Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission
 En Español
 About FMSHRCNewsCommissionersChairman and Commissioner TenureAdministrative Law JudgesGuidesFrequently Asked QuestionsFOIA GuideHow a Case Proceeds Before the CommissionGuide to Commission ProceedingsRequests to ReopenInstructions for Electronic FilingVideoconference HearingsSection 105(c)(3) ComplaintsDecisionsReview Commission DecisionsALJ DecisionsBlue BooksReview Commission Arguments & MeetingsOral ArgumentsMeetingsThe Mine Act & Procedural RulesThe Mine ActProcedural RulesChanges to Procedural RulesFOIASubmit a FOIA RequestFOIA GuideRulesFOIA ReferencesFOIA LibraryFOIA Public LiaisonFOIA ReportsProposed FOIA RulesReports & Budget SubmissionsStrategic PlansBudget and Annual Performance ReportsBuy American ReportsPerformance Accountability ReportsSustainability ReportReports to CongressContingency PlanReports to the PresidentCases on ReviewCases Currently on Review Before the CommissionCommission Decisions On AppealContact Us
 Breadcrumb
    Home
          Cases on Review
          Commission Decisions On Appeal
    Commission Decisions On Appeal
 Date
              02/26/2024

  PENDING
              No.
**Appellate Case Name and Docket No.**
**Commission Decision****1**
**KC Transport, Inc. v. MSHA**
**D.C. Cir. No. 22-1071**
**SCOTUS No. 23-876**
**KC Transport, Inc., 44 FMSHRC 211 (Apr. 2022) (whether the Judge erred in ruling that two trucks were subject to Mine Act jurisdiction).****2**
**Continental Cement Co. v. MSHA o/b/o Otten**
**8th Cir. No. 23-2213**
**Sec’y of Labor obo Otten v. Continental Cement Co., 45 FMSHRC __, No. CENT 2021-0013 (May 8, 2023) (whether the Commission erred in finding that Continental violated sections 103(f) and 105(c)(1) of the Mine Act when the operator refused to pay Otten the wage-rate she would have earned had she not served as a miners’ representative).****3**
**GMS Mine Repair v. MSHA**
**D.C. Cir. No. 22-1143**
**SCOTUS No. 23-551**
**GMS Mine Repair, 44 FMSHRC 399 (May 2022) (ALJ) (whether the ALJ erred in his consideration of the operator’s history of violations when assessing a penalty).****4**
**Crimson Oak Grove Res., LLC v. MSHA o/b/o Collins**
**11th Cir. No. 23-13665**
**Crimson Oak Grove Res., LLC, 45 FMSHRC __,  No. SE 2023-0235 (Oct. 11, 2023) (whether the ALJ erred in finding the Secretary demonstrated a non-frivolous case that the miner engaged in protected activity).****5**
**Grimes Rock Inc., v. MSHA o/b/o Saldivar**
**9th Cir. No. 24-4418**
**Grimes Rock, Inc., 45 FMSHRC __, WEST 2021-0178 (Nov. 28, 2023) (Whether in a temporary reinstatement case, the ALJ erred in ruling that economic reinstatement for the miner should not be tolled; whether the ALJ erred in terminating economic reinstatement on the date she issued the merits decision; whether the ALJ erred in granting motion to enforce settlement agreement.)**

  DECIDED
              **FMSHRC Decision(s) Appealed**
**Party Appealing**
**Circuit Court Docket Number**
**Result**
**Reported at**
**Decision Date****Consol Pennsylvania Coal Co.,**
**44 FMSHRC 211**
**(Apr. 2022)**
**Consol**
**3d. Cir. No. 22-2191**
**Affirmed**


**September 14, 2023****Jones Brothers, Inc., 43 FMSHRC 219 (Apr. 2021)**
**Jones Brothers**
**6th Cir. No. 21-3498**
**Affirmed**

**Unreported**

**May 5, 2023****Westfall Aggregate & Materials, Inc., 44 FMSHRC 369 (May 2022)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 22-1088**
**Vacated and Remanded**

**64 F.4th 315**

**April 7, 2023****Cactus Canyon Quarries, Inc., 44 FMSHRC 289 (Apr. 2022)**
**Cactus Canyon**
**5th Cir. No. 22-60322**
**Affirmed**

**64 F.4th 662**

**April 4, 2023****Northshore Mining Co., 43 FMSHRC 1 (Jan. 2021)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**8th Cir. No. 21-1334**

**8th Cir. No. 21-1383**
**Reversed and Remanded**

**46 F.4th 718**

**August 22, 2022****KenAmerican Resources, Inc., 42 FMSHRC 659 (Aug. 2020)**
**KenAmerican**
**6th Cir. No. 20-4102**
**Affirmed**

**33 F.4th 884**

**May 11, 2022****M-Class Mining, LLC, 42 FMSHRC 491 (Aug. 2020)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. No.**
**20-1369**
**Vacated and Remanded**

**1 F.4th 16**

**June 11, 2021****Thomas v. CalPortland Co.,**
**42 FMSHRC 43 (Jan. 2020)**
**Thomas**
**9th Cir. No.**
**20-70541**
**Remanded**

**993 F.3d 1204**

**April 14, 2021****Knight Hawk Coal, LLC, 42 FMSHRC 435 (July 2020)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. No.**
**20-1299**
**Affirmed**

**991 F.3d 1297**

**March 26, 2021****McNary v. Aloca World Alumina, Inc., 42 FMSHRC 9, (Jan. 2020)**
**McNary**
**D.C. No.**
**20-1049**
**Dismissed**

