I couldn't have choosen a better place to stay in Caye Caulker. The location is perfect on the island. I really liked the breakfast in the morning. The guesthouse provides hammocks, beds and beach towels (in addition to the room towels) and palm trees for the hammocks are just in front of the house viewing the sea. The ladies at the reception are very friendly too. The only two improvement should be 1) longer opening hours of the reception, it's closed between 7pm and 8am. Books, microwave, water to refill is there inside. 2) Breakfast should start at 7 am instead of 8 am for activity days or in case of taking a early morning ferry.
These are little things.
All in all it was a very nice stay there and I even stayed longer then I planned.