N OTE : This disposition is nonprecedential. 

# United States **Court of Appeals**  **for the Federal Circuit**

______________________ DRAGON INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, LLC, Plaintiff - Appellant v. APPLE INC., AT&T SER VICES, INC., CHARTER

COMMUNICATIONS, INC. , COMCAST CABLE COMMUNICATIONS, LLC, COX COMMUNICATIONS, INC. , DIRECTV, LLC, DISH NETWORK LLC, SIRIUS XM RADIO INC., TIME WARNER CABLE INC., V ERIZON COMMUNICATIONS, INC. , Defendants - Appellees

______________________ 2016 - 2186, 2016 - 2453, 2016 - 2454, 2016 - 2456, 2016 - 2459, 2016 - 2460, 2016 - 2461, 2016 - 2462, 2016 - 2463, 2016 - 2464

______________________ Appeals from the United States District Court for the District of Delaware in No s . 1:13 - cv - 02058 - RGA, 1:13 - cv 02061 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02062 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02063 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02064 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02065 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02066 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02067 - RGA, 1:13 - cv - 02068 - RGA, 1:13 - cv 02069 - RGA, Judge Richard G. Andrews.

______________________ Decided: November 1, 2017

______________________DRAGON INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY v. APPLE INC . 2 L EI M EI , Mei & Mark LLP, Washington, DC, argued for plaintiff - appellant. Also represented by L AURENCE M. S ANDELL . M ICHAEL J AY , Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP, Santa Monica, CA, argued for defendant - appellee Apple Inc. Also represented by N ANDAN P ADMANABHAN . M ICHAEL H AWES ., Baker Botts LLP, Houston, TX, argued for defendant s- appellees AT&T Services, Inc., DISH Network LLC, DirecTV, LLC. Defendant -appellee AT&T Services, Inc. also represented by M ICHELLE J ACOBSON E BER , R OGER F ULGHUM ; B RYANT C. B OREN , J R ., Palo Alto, CA. Defendant - appellee DISH Network LLC also represented by B RADLEY B OWLING , A LI D HANANI , M ICHAEL S HERBY ; G EORGE H OPKINS G UY , III , Pa lo Alto, CA; J AMIE R OY L YNN , Washington, DC. Defendant appellee DirecTV, LLC also represented by K EVIN G ERARD M C B RIDE , Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld, LLP, Irvine, CA; J OHN W ITTENZELLER , Philadelphia, PA. M ICHAEL M ARTIN M URRAY , Winston & Strawn LLP, Ne w York, NY, argued for defendant s- appellees Charter Communications, Inc., Comcast Cable Communications, LLC, Cox Communications, Inc., Time Warner Cable Inc., Verizon Communications, Inc. Also represented by M ICHAEL L OUIS B RODY , Chicago, IL; G EOFFREY P. E ATON , Washington, DC. M ARK B AGHDASSARIAN , Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP, New York, NY, argued for defendant appellee Sirius XM Radio Inc. Also represented by S HANNON H. H EDVAT .

______________________DRAGON INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY v. APPLE INC . 3 Before M OORE , M AYER , and S TOLL , Circuit Judge s. S TOLL , Circuit Judge. Dragon Intellectual Property appeals the district court’s Final Judgments entered pursuant to the parties’ stipulations of noninfringement of claims 1

– 4, 8, and 10 of U.S. Patent No. 5,930,444 . Our decision today in a rela ted case, Dragon Intellectual Property, LLC v. DISH Ne twork LLC et al. , No s . 2016 - 2468, - 2492, affirms the Patent Trial and Appeal Board ’s determination that claims 1– 4, 7– 10 , 13, and 14 of the ’ 444 patent are invalid. Accordin gly, we dismiss this appeal a s moot. DISMISSED AS MOOT C OSTS No c osts.