**989 F.3d 21**

**March 2, 2021****Sec’y obo Greathouse v. Monongalia County Coal Co., et al.,  40 FMSHRC 679 (June 2018) & 38 FMSHRC 941 (May 2016) (ALJ)**
**Monongalia County Coal**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1196**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2020 WL 282907**
**(Jan. 17)****Cactus Canyon Quarries, Inc., 40 FMSHRC 1529 (Dec. 2018 (ALJ)**
**Cactus Canyon**
**D.C. Cir. No. 19-1040**
**Affirmed**
**953 F.3d 790**
**Jan. 14, 2020****Rain for Rent, 40 FMSHRC 1112 (Aug.  2018) (ALJ)**
**Western Oilfields Supply Co. d/b/a Rain for Rent**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1296; S. Ct. No. 19-1352**
**Affirmed**
**946 F.3d 584**
**Jan. 7, 2020**
**Cert. denied**
**2020 WL 6037213**
**(Oct. 13)****Signal Peak Energy, LLC, 40 FMSHRC 1059 (Aug. 2018) & 39 FMSHRC 638 (Mar. 2017) (ALJ)**
**Signal Peak**
**9th Cir. Nos. 18-72837 & -72938**
**Voluntarily Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 31, 2019****Consol Pennsylvania Coal Co., 40 FMSHRC 998 (Aug. 2018)**
**Consol**
**3rd Cir. No. 18-3078**
**Affirmed**
**941 F.3d 95**
**Oct. 22, 2019****Sec’y obo Scoles v. Harrison County Coal Co., 40 FMSHRC 1393 (Sept. 2018) (ALJ)**
**Harrison County Coal**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1320**
**Affirmed in part, Vacated and Remanded in part**
**790 Fed. Appx. 210**
**Oct. 4,****2019****Small Mine Development**
**37 FMSHRC 1892 (Sept. 2015)**
**Small Mine**
**D.C. Cir. No. 15-1391**
**Voluntarily Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Sept. 12, 2019****Poland Sand & Gravel, LLC**
**40 FMSHRC 1558 (Dec. 2018) (ALJ)**
**Poland Sand**
**D.C. Cir. No. 19-1057**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2019 WL 3955750**
**(July 29)****Peabody Twentymile, LLC**
**39 FMSHRC 1323 (July 2017); 37 FMSHRC 2635 (Nov. 2015) (ALJ)**
**Peabody**
**10th Cir. No.**
**17-9540**
**Reversed**
**931 F.3d 992**
**July 18, 2019****The American Coal Co.**
**40 FMSHRC 1011 (Aug. 2018); 38 FMSHRC 1987 (Aug. 2016); 38 FMSHRC 2612 (Oct. 2016) (ALJ)**
**American Coal**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1270**
**Affirmed**
**933 F.3d 723**
**June 11, 2019****Sec’y obo McGary et al. v. Marshall County Coal Co. et al.**
**38 FMSHRC 2006 (Aug. 2016); 40 FMSHRC 261 (Mar. 2018); 38 FMSHRC****2694 (Oct. 2016) (ALJ)**
**Marshall County**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1098**
**Affirmed**
**923 F.3d 192**
**May 7, 2019****Rain for Rent,**
**40 FMSHRC 976 (July 2018) & WEST 2016-730-M (Aug. 30, 2018)**
**Western Oilfields Supply Co. d/b/a Rain for Rent**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1269**
**Remanded Pursuant to Parties’ Agreement**
**Unreported**
**Mar. 22, 2019****Mach Mining, LLC**
**40 FMSHRC 1 (Jan. 2018)**
**Mach**
**D. C. Cir. No. 18-1048**
**Affirmed**
**748 Fed. Appx. 357**
**Jan. 11, 2019****The American Coal Co.**
**40 FMSHRC 330 (Mar. 2018)**
**American**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1090**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2018 WL 4148605**
**(Aug. 6)****Jones Brothers, Inc. 39 FMSHRC 570 (Mar. 2017) (ALJ)**
**Jones Bros.**
**6th Cir. No. 17-3483**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**898 F.3d****669**
**July 31, 2018****KenAmerican Resources, Inc.**
**39 FMSHRC 1709 (Aug. 2017) (ALJ)**
**KenAmerican**
**D.C. Cir. No. 18-1084**
**Dismissed as premature**
**2018 WL 4148593**
**(July 30)****Sec’y of Labor obo Groves v. Con-Ag, Inc.**
**39 FMSHRC 1811 (Sept. 2017) (ALJ)**
**Con-Ag**
**6th Cir. No. 17-4200**
**Affirmed**
**897 F.3d 693**
**July 26, 2018****Bussen Quarries, Inc. 39 FMSHRC 970 (May 2017) & 37 FMSHRC 2786 (Dec. 2015) (ALJ)**
**Bussen**
**8th Cir. No. 17-2281**
**Reversed**
**895 F.3d 1039**
**July 16, 2018****Canyon Fuel Co.**
**39 FMSHRC 1578 (Aug. 2017)**
**Canyon**
**10th Cir. No. 17-9541**
**Reversed**
**894 F.3d 1279**
**July 10, 2018****Consolidation Coal Co.**
**39 FMSHRC 1737 (Sept. 2017)****& 37 FMSHRC 2396 (Oct. 2015) (ALJ)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 17-1219**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**895 F.3d 113**
**July 10, 2018****Coeur Alaska, Inc. v. FMSHRC and Sec’y of Labor**
**38 FMSHRC 2384 (Sept. 2016) (ALJ)**
**Couer**
**9th Cir. No. 16-73682**
**Affirmed**
**738 Fed. Appx. 916**
**June 21, 2018****Lowe, et al. v. Varis Gold USA, Inc., et al.**
**39 FMSHRC 781 & 801 (Mar. 2017) (ALJ)**
**Lowe, et al.**
**9th Cir. No. 17-72019**
**Dismissed as untimely**
**Nov. 15, 2017**
**Petition for Reconsideration denied June 21, 2018**
**Unreported****Hirt v. Gary Servaes Enterprises**
**38 FMSHRC 2319 (Aug. 2016) (ALJ) and 38 FMSHRC 2553 (Oct. 2016)**
**Servaes Enterprises**
**10th Cir. No. 16-9552**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 31, 2017****Sec’y obo Hamilton v. American Mining & Tunnelling, LLC**
**38 FMSHRC 2346 (Aug. 2016) (ALJ)**
**Hamilton**
**9th Cir. No. 16-73571**
**Dismissed for Failure**
**to Prosecute**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 20, 2017****John Richards Constr. Co.**
**39 FMSHRC 959 (May 2017)**
**John Richards**
**9th Cir. No. 17-71948**
**Dismissed as untimely**
**Unreported**
**Sept. 21, 2017****Wilson v. Browning**
**38 FMSHRC 1161 (May 2016) (ALJ)**
**Wilson**
**D.C. Cir. No. 16-1250**
**Affirmed**
**863 F.3d 876**
**July 21, 2017****Hopkins County Coal, LLC**
**38 FMSHRC 1317 (June 2016)**
**Hopkins County**
**6th Cir. No. 16-3848**
**Affirmed**
**875 F.3d 279**
**July 18, 2017****Original Sixteen to One Mine, Inc.**
**38 FMSHRC 1019 (May 2016) (ALJ)**
**Original Sixteen**
**9th Cir. No. 16-72349**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**June 6, 2017****The American Coal Co.**
**38 FMSHRC 1972 (Aug. 2016)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 16-1333**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Mar. 28, 2017****Knife River Construction**
**38 FMSHRC 1289 (June 2016)**
**Knife River**
**D.C. Cir. No.  16-1233**
**Dismissed Pursuant to Settlement**
**2017 WL 2347681**
**(Mar. 28)****Sec’y obo Bungard v GMS Mine Maint. & Repair**
**38 FMSHRC 2664 (Oct. 2016) (ALJ)**
**GMS**
**4th Cir. No. 16-2368**
**Dismissed Pursuant to Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Mar. 8, 2017****Maxxim Rebuild Co.**
**38 FMSHRC 605 (Apr. 2016)**
**Maxxim**
**6th Cir. No. 16-3530**
**Reversed**
**848 F.3d 737**
**Feb. 13, 2017****Consol Pennsylvania Coal Co.**
**38 FMSHRC 470 (Mar. 2016) (ALJ)**
**Consol**
**3rd Cir. No. 16-2643**
**Affirmed**
**666 Fed. Appx. 165**
**Dec. 20, 2016****Consol Buchanan Mining Co.**
**37 FMSHRC 90 (Jan. 2015) (ALJ)**
**Consol Buchanan**
**4th Cir. No. 15-1321**
**Affirmed**
**841 F.3d 642**
**Nov. 10, 2016****Noranda Alumina, L.L.C.**
**37 FMSHRC 2731 (Dec. 2015)**
**Noranda**
**5th Cir. No. 16-60049**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**841 F.3d 661**
**Nov. 8, 2016****Sec’y of Labor on behalf of Pappas v. CalPortland Co.**
**38 FMSHRC 137 (Feb. 2016)**
**CalPortland**
**D.C. Cir. No. 16-1094**
**Reversed**
**839 F.3d 1153**
**Oct. 20, 2016****Jim Walter Resources, Inc.**
**37 FMSHRC 1968 (Sept. 2015)**
**Warrior Met Coal Mining, LLC**
**11th Cir. No. 15-14885**
**Affirmed**
**663 Fed. Appx. 809**
**Oct. 6, 2016****Petro Chemical Insulation, Inc.**
**37 FMSHRC 2826 (Dec. 2015) (ALJ)**
**Petro Chemical**
**D.C. Cir. No. 16-1090**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Sept. 27, 2016****Warrior Coal, LLC**
**38 FMSHRC 913 (May 2016)**
**Warrior**
**6th Cir. No. 16-3646**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 31, 2016****Tilden Mining Co.