I had a wonderful stay in the Cozy Cabana and on Caye Caulker. The Cabana is perfect for the one or two visitors who are looking for a simple comfortable place to stay. Location is far enough away from the main street for peace and quiet yet only minutes away from water in 3 of 4 directions.
Monique and Maurice are two of the nicest people I have had the pleasure of meeting. Monique was happy to give recommendations for activities and what to do while on the Caye. Maurice is an excellent chef and the meals I had at their restaurant Wish Willy were some of the best I had my entire stay (get the whole grilled fish, you won't be disappointed.
The people on the Caye are extremely nice and I made several friends during my 1 week stay.
If you aren't looking for fancy and you want the "local experience" then definitely book with Monique. The island motto is "Go Slow" and that is exactly what I did