I stayed on San Pedro for a few days before heading over to Caye Caulker. I really which I would've just stayed on Caye Caulker. It's the same vibe, just less of a "spring break" vibe to it. I was looking for a super relaxing and quiet place and Colindas was it!
This is an amazing place to stay. Caye Caulker is a quiet island and Colindas in particular really kept to that. There were only a few people out on their private dock when I was out there no matter time of day it is. All of the guests were extremely nice and from all over the world.
The sunrises from the dock are amazing. Watching the stars at night on the dock is great the stars too. My room was very clean. They have a fridge, an umbrella, a big water jug of drinkable water, binoculars if you're into watching the exotic birds of the island and a bike.
All of the staff was very nice and helpful. I met Linda and Juan both of which were helpful and responsive. They gave me a bike and map which was very helpful. Tips on where to go and what to see. So that was all very useful. It takes less than 10 mins to get from their part of the island to "the split" which is the northern end of the island and there are a lot of great shops bars and restaurants along the way.
I would highly recommend taking the flight from Caye Caulker back to Belize City. The airport is about a 3 mins walk along the water to the airport or Linda can arrange a taxi. The views are amazing.
Just a tip. Buy your booze at the Duty Free at the Belize city airport. There are Duty Frees everywhere when you first get through customs and you can bring a couple bottles of liquor or I think up to 4 bottles of wine. You'll save yourself some money as they only have one or two stores on the island and the price a bottle was triple what it was at Belize City's Duty Free.