The Pros and Cons of Captains Rest - PROS: Beautiful shack with an absolutely stunning waterfront view of Lettes Bay. Loved the decorations. Sarah definitely has a great taste and an amazing flair of creativity in design, decorating, styling, marketing and attention to details while incorporating the old and the new. Her personal touches, the comfy couch, the functional kitchen, the big bathtub and the massive bed (but I found the bed to be too high for a short person like me :-D) Checkin was great. Helpful information and very detailed instructions made it very easy to find the shack. I didn’t meet Kayla, but she’s an amazing host, very friendly and always ready to answer my calls. Now the CONS: The shack was only available for 1 night which was not enough time to settle in because everything felt rushed. However, I was actually glad to stay only 1 night because the price was quite expensive. This is the only reason why I won’t be back soon. I was able to compare between Captains Rest and the 2nd shack I stayed in. At half a price, with same view, same location, same comfort, and some brekkie provisions provided, the 2nd shack was much better value. And I slept better there too for some reason. Also, I was expecting a peaceful stay at Captains Rest, but unfortunately it's not to be had with the close proximity to the shack nearby with a family with screaming kids. I also had the weirdest shower in a bathtub LOL but it’s my own fault of not reading the listing properly that there’s only a bathtub. The bathtub was cracked, but Kayla/Sarah wrote an apology card and gave me a complimentary wine. Thank you for that! The hot water ran out halfway, but since it’s already so late at night and I felt bad of calling Kayla (at 11PM) so I just made do with lukewarm water for my wash. A quick call to Kayla the next morning was easy fix to change to the new tank. Sorry, Captains Rest, I do like you, but I like the other shack better. Still 4 stars for you :-)