Kinloch's place is everything as described and more (That fishpond!). The room is quite large, clean, with tons of storage space. The rest of Kinloch's home is also extremely clean and quiet. Location can't be beat for Fitzroy, with easy access to Carlton and Collingwood as well. It's two blocks from the 96 tram and Brunswick Street both, about 20 min tram ride from Melbourne CBD, although Fitzroy itself is more than ripe for ample exploration, with fantastic eateries, great vintage shops, and amazing street art. (Note: Fitzroy is outside the free tram zone, so you'll need a myki card with balance or pass)

Kinloch himself is also an awesome host. When I first booked, he sent instructions on how to get to his place; when I arrived, he walked me through the Melbourne tram system. Although the first night was rather rushed as I was running late and he was off on his way to work, he was still very gracious and helpful. The next night, we had a chance to chat and spoke for hours. Kinloch is eloquent, thoughtful, and extremely intelligent.

p.s., the shower water pressure is as strong as Kinloch says it is, which is a total blessing in Melbourne winters.