5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

)LOH 1DPH DS

	

		

	







,&+$5'

8*+

	






(77<

,7&+(//


	













 

!""#$%&'
(&	&&)*()&(+&,&

$&'&'*()&(+&$'(&!-

./001*2(**34*()&(+&4,5

!5,67,890

*+((#680

$6	
:*!
;<:(+,(&

4,5)






	  ') ; ( =
:
 **>	 
 =
:
 ** 
		
#,%7,)'($!""##&	+&&()) !< ;!: 
	:

;!
 	
 #,%7,) '( $ !""## 
  '()&  '% *2(  (-=
:
 **>	  
 =
:


0  

** 
		
 !""##&	+&&());!: 
	 :#,%7,)'($!""##







;
<: 4(+,(& 4,

7&,5'3)+2(+&$"
../,5' $(#"&(&( $##5(5&'&&'&(#+,&>)%(2(#&'()+$&&((5'&)@&7+&)2(+2(#&'(),&'&'()&(#+,)#"2((()&(+&+,&,#&(%(&'""#)   &' )) )&& 

+()($&'()&(+&+,&

	



 #8 4,8 .?. ,5'>

7( &# ' %&' #8%#)&',5'3)((+&2%70?0..?.$'(2()C0. 0D!)&+&&%$(%"()%&'&3&8$(28))&#()(5$(2))(5%+,&()),(&'()""*()&(+&$'($$(%,5'>)++'..

..:?D..E,5'),5'&()+&(82(3,&&'
(&	&&)	,"3(9

9 09D'(
  

+&70.../,5'$(#'7)"&(&((&'


(&	&&)*()&(+&,&$&'&'*()&(+&$'(()(5&'5,)$#($()&,5'##5&'&&'%())($&'')8)&&%&)$7(&',5'$,,#&3(&)))2(#&'() (5'&),&'$&&(#,)  	+ ,5' ##5 &'& &' %())( $&)&(%8 ++(5 "( +&) $ %#)&&( ##5#8+%%(&&78,5'('(%$(&(#(2(#&($&'*,=+))#,)$&',&&'!%%&'&'(5,$'7)#($3)&'##5(#$$$+&(2))()&+ $ +,)# & &(# ( 2(#&( $ &' 	(A&'!%%&  ' ()&(+& +,& ))(5 &' +) & %5()&&B,53'7,8...+%%&'(#$,5'>)"&(&(,5'$(#7B+&()&&'%5()&&B,5>) "&!,5,)&...&'()&(+&+,&'#5,%&&'+#(%)(2#2(5&'')8&)&(%8&'+&)2(+

2%700...&'()&(+&+,&()),"((

  8(5 ,5' '7) #($  &' +#(%)++(5&'')8&)&(%8&'%())($"(7+&)2(+'()&(+&+,&#)B+&%)&$,5'>) 5,%&) ++(5&'($$+&(2 ))()&+$+,)# +#(% 7,&   2(&(8 '(5 &&%( 3'&' &(# +,)# ' )&&5(+ )) $$(#(5&7&(("&%&#'#&'A%(&($7(##3(52(&(8'(5*+%7905()&& 4,5;5:(%7&()),  "&(3'(+' ' +%% &' (# $ ,5'>) ($$+&(2))()&+$+,)#+#(%+'90&'()&(+&+,&()),(&)"(("&(55()&&4,5:(%7&>)"&+%%&(

'()&(+&+,&()),+&($(+&$""#7(#(&8)&

&'()),)6G3'&'H,5'>)I$#+)&(&,&(#(5'&)32(#&78&'(&,+&($&'+&)&)&(%878&'(&,+&($')8&)&(%878&'$(#,$'()+,)# & %2 $  ("& H")8+'#5(+#IA%(&($&'2(+&(%J+&700&'(),&

  ( ,5'>) ""#(+&( $ ""#7(#(&8)&&'%((5(




	


""#$'7)"+

++#,)() $ &' ()&(+& +,&$((5)$+#D/&'(00E@ 00EG'&'()&(+&+,&#"&(&(>) )&& &(#  &%(&()$$+&32(3$((5))3##J

"#$$%

' %

+,),5'>)'7)"&(&(

../(&()),7B+&&&'"2()($$+&(2*&'=#&8!+&$.	&&0D../EDG!*=!J!"(#0../ !

D.. E@"
0?
!*=!

""#(+&($3(&$'7")3'()(++&",),+& 7 5& 3(&' )"+&B,(+&  &' %(&) ( B,(+&(6GDE),#&(&(2#2,)7#)&7#()'##3)&,&$&'
(&	&&)@D0&'&3)7),",)&'$+&)(#(5'&$&'2(++,&"+(5J

"00..0?
	C009DEE((5)$
 

9

"),%++&+7+&2#83'&''7)"&(&()'3)78+#+2(+(52(+&'&&')&&+,&>)$+&,#$((5)3,)0?
	C009DEDE@#0/./0./ D/&'(0EG'()"),%"&($++&))#)""#()&&' $+&,# $((5)$ )&&""##&+,&7)&')&&&(#+J#0/.&/ D+(&(5#

.
	9.9/ D.?EE


#90.
	/0D0E&'	,"%

,& #7& ," &' )& $ 2(3 ,C009DEA"#((5&'&)&&+,&+()(()G+&8&J+##8)&7#()'$##3G($&')&&+,&(2)& ++#,)( "")(& & &'& +' 78 &'() ,&  F,)&($#3($&')&&+,&+()+)($$&'&'(),&'))&$%&(##8(()&(5,()'7#$+&)J 90.
	 &!G,)7#""#(+&(J$+##8)&7#()'$##3++,)3'G&')&&+,&(&($() &' ++& 52(5 #5# "(+("# $% &'(),&>)+()(7,&,)7#8""#()&'&"(+("#&&'$+&)$&'"()>)+)J$@#0/.

