We had a fantastic experience at Hilary and Pike's place. They were both very friendly and helpful with information about the island and transportation.
They even picked us up and dropped us off at the water taxi terminal, which was really useful and greatly appreciated.
Their place is exactly as they describe in the listing. A quiet location on Caye Caulker away from the main bars but close enough to get anywhere on the two bikes they lent us. Everything inside is well-stocked and works perfectly well including a good wifi connection. Their two dogs and two cats are really nice and make the place feel homelier than ever.
I would highly recommend it if you're looking for a good spot to stay for a few days in the island.