My girlfriend and I really enjoyed our stay at Colinda Cabanas. Colin and Linda are very friendly and gracious hosts and gave us excellent recommendations on bars, restaurants, and snorkling options in Caye Caulker.
Our cabana was nicely appointed and had a beautiful view of the sea. The private pier is great for star gazing and to watch the sun rise. The location is close to the center of town but far enough away to be extremely relaxing and peaceful.
We only stayed for two nights and were sad we couldn't stay for more. Highly recommended - we hope to be back!