5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




//$5' 17(535,6(6 
1&

	






'9$1&(' 52*5$00,1*

(6285&(6 
1& $55<($*5(1

	



 !"#$%
&'$(	$

!"$%	,$%"&*')$"'+$!

./012%&* 

"3,(4*+#-

*+'((&(' (4

!"45
7*8

'"+,'$2,(3






	:' 95""'))6	*,- '& %' !"  &$  2 9*5 ;  )
:' 95
 	

	






:
9	*,- '&%'!" &$2&&	$")'#$%65' "
	9*5; ,#-,)%'!" )







7*8 '"+,'$ 2,(3   '&$'!! &$  "(

&$""')) 
&+ "'3'& 6 -",3%$ ),'$ 3'&)$ (!&(&$    3'&3 '&$"  ' !("  $"(#"<'&!"'&3#&$*!&(&$(=&+("3"##'&3),"+)
&+!' (" $(+,&$"+ '#)$%"$')),3%$>+ ,)'="'3%$)$,)$%?@#"<%(')$"'+$+,"$!,&($%$(!&(&$) ,)( $% #"< !'")$ &( ')),(  &$'&A'('&B,&+$'&&B'&'&3 '&$'!!C),)!$%#"<& $% 	'>$% '"+,'$ !!'"#( $% (')$"'+$ +,"$C) "'"'$6($"#'&$'&)$!'")$,)-,$"#&(($$%(')$"'+$+,"$$#<!'&('&3)&(')),&"("3"&$'&3$%""'$33"%'+)+!'&B,&+$'=" '!&"#&($%(')$"'+$+,"$+&+ ( '&$'!!C)!(" "3')$"$'&&(", ($%$(!&(&$) %( "'" +##& A "'3%$) '& $% #"<$%",3%,$$%)$$!%' '&$'!! "(&A ) 3'&3$%$$%(')$"'+$+,"$""('&DE3"&$'&3&A$"' $%"='(&+&$%33"%'+)+!$%"'",)!$%#"<DE"#'$$'&3(!&(&$)$#&($%'"&)A"$'&+ ,( $% +,&$"+ '# !" +&+ $'& !  '&$'!!C)"3')$"$'&DFE+&+ ,('&3$%$(!&(&$)%(),"'""'3%$)'& $% #"< $%",3%,$   ! %' &( DE !'&('&3 $%$ '&$'!!%(&$+G,'"(&6+##& A"'3%$)'&'$)!%'#"<,$)'(!%'

"$%")&))$$(- AA!!'"#$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)

(+')'&$3"&$&A$"' H"=")$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)(+')'&$"#'$#&(#&$!(!&(&$)C+,&$"+ '#&(A$%"!""'&)$$ '&$'!!C)!(" "3')$"$'&H!!'"# $% (')$"'+$ +,"$C) ", '&3 $%$ (!&(&$) %=>+ ,)'="'3%$)$,)$%#"<'&+&$" %'-,$=+$$%
 	




(')$"'+$+,"$C)"'"'$6($"#'&$&("#&($$%(')$"'+$+,"$!+&)')$&$A'$%$%')'&'& )$$%",3%,$%'&($%",3%,$$%



% &3$%6!+$, -+<3",&(

#"($' '&$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)"=',)'&'&-,$-"'!="=/)(!&(&$""63"&(=&+( "3"##'&3 ) ,$+#&6 $%$  +( # 6"+))'&3B-)&(,)($%#"<'$))"='+) (A)-,3%$&(!$"$A6"-,6,$"'(!$%#"<'&*+#-" "(-$%A"<(!":	&'&+""$(&A+#&6+ ),"+)
&+D&A"(!&$A"<!":	7&
&+$%& "( !$ :	 &( % &( %') &$""'))
&+D "(" '&$'!"3')$"(? "("3"##'&3&#A'$%$%)$$!%' "3')$"$%&#?@-,$'$A)&"'  "(),++)&#?!%'@A'$%$%)$$

3"&- '='&3'&+""+$ 6

"'3%$)$$%#"<(=')(&A! $$%$ "(C),)!'&!"'&3(&&AC)"$+$(")&) "(!' (& '+$'A'$%$%
&'$(	$$)$&$&("3')$"$'&!'$)!%')"!'")$,)($%#"<'&+&&+$'&A" 6)"' F@&	$#"<?!%'@A)"3')$"
 	

