The chapel is a really great place to stay. My wife any I like to nerd out about the idea of living in a converted church, but all too often we see renovations that fall short in terms of style, or don't do justice to the space. Not so with this place - it's been transformed into a clean, austere place that doesn't feel cold at all, nor do things look out of place or proportion.
Even though it's a very modern renovation (excellent heating & a very nice bathroom and kitchen), things like the tasteful light fixtures and furniture, and the original doors can make you really feel like you're in a nearly 80 year old space. That window at the front is amazing to wake up to (and yes, the bed is far enough to the back of the chapel that it feels perfectly private).
So the place itself is fantastic. The location is great too - 15 minutes from Apollo Bay, and a great base for a day trip to Warrnambool or the Otways.
It turned out that we didn't even see our hosts during our stay, but Sam made it clear that they were there if we needed anything. Highly recommended overall!