&/. %8&2&,)&&+,&+()(,#))3&%(&'&&'""#(+&($	,"%,&"+&3) 7B+&(2#8 ,)7# # 0/.  & /.,&'%G+##8)&7#()'$##3J$)&G&''#(5))"")&&'(+&$H&'	,"%I,&>)+()())$&'&(%$&'#2&)&&+,&+()(J#90.
	&0@0??&?9'2+5(K'32&'&!*=!)&F,(&'&&'	,"%,&G%,)&'2"2(,)#8+(&'28+)&'+,&')7$(&J0??&

?9##8)&7#()'#3G+%")))%&'B,)&7(5'&#( ,#) #( 3 78 &' ,&  
& #) +##8(+#,) #5# "(+("#)  )&) ,+(& ( &',&>)+()()J$


 *%
+ $$$

,5'5,)&'&'()	(A&'!%%&+$&&((5'&)

3 2(#& 3' &' &(# +,& ##3 $, ,#&)

/  

%XJK DOVR DUJXHV WKDW WKH WULDO FRXUW 

ZKLFK -RQHV H[SUHVVHG KHU RSLQLRQ WKDW DEXVH DQG WKDW WKLV HUURU YLRODWHG WKH &RQFRXUW GLG QRW LVVXH D FHUWLILFDWH RI D#8,5'(&'4)L&4&'&&)&($8)&,&7(++(5&'7,)78'#8&)&($(&'&,5'G&,+''+&)#+,#&),)&(,
-' *$

#8,5'7(>)%&'

)&&>) $()& 3(&))  #8 +2)&(3(&'7((4,8'&'&'$&'%#)&'6

	'&#%&'&')-'&HI,''#))-'&),+)'(')(&'&)')$'(%",&'()"(2&)5&'%,

'&(#+,&2,#')8

7( &)&($( $& #8 

&'$$754)7($&3&8&3)))()&'$,5'>)%#)&&(6

HI'2(&2(3"&+# F,)&()  )' &# &,+'''"(2&"&)"&,"()($'&'''%'),+-'(+%,&

' &(# +,& 2,#  '&)&(%8
 

 

$FFRUGLQJO\ WKH FODLP LV QRW EHIRUH WKLV &RXUW 6HH 9DOHQWLQH Y )UDQFLV )G   WK &LU 

* &' 3' "$%  "'8)(+# A%(&( $

7( ( 7,8 .?. #) &)&($( ) & 7(>))&&%&)++(5'$&'>))A,#7,)*&')&&&'&G7('&#%,'('33)
>##B,)&F,&&'()&'&M*8&,+'%8"(2&)>	&&(5(&M'""#&)$&(%)(&'7&'% (%%%8>)7>J*&'$,&'&)&($(6

	' #) )&& G*8&,+'%8"(2&)3(&''()"(2&)J#))&&(&',&')##'33)
>%(5'
')'#))&&G&'&8&#%&",&%8%,&''()"(2&)J3'
)-'3'&&'&3)#(-)')(B,(++%,&$(&')5(3'A+&3)
'3'
)-'3'&')&'(5)''"")')&&'3&'8'"")')&&G'%%)(&'()#"'8'""(&'7&'&,7(&')'3)3##)(&'7J

'&(#+,&2,#7B+&()&&'()&)&(%8)3##

(##8$$75)+(#)2(+)),"2()%"#8

78 &' ## ,&8 *"&%& $ ,% 	2(+)&)&($(&3'&7('&#'$$75"&(+("&(&'(2)&(5&($,5'>)+)(&2(37(&&'(2=#(+)&&((4,8.?.('$$(+(7,8.?.
&'$()&(&2(37((&&##$$75$8)A,#7,)
&')+(&2(33'(+'3)2(&"7(,)&%(+##8++&##)&8 7)   ",""& & )+(7 &' )A,# 7,)$$75&)&($(&'&6

!&&'&&(%7(&#,'%)&&3(&'&'##)&'&,'' $&''&,+''"(2&"&)  	'%)&&&%&'&&'+'(#$%###3)",&&"$&'%###=(&&'&)'',))7&'&',#&%###,#&%#&%(+##8++&##

?  

&' +'(# $%### 
'%)&&3(&'&'##)&'&(&)%,&'&'%#"()	&'&3'2&'+'(#$%# &' ,#& %# "() &'& $&'>)"()3'2'

' &(# +,& 2,# ,%())(7(#(&8$&'()&)&(%8

),"F,)&((5,(5

+,&+#7(+%"&&&'2(57%+%"&&&',5'%,+'$'A%(&()(&&(5'%&'>)#")&&"(2&)J&'&&'()'""	'(&&)&($827##8&'$&78(5''$$(%&(2#8

N6-8!3'8,)8"(27(O'&"&$8,78!D)")EN *( )%&'(5 #) '""8&'(5#)&'&%(5'&'2'!D)")EN-8*(8'28,&,8,%%7O!D)'EN28,ͮ#)!D)'8)EN*8,-3(&'4)O<>&8,O!D)'8)EN*(8,&##(&'7,&3'!D)'8)EN-8*(8,&##%%%8!D)'8)EN*(8,&##,'8,-3!D)")E
 

.

