consider here again? Absolutely, if I ever visit Belize again. Enjoy your stay here.