Hillary and Pikes studio apartment is large and we found it had everything we needed during our week long stay. If you are looking for 5 star American accommodation on Caye Caulker you wont find it but if you enjoy the adventure and real life, its here.
This is a quieter area of the island which suited us perfectly but they provide bicycles to get around to the entire island very easily so this is a great plus as it is the best form of transportation on the island. The local info on eating tours etc that Pike gave us was invaluable, and he also met us at the ferry with his golf cart and took us to the ferry when we left complete with our bags.
We felt at home and comfortable at their place and have no reluctance recommending it.