We enjoyed our stay at Sal's place on Caye Caulker. The location was great, it is slightly closer to the split than the water taxi, but it really is in a great location. It is a small island, but in the heat short distances can seem much farther. It also had a good working AC system, which was big for us as the other places we stayed were quite warm. It was nice to be able to sleep comfortably. Everything I read said you only need 2 days on Caye Caulker, but I wish we would have had at least 3 nights here instead. Sal recommended Caveman tours to us which we took his suggestion, and were skeptical at first, but it ended up being a really good snorkeling tour. We got to see Sea horses, feed tarpin, see some nurse sharks (not just at shark ray alley but at the reef itself feeding), and we finally got to see our Sea Turtle. I would definitely book here again if I make it back to Caye Caulker. The value and amenities were great, plus a view of the beach right from the room.