JUN/17/2011/FRI II: 21 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No, 267 212 5001

F'AGE 02/1a

P.002 gliO

ß6/16/2811 14: 29 7324932643 DEGENNARD

AttoI'/1ey(s) Alfi"eil boGtnnaro

Oflloo Address 12 ChristogliorWl'll .Sulto 200

TQWl1l State, Zip (Ji.)do ~ 1121l011u)Wil, N¡

Toleplione Number ('13?) 493.821 i

Attorney(s) for Plalrit(ff /l.1lciJ Q'Britm

...

Superior Court of

New Jerscy

.... Oaean COUNTY

Law DivIsIon-Civil Part DIVISION

Dooket No: L. I 9(ij'. II

... -

Allca cranen

PI(ill\tims)

Va.

. ,:rhe 'Pø.ln l\ud ~~DI Ç!inter Ç)rianghQmo

Dootor Phillip SllB$O

~ Dofimdai\t(s)

CIVIL ACTION

SUMMONS

From rho siato otNcw Jol'$ciy To Tho J)efendant(~) Nam,,¡f Abovøi

The plaintiff, nnrried abQvt1. has tiled a.ll1w:mit agaillM you In thfl SuperiDr CO\lrt nfNcw Jeflloy. Tfiii:

complaint atløQheci to this BUmmOI'l$ states the onlii fQrthriilaw8ult. lfyól,l diiipuiø this complalnft you Or

your ii.ttoll1e.y ll1lJst file a written itnswer or moilon and proof of :¡ørviCtl witb thÐ deputy i:lt;rk of the

Supc:rlor Court in tho i;i)uniy liB~ abovl\\ wltliln 'JS dayø &On'l the: (llte YQU f'C(lClvei1 thia iiummonø, not

counting the illltii yoiireooived It, (me addresG Qf eaoh deputy clerk oftlie Siipenol" Court is provided.)

Trthe: oompliilnt is one Itt fONIlIusure, then you mU4lt fill(l yöur wrlttèl'l anewer i;ir Il1Qtlòn and proof of

øervice with the Clerk oftiit'l Sllpenor Court, Hiigbe& Jmitloo Complex. P.O. Box 971, Trenton, NJ 08625-

0971. A filing ~ payiiblo to tho 1'reasi.irer, Stnte ofNi;iw lenioy and l1 øomplQlëd Case Tnfonns.t(clJ

StatElmont (iivaililblo ft\')m tb$ ¿iipi.ily cICl'~ ofthe SuperioJ' COl)l'l:) muat e.çtom'tlinn' Y0'Uf l1I\9wer Dr motíon

wbcm It l$ fllod. You must aIdO $dncl a gOllY of your amiwør Qr motion ti:i plalniHl"s!lttomBY whoøe nMlO

and IIddrCl~ø appoor above, OT"1o pfabitlfti iflla atWmey IS named above. A wlephQnB Dan will mit protøc.t

your rlghl.$; you must ftle and setvø a written 8l\swer or motion (with foo of$ \35,00 an It cQmpl",tod Cuo

Inførmatloii Stmrnent) If you wimi tliei ~urt to 1iiiar your detèruic..

TfYQ\l do llot fite; iind serva ;i. wrlttiin al1swer or motion withln 35 days, t'hQ OOurt may Ollter å

.hidgimmt agi'tliliit you for thd relii:itplliMlff domantbi, pl\lll interost l\l1d OO$1a Qfiniit. If JudQlllerit iii

entered iiguiiiat you, 'the Shrir/ff may sejze yout money, wllßeii c;ir properly to piiy all 01' part ofthÌ¡i

judgmenl

It';YQu cannot afford an attorney. you may call the Lr;igål SOrvlCllll office in the çoun~ where yinilive

or tJ\e L~giil Services of New JÐT'tIey StatewIde 'ijOtllné at 1.8Sg..LSNJ-LA W (i "88S-57is-.SS29). A (.at of'

t1iese offices Is pl'\lvlded. lfyou do not hiVl~ lIß attorney and lII'Q not QlI8ibi~ rorffcè le,iitiJ lWs(!l1im1e. you

may obtaIn II r(itenal to iin attorney hy 118l1ing ~ti~ C)fthe La: er Rln'imal ServlcÐs. A liJt Qft1iesø

Twmbcrs If) 0180 pl'Q\lidcid.

DATEP: 06/16/20'U

Namø ()fJ)~fllI1dantto Be Served; the Pai," aud SUffiiçaf CiinterutL~h~mei , if

Addteßs ofOtlfendalli 10 De Served: 820 'lown CQnIii:t OrivçJi!!~ ~OO, ~lil1glio\i'JQ! l A 19047

NOrß: TIitCiisli Tnf!;i'mlatlon SIl1lcmienllø n.vnlliiblo 61 www.ii1ooui'ta,QQllI.

ll~vlso(l O!1l01/201 0, r:.'N Ul792.r:.ngllsh (Apponill"Xir.Al

paii1i1 ~A

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 1 of 13 PageID: 10
JUN/17/Z011/FR i 11: 21 AM PAl N&SURG I CAL CENTER FAX No, 267 212 5001

,

Ðß/16/2eii 14: 29 7324932643 DEGENNARO

.D1roctt;iry of Superior Court Deputy C1erk's Offiees

A'n.AN'lTC cotJNl'Y.

