Forum: bicycles.stackexchange.com
Tags: <racing><etiquette>
Title: Is it ethical to ride with races without being part of them?
Question: I find it tedious to spend half a day riding the dangerous streets of the city to purchase a mountain insurance, then spend money on race subscription and in then arriving early as hell on the start line to get my number.   Provided I do not take any water or food from the checkpoints and I do not cross the finish line, is there an ethical reason not to ride with the race?

Answers:
sents: text: Unethical, because you're imposing costs on the organisers anyway.
text: Apart from the obvious "if you get hurt they're going to help you", they almost always face costs per participant and often have a limit on numbers.
text: Violate those limits and the organisers will have problems.
text: You're also causing wear and tear on the track, equipment and marshals.
text: You can't pretend that away by saying "other people do it too"...
text: yes, and they paid for the privilege.
text: You're stealing it.
text: Not really ethical IMO.
text: This is another case where your exact marginal impact is low, but at some point one more increment like that will get the race cancelled or refused permission to do it again.
text: The other thing is that if you are involved in an incident and are deemed to be at fault, you will not be insured.
text: The race insurance won't cover you (obviously), but whatever insurance you have almost certainly has a an illegal activity exclusion.
text: They'd most likely leave it to you to show that what you were doing was lawful.
text: But since most races take place on temporarily closed areas, that would be hard.
text: They close the area specifically to people like you.
text: For exactly that reason.
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/7044/Móż
score: 39
sents: text: I’d say it’s totally
text: okay if the road is not closed for the event and still open for cars and other vehicles.
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/19529/Michael
score: 11
sents: text: If it's a race with competitors who are trying to win, then I would definitely say no.
text: Like time travel, just being there at the same place and time can cause unknown effects on future outcome.
text: If you want to use the track, contact the race organizers and see if they want people to help out checking the track the morning or night before the race for unplanned obstacles or other problems with the route.
text: See if they need referees (not sure if this is the correct term in cycling) to follow the riders to make sure everybody is following the track and not taking short cuts.
text: Do you have any first aid certifications?
text: Maybe they need on-the-trail first-aid care for riders who get injured.
text: If it's a route without laps, they may even allow people to ride a safe distance (half hour or more) behind the actual competitors.
text: If it's a charity or other type of non-competitive road ride, and the roads are open to cars, then you technically have every right to be there, and although some may frown at it, there isn't really much of a reason not to go, provided you are a courteous rider and don't use any of the facilities furnished to riders.
text: I think that any kind of closed course, even on the road, and even for a non-competitive rides is probably off limits.
text: And "closed course" doesn't mean that the entire thing is behind a barbed wire fence.
text: It would be impractical for them to block off every entrance to a course.
text: A closed course is any course where they have made some effort to try and stop unregistered riders, vehicles, and pedestrians from being on the route.
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/163/Kibbee
score: 9
sents: text: Yes, that's highly unethical.
text: This isn't any different than banditing a marathon.
text: Race organizers go through quite a bit of trouble and expense to provide a safe racing environment, especially if the race goes over public roads.
text: By jumping into a race you're exposing race organizers, participants and yourself for liability and in some situations stealing "resources."
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/23036/Velosurance
score: 3
sents: text: I contemplated the topic, visited a local XC/Enduro* race, asked the guys that organise it.
text: "Are riders without subscription and numbers hindering the race, they are not one or two but about 20%?
text: "
text: "No.
text: Why would they?"
text: My conclusion is that any cyclist without registration is no different than any other bystander .
text: Consequently, if the race organisers have taken strain to restrict outside personnel
text: **, then Mσᶎ's answer applies with full strength.
text: On the other hand, if travel is allowed, cycling is no more immoral than walking on the race course.
text: However: taking food or water constitutes theft, just as if a random hiker helped himself (optional) as unnumbered riders are not in a hurry for anywhere, they must help any racer in need.
text: as Criggie explains not subscribing for insurance and for the race does not help the race to be held the next year or the medical crews to be funded.
text: Those are supposed to be objective arguments, on the basis of which each individual can decide.
text: * - 100m positive attitude gain, 1700m negative attitude gain, mix of loose gravel road and singletrack of moist sharp stones; hikers, children, dogs, automobiles everywhere
text: ** - for example, I would consider a large warning sign a suitable restriction for hikers, or a police car a suitable restriction to automobiles
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/3927/Vorac
score: 2
sents: text: Would you ride that exact route on another day, when there was no race on?
text: I'd say stop being frugal and support cycling in your area.
answer_details: author: bicycles.stackexchange.com/users/19705/Criggie
score: 1

Summary of the answers:
Generally, it is considered unethical to ride with a race if you haven't registered as a competitor. Firstly, you have not contributed to the cost of the event. Second, you may cause an accident and not be covered by the race insurance. If you want to use the track and do not want to register for the race, contact the organizers and see if they need people to help out at the event. However, if it is an open road or charity event, you have the right to be there as does the public in general.
Especially on a closed course, an unregistered rider is taking the services of the organisers without paying the set price. This may also increase participant numbers beyond the permitted number and may affect insurance coverage, and may affect the outcome of the race for paying participants. Taking food, water and resources from the organisers constitutes theft and makes the event less profitable and likely to be repeated. You should support local cycling events. Organisers are not able to stop you from cycling on and event with open roads, but if you are unable to pay then it would be best to stay out of the way or offer to help at the event in exchange for participation.