**
**36 FMSHRC 1965 (Aug. 2014)**
**Tilden**
**D.C Cir. No. 14-1170**
**Affirmed**
**832 F.3d 817**
**Aug. 12, 2016****Northern Illinois Service Co.**
**37 FMSHRC 1225 (June 2015) (ALJ)**
**Northern Illinois**
**7th  Cir. No. 15-2640**
**Affirmed**
**820 F.3d 868**
**Apr. 27, 2016****Cactus Canyon Quarries, Inc.**
**36 FMSHRC 3186 (Dec. 2014) (ALJ)**
**Cactus Canyon**
**D.C. Cir. No.  14-1260**
**Affirmed**
**820 F.3d 12**
**Apr. 19, 2016****Knox Creek Coal Co., 36 FMSHRC 1128 (May 2014)**
**Knox Creek**
**4th Cir. No. 14-2313**
**Affirmed**
**811 F.3d 148**
**Jan. 21, 2016****Mach Mining, LLC, 36 FMSHRC 2533 (Sept. 2014) (ALJ)**
**Mach Mining**
**D.C. Cir. No. 14-1266**
**Affirmed**
**809 F.3d 1259**
**Jan. 12, 2016****DQ Fire & Explosion Consultants, Inc., 36 FMSHRC  3090 (Dec. 2014) and 34 FMSHRC 2318 (Aug. 2012 (ALJ)**
**DQ Fire**
**D.C. Cir. No. 15-1008**
**Affirmed**
**632 Fed. Appx. 622**
**Dec. 1, 2015****Connolly-Pacific Co., 36 FMSHRC 1549 (June 2014)**
**Connolly-Pacific**
**D.C. Cir. No. 14-1133**
**Dismissed Pursuant to Settlement**
**2015 WL 9309653**
**(Nov. 30)****Brody Mining, LLC, 36 FMSHRC 2027 (Aug. 2014)**
**Brody**
**D.C. Cir. No. 14-1171**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2015 WL 7720348**
**(Nov. 2)****Rex Coal Co., 36 FMSHRC 3195 (Dec. 2014) (ALJ)**
**Rex Coal**
**6th Cir. No. 14-4123**
**Affirmed**
**630 Fed. Appx. 359**
**Oct. 29, 2015****UMWA obo Franks and Hoy v. Emerald Coal Resources, LP, 36 FMSHRC 2088 (Aug. 2014) & 36 FMSHRC 3315 (Dec. 2014) (ALJ)**
**Emerald Coal**
**3rd Cir. No. 14-4029**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**620 Fed. Appx. 127**
**Aug. 6, 2015****American Coal Co., 35 FMSHRC 380 (Feb. 2013) and 36 FMSHRC 2609 (Sept. 2014) (ALJ)**
**American Coal**
**D.C. Cir. No. 14-1206**
**Affirmed**
**796 F.3d 18**
**July 31, 2015****Prairie State Generating Co., 35 FMSHRC 1985 (July 2013)**
**Prairie State**
**D.C. Cir. No. 13-1315**
**Affirmed**
**792 F.3d 82**
**June 26, 2015****Sec’y obo McKinsey v. Pretty Good Sand, Inc., 36 FMSHRC 2843 (Nov. 2014 ) (ALJ)**
**Pretty Good Sand**
**4th Cir. No. 15-1103**
**Dismissed for Failure to Prosecute**
**Unreported**
**Mar. 13, 2015****Power Fuels, LLC, 36 FMSHRC 695 (Mar. 2014) (ALJ)**
**Power Fuels**
**4th Cir. No. 14-1450**
**Affirmed**
**777 F.3d 214**
**Jan. 27, 2015****Oak Grove Resources, Inc., 35 FMSHRC 3039 (Sept. 2013) (ALJ)**
**Sumpter, et al., emp. by Oak Grove**
**11th Cir. No. 13-15360**
**Affirmed**
**763 F.3d 1292**
**Aug. 15, 2014****Black Beauty Coal. Co., 34 FMSHRC 1733 (Aug. 2012)**
**Peabody Midwest Mining, LLC, fdba Black Beauty**
**7th Cir. No. 13-1659**
**Affirmed**
**762 F.3d 611**
**Aug. 12, 2014****Shamokin Filler Co., 34 FMSHRC 1897 (Aug. 2012)**
**Shamokin Filler**
**3rd Cir. No. 12-4457**
**Affirmed**
**772 F.3d 330**
**July 11, 2014**
**Cert. Denied**
**135 S. Ct. 1549**
**Mar. 23, 2015****Sec’y obo Piper v. KenAmerican Resources, Inc., 35 FMSHRC 1969 (July 2013)**
**KenAmerican**
**6th Cir. No. 13-3804**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**June 17, 2014****Dickenson-Russell Coal Co., 35 FMSHRC 123 (Jan. 2013) (ALJ)**
**Dickenson-Russell**
**4th Cir. No. 13-1374**
**Affirmed**
**747 F.3d 251**
**Mar. 27, 2014****Hopkins County Coal,  35 FMSHRC 134 (Jan. 2013) (ALJ)**
**Hopkins County Coal**
**6th Cir. No. 13-3322**
**Affirmed**
**557 Fed. Appx. 515**
**Mar. 3, 2014****Veris Gold, USA, 35 FMSHRC 2977 (Sept. 2013) (ALJ)**
**Veris Gold**
**D.C. Cir. No. 13-1282**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2014 WL 590866**
**(Feb. 11)****Raw Coal Mining Co., No. WEVA 2008-858, etc., Unpublished Order (July 25, 2013)**
**Raw Coal**
**4th Cir. No. 13-2060**
**Dismissed for lack of jurisdiction**
**553 Fed. Appx. 340**
**Feb. 4, 2014****Sec’y obo Ratliff v. Cobra Natural Resources, 35 FMSHRC 394 (Feb. 2013)**
**Cobra**
**4th Cir. No. 13-1406**
**Dismissed for lack of jurisdiction**
**742 F.3d 82**
**Jan. 27, 2014****Mach Mining LLC, 34 FMSHRC 1784 (Aug. 2012)**
**Mach Mining**
**7th Cir. No. 12–3598**
**Affirmed**
**728 F.3d 643**
**Aug. 26, 2013**
**Cert. Denied**
**572 U.S. 1060**
**Apr. 21, 2014****Metz v. Carmeuse Lime, 34 FMSHRC 1820 (Aug. 2012)**
**William Metz**
**3rd Cir. No. 12-3507**
**Affirmed**
**532 Fed. Appx. 309**
**July 29, 2013****Mach Mining, LLC, 34 FMSHRC 2449 (Sept. 2012) (ALJ)**
**Mach Mining**
**D.C. Cir. No. 12-1466**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**2013 WL 3357821**
**(June 11)****Cumberland Coal Resources, LP, 33 FMSHRC 2357 (Oct. 2011)**
**Cumberland**
**D.C. Cir. No. 11-1464**
**Affirmed**
**717 F.3d 1020**
**June 7, 2013****Big Ridge, Inc., 34 FMSHRC 1003 (May 2012)**
**Big Ridge, et al.**
**7th Cir. Nos. 12-2316, - 2460**
**Affirmed**
**715 F.3d 631**
**Apr. 26, 2013****Sec’y obo Howard v. Cumberland River Coa l Co., 34 FMSHRC 1396 (June 2012) (ALJ)**
**Cumberland River**
**6th Cir. No. 12-3918**
**Affirmed**
**712 F.3d 311**
**Apr. 4, 2013****Oak Grove Resources, LLC, 34 FMSHRC 594 (Mar. 2013 (ALJ)**
**Oak Grove**
**D.C. Cir. No. 12-1223**
**Affirmed**
**520 Fed. Appx. 1**
**Mar. 29, 2013****Lone Mountain Processing, Inc., 33 FMSHRC 2373 (Oct. 2011)**
**Lone Mountain**
**D.C. Cir. No. 11-1431**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**709 F.3d 1161**
**Mar. 19, 2013****Excel Mining, LLC, 34 FMSHRC 99 (Jan. 2012) (ALJ)**
**Excel**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 12-1138, -1308**
**Affirmed**
**497 Fed. Appx. 78**
**Mar. 15, 2013****Northshore Mining Co., 34 FMSHRC 663 (Mar. 2012) (ALJ)**
**Northshore**
**8th Cir. No. 12-2249**
**Reversed**
**709 F.3d 706**
**Mar. 8, 2013****Black Beauty Coal Co., 33 FMSHRC 1482 (June 2011) (ALJ)**
**Black Beauty**
**D.C. Cir. No. 11-1306**
**Affirmed**
**703 F.3d 553**
**Dec. 28, 2012****Sec’y obo Clapp v. Cordero Mining, LLC, 33 FMSHRC 3029 (Dec. 2011) (ALJ)**
**Cordero**
**10th Cir. No. 12-9502**
**Affirmed**
**699 F.3d 1232**
**Nov. 15, 2012****Sec'y obo Dunne v. Vulcan Construction Materials, LP, 33 FMSHRC 1587 (July 2011)**
**Vulcan**
**7th Cir. No. 11-2860**
**Reversed**
**700 F.3d 297**
**Oct. 25, 2012****USA Cleaning Service & Building Maintenance, 33 FMSHRC 2264 (Sept. 2011) (ALJ)**
**Jeroski d/b/a USA Cleaning**
**7th Cir. No. 11-3687**
**Affirmed**
**697 F.3d 651**
**Oct. 11, 2012****Sec’y obo Gray v. North Fork Coal Corp., 33 FMSHRC 27 (Jan. 2011)**
**North Fork**
**6th Cir. Nos. 11-3398, 3684**
**Reversed**
**691 F.3d 735**
**Aug. 14, 2012****Pattison Sand Co., 33 FMSHRC 3096 (Dec. 2011) (ALJ)**
**Pattison**
**8th Cir. Nos. 12-1194, -1196**
**Affirmed**
**688 F.3d 507**
**July 31, 2012****Mainline Rock and Ballast, Inc., 33 FMSHRC 307 (Jan. 2011) (ALJ)**
**Mainline**
**10th Cir. No. 11-9525**
**Affirmed**
**693 F.3d 1181**
**May 24, 2012****Mountain Edge Mining, Inc., 33 FMSHRC 1290 (May 2011) (ALJ)**
**Mountain Edge**
**4th Cir. No. 11-1777**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**May 23, 2012****Ames Construction, Inc., 33 FMSHRC 1607 (July 2011)**
**Ames**
**D.C. Cir. No. 11-1303**
**Affirmed**
**676 F.3d 1109**
**Apr. 17, 2012****Wolf Run Mining Co.32 FMSHRC 1228 (Oct. 2010)**
**Wolf Run**
**D.C. Cir. No. 10-1392**
**Affirmed**
**659 F.3d 1197**
**Nov. 4, 2011****Performance Coal Co., 32 FMSHRC 811 (Aug. 2010)**
**Performance**
**D.C. Cir. No. 10-1280**
**Vacated**
**642 F.3d 234**
**June 10, 2011****Baird v. PCS Phosphate Co., 33 FMSHRC 5 (Jan. 2011)**
**PCS Phosphate**
**4th Cir. No. 11-1102**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Apr. 11, 2011****Aracoma Coal Co., 32 FMSHRC 1249 (Oct. 2010)**
**Aracoma**
**4th Cir. No. 10-2300**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 7, 2011****Jaxun v. ASARCO, LLC, 31 FMSHRC 631 (May 2009) (ALJ)**
**Vernun Jaxun**
**9th Cir. No. 09-72459**
**Affirmed**
**408 Fed. Appx. 70**
**Jan. 7, 2011****Orchard Coal Co., 32 FMSHRC 371 (Apr. 2010) (ALJ), PDR denied, 32 FMSHRC 454 (May 2010)**
**Orchard Coal Co.