"Did not live up to it's full potential"
We stayed at Verina's place earlier this week. The pros include it's location (secluded but within a few minutes walk to the start of the wineglass bay circuit), beautiful architecture with lots of natural light; and a spacious kitchen with an outdoor barbecue.
However, the place did not live up to its expectations and is somewhat lacking in its upkeep. The front door lock was not working properly; the heater in the hallway was broken; the "amenities" in the fridge to get us started included only a tiny box of long life milk (this apartment is designed for 4 people); the dining table, oven and barbqueue had a lot of grease and stains; and the place (like the carpet) generally looked a bit tired and in need of a touch up.
Overall, we would recommend this place for its location and tranquility. However, a guest should not choose this place if they want a 5* experience.