UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

KIMBERLEE WILLIAMS, et al )

) No. 11-01754-BRM-AME

Plaintiffs, )

)

vs. )

) CIVIL ACTION

BASF CATALYSTS LLC, et al. )

)

Defendants. )

 HIPAA - QUALIFIED PROTECTIVE ORDER

This matter having been opened to the Court upon the Report and

Recommendation [D.E. 644] of the Honorable Marina Corodemus, J.S.C.

(Retired), whom the Court appointed as Special Master and Settlement Trustee in

this matter; D.E. 644 having been issued pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 53; no

opposition having been filed; the Court having reviewed and considered the

Report and Recommendation; and for good cause shown, the Court adopts the

Special Master’s findings and recommendation and enters the following as the

ORDER of this Court this 28th day of January 2022.

BACKGROUND

WHEREAS, the Special Master/Settlement Trustee by prior order of this

Court has been assigned the responsibility to administer and carry out the terms of

the Parties’ class action Settlement Agreement and related Plan of Distribution

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 1 of 10 PageID: 51232 
2

(POD)

1 which was approved by this Court on September 24, 2021. (ECF No. 643);

and

WHEREAS, Edgar C. Gentle, III, Esq., of Gentle, Turner, Sexton & Harbison,

LLC (“Lien Administrator”), has been duly appointed by the Court to serve as the

Lien Administrator with authority to execute the lien resolution requirements and

duties provided in the Settlement Agreement and POD (ECF Nos. 623); and

WHEREAS the Lien Administrator has requested entry of a HIPPA Qualified

Protective Order in this matter to enable and facilitate its fulfillment of the lien

resolution duties relating to Settlement Class Members who made claims to the

Settlement Fund and were awarded compensation under the POD; and

WHEREAS, under the POD the Lien Administrator is authorized and required

to: (1) identify Liens that may be held or asserted by Governmental Payers2

, Other

Governmental Payers, Medicare Part C or Part D Program sponsors, and Private

Third Party Payers/Providers; and (2) satisfy the Lien obligations of BASF, Cahill,

1 All capitalized terms appearing herein and in the Attachment A shall have the

same meanings ascribed to them in the Settlement Agreement and POD approved

by the Court.

2 Governmental Payers means any federal, state, or other governmental body,

agency, department, plan, program, or entity that administers, funds, pays,

contracts for, or provides medical items, services, and/or prescription drugs. These

include CMS, the Medicare Secondary Payer Department, and the Medicaid

programs of each state and territory and of the District of Columbia (each a

“Medicaid Agency”); Veteran’s Administration, Defense Health Agency

(previously managed by TRICARE), and Indian Health Services.

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 2 of 10 PageID: 51233 
3

Settlement Class Members, and the Settlement Fund, including any relevant

reporting obligations under a global lien resolution approach, or facilitating the

relevant reporting by providing all necessary reporting information for submission

under Defendants’ standard operating procedures (whether pursuant to MSP or

otherwise), provided however, that each Settlement Class Member receiving an

award from the Settlement Fund (and his or her respective counsel, if applicable)

will be solely responsible for the payment, satisfaction and discharge of any all

Liens. (See Settlement Agreement §3.4.2.; POD §7.3.2.).

WHEREAS, the Lien Administrator is authorized and empowered to act under

the POD on behalf of Settlement Claimants as their agent to identify, negotiate and

attempt to resolve the amount of any health insurance reimbursement claims and/or

liens, including those relating to deceased Claimants’ estates and/or heirs; and

WHEREAS, in many instances there is not presently an estate open for a

deceased Settlement Class Member from which to obtain information releases or

authorizations; and

WHEREAS, in order to carry out and perform its duties and functions under

§7 of the POD the Lien Administrator in particular has been given: (1) the authority

to act as agent for the benefit of all Settlement Class Member Claimants and/or their

respective individually retained attorneys, the Settlement Fund, and the Settlement

Trustee for the sole and limited purposes of claim and/or lien resolution; (2) the

