we loved staying at Sandcastle! the area was so quiet and peaceful, but it was only a 20 minute walk/5 minute bike ride to get to the main street and the Split. the poolhouse itself was very well stocked and had everything we needed. John and Israel were super responsive via Airbnb and any issues we had were quickly resolved. we wanted to see the Lamanai ruins and Israel was incredibly helpful in getting it all set up for us. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it for anyone staying on Caye Caulker!