05/23/2014 15:50 FAX 19732868800 SAULEWING Ia! 003/01 1 

Charles M. Lizza 

William C. Baton 

SAUL E\WJO LLP 

One Riveifront Plaza~ Suite 1~20 

Newark, NJ 07102-5426 

(973) 286-6700 

clizza@ saul. com 

wbaton@ saul. com 

Attorneys for Plaintifft 

Helsinn Healthcare S.A. and 

Roche Palo Alto LLC 

Eric I. Abraham 

HILL W AI..LACK LLP 

202 Carnegie Center 

Princeton, New Jersey 08S43 

Telephone: (609) 924·0808 

Fax: (609) 4.52-1888 

eia® hillwallack.com 

Attorneys for Defendan, 

Sandoz Inc. 

RECEIVED 

Stuart D. Sender MAY 2 9 2014 

BUDDLARNER, P.C. 

lSO John P. Kennedy Parkwi~~~po_ M 

Short Hills. New Jersey 07078 ILU~~E~~ALSH- (973) 379-4800 . 

ssender@buddlamer .com 

Attorneys for Defendants 

Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Ltd. and 

Dr. Reddy 's Laboratories, Inc. 

Michael E. Patunas 

Mayra V. Tarantino 

LITB DEPALMA GREENBERG, LLC 

Two Gateway Center, Suite 1201 

Newark, NJ 07102 

(973) 623-3000 mpatunas@ Utedepalma.com 

Attorneys for Defendants 

Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. and Teva 

Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY 

HELSINN HEALTHCARE S.A, and 

ROCHE PALO ALTO LLC, 

Plaintiffs, 

v, 

DR. REDDY•s LABORATORIES, LTD .• 

DR. REDDY'S LABORATORIES, INC .• 

SANDOZ INC .• TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS 

USA, INC., and TEV A PHARMACEUTICAL 

INDUSTRIES, LTD., 

Defendants. 

Civil Action Nos. 11 .. 3962/11-5579 

(MLC)(DEA) (consolidated) 

Civil Action No. 13-5815 (MLC)(DEA) 

Hon. Mary L. Cooper, U.S.D.J. 

Hon. Douglas E. Arpert. U.S.M.J. 

JOINT STIPULATION AND 

tpR8P68'!B] ORDER 

CONSOLIDATING CML ACTION 

NO. 13·581! WITH CML ACTION 

NOS. 11·3962/11·5579 AND 

DISMISSING WITH PREJUDICE 

UNITED STATES PATENT NOS. 

8,5181981 AND 8,598,218 

(Filed Electronically) 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 1 of 9 PageID: 3871
05/23/2014 15:50 FAX 19732888800 SAULEWING 

WHEREAS. Plaintiffs Helsinn Healthcare S.A. and Roche Palo Alto LLC (collectively, 

"Plaintiffs") initiated Civil Action No. 13·5815 (MLC)(DEA) alleging infringement of United 

States Patent Nos. 8,.518,981, 8,598,218~ and 8,598,219 by Defendants Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, 

Ltd., Dr. Reddy's Laboratories. Inc.~ Sandoz Inc., Teva Phannaceuticals USA, Inc., and Teva 

Pharmaceutical Industries. Ltd. (collectively, ''Defendants,.); 

WHEREAS, Civil Action No. 13-5815 (MLC)(DEA) involves the same parties as well as 

patents sharing a common priority application with those at issue in Civil Action Nos. 11·3962 

(MLC)(DEA) and 11·5579 (MLC)(DEA) (consolidated), which are also before this Court; 

WHEREAS, good cause exists to consolidate Civil Action No. 13-.5815 (MLC)(DBA) 

with Civil Aotion Nos. 11-3962 (MLC)(DEA) and 11-5579 (MLC)(DEA) (consolidated); 

IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AOREED by and between Plaintiffs and 

Defendants, by their undersigned counsel, as follows: 

1. The parties agree to dismiss their respective claims and counterclaims concerning 

U.S. Patent Nos. 8PS18,981 and 8,598,218, with prejudice, as well as any requests for 

costs and/or fees relating to these patents. 

2. Plaintiffs identify the following eight (8) claims from among those at issue in the 

three actions to assert in the consolidated bench trial: U.S. Patent No. 7.947,724 

~ 004/01, 

claims 2 and 9, U.S. Patent No. 7,947,725 claim 2, U.S. Patent No. 7,960,424 claim 6, 

and U.S. Patent No. 8.S98,219 olaims 1, 2, 6, and 7.~ 

3. The parties agree to limit fact discovery to new infringement, validity and 

enforceability issues raised by the asserted claims of U.S. Patent No. 8,598,219. 

4. Expert depositions will be limited to a maximum of four (4) hours on the record for 

1 Plaintiffs have not asserted claim 7 of U.S. Patent No. 8,598,219 against Defendants Dr. 

Reddy,s Laboratories, Ltd. and Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Inc. 

·2· 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 2 of 9 PageID: 3872
05/23/2014 15:51 FAX. 19732866800 SAULEWING 

any expert who previously submitted a report and was deposed in Civil Action 

Nos. 11·3962 and 11·5S79 (consolidated), and seven (7) hours for any expert who 

was not previously deposed in Civil Action Nos. 11-3962 and 11-5579 

(consolidated). 

