My husband and I stayed at the Seahorse cabana for a week to celebrate my birthday and it was absolutely perfect. It has gorgeous wood floors and ceilings which gives it an open, roomier feel. The A/C was nice to come home to after riding our bikes around the island, and the pool was sparkling clean and a wonderful, refreshing temperature.
The most impressive quality about the Seahorse was the management. They were super accommodating and always nice. We loved seeing Michael and CeCe on our way to lay on the beautiful pier. Be sure to bring your snorkeling gear to explore the ocean around their beach. It was full of tropical fish. And also opt for the flight onto the island instead of the water taxi-- the landing strip is within walking distance to the cabana and you won't have to worry with taxis and crowded, hot boats.
We are already planning our trip back to stay at the Seahorse.