5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	





1,7(' 	7$7(6 2) 0(5,&$

	





+$5/(6  $6+,'

$&. $6+,'


	



 !"#$%&'(!
)*'!+	'

$%'(!"'!%),*'%*-'$/

1231435()%6!''

%0.!+8.)!

,!-*+!+")+*#!+8,!-

:!$%!8		




*%-.*'.+0






	+="%+>*()=*-("%+/?.'*0
,/:*%&*)0("&/*-(*0")$% !#		
	 

, 	
  

/*-(*0")$% !##!!
+="%+>*()=:*%&*)0("&/*-(*0")*-("%+/?.'*0
,/?
	
; ?>  :*%&*)0("& /*-(*0") $% !##")'  !))*$!%  @!%!0%+ 		
	 

,		<,!'%*'/*-(*0")$% !##!!








?  	 *%-.*' .+0!  ,!$!)+")'

("%#!")+"-A"(*+" !"#'(!-)*-'*)")+!)'!)-!$'(!,*'%*-'.%'"-A #!+0.*#'B'-) *%"-B'-&&*'&)!B #".)+!%*)0 ")+ =" !)'!)-!+ ' 42 &)'(*)-"%-!%"'*) =*'( -%!+*' $% '*&! !%!+ '(%!! B!"%. !%*!+%!#!"!")+%!'*'.'*)$C1D3333333
)"E.%B'%*"#("%#!="$.)+0.*#'B")+-)*-'!+)$'(!-.)' "0"*)' (*&  ! =" !)'!)-!+ ' 94 &)'(*& %*)&!)'9B!"%. !%*!+%!#!"!")+%!'*'.'*)$C1D333333  ("%#! ")+ "-A "(*+ )= " !"# '(!*%-)*-'*)")+!)'!)-!(!" !"#=!%!-)#*+"'!+% '(! %!") '"'!+ 6!#= =! 	

 '(! ,*'%*-'

.%'7+!-**)




)  %*# 9 4 " 0%")+ E.%B *''*)0 *) '(! "'!%)

,*'%*-' $ /*-(*0") %!'.%)!+ " &.#'* #! -.)' *)+*-'&!)'"0"*)''(%!!6%'(!%"-A("%#!")+;!%0!"(*+")+'(!*%"''%)!B"-A(*#*)0*%*")(!*)+*-'&!)'"%!.'$"-(!&!#"%0!#B-"%%*!+.'6B"-A")+("%#!"(*+'+!$%".+*)!'%*) $%".+.#!)' 6.*)! !)'*'*! 6"!+ )"-'."#%)!"%#B-& #!'!+&.#'*&*##*)+##"%-)'%"-'$%'(!"#!$%"+"%6%"A*)0B'!&")+%!#"'!+%"+"%'!-()#0B;!%0! #!+0.*#'B'"#!!%-("%0!")+*)'*)#!+*)'(*" !"#


) '(! D3 ;!%0! "(*+ 	% '(! "(*+7 $"'(!%

*)!)'!+")".'&6*#!%"+"%6"!+="%)*)0B'!&=(*-(=.#+ ="%) $ *& !)+*)0 -##**)  !% '*&! ;!%0!

 

*)#! %-!!+$%& !-*$*!+*+%.0'%"$$*-A*)0")+%0")*F!+-%*&D22  
)  '(! &)!B #".) %-!!+$*##!0"#0"&6#*)0")+

'(! *)-#.*) $ 0"&6#*)0 $$!#".)+!%*)0 '"'.'! " G !-*$*(= -)-#.*!#B '("' ") $$(!"%'#")+&!%!#B6!-".!*'*)%"'(!% '(") +%.0 % %0")*F!+ &"B$-.%!6!"%'*-.#"6#!%0"&6#*)0 -"! +! )' '(%!")0%!"*&!+"' %!!)'*)06(=)")B>*'(.'&!(=G$ " A*)+ % ' " +!0%!! )-)*+!%"'*) 6B '(! 	!)'!)$%&.#"'*)0'(!0.*+!#*)!G9+ 2 D 1'( *% K9DD96'(!+*'%*-'-.%'(

29+"'D22?*A!=*!*)'(!-"!"'6"%=*%!.)+!%#B*)0 *##!0"# "-'**'*! '("' 0*.! ")+ 6'( $$!)! "%! *)-#".)+!%*)0'"'.'!"L !-*$*!+.)
	KD1-4(.'(!#".)+!%*)0+*+)'*)#! %-!!+%0")*F!+-%*&!*)'".$$*-*!)-)-#.+!'("' (* $$!)! =" .&)!B#".)+!%*)0.)+!%'(!;.*+.%'+*+)'!%%*)+!)B*)0"(*+.)+!%'(!$%".+0.*+!#*)!




%'(!%!")'"'!+"6!=!

'(!,*'%*-'.%')"## *)'
2  

7KH 7KLUG &LUFXLW KDV VLQFH FODULILHG WKH KROGLQJ RI 6PLWK

:KHUH PRQH\ ODXQGHULQJ LV QRW μPLQLPDO RU LQFLGHQWDO¶ DQG LVμVHSDUDWH IURP WKH XQGHUO\LQJ FULPH¶ DQG LQWHQGHG WR μPDNH LWDSSHDU WKDW WKH IXQGV ZHUH OHJLWLPDWH¶ RU WR IXQQHO PRQH\ LQWRIXUWKHU FULPLQDO DFWLYLWLHV  6 LV DQ DSSOLFDEOH JXLGHOLQH7KH JXLGHOLQH PD\ DOVR EH DSSOLFDEOH LI WKHUH LV HYLGHQFH WKDW WKHDFWLYLWLHV ZKLFK IXOILOOHG WKH EURDG VWDWXWRU\ UHTXLUHPHQWV IRUPRQH\ ODXQGHULQJ ZHUH H[WHQVLYH ZLWK GUXJ WUDIILFNLQJ RU RWKHUVHULRXV FULPH

