Here's a short answer to whether or not you should rent Gordon's place: absolutely yes.
Gordon is a fantastic host. He made sure we had enough beds for 8 people and only charged us what he thought was fair. We asked to use the firepit and he graciously agreed and set it up for us. He even got us twigs for us to make smores. When we needed more pots and cutting boards, Gordon got us some more. Gordon never once hesitated to help.
Gordon's place is very clean and cosy. It is what I would consider peaceful location, somewhere I'd want to return to every now and then. The beds were clean and tidy, the living area was vast and cosy. The area resonates the amazing sounds of nature and smells of fresh air.
I'd rate Black Georges House 100/10 if I could. Never have I felt so welcomed in my entire life. You won't regret this place.