~\ 'RU\)~ ~(o. D1sC.Rt:T10NAR~ rn:vxeW Il\) G B\'lE Ra·t. LPI 11Ltg-os,eu,cn,f8 

RECEIVED IN 

COURT OF, CRIMtNAL APPEALS 

MAR 16 2015 

/ 

...... ·.·· .. 
RuLE &>,.1, Wz7t·t o~ W:z:rnouT PB7ZI:ZdvJ 

7'/,.e. ColJ.V't ··.of cy{M(n~} fippc~:1s' r~~v re-view~- Ca"Wv-~ 

t;:>·t.· ~fl'ea.o~· .. J , ec/s/o';., /11 rtil c r1 'Y'Y1/nal ce.tJ"e oh )t;a- t:t~J ~ 

ti·pv'·tge# t/v..rp tvt~1eier l(w/e tbl ~--r ~h thJ?... pet)i;,;ia't# o·.f.? "' ~ biJI " . · JlJ 11-Jt • f) A J -~ l (!? . e~·- "~ ~~ ~f. ~r~t;r.r~-r n rb'&' ·~ ~)(:jt~ 

·, 
Ru.~e b" ;), tVo7 l.J /JIJp;·;: 7''EJN~ oF R<ZGHT · 

P·iS~Y e.ti ()\r\.a,'(""y. r-evielAJ• Jy !:f}.,e. ~u~t of? Ca--6~(ne~o »pp~Js 

rs n.ot_.r a me.vt;·~ of ru~h·t; bu:~ o:.f t<hA Co~t·~b~ dt~'~·e.ctio~ .
~uLE ''· 3. l'?~tYS't~hJS' rove. (;tf~~N"fZNG R~:Iv:Z!'W 

Wh n e . nel·t:h-e'f- C~'V\-tir"tJ l t. if~~ t'lO'r .. ft.dt y me~Ur\ r'\9 {{he. Cour-t" af 

Cn"rvlon~\ Ytffeo.\s1 olls~etit~V~ , ~he .followir.g wiH be C@'r>~id~ 

ev.,ed .. br t:h·C? Co~trt on decH:J .. ~nsg w~t'~r to 71r0t,n.t d.sc..,r-etloha,'r-y re.vre w: 

(a) whet;·he~ a eourt of appec~JI oJ.ec,~r)'dh ce:r-n.P,Irc:ts with 

Ct \'10trh~e'r CO~' r- b. 0 f G\i)pea.~S) a/€CtS~6w1 0" ~-~t ~m.e; 

iSs wet; 

(~) wl".e~J~ .. r a cou,rt uf ~~,-ea.!.r hqs dec,eJ~d 0.111 ,~Vt',p<'rh"' 

Ca.n b q_~€Sb\'O ~ of f'i:t'Ct ~e ~y- keierQ.u/ 1~. w -~sJ,Q. tr Ac,s 

ri@b /;eet;O)i. bUt sh~~tld he) seh~\ecJ by ~hce CaL.ttr~ of 

C\r\~~.\·f\.q,\ ¥~~ PlQ~~ed r; ~) whet \~r o. Co'\A.r~y, ~~ ~ppf!Cli.\S' 1-.o-.r decJd.eel o..,.,. 

i""" ~ ef"<' teA\"\~ ~ \AeS:b I 0 VI () f s !:Ate 0 r fec:Je'f"O,j /CWJI f..:n c::t WO\¥ 

thG\ b. co\~~)t~c..ts w, ~'h \s"'.c.. G\~~h·c.~hle a!ecAsro~s o~ b'h.Q... Co~,~·~ of C'«,~\.~Q.\ Y\p~\s ~ ~"'-t. Su.tve~e Cou~ 

C)f ~-''h~t. u~\a~ S~\:J!S; 

) whet::her ~ CO~l.,t of' ~~eaJr ha> decJatJ!.d a )tc...Wt;£1 

rt..~!.ej regu/Cl-t;fiJn1 O'V O'Yq/hOI. n~ UnCOnJ·ts/but/dfl)ctiJ) OY 

~p?€et.,...r 6o Aav,e m/s- c"'nst:r·ued ~ sea~.\L4te; -~'u).e4 ~Lj}a,is-l't:Jn1 OY 0 Ydl}t1&1,/J'IC.e; .. 

(e) whet;ker ~M Ju;-bC..es 01~ a Cou~rc ol' a;~eee.Js frtCL~ 

dtJ.qfJir·ee.J Oh q .fl'·'lff4ter~4'ctl lf:'l/! 2UeS61dYl of. Ja..w 

n-eces.?Cil")' if~ {;;'/t,e Cc?Urt ~ declfJ:r:;n,,· qne/ 

(If) whe-t k'r .o.. Co~""- c .r o.-~f.e.aJS hOts Sa fo.._v ·de~rteol ho'rv-t 

~ hR 0\. C..Ce? ~eol 0... rd USUC\\ CoV\-Y".S"e 0 f J \...loA,' C.lG\l r~ YO c.e-ecJ~h~S; 

Or SO h'<"' Sc::\."<\C.. \:\a~e_ol SUe"'- C... oA epo...-..r~~~ ,b~: Q. } oW€X' 

<=:o\...t.~l C\.S \:.o Co..,\\ fa~ v...~ exev-c\se. o-P t~ Couv-t- a ..fl 

C,y-,~~\ Yt ppeevl.s) pow,e.., o·f SLJ.-p-e~v''~''"'O~ 
Rule- b h~ i..l, Poe UW\~lJ-rs 7tJ J!)zD "bgc..xs:uN . 

(0 ) . ACq_,vtiri n-'J Doc.u.rY\e-\\'t;.S, 7h~ (our":. r::> F Cv\V"n,"'o...\ r.+ppea.-ts-

-o v- o.-""'1 ~ u~ e. o ~ \s'hct Cov,;d;, -mo:y a--role,... t:hR cau.>-t a fl. 

4-pp·eevls c.eyk b-o tJroY"vl.pt'\y ~e.-~ t\"t ~ll~,·'n<jS >ta "t;;\.e. Co\A.r-t 

;"' ov--oleir b-o a\ol i~ ih olecfol.f'hS w h.e.A5~Y" 1:;o ~ra.-"'~ d,·sc..r-ets,·u~­

Dttr y re llt'ew .. · 

(~) b:he_ evfpeJlC(;t-;€ r-e.c.on:ij 

tl) ~ copy e1~ e A.e o?/h/~n o~ ~ie cot.J~t oP appeo.,ls;,~ ·:1 

{S) a. Co fY d/- /s~e IY?Ot;~o ns //Jed' 'n t;'~t. cout"t. of' 

Cip~ls; qh~ . . . 

(~) cer c-r fteo~ coptes of CA.v-..y judgm~~~ O'r oy-~"" · 0 .f ~n-e 

c.ou~~'t. o + ~f-pectl~, · 

Lb) Reb~rn c); 'Doc.U'r-r\~""~~~ Zl; olJsc.,y-etda~.~v_y rev,'ew .,'s 

hOb Cj'f'C\.·'r\ \¢d) t h,e_ \C} <Z-'r \C:: 0 f- i;'~ ~UYt CJ ( U\~f'C\Cv\ 

4-fpea/s wt'l/ r~&uv--}'1 i::M ~opeJI~be. recoYd b-" ~l\.-( 

LoUr-b a f C\rp ectls e ) ex- k..