County Lawyer Referral and Logal Servit:es OfiicéS . . D6p\ll)' Cltirlc øl" tJili S\lporlor CQllrl

Civil Diviaiiin, DIrect. Fllfnl.l

1201 Bll.olian!lCh .lJlvd., Pirat FI.

Atliuitl9 OL~) NJ 0&40'

B'EP.GE~ COVN".lV:

Oop\lt)' Clerk of thii SUperior Court

Civil DivislDn. Room i 15

Juølice çiints', JO MlUn St.

HBCkemlBDI(" NI 0760'

LA wyaR RBPBRR.AL

(609) 34M'l44

.i.~OAr.. SJlR. VICßS

(609) 343-4200

I.A WY.BR RßPBRll.AL

(:to!) 481l-ll/M4

LEGAL SKRVrC:es

(201) 4~7.~1GG

pU.RLti~GTON' COVNrYi

Ðopu~ Ci"",~ ofih, S\l~rior CQurt

~tltri'" Proeo.sslns; Offia~

Attn¡ Judli:liil lntako.

Fit'&t FL., Courtii Faoillty

49 \Wioiiciu Rd.

Mt. ttfoll'y,NJ 08060

CAMDl&N COUNfY,

D"I'uty Clerk onb~ Siipmor CQ1lit

civil Prnl!8l1Slug Offieii

Hnll nf JiiatlOO

!At ~i., S\.Iltc 150

J 01 South :slh street

('oIIlfldsli, N1 08103

CArt MAY còUNTV:

.()ep\ll)' C:l~tk Qftlie Supiirfor Court.

9 N. MaIn Slti:iit

('.tl)lO MlIY Court Rr;iiisi:i, NJ ()8210

Cl.JJV,Q)ERliAND Ç(i'(JNTV:

Dcpuiy Clwk of tiie Sup~ñor Colin

Civil CLUe Mallftpmcont omce

t$1l Wesl BlolIil Sùci:t

P.O. box io

'Brldaeloni NJ 08302

ESSEX COUNTY:

Ooputy CJork. oftJiø Supiirlor Court

Civil Customer St.MIlce

HI\II ¡)fltqcørc.lii, lI.oom 201

"CLS Dr. Martin J.uilIer ktii~ Ir. Blvd.

NøWlU'k, NJ 01102

LAWYEllRI!P~

(609) :Zdl"4~6~

LßGAL B'BllVICBS

(800)49~7(i

LA WVBR llBPBRRAL

(8~6) 964-4520

LUGAL S~ll,V1CES

(8"6) !16L:i,olo

LA WVB'R R.IlPBRRAL

(609) ~il63.0313

LBGAl. SRR,VJCES

(60~) 465-3001

i,A WVER REFBJUtAL

(856) 1i96-5~5(l

L'BOAL SßYl..V)OBS

(ll'e!) (ill i .04?4

LA WYRR RJ1VIBkRAl.

(~73) s22-6:w4

LBOAL SJlRVICH5

(973) 624-4jOO

RQ'JIle~ 09I011íl010. ON 1i)192-EnDIiGh (Al'ipolldlil XII-A¡

DlrettQI)' Qf Superior Court Deputy CI$rK'$ officea I QDUntt Lawyer R~rerr81llnd L.tpill Sørvloea

R&vlse~ 11~OiOI ON: 101ßß..El1glltih

P~Il.2014

P,003 D¡ig

PAGE 03IHl

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 2 of 13 PageID: 11
JUN/17/2011/FRI 11:21 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No. 267 212 5001

,

aG/iG/2011 14: 29 7324S3264:3 DE:GE~O

GLOUCESTER CO'ONTVi L,AWYEI\ RBfBRRAL

OoP\ltY Clerk llflhó 8upi;nor CoUrt (856) 848.4S8? CIvil Cai;~ M¡l.l)ii¡iommit Oflli::e I.BOAL SBRVlCBB

ALIU: T"w.ke (SSG) 848-5360

FiJi! Pl., CoUI1ß'Øi:lfil'i

J North Biood Street.

