We had a blast in Caye Caulker and this house made us feel like at home. It's a beautiful house with two bedrooms and a great living room and kitchen. Everything was clean and looked great, we used the fully-equipped kitchen every day and, while not in the center of the town, it took us only 5-10 minutes to walk everywhere. And to be honest, walking everywhere in Caye Caulker is part of the fun!
The only room for improvement is the heating system of the shower, which made it really hard to keep a constant water temperature. We let the host know about it and they said they were going to find a solution for future guests.
That being said, I'd definitely recommend this Airbnb to anyone visiting Caye Caulker with no hesitation.