8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y 0XVWDID  )G   G &LU  TXRWLQJ

8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y %RFNLXV  )G  UG &LU  ,Q WKLV FDVH LWFRXOG DOVR EH DUJXHG WKDW HYHQ LI WKLV &LUFXLW ZHUH WR DSSO\ 6PLWK LWV

UDWLRQDOH ZRXOG IDLO WR SURGXFH WKH UHVXOW GHVLUHG E\ 5DVKLG 7KH PRQH\ODXQGHULQJ LQ WKLV FDVH ZDV QRW PLQLPDO QRU LQFLGHQWDO DQG WKH PRQH\DSSHDUV WR KDYH EHHQ IXQQHOHG WKURXJK WKH FOLHQW WUXVW DFFRXQW LQ RUGHU WRPDNH LW DSSHDU OHJLWLPDWH DQG LQ RUGHU WR IXUWKHU WKH UDGDUWHFKQRORJ\IUDXG VFKHPH

+!-%*6!+ " " %.'*)! $%".+ -"! *) =(*-( '(! &)!B#".)+!%*)0"-'**'B="")L*)-*+!)'"#6B %+.-'M$"A*-A6"-A-(!&!219+"'933(!-.%'!N #"*)!+'("''(!!)'!)-*)0-.%'&.' !%$%&"L(!"%'#")+M")"#B*=(!)+!-*+*)0=("'0.*+!#*)!(.#+6!" #*!+=(!)+!-*+*)0=(!'(!%'+! "%'"'2!& ("*"++!+(.*)

%+!%'+!'!%&*)!=(!'(!%'(!&)!B#".)+!%*)00.*+!#*)!(.#+" #B'(!-.%'("+'+!'!%&*)!=("'-)+.-'="-)*+!%!+6B'(!	!)'!)-*)0&&**)'$"##=*'(*)'(!(!"%'#")+ $ '(! &)!B #".)+!%*)0 0.*+!#*)!  (! -.%'-)*+!%!+ '(! 	!)'!)-*)0 &&**)7 % !+"&!)+&!)'''(!&)!B#".)+!%*)00.*+!#*)!=(*-(=!%!%!E!-'!+6B)0%!")+L-)-#.+!H+I'("''(!	!)'!)-*)0&&**)*'!#$("*)+*-"'!+'("''(!(!"%'#")+$
		;K 	 * '(! &)!B #".)+!%*)0 "-'**'B -))!-'!+ =*'(!N'!)*!+%.0'%"$$*-A*)0")+!%*.-%*&!M"'933

(."(*+"%0.!'("'6!-".!'(*-"!+*+)'*)#!

+%.0'%"$$*-A*)0%%0")*F!+-%*&!'(!&)!B#".)+!%*)00.*+!#*)!=")'%!"##B&!")''" #B(*.%'(=!!%("%!E!-'!+'(!*+!"'("'")$$!)!*.'*+!$'(!(!"%'#")+$ '(! &)!B #".)+!%*)0 0.*+!#*)! &!%!#B 6!-".! *'

 

9566¶V VHFUHWDULHV WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH

GROODU 3FRQWUDFWV ́ VRPH RI ZKLFK ZHUH ZRXOG EH UHDG\ LI DQ LQYHVWRU FDPH LQWR ZLWQHVVHV IURP YDULRXV FRUSRUDWLRQV WHVIDOVH DQG FRQWDLQHG IRUJHG VLJQDWXUHV DXQGLVSXWHG WKDW WKH FRQWUDFWV GLG QRW UHDO

7KH 35R]LFK *URXS ́ DOVR LQFOXGHG 

%R\OH &KDUOHV :ULJKW DQG 5D\PRQG 6K

"(*+ 	% ")+ (* ) "-A -)'*).!+'%!$*)!'(! %+.-'*) '(! !"%#B 23 6.' (* )-& ")B O!(*-#! "+"% 	"$!'B ("%#!!%!+"'(!-& ")B7!)$"+&*)*'%"'*)")+"#!(! !-*$B;!%0!%7%#!*)'(!$"


)22'(!"(*+6%'(!%6!0"

")+ "-J."*)'")-! ' *)!' *'!-()#0B
)%+!%'=*)*)!'=.#++* #"B"%*.$%".+.#!)'+&*##*) +##"% L-)'%"-'M ")+  .% %'!+#B%! %!!)'!+"-'."#%)+!"#*)0=*'(#"%0!-% %"'*)

+-.&!)''(!6%'(!%=.#+"#"6.' '(!% #.-%"'*! L+!"#M *) &!'(+'(!"(*+ !%."+!+ ! #!'*)!'-)*+!%"6#!.&)!!%"="%!'.%))'(!*%&)!B*)!'&!)'6"-A

	'"%'*)0*)/"B22'(!$*%'0%

#!+6B	'!!)F*-((!*)!%!'.%) ) '(!*% *)!'&!)'  +-.&!)' %! %!!)'*)0 L+!"#M )"'*)"#-% %"'*)*)-#.+*)0;	*!&!)% %"'*):B3(*)!'% 6!-"&! -)-!%)!+ "6.&"'!%*"#*F!+ ")+ $*#!+ " -& #
  