	






"3')$" ! $% $&$ &( "(#"< !!'+ 5&A%' 3"& "&( $%$ $% )"='+ #"<  A) +$, 6"3')$"( $ :	 &$ $ &A   3"& $"'(,&),++))!, 6$"3')$"&(?!%'@A'$%$%)$$!%'

 '&$'!!  "( -",3%$ $%') +$'& '& $% 
&'$( 	$$)

*')$"'+$ ,"$ !" $% 	,$%"& *')$"'+$ ! %'  3'&3!(" $"(#"<'&!"'&3#&$! )()'3&$'&!"'3'&+##& A$"(#"<'&!"'&3#&$,&!'"+#$'$'&&((+$'= $"( "+$'+)  *!&(&$) 3"& &( +,&$"+ '#( 3'&3! )()'3&$'&!"'3'&+##& A )"='+ #"<'&!"'&3#&$ ,&!'"$"( "+$'+) &((+$'=$"("+$'+),&(")$$ A$%"$')),3%$'&B,&+$'=" '!"=&$'&3$%$%"!"#,)'&3$%)"='+#"<

)"), $!$%"'3'& $"' '&$%')+)$%(')$"'+$+,"$

% ($%$(!&(&$)%()$- ')%(,)!$%)"='+#"<"'"'&$'#$ '&$'!!C),)&(%(="+#$%"),#$'& )$- ')%( -6  '&$'!!  "(C) !(" "3')$"$'&!$%#"<)"), $$%(')$"'+$+,"$')),(&'&B,&+$'&)$$'&3$%$? '&$'!!)""#&&$ 6&B'&(!"#+&$'&,'&3$,)$%#"<JC"$%#"<J!%'C'&+&&+$'&A'$%$%-,)'&))! +'&3$#""6"+&$"+$+#,$""'&$(")&& A'$%# 6")@D*')$$20.E '&$'!! "($%& ($%$(+')'&$$%	'>$%'"+,'$,"$! )& $%')+,"$!!'"#($%$"' +,"$C)"'"'$6($"#'&$'&-,$=+$($%'&B,&+$'&&$%3",&()$%$'$? +<K(L$%"G,')'$!'&('&3)$),"$),+%&$'&A'('&B,&+$'&+"$'&3" "')<$%$$%'&B,&+$'&")+"'-)&=" 6-"("&3! +&(,+$@ 	 
  
 	
.F(FIF.D.$%'"/E&("#&((!"!,"$%""+('&3)

&"#&($%(')$"'+$+,"$"("(&A$"' $%"

='(&+&$%33"%'+"&3!(!&(&$)C"'",)!$%#"<A'$%'&)$",+$'&$$%"$')$%$?='(&+)%, (

 	




#"<&$%'&$"&$$%",3%,$ 
&'$(	$$)+&)')$&$A'$%$%')
. 	

	






%=% ($%$%)),"'""'3%$)$,)$%#"<$#'&'#,#'&+&$" %'A(+ '&$!!'"#$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)+&+ ,)'&$%$&'&B,&+$'&"%'-'$'&3 "(C),)! $% #"< '&  )+'!'+ 33"%'+ " &+))"' 6"+ ,()&6,)!$%#"<-6 "(&$%'&$"&$)$% "$') %= &$ -"'!( " "3,( $%'" )'$'&) A"#&( $%') ')), $ $% (')$"'+$ +,"$ $ +&)'(" !$"-$'&'&3-"'!)&$%')),

