The .gov means it’s official.
 The site is secure.  https://
 Search FDIC.gov
          Search


About
                Toggle submenu
    AboutThe Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) is an independent agency created by the Congress to maintain stability and public confidence in the nation’s financial system. Learn about the FDIC’s mission, leadership, history, career opportunities, and more.Learn More About the FDIC

      What We Do

        Leadership

        Careers

        Diversity & Inclusion

        Initiatives

      Strategic Plans

        Financial Reports

        History

        Governance

        Ombudsman

        Doing Business with the FDIC

      PRESS RELEASE / March 07, 2024
                                FDIC-Insured Institutions Reported Net Income of $38.4 Billion in Fourth Q...
          PODCASTS / March 05, 2024
                                Success in Community Banking
          PRESS RELEASE / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Releases Economic Scenarios for 2024 Stress Testing
          EVENT / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Unveils Immersive Timeline of Agency's History and Mission

        Resources
                Toggle submenu
    ResourcesThe FDIC provides a wealth of resources for consumers, bankers, analysts, and other stakeholders. Browse our collection of financial education materials, data tools, documentation of laws and regulations, information on important initiatives, and more.Additional FDIC Resources

      Consumer Resource Center

        Banker Resource Center

        Deposit Insurance

        Supervision & Examinations

        Laws & Regulations

        Resolutions

      Publications

        Forms

        Data Tools

        Community Banking Research Program

        Coronavirus Response

        International Seminars and Training

      PRESS RELEASE / March 07, 2024
                                FDIC-Insured Institutions Reported Net Income of $38.4 Billion in Fourth Q...
          PODCASTS / March 05, 2024
                                Success in Community Banking
          PRESS RELEASE / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Releases Economic Scenarios for 2024 Stress Testing
          EVENT / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Unveils Immersive Timeline of Agency's History and Mission

        Analysis
                Toggle submenu
    AnalysisThe FDIC is proud to be a pre-eminent source of U.S. banking industry research, including quarterly banking profiles, working papers, and state banking performance data. Browse our extensive research tools and reports.More FDIC Analysis

      Center for Financial Reserach

        Consumer Research

        FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households

      Quarterly Banking Profile

        FDIC Academic Challenge

        FDIC Banking Issues in Focus

        Annual Risk Review

      EVENT / March 07, 2024
                                Quarterly Banking Profile for Fourth Quarter 2023
          EVENT / November 29, 2023
                                Quarterly Banking Profile for Third Quarter 2023
          EVENT / September 07, 2023
                                Quarterly Banking Profile for Second Quarter 2023
          EVENT / May 31, 2023
                                Quarterly Banking Profile for First Quarter 2023

        News
                Toggle submenu
    NewsThe FDIC publishes regular updates on news and activities. Keep up with FDIC announcements, read speeches and testimony on the latest banking issues, learn about policy changes for banks, and get the details on upcoming conferences and events.Find More FDIC News

      Press Releases

        Financial Institution Letters

        Conferences & Events

        Board Matters

        Natural Disasters

        Media Campaigns

      Speeches, Statements & Testimonies

        Podcasts

        Videos

        Opinion Editorials

        Policy Fact Sheets

      PRESS RELEASE / March 07, 2024
                                FDIC-Insured Institutions Reported Net Income of $38.4 Billion in Fourth Q...
          PODCASTS / March 05, 2024
                                Success in Community Banking
          PRESS RELEASE / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Releases Economic Scenarios for 2024 Stress Testing
          EVENT / February 15, 2024
                                FDIC Unveils Immersive Timeline of Agency's History and Mission

          Search
                Toggle submenu
    Search FDIC.gov SearchAdvanced Search
 Breadcrumb
                    
            Home
            
                    
            News
            
                    
            Editorials


News Editorial
How the state can stabilise housing market


          April 29, 2008
*Share This:*Share on FacebookShare on XFollow the FDIC on LinkedInShare through emailPrint


