We had a wonderful stay at the cottage in Binnalong Bay. The cottage is very nice. It has timber flooring and a great heater which kept us warm in the evenings.
Location is as good as it gets. You can see the water from the windows - pristine water. St. Helens is the closet town which is 15 mins away but I would prefer to stay at Binnalong Bay for the views and beach/lookout being a 2 min walk from the property.