&KLOLQJLULDQ VHUYHG DV WKH FRXQVHO IRU WKH 5DVKLGV DQG 9566 IURP

HLWKHU  RU  WKURXJK WKH GDWH RI WKH LQGLFWPHQW +H KHOG D ILIWHHQSHUFHQW VKDUH LQ 9566

$WWRUQH\ &KLOLQJLULDQ KDQGOHG WKH 9566 EDQNUXSWF\ SURFHHGLQJV7KH RWKHU PHPEHUV RI WKH 35XGGHU *URXS ́ ZHUH *DU\ 5XGGHU

9LFWRULD :HVWRQ DQG /HQ -DUURWW

7KH 3+D\GHQ+DOHN *URXS ́ FRQVLVWLQJ RI -RH +D\GHQ DQG 9LQFH

+DOHN OHDUQHG RI 9566 WKURXJK *DU\ 5XGGHU +D\GHQ SURYLGHG PRQH\WR WKH 5DVKLGV DQG DW WKH 5DVKLGV¶V UHTXHVW ZDV QRW HQWLUHO\ WUXWKIXO

,! "%'&!)'$&&!%-!
)!"%#B'(!!*)!'%")+'(!*%"''%)!B&!'=*'("-A"(*+")+'(!"(*+O		"''%)!B "-A(*#*)0*%*")' +!&")+'(!*% &)!B 6"-A(!B+*-.!+'(!L-)'%"-'M'("'("+$%&!+'(!6"*$%'(!*)!'&!)'(*#*)0*%*")$$!%!+"+!$".#'E.+0&!)'6.') -"( %!'.%) =(*-( =" %!$.!+  	.6!J.!)'#B "$'!%#!"%)*)0'("'-!%'"*)L-)'%"-'M=!%!*)+!!+$%".+.#!)''(!F*-(*)!'%"0"*)+!&")+!+%!'.%)$'(!*%*)!'&!)'(!"(*+")+(*#*)0*%*")+!)*!+")B$%".+.#!)'"-'**'*!")+*)*'!+'(!%!=!%!"-'."#L+!"#M*)'(!=%A6.''("''(!+!"#)!!+!+'%!&"*)-)$*+!)'*"#


)")."%BO		$*#!+$%6")A%. '-B %'!-'*)$*%'

*)(" '!%")+#"'!%-)!%'*)0'(" '!%4>(*#!'(!!

 %-!!+*)0=!%! !)+*)0'(!"(*+=!%!)!0'*"'*)0=*'(;!)-%  !%E!' " "#*$%)*" -% %"'*) $% *6#! .%-("!$'(!%"+"%6%"A*)0'!-()#0B%$%O		*)*'!)'*%!'B
).0.';!)-% &")"0!&!)'*)$%&!+'(!"(*+'("''(!%!=.#+6!)+!"#6!'=!!)'(!-& ")*!=!!%6"!+)!!*)0*0)!+L-)'%"-'M6!'=!!)O		")+ :/> ")+ O		 ")+ /"- " ,!'%*' -% %"'*) %+.-!+6B"-A"(*+'!)-.%"0!*)!'&!)'";!)-% !%E!'!)0*)!!%("%#!.++!%")+'(!%(!6%.0('*)=*'((*&+!-*+!+' !%)"##B*)!'*)O		)!$'(!

.++!% *)!'% "# 6%.0(' *) '(!% *)!'% &! $=(& 6!-"&! '(!&!#! !)'")0#!+ *) '(! "(*+ $%".+"-'*)

 


 !"#!

"-A "(*+ #!"+ 0.*#'B ' 

&)!B#".)+!%*)0")+(*"''%)$.)+0.*#'B)'("'-.)'6B'(!'%!)'!)-!+ 6'( +!$!)+")' 6.'"--%+*)0 ' +*$$!%!)' !)'!)-*)0!)'!)-!+ "-A (*#*)0*%*") "--0.*+!#*)! $% $%".+ K  ")"--%+*)0''(!!)'!)-*)00.*+!#K	(!$%".+0.*+!#*)!%!.$$!)!#!!#(."-A"(*++*'%*-' -.%' !%%!+ 6B " #B*)0(*#*)0*%*")")+)''(*&

"(*+"%0.!'("''(!,*'%*-'

'(!#=!% $%".+0.*+!#*)!*)'!"+0.*+!#*)!  :B -)'%"' '(! 0!,*'%*-'.%'7$"*#.%!'+! "%'+14

D2
	243	

%+*)"%*#B'%.!=!!%+.%*)0-.%'!N #"*)!+'("'*'=.#++!)="6"!+)6!-".!L""&"''!%$#"&.-(+*$$!%!)'!'$-*%-.&'")-!@#!"0%!!&!)'=(*-("0%!!)6,!$!)+")'(*&!#$"0%!!'"+*$$!31 
' " !"%'("''(! ,*'%*-+! "%'+=)="%+="6"!+)*'-*%-.&'")-!.%0!+6B'(!+!$!)+$% +! "%'.%!M  (. '(! +!-**

   2 9+ D11 D2

+*'%*-'-.%'7#!0"#+!'!%&*)"'*)'+! "%')'(!6"*$"-!%'"*)$"

"(*+(!"*#B%!#*!)")

'(!%!*)  
)  '(! (*%+ *%#".)+!%*)0 0.*+!#*)! =!%! ' (
1  

FLUFXPVWDQFH RI D NLQG RU WR D GHJUHH QRW DGHTXDWHO\ WDNHQ LQWRFRQVLGHUDWLRQ E\ WKH 6HQWHQFLQJ &RPPLVVLRQ LQ IRUPXODWLQJ WKHJXLGHOLQHV WKDW VKRXOG UHVXOW LQ D VHQWHQFH GLIIHUHQFH IURP WKDWGHVFULEHG    ́ 866*  .(*-.%'("(!#+'("'"&'*) $%+=)="%++! "%'.%!6"!+ ) .6'")'*"# "*'")-! &.' 6! &"+! 6B '(!0!%)&!)' 3+3139D

1'(*%3
94D


	 ?
	4419"'P91'(*%.#BD/%!!%'(!-"!. )=(*-(+!$!)+")'%!#*!'"%0.!'("''(!-.%'(.#+6! !%&*''!+!
'+! "%'6"!+)

