Gumbo Limbo is the best, really!! It's a super cute beach house with the most beautiful views!! It's far enough away from the main street so it's nice and peaceful, but close enough to easily walk to. Everything is within walking distance (10-15min), but Aria and Ben also provide bikes so that was very nice. They provide tons of recommendations and respond very quickly. Aria and Ben made our stay so worry free, just like the island :) Everyone needs to stay here, I can't recommend Gumbo Limbo enough. Me and my friend really enjoyed our stay! I can't wait to be back.