Forum: music.stackexchange.com
Tags: <theory><notation>
Title: Why you need a rest here in this score?
Question: Beginner warning :-)    This is the piano sheet music for Elgar’s Variation, Nimrod.   Please do note: I am currently learning time and key signatures with my theory teacher, but in looking at the music here I can not understand why this rest is required.

Answers:
sents: text: It prevents the appearance of an overfull measure.
text: Without it, what we see on this staff is a quarter-note chord, a half-note chord, and a quarter-note chord.
text: 1/4 + 1/2 = 3/4, and we're in the time signature 3/4, so the measure should be done already.
text: Then where does that quarter-note chord on the third beat come from?
text: It comes from another voice, as Todd Wilcox says — a voice that's silent on the second beat.
text: By writing a quarter-rest for that voice on the second beat, and writing it on the staff where it's about to have some notes, we properly set up, in advance, when that chord takes place.
text: Yes, the quarter-note duration already exists on the upper staff, but that's a long long way away.
text: The rest establishes that information locally , on the lower staff, to improve clarity.
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/14840/hobbs
score: 36
sents: text: The score has three voices.
text: We can call them the "lower voice", "middle voice" and "upper voice".
text: The lower voice is completely notated on the bass clef.
text: The upper voice is completely notated on the treble clef.
text: The middle voice switches back and forth.
text: When the middle voice is in the treble clef, its notes have down stems, and vice versa when the middle voice is in the bass clef.
text: In the first measure, the middle voice plays the G and Bb quarter notes (crotchets) that are in the treble clef with down stems below middle C.
text: The second beat the middle voice plays the rest that you are asking about.
text: For the third beat the middle voice plays the C below middle C and the Eb just above it, notated on the bass clef with up stems.
text: A bigger question is where is the middle voice for the first two beats of measure two?
text: And I'm a bit wrong because measure three seems to have four voices in it.
text: Perhaps that's the titular enigma.
text: Edit:
text: On further consideration, I think there are four voices the whole time, and it's just notated in an unclear manner.
text: I think the lower middle voice plays the Eb below middle C that is the top note of the first chord in the bass clef, then the lower middle voice rests for the second beat, and then the third beat is the C and Eb in the bass clef.
text: The upper middle voice is the G and Bb below middle C in the treble clef for the first beat, then the second and third beats are the middle Cs that are the lowest notes of the treble clef chords.
text: Then they proceed from there.
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/6070/Todd Wilcox
score: 19
sents: text: Though clear, it would be marked wrong in a theory exam.
text: The correct notation would actually be this.
text: Each voice technically needs to show a complete bars worth of beats.
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/17003/Laurence Payne
score: 10
sents: text: As others have said, there are multiple voices.
text: Pictures are helpful:
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/10290/MattPutnam
score: 6
sents: text: Common practice nowadays is to show all notes that are played simultaneously on a staff using a single stem if they start and end at the same time, and if nothing else will happen on that staff during that time.
text: This is done even in choral music where a staff is shared e.g. between soprano and alto, or between tenor and bass.
text: Notation is only divided into up-stem and down-stem portions at beats where different notes start and end at different times, or when there are distinguishable voices (e.g. sopranos and altos) and some but not all should refrain from singing on that beat.
text: In beat 2 of measure 1, bass clef, not everything is supposed to sustain a half note, but something else is supposed to happen during that time (i.e. some quarter notes are supposed to play on beat 3).
text: Thus, at beat 2 the bass clef splits into two logical voices, one of which plays half notes, and the other of which rests for a quarter note and then plays quarter notes.
text: Note that on beat 3 of measure 2, the treble clef actually has three voices, with the middle one playing a quarter note while the outer ones play eighths.
text: The bottom voice is beamed with the eighth note on the second half of beat 3 in the bass clef because doing so avoids having to write an eighth rest for the first half of that beat, and because it makes clear that that note starts at the same time as the quarter note but lasts a different duration.
text: Had the bass clef not had an eighth note that could be beamed to that note in the treble clef, other ways of notating that measure would be: Notate the treble clef with homophonic eighth notes including a "d" which is tied to another "d",
text: avoiding the need for quarter notes.
text: This would avoid crossed stems, but such ties can make music hard to read. Place the "a" on the same stem as the "e" and "g" above.
text: This would avoid the need for ties, but at the expense of crossed stems.
text: Stack the notes as they are, but use a "flagged" eighth note on beat 3, and add an eighth rest for the second half of that beat.
text: Compared with the above, the use of the cross-staff eighth-note beam was a reasonable "least of evils" judgment.
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/5603/supercat
score: 1
sents: text: A chord on a staff is executed immediately after the preceding chord, held for its full duration.
text: If the quarter-rest were absent, the (c e-flat) chord at the end of the 1st bar would be played on the 4th beat, instead of the 3rd, as we would infer from its alignment with the chord in the upper staff.
text: The quarter-rest explicitly indicates a splitting of the lower staff into two simultaneous "voices", but only in a notational sense.
text: There is no functional splitting of voices.
text: At a large scale, I would say the voices act functionally as follows, though individual subvoices become discernable around the eighth-notes:
answer_details: author: music.stackexchange.com/users/31357/Gooseberry
score: 0

Summary of the answers:
Common practice nowadays is to show all notes that are played simultaneously on a staff using a single stem if they start and end at the same time, and if nothing else will happen on that staff during that time. This is done even in choral music where a staff is shared e.g. between soprano and alto, or between tenor and bass. Notation is only divided into up-stem and down-stem portions at beats where different notes start and end at different times, or when there are distinguishable voices (e.g. sopranos and altos) and some but not all should refrain from singing on that beat.  
Notation can be complex, such as if the bass clef had three voices and the middle one played a quarter note, and the outer ones played eighths.