Comfy cabanas was great for our brief stay on Caye Caulker. The property managers Joshua and Jana were very responsive via email both before and throughout our stay. They had a taxi waiting for us when our ferry arrived on the island even though we had a last minute change and had to take a later ferry.
The 2 bedrooms and 2 baths in our cabana were both a good size and plenty of space for the 3 of us. The air conditioning in the bedrooms was a huge plus and made sleeping comfortable despite the hot days. Fair warning that the beds have foot boards and I'm 5' 7" and could stretch out and reach the frame with my feet when my head was on a standard sized pillow. If you're significantly taller then you might want to put a towel over the foot board to provide some padding.
I don't know why but I was expecting the pool to be shallow and more like a wading pool so we were pleasantly surprised that it also had a deeper end and we took full advantage of cooling off in the pool on more than one afternoon/evening. The location of the property is on the southern end of the island, away from the noise and activity you'll find as you make your way towards the Split, which made for quiet, restful evenings. And everything we wanted to do was still within walking distance.
Some of our favorite things while on the island included breakfast at Errolyn's House of Fryjacks (make sure to go next door to buy fresh juice to go with your meal) and snorkeling with Carlos' Tours on his catamaran, both of which were recommended by our hosts. Everything about our stay at Comfy Cabanas was easy to coordinate which made for a very relaxing trip.