This place is all about the location. We stayed in the room that's on top of the ice cream store on the second floor. It's central to everything and reasonably quiet. The porch facing the water is a great place to hang out and watch the people traffic in addition to the water. There's a great breeze coming off the water and we didn't need to use the AC once during our week.
The room is a bit rustic. We never had a problem with hot water from the shower, but the sink only gives cold water. To get to the room, you have to walk up stairs in the back. The 9th step is a different height than the others so it's easy to trip on it. It's dark so be careful at night, as the motion sensor on the light doesn't really do anything until you're already at the top of the stairs. I would still stay in this room again for the location and the porch.