Book with Alexis and Scott. We enjoyed Caye Caulker so much we wanted to extend a night or too and decided to book with them. They informed me shortly after that there may have been a mistake with scheduling but they were ready to make arrangements for us elsewhere. The issue was resolved and we were able to stay with Alexis and Scott after all but they went above and beyond to make sure we'd have a place to stay on such short notice. On top of that the room was the most comfortable one we stayed in our entire trip.