Hilary and Pike are extremely friendly and kind- when we arrived, Pike gave us a brief tour of the island which lead us to some of our favorite repeat spots! The room we stayed in was very clean and the beds were super comfortable- one nice and firm, the other a bit softer, so good for both types of sleepers. They are on a very quiet and peaceful side street- abt a 5 min bike ride from everything. The provided bikes worked great and were a huge benefit for us. They also have three adorable dogs who were super well behaved!
PS at night a cute little cat will come around and look for pets...
The value for the space and location is fantastic. Worth noting that it's kind of a bonus it's not right on the beach, in case you happen to be around when seaweed washes up (we were and it can make the beachfront quite stinky- apparently this isn't uncommon, but you'll probably spend most of your time out diving/snorkeling like us, and it's no issue on open water).