This place is a gem! It's comfortable, clean, peaceful and lovely. Caye Caulker is SMALL, and many comparable facilities are on the main strip, so they are crowded and there is noise all day and night. Mayan Falls is on a quiet tip of the island, away from all of that.
It's about a 15-minute walk to the heart of Caye Caulker. We never minded the walk. It was worth it to have a calm oasis where we could get away from the crowds and parties. There are lots of cute cafes and shops along the walk as well.
The pool is a fantastic perk. Never crowded, and we enjoyed late-night swims under the stars. Perfect for cooling down after the walk. Very few places on Caye Caulker have pools.
The rooms are basic but they are clean and comfortable. Ours had A/C. No issues with hot water and showers.