+!$!)+")'7- !%"'*)=*'('(!0!%)&!)'"%!)#)0!%-)*+!%!+0+#"=!!)*)'(!-*%-.*'*)=(*-('(!-"!=!%!+!-*+!+ 
)"9+23,*%2'(!,*%-.*'(!#+'("''(!+*'%*-'-.%'=" ".'(%*F!+ ' +! "%' $%& '(! ;.*+!#*)! 6"!+ ) "+!$!)+")'7.6'")'*"#"*'")-!!!)=(!%!'(!0!%)&!)'+*+)'$*#!"&'*)=!!%'("'.%'*''*)0!)6")-%!(!"%+'(!-"!")+(!#+'("'"6!)'"0!%)&!)'&'*)"+*'%*-' -.%' -.#+ )' +=)="%+#B +! "%' 6"!+ ) '(!+!$!)+")'7.6'")'*"#"*'")-!"#$%&''(29+2,*%(!!)6")--.%'!N %!#B%!E!-'!+'(!"&!"%0.&!)''("'"-A"(*+&"A!(!%!'("'!!)*$'(!-.%'#"-A".'(%*'B'+! "%'.)+!% K DQ =*'(.' " &'*) K DQ3 %*+! ")*)+! !)+!)'.%-!$".'(%*'B$%+! "%'.%!"'3
)19+2D'(*%2'(!

!-)+ -"! ) =(*-( +!$!)+")' %!#*! ' . %' (*"%0.&!)' =" "-"'!+ ) %!(!"%*)0  (! *$'( *%-.*'%!-)*+!%!+*'!"%#*!%+!-**)")+*)".6'*'.'! *)*)'(!.%'(!#+L'("'KDQ3+!)'"$$%++*'%*-'-.%'")B "++*'*)"# ".'(%*'B ' -)*+!% .6'")'*"# "*'")-!+! "%'.%! =*'(.' " ;!%)&!)' &'*)M   "' 4

(!%!$%! !%'(!-#!"%+!-**)$'(**%-.*'")+'(!%'(!,*'%*-'.%' =" -%%!-' =(!)*' '"'!+'("'*' -.#+ )'0%")' " +=)="%+ +! "%'.%! =*'(.' " &'*) $%& '(!0!%)&!)'

 DERXW WKLV PRQH\ ZKHQ GHSRVHG LQ WKH ED

(%.0(D(*#*)0*%*")-)

'("''(!"(*+=!%!=%A*)0)"''!& '!+'J.*-A#B!''#!"##'(!O		")+'(!"(*+-#"*&*)0'(%'(!&)!B""*#"6#!$%!''#!&=.#+6!-&!.)""*#"6#!(!$")"+*")*)!'%#!+6B@".=( =!%! %!#"'!+ ' "-A "(--"*)"-A"(*+(=!+'(L-)'%"-'M)!=*'(:/>/"-*%#*)!  >%A*)0 '(%.0( @".("%#!")+"-A"(*+=!)'''!-()#0B'"#"%0!0%. $ !!%B)! $ '(! *&&*)!)' :/>&)!B =" "#%!"+B *) !-%=  (!"*#B*)O		

?"'!%'("'B!"%'(!"(*+*)-

	B'!&L	M*)")"+"""$%!*0)*)!'&!)'!*'(!%'(!*)$%&!+'(!")"+*")*)!'%"6*)'(!
)*'!+	'"'!%'("''(!B #&)!B' "BO		7-%!+*'%


)1(*#*)0*%*")")+&!&

+*-.!+ !''#!&!)' $ '(! *)"(*+O		  	&!*)!'% &)!B6"-A6.''(!B("+'*0)""(*+  ,! *'! ).&!%. -(*#*)0*%*")-)'*).!+'+! *'&*)'(*-#*!)''%.'"--.)'")+'((*&!#$")+"-A"(*+

("%#!7'%*"#="(!#+$%&/

("%#!="$.)+0.*#'B(*&)	! '!&6!%D("%#!=
1  

&KDUOHV 5DVKLG ZDV FRQYLFWHG RQ PXOWLSOH FRXQWV RI FRQVSLUDF\ WR

GHIUDXG WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV DLGLQJ DQG DEHWWLQJ ZLUH IUDXG DQG DLGLQJ DQGDEHWWLQJ PDLO IUDXG

94&)'( -.'+*"#'!%& $ "##  -.)'  ! =" "#

"!!+ " C33  !-*"# "!&!)' ")+ %+!%!+ ' "B%!'*'.'*)$C1D&*##*))" !"#("%#!"%0.!'("''(!%!=""-)'%.-'*!"&!)+&!)''(**)+*-'&!)'")+'("''(!-.%'$"*#!+'*.!"%!J.!'!+E.%B*)'%.-'*)

)")."%BD"-A"(*+ #!+0.*#'B'.)'99

-) *%"-B'-&&*'&)!B#".)+!%*)0)/"B2"-A$*#!+"&'*)!!A*)0'=*'(+%"=(*0.*#'B #!"+.!''(!0!%)&!)'7%!$."#'%!-&&!)+"KDQ+=)="%++! "%'.%!$%.6'")'*"#"*'")-!),!-!&6!%9"-A="!)'!)-!+'42&)'(*& %*)&!)'")+'(%!!B!"%7. !%*!+%!#!"!!=""#"!!+"CD3 !-*"#"!&!)'")+%+!%!+' "B%!'*'.'*)$C1D&*##*))" !"#"-A"(*+"%0.!'("''(!0!%)&!)'7%!$."#'$*#! " K DQ &'*) ="%%")' E.+*-*"# %!*!= 6!-".! '(!0!%)&!)' +*+ )' "-' *) 0+ $"*'( *) *' %!$."#  "-A"(*+"#"##!0!'("''(!,*'%*-'.%'!%%!+6B" #B*)0'(!$%".+!)'!)-*)00.*+!#*)!'(*#*)0*%*")")+)''"-A"(*+

		
&

(*.%'%!*!='(!J.!'*)$=(!'(!%'(!%!="")

"&!)+&!)' ' '(! *)+*-'&!)'      

