This house was everything we needed -- it was just the right balance of spacious and cozy, we couldn't get enough of the roof deck, and the complimentary bicycles were really great to have. A couple things happened to break during the week we were there and Nick was very friendly and helpful in getting them fixed or replaced right away. Overall, great experience.
I should say, if you are looking for white sands, beaches, *clean beaches, clean streets, hammocks, and water that you would want to swim in -- look elsewhere. You can find all that about a 10 minute bike ride away, but not around the house, which is down the street from the dump and currently next to a [happily inactive when we were there] construction site. We were fine with all that -- being in a residential neighborhood, a lovely bike ride away from the restaurants, bars, and other tourists, and on the non-'shiny' side of the island, has its own different kind of draw. If that's not your bag though and you've just come for tropical paradise, you'll have a better time in Caye Caulker if you go find a cabana along Playa Asuncion or stay at a hotel in town. If you're cool with a little peak behind the curtain, enjoy that roof deck, it. is. gooood.