We had a wonderful stay at Ben and Aria's lovely little house. It has a great location, just secluded enough to feel private and quiet, but an easy and scenic 10 minute walk from all the fun activities in Caye Caulker. It has easy beach access and is well-equipped with everything you could need for your stay, including fresh water.
The cabana is exactly as described in the listing (cute, comfy, and tropical), and Ben and Aria are great hosts. They give you a lot of privacy but are available for any questions you might have.
The dogs are real sweethearts, and Shadow in particular spent a lot of time with us on the porch as we lazed in the hammock.
I'd highly recommend staying here if you plan to visit Caye Caulker!