**
**3rd Cir. No. 10-2718**
**Dismissed for Failure to Pursue**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 27, 2010****Walter Kuhl, 31 FMSHRC 700 (June 2009) (ALJ)**
**Walter Kuhl**
**3rd Cir. No. 09-3779**
**Dismissed as Untimely**
**Unreported**
**Apr. 21, 2010****Sec'y obo Pendley v. Highland Mining Co., 31 FMSHRC 61 (Jan. 2009)**
**Lawrence Pendley**
**6th Cir. No. 09-3213**
**Affirmed in part/remanded in part**
**601 F.3d 417**
**Apr. 2, 2010****National Cement Co. of California, 30 FMSHRC 668 (Aug. 2008)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 08-1312**
**Reversed**
**573 F.3d 788**
**July 21, 2009****Speed Mining, Inc., 29 FMSHRC 701 (Aug. 2007) (ALJ)**
**Speed Mining**
**4th Cir. No. 09-2090**
**Affirmed**
**528 F.3d 310**
**June 11, 2008****Plateau Mining Corp., 28 FMSHRC 501 (Aug. 2006)**
**Plateau Mining**
**10th Cir. No. 06-9582**
**Reversed**
**519 F.3d 1176**
**Mar. 17, 2008****Cumberland Coal Resources, LP, 28 FMSHRC 545 (Aug. 2006)**
**Cumberland Coal**
**3rd Cir. No. 06-4192**
**Affirmed**
**515 F.3d 247**
**Feb. 15, 2008****National Cement Co. of California, 27 FMSHRC 721 (Nov. 2005)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 06-1094**
**Vacated and remanded**
**494 F.3d 1066**
**July 20, 2007****Crimson Stone, 27 FMSHRC 980 (Dec. 2005) (ALJ)**
**Crimson Stone**
**11th Cir. No. 06-11442**
**Affirmed**
**198 Fed. Appx. 846**
**Sept. 8, 2006****Twentymile Coal Co., 27 FMSHRC 260 (Mar. 2005)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 05-1124**
**Reversed**
**456 F.3d 151**
**July 7, 2006****Original Sixteen-to-One Mine, 29 FMSHRC 21 (Jan. 2004) (ALJ)**
**Original Sixteen-to-One**
**9th Cir. No. 04-71301**
**Reversed**
**175 Fed. Appx. 825**
**Mar. 30, 2006****RAG Cumberland Resources, 26 FMSHRC 639 (Aug. 2004)**
**Cumberland Coal**
**D.C. Cir. No. 04-1427**
**Affirmed**
**171 Fed. Appx. 852**
**Nov. 10, 2005****Cannelton Industries, Inc., 26 FMSHRC 146 (Mar. 2004)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 04-1126**
**Reversed**
**415 F.3d 82**
**July 22, 2005****Twentymile Coal Co., 26 FMSHRC 666 (Aug. 2004)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 04-1293**
**Reversed**
**411 F.3d 256**
**June 10, 2005****D.A.S. Sand & Gravel, Inc., 25 FMSHRC 364 (July 2003) (ALJ)**
**D.A.S. Sand & Gravel**
**2nd Cir. No. 03-40668**
**Affirmed**
**386 F.3d 460**
**Jan. 27, 2005**
**Cert. Denied**
**544 U.S. 1048**
**May 23, 2005****RAG Shoshone Coal Corp., 26 FMSHRC 75 (Feb. 2004)**
**United Mine Workers of America**
**D.C. Cir. No. 04-1075**
**Dismissed for Lack of Standing**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 26, 2004****Olson v. Jacobs Ranch Coal Co., 25 FMSHRC 9 (Jan. 2003) (ALJ)**
**Hazel Olson**
**10th Cir. No. 03-9528**
**Affirmed**
**381 F.3d 1007**
**Aug. 24, 2004****Ohio Valley Coal Co., 24 FMSHRC 1072 (Dec. 2002) (ALJ)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 03-1070**
**Reversed and Remanded**
**359 F.3d 531**
**Feb. 24, 2004**
**Clarified 2004 WL 547606 (Mar. 17)****Kinder Morgan Operating, L.P., 23 FMSHRC 1288 (Dec. 2001)**
**Kinder Morgan**
**6th Cir. No. 02-3052**
**Affirmed**
**78 Fed. Appx. 462**
**Oct. 10, 2003****Sec’y obo Jackson v. Mountain Top Trucking, Inc., 23 FMSHRC 1230 (Nov. 2001)**
**Mountain Top**
**6th Cir. No. 01-4356**
**Affirmed**
**77 Fed. Appx. 321**
**Oct. 1, 2003****Garcia v. Colorado Lava, Inc., 25 FMSHRC 144 (Mar. 2003) (ALJ)**
**Andrew Garcia**
**10th Cir. No. 03-9562**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 7, 2003****Excel Mining, LLC,23 FMSHRC 600 (June 2001)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 01-1335**
**Reversed**
**334 F.3d 1**
**July 8, 2003****Sec’y obo Owens v. Drummond Co., 24 FMSHRC 768 (July 2002) (ALJ)**
**Drummond**
**11th Cir. No. 02-14394**
**Affirmed**
**67 Fed. Appx. 588 (Table)**
**May 9, 2003****Christie v. Mountain Spring Coal Co., 22 FMSHRC 1322 (Nov. 2000) (ALJ)**
**Brian Christie**
**3rd Cir. No. 01-1124**
**Affirmed**
**64 Fed. Appx. 850**
**Mar. 21, 2003**
**Cert. Denied**
**540 U.S. 878**
**Oct. 6, 2003****Darwin Stratton & Son, Inc., 24 FMSHRC 817 (Aug.  2002) (ALJ)**
**Stratton & Son**
**10th Cir. Nos. 02-4222,**
**-4239**
**Mandamus Denied**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 12, 2002****Cannelton Industries, Inc., 24 FMSHRC 840 (Aug. 2002) (ALJ)**
**Cannelton**
**D.C. Cir. No. 02-1330**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**2002 WL 31696939**
**(Dec. 3)****Sec’y obo Noakes v. Gabel Stone Co., 23 FMSHRC 1222 (Nov. 2001)**
**Gabel Stone**
**8th Cir. No. 01-4016**
**Affirmed**
**307 F.3d 691**
**Oct. 7, 2002****Northern Illinois Steel Supply Co., 23 FMSHRC 162 (Feb. 2001)**
**Northern Illinois**
**7th Cir. No. 06-1752**
**Reversed**
**294 F.3d 844**
**June 20, 2002****Alcoa Alumina & Chemicals, LLC, 23 FMSHRC 911 (Sept. 2001)**
**Alcoa**
**5th Cir. No. 01-60783**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 26, 2001****Dynatec Mining Corp., 23 FMSHRC 4 (Jan. 2001)**
**Dynatec**
**D.C. Cir. No. 01-1071**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 11, 2001****RAG Cumberland Resources Corp., 22 FMSHRC 1006 (Sept. 2000)**
**RAG Cumberland**
**D.C. Cir. No. 00-1438**
**Affirmed**
**272 F.3d 590**
**Dec. 7, 2001****Consolidation Coal Co., 22 FMSHRC 340 (Mar. 2000)**
**Consol**
**4th Cir. No. 01-1228**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 19, 2001****J. Davidson & Sons Construction Co., 23 FMSHRC 359 (Mar. 2001) (ALJ)**
**J. Davidson & Sons**
**9th Cir. No. 01-70855**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**June 13, 2001****Bennett v. Newmont Gold Co., 21 FMSHRC 252 (Feb. 1999) (ALJ)**
**Gregory Bennett**
**9th Cir. No. 99-70531**
**Affirmed**
**12 Fed. Appx. 492**
**May 3, 2001****Eagle Energy, Inc., 21 FMSHRC 1235 (Nov. 1999) (ALJ)**
**Eagle Energy**
**4th Cir. No. 00-1073**
**Affirmed**
**240 F.3d 319**
**Feb. 15, 2001****Ankrom v. Wolcottville Sand & Gravel Corp., 22 FMSHRC 137 (Feb. 2000)**
**Ankrom**
**6th Cir. No. 00-3374**
**Affirmed**
**238 F.3d 419 (Table), 2000 WL 1828477**
**(Dec. 4)****Martin Marietta Aggregates, 22 FMSHRC 633 (May 2000)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 00-1284**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Nov. 20, 2000****Sec’y obo Bowling & Ball v. Mountain Top Trucking Co., 21 FMSHRC 883 (Mar. 1999)**
**Mountain Top**
**6th Cir. No. 99-4278**
**Affirmed**
**230 F.3d 1358 (Table), 2000 WL 1478374**
**(Sept. 29)****Capitol Cement Corp., 21 FMSHRC 883 (Aug. 1999)**
**Capitol Cement**
**4th Cir. No. 99-2264**
**Affirmed**
**229 F.3d 1141 (Table), 2000 WL 1205389**
**(Aug. 24)****Akzo Nobel Salt, Inc., 21 FMSHRC 846 (Aug. 1999)**
**Akzo Nobel**
**D.C. Cir. No. 99-1370**
**Vacated and remanded**
**212 F.3d 1301**
**May 26, 2000****Sec’y & ICWU v. ASARCO, Inc., 