WÇIQ(;/bliry, NY 08096

IllJDSON COUNTYi LA WYBR. lUWluUl.AL

.Diiputy Cl~tk of tIle Siipiirlor Court (3~i) 798-2721

B'ilperiQf Coul'ti CIvil Ttecoma. Dtpt. LBGA:L SEl\V/GBS

'BnIJlni.w COllrt HOUl1&'.ll1t Floor

CZ01) 792.U63

583 Newàrk Avø.

Jar:io:y CIty, NJ 07306

ßUNT~n.OON COUN'.'tY i LA WY.611 RBl'lEJUlAJ.,

'plDp'llty Clerk ot t1iá' SliperfQr (lourt (908) 7i'.2C1 i i

Clvii Olvlølol1 LBOAJJ $BltVlCßS

ISS 'Pork ',AVellUIli

(908) 78'J,w7979

Fliimlnå1On, Nl O/lR22

M~ri.CER CQUNTVI. .iA WY8'R iuiFBR~AI~

Ooputy Clerk Qf1Jle SliperlQr Court (609) SU.(j~OO

LoCÌ\1 Pi lint Officll', CouMhouøt L'B(lA L SRlt VICES

1 '/5 S. BrQitil SIMet, ft.o. Box 8MB (6Q9) 695-6249

TroltloJl, Nl 08650

MI'DJ)t.ßßix COUNTY: L.A.WYER ImPBRRAL

Oepulåi CJirk otthç SuperIor Court, (132) lJ2l1-QO.53

MIddlesex vioiiiøgti LßGAL. SBR.VJOB$

2iid Floor. 'lowtir (7i2) 249.7600

~~ l~Qmon Stroiiilf, P.O. aOlC 26~.lI

Now Brunswlclc, NJ 08903.263.3

MONMotlm coUN1''li': 1.,A WYltR. amillRRAL

.Døp\ltY clCI'k øfthø SiiperlQr Cø\lrt (7m 431-5544-

Court .IlÖ\l81: l"EGAL BBltvrCBS

P.O. Bo" 1269 (1.l2) 866-0020

Pl'OOhold, NJ 0'172B. 1 269

MORRTS COUNn'= LA wYE'Ø.llBF2RRAL

MOlTif OountY (:ill1it!iOUSfl (973) il47-5Bll2

ctvii Olv!sion LBGAL SBRVICRS

Wiislilnilon iiiid Oøint 13tteels (979) 285-691 I

1'.0, ßOx $110

MorrIstown, Nl 079ii9-0~1 0

OCEAN COUNT\,1 LAWYBR. RlW~RRA1i

DQPlllY Clerk ultJie Sllfltltlof cøurt (73i) 24()"jGG6

US Wiishi'iist(lll Strçot, R.oom 121 J,..JlGAL SBRVJCBS

P.O. Box '191 (7.12) 341.:2727

TQf(J8 RJver. N1 087S4-2 191 

Rll\II&lld 01110112010. ON 107ll2-!1I(I1I$l\ (Appvndlii XII.A)

Olrecloiy of supiirlor Court Deputy cltll'k', O(ftçes 1 COunty Lawyer RI'l'srral and liigtil $ervlçc/l

Revised 11/2010, eN: 1 ci11SS-Sn/Jlilih

Paiiii ~ llf4

P,004 g¡ig

PAGE Ø4/18

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 3 of 13 PageID: 12
JUN/17/2011/FRI II: 22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL GENTER FAX No. 267 212 5001

ß6/16J2aìi 14:29 7324932643 DEG~NNARQ

PAS$AIC C()UNTVr

Diplll)' CIQrk oftlui IJUperior Coon

Civil DSvlølDn

t6urt ffoii.~l'

77 Hnmilton fltN:et

Piitersrm. 'NJ 07'05

Mr.-1M COUNTYI

DØpufN Clctrk oflJto Suporior Court

Attn: CMI Ciise MßllAQOlfitiiit OffiOB

Q2 Mark-lit Street

Siiliim, NJ 08019

SOMERS&TCOl;JN'J.'V;

DepUIY Clark atthe $\lPorlQr Court

eM' DivIsIon

P.O. Bi;i)( 3000

4() North .Rridsc StRut

Bomtirvlll", N.J. "8$76

SUBJ:1ÊX CO'tJNTV~

D~j)\lt.Y ci.,k oftha StJpel'l'or Co\lri

SOltÐOli Coun~ ¡"dIDlal Ciinter

13-47 HI2b StIm

Newton, NT 07360

tJN10N COl1.NTV,

.Oeputy'CIOTkofihø 5upelÌD'i' COllrt

1 st Fl., Cöiut Houso

2 Broad Street:

BIlz:iibet/i, NT 07207-6073

W A'RREN COUNTV.

Deputy Cleric offhii 6uporÎorCoUJt

CIvlI DI'ViM(.irl Office

COlirt Hausa

413 Second Sii-t

Bclvidiirfli NJ 07823.1'00

LA WYRR kE.rnRRAL

(973) 271-9223

LEGAL SB~V1CBS

(973) 523-2900

LA WYsrt IUill"ßRMt,

(S~d) !i3,.,G29

I'BQAL 8BRVlC8S

(856) 451 -0003

LAWYUR..lUWSRRAL

(908) (iS$-2328

UJUAL SBltVrci;i.s

(908) 23 Jo.OB40

LA WYBR Rnpp.ft,RM

(g13) ~67..sB32

t.aOt\L SBRVlÇES

(973) 383-7400 .

LAwvER. MFBRRAL

(?OS) ;'$3-471 S .,.

LßOAL SBR,ViCFB

(SlO8)'$S~4340" .

LAWYRR RHPERML

(973) 267w5R82

M~dMB2RVrCBS

(9D8) 475-2010

AtJ'llOOCl Oe/OIIJlQlO, eN 107Ð2Æ~lloh V'J1~enilb! XII.A)

Dlrcctoiy of Supel1Ol' court DellUly Olerk'a Offlociil OQl,lnty Lawyer Reftiia.ll.1nd l.egai Servlc"

Revised 1112010, ON: 101~3-i;¡ngllsl1

P,005 O¡ig

PAGE 96/18

Pílge4 or4

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 4 of 13 PageID: 13
, .