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 3 of 10 PageID: 51234 
4

authority to provide to, receive from, and disclose to/from Payers (defined below)

certain protected health information (“PHI”) and personal identifiable information

(“PII”) related to Claimants in the above-captioned action; (3) the authority to

resolve any and all potential recovery claims for medical items, services, and/or

prescription drugs with Governmental Payers, Medicaid Program sponsors, and/or

Other Payers/Providers, including all private health plans whether insured or selffunded (collectively “Payers”) associated with the above-captioned action; and (4)

to provide to or receive from Payers PHI, PII and potential recovery claim

information in acceptable data file formats and other electronic means, provided

however, that any information including any submissions or data files provided to

or received from any Payer by the Lien Administrator shall be maintained strictly

confidential, not disclosed to any third party and used solely for identifying and

resolving any lien obligations relating to the compensation payments to be made to

a Claimant under the POD.

THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AS FOLLOWS:

1. Specific Requirement for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid

Services. The Lien Administrator shall serve as the exclusive agent of the Settlement

Class Member Claimants in the above-captioned action, together with their

respective individually retained attorneys (if any), including any deceased

Claimants’ estates and/or their heirs, for purposes of (1) medical payment claim

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 4 of 10 PageID: 51235 
5

and/or lien identification, and (2) resolution of any and all potential recovery claims

for medical items, services, and/or prescription drugs with Payers associated with

any Settlement Fund payments arising out of the above-captioned action. In

particular the Lien Administrator is vested with the exclusive authority to administer

a process with CMS for the identification and resolution of Medicaid fee-for-service

reimbursement claims on behalf of all settling Claimants who are or were Medicaid

entitled.

2. The Lien Administrator is further authorized to and shall serve as the

exclusive government medical payment claim and lien resolution agent of the

Settlement Class Member Claimants in the above-captioned action, including any

deceased Claimants’ estates and/or their heirs, together with their respective

individually retained attorneys (if any), with respect to identification and resolution

of any other government medical payment liens. The Lien Administrator shall

resolve any and all potential Medicaid fee-for-service claim(s) related to settlements,

judgments, awards, or other payments associated with the above-captioned action

for those Claimants who are or were Medicaid beneficiaries. Claimants have been

informed in the Class Action Notice that as such agent, the Lien Administrator has

the authority to act in such capacity for the benefit of all Claimants to resolve any

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 5 of 10 PageID: 51236 
6

and all Medicaid reimbursement obligations, consistent with federal law.2

3. Settlement Class Member Claimants have been informed in the Class

Notice that the Lien Administrator would be appointed to act on their behalf and in

the POD (See § 7.5.22.) that as a condition of participation in the settlement

proceeds, each Claimant by participating in the Settlement Fund distributions has

agreed to the Lien Administrator’s protocols for global resolution which specify that

every settling Claimant is bound to the terms of a global resolution of all Medicaid

claims, and understands that certain individual rights have been waived, including,

but not limited to, the right to seek a waiver, compromise, and/or appeal of

Medicaid’s reimbursement claim.

4. With regard to Medicaid fee-for-service, the Lien Administrator shall

provide CMS with a final and verified list of qualified Medicaid enrolled

beneficiaries. The list shall be maintained by all recipients as strictly confidential

and be used solely for the purposes of identifying and resolving medical payments

liens.

5. The Lien Administrator is authorized to provide to, receive from, and

disclose to Payers lists of settling Claimants, and related information, which

identifies those Payers that have or may have asserted against such Claimants a lien,

2 See 42 C.F.R. §405.910.

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 6 of 10 PageID: 51237 
7

claim, or right of subrogation, indemnity, reimbursement, conditional or other

payments, or interest of any type for injury-related medical items, services, and/or

prescription drugs paid on their behalf. Any lists or related information shall be

maintained by all recipients as strictly confidential and be used solely for the

purposes of identifying and resolving medical payments liens as set forth in greater

detail herein.

