Fantastic location - short walk across beautiful Yarra River to the city for meals and shopping without needing to deal with tight spaces living within the city itself. Amazing views from the apartment. Very clean and comfortable. Great value.
If I had to pick on something it would be the long list of dos-and-donts. Honestly, not a big deal at all but could be slightly overwhelming for folks looking for a no-frills holiday. I guess it's understandable why the host found it necessary to do so - most likely due to past negative experiences.
I'd say, if you're a respectful and responsible guest, it shouldn't require you to change your behaviour at all.
Overall, very pleased and would definitely recommend to friends who would like to visit Melbourne.