)3+91D9121'(*%32
	13L+*'%*-'-.%'R%!$."#'+!#*!%"%!J.!'!+*)'%.-'*)*%!!%*6#!*$'("'*)'%.-'*)* " -%%!-' '"'!&!)' $ '(! #"=  )' .6'")'*"##B-!%!+ 6B '(! -("%0! "-'."##B +!#*!%!+ ' '(! E.%B ")+9-)-!%)" *)'*& %'")'*)'(!'%*"#'("''(!$"*#.%!'0*!*'.6'")'*"##B*& "*%'(!+!$!)+")'R+!$!)!M  * D + D3 D 1'( *% !& ("*"++!+

 

6HFWLRQ . SURYLGHV LQ UHOHYDQ

LPSRVH D VHQWHQFH RXWVLGH WKH UDQJH JXLGHOLQHV LI WKH FRXUW ILQGV WKDW WKHUH H[L


' * =!## !''#!+ '("' L"6!)'

"0%!!&!)''("'6*)+'(!0!%)&!+! "%'.%!H"+!$!)+")'I*-)$*)'("' '(! 0!%)&!)' $"*#!+ ' &*& !%&**6#! %!") .-( " %*419+939&*''!+
)$"-''(*.%'("(=")'%!J.*%!+'-)+.-'")!* #!""0%!!&!)' %*+!+'("''(!DQ&'*)L=(!)")+*$'(!
)'(!+!$!)+")'(".6'")'*"##B"*+!$!)+")'+*+ %*+!&!"*'=*'(.'!N #")"'*)''(!-.%'+!    + 4 9=!!%*)"%!-!)'.) .6"-A)=#!+0!+ '("' '(!% -*%-.*" % %*"'!'%!*!=$%6"+$"*'(' $*#! "KDQ&'*)  !-*$*-

=(*-(+!$!)+")'%!#*!DPD1'(*%333%+!%+!))!'(!#! '(! .%' (!#+ '("' %!-!+!)'="''(!-)'%"%B


)'(!-"!"'6"%'(!0!%)&

+*-%!'*) ' +!-*+! =(!'(!% '"*'")-!+! "%'.%!")+"-A"0!%)&!)'"-'!+=*'(").)-)!#!-'!+)''$*#!.-("&'*)>'(!!''#!+#"=$'(**%-.*'("-'!+" % %*"'!#B=(!)*'+!)*!+!*+!)'*"%B(!"%*)0


)'(!"#'!%)"'*!"-A"(*+"

KDQ&'*)6B'(!0!%)&!&"A! " +=)="%+ +! "%'.%! - !%"'*).)+!%KDQ3$'(!
  

-DFN 5DVKLG SULPDULO\ UHOLHV RQ 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y 0LNDHOLDQ  )G

 WK &LU DQG 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y /H]LQH  )G  WK &LU

 ,Q 0LNDHOLDQ WKH 1LQWK &LUFXLW VWDWHG WKDW 3>D@OWKRXJK WKH

JRYHUQPHQW KDV WKH GLVFUHWLRQ WR GHFLGH ZKHWKHU WR ILOH WKH PRWLRQ LW GRHVQRW KDYH WKH ODVW DQG RQO\ ZRUG RQ ZKHWKHU D GHIHQGDQW SURYLGHGVXEVWDQWLDO DVVLVWDQFH ́  )G DW  3,I WKH GHIHQGDQW SURWHVWV WKDWKH GLG LQGHHG FRRSHUDWH DQG WKDW WKH JRYHUQPHQW LV DFWLQJ LQ EDG IDLWK LQUHIXVLQJ WR ILOH D PRWLRQ D IDFWXDO GLVSXWH DULVHV DQG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FDQGHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU LQ IDFW WKH GHIHQGDQW GLG SURYLGH VXEVWDQWLDO DVVLVWDQFHDV SDUW RI WKH EDG IDLWK GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ́ ,G 7KLV &RXUW KDV UHMHFWHG WKH

DUJXPHQW WKDW DQ DOOHJDWLRQ RI WKH JRYHUQPHQW¶V EDG IDLWK LV VXIILFLHQW WRZDUUDQW MXGLFLDO UHYLHZ RI WKH JRYHUQPHQW¶V GHFLVLRQ QRW WR ILOH D  .PRWLRQ ,Q /H]LQH WKH 6HYHQWK &LUFXLW KHOG WKDW WKH JRYHUQPHQW KDGOLPLWHG LWV GLVFUHWLRQ DV WR ZKHWKHU WR ILOH D  . PRWLRQ E\ REOLJDWLQJLWVHOI LQ WKH SOHD DJUHHPHQW WR PDNH VXFK D PRWLRQ 3DVVXPLQJ WKHGHIHQGDQW¶V IXOO DQG WUXWKIXO FRRSHUDWLRQ ́ /H]LQH  )G DW 7KXV WKDW FRXUW GLVWLQJXLVKHG /H]LQH IURP FDVHV LQ ZKLFK WKH JRYHUQPHQWH[SUHVVO\ DIILUPHG LWV GLVFUHWLRQ E\ UHVHUYLQJ WKH ULJKW LQ LWV VROHGLVFUHWLRQ WR GHFLGH ZKHWKHU RU QRW WR PDNH VXFK D PRWLRQ ,G DW 7KXV WKH FRXUW ZDV UHTXLUHG WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH GHIHQGDQW KDGVDWLVILHG WKH SUHFRQGLWLRQ RI IXOO DQG WUXWKIXO FRRSHUDWLRQ ,G DW  7KHFDVH DW EDU RQ WKH RWKHU KDQG LV PRUH VLPLODU WR WKH FDVHV GLVWLQJXLVKHGE\ /H]LQH EHFDXVH WKH SOHD DJUHHPHQW H[SUHVVO\ VWDWHG 37KH JRYHUQPHQW

