Wren Cottage was absolutely perfect for our group of two families. Beautifully appointed, loads of space and two living areas meant we spent more time than intended at 'home' since it was such an inviting place to be. We even managed to keep the nature lovers and screen addicts happy at the same time (albeit with a bit of forward planning as no WiFi).
Lots of thoughtful extras including a welcome basket, warm bread, a movie under the stars (perfect!) made this a special holiday.
Location is also good between Denmark and Albany creating plenty of options if you do want to get out and about. There is a beautiful beach close by (5 mins drive) at Shelter island.
Tanya is an excellent host; prompt responses to queries, a mine of information and a pleasure to deal with.
We would thoroughly recommend Wren Cottage.