      April 29, 2008By Shiela C. BairFinancial TimesOver the past year, federal and state governments, consumer groups, industry and others have worked to contain the growing tide of foreclosures. While some success has been achieved, foreclosures continue to mount and delinquency rates for subprime and even some prime mortgages have risen dramatically.The US housing market needed to adjust after an unsustainable expansion. However, the lax lending of recent years has distorted this natural cycle. The existence of too many unaffordable mortgages has created a cycle of declining home prices and limited refinancing options that has contributed to more defaults, foreclosures and the ballooning of housing stock. This in turn has led to further home price declines. Government efforts should focus on helping the market reach equilibrium without overshooting.This can be done only through widespread restructuring of unafford-able mortgages into affordable ones. However, it is questionable whether government programmes can, or should, help borrowers who view home ownership as a leveraged investment. Solutions should focus on those with a long-term commitment to remaining in their homes and paying their mortgages if they had an affordable payment.The question is how to restructure unaffordable mortgages on a sufficient scale to stabilise home values and contain the broader economic damage. Solutions must be practical and administratively quick and simple to implement. We must also minimise any burden on taxpayers by keeping the risk of mortgage defaults in private hands.Congress and the White House are moving forward with plans to expand eligibility for loans guaranteed by the Federal Housing Administration. These proposals are laudable and will help some borrowers, but they have generally acknowledged limitations.As a complement, Congress may want to consider a publicly funded borrower loan programme. The Treasury department could, if authorised by Congress, make loans to borrowers with unaffordable mortgages to pay down as much as 20 per cent of their principal. Participating mortgage lenders would be required to restructure the mortgage to ensure an affordable, long-term payment and subordinate their lien interest - the right to retain possession of the property - to the government's claim. To give borrowers time to stabilise their finances and rebuild some equity, repayment of the Treasury loan would be delayed for five years and then amortised over the remaining life of the mortgage. Mortgage investors would pay a subscription fee to cover the government's interest costs during the first five years. To prevent gaming of the system, eligibility could be confined to loans originated in recent years that were unaffordable at origination, based on a simple debt-to-income ratio.Borrower loan programmes have been suggested by eminent economists, such as Martin Feldstein. This proposal would require cost-sharing by mortgage investors as well as borrowers; it limits eligibility to mortgages that were al- ways unaffordable and provides a super- priority interest to assure repayment.Importantly, this proposal keeps the risk of re-default on mortgage investors. It allows the government to leverage its lower borrowing costs to reduce fore-closures significantly with no expansion of contingent liabilities and little net cost. Ownership of the loans, with the corresponding risk of declining collateral values and credit risks, remains with the current mortgage investors. As a result, it has built-in incentives for mortgage investors to qualify those borrowers who have a good chance of paying off a restructured loan over the long term.It also works within existing securitisation contracts and is administratively simple. In most cases, eligibility could be assessed with information readily available from existing records. Principal write-offs, which can require investor consent, are not required, limiting the prospect of potential conflicts of interest. Investors benefit by receiving immediate principal payments and from the reduced default risks.Most importantly, those homeowners who remain committed to their homes would be given the means to ride out the crisis. For homeowners deeply underwater, turning to the FHA should be another option. The housing crisis is a national problem. Painful as it is, we must be prepared to apply government efforts now. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation's past experience cautions us that prompt action is always cheaper than a delayed response.*The writer is chairman of the US Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
Last Updated: January 22, 2013 CONTACT THE FDICCONTACT US
STAY INFORMEDEnter your email address Get StartedFollow the FDIC on FacebookShare on XFollow the FDIC on InstagramFollow the FDIC on LinkedInFollow the FDIC on FlickrFollow the FDIC on YouTube
HOW CAN WE HELP YOU?
    Define “I am a . . . ” to learn more specific information
            I am a...Bank CustomerBankerConsumerSmall Business OwnerAnalyst/Researcher/StudentLegal ProfessionalBank RegulatorPress/MediaVendor/ContractorLegislative Staff MemberJobseekerCourt ClerkProsecutor/Probation OfficerInvestigatorSelect the information you wish to explore based on who you are
            I want to...Get Started


      Footer Secondary Menu
  

        
      Policies
                              Help
                              Foia
                              En Espanol
                              Accessibility
                              Open Government
                              Site Map
                              usa.gov
                              Contact Us
                              Privacy
                              Plain Writing
                              No Fear Act Data
                              Inspector General