H),33)$$%$(,$$%,+'$6!+) A(("))'&3

+&+,""&$$"(#"<"'3%$)&('&$"&$,)$%(')$"'+$+,"$#6A&$$+&)'("+))(("))'&3$%" !&$'& (="$')'&3 -6 "$') A'$% +&+,""&$ $"(#"< "'3%$),"$)%=% ('&)#+))$%$()'$+&+,""&$,)"A'$%  $""'$"6 ! >+ ,)'= ,) &  #)$&$'&  ,)")%, (-"#'$$()#!"#!&$'& (="$')'&35+"$%6M.4.
&#")$"'3%$!"A"(+)'&A%'+%)&'",)"% () !("  "3')$"$'& ),-B+$$ '#'$(+&+,""&$"'3%$)!B,&'",)""#'$$'&3)#!"#!'&$"&$,))#)&+))"6$%"A')'!$A"$')%=+&+,""&$"'3%$)$$%)##"<'&(')$'&+$33"%'+ ") &'$%" "$6 A, ( =" -  A( &6 ,) ! $%'&$"&$%")&$+)%A="')+# '+$(-6$%!+$$%$ "(%)-$'&(!(" "3')$"$'&&($%$C)'&'$' '# #&$$'&!'$)A-)'$")$%=++,""("'"$ "(C)"3')$"$'&H$%"!" ='$$$%(')$"'+$+,"$$= ,$$%"3,#&$)&($%,&,), !+$)!$%')+)'&$%!'")$'&)$&+&"#&(




&),#A+&+ ,($%$$%(')$"'+$+,"$('(&$""'&

3"&$'&3&A$"' -,$('(""'&"#'$$'&3(!&(&$)$#&($%'"+,&$"+ '#$"G,)$+&+ $'&! '&$'!!C)!("  "3')$"$'&  H "=") $% (')$"'+$ +,"$C)+&+ $'&! '&$'!!C)"3')$"$'&
&(('$'&A!!'"#$% (')$"'+$ +,"$C) +&+ ,)'& $%$ (!&(&$) %= $%>+ ,)'="'3%$$,)$%#"<'&+&$" %'H"#&($$%(')$"'+$+,"$$= ,$$%"$')C"'3%$)$,)$%

 	




&$(, '+$='(&+")&$('&+ ,((('$'& ='(&+!(!$&('&+ ,('&3	$#-"0#"< A) "3')$"(@ D"(" 2"3,#&$)'&$%$)+&($"' (!!'")$$'#$%$$%+,"$+&+  "3')$"$'&%$"' B,(3)$$( #$'& $ #&( (!&(&$+,&$"+ '#!"+&+ $'&! $"' B,(3$%&3"&$((!&(&$)2 FE  
& '$) !'&  "("(!&(&$)C +,&$"+ '# +&+$"(#"< "3')$"$'& &( % ( $"'3%$)'&$%#"<$%",3%,$&("("2/0E '&$'!!



 '&$'!!"3,)!'")$$%$&"#

A)&$"G,'"($+# 6A'$% '&$'!!"3,)$%$-+,)(!&"G,)$(&'&B,&+$'&3'&)$ %=),-#'$$(='(&+)$$%'&B,&+$'&$$%!'")$$"' %,) !$%""'$33"%'+"&3- '#'$($"='A!$%!, "

*)'$$%!+$$%$-$%"$'

$%!'")$$"' '$')+ "$%$$%& $"'  A) "'"'$6 ! ,) %') ++&+ ,(($%$$%(')$"'+$+,"$""'&B,&+$'& A'$%,$ $% !'&('&3)$"&3	. F( $F.)$$( $%$ $% "+"( A) &$ )""'$)+!$%'&B,&+$'&"+"('&$%') +)"='()'&(3,3$%33"%'+"&3!(#"<@	.F($F.

! A'&3#&($$$%$"' +,
. 	

	






KHL=+$$%'&B,&+$'&&("#&($%')+)$$%*')$"'+$,"$!"!,"$%""+('&3)%*')$"'+$,"$!'")$ )%, ( #< !+$,  !'&('&3) (!'&'&3 $% "3'&A%" (!&(&$) +&$'&,,) 6 ,)( $%'"  #"<-!" '&$'!!C)"3')$"$'&&($%&)%, (')),&"("3"&$'&3$%""'$)+!'&B,&+$'=" '!

$F.&"#&($%$"' +,"$"("(&='(&$'"6%"'&3$($"#'&$%""'$33"%'+)+!$%'&B,&+$'& )$$'&3 $%$ ?K'L! $% "+"( ) '$ >')$) A)'&),!!'+'&$!"$%,"$! )$#<$%$!'&('&3'$'))'#' " 6'&),!!'+'&$!"$%'),"$$()@D2/FE

