Colinda Cabanas is a great place to stay on Caye Caulker, probably the best. We had cabana#8, the furthest from the sea but still had enough sea breeze on the porch to make it comfortable. It is a small cabana but had all the things to make it comfortable - several fans, reading lights, a clock on the wall. Having the use of bicycles is a big plus - Colinda is far enough away to insure it's quietness but just a quick bike ride into town. The hammocks and chairs on the dock made a great place for hanging out.
Colin is a great host. He knows the island well and can make great recommendations for food and things to do.
We hope to get back to Caye Caulker soon and will definitely stay at Colinda Cobanas.