My partner and I enjoyed our 6 day relaxing stay in the two bedroom, 1 bath cabana in Caye Caulker!

Here is our personal perspective.

Pros:
Chip and Laura were prompt and responsive via email.
Property Manager Basilio was a nice and mellow guy. He picked us up from the water taxi along with his wife and child. He came around the cabana a couple times to check on us and delivered water once. He also informed us of the leerily drug cartel and shady cops in the area.
The cabana was presentable.
The A/C worked well.
The area was quiet - most of the time. There's a school across the street and there was some light street construction.
All appliances worked.
There were enough towels for two people.
The cookware and dinnerware was adequate.
The refrigerator kept everything really cold.
Nice breezes through the cabana windows.
The property was well kept.
The pool was refreshing and convenient.
The character of the interior was cozy and minimal.
The location of the property was fairly close to the activity. (15 min walk to The Split)
Wifi was easy to access - yet slow.

Cons:
Mirrors and TV had dirty finger prints all over them.
Kitchen could use a microwave.
Cabana could use an iron.
The futon sofa was uncomfortable and a coffee table would have been convenient.
More counter space in the bathroom is needed.
The pool deck vibrates sound. So if you're sleeping and there are other tenants walking on the pool deck, your sleep can easily be disturbed.
The outside deck lighting was very harsh. (Fluorescent lighting is not conducive for relaxation.)
Kitchen could have used baking pans since there was no microwave to heat up leftovers.
The power in the surrounding neighborhood went out 3 times. Power was back up in about 10-15 mins.

In regards to Caye Caulker, we were disappointed with the seafood selection and the food in general, being that it is an island. (Shrimps are shockingly tiny, fillets weren't memorable and most food had limited flavor.) Unfortunately March isn't Lobster season. :( The most we ate was Chinese food, Chicken, Rice and flower-based fried foods. The island culture is also not pleseantly service inclined, not many smiles or at all accommodating. A Starbucks small iced plain coffee was $4 dollars. "Go Slow" is taken to heart and most people ignore you unless trolling for money. Not really what we were expecting. Also, there aren't any "beaches" here - just docks and reefs - where you can swim and lay out (The Split). Travel in groups. People can be shady. Also, be aware that leaving the country will cost you an extra $40 US dollars per person at the airport. Yikes!

All-in-all it was a restful, quiet time with lots of sun!