%(')$"'+$+,"$C)(+')'&$% (&='(&$'"6%"'&3

')&$,$)'(!$%#&($"='((-6$%')+,"$
&("$%?#&($", @$%(')$"'+$+,"$#,)$+$&"#&('&++"(&+A'$%$%(+')'&!),"'"+,"$4

KL%#&($", "G,'") A"+,"$)$(%"$$% +##&() !  ),"'" +,"$    ++"('&3 6?K,L&"#&(!$%+)!"!,"$%""+('&3)!$" (+')'& -6 $%  $ +,"$ $% $"'  +,"$ #,)$J"+('&++"(&+A'$%$%#&($&($% A!$%+)))$- ')%(& C%$"' +,"$#,)$J'# #&$-$%$% $$"&($%)'"'$!$%#&($$<'&3'&$++,&$$% $+,"$C)'&'&&($%+'"+,#)$&+)'$#-"+)C@


F/F(D.$%'"E

DG,$'&3
 0(00.DF('"EE  
& $% ")&$ +) $% 	'>$% '"+,'$ > '+'$ 6"#&(( ?!" !,"$%" "+('&3)@ $ ($"#'& $%""'$33"%'+)+!$%'&B,&+$'&%(')$"'+$+,"$C)(+')'&$%"#"='(&+&$%$')),('(&$=' $$%')+,"$C)#&($

 '&$'!! ) 3)$%$=&'!'$A"&$,$)'(!$%

#&($!$%')+,"$$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)(+')'&$% (&A $"'  A) & -,) ! (')+"$'& -+,) (!&(&$))%, ( %= ")&$( &6 ='(&+ " =&$ $ $%

 	




"A, ($%&-+#&"!"3')$"$'&+="'&3'$A)3"&%,)A+&+ ,($%$$%(')$"'+!+$")&(+&)'("$'&!N&""'$H"#&($$%(')& 6$+&)'("='(&+'&$%"+"'" $  "(C)  '+$'& !($"#'&A%$%"%)"'3%$))$$!%'

'& 6-+,)'$+&+ ( 

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

H  ) =+$ $% (')$"'+$ +

 "(C),)!$%#"<&$
 	

	






%=-&+&+ ($%(')$"'+$+,"$)%, (%=+&)'("(& 6='(&+!C),)'&%'"'"$ "(C).!(" "3')$"$'&

%') +,"$ #,)$  ) +&)'(" A%$%"$% (')$"'+$ +,"$

 '($%""'$$)$$$%='(&+")&$(-6$($"#'&$%$%)$""'$"' "'"'$6$%",3%,$$%&$'" )$$ ! %' ()'$ )#A%$ '#'$( +$,  ,)!$"$%')+,"$C)"=',)"#&($$%(')$"'+$+,"$$%(')$"'+$+,"$ '(!,""&3$)$$($"#'&'&A%$33"%'+  +$'&) C) #"<$ &$"$'& A)),!!'+'&$$A""&$"$+$'&%!,"!+$"),)('&$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)+$-"'&'&A")! A)4DE$%= ,#!) )!$%"(,+$'&$%$"DE3"A$%$"&()'&$%" DFE$%#"<$&$"$'&) !,&+$'&!$%$$ "(,+$#"<$&(DE$%#,&$!(="$')'&3D2/E%(')$"'+$+,"$$<$%)!+$")('"+$ 6!"#	
	/.	,D** E-,$ &,#-"!$%" +'"+,'$) +,"$)%= ($()'#' "$)$)!"#$
%&'(0.(F/FF/DF('"/IE)   
 )  *
 .I ( ID/E#
F/(FD/$%'".0E%)+,"$3"&$("'"'$6$B,&'",)"O"3')$"&$),-B+$& 6$$%)&'",)"C)"'",))(!'&(-6!+$"))'#' "$$%)-=).I($IF%+,"$> '&($%$?+$, ,)'&$""'$"6K')L&$&+))"6$)$- ')%"'3%$)'&$%$$""'$"6@'!$%!+$")()+"'-(")$')!'(

% 
	 ,"$ ! ,)$#) &( $&$  ) %)

> '+'$ 6(("))(?$%G,)$'&))$A%$+'"+,#)$&+)'!&6)%"$!+$, ,)!$%$"(#"<#6+"$"'3%$)'&$""'$"6@+"*(..