UHVHUYHV WKH ULJKW WR PDNH WKH VROH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ DV WR ZKHWKHU DQG ZKHQGHIHQGDQW KDV SURYLGHG VXEVWDQWLDO DVVLVWDQFH ́ -$ DW  7KXV HYHQLI WKLV &RXUW DJUHHG ZLWK WKH 6HYHQWK &LUFXLW WKH UDWLRQDOH LQ /H]LQH

ZRXOG QRW DSSO\ KHUH


'$##='("'"-#"*&'("'"+!$!)+")'&!%!#B %*+!+.6'")'*"# "*'")-! =*##)' !)'*'#! "+!$!)+")'' "%!&!+B%!!)'+*-!%B%")!*+!)'*"%B(!"%*)0% =.#+ "++*'*)"# 6.' 0!)!%"#*F!+ "##!0"'*) $*& % !%&'*!M

D3
	22D21


)'(!*)'")' -"! "-A"(*+ +! )' "%0.!'("''(!

0!%)&!)' ("+ ") .)-)'*'.'*)"# &'*! $% $"*#*)0 '&!$%+=)="%++! "%'.%!"'(!%"'"'!+"6!(!"%0.! 6"!+ ) -"! #"= $%& '(!% -*%-.*' '("' '(!0!%)&!)'"-'!+*)6"+$"*'(,!$!)+")'7"%0.&!)')

'(**.!("!6!!).)+#B%!E!-'!+6B'(*.%'

 

(*.%'%!*!=$%-#!"%!%%

$*)+*)0*)*'" #*-"'*)$'(!	!

  .D 9+

-*'*)0*9  =!!% '(! +*'%*-' -0.*+!#*)!*%!*!=9+49441'(*%4




("%#! ")+ "-A"(*+ %"*! 

*%'("%#!"%0.!'("''(! %!!'(!F*-(;%. !$$!-'!+"-)*)+*-'&!)'!"#"##!0!'("''(!*.! (* %!J.!'!+ E.%B *)'%.-'-)'%"' "-A "%0.! '("' '(! ,%!-&&!)+"KDQ+! "%'.%!=""%0.!'("''(!,*'%*-'.%'(.0.*+!#*)! ' (* !)'!)-*)0  "%0.&!)'#"-A&!%*'	!'
#!"	(!

("%#!"(*+"%0.!'("''(!"

'(!$*%'0%. $*)!'%'(!"%*")-!$%&'(!*)+*-'&!)''("'""&!)+&!)'("%#!"!%''("''(' '(! F*-( ;%.  ")+ '("' !F*-(;%. =""6.'"-'**'*!'"'.'!$#*&*'"'*)  %*%' "%0.!'("''(! %!!)'"'*)$.-)'%.-'*!"&!)+&!)'=(*-(=

(!*$'(&!)+&!)'0."%")'!

)#B ) '(! $$!)! %!!)'!%!'.%)!+6B"0%")+E.%B

423	'4349413  LHI'(! -)'*'.'*)"# %*#"'!+ =(!) " &+*$*-"'*) "' -("%0!-)'"*)!+*)")*)+*-'&!)'

24+99D 1'(*%
2  

*)+*-'&!)'I --.% =(!) S'(! -("%0*)0 '!%& H$ '(!*)+*-'&!)'I"%!.)-(")0!+6.''(!!*+!)-!"''%*"# %!$"-' &"'!%*"##B +*$$!%!)' $%& '(! "##!0!+ *) '(!*)+*-'&!)'7
)-)'%"'")*)#!"-(")0!=(!'(!%#*'!%"#%*)!$$!-'*)'(!'!%&$'(!*)+*-'&!)'M+/29+2221'(*%4!& ("*"++!+

("%#! +! )' "%0.! '("''(!*)+*-'&!)' ="#*'!%"##B

-(")0!+!"%0.!%"'(!%'("''(! %!!)'"'*)$!*+!)-!"6.' '(! F*-( ;%.  ("+ '(! !$$!-' $ -(")0*)0 '(!-) *%"-B -("%0! $ '(! *)+*-'&!)' .)'   (. (!"%0.! '(* * " !  =(*-( ="%%")'

%!!%"#L(**%-.*'("(!#+'("'""%*")-!%*!''(!#!!# $ " -)'%.-'*! "&!)+&!)' =(!) '(! '!%& $ ")*)+*-'&!)'"%!*)!$$!-'"#'!%!+6B'(! %!!)'"'*)$!*+!)-!")+E.%B*)'%.-'*)=(*-(&+*$B!!)'*"#!#!&!)'$'(!$$!)!-("%0!+'("''(!%!*".6'")'*"##*A!#*(+'("''(!+!$!)+")'&"B("!6!!)-)*-'!+$")$$!)!'(!%'(")'("' -("%0!+*)'(!*)+*-'&!)'M0   	 23 + 3 4 1'( *% 21!N #"*)*)0 '("' " -)'%.-'*! "&!)+&!)' --.% =(!)L'(!%!("6!!)"&+*$*-"'*)"''%*"#*)'(!!#!&!)'$'(!-%*&!-("%0!+M(!+!$!)+")'("'(!6.%+!)$ %$)'(**.!"'2

