We had a great stay at the Spoonbill House. We've been to Caye Caulker before, so it was nice to experience a more residential living arrangement, and I felt like it gave us the opportunity to see more of the island than we would have otherwise. With the bikes, we were maybe 5-7 minutes from Front Street, and the trek on foot wasn't bad either.
When we weren't eating at Errolyns House of Fry Jacks, we made breakfast most mornings ourselves, and I loved walking out onto the deck to find the neighbourhood dogs hanging out waiting for us to start our day.
The owners Monique and Maurice are great people and very helpful, and you have to eat at their restaurant, Wish Willy's! It's a great place to relax, meet other travellers, and enjoy some of the best food on the island.