Quaint place with lots of space and good amenities. Excellent location, adequate heating and hot water. Some aspects of the house were not maintained - one of the guests staying with me was unable to open sliding door to the bathroom and was worried she was trapped. After some effort we opened it, and did not close it again for the rest of the trip. There were also a few light bulbs missing from some lamps around the house.
Overall 4 stars, but it really is an excellent place for a group to stay right in the heart of Melbourne.