(!%!=")"%*")-!%-)'%.-'*!"&!)+&!)'*)'(*

-"!(!$*%'-.)'$'(!*)+*-'&!)'-("%0!+("%#!")+"-A"(*+"#)0=*'("-A(*#*)0*%*")=*'(-) *%"-B*)*#"'*)$2 
	K94 ")+'(!% -.)' -("%0!'(!+!$!)+")'=*'(&"*#")+=*%!$%".+(!$*%''=!%'"-'$ -) *%"-B#*'!+*)'(!*)+*-'&!)' !%'"*) #!#B''(!F*-(;%. ("%#!$-.!)" "%'$'(!*)+*-'&!)''("'"BL;!)!%"##B'(!"(*+=.#+#*-*'$.)+$%&"0%.  $ *)+**+."# '(%.0( " -)'"-' !%) % !%)*)-#.+*)06.')'#*&*'!+';"%B.++!%! ("B+!)@".#*)+"##")+:B+Q%"$'M")+'(!$"-''("'))!$%&'(! F*-( ;%.  * *)-#.+!+ *) '(* #*'   !-*"##B-)*+!%*)0'(!$"-''("'!%'"-'=!%!#*'!+=(*-(*)#!+)#B'(!F*-(;%. ")+'(!$"-''("''(!"6!!N-!% '

 

86 6HQWHQFLQJ *XLGHOLQHV 0DQX

PRWLRQ RI WKH JRYHUQPHQW VWDWLQJ WKDVXEVWDQWLDO DVVLVWDQFH LQ WKH LQYHVWLJDWLRQ RZKR KDV FRPPLWWHG DQ RIIHQVH WKH FRXUW P'+!'!%&*)!=(!'(!%'(!+!$!)+")"*'")-!(.'(!-.%''"'!+'*'E.+0&!)'$%'(!0!%)&!)'7") !*+!)'*"%B (!"%*)0  	*&*+!$!)+")'7&'*)'+! "%'+= %!E.+*-!''(!+!$!)+")'7%"**)'*&!$!)'!)-*)0"-A"(*++*!)'!)-*)06.''(!-.%'+!)*!+'("&'*)&.'-&!$%&'(!0

"-A"(*+"%0.!'("''(!0

KDQ&'*)$%+=)="%++! "%$"*'("-A-)'!)+'("'(!"'*$*!"0%!!&!)'")+'("''(*.%'(-.%''-)+.-'")!*+!)'*"%B(!"'(!0!%)&!)'=""-'*)0*)6"+$.%'+!'!%&*)!'("''(!+!$!)+""*'")-!")+'("''(!0!%)&!)'(!)'(!+*'%*-'-.%'(.#+-& +=)="%++! "%'.%!&'*)
)'("%0.!'("''(!+*'%*-'-.%'(.#+- !%"'*)=*'(.'"KDQ&'


)*D3


23292?++D"*+8

LH>I!(#+'("'$!+!%"#+*'%*-'%!*!= " %!-.'%R .6'")'*"#"*'")-!&'*)"'(!B $*)+ '("' '(! %!$."# .)-)'*'.'*)"# &'*!  (.!)'*'#!+ ' %!#*!$ *$ " %!-.6'")'*"#"*'")-! &'*) +!$!)+")'R%"-!%%!#*0*)
  

'(!'%*"#'("''(! $"*#.%!'0*!*' .6'")'*"##B*& "*%'(!+!$!)+")'R+!$!)!M *D +

D3D1'(*%!& ("*"++!+(.6!-".!'(!%!J.!'!+*)'%.-'*)-)'"*)!+")*)-%%!-''"'!&!)'$'(!#"='(!+*'%*-'-.%'+*+)'!%%*)%!$.*)0'*.!'(!*)'%.-'*)
,-#.! 	!)/0*+

)")."%BD"-A"(*+!)'!%!+*)'".#!

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

)/"B2"-A"(*+$*#!+"/'*)'>*'(+%"=

;.*#'B @#!"  
) '(! "#'!%)"'*! '(! +!$!)+")' &!+ $%+=)="%++! "%'.%!6"!+)(*- !%"'*)")+"%0.!+'("' '(! -.%' (.#+ 6! "6#! ' +! "%' ) '(* 6"*!


(!,*'%*-'.%'+!)*!++!$!)+")'7&'*)*%''(!

-.%' *) "0%!!&!)' =*'( '(! "%0.&!)' .6&*''!+ 6B '(!0!%)&!)' +!'!%&*)!+ '("' '(! @%!!)'!)-*)0 ! %'7!)(")-!&!)' $% 6'%.-'*) $ E.'*-! =" " % %*"'!(!%!$%! '(! -"  *) '(! #!" "0%!!&!)' =" =*'(*) '(!0.*+!#*)!%")0!")+'(!-.%'-.#+!)'!)-!+!$!)+")'=*'(*)'(!'!%&$'(! #!""0%!!&!)'	!-)+'(!-.%'-)-#.+!+'("''(! #!""0%!!&!)'%!!%!+''(!0!%)&!)''(!%*0('

 

!N #*-*'#B"BL)'#*&*'!+'M)"&!$)!$'(!F*-(;%. '%*"# (.#+ ("! 6!!) *)-#.+!.) !%."*! /%!!% "--%+-) *%"-B#"'!+$%&2'(%.'(!!*+!)-!$'(!"(*+7*);%. -)-!%)"-'**'*!'("'''(!-) *%"-B*+!)'*$*!+*)'(!*)+)' "%"##!#''(!-"!%!#*!+)6'(!E.%B=" !%&*''!+'-)*+!.6'")'*"##B +*$$!%!)' $%& '(!*)+*-'&!)'9D1'(*%2$*)+*)0-)'*)+*-'&!)' -("%0!+ +!$!)+")' " $*%!"%& ) 	! '!&6!% 2 24 "-)*+!% %$$ !*))"'(!-("%0!

