We had an average stay at Paul and Nat's place. Compared to other Airbnb's that I have stayed in, this one definitely sits at the bottom end. The cups and cutlery were dirty and we had to rewash, dishwasher broken, most of the board games were missing pieces, water tank ran out of water on our last night and 3 of us couldn't shower or flush the toilet and had to wait until early the next morning to go out and buy drinking water. Paul did refund me the cost of 1 night's stay for the inconveniences which was good of him, but it would've been good to know that the tank might run out of water so we could ration what was left over in the tank during our stay. This is definitely a no-frills accommodation which is used by the owners and his family a lot.
The location of the property is very close to a swimming beach (walking about 5 mins) but it's set in the back of the block so no beach views from the property. It is not close to any shops or other amenities so you will need a car. The drive to Coles Bay shops is about 10 minutes.