COURT OF APPEALS
EIGHTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS EL PASO, TEXAS

DEBORAH J. GREER, DI ANA
ELIZABETH MACY, MARVIN GREER, JR. AND MAP20 04, LLC
D/B/A MAP2004

- OK, WOLF BONE RANCH PARTNERS LLC, SAPPHIRE ROYALTIES, INC., STE PHEN FLANAGAN, TRUSTEE OF THE MIDLAND TRUST, JOHN G. HARPER, JOHN P. WAND EL, JR.,
MAGNOLIA ROYALTY COM PANY, INC., WP RANCHES FAM ILY
LIMITED PART NERSHIP, J.M.
MINERAL & LAND CO. , GLML INVESTMENTS, LTD., S HAWN P. HANNIFIN, FRANCES A. HANNIFIN, FALL RIVER RESOURCES, INC., STR ATA MINERALS, INC., CHRISTA I.
LEAVELL AND T

- BAR OIL AND
GAS LTD. AND REG M. DAY, AS
TRUSTEE OF THE DAY F AMILY TRUST, SHARON M. STROMBERG, PATRICIA MURPHY, ARL ENE M. MURPHY, TRHUSEE OF T HE JOHN TIMOTHY MURPHY, SR., REVOCABLE TRUST, ELI ZABETH FOLEY RAPE, TRUSTEE OF THE
TESTAMENTARY TRUST F /B/O
WHITNEY ELIZABETH RA PE
UNDER THE WILL OF JO HN DAVID RAPE, MARGARET JUSTI NE BALLANTYNE, ELIZABET H ANN MARTIN, FFF, INC., J OE MARVIN CAYTON, Appellants, §

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§ No. 08

- 15

- 00040

- CV

Appeal from the 143 rd

District Court

of Reeves County, Texas

(TC # 13

- 08

- 20458

- CVR)2

v.

GLENN DAVID SHOOK, CHARLES JOSEPH BOYD, SARAH A NN LECLERQ, REBEKAH LEL A PRINCE, TIMOTHY DAMR ON BOYD, JONATHAN MARK BOYD,
JUDITH AND RICHARD COTHRUN, TRUSTEES OF THE
COTHRUN LIVING TRUST , RUTH
DELL SOMMERS AND RUT H COTHRUN SOMMERS, TRU STEES
OF THE RUTH C. SOMME RS
REVOCABLE TR UST, SHEILA LUCILE MCCREA, ESQ. ON
BEHALF OF THE MARGUE RITE A. MCCREA TRUST, AS CO

TRUSTEE, CARL A. CRO WLEY, AS
EXECUTOR OF THE ESTA TE OF ANNIE LEE CROWLEY,
CHRISTOPHER LANCE TR IGG,
CECILY TRIGG ORTENBE RG, CAMERON LEIGH TRIGG, LYNN D. HUGHES, FRAZEE D.
ARL EDGE, JULIE D. CANON

, MELANIE D. LEE, DONN A D. PEPPER, ROBERT HAILE Y, BARRY LEE HAILEY, JO HN
FORREST GRIFFIN AND JOHN W. BUSH, CO

- TRUSTEES OF THE
BUSH/GRIFFIN LIVING TRUST, DATED MAY 1, 1999, G WEDOLYN B. GELTEMEYER, JESS ST. CLAIR,
GUARDIAN OF THE ESTA TE O F SHARON B. ST. CLAIR, SYLVIA
RAMONA BUSH AND PRIE ST
FAMILY LIMITED PARTN ERSHIP, EDWARD LEE CLARK, AS
EXECUTOR AND SOLE HE IR OF
THE ESTATE OF CHOLE CLARK, VICTOR M. JOUFFREY, JR., HEIR
TO THE ESTATE OF VIC TOR M. JOUFFRAY, DECEASED, AND
EXECUTOR OF THE ESTA TE OF VICTOR M. JOUFFRAY, §

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§3

DECEASED, CHRISTINE JOUFFRAY, YAKKA II, LLC AND YAKKA OPERATIONS, LL C, CHAD SMITH, MICHAEL MCCRE A,
VICTOR CHASE MCCREA III,
JEFFREY REESE MCCREA AND
CYNTHIA ANN MCCREA TRUEBLOOD, AS CO

- TRUSTEES
OF THE BARBARA MCCRE A TRUST, DESERT PARTNERS V, L.P., JUDY W. OGILVY , AS HEIR
AND MICHAEL ALEX OGI LVY, AS
HEIR AND EXECUTOR OF THE
ESTATE OF ALEX OGILV Y, DECEASED, ABH BAXTER , LP, RAY MORRIS, L.W. BEN NINGER, DAVE MOODY, J.W. KIR BY, W.B. PANKHURST, GEORGE S. SALEH, R.W. PARKS, MARY KAT HRYN
AL LMAN, J. WALLACE HAW KINS, J.L. FARB, I.E. HOOD , MAX MANUS, MARIUS VILLAR ET, ANNIE LEE CROWLEY, J AMES W. SANDEFER, W.H. LACY, IRVIN J. FARB, RUTH ROWLAND, W.L. GRAY, KATHRYN BOURQU E, CLARENCE MOORE, LOUI SE MOORE, ROSALIE WILLI AMS, HARRIS CLANTON, JR., J.K. HAZLIP, JR., UNKNOWN HEIRS OF S.P. HAZLIP, UNKNOWN HEIRS
OF PAULINE RETHMEYER , PAUL CELINE ROBIN, OTEKA JUNE MCFARLAND, AS EXECUT OR OF
THE ESTATE OF CHARLE S “CHICK” FAIR, DECEAS ED,
PATRICIA SHORTES DOY AL,
INDEPENDENT ADMINIST RATOR
OF THE ESTATE OF JOH N OCI E SHORTES, DECEASED,
SAPPINGTON ENERGY INTERESTS, LTD., RAY STOKER, JR., EXECUTOR OF CLA UDENE STOKER’S ESTATE, BET TY SUE ELLIOT, GREGORY EDDI NGS,
EXECUTOR OF DOROTHY §

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§

§4

HEARN’S ESTATE, HARR IS ROBERTS FENDER, JR., MILAM SONS’ MINERALS, LLC, RETTA HAZLIP, CHRIS TIAN C. WICHSEL II, JAMES WALLACE HA WKINS,

Appellees. §

§

J U D G M E N T

The Court has considered this cause on the record and concludes there was no error in the

judgment. We therefore affirm the judgment of the court below. We further order that

App ellees recover from Appellants all costs in this Court. This decision shall be certified below

for observance.

IT IS SO ORDERED THIS 19TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2016.

STEV EN L. HUGHES, Justice

Before McClure, C.J., Rodriguez, and Hughes, JJ.