20 FMSHRC 1001 (Sept. 1998)**
**ASARCO**
**6th Cir. No. 98-4234**
**Affirmed**
**206 F.3d 720**
**Mar. 17, 2000****Contractors Sand & Gravel, Inc., 20 FMSHRC 960 (Sept. 1998)**
**Contractors Sand**
**D.C. Cir. No. 98-1480**
**Reversed**
**199 F.3d 1335**
**Jan. 7, 2000****BHP Copper, Inc., 21 FMSHRC 758 (July 1999)**
**BHP Copper**
**9th Cir. No. 99-71113**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 7, 1999****L& T Fabrication and Construction, Inc., 21 FMSHRC 607 (June 1999) (ALJ)**
**L&T Fabrication**
**10th Cir. No. 99-9523**
**Dismissed for Lack of Jurisdiction**
**197 F.3d 1289**
**Nov. 29, 1999****Sec’y obo Hyles v. All American Asphalt, 21 FMSHRC 34 (Jan. 1999)**
**All American**
**9th Cir. Nos. 99-70169,**
**-70496**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement of Penalty**
**Unreported**
**Nov. 17, 1999****Cyprus Emerald Resources Corp., 20 FMSHRC 790 (Aug. 1998)**
**Cyprus Emerald**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 98-1442,**
**-1548**
**Reversed**
**195 F.3d 42**
**Nov. 5, 1999****UMWA obo Burgess v. Meredith, et al., 20 FMSHRC 691 (July 1998)**
**Meredith, et al.**
**D.C. Cir. No. 98-1359**
**Reversed**
**177 F.3d 1042**
**June 4, 1999****Consolidation Coal Co., 20 FMSHRC 227 (Mar. 1998)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**4th Cir. No. 98-1613**
**Affirmed**
**1999 WL 335777 (Table) (May 27)****Rock of Ages Corp., 20 FMSHRC 106 (Feb. 1998)**
**Rock of Ages**
**2nd Cir. No. 98-4095**
**Affirmed**
**170 F.3d 148**
**Mar. 3, 1999****Stillwater Mining Co., 19 FMSHRC 1803 (Nov. 1997) (ALJ)**
**Stillwater**
**9th Cir. No. 98-70062**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 16, 1999****Hobet Mining, Inc., 20 FMSHRC 889 (Aug. 1998) (ALJ)**
**Hobet**
**4th Cir. No. 98-2693**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Nov. 24, 1998****Walker Stone Co., 19 FMSHRC 48 (Jan. 1997)**
**Walker Stone**
**10th Cir. No. 979528**
**Affirmed**
**156 F.3d 1076**
**Sept. 22, 1998****In re: Contests of Respirable Dust Sample Alteration Cases, 17 FMSHRC 1819 (Nov. 1995)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 95-1619**
**Affirmed**
**151 F.3d 1096**
**Aug. 21, 1998****Windsor Coal Co., 19 FMSHRC 675 (Oct. 1997) (ALJ)**
**Windsor Coal**
**4th Cir. No. 97-2766**
**Affirmed**
**166 F.3d 337 (Table), 1998 WL 879062 (July 31)****Stillwater Mining Co., 18 FMSHRC 1289 (July 1996) (ALJ)**
**Stillwater**
**9th Cir. No. 97-2766**
**Affirmed**
**142 F.3d 1179**
**Apr. 28, 1998****Eastern Ridge Lime, L.P., 19 FMSHRC 398 (Feb. 1997) (ALJ)**
**Easter Ridge**
**4th Cir. No. 97-1579**
**Affirmed in part/vacated and remanded in part**
**141 F.3d 1158 (Table), 1998 WL 169213**
**(Apr. 13)****Consolidation Coal Co., 18 FMSHRC 1903 (Nov. 1996)**
**Consol**
**D.C. Cir. No. 97-1100**
**Affirmed**
**136 F.3d 819**
**Feb. 27, 1998****Mingo Logan Coal Co., 19 FMSHRC 246 (Feb. 1997)**
**Mingo Logan**
**4th Cir. No. 97-1392**
**Affirmed**
**133 F.3d 916 (Table), 1998 WL 3613**
**(Jan. 8)****McClanahan v. Wellmore Coal Corp., 19 FMSHRC 55 (Jan. 1997)**
**Wellmore**
**4th Cir. No. 97-1280**
**Reversed**
**133 F.3d 920 (Table), 1997 WL 794132**
**(Dec. 30)**
**Cert. Denied**
**525 U.S. 1025**
**Dec. 7, 1998****Amax Coal Co., 19 FMSHRC 1542 (Sept. 1997)**
**Amax**
**D.C. Cir. No. 97-1657**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Dec. 19, 1997****Beck Materials Co., 18 FMSHRC 772 (May 1996) (ALJ)**
**Beck Materials**
**8th Cir. No. 96-2984**
**Affirmed**
**129 F.3d 121 (Table), 1997 WL 636614 (Oct. 14)**
**Sec’y obo Poddey v. Tanglewood Energy, Inc., 18 FMSHRC 1315 (Aug. 1996)**
**Sec’y of Labor to enforce decision**
**4th Cir. No. 97-2102**
**Enforced**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 2, 1997****Perkins v. Morningside Develpment Corp., 13 FMSHRC 958 (June 1991) (ALJ)**
**Perkins to enforce decision**
**4th Cir. No. 97-1797**
**Enforced**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 20, 1997****RNS Services, Inc., 18 FMSHRC 523 (Apr. 1996)**
**RNS Services**
**3rd Cir. No. 96-3245**
**Affirmed**
**115 F.3d 182**
**May 29, 1997****Jim Walter Resources, Inc., 18 FMSHRC 1687 (Sept. 1996) (ALJ)**
**JWR**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1456**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**May 9, 1997****Amax Coal. Co., 18 FMSHRC 1355 (Aug. 1996)**
**Amax**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1487**
**Dismissed as Moot Upon Settlement**
**1997 WL 362750 (May 8)****Jim Walter Resources, Inc., 18 FMSHRC 508 (Apr. 1996)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1164**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**111 F.3d 913**
**May 2, 1997****Energy West Mining Co., 18 FMSHRC 565 (Apr. 1996)**
**Energy West**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1243**
**Affirmed**
**111 F.3d 900**
**Apr. 25, 1997****Freeman United Coal Mining Co., 18 FMSHRC 438 (Mar. 1996) (ALJ)**
**Freeman United**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 96-1185,**
**-1186**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**108 F.3d 358**
**Mar. 11, 1997****Peabody Coal Co., 18 FMSHRC 686 (May 1996)**
**Peabody**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1205**
**Affirmed**
**111 F.3d 963 (Table), 1997 WL 159436 (Mar. 3)****Primrose Coal Co., 18 FMSHRC 1443 (Aug. 1996) (ALJ)**
**Primrose**
**3rd Cir. No. 96-3525**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 28, 1997****Blue Bayou Sand & Gravel, Inc., 18 FMSHRC**
**Blue Bayou**
**8th Cir. No. 96-2782**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 27, 1997****Doss Fork Coal Co., 18 FMSHRC 602 (Apr. 1996) (ALJ)**
**Doss Fork**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1199**
**Affirmed**
**111 F.3d 962 (Table), 1997 WL 159414 (Feb. 21)****Austin Powder Co., 18 FMSHRC 1878 (Oct. 1996) (ALJ)**
**Austin Powder**
**D.C. Cir. No. 97-1013**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 19, 1997****Deshetty v. Manalapan Mining Co., 18 FMSHRC 2133 (Dec. 1996) (ALJ)**
**Deshetty**
**6th Cir. No. 97-3151**
**Dismissed for Failure to Pursue**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 18, 1997****Jim Walter Resources, Inc., 17 FMSHRC 1423 (Aug. 1995) (ALJ)**
**JWR**
**D.C. Cir. No. 95-1554**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**103 F.3d 1020**
**Jan. 17, 1997****Joy Technologies, Inc., 17 FMSHRC 1310 (Aug. 1995)**
**Joy Technologies**
**10th Cir. No. 95-9540**
**Affirmed**
**99 F.3d 991**
**Nov. 5, 1996**
**Cert. denied**
**520 U.S. 1209**
**May 12, 1997****Peabody Coal Co., 18 FMSHRC 494 (Apr. 1996)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 96-1246**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Nov. 4, 1996****Cold Spring Granite Co., 17 FMSHRC 79 (Jan. 1995) (ALJ)**
**Cold Spring Granite**
**D.C. Cir. No. 95-1186**
**Reversed**
**98 F.3d 1376**
**Nov. 1, 1996****Mechanicsville Concrete, Inc., 17 FMSHRC 483 (Mar. 1995) (ALJ)**
**Mechanicsville**
**4th Cir. No. 95-2861**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 1, 1996****Sinnott v. Jim Walter Resources, Inc., 16 FMSHRC 2445 (Dec. 1994) (ALJ)**
**Sinnott**
**11th Cir. 95-1692**
**Affirmed**
**89 F.3d 855 (Table), 1996 WL 346401 (June 17)****Sec’y obo Bowling et al v. Mayes Trucking Co.et al., 17 FMSHRC 1695 (Oct. 1995) (ALJ)**
**Mayes Trucking**
**6th Cir. No. 95-4170**
**Dismissed for Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction**
**83 F.3d 422, 1996 WL 