The Birdhouses are everything you could wish for! They're really quiet and private, and the hosts make sure you have everything you need and keep you updated with what's going on in the area and fun things to do. Every time we told someone where we were staying on the island they said 'oh that's really nice isn't it?' I think this is the best experience for you if you want a quiet peaceful stay. it's close enough to town to easily ride there multiple times a day on the complimentary bikes, but far enough away that no one walks by the house.