We stayed in Belize City for one night before moving on to Caye Caulker, and this was the perfect location and accommodation for us and this itinerary.
The lodging: excellent. Our cottage was beautiful, clean, and in a quiet compound situated with other cottages around a long, narrow pool. Check in was seamless and the host was very friendly. There is also a garden and winding path connecting the different buildings on the compound (as well as a larger pool).
The neighborhood: quiet, scenic, and convenient. Across from our accommodations was the cafe and yoga studio. We didn’t do the yoga but the facilities looked really nice. Cafe had amazing Belizean / European fusion food with a mostly vegan menu. Delicious. Upper veranda faced out to the bay and ocean with sunset views. Belize Express whatever taxi to the Cayes was also a short walk (10-15 mins). Museum was also close by (but it was closed when we were there).
Would definitely stay here again!