If you're looking at visiting Caye Caulker, do yourself a favor and stay with Hilary and Pike! My boyfriend and I booked our first visit to Belize on fairly short notice, and from the day we booked through check-out, Hilary was SUPER responsive to my countless questions. They coordinated the taxi pickup from the airport, and Pike picked us up from the dock in his golf cart so that we wouldn't need to lug our bags to the house. He is an absolute delight!
Having never been to Caye Caulker, we weren't sure where to begin looking for restaurants, bars, excursions, etc. but Hilary had an amazing recommendation for everything. We ate at Chef Juan's daily, hung at the Sip and Dip, and snorkeled with Carlos' Tours all on her suggestion -- it was perfect! Having bikes available ended up being a game changer, as the house is set a bit back in the quiet, residential area. It takes 5-10 minutes to bike anywhere on the island. Since the unit is equipped with a kitchen, we hit the fruit stand every morning for breakfast fixings and cooked at home.
Hilary and Pike are overall amazing hosts and helped make this trip so painless! Their daughters are so sweet, and playing with their cat and dogs were one of our favorite parts of our stay. We will definitely be back!