86/15/2011 14129 7324932643

JUN/17/2011/FRI 11:22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER

OE:aENNAli!Cl

FAX No, 267 212 5001

PAGE lB/1a

Alfred D~Glmniii'Q1 Baqulre

Alfred Di'lOennaro LLC

12 Cbrlswphsr Wiiy~ Suiic 200

EMOntowli, NJ 07724

731.493~82 i J

MI"(I. Alioe Ú'Brien

Plilintlfl'

VS.

'lbø Pa.in aud Súrgiçal Center of LlllJshomø

;Ooctor Phillip Sl\llllQ

))croiidaotii

P,006 D",g

Fru:o

.. .1'1'-

MAY 3 1 2011

:

SUPERIOR COURT

OF' NBW JSRSBY

i./11JS' plÓ' I \

OCEAN CO'ONTY

Lii.w Divliricn-eÎvil Part

Civil Actlon No,

Complaj,gt iuid jury Demond

Plaintiff, by and tbroug/;i iJ:l¡ tJndorsíS'J,cul couBllel fîl~ thiii coml?làlnt 112~inet PiifÐüdiUlt" biinBini

1iiis action for rolief. BrlSl,t)~ t.l'?in Plalhtlff, Alice O'Brion Age R7, faJlffig At The l'am l\.nd Surgid~ CenbM

()t LallgIi01'.ll.e wbi.le waUr.Îi;ig- to reoiiMng injections for her 1l'øa.tm.;lnt nf iiipmiil stcnoiiiJ. by bet tnmting

Jihyøioliin Dr. PhUlp $8$80 as well WI their fkfhiro to admJnls~pii.~ J:ßJiflfa:ller the fun. malntiff, A1içc

O'Briøli (who sufi'ered a dIslocated should"" lind cont\lSloiis iuid abl'WliQD.Ø to her :Oioe) aUßg/)s t\iiú' tlio

(le1:'end~nta iiwed the Plaintiff a 4uty and faJiee:i: t6 pcrtbrm tJmt duty Wlä:iln IlI'J äOCl0piabie s~dard Qf

medical oarl!J tbrougb f.uade'luatei iiup~iii())1 whUo iibo was walklp,g ~v.iJ :fu,lIure to treat lwr injlU'iaB øítót

she fell. Dö:lòndmils also breIlCl1fl~ tbeir duty by ori:Unl\JY N"gliglSnlia resurt¡(lg i11 the taU and tho faili.rro to

administer tbt aid/pain relief. ~iiiintiít now brliigs this 8Qtlop olaÎmllll Medical Malpractice Il~ w~1l Øj

ordìnti.ry Negligen~Q.

Pagelon

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 5 of 13 PageID: 14
JUN/17/201 I/FR I ¡ I: 22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER

FAX No. 267 212 5001 Po 007 g;iO

a6/16/~eii 14: 29 7324932643 ÐE:lìENNARO PAGE 11/16

III support ffii:lrt()f,. pJabitiff allogcs,qtl fuUOWll1

S'l ATEM.RNl' O~ .mRJSDClTION ANO V.BNOB

rial.utitlpre$$lltl1 is mid was a le8fd~t ofOciian COuiity NeW' JOMW at l1te tbnc thIs cause of Ilotion

aro9ti, Thi$ ~ t'Jf~'lion iir16$9 fuJm ttia Plainti1l;, AlIe:e O'.Brlen Age "7, fldJinS md di9locatfn~ her

èho'llldel'lIt 1be :Pain and. surgical ~nti;ir oftansLorn~ whiio walking to ~ÎV$ tò reeei'Va ktatmiiill fer

hor $pìnlll islmiQsjs, by hor tl'oatlog physiçiaD n', PlilUp SQUó nii w~1 wiihc fjiilum oftbo Dë6mdants.to

udn,ftll.lloJ' 1I1odicaJ iitæntioXl for pain reJiefllttert11e fall. 'nIo ~4Ìfi 8I/d Siirtlcal CentcrofLaiighomcls

lo~d in .tanghòine P(l'tlt.l$Ylys,niii approxbxiiiteiy 8 nnløs from Trciritoii, New lèf8ey, M~. All"", O'Bt1eJJ

WB3 a psitf0l1t oftb$' l)Gfmidånm imd tum visited tliö surglord QGjlter for hmo tfnt trciitni(lnt tlpprø.¥úiiately i

:~f)ats prlOl to tIiG ~ojdimt. After tiul first tteBlmeiit sha wiiii asked m malæ a new appoin1mößt, Priót

iJisous:ilQijS wlth Doctor SiisIlO indicated tJillt the tRiatmmts would Dot lui OD a reguJiil' a"hiii4ul~; 110 she

