I had a really nice stay in this AirBnb in mid February 2022. I had wanted to "disconnect" from a corporate job and this AirBnb in Caye Caulker was perfect! The bed was super comfy (and I appreciated the mosquito net) and there were plenty of spots to lounge around like the day bed, the couch and/or chaise in the enclosed porch, the hammocks on the deck, the chairs on the private dock. It was such a nice getaway and Don and Cindy were wonderful hosts. Super responsive and very friendly and it's clear they care about their guest. The only issue I had was a dead battery in a remote for a fan, which Don took care of right away. Their dogs (Rice and Beans) are adorable and so mellow. I can't recommend this slice of island life in paradise enough!
For anyone looking to stay here, know that the mosquitos and bugs are extra spicy in this tropical locale. Although Cindy and Don provide nets, and mosquito coils, and other deterrents for inside the AirBnb, you'll definitely need bug spay for outdoors. Most of my itchy bites were from the bike ride in from town and the short walk from the gate to the front door. I also recommend bringing cortisone cream. Only the bigger convenience stores in town carry stuff like this.
Finally, be prepared for the bike ride into town and the state of the roads in Caye Caulker. I didn't rent a golf cart for the trip and relied on the provided bikes from this listing. The bikes were in good working order and Cindy and Don provide locks (only used it once when I was gone for a snorkel trip). The roads in Caye Caulker are NOT paved or well-maintained and when I was there, all the roads were bumpy to varying degrees and the path between the town (20min bike ride) and the AirBnb on the southside was atrocious in spots after a rainstorm. Huge puddles spanning the entirety of the path and overgrown in some spots. Would it have been easier with a golf cart for my twice daily trips for food? Yes, absolutely. Did it add to the charm and the "rustic"-ness and the disconnection from the sterile city life I had wanted when I booked this trip? Also, yes. Overall, no regrets, but your mileage may literally vary. :)