This has to be one of the best locations in town. My family enjoyed a week here over Christmas and found the cottage to be just about perfect. The house is very private, a short walk to everything, and close enough to the beach to hear the waves (and the penguins!) at night. The cottage is as described - a lovely old dame who has been loved and updated just enough to be comfortable. Great response from Lara when we had an issue on Christmas day.
Make sure you enjoy a coffee on the deck each morning, it’s a lovely sunny spot where you can watch the swell roll in.