I~P.lalnoo "be wQuld. ~um whtm tho l'ilW would indJØii 1bu iiëiäl, Sh_ riri.\lmod for appro~ly 3

mof'Ø t.reatmcritii9lJd on Ot iibout ~ :zit. 2009 she *ii iiftçt lifip1lng ln aiid beginning t(J walk to the

irii:atmeiit fOQtll whc:n 'the !lbi.tfö'1embër responsiblo fur iii~rting horwn1kod am oftellOh. Plølntiff Bl1soiù

that th¡' New JfØ;'Wy Superl.Qr Court hu 6poçifio jur.ilidlotWii over tlds caiui (luI) to the priut" Mà~II$hmelJ.i

e;i.f4n ongoing doinuT piitient rdationshlp witho".citizm of Now J~ by nie Pain and ~iqìcal .ClJl.ter of ,

LÐJlsJi()nUt III\(I Dr. $asSQ wMa'" bcpn s,pprox;lwJJtoi,2 Ycål$ priM to 1he llocldcmt and tJJc ~a:irts

sQlloitation rol'l'laioli1lto nitùm. In atJditiDtJ given the 8 tune ptexlnuf;y ofilio PaÙl ønd Siirgjoid Ccntot .

ofl;iWab(lqtll ro flkC 8ime Cápitid of Tnmton, Now J~ Ilfiould 8J1ClOîßu juri~ititl(l.n "0 ii1iailongèd

do1aUed dlsc.ov~ ~bould tWbiblísb gòtletal iiirliu:lliit.lon, inlkpendv.ntly Qr bolsær Plaiiititrs arsiiment

ooncemlng speo.î.tlc jllriiidtctloir.

nm PAk'l'IBS

1) piahiti1f, Mrs. Alice otllrlei.n. Age 31 residi.lliJ tlt 22 ~w.icb Ave" Mmichestert County of

Ocean. NJ 08759

2) .Déteodiint, The .Pain iwd S\ll'gÎcal cehter oftangbOlIlu . 820 Towii Ctxrter D~, Sufte 200~

' Lllllghomß, Buoks Comity, PA 1~047

Fage2of7

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 6 of 13 PageID: 15
JUN/17/2011/FRI 11: 22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER

FAX No. 267 212 5001

86/16/2011 14: 29 7324932643 DE~NNARO

3) Defendmlt;. Doomr Philip SlIllllO, Plaintilr$ treating pli;yiiioilm at The P~n 8l1d Sur$loal Center of

Langhimia i 82Q 1Qwn Cimtar D1iVl11 Sul~ 200, lailgJJ()me, B~ks COUiity, PA 19047

FACTS COMMON''lO ALL COUNTS OF'lHE COMPLAINT

i) PliiintüE Mm. Alice O'Orlim, W~ l;eiîn~ mmæd fll Th~ P4Ui aM Surgical Cctit.or ofLtiogl\OIllo fòt

SpÎltll SlimlJllÍlJ, by blSl' troiltÎtig p~lclaii Dr. )llUJip fSU$Q.

2) The PlÚn Md SurSíoaJ Center of l..angltorot Is 1()Çl~ in luishome Panl)aylVil!i'Cl approxfmatcl)l8

miles from ~too" Nòw Jerse,r.

:3) Mni. A1l(le O'Srlen, a ros/dent õrMaiioltll(lter, New Jørti6Y. nicdvod har Drst1realmeot at The Pain lind

Surgical Center ofLan3bome apprQximatol,. 2 yeam prior'to thu IItlcideiit wlili:il\ ooo~tred i)1I or about

May 28, 2009.

4' AftÐrtbe first treiiJ.ment .IIh. was aøkod to m. a now appoiiilinimt. Prior dtBQus¡iii;ms witli Th;iotor

Siiaso indlçate4 thBl thø pain tmitmenb WQutd' not be QII a rc¡u1ar 8OhoduJe. $0 sli, e'I!PJa1lied sho wouJd

1'lrtv.rA when the pain indli;iii1W tho 1i"'fJd.

5) Sho rCllumed tòr ap)nwdmatoly 3 rnOJ'l miatniOllI$liJ'J.d on Ok' abomMIlY 28t 20ô9 atlet mgnlns In fur

thii:t treiitmim4 Mra. O'Brien wa,. being eaaomd 'ki the b1laIment room, when the $la1f mcmbør (lS(¡Qrtlng

her wa\tç44 up lIh~d Md WlIB.oo 100gOl' Gtiaiøfng 01\ het ~idc 6nd the~re out of reaoh of Mrs. O'Brien.

6) Mrs. O'Brien then feU ditilocatIn:e Iiét M01JlcJ"t iind mf'fmns collfniiions and abiasioiis1i) hoi' fåOe.

p,age 3 of7

P.008 g¡iD

PAGe: 12/18

~

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 7 of 13 PageID: 16
JUN/17/2011/FRI II: 22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No, 267 212 5001 P,009

a6/1ç/2Ðii i 4: 29 1324g32g4~ bl!:GENNMO PAGE 13/ia

7) PliiìJltfti: in uianîiln¡ páÌll tepe.il'leI:lJr reqlJ~ 8lie be lli'liliid with ber. daughter Carol ~Dl Who

WlliI in the Wllftinii room.