0I D 0E  % +,"$C) &)A" " '( & $%,&(" 6'&3,")!$"(#"< A$ '#'&$+&),#"+&!,)'&  %+ +,"$ > '&( $%$ ?KAL%" "$6 %) ),-#'$$( ='(&+ ),!!'+'&$ $ "=  )$"&3"--' '$6!!,$,">&)'&!%')$"('&$&"$%$

 	




""'$)+!&'&B,&+$'&!'")$ "G,)$( & '&B,&+$'&  ),-)$&+ ! $%') "3,#&$ & $% ('&3$%$'$ +, ( "='A$%"3"( ))!$% +<!&6(')+,%')+,"$% ($%$ '&$'!!C)!' ,)+!$%'&B,&+$'&- AA	.F($F.+,)+% &3$$%)+!$%'&B,&+&$-,)%')(')+"$'&-6%"'&3+&+ ,($%$$%(')$"'+$+,"$+$%')+,"$&(A'$%'&'$)(')+"$'&%"'&3 $ #< !+$,  !'&('&333"%'+)+!$%'&B,&+$'&



 '&$'!!&>$ 3)$%$$%(')

(!&(&$)C #$'& $ #&( $%+,&$"+ '#!"+&+ $'&! "3')$"$'& H #,)$ !'")$ ($"+,"$+$(+&$""6$$%#&($!'")$ )()+"'-(-=$%$,&"#&(!"#$%')+,"$'& ++"(&+ A'$% $% #&($ )$- ')%( &     $%,?'# #&$-$%$% $$"&()'&$ ++,&$ $%  $ ++'"+,#)$&+)'$#-"+)@D.$%'"ED+'$$'?#6+&)'("$%)')),)&$(+'-6 $%  $ +,"$ "  "='$# I0 ( . . D.$% A%$%"$%(')$"'+$+,"$! A($%#&($%A="'$')'#"$%"#&(')),(-6$%')+,"$$3&" " '#'$(&$,"4
/ 	

	






KL#&()+&-'$%"3&" " '#'$('&)+9'#'$( "#&() > '+'$ 6 ,$ '& $% ')),) $ -(("))( -6 $% *')$"'+$ ,"$ &( +"$  &""A!"#A"<A'$%'&A%'+%$%*')$"'+$,"$#,)$"$:&" "#&()'&+&$")$3'=$%*')$"'+$,"$,$%"'$6  $ (("))   #$$") ) &3 ) "#'&'&3+&)')$&$A'$%$%"#&(


*
-./F(.F.ID.$%'"E

%(')$"'+$+,"$" '(&$%')+,"$C))$$#&$$%$$%

+)A)"#&((?!"!,"$%""+('&3)+&)')$&$A'$%$%')'&'&@$($"#'&$%$$%#&($A)3&" &D20E%(')$"'+$+,"$A&$&$+&+ ,($%$$%	'>$%'"+,'$(+')'&%(&$(("))($%= '('$6! '&$'!!C) "3')$"$'&  )( & '$) +&+ ,)'&) $%$ $%"#&(A)3&" &($%$$%')+,"$%(&$(("))('$%" > '+'$ 6 " '# '+'$ 6 $% = '('$6 !  '&$'!!C)"3')$"$'&$%(')$"'+$+,"$% ($%$'$+, (= ,$$%"3')$"$'&A'$%,$=' $'&3$%#&($", 

&$""6$$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)+&+ ,)'&%A="$%')

+,"$C)'&'&),33)$)$%$$%"#&(A)'&!+$ '#'$('&)+%')+,"$"=")($%(')$"'+$+,"$& 6)$$%)+ ! $% '&B,&+$'&  % " =&$ &3,3 !"# $%')+,"$C)'&'&'))! A)4

%$",(!'+'&+6!$%"("'&$%') +)')$%$'$ +<)$%"G,')'$!'&('&3)$),"$),+%&$'&A'('&B,&+$'& +"$'&3  "  "')< $%$ $% '&B,&+$'&")+"'-)&=" 6-"("&3!+&(,+$K	'>$%'"+,'$L+))#<'$+ "$%$ "(&$""'))"$'&($% "'3%$$ ,)'$) #"<'&$%) 33"%'+"3'&)$%$(!&(&$)%(&$&$"($$%$'#! "(&$""'))C!(" "3')$"$'&%"!"A!'&($%$$%+,"$C)"("!' )$?)$!"$%$%")&)!"'$)')),&+@&(",&)!, !, .ID(E5"="$%"+"('&$%')+)"='()'&(G,$='(&+!"

