Colinda Cabanas is a lovely place. Our cabin was super clean, the beds were comfy, and the place had everything we could possibly want - free AC, fans, a clean shower with hot water, a mini fridge, Wi-Fi, drinking water, coffee and coffee machine, some dishes, beach towels if we wanted them, personal bicycles (just old cruisers, but they get you where you need to go), a private dock, floaties and kayaks to borrow - we couldn't even use all of their amenities in the 3 days we were on the island! And the property itself is very clean and well kept. We walked all over the island, and I didn't see one other place that looked as nice and inviting. Colinda Cabanas is at the southern end of the middle street on the island, which is less than a 10-minute walk to the water taxi terminal, and probably only 15-20 minutes to the split. It's in a quiet location, so you're not in the middle of the action and can sleep peacefully. The front desk staff was very helpful and friendly, and Juan had great recommendations for where to eat on the island. I was thrilled with our stay and would definitely stay here again!