193730 (Apr. 19)****Dixie Fuel Co., 17 FMSHRC 727 (May 1995) (ALJ)**
**Dixie Fuel**
**6th Cir. No. 95-3721**
**Affirmed**
**82 F.3d 417, 1996 WL 185794 (Apr. 17)****Wyoming Fuel Co. n/k/a Basin Resources, Inc., 16 FMSHRC 1618 (1994)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**10th Cir. No. 95-9527**
**Affirmed**
**81 F.3d 173 (Table), 1996 WL 164529 (Apr. 8)****Sec’y obo Wamsley, et al. v. Mutual Mining Co., 16 FMSHRC 1304 (June 1994) (ALJ) & 2371 (Nov. 1994) (ALJ)**
**Sec’y of Labor; Mutual Mining**
**4th Cir. Nos. 95-1130,**
**-1212**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**80 F.3d 110**
**Apr. 3, 1996****Sec’y obo Nantz v. Nally & Hamilton Enterprises, 16 FMSHRC 2208 (Nov. 1994)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**6th Cir. No. 94-5325**
**Dismissed as Moot**
**Unreported**
**June 21, 1995****Rhone-Poulenc of Wyoming Co., 15 FMSHRC 2083 (Oct. 1993)**
**Rhone-Poulenc**
**10th Cir. 94-9521**
**Affirmed**
**57 F.3d 982**
**June 14, 1995****W.S. Frey Co., 16 FMSHRC 975 (Apr. 1994) (ALJ)**
**W.S. Frey**
**4th Cir. No. 94-1860**
**Affirmed**
**57 F.3d 1068 (Table), 1995 WL 352494 (June 13)****Thunder Basin Coal Co., 16 FMSHRC 1849 (Aug. 1994)**
**Thunder Basin**
**10th Cir. No. 94-9563**
**Affirmed**
**56 F.3d 1275**
**June 7, 1995****L & J Energy Co., 16 FMSHRC 796 (Apr. 1994)**
**L&J Energy**
**D.C. Cir. No. 94-1454**
**Remanded for Penalty**
**57 F.3d 1086**
**June 6, 1995****Buck Creek Coal Inc., Unpublished Order (Feb. 8, 1995)**
**Buck Creek**
**D.C. Cir. No. 95-1158**
**Mandamus Denied**
**1995 WL 311482 (Apr. 24)****Buck Creek Coal Co., 16 FMSHRC 540 (Mar. 1994) (ALJ)**
**Buck Creek**
**7th Cir. No. 94-2084**
**Affirmed**
**52 F.3d 133**
**Apr. 20, 1995****Shirel and Guess, emp. by Piro Mining Co., 15 FMSHRC 2440 (Dec. 1993)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 94-1030**
**Affirmed**
**52 F.3d 1123 (Table), 1995 WL 225707 (Mar. 29)****Deshetty, emp. by Island Creek Coal Co., 16 FMSHRC 1046 (May 1994)**
**Deshetty**
**D.C. Cir. No. 94-1479**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Feb. 8, 1995****Vanover v. Shamrock Coal Co., 15 FMSHRC 2505 (Dec. 1993) (ALJ)**
**Vanover**
**D.C. Cir. No. 94-1089**
**Affirmed**
**48 F.3d 563 (Table), 1995 WL 35316 (Jan. 13)****Collins v. Andalex Resources, Inc., 15 FMSHRC 257 (Feb. 1993) (ALJ)**
**Collins**
**6th Cir. No. 93-3427**
**Affirmed**
**43 F.3d 1388 (Table), 1994 WL 683938 (Dec. 6)****Energy West Mining Co., 15 FMSHRC 587 (Apr. 1993)**
**Energy West**
**D.C. Cir. No. 93-1296**
**Affirmed**
**40 F.3d 457**
**Dec. 2, 1994****Kerr-McGee Coal Corp., 15 FMSHRC 352 (Mar. 1993)**
**Kerr-McGee**
**D.C. Cir. No. 93-1250**
**Affirmed**
**40 F.3d 1257**
**Dec. 2, 1994**
**Cert. denied**
**515 U.S. 1159**
**June 26, 1995****Bethenergy Mines, Inc., 15 FMSHRC 981 (June 1993)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 93-1475**
**Affirmed**
**43 F.3d 712 (Table), 1994 WL 665199 (Nov. 9)****United Energy Services, Inc., 15 FMSHRC 2022 (Sept. 1993) (ALJ)**
**United Energy**
**4th Cir. No. 93-2520**
**Affirmed**
**35 F.3d 971**
**Sept. 23, 1994****Materials Delivery, 15 FMSHRC 2467 (Dec. 1993) (ALJ)**
**Mechanicsville Concrete, Inc., t/a Materials Delivery**
**4th Cir. No. 94-1222**
**Affirmed**
**35 F.3d 556 (Table), 1994 WL 503846 (Sept. 16)****Air Products & Chemicals, Inc., 15 FMSHRC 2428 (Dec. 1993)**
**Air Products**
**3rd Cir. No. 93-3646**
**Affirmed**
**37 F.3d 1485 (Table), 1994 WL 511408 (Aug. 18)****Boswell v. National Cement Co., 14 FMSHRC 253 (Feb. 1992) & 14 FMSHRC 541 (Apr. 1992) (ALJ on remand)**
**National Cement**
**11th Cir. No. 93-6557**
**Reversed**
**27 F.3d 526**
**Aug. 3, 1994****Jerry Ike Harless Towing, Inc., 16 FMSHRC 683 (Apr. 1994)**
**Harless Towing**
**5th Cir. No. 94-40545**
**Dismissed as Untimely**
**Unreported**
**July 14, 1994****Sec’y obo Smith v. Helen Mining Co., 14 FMSHRC 1571 (Sept. 1992) (ALJ)**
**The Helen Mining Co.**
**D.C. Cir. No. 92-1599**
**Affirmed**
**16 F.3d 1291**
**Mar. 4, 1994****C&B Mining Co., 15 FMSHRC 917 (May 1993) (ALJ)**
**Gary L. Lorenz**
**3rd Cir. No. 93-3652**
**Dismissed for Failure to Pursue**
**Unreported**
**Jan. 31, 1994****Stroud v. CBM Mining, Inc., 14 FMSHRC 1795 (Oct. 1992) (ALJ)**
**Stroud**
**D.C. Cir. No. 93-1001**
**Affirmed**
**1993 WL 411200 (Oct. 7)****Cyprus Tonopah Mining Corp., 15 FMSHRC 367 (Mar. 1993)**
**Cyprus Tonopah**
**9th Cir. No. 93-70453**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 5, 1993****Burgan v. Harlan Cumberland Coal Co., 15 FMSHRC 889 (May 1993) (ALJ)**
**Burgan**
**D.C. Cir. No. 93-8023**
**Dismissed as Untimely**
**1993 WL 404003 (Sept. 30)****Meek v. Essroc Corp., 15 FMSHRC 606 (Apr. 1993)**
**Essroc Corp.**
**6th Cir. No. 93-3833**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**Unreported**
**Aug. 27, 1993****Southern Ohio Coal Co., 14 FMSHRC 978 (June 1992)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 92-1306**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**(Sometime after June 15, 1993)****Smith v. KEM Coal Co., 14 FMSHRC 67 (Jan. 1992)**
**KEM Coal**
**6th Cir. No. 92-3734**
**Affirmed**
**995 F.2d 1067 (Table), 1993 WL 173689 (May 24)****Sec’y obo Bowling v. Perry Transport, Inc., 15 FMSHRC 196 (Feb. 1993)**
**Perry Transport**
**6th Cir. No. 93-3204**
**Dismissed for Failure to Pursue**
**Unreported**
**Apr. 28, 1993****Homestake Mining Co., 13 FMSHRC 988 (June 1991) (ALJ)**
**Homestake**
**D.C. Cir. No. 91-1423**
**Dismissed as Moot**
**979 F.2d 248 (Table), 1992 WL 328471 (Nov. 5)****Burns v. D.H. Lattner & Sons, Inc., 13 FMSHRC 995 (June 1991) (ALJ)**
**Estate of Burns**
**D.C. Cir. No. 91-1379**
**Voluntarily Dismissed**
**Unreported**
**Oct. 21, 1992****Hays v. Leeco, Inc., 12 FMSHRC 1850 (Sept. 1990)**
**Hays**
**D.C. Cir. No. 91-1276**
**Dismissed Upon Settlement**
**976 F.2d 46 (Table), 1992 WL 225480 (Aug. 26)****Pennsylvania Electric Co., 12 FMSHRC 1562 (Aug. 1990)**
**Pennsylvania Electric**
**3rd Cir. No. 90-3636**
**Affirmed**
**969 F.2d 1501**
**July 15, 1992****Lancashire Coal Co., 13 FMSHRC 875 (July 1991)**
**Lancashire Coal**
**3rd Cir. Nos. 91-3433,**
**-3566**
**Reversed**
**968 F.2d 388**
**June 29, 1992****Utah Power & Light Co., Mining Div., 12 FMSHRC 965 (May 1990)**
**Utah Power**
**10th Cir. No. 90-9538**
**Affirmed**
**951 F.2d 292**
**Dec. 27, 1991****Puerto Rican Cement Co., 12 FMSHRC 1934 (Oct. 1990) (ALJ)**
**Puerto Rican Cement**
**D. C. Cir. No. 91-1078**
**Affirmed**
**950 F.2d 797 (Table), 1991 WL 265867 (Dec. 12)****Wagner v. Pittston Coal Group et al. and Ann McGlaughlin et al., 12 FMSHRC 1178 (June 1990)**
**Dennis Wagner**
**4th Cir. No. 91-2025**
**Affirmed**
**947 F.2d 943 (Table), 1991 WL 224257 (Nov. 5)****Southern Ohio Coal Co., 12 FMSHRC 1498 (Aug. 1990)**
**Southern Ohio**
**4th Cir. No. 90-1827**
**Affirmed**
**940 F.2d 653 (Table), 1991 WL 153649 (Aug. 14)****Begay v. Liggett Industries, Inc., 11 FMSHRC 887 (May 1989) (ALJ)**
**Liggett Industries**
**10th Cir. No. 89-9546**
**Affirmed**
**923 F.2d 150**
**Jan. 9, 1991****Sec’y obo Price and Vacha v. Jim Walters Resources, Inc., 9 FMSHRC 1305 (Aug. 1987)**
**Jim Walters**
**11th Cir. No. 87-7484**
**Affirmed**
**920 F.2d 738**
**Dec. 21, 1990****Otis Elevator Co., 11 FMSHRC 1896 (Oct. 1989) and 11 FMSHRC 1918 (Oct. 1989)**
**Otis Elevator**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 89-1712,**
**-1713**
**Affirmed**
**921 F.2d 1285**
**Dec. 18, 