$%("%#!7"%0.&!)''("''(

-)'%.-'*!"&!)+&!)'6!-".!' %!+"'!+'(!'*&!$%"&!.)+!%-=*'( '(! '"'.'! $ #*&*'"'*) '(*)"--.%"-*!"=!##%*)'")-!'(! !&6!%  &!!'*)0 +" #*-"6#!'*&!$%"&!.-('(!F*-(;%. +*+*)#!"-'*'(!%!#!")' !%*+$'*&!

=!!% '(! 0!%)&!)' +*

"-'**'*!'("''A #"-! %*%':.''(!0!%)&!)'* !%&*''!+!"%#B-) *%"'%*"#-)+.-''("'*6B'(!'"'.'!$#*&*'"'*)L"#)''%*"#("-)'*).!+*)''(! !%&")+")!%'"-'*) $.%'(!%")-!-&&*''!++.%*)0'("' !%*+M+99 +*%41 L"!"%#*!%$$!)!&"B6!6"%%!+*'("!*+!)-!$'("'$$!)!&"B)! %! " #"'!% -%*&! =(*-( '(! 0
3  

 %!-.'!M 
) $"-''(**%-.*'("(!#+'("'!!)=(!)!*+!)-!* %!!)'!+$"-'**'*!'("'--.%%!+.'*+!$'(!-) *%"-B+"'!-("%0!+*)'(!*)+*-'&!)'" !+''(!'"'.'! $#*&*'"'*) +"'!'("' +*+ )' -)'*'.'! " $"'"#"%*")-!,9+991931'(*%2 (#+*)0'("'!*+!)-!$&!!'*)06!'=!!)+%.0-) *%"'%=(*-(--.%%!+ (%'#B6!$%!6!0*))*)0+"'!$'(!-) *%"-B"-("%0!+*)*)+*-'&!)'="&*)%"%*")-!1-21+41'(*%22!*+!)-!$+%.0+!"#--.%%*)0"$'!%!)+*)0+"'!$ -) *%"-B " -("%0!+ *) *)+*-'&!)' =" )' $"'"#"%*")-!


) .&'(!*)'%+.-'*)$'(! !*+!)-! -)-!%)*)0'(!

F*-( ;%.  +*+ )' %! $"-' '("' =!%! .6'")'*"##B+*$$!%!)'$%&'(!!'$%'(*)'(!*)+*-'&!)'")++*+)'-%!"'!"#*A!#*(+'("'("%#!"(*+=.#+6!-)*-'!+$")$$!)!'("'=")'-("%0!+*)'(!*)+*-'&!)'(!%!$%!'(!E.%B % !%#B-)*+!%!+'(*!*+!)-!")+" % %*"'!#B+!'!%&*)!+("%#!"(*+70.*#'*)'(*-"!/$!#!)
* *+

("%#!"(*+)!N'"%0.!'("''(!,*'%*-'.%'!%%!+6B

$"*#*)0'*.!'(!$##=*)0E.%B*)'%.-'*)"'(*%!J.!'8

	
,
  
 O
,@	,>
	@

*+!)-!("6!!) %!!)'!+=*'(%! !-'',!$!)+")'("%#! "(*+7 %!#"'*)(*  *) -))!-'*) =*'(*)+**+."#*+!)'*$*!+"	'! (!)F*-(6!%'/*)A! (:B#!(.-A>%*0('?"%%B(!!A")+"B&)+	-(!%
)%+!%'$*)+,!$!)+")'("%#!"(*+'("!-&&*''!+.)'
'("'*-) *%*)0'-&&*''(!-%*&!$=*%!$%".+")+&"*#$%".+6"!+)'!'*&)B")+!*+!)-!*)'%+.-!+ !%'"*)*)0'	'! (!)F*-(6!%'/*)A! (:B#!(.-A>%*0('?"%%B(!!A")+"B&)+	-(!%B.&.'$*)+'("'(!-&&*''!+") "-' *) $.%'(!%")-! $ &"*# $%".+ % =*%! $%".+ "$.%'(!%+!-%*6!+*)'(!!*)'%.-'*) !%'"*)*)0''(!F*-(0%. $*)+**+."#

 


$ '(! !*+!)-! ")+ '!'*&)B 6!B)+ " %!")"6#! +.6' -&&*''!+")"-'*)$.%'(!%")-!$%".+ $$!)! =*'( %! !-' ' 	/*)A! (:B#!(.-A>"B&)+ 	-(!% " $.%'(!*)'%.-'*)B.&.'$*)+'(!,)' 0.*#'B $ '(! -) *%"-B -F*-(0%. $*)!'%

"'29

(!,*'%*-'.%' % !%#B%!$.

)'(!6"*'("'*'-)'"*)!+")*))'%"%B ' ("%#!7 *)'%.-'*) %!J.*%!+' %!'("'("%#!"$.%'(!%")-!$&"*#$%".+%=*%!F*-(0%. $*)+**+."#M%!#!")'	*N'(*%-.*'@"''!%).%B0!%)&!)'&.' %!'("'"'#!"=" -&&*''!+ 6B " ) $ %*&.%B
)'%1'(*%93  43 +'"'*)0'("'' %!"-) *%"-B0!%)&!)' &.' (=8 L '(!$%&!+")+="!N*'*)0"'%"6.'(!"--.!+=*##$.##B6!-"&! "&9
"'#!"')!$'(!!%'.-(!%'"-'="A)=*)0#B+)6E!-' % .% ! $ '(! -) *% D91D1"'P31'(*%.09"&!!#!&!)'

(!,*'%*-'.%'+*+)'-&&

+*'%*-' -.%'R %!$."# ' +!#*!% %!!%*6#!*$'("'*)'%.-'*)*'(!#"=)'.6'")'*"##B-!+!#*!%!+''(!E.%B")+9-)-!