In the last decade, scenario-based serious-games have become a main tool for learning new skills and capabilities. An important factor in the development of such systems is the overhead in time, cost and human resources to manually create the content for these scenarios. We focus on how to create content for scenarios in medical, military, commerce and gaming applications where maintaining the integrity and coherence of the content is integral for the system's success. To do so, we present an automatic method for generating content about everyday activities through combining computer science techniques with the crowd. We use the crowd in three basic ways: to capture a database of scenarios of everyday activities, to generate a database of likely replacements for specific events within that scenario, and to evaluate the resulting scenarios. We found that the generated scenarios were rated as reliable and consistent by the crowd when compared to the scenarios that were originally captured. We also compared the generated scenarios to those created by traditional planning techniques. We found that both methods were equally effective in generated reliable and consistent scenarios, yet the main advantages of our approach is that the content we generate is more varied and much easier to create. We have begun integrating this approach within a scenario-based training application for novice investigators within the law enforcement departments to improve their questioning skills.
One traditional approach for activity-details generation is planning-based systems @cite_23 @cite_9 @cite_15 @cite_16 . The planning-based approach uses a causality-driven search to link a series of primitive actions in order to achieve a goal or to perform a task. For the domain of descriptive, every day activities, hierarchical scripts can capture common ways to perform the activity. Therefore, we implemented the planning-based generator using a Hierarchical Task Network (HTN), which is one of the best-known approaches for modeling expressive planning knowledge for complex environments. We used the state-of-the-art SHOP2 planner @cite_3 , a well known HTN planner, which has been evaluated and integrated in many real world planning applications and domains including: evacuation planning, evaluation of enemy threats and manufacturing processes. In order to validate the significance of modified scenarios with the activity-details we created, we also implemented a planning-based activity-details generator. As we later report, this approach is more costly to implement and generates less varied scenarios than the crowdsourced approach we now describe.
@cite_9 @cite_3 @cite_23 @cite_15 @cite_16
2170516265 2147357263 1498806819 2396534511 2003394453
In this paper, we address the problem of generating preferred plans by combining the procedural control knowledge specified by Hierarchical Task Networks (HTNs) with rich qualitative user preferences. The outcome of our work is a language for specifying user preferences, tailored to HTN planning, together with a provably optimal preference-based planner, HTNPLAN, that is implemented as an extension of SHOP2. To compute preferred plans, we propose an approach based on forward-chaining heuristic search. Our heuristic uses an admissible evaluation function measuring the satisfaction of preferences over partial plans. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of our HTNPLAN heuristics. We prove our approach sound and optimal with respect to the plans it generates by appealing to a situation calculus semantics of our preference language and of HTN planning. While our implementation builds on SHOP2, the language and techniques proposed here are relevant to a broad range of HTN planners. In this paper we address the problem of generating preferred plans by combining the procedural control knowledge specified by Hierarchical Task Networks (HTNs) with rich user preferences. To this end, we extend the popular Planning Domain Definition Language, PDDL3, to support specification of simple and temporally extended preferences over HTN constructs. To compute preferred HTN plans, we propose a branch-and-bound algorithm, together with a set of heuristics that, leveraging HTN structure, measure progress towards satisfaction of preferences. Our preference-based planner, HTNPLAN-P, is implemented as an extension of the SHOP2 planner. We compared our planner with SGPlan5 and HPLAN-P- the top performers in the 2006 International Planning Competition preference tracks. HTNPLAN-P generated plans that in all but a few cases equalled or exceeded the quality of plans returned by HPLAN-P and SGPlan5. While our implementation builds on SHOP2, the language and techniques proposed here are relevant to a broad range of HTN planners. SHOP (Simple Hierarchical Ordered Planner) is a domain-independent HTN planning system with the following characteristics. • SHOP plans for tasks in the same order that they will later be executed. This avoids some goal-interaction issues that arise in other HTN planners, so that the planning algorithm is relatively simple. • Since SHOP knows the complete world-state at each step of the planning process, it can use highly expressive domain representations. For example, it can do planning problems that require complex numeric computations. • In our tests, SHOP was several orders of magnitude faster man Blackbox and several times faster than TLpian, even though SHOP is coded in Lisp and the other planners are coded in C. Most practical work on AI planning systems during the last fifteen years has been based on hierarchical task network (HTN) decomposition, but until now, there has been very little analytical work on the properties of HTN planners. This paper describes how the complexity of HTN planning varies with various conditions on the task networks.