 	




%(!&(&$)C#"<$&$"%'&(=&'&$%3"$""A%'+%'&+ ,()$%),$%,&$6$% A)$"&"$'&),&$')&("$)!'+<A,&$')')&$)"',) 6('),$') $% " A%" (!&(&$)++,""(&($%6%=),"'

D2E&$%!'")$ '&$%$%(')$"'+$+,"$C) !+$,  !'&('&3 ,#-,) #$" '$& " A%+,"$C) ($"#'&$'& $%$ (!A&")%'"'3%$)$$%#"<)"), $%)&>+ ,)'=3"$" ,#-,)"()'$ I '+$'&&(),++))!, 

%(')$"'+$+,"$ )+&+ ,(

"'3%$ $ ,) $% #"< $%",3%,$-+,)%($#'&'#,#A)A'$%'&'$)&$," N&!>& "( !'")$ ,)( $% #"< '& +&+ ,)'& %A=" $% (')$"+#$'&3 +##& A "'3%$) +<&A (3 "(C)+&)$",+$'=.!(" "3')$"$'&%(' &3$'$(  )$$A'( +*"$#&$ ! "&)"$$'& # 6#&$ 	"='+) "'"$  +&)$",+$'=D2E&($%$$%$  ")&- 6 >+$( $%",3%,$$%)$$
&(('$'&$('(#<)# &,#-"! $% )$$&((="$')($%",3%% (')$"'+$ +,"$ ('( &$ !!" '&'&%A=")$A%&$%')%= '&+""+$ 6 " '( & +$'= "(C)"3')$"$'&+,) 
 	

	






IHGHUDO UHJLVWUDWLRQ DQG D VHQLRU XVHU ODWHU LQVWLWXWHV FRQFXUUHQW XVHSURFHHGLQJV ,Q WKDW FDVH WKH FRXUW VWDWHG WKDW

>:@KHUH WKH SULRU XVHU GRHV QRW DSSO\ IRU D UHJLVWUDWLRQ EHIRUHUHJLVWUDWLRQ LV JUDQWHG WR DQRWKHU WKHUH PD\ EH YDOLG JURXQGVEDVHG RQ D SROLF\ RI UHZDUGLQJ WKRVH ZKR ILUVW VHHN IHGHUDOUHJLVWUDWLRQ    IRU SHUPLWWLQJ WKH SULRU UHJLVWUDQW WR UHWDLQ WKH

QDWLRQZLGH SURWHFWLRQ RI WKH DFW UHVWULFWHG RQO\ E\ WKH WHUULWRU\RI WKH SULRU XVHU

,G DW  Q ,Q :HLQHU .LQJ ,QF Y :LHQHU .LQJ &RUS  )G 

&&3$  WKH FRXUW JDYH UHJLVWUDEOH ULJKWV WR DOO SRUWLRQV RI WKH8QLWHG 6WDWHV LQ ZKLFK WKH PDUN KDG QRW EHHQ XVHG WR WKH MXQLRU XVHUUHJLVWUDQW UDWKHU WKDQ WKH VHQLRU XVHU ,G DW  :KLOH HPSKDVL]LQJ WKH

QHHG WR FRQVLGHU LQGLYLGXDOO\ WKH IDFWV LQ HDFK FDVH WKH FRXUW KHOG WKDW LQVRPH FDVHV 3WKHUH LV D SROLF\ RI HQFRXUDJLQJ SURPSW UHJLVWUDWLRQ RI PDUNVE\ UHZDUGLQJ WKRVH ZKR ILUVW VHHN UHJLVWUDWLRQ XQGHU WKH /DQKDP $FW ́ ,GDW 

$OWKRXJK WKHVH FDVHV DGGUHVVHG WKH YDOLGLW\ RI D MXQLRU XVHU¶V

UHJLVWUDWLRQ ZKLFK ZH GR QRW HYDOXDWH KHUH ZH UDLVH WKHP WR VKRZ WKDWWKH UHVXOW ZH UHDFK EDVHG RQ SURFHGXUDO UXOHV GRHV QRW SURGXFH D UHVXOWLQKHUHQWO\ FRQWUDU\ WR WKH /DQKDP $FW ,Q DGGLWLRQ ZH ILQG WKDW VRPH RIWKH JHQHUDO JXLGHOLQHV XQGHUO\LQJ FRQFXUUHQW XVH SURFHHGLQJV PD\ GLUHFWRXU GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI DQ HTXLWDEOH GLYLVLRQ RI JHRJUDSKLF SULRULW\ LQ WKHSUHVHQW FDVH

