If John and Susan's place is available...don't hesitate to book it right away! It is a beautiful oasis. Their managers, Israel and Mary, were so helpful with check in, questions, delivering water, setting up taxi rides and with advice for things to do on Caye Caulker.
We stayed in the Pool House and it was very clean, well set up and very comfortable. The pool area is so beautiful, relaxing and peaceful. We played games, read and sat in the pool with a kindle to cool down in the afternoon. The wifi was great and we had no issues with the unit or the amenities. It's nice that it's located in a quiet neighborhood away from the island activity, but very close to walk or ride to restaurants.
We greatly enjoyed having the bike to ride around on the island. We like to get out and exercise, but it is a jaunt to the Split and nice to have bikes when you want a quicker ride to restaurants.
If we return to Caye Caulker, this is where we would want to stay. You can't go wrong here and you'll be so pleased you have such a beautiful and peaceful place to relax and enjoy the sunshine!