1990****Local Union 1261, UMWA v. Consolidation Coal Co., 11 FMSHRC 1609 (Sept. 1989)**
**Local Union 1261**
**D.C. Cir. No. 89-1637**
**Affirmed**
**917 F.2d 42**
**Oct. 26, 1990****Green River Coal Co., 11 FMSHRC 2036 (Oct. 1989) (ALJ)**
**Green River**
**6th Cir. No. 89-4133**
**Affirmed**
**914 F.2d 256 (Table), 1990 WL 126420 (Aug. 30)****Bryant v. Dingess Mine Service, et al., 10 FMSHRC 1173 (Sept. 1988)**
**Bryant and Winchester Coals**
**4th Cir. Nos. 89-3247**
**-3352**
**Affirmed**
**905 F.2d 1533 (Table), 1990 WL 74302 (May 10)****Western Fuels-Utah, Inc., 11 FMSHRC 278 (Mar. 1989)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 89-1258**
**Reversed**
**900 F.2d 318**
**April 6, 1990****Utah Power & Light Co., 10 FMSHRC 302 (Mar. 1988)**
**Utah Power**
**10th Cir. Nos. 88-1655,**
**-1659**
**Affirmed in part/Reversed in part**
**897 F.2d 447**
**Feb. 26, 1990****Sec’y obo Pack v. Maynard Branch Dredging et al., 11 FMSHRC 168 (Feb. 1989)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 11-8962**
**Affirmed**
**896 F.2d 599 (Table), 1990 WL 18651 (Feb. 21)****Frye v. Pittston Coal Group/Clinchfield Coal Co., 11 FMSHRC 187 (Feb. 1989) (ALJ)**
**Frye**
**4th Cir. No. 89-2668**
**Affirmed**
**896 F.2d 1367 (Table), 1990 WL 15594 (Feb. 9)****Local Union 2274, Dist. 28, UMWA v. Clinchfield Coal Co., 10 FMSHRC 1493 (Nov. 1988)**
**Clinchfield**
**D.C. Cir. No. 88-1873**
**Affirmed**
**895 F.2d 773**
**Feb. 9, 1990****Sec’y obo Keene v. S&M Coal Co., et al., 10 FMSHRC 1145 (Sept. 1988)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 88-1765**
**Affirmed in part/reversed and remanded in part**
**888 F.2d 1448**
**Nov. 3, 1989****Davidson Mining, Inc., 10 FMSHRC 765 (June 1988) (ALJ)**
**Davidson**
**4th Cir. No. 88-1136**
**Affirmed**
**884 F.2d 1387 (Table), 1989 WL 100533 (Aug. 28)****Sisk v. E.R. Mining, Inc., d/b/a E.R. Trucking Co., 10 FMSHRC 1101 (Aug. 1988) (ALJ)**
**Sisk**
**6th Cir. No. 88-3982**
**Affirmed**
**878 F.2d 1436 (Table), 1989 WL 76156 (July 13)****Western Fuels-Utah, Inc., 10 FMSHRC 256 (Mar. 1988)**
**Western Fuels-Utah**
**D.C. Cir. No. 88-1313**
**Affirmed**
**870 F.2d 711**
**Mar. 24, 1989****Asarco, Inc.-Northwestern Mining Dep’t, 8 FMSHRC 1632 (Nov. 1986)**
**Asarco, Inc.**
**10th Cir. No. 86-2765**
**Affirmed**
**868 F.2d 1195**
**Mar. 13, 1989****Sec’y obo Bushnell v. Cannelton Industries, Inc., 10 FMSHRC 152 (Feb. 1988)**
**Sec’y of Labor**
**D.C. Cir. No. 88-1229**
**Reversed and remanded**
**867 F.2d 1432**
**Feb. 14, 1989****Sec’y obo Gilbert v. Sandy Fork Mining Co., 9 FMSHRC 1327 (Aug. 1987)**
**Gilbert**
**D.C. Cir. No. 87-1499**
**Reversed**
**866 F.2d 1433**
**Jan. 29, 1989****Sec’y obo Maggard v. Chaney Creek Coal Co., 9 FMSHRC 1314 (Aug. 1987)**
**Chaney Creek and Maggard**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 87-1494,**
**-1500**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**866 F.2d 1424**
**Jan. 27, 1989****Thurman v. Queen Anne Coal Co., 10 FMSHRC 131 (Feb. 1988)**
**Thurman**
**6th Cir. No. 88-3210**
**Affirmed**
**866 F.2d 431 (Table), 1989 WL 3974 (Jan. 20)****Emerald Mines. Corp., 9 FMSHRC 1590 (Sept. 1987)**
**Emerald**
**D.C. Cir. No. 87-1816**
**Affirmed**
**863 F.2d 51**
**Dec. 6, 1988****Austin Power, Inc., 9 FMSHRC 2015 (Dec. 1987)**
**Austin Power**
**5th Cir. No. 88-4051**
**Affirmed**
**861 F.2d 99**
**Nov. 30, 1988****Wilmot Mining Co., 9 FMSHRC 684 (Apr. 1987)**
**Wilmot**
**6th Cir. No. 87-3480**
**Affirmed in part/reversed and remanded in part**
**848 F.2d 195 (Table), 1988 WL 48543 (May 17)****Simpson v. Kenta Energy, Inc., et al., 8 FMSHRC 1034 (July 1985)**
**Simpson**
**D.C. Cir. No. 86-1141**
**Reversed and remanded**
**842 F.2d 453**
**Mar. 18, 1988****Local Union No. 5817, Dist. 17, UMWA v. Monument Mining Corp., 9 FMSHRC 209 (Feb. 1987)**
**UMWA**
**D. C. Cir. No. 87-1136**
**Reversed and remanded**
**840 F.2d 77**
**Feb. 23, 1988****Sec’y obo Corbin, et al. v. Sugartree Corp., et al., 9 FMSHRC 394 (Mar. 1987)**
**Terco, Inc., et al.**
**6th Cir. Nos. 87-3391,**
**-3572**
**Affirmed**
**839 F.2d 236**
**Dec. 8, 1987**
**Cert. denied**
**488 U.S. 818**
**Oct. 3, 1988****Jones v. D&R Contractors, 8 FMSHRC 1045 (July 1986)**
**Jones**
**6th Cir. No. 86-3759**
**Reversed**
**827 F.2d 769 (Table), 1987 WL 44563 (Aug. 27)****Sec’y obo Hogan v. Emerald Mines Corp., 8 FMSHRC 1066 (July 1986)**
**Emerald**
**3rd Cir. No. 86-3786**
**Affirmed**
**829 F.2d 31**
**Aug. 7, 1987****Consolidation Coal Co., 8 FMSHRC 890 (June 1986)**
**Consol**
**D.C. Cir. No. 86-1403**
**Affirmed**
**824 F.2d 1071**
**July 24, 1987****Sec’y obo Acton, et al., v. Jim Walters Resources, Inc., 7 FMSHRC 1348; UMWA obo Rowe et al. v. Peabody Coal Co., 7 FMSHRC 1357 (Sept. 1985)**
**Brock (Sec’y), Merrell, UMWA**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 85-1714,**
**-1716, -1717; 86-1002,**
**-1027**
**Affirmed**
**822 F.2d 1134**
**July 7, 1987****Sec’y obo Ribel v. Eastern Associated Coal Corp., 7 FMSHRC 2015 (Dec. 1985)**
**Eastern Associated and Ribel**
**4th Cir. Nos. 86-3832(L),**
**-3833**
**Affirmed in part/reversed in part**
**813 F.2d 639**
**Mar. 9, 1987****Paul v. P.B. – K.B.B., Inc., 7 FMSHRC 1784 (Nov. 1985)**
**Paul**
**D.C. Cir. No. 85-1801**
**Affirmed**
**812 F.2d 717**
**Feb. 27, 1987****Southern Ohio Coal Co., 8 FMSHRC 295 (Mar. 1986)**
**Southern Ohio**
**6th Cir. No. 86-3292**
**Affirmed**
**815 F.2d 80 (Table)**
**Feb. 25, 1987****Sec’y obo Cameron v. Consolidation Coal Co., 7 FMSHRC 319 (Mar. 1985)**
**Consol**
**4th Cir. No. 85-2369**
**Affirmed**
**795 F.2d 364**
**July 8, 1986****Consolidation Coal Co., 7 FMSHRC 332 (Mar. 1985) (ALJ) & 7 FMSHRC 490 (Apr. 1985)**
**Consol**
**4th Cir. No. 85-1434**
**Affirmed**
**786 F.2d 1152 (Table)**
**Mar. 13, 1986****Sec’y ex rel. Bennett, et al. v. Emery Mining Corp., 5 FMSHRC 1391 (Aug. 1983)**
**Emery**
**10th Cir. No. 83-2017**
**Reversed**
**783 F.2d 155**
**Jan. 31, 1986****Pyro Mining Co., 6 FMSHRC 2089 (Sept. 1984)**
**Pyro**
**6th Cir. No. 84-4022**
**Affirmed in part/reversed and remanded in part**
**785 F.2d 310 (Table)**
**Jan. 6, 1986****Old Dominion Power Co., 6 FMSHRC 1886 (Aug. 1984)**
**Old Dominion**
**4th Cir. No. 84-1942**
**Reversed**
**772 F.2d 92**
**Sept. 18, 1985****Kitt Energy Corp., 6 FMSHRC 1596 (July 1984)**
**UMWA**
**D.C. Cir. No. 84-1428**
**Affirmed**
**768 F.2d 1477**
**Aug. 2, 1985****Moses v. Whitley Development Corp., 4 FMSHRC 1459 (Aug. 1982)**
**Whitley**
**6th Cir. No. 84-3375**
**Affirmed**
**770 F.2d 168 (Table), 1985 WL 13502 (July 31, 1985)****Sec’y ob [7 miners] v. Metric Constructors, Inc. 6 FMSHRC 226 (Feb. 1984) & 6 FMSHRC 1050 (Apr. 1984) (ALJ)**
**Sec’ of Labor**
**Metric**
**11th Cir. No. 84-3427**
**Affirmed**
**766 F.2d 469**
**July 23, 1985****United States Steel Corp., 4 FMSHRC 954 (May 1982) (ALJ)**
**U.S. Steel**
**8th Cir. No. 84-1889**
**Affirmed**
**756 F.2d 658**
**Mar. 6, 1985****Council of Southern Mountains, Inc. v. Martin County Coal Corp., 6 FMSHRC 206 (Feb. 1984)**
**Council of Southern Mountains**
**D.C. Cir. No. 84-1092**
**Affirmed**
**751 F.2d 1418**
**Jan. 15, 1985****Hollis v. Consolidation Coal Co., 6 FMSHRC 21 (Jan. 1984)**
**Hollis**
**D.C. Cir. No. 84-1041**
**Affirmed**
**750 F.2d 1093 (Table)**
**Dec. 28, 1984****Emery Mining Corp., 5 FMSHRC 1400 (Aug. 1983)**
**Emery**
**10th Cir. No. 83-2046**
**Affirmed**
**744 F.2d 1411**
**Sept. 26, 1984****Monterey Coal Co., 5 FMSHRC 1223 (July 