Easy check in at the coffee shop. I got in a day early, and though they didn't have a room for me, they did help me find a place to stay for the evening. I was grateful for that!
The room we stayed in for our designated time was in a great location. Tucked away behind a pizza shop and a block off of the main strip. It is walking distance to everything on Caye Caulker. The room is very simple. Liked that it had a small burner for cooking and a fridge.
The futon in the front room isn't comfy, so I'd suggest if you have more than 2 people, then you find another room. A kid could sleep on it, but pretty lumpy for an adult. Better when the comforter was placed on top as a cushion.
Amazing snorkeling tours at French Angels on the next block over. Great food all around. Roy's Restaurant is right across the street. BBQ on the strip on the weekend. All in all a good place to stay.