N * 8, %%7 5(5 ," &  7(5 ')"(&# (!-O!D)'8)EN*(8,&#-&+&&'O!D)'8)EN)(&%+&3%+&O*8,%%7O!D)'EN-8*(8,&##&'&+&3'&'""&8,O!D)'8)EN'8,&#(&'3'&'""&8,(8,&##(&'&'&,&'O!D)'8)EN!3'8,&#%%%83'&'""&8,(8,&##%%%8&'&,&'O!D)'8)EN!3'8,&#&'()+&3'&'""&8,(8,&##&'&,&'O!D)'8)EN*8,%%73'&'()'""7(8,%%73'&'""O!D)'8)EN-8!+8,&##,)8&'(5%7,&(&O!D)")EN*8,%%78,&3&&&##,)3'&'""O!
>&%%7N<,>& %%7 -8'8,&#-&(&'4)(8,%%73'&'""O!D)'8)EN!3'8,&#-&%%%8(8,%%73'&'""O!D)'8)EN-8!3'8,&#-&&'+&(!-(8,%%73'&'""O!D)'8)E,5'>)&&8&'+))A%(7(7(52

27#)3)&%)&$&'F,)&()")&'+))A%(&(%)ͮ)',55(5')',#)6

  

N*8, %%7 2&##(3'&8,3&#-(5&H&')&!D	',5))',#)EN*8,%%7&##(5'8,8O!D	',5))',#)EN'38,3'8,&3'&8,8(O!!&'%N''8O!!&'%N!&'%-8*(8,&##'""O!D	',5))',#)EN*(8,&##8,5%-3O!D	',5))',#)EN7(')878)-8'&&'+&&87!D	',5))',#)EN)878)-8,&)8,8O!D	',5))',#)EN)8782"%()($8,)8)%&'(57,&8,!D	',5))',#)EN <, >& -3O  ) 8&'(5$8,($8,)8)%!D)'EN7(
3&8,&&'(-#$%-8O
3&8,&&'()',#))3(8388,&'(-(5+"O*8,#!D)'8)E
'())&&+,&""#,5'

++(57(>),&$+,&)&
  

')8&'&&'%())($),+'&)&(%8),#&((#$'()	(A&'!%%&(5'&&+$&3(&)))5()&'(%	"+($(+##8,5'+&&'&&'&)&(%8) & 7(>) ,&$+,& )&&%&) 3) & %())(7#,&'')8A+"&( $A+(&,&&+)')8)&&%&)$"((&($(+&( 
(&(,5'5, &'& &' )&&%&) $ 4) * &' $$753&%())(7#,&'%(+#(5)()A+"&(&&'')8,#

'A+(&,&&+A+"&(+($(('(2(+

,#?D0E"2()&'&G)&&%&#&(5&)&&#(52&+(&(%3'(#&'+#&3),&')&))$A+(&%&+,)78&'2&+(&(J()&A+#,78&',#5()&')8+,2

9,' ?D0E

,5'5,&'&7(>))&&%&),5'3&A+(&,&&+)7+,)&&'&(%7(%&')&&%&)&'3))&&#(52&3'(+'3,#'2",+ 2,) A+(&%&  ' )&& ""#) +,&B+& &'() 5,%&  ((+& &'& &' A+"&(""#(  ' )&& ""#) +,& & &' G+# B,(+(#&('(&+5(K#(7#(K&($&'F,(%&)$  A+(& ,&&+ 3' ""#( & 8,5 +'(#2(+&(%(K78)A,#)),#&)J..:?&P

'+,&#)()+,))9?0/

/ D'(&!"".?/E(3'(+'&''(""#)+,&&&'G#(%(&$#+&(2"3)J$&'8#&'#+-$%&(2$#+&(2+"+(&()&"2(+&&'+(+,%)&+)$&&+-)),""&(5&'&,)&3&'())$+'(#>)+%%,(+&()&&')!++(5&&')&&""#) +,&&' $+&)$,5'>) +)"###&')(

H5I(2&'$+&&'&&'+'(#3)$&8)#+-)"'()&(+&&(#-3#57,&)A,#+&)&'&&')&&%&3)+7&78"'8)(+#2(+$ "&&( $ &' 2(+&(%>) 25(  &'& &'$& 3) ' $&' &' )&&%& % 78 &'2(+&(% & ' %&' +&( ),$$(+(& ((+( $#(7(#(&8&B,)&($8(&)%())(78&'&(#+,&

0  


..:?&P'$+%,)&7++&&',#(5,'(#3$@0D'(.?.ED)&&(5&'&G&'( &%((5 3'&'  & %())(7#,&')"&,)&' ')8 ,# HA+(& ,&&3' ),+'+()( "")&7&',5'&'2(3(5+,&3+()(JE

')&&""#)+,&#)B

&' &)&(%8 3) (%())(7# )&&%&) $ "( (&($(+&(?D*EDED+E)&&)&'&G)&&%+#&&)&($()&&(#&(&($(+&($") )$+(+,%)&+) %)&& &' (&($(+&(J+,2

9,' ?

&'& &'() A+"&( 3) ("")&&%&)3&%)$&&'""&&7(3)&)&&%&)&&(#(&%')&&""#)+,&&&'&&'990&0&'() ,# & %(&  +'(#>) )&""&&$+'(#7,))&&""##&+,&F,&&'

"((&($(+&(&'&()$,$##),&)(&'')8,#($(&(&($( (&' & &(#   '),7B+&&+))A%(&(,(&($(+&()&&%&&'&F,)&()7,&&'"2(,)+(&()%&&'B,5"( (&($(+&( #(7# &'+#&+7%(&&&&(& 3'%  ( 3') ")+%
  

7KH VWDWH DSSHDOV FRXUW IXUWKHU KHOG WKDW GXH WR KHU WHQGHU DJH

5RELQ¶V VWDWHPHQWV WR 'U %RWKQHU GLG QRW TXDOLI\ XQGHU WKH KHDUVD\H[FHSWLRQ IRU VWDWHPHQWV PDGH IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI PHGLFDO GLDJQRVLV RUWUHDWPHQW FRGLILHG LQ 2KLR (YLGHQFH 5XOH  EXW WKDW WKH\ ZHUHDGPLVVLEOH XQGHU 2KLR (YLGHQFH 5XOH 'F 7KH FRXUW H[SODLQHGWKDW WKH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW KDG VWDWHG WKDW LQ FHUWDLQ FLUFXPVWDQFHV5XOH 'F ZDV SUHIHUDEOH WR 5XOH  DV D PHDQV RI DGPLWWLQJVXFK VWDWHPHQWV %RVWRQ  1(G DW  7KH 2KLR 6XSUHPH

