I really loved Caye Caulker! Definitely my favorite part of my trip. The cottage was really well-located...off the beaten path, so it was super quiet and relaxing. The bikes make it super easy to get where you want to go, and the staff were very helpful in securing taxis to and from the port, and then from the Belize City ferry port to the airport. The pool is AMAZING, especially after a long day being out and about. There is also a sweet little kitty who lives on property who makes sure to say hello to you as soon as you walk through the gate!
The only complaint I have is that there were a lot of ants - outside of course, but there were quite a few that found their way into the cottage. They weren't in the bedroom, which was good, but in the bathroom and kitchen. Make sure to get some bug spray!
Also be aware that the A/C is only in the bedroom. The kitchen is stocked with everything you'd need, but I didn't want to cook bc it woulda been miserable in there.
If you're looking for a no frills, relaxing stay, this is the place!