I would give Caye Casa more than five stars if I could! It was truly an ideal spot for our vacation.
The room was spotless and sparkling when we arrived. The bed was comfy and there were enough pillows for us to be comfortable! The AC kept the room nice and cool, even on a hot day and the drinking water provided in the room was convenient. They provided shampoo, conditioner, body wash and lotion - so I didn't have to buy any. They also provided PLENTY of towels for the bathroom and beach.
I know there were several other guests staying at Caye Casa but our room was nice and quiet - if I hadn't seen guests outside, I would have thought we were the only ones there.
The location couldn't be better. We stepped outside our door and saw a postcard picture view. Stunning. The infinity pool was beautiful and a great way to cool off and relax at the end of the day.
As great as the room was, the concierge-level service we received was the best part. Whatever we wanted, Jake was on it and had it arranged in no time at all. The staff kept the common areas clean and gorgeous at all times. Everyone was friendly and engaging.
I literally can't imagine anything Caye Casa could do to improve the quality of our stay.