My wife and I stayed in this hotel for two nights. We loved the location as it's right in the middle of the island and walkable to pretty much everything. The view from the rooftop is great, and we spent some time both nights in the hammocks there.
The doors and walls are a bit thin so noise can be an issue, but other than one instance of noisy guests returning to their room late at night, we didn't experience any major issues.
Check in and check out were both very easy. If we return to Caye Caulker, we would stay here again.