In the 

United States Court of Appeals 

For the Seventh Circuit IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIO


!;O33L4376O


</%/;<O

 %$."" %$<O

',



	</%/,<O

  %$.""$;O

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIO


)))	
)
)))))

)))&)
)%)

%)""))$#$)()		


&%)

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIO

41< 3134 N 32< 3135O

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIO

!$O	<O<O O	</#&%/
&$;O

	</#&%/
&;O) $%O!O&)!O"$%O!O$O

%&&O  O !O ! & O &&O  %O 0"&O &!O !&O

 !&%O O!$&%O&&O! O&!O.$ &O,  O %&L

&'&! %;O+O&O&O&%O$O%'&O <O&O%&&O'$+O

O $'O &&O &O  %O)$O &&O &!O !$!%O ! O !&O

"$%<O'&O&+OO+&O&!OO%!<O O&O!'$&OO !&O L

&$O , O ' &%O %"+ O )!O !)%O !)O 'O &!O
3O 
!;O33L4376O

)!;O &.%O %+O &&O &%O(%O &O  O !""!$&' &+O &!O

 O O$O&&! O' $O&O! O!O))! /
!/

!#",/',/&/$/	 &$%#$/!#";<O655O;;O391OA3116B;O'&O&O

%&$&O!'$&O! 'O&&O&/!!#. O!&$ <O' L

$O)O! +O &O'"$O!'$&O!O &O &O&&%O O

$()O &O ' &%O !O %&&O !'$&%O O (O %'&%<O $#'$%O

%%%O !$O O !O %'&L0$O '$%&! ;O 3133O ;;O

%&;O	O324612OA
;;O;O
!(;O39<O3133B;O

))! /
!O&%O'%O&&O"$O%&&O O$O&&! O

%O"$!"$O%O! O%O &O%&&O%'&O$ %O"  O O &&O

&/!!#. O!&$ O""%O! +O) OO!%$O O%&&O

!'$&O,%O O $O%'&O% O $()O  O $&! O!O &O

%&&O!'$&F%O' &;O655O;;O&O3:2M:5;O'$O" &.%OO

!%&OO0O O%&&O!'$&O'&OO !&O+&O!%&O&O)$;O!$L

!%'$O &&! O  O  !%O ! & '%O ' &O &O !&$O %O

%!<O&O'O! ,$%O&O%<O O&O!'$&O&$O &$%OO

, +O ' &O !$O %&$'&%O &O %'$"'%;O O O  

/  / -/ ,,/ ',/ !( $ <O 8:4O ;4O 882O A8&O $;O

3126B<O&&OO$' O!O!$!%'$O O"$(&O(O&&! O O

 !%O%O !&OG, HO!$O&O"'$"!%O!O""O' $O39O;;;O

J23:2O ' &O &O %<O ! ,$&! <O  O "!%&L! ,$&! O

' &%O(O!'$$;O&O%O$O&!O%O)+OO!'$&O%!'O

&$ O, &+O.$ &+O!$O"'$"!%%O!/))! /
!;O

O %&$&O !'$&O O &O !$!%'$O %! O G.L

&(+O, H;O3133O;;O%&;O	O324612O&OK6;O&OO !&O&

/  / ',/ !( $ <O +O '%O &O "$&%O O !&O

&O &&O %O O &O %&$&O !'$&;O '&O '%O &/!!#.

