In all my travels, I'm hard pressed to think of someone who took better care for me and my wife than Juan, the caretaker. This also includes the ladies who cleaned our room everyday. They made this trip our most worry-free ever!
Caye Caulker is a very beautiful, laid-back place. The island is full of beautiful, joyful people. We were within constant earshot of kids laughing while playing outside.
I would highly recommend this specific cottage, #2. It is right on the beach at the end of the pier. It gas a great view and is quiet and peaceful. Even though it faces east, the bedroom has a good door to keep the morning sun from waking one. Also, we were glad our place had A/C.