Cathy's condo at Sunset Beach was fantastic! My husband and I spent our honeymoon at her place and found it extremely clean and comfortable - great water pressure, air conditioned, full kitchen with a corner store less than a block away. It is right on the water with a gorgeous view!! Cathy was very responsive from the minute we booked, and provided us with great restaurant recommendations and island tips. The on-site concierge, Juan Carlos, was also wonderful! He was available every day and assisted in booking our excursions.
Sunset Beach is pretty far south of the town of San Pedro which makes it very peaceful and quiet. We used a taxi the first few days, rode (complimentary) bikes one day, then ended up renting a gold cart for the last few. It is worth it and actually pretty fun to drive around!
Overall, we loved Sunset Beach!