 O !&$ O ! $ %O %'&L0$O '$%&! <O O

$' &%O !&OO)(O!$O!$&;OO'%&O""+O&O

!&$ O !$$&+O !O 0$O !)O "!!$+O &O %%'%O )$O

$O O&O%&$&O!'$&;O

!;O33L4376O 4O

$O%&&O O$O&&! O%O"!%%O'%O&O

' $+ O%"'&N)!O!) %O&O !&%O O!$&%@N

"$&%O &O %&&O &&! O  O  O O $%!(O  L

"  &+O!O&;O/))! /
!<O655O;;O&O3:4=OGOO$O

" &.OE"$% &C%DO%!O "  &O<O&O! O &&O

 %OOO! '%! O &&OO%&&O!'$&O%O$O OO

%O&!O)OO)%OO"$&+O?<O& O&$O%O'$%&! O O

%&&O)O &$ %O)&$O &O   &O "$(%O ' $O

"$ "%O!O"$'%! ;FO/$$!$,/',/!$! &<O::6O;3O

837<O839OA8O2::4BH;O&O%$"&! O,&%O!'$O%;O

O%&$&O!'$&O$O! O&#/',/!$%#<O:62O;4O974O

A8&O$;O3131B<O!$O&O"$!"!%&! O&&OO!$!%'$O%! O

%OG.&(+O, HO)&!'&O&O O!$O +O&$O"$!L

 %;O &O %O !&<O !)($<O )&/ &#O !%;O&$O O %&&O

!'$&O$'O&&OO $O)%O &&O&!O!$!%O! OO!$&L

<O&O"$O)%O !&O%!O'%O&O!) $%O$O

' $O%&&O)O+O& $ O"+ &;OO%"'&O!'&O!)O

'O &$%&O &+O!)O)%O%0<O  O &O $O,O O

%&%&! O!O' &;O!O &O%&&O&&! O /&#O)%O

 !&O'%&OG.&(+HO, >O&O)%O, O O +O"!%%O% %;O


!&O' &O!$O& O&)!O+$%O&$O&O%&%&! O!O'L

 &O O%&&O!'$&OO" &.%O! O&$O$O%'&<O

)O! %&&'&OO$&O0O! O&O' &O OOL

 O &!O&O &$O! +O;O&O%&'&! O%O!($O+O

&/!!#. O!&$ ;O

O'"$O!'$&O%& '%O /))! /
!O&) O

'$%&! O&%O O&O! O!O"$'%! OA%%'O O

O"$'%! <O%!&%OO!&$O%&!""O O$%O

'&B;O655O;;O&O3:4;OO$O%'&O&&O! &%&%O&OL

%! O!OO%&&O!'$&O+OO!O+O"$'%! O( O) O

&O $O !'$&O %O '$%&! ;O O %&&F%O !$!%'$O
5O 
!;O33L4376O

%! %O"$&O&O$O%'&F%O!  &;O+O&O

&O&O%&$&O!'$&O%%%O&%O%'&<O!)($<O&O%&&O

&&! O !'&O ! O "$O)%O !($O '%O O %O O !L

'$$O O O! ,$<O O+O&O&O)O$O!$O$L

' &O&&O)%O&$'O!$O&O%! O"$O%O);O

O%&$&O'O)$!&=O

)
))
))
) 
)
) ) 
)
)


)

))
)
)
)
)
)
)
))
)


))
))
)) )))

))
)
)
)!))))


)
))

))))
%)')
)))
)

)')%))))))) 
)
))
)
&))


)
))
))
)

))
)%)

3133O;;O%&;O	O324612O&OK8;O &.%O! & O&&O&%O

%O%& <O'%O&+O"$% &O! %&&'&! O&!$%O&&O

&O%&&O'$+OO !&O$%!(;O&O !%O!$%O%#' L

&O&&! O!'&O&O%OOA%'O%O)!O!) %OO !&O

 O!$&BO( O) O&O" &.O O&O%! O%O!L

$%O !(O$' &%;O<O;;<O!(/',/%,/%//!!<O

2:8O;O3O492<O49:OA3112B>O'#/#-/	 ,/',/ /#<O295O

;O3O3:1<O425M26OA2::9B>O!#/',/!#/%*/ $-/	 ;<O35O;O

3O568<O572M73OA2:73B;OA&&O)O!($ %O%%'%O!O"$'%! O

' $O39O;;;OJ2849;BO!+O &O%&&O&&! O%O!($O+O

 +O%& $;O &.%O!'O(O"$% &O&$O! %&&'L

&! O $' &%<O  ' O &$O ! & &! %O &&O &O %&&O

'O O O*O"$&O! &&%<O&$!'O&O'O$L

$+O O !%;O+O$O !&O$O&!O!(O)&O!' &%O&!O

 O""&O$' &O&!OO.$ &O'O%+%&;O'$OL

%! O O' $ /',/#+#<O:2O;5&O987OA8&O$;O3135B<O L

(%%%O &O)O !O "$'%! O O  !%O  O *" %O )+O O

%&&O !'$&F%O , O %! O O &$O &O $O &&! O

!;O33L4376O 6O

 %O%O "$'%(O ' $O &O)O !O ' &%O O  !%<O

)O""%O&!O&%O%'&;O

 O, O!%$(&! ;O!O'"<O &OO  &<O

)%O !&OO"$&+O&!O&$O%&&O%O O!%O !&OO&O L

,&O!O"$'%! ;O&F%O'%OO)%O&O&$O';O!L

! O)!O) &%O&!O"$% &OOO&&O%O%%$&+O " L

 &O!O&O%&&O&&! O$$%%%O&&O.!$&O+O%' O&O

%&&O '<O )O %O &O $O !'$&O &!O & O &&O &O

%&&L!'$&O' &O%O*&+O)&O&O$O%'&O! $ %;O

&O O ( &%<O 'O '"O%O  &&O &!O %!'&OL

' &+O$!O%<O'%OO&O OO'O"&+O

 OO$%"&%O &&O" &.%O! &%&;OO%&"/',/"# <O

546O;;O45:<O467OA2:89B>O *#/',/! <O491O;4O38:<O396M97O

A8&O$;O 3115B;OO%&$&O!'$&O ""O'O' &+O

)&!'&O( O" &.%O O!""!$&' &+O&!O$%%O&O%'L

&<O'&O)O(OO&O ,&O!O""&O$%;OO" L

&.%OO%O O&O%&$&O!'$&O($+& O&+O%+O! O"L

"<O&O)!'O !&O(O"O&;O'O'"F%O &L

& &O &!O' &+O !&OO!'&;O
 O)!'OO

"! &%%;O

O' &O!O&O%&$&O!'$&O%O!,O&!O$-&OO

%%%O)&O"$'O$&$O& OO%%%O!$OO!O'L

$%&! <O O%O%!O!,O&O%O/$;O