+,"$""('&+&+ '&3 '&$'!!C) !("  "3')$"$'&A+&+ ,( $%$ $% >$&$ ! $% 33"%'+ "'"'$6 ! $%"$')#,)$-($"#'&(-6$%"),#$'&! '&$'!!C)!("  "3')$"$'& &( &6 "'" +##& A "'3%$))$- ')%( -6 (!&(&$)  )$%') +,"$ % ( &$% !'")$ ? "(&$""'))C!(" "3')$"$'&!$%
)"='+#"<)"=))"'#!+'='(&+!A&")%'&( +)&(!&(&$)$%-,"(&!)%A'&3$%'""'"""'$'&&(+&$'&,(,)!$%#"<@	.($FI.')$%)&'",)"%A="&(?$% )&'",)" +& " 6&'$) +##& A,)$"=>+ ,)'= "'3%$) '& '$) $""'$"6 ! ,) &( ="+# $%"3')$"&$C)"'#!+'"),#$'&@5+"$%6M.4IF

%(')$"'+$+,"$+&+ ,(($%$A)$%)&'",)"

!$%#"<-)(&$%!+$$%$,)($%#"<'&$% ,#-,)""'"$ "(C)!'")$,)'&2,&!

 	




3ODLQWLII DOVR DOOHJHV WZR DGGLWLRQD

FRXUW HUUHG LQ SHUPLWWLQJ GHIHQGDQWV WR DGSODLQWLII¶V IHGHUDO UHJLVWUDWLRQ )LUVW SODD FRPSXOVRU\ FRXQWHUFODLP DQG WKXV XQZDLYHG E\ GHIHQGDQWV ZKHQ WKH\ IDLOHG DQVZHU 6HFRQG SODLQWLII DOOHJHV WKDW HYHSOHDGLQJ E\ OHDYH RI WKH FRXUW ZKHQ MXVWLFSHUPLWWHG LQ FDVHV LQFOXGLQJ WKLV RQH Z

XQGXH GHOD\ DQG XQIDLU SUHMXGLFH %HFDXGLVWULFW FRXUW YLRODWHG WKH PDQGDWH UXOH EWKH FRXQWHUFODLP LQ TXHVWLRQ ZH QHHG QGHFOLQH WR GR VR

,)$3,3$%33"%'+"&3!$%#"<"$%)")&)A&( "#&($%') +)$$% *"+('&3)%*')$"'+$,"$!'&('&3) (!'&'&3 $% "3'+&$'&,,) 6 ,)( $%'"  "3')$"$'&&($%&)%, ('))""'$)+!'&B,&+$'=

	 . F( $ F..  
& &3,3G,$(-=$%')+,"$'&)$",+$'&)$$%(')$"'+$+,"$"(')$"'+$+,"$!' ($(("))$%$)$%$ $%') A)  3&"  "#&( (')$"'+$+,"$C)+$'&$& 6$%$&!'&('&3)!!+$&(')),&"

%,) A +&+ ,( $%$ $% (

#&($", -6"#'$$'&3$%+,) "), $$%(')$"'+$+,"$C) ", +&&$ )$&( &( A "=") $+&+ '&3 '&$'!!C)$"(&# " "(C) !("  "3')$"$'&A'$%- A
 	

	








 '&$'!! )+&$)$)$%(')$"'+$+,"$C)($"#'&$'&!

