I can speak for all 4 of us by saying that our stay was wonderful! We loved Caye Caulker, the atmosphere and our cabana was adorable. Basillio was an excellent property manager, checked on us just enough. When we needed something he was happy to help and was very friendly. Our power did go out one day for a few hours (something about the electrical bill not being paid on time) didn't really effect us, because the power went out when we were headed out for the day, and later that afternoon Basillio took care of it right away when we informed him.
The air conditioning was powerful and worked very quickly. Made sleeping very comfortable. The linens and the cabana were all clean and very nicely decorated. We were happy to have a cold fridge and a stove. I could go on and on about how lovely everything was. We really enjoyed our stay. I wouldn't hesitate recommending Caye Caulker Cabanas to anyone.