We had a great stay at the Forest Cottage! It had a nice view down to the ocean, and a chorus of birds in the mornings and evenings. We even saw a koala in a tree right next to the driveway!
It is located about 30min from Apollo Bay and about 45min to the Twelve Apostles, with not much besides the Otways in between, so it's fairly remote but yet centrally located for all sorts of coastal/rainforest adventures.
Would definitely stay again- thanks for everything!