8) Th~ rellp'on6le to tboiie ~ 'WflS slow adinOlJto the 6motloiiøl dlS!tCSS the :rhihititf.wwi

cxperionaÍQg,

9) lláinfltf f(lçelaed 110 mc!dicaJ iraiIriie1it fbI' palri relief alhir hitd' 1à!l by eitbør her tiwdii:ig physician. Dr.

Suso, Qr any øilier electors at The Pain and SUrgfoal Centiør of LimghMJc:i. Defendti.tlts merely a.rtiiriged to

have PIlIlrrtltftakm fl) St. Møy'G Hospiim by aiiibidiuiçe.

10) PlAintÎft'was in an flIcapacfbnÐd ~lin& tiw approxmiately' 4-5 week$ tlild 81liO ieoeì'll'ed thllNiP1 ee88ionl

during tliat time 4tul 1Illtll tb., first WëeX; of¥mbtt 201J9. Ditri""t1ie period ofhC'l'.t'tltasc from tho

hoaiitiil $¡lei ffirough the fiftltweelc QfSepfÐmber of2Ø09 iifie was !ivins witli hcr dai,igJa'ler Carol who

tel1ded lu hor pørso.oal us WéJl fwuschQtd needs,

11) Aftot tho Q.C(líderitMs. OlÐrîl.'ll1 ret:umed 'in tll& ~ for D1ØM visits thrqugñ tñe SUIlb\1b:t oUOll

12) As 51 pronii;iiite manIt of the Qrdiiimy oegllselJCi). 6S well as the biMch oftbc appIlC4bJo sWidards of

tllldloal caw (p.ro$9sioiial nti81jgoJlI;lll) by The Piiin and Sut¡ical CenærofLøiigllome end Dr. SIIS$Q. the

PlaÎntiff 5UffilrGd: (1) II dislOQlliwd Ilhouldor fmd QQAtusjQiJll aiid abI1isÎWll to be.r &00 (2) t'motmOll$ puio

(:J) pat llll1otlonal dl~ and (4) ciiQlmQUS Iniioiiven'(!'lJoø inclndiiigtlic:i mabiliW to tetid to her ¡)erscnal

8l1d bomiohold needs diiitng a:3 month period. PI~ Ml1;l. AJrcti O'Brleii DOW &Ilea:

COUNT X .

PLAINTIFF VIi. :Ð.'E'FENDA.NlS' OJU)JNA.l'tY NliOtlO.ENæ FOR lNAJ).BQUA'm

SOPER-VISION'

Page4of7

gila

ø

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 8 of 13 PageID: 17
JUN/17/2011/FRI I i: 22 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No,267 212 5001

e6/1G/2~1i 14 i 29 7324932643 DE~i;:NNARD

13) .lIltlitlIff; Alfi::o O'.Ðrieii, inaQJ'POl'tft(lB by.re1lbænoo all Other pani~1i8 ottJds IJompllint I~II ¡fibUy set

.rQlt!i here and on mfonnatlon I1t'(d belief further aUo~ åll follows:

.(4) Both Dø&iidAnø 1lAtJ a duty to Plinnli1ffo a.dequan,iy supervise Plldnflftwhile wa3lcJns totbe

l.m\'tlI1ent roOM afuir iihø signed in and tiitXed to piidomi 1hat dut,y wJthlii an acceptable mdard.

'( $) The mUure to pio\IJdo that adequlIte supervisIon WlI8 an Intwi1ionølltJld miklcs& omission.

16) WBEREFORE. PlaløtlffxoopeotlùUy asks the Courtirant tho piafntlfflljoogmenrtllllt tho ~dmiis

bxeãciiød thclr dUW and awiitding PJailitlt'f ~ii dlll)liiitia punilJve dmagcm, attommy We". iwd aJJ i;ø~i

COUNTIr

PLAJN'J1F.lf vs. 'O.BPBNDANT8t ORDlNAll.YNOOLlOrmcJ::.FQ:R. P'AJLINtl 1'0 P:ROVlDE

FIRsi' AJJ) ,AND TREAtMENT AFJ'BR 't.FJ.E PLAINTIFF FBLL

J 7) Pla.iirtltt AUevi O'Elrlem. hietirponiteii ~ rvifemnÇ(i idJ othClr paniiiniPbs ofthfs oompJl1ll1t as fffully sot

forth hi'd'8 and on iiiíomiation wid bf.llleifurtbol wlage" as foU()\V$:

~$) iiotJi Defiindwi1s hiid II; duty to lllalntlffto provide first aid tniatmont after fler All Md thoy fåited A\

ii~Qim that dut¡y.

) 9) The: lWlurci to provide that f.lr6t ald Md fJ:ea.imant wu au UitentionaJ Bud i'tcldøss omission.

20) wmntBFölUl, P1aîritif:tteS~Uy MIG 1bø 00\111 to ~ tho 'Pfiiintlft' 4JI'l~_ t1ii'itthc

D~ndaiitii brcacliC(l. ~ejf dU\f lII1c\. awarding PJatiitift'all damllBt:i, pO'Ditivo diunages. attomey ~ tmd

illløo~.