&RXUW VXEVHTXHQWO\ KDV PRGLILHG LWV HYLGHQFH UXOHV DQG LWV GHFLVLRQ LQ

%RVWRQ 6SHFLILFDOO\ WKH FRXUW KDV HOLPLQDWHG WKH ULJLG PRWLYDWLRQDOUHTXLUHPHQW RI 2KLR (YLGHQFH 5XOH  LQ FDVHV LQYROYLQJ \RXQJFKLOGUHQ 6HH 6WDWH Y 'HYHU  1(G   2KLR 

6XEVHTXHQW GHFLVLRQV LQ WKH 2KLR DSSHOODWH FRXUWV DOVR KDYH H[SUHVVHGGLVDSSURYDO RI WKH OLEHUDO LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI 2KLR (YLGHQFH 5XOH'F LQ FDVHV LQYROYLQJ \RXQJ FKLOGUHQ 6HH HJ 6WDWH Y 7XUYH\

 1(G   2KLR &W $SS  ,Q DGGLWLRQ VLQFH %XJK¶VWULDO WKH 2KLR /HJLVODWXUH HQDFWHG (YLGHQFH 5XOH  ZKLFK WRRN HIIHFWLQ -XO\  WR JRYHUQ WKH DGPLVVLRQ RI KHDUVD\ WHVWLPRQ\ LQ FKLOG DEXVHFDVHV

$ DF,&(5  99 0 & 0/ E  !$&

+,&(5 7(>) &)&(%8 &'& G*8 &,+' %8"(2&)J  ' 27# )")) ( &' $% $(5 ' ' $$(%&(2#8  5&(2#8 & 2(,)F,)&() ") & ' ++(5 &' )&&%&) )' '%&')&&""#)+,&)&&&'&

H&I'&(#+,&'2(5'&'&)&(%85(5&'(&($(+&($,(&&7#(7#%(&&(&'+'(#2(+&(%&)&($(&&(#()"&)%$&'#(%(&F,)&()")78$)+,)#5(5')&&%&,(5+))A%(&(3(&'&'%(3'(+'$,8#+'(#+,#7A"+&&+&&+,&%""+&&)&($85(5)A,#+&""&&,"'78'$&'

$&P9."#$' *$


 '() '7) "&(&(,5' ))&&'& &'&)&(%8

++(57(>))&&%&)78##$,$&'3(&)))

  

3) (%())(7# ')8  &'%(&&(5(&,5'$,&'+&(2(#&($'()	(A&'!%%

'	(A&'!%%&"2()

##+(%(#")+,&()&'++,)& 7 +$& 3(&' &' 3(&2167 % Q
'$

+))(#8 "'(7(& &' %())(5()&+(%(#$&2),+')&&%&)%(5'&7&',5'&$&'#,)J$')+"$&'$&&(#&'5#,#"'(7(&(5')G7)&'%())($)%2(%())(7#,A+"&(&&'

' ()&(+& +,& ++#, &

(5'&)3&2(#&7+,)+))A%( 7(  &' 37(>),&$+,&)&&%&)%?
	()),  
  &' 	,"%$&&(#,))&7&$+,&)&&%&)$(&($(+&(7+,)$%%8#))& A"#(&($(+&(  ? 
	 & 99.A"#(&'&&'$&&(

 $ $$+&(2 +))A%(&( &'& () $$+&(2 (3'&2 A&& &' $) %

DF,&(5&'?0
""&,(&8()&(G3'+,&7#($7,&(),7#& +7#($J$!++(5&&',$&')&'""&,(&8&73(&))> 7() '() #+- $ + 8)(5'&  2    &' 28%%8J$@ (000 D.?9E D" +,(%E D'#(
  9

7KH 5REHUWV &RXUW ILUVW VWDWHG WKDW WKH SURSRQHQW JHQHUDOO\ PXVW

GHPRQVWUDWH WKDW WKH ZLWQHVV LV XQDYDLODEOH  86 DW  +RZHYHU WKH6XSUHPH &RXUW VXEVHTXHQWO\ OLPLWHG WKLV XQDYDLODELOLW\ UHTXLUHPHQW WRFDVHV LQ ZKLFK WKH RXWRIFRXUW VWDWHPHQWV LQLWLDOO\ ZHUH PDGH LQ WKHFRXUVH RI D MXGLFLDO SURFHHGLQJ 6HH :KLWH Y ,OOLQRLV  86  



#,)3)&2(#&3'A"&3(&))3'&)&($()&'()"((+,#&+##+&&'7)(),"3'(+'''$%&'&"((E,&'( &',&A"#(&'&6

' $&&( #,) (+#,)  5,& &'&283(&))+##78&'")+,&(3(##$($%5(2(5 &)&(%8 &'& () % 78 $5&$,#))+$,)(2)(&'+&8&'$&&(#,)()5##8)&()$(3'&'$)()5(2$,##  $( ""&,(&8 & "7  A") &')($(%(&()&',5'+))A%(&(&'78+##(5&&'&&&($&'$+&$(&'))$5(2(5)+&3(5'&&&'3(&))>&)&(%8

 
	&000 ',& $,&'()"(+("#

""#(F,##8(&'+)$,&$+,&)&&%&)?
	&99.

