My husband and I and another couple visiting from Europe stayed at Phoebe and Dylan's place and loved it. It is exactly as it appears in the photos-carefully decorated and simple. It's in an absolutely perfect location (short walk down a steep hill to the beach and gorgeously stocked general store and coffee shop), and the Shack itself is relaxing with plenty of light. Good for rainy grey days when you want to curl up with a book or the perfect place to return to after the beach. It's well stocked in terms of being able to cook. Phoebe was extremely responsive with any queries we had. Highly recommend and will be back.
Oh and spotting koalas sleeping from the balcony in the evening was an added bonus for the tourists!