6. The Lien Administrator isfurther authorized to perform all duties

and functions identified in the preceding paragraphs in this Order, including but not

limited to, identifying and resolving potential recovery claims related to Claimants

in this action for medical items, services, and/or prescription drugs with all entities

defined as Payers herein by all means necessary, as determined by the Lien

Administrator including, but not limited to, en masse data submissions with Payers

designed to identify healthcare coverage and related claims itemizations for

Claimants, requesting information from relevant parties and accessing internetbased healthcare coverage information sources including, but not limited to,

mymedicare.gov.

7. Any information including any submissions provided to or received

from any Payer or the Lien Administrator, including but not limited to PHI and PII,

shall be treated as made in the course of settlement discussions between the Payer

and the Lien Administrator, and shall be intended by the parties to be confidential

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 7 of 10 PageID: 51238 
8

and be protected by all applicable state and federal privileges, including but not

limited to those directly applicable to settlement discussions. The information is to

be used relating to the compensation payments be made to a Claimant under the

POD. The Lien Administrator and the Payors shall, on their own initiative,

individually and collectively take steps to preserve the privileges set forth herein.

Any Payor in receipt of a subpoena or other request for confidential information

including any form of Discovery (as defined below) shall provide a copy of such

request to the Lien Administrator. The Lien Administrator and the Payor shall each

on its own initiative take appropriate steps to preserve the privileges before all

courts.

8. This Order shall apply to the use of all information related to Settling

Claimants that the Lien Administrator creates, provides to, receives from, and

discloses to Payers that is or may be protected under HIPAA and its amendments,3

or other applicable federal or state law, including all Protected Health Information

and Personal Identifiable Information, as defined in 45 C.F.R. §160.103.4 The Lien

3 HIPAA shall mean the administrative simplification provisions of the Health Insurance

Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, Pub. L. No. 104-191, 110 Stat. 1936 (1996) and the

implementing regulations issued thereunder, 45 C.F.R. Parts 160, 162, and 164, and shall

incorporate by reference the provisions of the Health Information Technology for Economic and

Clinical Health Act (Title XIII of Division A and Title IV of Division B of the American

Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, Pub. L. No. 111-5 (2009)).

4 This includes demographic information that could be used to identify Medicare-eligible and/or

Medicaid-enrolled Claimants, information related to Claimants’ eligibility for and entitlement to

benefits under the Medicare Program and Medicaid Program and information related to health

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 8 of 10 PageID: 51239 
9

Administrator is specifically authorized to provide to, receive from, and disclose to

Payers lists of Claimants and related information, in lieu of providing copies of

individual HIPAA authorizations and information on a Claimant-by-Claimant basis.

9. Nothing within this Order shall be deemed or construed to entitle any

party, third party or entity to seek information in the form of Discovery. As used in

this order “Discovery” means a request for any information provided to or received

from the Lien Administrator pursuant to this Order or the POD in any form including

subpoena or FOIA (as defined infra). No provision of this Order shall be cited in

support of any request for enforcement of a subpoena, Freedom of Information or

similar state law document request (“FOIA”), or discovery request in any

proceeding.

10. Prior to providing or receiving any information, lists of Claimants or

lists of Settlement Class Membersto or from any person, entity, agency or third party

administrator holding or handling potential lien claims, the Lien Administrator shall

provide a copy of this Order to such person, entity, agency or third party

administrator and obtain from it an acknowledgement that it has received, read and

agrees to be bound to and abide by the terms of this Order which shall be enforceable

before this Court. The form of acknowledgement shall further obligate any recipient

care services rendered, including the payment of such services.

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 9 of 10 PageID: 51240 
10

of such information or lists from the Lien Administrator to promptly notify the

Settlement Trustee and Lien Administrator of any request received or any subpoena

served upon it seeking information or documents on Claimants provided to or

received from the Lien Administrator pursuant to this Order.

 

SO ORDERED. Dated: January 28, 2022

/s/ André M. Espinosa

ANDRÉ M. ESPINOSA

United States Magistrate Judge

Case 2:11-cv-01754-BRM-AME Document 647 Filed 01/28/22 Page 10 of 10 PageID: 51241