We enjoyed our stay at Kate and Jim's apartment.
It was clean and had all that you need for a stay in the city of Melbourne.
Kate left us some food items in the fridge and pantry which was very thoughtful of her.
We were over from Perth which has a 3 hour time difference so we tended to sleep in ( as we were on holiday) , unfortunately we could hear the trams and other traffic from the street below and the blind in the bedroom let in the morning light which was unfortunate.
If you are an early riser these issues would not be a problem at all.
We loved Kate's apartment it was very central to everything.