Overall rating: 4/5
House is clean, authentic, well-equipped, and provides excellent views of both sunset and sunrise from 3rd story wrap-around deck. Lots of privacy.
-both the owners and the local caretaker were absolutely lovely, and went out of their way to provide relevant advice and recommendations for our stay
-2 bicycles provided
Drawbacks:
-bed was pretty hard and "springy"... usually woke up a bit sore
-location. Caye Caulker is very small, but the house couldn't really be farther away from the restaurants/bars/stores. Expect 25-45 mins round trip by bicycle across heavily potholed road, depending on your athleticism/enthusiasm. Renting a golf cart would mean considerably less effort and a bit less time in-transit, but when trying to cart even a modest amount of groceries by bicycle (think 2 gallons of bottled water), the distance gets tiresome fairly quickly. This may be a plus for some folks.