'  ')8 +#& ) & &)&($8 ( +,& &'

	,"% ,& ') )& $&'  )& $ &%((53'&' &' %())( $ ')8 )&&%&) 2(#&) &'$&&(#,)
)&',&)&&

&'&,&$+,&)&&%&()%())(7##8($(&7)F,&((+($#(7(#(&8?
	9//9D.?E '

,&#&A"#(&'&338)(3'(+')'3(5$#(7(#(&8%87%&6G#(7(#(&8+7($3(&',&%(+)3'&'2(+$##)3(&'($(%#8&')8 A+"&(  
 &' +)) &' 2(+ %,)& 7A+#, & #)& 7)&  )'3(5 $ "&(+,#(K5,&)$&,)&3&'())J$&//@ $. 
	?9? 0D..ED#7&(5,"&'F,(%&)$&'&3"5),+()E

/  


'32&'	,"%

&&'#(7(#(&8#8)()G+## $ 3'  ')8 +#),7B+&&,)&(+&+))A%!++(5#8$&$((5&'&()&(+&+,&'#&'&,5'>)+2(#&7+,)7(3)")""&,(&8 & +))A%( 3(&)))

,5'+&)&'&&'()&(+&+

&7$&&(#,)2(#&)&($(3)),7B+&&+))&'&&'")+,&(>)+)3)2)(# &)&(5 &'& () &' +(%(#"+(5)J

D..E&'&7(3)&(A%(&( )&' )&&%&)()&(+& +,&>) #(+  DE3)+(7$7

D0E  (2#2  ,#& 3"7#%)3'(#*,5'+&)&'&*((+( $ #(7(#(&8 3 )&&%&) ""#8 & 7 %(&&)&&%&) #+- &' G"&(+&,)&3&'())JF,($%

';2%&5,)&'&&'

"%(&&' ')8&)&(%8() (++&""#(+&($+##8)&;2%& 5,) &'&  +)()&& 3(&' &'& +()( &'#,) 2(#&( 7+,)7(&+))A%( 2 ($ ' )"27#!++(5&&';2%((+&&'&)''+##+#5,)&&'3(&))3')%
   

/	()$ $


 !*=!, 2(3()#(%(&& (F,(8(&

3'&'&')&&+,&+()()3+&8&(2#2,)7# ""#(+&() $ +##8 )&7#()' 	,"%,& "+&  ' )&& ""#) +,& ( & (&($8+&##(5	,"%,&"+&2A"#(+(,#&'&&'%())($&'')8)&&%&)(&2(#&&'$&&(#,)
),+'+(+,%)&+)3'2'#&'&&'G),#&$)&&+,&>)+()(+&#)3'&')&&+,&$(#)&A"#((&))(5J#
99//9?9D/&'(0ED+(&(5"00

&.E,&'%(),+'+(+,%)&+)3'2'# &'& G&' M+&8 &> &' &' &' M,)7#""#(+&(>"5$C009DEDE52)7+,)&')&&+,&M(&)&'	,"%,&$(,)7#""#(+&(++(&($8&'52(5#5#"(+("##8 & ,)7#8 ""#8 &'& "(+("# & &' "&(+,#$+&) $ &' +) & '>J  #
 9  & 9?/DF,&(5(0  00 D/&'(0EE',)(2(3(5,5'>)$&&(#,)+#(%3$+,)&'),#&$&')&&+,&+()(&&%(($(& 3) +&8 & +##8 )&7#()' 	,"% ,&"+&

+&)8&'&&'),#&$&')&&+,&>)+()(

3)+&8&+##8)&7#()'	,"%,&"+&'(#&'	,"%,&')&))+)3(&'$+&)(&(+#&&')(&'()+)(&',&+##8'#

&'&&'$&&(#,)5,&)#8&'""&,(&8$+))A%(&(&'&&'#,)()&2(#&78&' %())( $ ')8 2(+ 3' &' 3(&))>)%%8$(#)&&(#',&(&&(&)"2(,))&&%&) (    
	 & 00 &'& G&'$&&(#,)()5##8)&()$(3'&'$)()5(2$,##$(""&,(&8&"7A")($(%(&() H(3(&))>)&)&(%8%%8I&',5'+))A%(&( &'78 +##(5 & &' &&&( $ &'$+&$(&'))$5(2(5)+&3(5'&&&'3(&))>&)&(%8J?
	&99?'(#+,)#>)+))

?  A%(&( $ 7( %8 & )3)7(%8&'2),,(5'"2(,))&&%""&,(&8 & A") ),+' ($(7(>) 8,&'  #+- $ %%""&,(&8&7)27(>)%B,8&3(&)3++#,)() 3(&))  !) &' 	,"% G3")2(#7#&(%",5&'%%8#))()))&3(##$ +),++)) 7,& ),++))$,# +))+)&(&,&(#5,&J$&9&'+$&&((5'&(&($(77)&()$((&'()+)67(+,&  +$& &' ++,)+%"&&&&)&($8&)&($(&'$,##""&,(&8$+&%" &' B,5 B,8  ,5' 3%78#5,5))'


	&?9

,&'%&',& 

5)))+(&3(&'')8A%( $ (&' ((+( $ 5,&)$&,)&3&'())3'+))A%(&(6

&&'(- ),+' (F,(')8 +#& () ")& ,)&(+&+))A%(&(,&+5(K(H*+

D. EI &' &(&(# "&+&(A%(&(""&,(&8$3(&))> % )&()$8F,(%&)

?
	&9/',)&'((F,(&%(&&')&&%&)&"+&'))&7#()'+&
  .

7R XVH WKH 0DU\ODQG SURFHGXUH WKH WULDO MXGJH ILUVW PXVW KDYH

GHWHUPLQHGWKDW LQFRXUW WHVWLPRQ\ ZRXOG FDXVH VHULRXV HPRWLRQDO GLVWUHVVWR WKH FKLOG 3VXFK WKDW WKH FKLOG FDQQRW UHDVRQDEO\ FRPPXQLFDWH ́ ,G

7KH SURFHGXUH DOORZHG D FKLOG WR EH H[DPLQHG DQG FURVVH[DPLQHG LQ DVHSDUDWH URRP RXWVLGH RI WKH GHIHQGDQW¶V SK\VLFDO SUHVHQFH ZKLOH D YLGHRPRQLWRU GLVSOD\HG WKH WHVWLPRQ\ LQ WKH FRXUWURRP ZKHUH WKH MXGJH DQG

B+&&'5,%&&'&()(""#(+7#7+,)

(& (2#2  ,#& &' &' +'(# 3(&)) 3' '%%8"7#%)&&(#',&(&#(%(&(&)

