We stayed in cabana #8, which is away from the water and very private. The cabana was great, even with no air conditioning, the fans kept the room cool and we slept with a sheet. The bed was comfortable and everything was clean and well tended. We were greeted by the hosts and given suggestions of where to go and offers of taxi's if we needed one. The day we left, as we were checking out, there was a taxi waiting to take us to the water taxi. The cabanas are at the far end of the island and away from the split. It is a 10 minute or so walk to get to restaurants. I had no problem with this, but I think my companion would have liked to be closer to the action. Keep this in mind when making your decision.
The coffee beans and coffee pot in the room was greatly appreciated. I would love to have some at home.
All in all, staying at Colinda's was a great experience, one that I would recommend to my friends.