We would definitely recommend Gumbo Limbo. We stayed in the Arte cabana and it is very spacious with everything you need and more! Very clean and aria and Ben gave us all the information we needed on arrival. If you have a few days and want a beach day, take the boat to Northside beach club it’s so nice over there (although food is not amazing)!
Go to Reina’s for food we found that on our last night and loved it! Only two blocks from Gumbo Limbo.