'#(5 & +)) (2#2(5 ,#& 3(&)))  
 $+& &'+,&) '2 ""#( &' ,# (  ( +)) (2#2(5

8,5+'(#
%" .??.D&'(...E@%-9.  9D?&'(..9E@**..0//D9&'(..E@.(???0D&'(.?.E

!)3(&'()+)&')+,&)$+)(&,&()3'&'8,5 +'(# +&,##8 &)&($(  3) ),7B+& & +))A%(&(  &' +,&) '2 +5(K &'& %#8"#+(5  +'(#  &' 3(&)) )& ) & #(%(&$&&(#,)++)
%


.0  D?&'(..E'(#&'%"'8)(+#")+$+'(#2(+&(%&'3(&)))&)&+))(#8#(%(&$&&(#,)++)33(##&)+5,))&')&&+,&&(#B,5>)&%(&(&'&7(3)%&,,5'&&)&($8&7+))A%(,)#'&'""&,(&8&+))A%(7(&'()""&,(&8)2&)&()$8,5'>)+$&&((5'&)7(>)(7(#(&8&+##%8$&'&(#)),,(5')&&%&))&#,)&++#,&'3()?
	&99?

!#&',5'3#)()53(&',5'>)+&&(&'&&'

'#(5)$*% #2&&,5'>)

+)3$(&'&(82&&'),#&$&')&&+,&+()(')&2(#&&',#))&7#()'(&')+))*(2#2+'##5&8#)&&,&8"+,&'&##3B,5&+(27838+#)+(+,(&()(&'&)&(%8$+'(#3(&))##5&7&'2(+&(%$7,). 
	&?'	,"%,&

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


&'	,"%,&'

')8 )&&%&) 7,& ##5+#& &  A%((5 "$&>)(5'&),&'$+)&')&&&(#+,&'&
  0

#2(+&(%3)&+"7#$&)&($8(5&&(#. 
	&?.')&&&(#+,&'%(&&&')&&%&),
'>) )(,# ')8 A+"&(  ' 	,"% ,&2) $& &%((5 &'& &' 	&& ' & %& (&)7,$"2(5&'&&'+'(#>))&&%&)7),$$(+(&((+( $ #(7(#(&8 & 3(&')& )+,&(8 , &'$&&(#,)$&?/',&'#&'&
'>)

)(,#')8A+"&(3)&G$(%#8&')8A+"&(J $ $&&( #,) ",")) 7+,) (&G++%%&)  '+ ()&+) ( 3'(+' )&&%&) &&'3()$##(53(&'(+5(K')8A+"&(%(5'&2&'#))7),$$(+(#(7#&7%())(7#&&(#J$&? 	&&%&)%(&&",),&&&'()A+"&(G&'$&)'&')%&(&($#(7(#(&8&'&),""&)&'%())(7(#(&8$)&&%&),$(%#8&')8 A+"&(J  $  ' ,& &' A"#( &'&

"&(+,#(K 5,&) $ &,)&3&'()) #) %8 7%)&&$%&'&&#(&8$&'#2&+(+,%)&+)&'&),,&'%-(5$&')&&%&)&'&&'+#&"&(+,##83&'8$7#($$&?.

'(#(&()&,&'&*$+&,##8)(%(#

&&'()+)(&'&7&'+))(2#2+'(#-8$+&()&(5,()')&'()+)$%7&'*7(

+$& &' ++,) ( +,&  3) ),7B+& &,)&(+&+))A%(&(,&'%&'%())($ 7(>) ')8 )&&%&) 3) & +&8 & &''#(5)(*  * ( &(2#2&'%())( $ ')8 )&&%&) &',5' &' &)&(%8 $&' 3(&)))    $ 90 
	 / 9?

D..0EDA"#((5&'&G*(2#2#8&'F,)&($3'&  "+,)  +)&(&,&(##8 F,( &5,&$&>)+$&&((5'&+3(&))()&)&($8(5JE@,##0 

D?&' ( 0E D&(5 &'& * (2#2 (+,&&)&(%8&'&',&$+,&+#&()E&'&',& '#&'&&'7)+$$+&$++$&&((& +)&(&,&  $&&( #,) 2(#&( 3' &'&'#%&)$&'+$&&((5'&3)&()$("" $((5 ' 7 % ) & &' +))(&8 $

00  )$5,) & "&+& &' 3#$. 
	&?990

A+"&( ( & )&()$8 &' ')8)&&%&)&)&()$8&'$&'()('327(3)"& +))A%(&(  
 ),+'  #(7(#(&8 $ &' )&&%&) () $&&( #,)   !++(5#8,*

$7(>))&&%&)3)&+	,"%,&"+&

 ' 

' )+()),""#()

2(+ ++(5 )(%(# ,%#)&&(78,5'2(#&,5$,%&##8$(&(#

' 2(+ & ()), ++

")+,&( 3(&)))  ()& )(A)+(7(+(&&'&++,,5'3)	&,&>))&"$&'',)'#!&&(#	&,&&)&($(

N*,(5&'&(%&'&8,#(23(&'&'$&()%&'(&'$&O!<N!8,>2((+&&'&8&(%O!	(AN!3'(&'()'""O!*($$&"&)$&'',)N8,&##&'B,8"#)('""O!##,'')&(+-%8"()(%-%",&'()(%8%,&'7N3%8&(%)(&'()'"!
##8>&+>&)8
  0

N&'&(%O!<)N	2#&(%)O!<')+3(&))3'&)&($(&,5'>)"(7+&)

3)*(+-'%)'%)3''%"#8,5')'8%&'())(++$&,5'$&'%)>),5'&2#&'&,5'')A,##87,)''&(# +,& ( & ##3 '%) & &)&($8 ) & 3'& '(),5'&')(7,&,5'7,&(##3'%)&#&3'& 3) )( ( &' +$&&( 7&3 &' &3 %'%)&)&($()$##3)6