1983) (ALJ)**
**Monterey**
**7th Cir. No. 83-2651**
**Affirmed**
**743 F.2d 589**
**Sept. 14, 1984****Consolidation Coal Co., 3 MSHC 1082 (July 1983) (ALJ digest)**
**Consol**
**3rd Cir. No. 83-3463**
**Affirmed**
**740 F.2d 271**
**Aug. 13, 1984****Sellersburg Stone Co., 5 FMSHRC 287 (Mar. 1983)**
**Sellersburg**
**7th Cir. No. 83-1630**
**Affirmed**
**736 F.2d 1147**
**June 11, 1984****Sec’y ex rel. Smith, et al. v. Stafford Construction Co., 5 FMSHRC 618 (Apr. 1983)**
**Donavan (Sec’y)**
**D.C. Cir. No. 83-1566**
**Reversed and remanded**
**732 F.2d 954**
**Apr. 20, 1984****Cleveland Cliffs Iron Co., 4 FMSHRC 2141 (Dec. 1982)**
**Cleveland Cliffs**
**6th Cir. No. 83-3021**
**Affirmed**
**734 F.2d 13 (Table)**
**Apr. 6, 1984****Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp., 5 FMSHRC 1209 (July 1983)**
**International Union, UMWA**
**D.C. Cir. No. 83-1867**
**Reversed and remanded**
**731 F.2d 995 (Table), 3 MSHC 1289**
**Mar. 9, 1984****Mathies Coal Co., 5 FMSHRC 300 (Mar. 1983)**
**UMWA**
**D.C. Cir. No. 83-1437**
**Affirmed**
**725 F.2d 126 (Table), 3 MSHC 1217**
**Jan. 13, 1984****Dickey v. United States Steel Mining Co., 5 FMSHRC 519 (July 1983) (ALJ)**
**Dickey**
**3rd Cir. No. 83-3265**
**Affirmed**
**727 F.2d 1099 (Table) 3 MSHC 1233**
**Jan. 10, 1984****Florence Mining Co., et al., 5 FMSHRC 189 (Feb. 1983)**
**Florence Mining Co., et al.**
**3rd Cir. No. 83-3124**
**Affirmed**
**725 F.2d 667 (Table)**
**Dec. 12, 1983****Frazier v. Morrison-Knudsen, Inc., 5 FMSHRC 139 (Jan. 1983) (ALJ)**
**Frazier**
**D.C. Cir. No. 83-1322**
**Affirmed**
**721 F.2d 1424 (Table), 3 MSHC 1138**
**Nov. 21, 1983****Neal v. Wayne Boich, dba W.B. Coal Co., 3 FMSHRC 443 (Feb. 1981) (ALJ)**
**Boich**
**6th Cir. No. 81-3186**
**Affirmed**
**719 F.2d 194 (on rehearing)**
**Oct. 14, 1983**
**704 F.2d 275 (original)**
**Apr. 5, 1983****Local Union 1957, UMWA, et al. v. Southern Ohio Coal Co., 2 FMSHRC 3472 (Dec. 1980)**
**Southern Ohio**
**6th Cir. No. 81-3007**
**Reversed**
**716 F.2d 1105**
**Sept. 12, 1983****Miller Mining Co., 4 FMSHRC 1509 (Aug. 1982) (ALJ)**
**Miller Mining**
**9th Cir. No. 82-7603**
**Affirmed**
**713 F.2d 487**
**Aug. 16, 1983****Brazell v. Island Creek Coal Co., 4 FMSHRC 1455 (Aug. 1982)**
**Brazell**
**6th Cir. No. 82-3562**
**Affirmed**
**716 F.2d 902 (Table), 3 MSHC 1036**
**July 18, 1983****Sec’y obo Chacon v. Phelps Dodge Corp., 3 FMSHRC 2508 (Nov. 1981)**
**Phelps Dodge**
**D.C. Cir. No. 81-2300**
**Reversed and remanded**
**709 F.2d 86**
**June 7, 1983****Climax Molybdenum Co., 2 FMSHRC 2748 (Oct. 1980)**
**Climax**
**10th Cir. No. 80-2187**
**Affirmed**
**703 F.2d 447**
**Mar. 21, 1983****Munsey v. Smitty Baker Coal Co., et al., 2 FMSHRC 3463 (Dec. 1980) & 3 FMSHRC 2056 (Sept. 1981) (ALJ)**
**Munsey & Smitty Baker, et al.**
**D.C. Cir. Nos. 82-1079,**
**-1084**
**Affirmed in part/reversed and remanded in part**
**701 F.2d 976**
**Mar. 11, 1983****Cowin & Co., 2 FMSHRC 2543 (Sept. 1980 (ALJ)**
**Cowin**
**4th Cir. No. 82-1336**
**Affirmed**
**694 F.2d 966**
**Dec. 10, 1982****Texas Industries, Inc., 4 FMSHRC 352 (Feb. 1982) (ALJ)**
**Texas Industries**
**5th Cir. No. 82-4132**
**Affirmed**
**694 F.2d 720 (Table), 2 MSHC 1915**
**Nov. 29, 1982****Kenny Richardson, 3 FMSHRC 8 (Jan. 1981)**
**Richardson**
**6th Cir. No. 81-3060**
**Affirmed**
**689 F.2d 682**
**Oct. 1, 1982****Sewell Coal Co., 3 FMSHRC 1402 (June 1981**
**Sewell**
**4th Cir. No. 81-1592**
**Affirmed**
**686 F.2d 1066**
**Aug. 30, 1982****Sec’y of Labor and Miller v. Old Ben Coal Co., 2 FMSHRC 294 (Feb. 1980) (ALJ)**
**Miller**
**7th Cir. No. 80-1536**
**Affirmed**
**687 F.2d 194**
**Aug. 19, 1982****Phelps Dodge Corp., 3 FMSHRC 458 (Feb. 1981) (ALJ)**
**Phelps Dodge**
**9th Cir. No. 81-7251**
**Reversed**
**681 F.2d 1189**
**July 22, 1982****Capitol Aggregates, Inc., 3 FMSHRC 1388 (June 1981)**
**Capitol**
**5th Cir. No. 81-4278**
**Affirmed**
**671 F.2d 1377 (Table)**
**Mar. 19, 1982****The Helen Mining Co., 1 FMSHRC 1796 (Nov. 1979); Kentland Elkhorn Coal Corp., 1 FMSHRC 1833 (Nov. 1979); Allied Chemical Corp 1 FMSHRC 1947 (Dec. 1979)**
**Sec’y of Labor and UWMA**
**D.C. Cir Nos. 79-2503, -2518, -2536,**
**-2537; 80-1021**
**Reversed and Remanded**
**671 F.2d 615**
**Feb. 23, 1982****Allied Products Co., 2 FSMHRC 2517 (Sept. 1980) (ALJ)**
**Allied**
**5th Cir. No. 80-7935**
**Affirmed in part/vacated and remanded in part**
**666 F.2d 890**
**Feb. 1, 1982****B. L. Anderson, Inc., 3 FMSHRC 1019 (Apr. 1981) (ALJ)**
**Anderson**
**8th Cir. No. 81-1637**
**Affirmed**
**668 F.2d 442**
**Jan. 15, 1982****Cyprus Industrial Minerals Corp., 3 FMSHRC 1 (Jan. 1981)**
**Cyprus**
**9th Cir. No. 81-7062**
**Affirmed**
**664 F.2d 1116**
**Dec. 28, 1981****Harman Mining Corp., 3 FMSHRC 45 (Jan. 1981) (ALJ)**
**Harman**
**4th Cir. No. 81-1189**
**Affirmed**
**671 F.2d 794**
**Dec. 24, 1981****Sec’y obo Pasula v. Consolidation Coal Co., 2 FMSHRC 2786 (Oct. 1980)**
**Consol**
**3rd Cir. No. 80-2600**
**Reversed**
**663 F.2d 1211**
**Oct. 30, 1981****Parks v. L & M Coal Corp., 2 FMSHRC 2815 (Oct. 1980)**
**L&M**
**4th Cir. No. 80-1820**
**Affirmed**
**672 F.2d 910 (Table), 2 MSHC 1481**
**Oct. 7, 1981****Duval Corp., 2 FMSHRC 781 (Apr. 1980)**
**Duval**
**9th Cir. No. 80-7213**
**Affirmed**
**650 F.2d 1051**
**July 13, 1981****Magma Copper Co., 1 FMSHRC 1948 (Dec. 1979)**
**Magma**
**9th Cir. No. 79-7687**
**Affirmed**
**645 F.2d 694**
**May 18, 1981****Shamrock Coal Co., 1 FMSHRC 799 (July 1979)**
**Shamrock**
**6th Cir. No. 79-3541**
**Affirmed**
**652 F.2d 59 (Table)**
**Mar. 23, 1981****Shamrock Coal Co., 1 FMSHRC 469 (June 1979)**
**Shamrock**
**6th Cir. No. 79-3393**
**Affirmed**
**653 F.2d 59 (Table)**
**Mar. 9, 1981****Shamrock Coal Co., 1 MSHC 1761 (Jan. 1979) (ALJ digest)**
**Shamrock**
**6th Cir. No. 79-3541**
**Affirmed**
**647 F.2d 166 (Table), 2 MSHC 1153**
**Feb. 3, 1981****Ace Drilling Coal Co., 2 FMSHRC 790 (Apr. 1980)**
**Ace**
**3rd Cir. No. 80-1750**
**Affirmed**
**642 F.2d 440 (Table)**
**Jan. 23, 1981****Monterey Coal Co., 1 FMSHRC 1782 (Nov. 13, 1979)**
**Monterey**
**4th Cir. No. 79-1827**
**Dismissed as premature**
**635 F.2d 291**
**Nov. 17, 1980****Scotia Coal Mining Co., 2 FMSHRC 633 (Mar. 1980)**
**Scotia**
**6th Cir. No. 80-3303**
**Dismissed as premature**
**636 F.2d 1219 (Table), 2 MSHC 1051**
**Nov. 14, 1980****Cowin & Co., Unpublished decision, HOPE 76-210-P through -213-P (Sept. 14, 1978) (ALJ)**
**Cowin**
**4th Cir. No. 78-1825**
**Vacated and Remanded**
**612 F.2d 838**
**Dec. 28, 1979****Westmoreland Coal Co., Unpublished Decision, HOPE 78-236 (Apr. 3, 1978) (ALJ)**
**Westmoreland**
**4th Cir. No. 78-1322**
**Affirmed and remanded**
**606 F.2d 417**
**Aug. 22, 1979**
 
 Footer Links
  

        
              EEO Policies
                No Fear Act Notice
                Employee Ethical Conduct
                Equal Access to Justice Act
                Motions to Approve Settlement
                Non-Discrimination
                Reasonable Accommodation Procedures
                Privacy Act
                Sunshine Act Regulations
                USA.gov
                FMSHRC Privacy Policy
                Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
 The Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission 1331 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW,Suite 520NWashington, DC 20004-1710Phone: (202)434-9900TTY/TDD (202)434-4000 ext. 293E-mail: fmshrc@fmshrc.gov