We had a great stay at the Piquitololo. It was clean and comfortable and nicely located. On Caye Caulker everything is within walking distance of everything else so the fact that the apartment is tucked into a side street away from the busier parts of town was nice, it made for a quieter location (and the bikes were definitely appreciated - it was a lot of fun to just bike around the island checking everything out). Hilary and Pike are amazing hosts - Pike gave us cart rides to and from the water taxi with a running commentary on the local sites (and locals). Hilary was amazing, answering all our emailed questions promptly and providing lots of useful information for us. Great hosts and a great place to stay.