We had a great stay in the Firefly House during our 8 day visit Caye Caulker. The house is far enough from town but close enough to get to any shop or restaurant in 10-15mins. This house also had the best stocked kitchen - everything you could possible need! The pool and the porches were great places to hang in the afternoon. The staff was all very friendly and helpful too! There are a few little restaurants close by - Cor's, Dur D's, and The Spot to Stop were all great.
What we did not like is that the property next door is completely littered with trash and played very loud music everyday from 4-8pm. We were also disappointed the grill was not available until half way through our stay, after asking numerous times.