N 
>% )-(58, 3'&8,&#&'$&'""&8,,5'&O!'&)''7&,+')A,##8,','','&'7&'&&&'&&&&##8787,& 3'& 7,& 3'& 3&   &'& &'() ''"",%7$++)()N())")3'8,#&&'&&'(%3)3'&O!)")(&(2#8&'&3)3'&"+("(&&)8(5&'&'$#&##877,&&')(&,&('),5'&+,)#(5  ),+' ) &'&  #) &'& ' ')"5&(2#8&'2(5%8&'&),'8&'&)$'%

' &(# +,& 2,# 7B+&() & &' &' +&)&)&(%8$((5&'&'%)>)	&,&>)&)&(%83)%())(7#,'(2(+#3&'&&'$)'",&&'(&(&8$&'))(#&&()),'&(#+,&#)"2(#(%(&(5()&,+&(()&,+&(5&'B,8&'&&'2(+$,5'>)"(7+&)+,#7+)(G&&%(&'A()&+$",")%&(2)+'%"#)8)&%7)+$%()&-++(&J7,&+,#G&7+)()8"$3'&)2&'&&'$&(8+&##5(&'((+&%&(&'()+)J(+&""# &' )&& ""#) +,& '# &'& &' 2(+ $)(%(#+&)3)%())(7#,'(#3..

: ? & P0  ,&'% &' +,& B+& &'

0  5,%& &'& ,5'>) "( +&)%())(7#7+,)&'#")(&("+#, ## &(#  #5(+# +$+(5""##&J$&P

'()&(+&+,&++,#

'7)#($2($&'"(+&)2(#&($'(#3GHI)()"+(##83(&' 5&&'%,),##8&+5(K7#($#'/ 0.9../0D/&'(

./0D.?E@ *#

D/&'(0E DG+,)&'()()+",) +()(  &  ""+2(+&(3&")),"M)&& #3 )"+(##8 ,#(5) 5A+#,)($ 2(+>J DF,&(500?0?/D/&'(.??EEE

&'#)) ,5' #) ##5

%(&&(2(#&($ $##2(+)2#8&%)&%J3))"B,(+(#&'&2(#&H'()I(5'&&$,%""#)+,&(&)),5, "+)) +#(%)  ' ()&(+)&(&,&(#+#(%)$((5&'&&')&&+,&+()()3+&""#(+&($+##8)&7#()'$),#&$&')&&+,&+()()),#& $ &') +()() () +&	,"%,&"+&#


'#&'&(&()&

'2(&(8,#(5())

(#$$,%&#$())&',)3&'7)#($*#  ' 00  9&'#))G+,&)M'2$(&'&2(#&M$,%&#$())
  09

 (# ... 0    ? D/&' ( ..E DF,&(5(   %  . 
	 0 90 D..EEG;##8)&&+,&2(&(8,#(5)+&()&&'#2#$,"+))2(#&(),#))&'8 M$$HI )%"(+("#$B,)&(+)&(&'&(&()+)+(+$,""#)&7-)$,%&#>J#00&990DF,&(5/++9?
	 D../EE


&'()+)&'%())($"(7+&)2(+3)

&+&8&+##8)&7#()'	,"%,&"+&' ()  +##8 )&7#()' 	,"% ,& "+&3'(+''#)&'&)&&2(#&),"+))78"%(&&(5"")(&82(+(&'$%$&'7+&)2(+
/,&'	,"%,&+#(&'#&'& &' %())( $ "( (B,8 2(+ 2(#& ,"+)) &',) 3&(5 '7) #($  90 
	 /0 9D..E',&)&&($&&&'&7+,)(&&+'&'()),(&A"))"(()&3'&')&!,#2(#&,"+))($(&"%(&&&',)$"(+(%)2(+&)'3"")(&8&+%%(&+'5+(%$& 992(
0?9
	99D./ E&'	,"%,&B+&&'5,%&&'&&'*, =+)) #,) F,() &' A+#,)( $ "B,(+(#2(+2&',5'#(%(&(5()&,+&()35(22#( )&& ",") () )2  $ & 9//  ' ,&+5(K &'& (& 3) & G ,#%-(5 5 $ &'"%,#5&($)&&,#)$+(%(#"+,!$ &' )"+($(+ "2()() $ &' )&(&,&( () &'(),&3(&'),+',&'(&8J$&9/'(#&'	,"%

,& ') )) 3'&' "( +&) &)&(%8 ()"%())(7# ,&' #,#) $ 2(+ 

*+%9.
	 0D.. E@"%  ?9 
	 /? D.??E (& ') & A"#(+())&'()),(+)&(&,&(#&%)!++(5#8&'()&(+&+,&++$,&'&&'()	,"%,&"+& &'& &' &(# +,&>) +()( +,# 7 %G+&8&J,!*=!

0/  

' 	$$ $

(##8,5'5,)&'&'()(5'

+,)# 3) 2(#& 3' '(),%7,5' $(#& ",), (A%(&($7((&$&)(K(5  ' 7 "5%##5&()

$&(#2%7..

("&A"&A%(&(3(&',&5&(58(5&'%),7%(&%),%$+%+#&'&(&3,#R#,&()&&(5G	($(&+>&7(,')78&'0 &'&'(&>)

,%7,5' &)&($( &'& ' '

"))(7(#(&8$7&((5")8+'#578)"-(53(&'+&&&''( 	&- ,&8 '(  ,%7'(%)#$3,#'2&+&+&&'A%  !++(5#8 ,%7,5' 2%7.'32,5'($3) ,7# & )+',#  &(%,%7,5'#&'&2#,&7$ &' &(# & ' +($,&'(&F,)&+&

(+&""#&')&&""