COUNtnI

Pago$of7

P,OIO

PAGE 14/18

D¡ilj

,.

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 9 of 13 PageID: 18
JUN/17/2011/FRI i i: 23 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No, 267 212 5001 p, 01 i

PAGE 15/19

D¡ig

Øó/16/201i 14: 2S 7324932643 VEGEi.MRO

PLAINTIff V8. D~DANT8' l'R01l'.BSSIONAL NEOLtOENCB POR INADaQlJA't,ij

SUPmtVJ8l0N

2 () Phlintift; Alicø O'Brien, lncorpOta14S by n1lireooe ii11 other ~h8 ottbfrJ C4tnpJaint as if &lly &et

forth li~ and Q2l bdIil'JJJ8.Uqn ~d bollof1\irtber alIeSftll M toUoW:!:

:22) J30tb Def.fndantii had 8 dutyto llalntlfft'ø iu!sqiiiiwly 5Upfrviøe llaliitiWwbili:i \'r"AMas; to tlic

I;i'èatlUótit room for ''pmal $kifiosjs treatmlJlt atter lIhø lJIgiii:ii;l in BJld fi'd'eit to I*form that d1ity wHbfn an

iiaoøptablø stBhdiml otmet!iiml WIl.

:i~) The faUnre to provlde 1hiit iuJ~ im~iOll Was au In_troDaI and 1'e'llc)0!II1ii omiMiøn.

?A) WHEImFOR.E., PJa:intiff reipeçtftiU.y iisq 1M Ço'Urt ¡m-¡t tho P'BÎn.tiff' aju(fgtnent1liat bøth the

l)i,fcmd8nts breached 1IleÎrdlliY to p~ withln BJl accqJttfblë støndiird ofmed~J caw and awarding

l)laintiff ai, damages, punitiv.ei diiml\~ atromey fC'éii. and all 00.

COTJNTrv

n.AJ.NUFF~. PBFBNDANT$' PROFESSIONAL NBOLlGBNCEFOR ABAN,POMNG

T.HBlR.RESPONBIÐlLi:TJ.BS TO T.RBAT THBIR PAT.l.EN',l

25) PWiitla; AIled O'Rrieii. Ï11òOrpcntø5 by tofimmllO all cihiit ~s oftfds complaJDt as itiwJy Stt

fi)rt1i run aii.d on lntormi.ltimi III1d belief I\irther IiUeges os toUIJ'Ml:

,.

26) Bo1Il ~øntiJ had a diiiy tó :P14iatüff.\) provide mi:idical c:ineIJl~ roelîcd'àfttir 1ha :Plalntltftø fall (Ill

they WOrtll her ~nB pJ~øilui:!l mxd tliGy macbed tliM duly to provl(lö medical care.

2'1) Tho falliito to pi'O\"Jde tIlat medioal ciire Was ftlJ inteiitlonal ~d mQkless omlssli:in.

. 28) WHEIUlFOn' Pláiritíff'resptllUùUy ask1 the Court _I the llai.iiiiff' ajudsmerrt 1lill.t thø.DcfciiidAniii

brtiAObOO ttJoit duf¡y to :PrOvide said modÌlllIl çace aud awarding PialntiffaU diimagß.'i.. p\U1itivo Wimagøll,

atlomiiy fOr¡iIi, and alI i;osJii.

l"l\M(t of7

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 10 of 13 PageID: 19
JUN/17/2011/FRI 11:23 AM PAIN&SURGrCAL CENTER FAX No, 267 212 5001

86/1&/2611 14i 29 79249~2643 DEGENNARO

1lr..~f)g Atfred lllll'O;. ~

Attiimcy fur Plaintiff'

a~IONATlON OF '.lRIA.L COUNSJlt.

S.JI-U

PW'l:IUlIl1ttô New J6J1'OY Còurt Rule4:2S4.. Álfuid PeGciimiuo. BiiqUli:e. is hea.'eby' &isigniit.e¡j WI triad

Qoim~oJ fur ebt Plaintjff. in tbø abwo rtlotmr.'

*IJ¿:: Mi.ii

Cim:rwicAnON O;F NO omBRACTIDNS .

PnrsU8DttQ Niiw .røniey CoUtt ltiue 4:$-1 b(2), it tlf hereby stated tbåtthv rnåt1llr ùi OOIltroveriiy fs nolth0

iiubjèQt of $lly otlltti' ~ ~dIl1g in l1iY other QOurt (il' afa pending ~oii proooedini to tliè b$st ôf

my ~owi. or oofiøt: Alrm. to thø hast ofmy holief, no other actlon or arbltmtion proceedidQ is

.

tOntiimp)lIbl(l Tlow&ver, otlitlr'tlwi the piutie.s set forth In thIA pleaitlng more pältÌeii QI~ 'bejoincd If

dl~övoiy tbrougn tbis lawsuit pn;idUQef the DllQles or otiMpdttÎès liubJe. In addifion, l ~gnlzei the

(I(lntInulng obJipiion'of each ~ 1.0 filti iiiid Øervll on all palli/1lll and tbill Ci)wt il.ii MlOlldcd cetdficatíoñ

If ibn i!i a. chaiigt in tlie faota øtlW4 in tiiti; orismai ceitifi~oii.

