We spent six nights at The Little Beach Shack in February. We really really loved it.. its a very comfortable and informal cabin in a great location very close to the sea and with a great view to the south. Great bed with a granite boulder slab view out one window, and the sea out the other, a great kitchen, dining table with view... day beds... comfy couch... It has a fire we did not light, and a TV we did not turn on. Wifi that we got to work. Its very spacious and we loved the light on all sides.. and the beach shack creative timber detailing.
We loved exploring Flinders Island from here. In February, the March flies had already arrived, but we had brought outback fly repellant which worked pretty well. And there was plenty of wind!
The LBS is a good 45 minutes from Whitemark, especially given the current roadworks delays north of Emita, that will add a bit more sealed road. And then being about 7km out the Leeka Rd, with a 1.5km driveway, we did find it a bit more remote than we expected.. and were glad we had hired a Subaru Forester... though could have done it carefully in a conventional vehicle.
We had wondered, before coming, whether we should have booked two places at either end of the island... but were very glad we did not. Most of the great beaches and rocky headlands we enjoyed were on the west side .. and it was just wonderful to come home to the LBS!
Highly recommended.