($$+&(2))()&+$+,)#+#(&2#,&,5'>)($$+&($##3

'	,"%,&)&,&&')&

 ($$+&(2 ))()&+ $ +,//
	//?D.?E)'3&'&&(#+,)#>)"$%/?   
 &' $()& "5 &"$%+ () G)7#8 $$+"&(&(%,)&)'3&'&&(#+
  0 

7#3  7B+&(2 )& $ )7#))  &'(F,(8 %,)& $+,)  G3'&' +,)#>) ))()&+ 3))7# +)((5 ## &' +(+,%)&+)J $ & /??G4,(+(#)+,&(8$+,)#>)"$%+%,)&7'(5'#8$&(#J$&/?.@*#
)*0/999D/&'(0EDG'+,&()&'&8+,& ""#8(5 &'() #8)() %,)&  ) 3(&' &%,)$+ & &(# +,)#>) +()()JE  ' ',&$,&'+,&(&'&G+,&%,)&(,#5)&5"),%"&( &'& +,)#>) +,+& $##) 3(&'( &' 3(5 $ )7# "$))(# ))()&+@ &'& () &'$& %,)& 2+% &' "),%"&( &'& , &'+(+,%)&+)&'+'##5+&( M%(5'&7 +)(),&(#)&&58>J$&/?.D+(&(5!9
	.D.99EE	+&'"&(&(%,)&)'3&'&&'$(+(&"$%+"B,(+&'$)3'(+'GF,())'3(5&'&+,)#>))3))(,))&"(2&'$&$ $(&(#&(#3') ),#&()#(7#J'//
	&/? @*#
)0/&99

!$&2(&(8'(5&'()),&'%5()&&

B,5()),"&+%%&(++#,(5&'&&'3)&&5(+))$+,)#>)+()(!$&2 2(3 &' ()&(+& +,& ++"& &' "& +%%&((,5'>)"&(&('()&(+&+,&A"#(6

),"'()A"(+(2)&(5&(!&&8,%7,5' +( &'&  ")8+'#5(+# A% $ &'2(+&(%3)&))&(#&&'$)&'!&&8,%7,5'$+,)'()$$&)#(%(&(5&'2(+&7 %(&& 5()&&'"&(&( ()+(&(5&'&)&(%8 $ &' 2(+&(%>) %&' &' "&(&(>) A3($& )'3&'&)''($#,+&'(,5'&>)##5&(),&2((+&(2))$%&'(2+,5'35,)&'&&'()&(+&+,&(++#,(5

&'&+,)#' )&&5(+ )) $ $(#(5&",),&'A%$,&'+&)&'&+,)#>)$(#,&",),&'

0?  

0DU\DQQ .RYDFK D OHJDO H[SHUW 

SV\FKRORJLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ ZRXOG QRW KVWUDWHJ\ ZHUH WR GLVFUHGLW 5RELQ¶V PRWKNQRZ ZKHWKHU WKH UHVXOWV RI DQ H[DP ZRXGHIHQVH $VNHG ZKHWKHU WKH IDLOXUH WLQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO .RYDFK \RXU WULDO VWUDWHJ\ LV WR PDNH LW ORRN OLNH WKVD\ WKDW PRP SODQWHG WKLV LGHD DQG ORRN QR ́ .RYDFK DOVR VWDWHG WKDW FRXUWV JUDVH[XDO DEXVH YLFWLPV RQO\ LQ H[WUDRUGLQDIRXQG EHFDXVH VXFK D UHTXHVW LV RXWVLGH WK ́ 6KH DOVR LQGLFDWHG WKDW D IDQWDV\ GHIPHGLFDO HYLGHQFH VKRZV DEXVHA%&F,)&+&(,++#(%)&'&&'+)&)'+()( 78 +,)#  &'& &'+&(,+3)3(&'(&'%((%$+,)#()5

,5'')&2+%&'G"

+(+,%)&+)&'+'##5+&),&(# )&&58>J',%7,5'((&(##8(2)&(5&&'")8+'#5(+#2#,&('&)&(&'()),3)"((&8)(+&'$3) & #(%(& &' 2(+ 5(#8,5'>)&)&(%8,%7'(&&'(-")8+'#5(+#A&'$)7+,)'(&73(&))
(&(,%7,5'&'3,#'2,)")8+'#5(+&7&(#()&'()+()(3'&' &' &)&(%8 3,# '$)  ' &' &(# B,5+%"&& & &)&($8 ,%7,5' ("&A%#8)G$% ( & #()&(+##8 &'(- &'5&';2%&#)"),""&&'5,%&&'&&'+()3))&&5(+
  0.

2($,5'+,#%)&&&'&+,)#>)"$%+

3)$(+(&'()+#(%$(#)7+,)'')&%)&&&'&'3)"B,(+78&'##5$(+(+8G!78 +,)# 2 ($ "$))(##8 ,)7# ) &3&)&&(5)(&'B,5%&$+(%(#"+(5($&''$$+&&'B,5%&J'//


	 & /.  G' $& %,)& )'3 &'& &' () )7#"77(#(&8&'&7,&$+,)#>),"$))(#)&'),#&$&'"+(53,#'27($$&! )7# "77(#(&8 ()  "77(#(&8 ),$$(+(& &,%(+$(+(&',&+%J$&/.

,5'')&%)&&)7#"77(#(&8&'&

7,&$+,)#>)##5($(#(5&$,&'",),7&( ("&")8+'#5(+# A%(&(&'B,83,#'2$,'(%&5,(#&8	"+($(+##8&'"'8)(+#2(+$)A,#7,)3,#'2"2&),++))$,#$) &'& 7( 3) $7(+&(5 &' 7,) ##5&()'()2(+((&(&&'&)&(%8$7(&'&'3(&)))  &' 2(+ $ "( +&) $ )A,# 7,)+%%(&&78,5',%(&'5,%&&'&&'3) )7#"77(#(&8&'&("&")8+'#5(+#A%(&($7(3,#+'5&'B,8>)2(+&

)F,&')&&+,&+()()&+&8&

+##8)&7#()'	,"%,&"+&

 


 &' )) )&& 72 3 	

 &' ()&(+&

+,&>)(#$'7)#($