My partner and I had a beautiful and restorative stay at Lisa's cosy cottage. The view, the fire, the wildlife - all amazing! (Didn't spot the koalas, but plenty of birds and a couple of bunnies!)
The kitchen had all the equipment we needed to cook what we liked, and the little milk bar/cafe in Wye River does great fish and chips (just watch out for their super friendly kookaburras who aren't afraid to help themselves to your chips!)
The place was exactly as described - it's not modern but it's clean and has retro charm, which I love. Great location too, with the little beach across the road and close to the Otways.
It was pretty cold and wet weather when we stayed but Lisa had plenty of firewood available, and the bed has electric blankets. Lisa was very helpful and communicative throughout the process, including letting us know about some road closures in the area as a result of the recent storms!