1

STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA

SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

Appalachian Boiler & Fab, LLC,

Employer Below, Petitioner

v.) No. 23-345 (JCN: 2019023975)

 (ICA No. 22-ICA-219)

 

Judith A. Caruthers, widow of Johnny A. Caruthers, 

Claimant Below, Respondent; Alberici Mid Atlantic

WV, LLC, Employer Below, Respondent; and West 

Virginia Office of the Insurance Commissioner, in its 

capacity as administrator of the Old Fund, Respondent

MEMORANDUM DECISION

Petitioner Appalachian Boiler & Fab, LLC (“Appalachian”) appeals the April 10, 2023, 

memorandum decision of the Intermediate Court of Appeals of West Virginia (“ICA”). See 

Appalachian Boiler & Fab, LLC v. Caruthers, No. 22-ICA-219, 2023 WL 2863260 (W. Va. Ct. 

App. Apr. 10, 2023) (memorandum decision). Respondents Judith A. Caruthers, widow of Johnny 

A. Caruthers, and West Virginia Office of the Insurance Commissioner (“WVOIC”), in its capacity 

as administrator of the Old Fund, filed timely responses. Respondent Alberici Mid Atlantic WV, 

LLC (“Alberici”) filed a timely summary response.

1 The issue on appeal is whether the ICA erred 

in affirming the October 3, 2022, decision of the West Virginia Workers’ Compensation Board of 

Review, which (1) reversed the claim administrator’s order denying Ms. Caruthers’ claim for death 

benefits following the decedent’s death from acute myeloid leukemia, and (2) designated 

Appalachian as the chargeable employer.

Appalachian asserts that the claim administrator’s May 14, 2019, order denying the claim

should be reinstated as there were no allegations and no evidence that the decedent was exposed 

to benzene-containing products during his brief employment by Appalachian.

2 Ms. Caruthers, 

Alberici, and WVOIC counter by arguing that as Appalachian was the decedent’s employer when 

he was last exposed to benzene-containing products before he retired, the ICA did not err in 

1 Appalachian is represented by counsel James W. Heslep. Ms. Caruthers is represented by 

counsel R. Dean Hartley and James C. Wright. Alberici is represented by counsel Joni M. Mangino 

and Aaron H. Weiss. WVOIC is represented by counsel Sean Harter.

2 Benzene exposure is a known cause for acute myeloid leukemia.

FILED

September 23, 2024

C. CASEY FORBES, CLERK

SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

OF WEST VIRGINIA
2

affirming the Board of Review because the Board properly (1) awarded death benefits, and (2) 

designated Appalachian as the chargeable employer pursuant to WVOIC’s policy that 

chargeability will not be allocated or divided among employers. See Pioneer Pipe, Inc. v. Swain, 

237 W.Va. 722, 791 S.E.2d 168 (2016).

This Court reviews questions of law de novo, while we accord deference to the Board of 

Review’s findings of fact unless the findings are clearly wrong. Syl. Pt. 3, Duff v. Kanawha Cnty. 

Comm’n, No. 23-43, 2024 WL 1715166 (W. Va. Apr. 22, 2024). Upon consideration of the record 

and briefs, we find no reversible error and therefore summarily affirm. See W. Va. R. App. P. 

21(c). 

 Affirmed.

ISSUED: September 23, 2024

CONCURRED IN BY:

Chief Justice Tim Armstead

Justice Elizabeth D. Walker

Justice John A. Hutchison

Justice William R. Wooton

Justice C. Haley Bunn