Overall, Alison's place was great for a couple of days in Fremantle. The location is extremely convenient, within walking distance to everything. The place was clean and comfortable. Communication with Alison was prompt and she provided additional information when requested.
The keys must be picked up from a separate location. This was not an issue for us as we had a car but it may be an inconvenience if arriving by train or taxi.
The only thing missing was the interactions of a true Air BNB experience. It appears Alison is a property manager of multiple listings (not the owner). From our experience, while bookings are always well organized in these instances, they are mostly business-like. They lack the personal touches of meeting with the local owner and getting their insight into the best places to eat and visit. While she provided some material in the place, it just wasn't the same. This may not be a factor for others, but it's one of the key factors we look for with AirBNB.