Conch Shell Inn is a centrally located, right in front of Caribbean Breeze Tours and Ocean Ferry (water taxi) if you chose to come by one of the companies. Was here for 1 month, and got to walk to a variety of restaurants. You don't need a golf cart unless you are going out to Secret Beach or just want to have a golf cart for a day to explore the island. Otherwise...walking is your best option and on occasion for farther places to eat, taxis are also super accessible on the side street next to the inn. Must try Jambel which is next door at SunBreeze Suites, it has amazing food and one of the best on the island.
The whole team, Kit, the host, and Vivian & Julia, who come around daily for housekeeping and making sure both inside your place and the rest of the common areas are immaculate, are just an amazing group of people. Kit answered anything via message thru arbnb without any hesitation and in a timely manner. And the ladies, always warm, welcoming, and super helpful in whatever was needed.
I know that I will return and stay with them once again in the future! This place is a true gem!