Exhibit L 

Case 2:11-cv-01576-KM-MAH Document 96-12 Filed 02/07/14 Page 1 of 4 PageID: 2842
Barghout, et al. v. Bayer Corp., et al. (Case No. 2:11-cv-01576-DMC-JAD)

Defendants' Supplemental Privilege Log

August 13, 2013

Priv Log # DateSent Document Type From To CC BCC Description Privilege Asserted

BBE-PRIV-001 8/25/2011 Email and attachments Todd Williamson William Klemick, Esq.;

Sandra James

Email and attachments requesting

legal advice related to US HEOR

organizational hierarchy in the context

of ongoing litigation.

Attorney-Client / Work Product

BBE-PRIV-002 9/9/2011 Email Sandra James Todd Williamson Pam Cyrus

Email containing legal advice re: V.

Barghout's grandfathering period in

the context of ongoing litigation.

(BBE000030334)

Attorney-Client / Work Product

BBE-PRIV-003 8/29/2011 Email and attachments Todd Williamson William Klemick, Esq.;

Sandra James

Email with documents related to the

US HEOR organizational hierarchy

provided to counsel at the direction of

same related to Barghout's return to

work and in the context of ongoing

litigation.

Attorney-Client / Work Product

BBE-PRIV-004 4/14/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-005 5/4/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-006 6/10/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-007 8/3/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-008 4/13/2012 E-mail and attachments Michael Virgintino Michael Irons

E-mail reflecting advice of counsel re:

attached STI presentation for

employees.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-009 4/30/2012 E-mail Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-010 9/28/2012 E-mail Cynthia HughesCoons, Esq. Michael Irons Legal advice related to compensation. Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-011 9/28/2012 E-mail Michael Irons Bill Hassan, Esq. E-mail seeking legal advice re: nonexempt sales employees. Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-012 7/22/2010 E-mail and attachments Sean Kolb-Hunt Michael Irons

E-mail with attachments reflecting

request for and provision of legal

advice regarding assessing litigation

risk in light of recent litigation against

other pharmaceutical companies.

Attorney-Client

1

Case 2:11-cv-01576-KM-MAH Document 96-12 Filed 02/07/14 Page 2 of 4 PageID: 2843
Barghout, et al. v. Bayer Corp., et al. (Case No. 2:11-cv-01576-DMC-JAD)

Defendants' Supplemental Privilege Log

August 13, 2013

Priv Log # DateSent Document Type From To CC BCC Description Privilege Asserted

BBE-PRIV-013 10/8/2010 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons Dorothea

Renner

E-mail and attachment providing

information re: pay equity study

performed under direction of counsel

for purposes of providing legal advice.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-014 4/14/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail and attachment providing

information re: pay equity study

performed under direction of counsel

for purposes of providing legal advice.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-015 5/4/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail and attachment providing

information re: pay equity study

performed under direction of counsel

for purposes of providing legal advice.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-016 5/9/2011 E-mail and attachments Sean Kolb-Hunt

Michael Irons; Mike

Virgintino; Dara

Robifker

William

Klemick, Esq.

E-mail re: legal advice on pay equity

study. Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-017 6/10/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail and attachment providing

information re: pay equity study

performed under direction of counsel

for purposes of providing legal advice.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-018 6/30/2011 E-mail Dara Robifker Myra Rosen; Pat

Johnson

Michael

Virgintino;

Michael Irons

E-mail with redacted portion

reflecting advice of counsel re:

attached STI presentation for

employees. (BBE00049174)

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-019 8/3/2011 E-mail and attachments Dara Robifker Michael Irons

E-mail related to privileged pay equity

study performed under direction of

counsel.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-020 3/22/2013 E-mail and attachments Bill Brenneisen Dara Robifker; Michael

Irons

E-mail re: LTI plan referencing legal

advice from counsel. Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-021 7/22/2010 E-mail and attachments Sean Kolb-Hunt Michael Irons

E-mail with attachments reflecting

request for and provision of legal

advice regarding assessing litigation

risk in light of recent litigation against

other pharmaceutical companies.

Attorney-Client

BBE-PRIV-022 4/13/2012 E-mail Michael Virgintino Michael Irons

E-mail with redacted portion

reflecting advice of counsel re:

attached STI presentation for

employees. (BBE00033385)

Attorney-Client

2

Case 2:11-cv-01576-KM-MAH Document 96-12 Filed 02/07/14 Page 3 of 4 PageID: 2844
Barghout, et al. v. Bayer Corp., et al. (Case No. 2:11-cv-01576-DMC-JAD)

Defendants' Supplemental Privilege Log

August 13, 2013

Priv Log # DateSent Document Type From To CC BCC Description Privilege Asserted

BBE-PRIV-023 10/19/2010 E-mail Lynne DeSherbinin

Wilhelm

Oehlschlaeger; Megan

Krueger; Myra Rosen;

Sean Kolb-Hunt;

Sandra James; Jamie

Jackson; Denise

D'Agostino; Jeffery

Getson; Jennifer

Hawtof; Michael Irons;

Pat Johnson; Marilyn

Hundley; Nichelle

Howe; Sharon

Minnich; Lillian

Serrano; Gabriele

Oehlschlaeger; Isabel

Veragner; Gretch

Starcher

E-mail re: HRCC meeting minutes

with redacted portion reflecting legal

advice re: addressing litigation risks

concerning overtime and

discrimination issues for

pharmaceutical sales representatives.

(BBE00030568-71)

Attorney-Client

3

Case 2:11-cv-01576-KM-MAH Document 96-12 Filed 02/07/14 Page 4 of 4 PageID: 2845