Deb and Brian's Blythe Cottage provided a blissful and relaxing experience. Their hospitality was well above average, the views were incredible (sunset photos are a must) and the quaint little cottage was unique in many ways. Definitely recommend ordering one of their hampers or bringing your own food supplies, as there is only one small convenience shop in the town. Also, don't forget to sample the various fresh produce around the town.
Side note: a Margaret river day trip is easily achievable, being only an hour and 10 minute drive.