Ben and Aria are fabulous hosts! Gumbo Limbo studio is perfect for one or two people. The private patio was our favorite place to hang out and just relax. There is a nice view of the ocean and the breeze is awesome. They have bikes to use for touring the island but we chose to walk (we logged over 70 miles in two weeks!) it's a short walk along the shore to your choice of THE BEST restaurants in the world. Our goal was to not eat at the same place twice!
Everything on Caye Caulker is close-- snorkeling, diving, kayak and paddleboard rentals, even the water taxi for a day trip to San Pedro. So, no matter where you stay, you'll have great access to a variety of activities. However, our suggestion is to book Gumbo Limbo because it is the best place to return to take a break, put your feet up and just be!