'$) "'3%$) &( (!&(&$)C "'3%$) $ $% )"='+ #"<  $+##& AA&")%'!$"(#"<")"='+#"<"'3%$)')-$'&(-6+$, ,)2%#)5+"$%65+"$%6&"(#"<)&(
&!'"#$'$'&M.4D$%(EK%"'&!$"5+"$%6L%!'")$$,)#"<'&$%) !3()")"='+)')$%?)&'",)"@!$%#"<&(3'&)+##& A "'3%$) $ $% #"< '& $% 33"%'+ " '&A%'+%$%#"<'),)(

A&")%'"'3%$)! A& 6!"#"'",)'$%"+$, "

+&)$",+$'=(" "3')$"$'&!$"(#"<")"='+#"<+&&$+"$"'3%$)&("'"'$6="$%")A%%="=',) 6 ,)( $% #"< '& +##"+ -,$ !(" "3')$"$'& ') "'# !+' ='(&+ ! $% "3')$"&$C)A&")%' &( >+ ,)'= "'3%$$,)$%#"<I 
	MMI0D-EIDE&(+&)$'$,$)+&)$",+$'=,)!$%#"<5+"$%6M.4F/D$%(E?&)$",+$'=,)@#&)$%$A%'+%)$- ')%)"'"'$6($A'$%$%)# 3  !!+$ ) $% " ')$ +$,  ,) !  $"(#"< $+##& A5+"$%6M.4F/D$%(E
&$%$6'+  +)'& A%'+%  )&'" ,)"  ') !"$% !(" "3')$"$'& ?K+L&)$",+$'= ,) A'  !'>  "3')$"&$C)&$'&A'( "'"'$6 "'3%$) '&  #"< !"# $% !' '&3 ! '$) '+$'&!""3')$"$'&@
&$%+)'&A%'+%B,&'"

,)" ')!""3')$"$'&%A="$%>$&$!$%)&'",)"O&&"3')$"&$C)$""'$"6')!"N&)!$%($!+$, "3')$"$'&$$%B,&'",)"5+"$%6MM.4I4IF9&%#+$MII
	M.I

%$""'$"' "'3%$)!% ("!!(" 6"3')$"(

$"(#"<" A6)),-B+$$&6),"'"+##& A"'3%$)+G,'"(-6&$%""$6$%",3%+$, ,)"'"$$%"3')$"&$C) +&)$",+$'= ,)  %,) '& $% ")&$ +) $%,3%  "( D$% B,&'" ,)"E !' ( &  '+$'& $"3')$"$%#"<&5"+%FI&($%#"<A)= '( 6"3')$"(&$%"'&+' "3')$"&	$#-"0.

 	




:H PDNH QR ILQGLQJV DV WR ZKHWKHU 

ZKLFK GHIHQGDQWV FRXOG VXFFHVVIXOO\ UHJLVWUDWLRQ RU UHTXHVW FRQFXUUHQW IHGHKRZHYHU WKDW XSKROGLQJ DW OHDVW D SRUWUHJLVWUDWLRQ DJDLQVW D VHQLRU XVHU¶V FKDOOH/DQKDP $FW RU SULRU FDVHODZ

)RU H[DPSOH LQ ,Q UH %HDWULFH )RRG

 WKH 86 &RXUW RI &XVWRPV DQG 3DWUXOHV IRU FRQFXUUHQW XVH SURFHHGLQJV 7KWKDW LQ WKH W\SLFDO FDVH LQ ZKLFK QHLWKHU WKH VHQLRU XVHU LV HQWLWOHG WR D UHJLVWUDW6WDWHV H[FHSW DUHDV RI SURYHQ XVH E\ WKH MUHFRJQL]HG DQ H[FHSWLRQ KRZHYHU LQ WKH 

 "(C)A&")%'"'3%$)"),-B A "'3%$) +G,'"( -6  D$"3')$"$'&%(')$"'+$+,"$%)$%')+,"$!!'"#($%$')$%#"<  
& $%" A"() $% (')$(!&(&$  ,)( $% #"< '& "(C)!'")$"+3&'N(,)'&'$)%,)'$')+ "$%$%))##"< ),"'" $  "(C) ("3')$"$'&%<6G,)$'&%33"%'+>$&$!$%$),"'""$%!'")$ ?(!&(&$)C"'3%$!")$%"A%"'$)+&$'&,"#$( '&$'!!C)+&)$",+$'=.F($F.

6'+ 6 ,&(" M D(E ! $%

MID(E'$')$%)&'",)"A%"3')$"$'&),-B+$& 6$$%"'B,&'",)"A%%),)($%#"< '+$'&!"!(" "3')$"$'&$% ")&$ +) %A=" A "+(,"  ")&)(!&(&$)+!(" "3')$"$'&%"%,)A! $% "$') '& $% +&$>$ ! !(" "3')$"$'&:'=&,"+