S~3 1.:11 .

.nr.RytlEMA'ND

P:li.Ù\t.rft; fiAt'e.by clet.itand friar hy Ajur;v on all ftlable ~8Ues riiJsed in tIiiíl compliiin~ purnUßI1t 10 New

New Jet&l:Y Court R~l/1l 4:3S~I(a).

.f&dd.. Æ.d. 5.31-11 ~óttiînn~.

CERTlFlCA nON IN i\CCORD.A1IJCB WITH RULE J :38-'7 (B)

i cmí£Y that (:(iiißdcmtilif po1'IlØlliil identìfiéi's have ~ ~ fi'(,m dOQtmieiiUl now ~utmiltWd tt) the

ai) ~ool,lmi:mci snlmiitled in tii.1litiirø illllJ)Cl)fd.ii(iCtHliith Riil1.'1 i :38~7(b)

..;ii..l1

Page 7 of1

p, 012 . Dt'O

FAcar:: 16/1e

p

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 11 of 13 PageID: 20
JUN/17/2011/FRI 11:23 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER

06/1~/2611 14; 29

FAX No. 267 212 5001 P,013 D¡iO

7324'332643 nEGI;NNARO PAGE 17/16

Atmeiidh m-Bt,

CIVIl.. CAse INFORMATION STATlSMENT

(CIS) .

Use fer Inrtr~1 law Dlviiiion .

olvn Part pleadIngs (not motíons) undel' Rule 4:5-1

If Infonni!ltron abovctl the b/llGk bàr rs tlot compieted

ö... atl:ornilly'A SigiiëltU~8 fs not afflXVd

AlTORNEV I PROSIi! NAMl! TaEPHONi¡¡ NUMI!IER

Alfred De@BnmilO. I:squlr(l (732) 4g~a~11

lll~M NAMIE (If ePPIICllblli)

Alfred DeGennaro LLC

OI'AI)I!Ati£l~fž8S

. 12 C::hrll!ltopher Wi.iy, SuIte 200, £:ati:iiitown. NJ 0'T124

COUf.trv Óp veNUe

OQ~sn

i;iOCKET Nl.JMÐr=R (wh~n "..;illablii'

. . '- 'II) -(

OOCUMÉlN'r'r.(P1!!

COMPLAINT

JURY tJl:MANO . YEI; 0 No

NAMEI oii PARlY (tug., JnM ClO6, PIi!Jin~rf)

Alia" Q'Brlen - Plaintiff

CAe~: TYPE NUMaER ($ee re\l61'$\) Ilkfa for iiiH~)

e04

RELATED OASES PltNQING'1

o Yiiii . No

00 YOUANTIOIPArr::AfJOIN~ ANY PARl'l;¡¡:

(Ø~I¡i!i oiit tlr.sp,mii trllnliøCllon Qr iiccuireni:.)?

O~ .NO

NAMr:! 01= r;ll!I"'ENDAN'r8 PRIMARY INSUAANCi;¡ COMPANY (iff(nQWR)

Hea!th~ia", Prøv/dem InSl1rtmoo eccherigoi

i:i Not-I!

tJ LJNlfmWN

~.

MA'f 3 1 2011

00 YOU OR voim cuimrNli1iO AMY tillJA!lIUTY ACOOi.iI.lODATlONS? 1G,: '0 Y~3 . No

WILL t\N IN'tWIlEl'ER Be NIlI!llE(l'"

o YES .NQ

" ClÐrUfythat co'nddenflal PlIl'$QßdJ IdÐntr

flldacted frum nllllQbUmønta: LIbiri/no

IF VIlli. ~LI!AIlI! IOIsNliFV

II' y¡¡¡¡, PÖR WNIIT lJ\NGl,IA .

hay 111l(t1l redlllltød n'cm dOèuinlinUl now subm'lted to .tl1' court. lind Will be

e m In l(oc;otdilnCQ with RUle 1 :ae~7(b',

ATTORNF.l' $IONATURf: r--~ 3/-11

paJle 14ti

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 12 of 13 PageID: 21
JUN/17/2011/FRI 11:23 AM PAIN&SURGICAL CENTER FAX No, 

267 212 5001

ø6/i6/2à11 14: 29 73249326qa

DEGENNARO

P,014 D"a

PAGE lS/IS

f ~ I ~ i Ij Sai~ ~, ~ ~~ s i~ S . D

S ~;~, of r §B 5~lj l d iR š~: , ~"'I

a'm N i as l y ; Ia§~ , m ijl I - ~ I

j '~i '. ~ I! "l' I

~ ~.s ',1 aSij

taii Ii a , ~ t'ø"

('t11 I c, i ~

B~~~5 l~ I S l i~~ I

l'~l" 8S IH1. IllS::: Ð Mi' rfi ! i ii l ~f .,

~ø , "S :, I I if- l!

i

. .,

Case 3:11-cv-04083-PGS-TJB Document 1-2 Filed 07/18/11 Page 13 of 13 PageID: 22