Only three small compromises:
(1) It's weird having an active Club House in your backyard.
(2) No Wi-Fi.
(3) The house is pretty old and a little daggy.
Offsetting that, the place is:
(a) Amazingly located.
(b) Spacious.
(c) Super clean.
(d) Very competitively priced.
(e) Well appointed and functional (bathroom, TV etc).
(f) Cosy.
(g) Comfortable.
(h) Has great towels/bed linen etc.
(I) Neat as a pin.
Especially for a family or small group (as opposed to a lux, couple's getaway), I can't imagine how you could really do better in Port Fairy. Fantastic place. Highly recommended.