~005/011 

S. The parties propose an agreed-upon schedule, attached as Exhibit A, for all remaining 

litigation dates for the consolidated actions~ provided. however, that (a) for all pretrial 

filings (including without limitation filings relating to claim construction and a 

Markman hearini), Plaintiffs and Defendants reserve their respective rights to 

propose to the Court in the future a briefer or altemati ve schedule, subject to the 

Court's preferences, and (b) Plaintiffs and Defendants contemplate that the Court at 

its discretion may decide that certain claim construction or pretrial filings and 

proceedings are unnecessary and/or that some or all of the usual party exchanges 

relating to, and components of, a pretrial order are not needed. Therefore, by 

agreeing to dates on the proposed agreed-upon schedule, attached as Exhibit A, 

Plaintiffs and Defendants are not waiving their respective rights to seek the Court's 

leave in the future to streamline the pretrial schedule. 

6. At the Court's discretion and in accordance with the Court's schedule, the parties 

respectfully request the Court to set an April2015 trial date and respectfully request 

the Court to set an initial pretrial conference date that the Court feels is consistent 

with the requested April201S trial date and the parties' proposed schedule attached as 

Exhibit A. 

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs and Defendants, by their attorneys. respectfully request that 

this Court consolidate this action with Civil Action Nos. 11·3962 and ll-SS79 (consolidated) for 

-3-

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 3 of 9 PageID: 3873
05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 19732866800 SAULEWING 

trial and for all remaining pretrial purposes, including without limitation all remaining litigation 

dates set forth in Exhibit A, and subject to paragraphs 1·6 above, and that all of the papers be 

maintained in Civil Action No, 11-3962. 

SO STIPULATED: 

By: r/ Charles M Lizza 

Charles M. Lizza 

William C, Baton 

SAUL EWING LLP 

One Riverfront Plaza, Suite 1S20 

Newark, NJ 07102-5426 

(973) 286·6700 

cUzza® saul.com 

wbaton@ saul. com 

Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

He/sinn Healthcare S.A. and 

Roche Palo Alto LLC 

Of Counsel.· 

Joseph M. O'Malley, Jr. 

Bruce M. Wexler 

Eric W. Dittmann 

David M. Conca 

Oary Ji 

Angela C. Ni 

PAUL HASTINOS LLP 

75 Bast 55th Street 

New York. NY 10022 

(212) 318-6000 

Attorneys for Plaintiff 

Helsinn Healthcare S.A. 

Mark E. Waddell 

LoBB & LOEB LLP 

34S Park A venue 

New York, NY 10154 

(212) 407-4127 

mwaddell @loeb.com 

Attorneys for Plaintiff 

Roche Palo Alto LLC 

Dated: May 23. 2014 

By: s/ Stuqrt D. Sendet 

Stuart D. Sender 

Michael H. Imbacuan 

H. Howard Wang 

Stephanie L. Donahue 

BtJOD LAANER. P.C. 

ISO John F. Kennedy Parkway 

Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 

(973) 3 79-4800 

ssender@buddlamer.com 

mimbacuan@buddlarner.com 

. hwang@buddlamer.com 

sdonahue @buddlarner.com 

Attorneys for Defendants 

Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Ltd. and 

Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Inc. 

By: s/ Eric[, 4brahqm 

·4· 

Eric I. Abraham 

Christy L. Saveriano 

Hn..L WALLACK LLP 

202 Carnegje Center 

Princeton, New Jersey 08543 

Telephone: (609) 924-0808 

Fax: (609) 452-1888 

eia @hillwallack.com 

csaverlano@ hillwallack. com 

Of Coun!el.· 

David C. Doyle 

E. Cary Miller 

MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP 

12531 High Bluff Drive, Suite 100 

San Diego, California 92130-2040 

Telephone: (8S8) 720-~100 

Pax: (858) 720-S 12S 

DDoyle@mofo.com 

lll006/011 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 4 of 9 PageID: 3874
05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 19732888800 SAULEWING 

EMiller@mofo.com 

Matthew M. D' Amore 

Jayson L. Cohen 

Hui Liu 

MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP 

250 W. 55th Street 

New York, New York 10019-9601 

Telephone: (212) 468-8168 

Fax: (212) 468-7900 

MD Amore@ mofo.com 

JCohen@ mofo.com 

HLlu@ mofo.com 

Attorneys for Defendant 

Sandoz Inc. 

