My fiancée and I were here on a scouting trip to find a wedding venue in Belize and we wanted to save some money during this trip. We found Scott's place and saw that it was central to the island (the whole island is walkable) and had very good reviews. For the two of us, it was perfect! Everything we needed (wifi, a comfortable bed, safe accommodations) and it was budget-friendly (weddings can be EXPENSIVE!). It was next to a pizza shop/bar, a juice place (kind of like Jamba juice, but more fresh fruit juices), and a place that sold Fry Jacks (which were DELICIOUS and super cheap!).
Scott has impeccable customer service and was extremely communicative with us. We were late getting into Belize City due to a flight delay from Houston and Scott called ahead to the water taxi company to try and have them hold the last boat out for us! When we missed it despite his efforts, he called hotels in the local area near the water taxi dock and found us a room! THAT'S how awesome of a guy Scott is -- he's willing to go above and beyond to make sure he did all he could for us.
When we finally arrived at Caye Caulker, we were greeted by Consuela, the property manager. She drove us to the room (via golf cart, a 1 minute ride) and was extremely friendly and pointed out places where we could find good food (which is pretty much everywhere on the island, you can't go wrong).
When we come back for our wedding in Caye Caulker, we'll definitely recommend Scott's place for some of our budget-conscious guests.