We stayed in the Penthouse for our 5 day visit to Caye Caulker. The view alone from the private balcony is reason enough to stay. The unit is well equipped with most of the amenities of home (it worth noting that the AC worked really well). The daily housekeeping was also greatly appreciated.
On a hot day, it is a little bit of a walk to the main part of the island. We rented a golf cart for $50 USD/day from J& Son's xtreme karts for the day that we explored the island. I recommend doing so toward the beginning of your trip to stock up on snacks and beer/rum. The rest of the time we were able to taxi for $2.50/person to anywhere on the island. Ask for Max; He was really reliable and we were able to schedule rides in advance with him. He was the closest thing to an Uber that you could ask for.
We went snorkeling for a full day with Raggamuffin tours. They were extremely friendly and took great care of us as it was our first time. I am so happy that we picked snorkeling as
Kiki was amazingly helpful with guidance on what to do and where to eat while on the island.
Our dining recommendations; Maggie's Sunset kitchen, Meldy's, The Happy Lobster, Caye Caulker Bakery (breakfast pastries) and The Lazy lizard.
We can't wait to return and will definitely try to book the penthouse again.