We loved the scenery and the privacy of not being at a resort (although it is close enough to get to a number of resorts with great dining options.) The cottage is charming and had everything we needed, plus some unexpected surprises. I especially appreciated the huge magnifying makeup mirror! And although we didn't need them, it was nice to know she stocked us with first aid and sewing supplies. The little lights and an abundance of candles made for very romantic dinners.
Our caretaker was very helpful when we needed him, and stayed out of the way when we didn't.
I hope to go back to San Pedro soon, and I'd definitely stay at the Tree House again.