By: s/ Mk/tael E. Patunas 

Michael E. Patunas 

Mayra V. Tarantino 

·S· 

LITE DEPALMA GRSBNBERO, LLC 

Two Gateway Center, Suite 1201 

Newark, NJ 07102 

(973) 623-3000 

mpatunas@ litedepalma.com 

mtarantino@ litedepalma.coro 

Of Counsel.· 

Oeorge C. Lombardi 

Lynn MacDonald Ulrich 

Julia M. Johnson 

Brendan F. Barker 

WINSTON & STRAWN LLP 

35 West Wacker Drive 

Chicago, IL 60601 

(312) 558-5600 

glombardi @winston.com 

lulrich ®winston. com 

jmjohnson ®winston. com 

Jovial Wong 

WINSTON & STRAWN LLP 

1700 K Street 

Washinaton, DC 20006 

(202) 282-SOOO 

jwong® winston.com 

llJ007/011 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 5 of 9 PageID: 3875
05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 19732866800 SAULEWINS 

tS . SO ORDERED on this~ day of ~I I 

-6-

Attorneys for Defendants 

Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. and Teva 

Pharmaceuttcallndustrie.t Ltd. 

'2014. 

Ia! 008/011 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 6 of 9 PageID: 3876
l.;.:l·'.'· ~:. 

i 

; 

05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 19732866800 SAULEWING Ill 009/011 

EXH·IBIT A 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 7 of 9 PageID: 3877
05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 18732866800 SAULEWING ~010/011 

Helsinn et aL v. Dr. Reddy's Labs. et aL (D.N.J.) 

Proposed ConsoUdated 11·03961/13..05815 Schedule 

. ' ,,, Event . I 

'' ~· .. Da• ,\: 1', ,! •' 

Deadline to amend oleadinas or join oanies May 15,2014 

Plaintiffs identify up to 8 asserted claims from among claims 

2 and 9 of '724 patent, claim 2 of '725 patent, claims 2, 5, May 23,2014 

and 6 of '424 patent. and the claims of '219 patent 

Exchange identification of all intrinsic and extrinsic 

evidence each party intends to rely upon to oppose other May29. 2014 

party• s proposed constructions 

Joint Claim Construction and Preheating Statement June 9, 2014 

Opening Markman brief$ June 19, 2014 

Complete exp_ert discovery relating to claim constroction July 11, 2014 

Close of fact discovery July 18. 2014 

Responding Markman briefs July 17, 2014 

Meet and Confer Deadline to propose Markman Hearing July 22. 2014 under Local Rule 4.6 

Markman Hearina Subleet to Coun' s Availability 

30 days after entry of Markman 

Disclose any reliance on advice of counsel order, OR 2 weeks before 

Plaintiffs serve draft Pretrial Order 

text, whichever earlier 

Opening expert reports (addressing claims or defenses for July 21, 2014 which a oartY bears the burden of proof) 

Rebuttal ex~:~ert reoorts Auaust 21, 2014 

Reply expert reports September 16, 2014 

Close of expert discovery November 12, 2014 

Deadline to file dis~ositive motions C 219 patent) On or before August 12, 2014 

Opposition briefs to dispositive motions Due 4 weeks after motion filed 

Reply briefs to dispositive motions Due 3 weeks after opposition brief 

filed 

Exchange Jist of legal issues November 17, 2014 

Bxchange fact witness lists (aside from those witnesses 

called for impeachment purposes, only the witnesses set November 24, 2014 

forth may testify at trial) 

Exchange expen witness lists (no expert shall be pennitted November 24, 2014 to testify at trial unless identified at this time) 

Exchange objections to fact and expen witness lists December 9, 2014 

Exchange exhibit lists December 19, 2014 

Exchange electronic collection of exhibits from parties' December 19, 2014 respective exhibit lists in a mutually acceptable format 

Exchange objections to the opposina DartY's exhibit list January 9. 2014 

Exchange affinnative deposition designations December 12. 2014 

Exchange deposition counter-designations and objections to January 16, 2015 affinnati ve designations 

Exohange objections to counter desianations January 30, 2015 

1 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 8 of 9 PageID: 3878
• 

05/23/2014 15:51 FAX 19732866800 SAULEWINS 

Helslnn et aL v. Dr. Reddy1s Labs. et aL (D.N.J.) 

Proposed Consolidated 11·03962 /13.0581S Schedule 

.... , '.~ :,<£vf!nt '" " Dates 

Exchange stipulation of facts for the issues on which the 

December 16. 2014 parties have the burden of proof 

Exchange resoonses to stioulation of facts January 9, 2015 ° 

Exchanae contested facts January 30, 201 S 

Exchange lists of the oarties' contemplated motions in limine December 5, 2014 

Meet and confer in an attempt to reach mutual resolutions December 12, 2014 regardina the parties' contemplated motions In limine 

Serve opening motions in limine December 19, 2014 

Serve responses to motions In limine January 16, 2015 

Plaintiffs serve draft Pretrial Order text February 6. 201 S 

Defendants serve rebuttal to Plaintiff's draft Pretrial Order February 13, 2015 text 

Proposed Final Pretrial Order Due FebruarY. 20, 2015 

Subject to Court's availability; 

Final Pretrial Conference parties will request a date that the 

Judge believes is consistent with 

an April 20 1 S trial date 

Trial Briefs and Proposed Findings of Facts One week after Final Pretrial 

and Conclusions of Law Conference 

Subject to Court• s availabiljty; 

Trial parties will request an April 2015 

trial date in May 2014 

2 

fll011/011 

Case 3:11-cv-03962-MLC-DEA Document 174 Filed 05/29/14 Page 9 of 9 PageID: 3879