### CAUSE:**2001-CI-16843 <\** **MICHAEL THOMAS** **PAUL (PLAINTIFF)** **IN THE** **DISTRICT COURr.** 

## VS**225 U.** **"- GREG** **AB30T ATTORNEY** **GENERAL "~** **FOR THE** **STATE OF** **TEXAS (DEFENDANT)** **BEXAR COUNTY,** **TEXAS**

## PLAINTIFF'S**ANSWER TO** **DISTRICT COURT'S** **ATTORNIES**

## CLAIM**OF NON** **INDIGENCY OR** **IN THE** **ALTERNATIVE FRIVILOUS** **APPEAL pLAINTIFF** **is pro** **se. The** **hearing set** **and heard** **in presiding** **court Bexar** **County on** **_.**

### December**5th, 2014** **was requested** **by DINAH** **GAINES, Chief** **Staff Attorney,** **Bexar^ ~<7£** 

## County**Civil District** **Courts as** **malicious filing** **in an** **attempt to** **silence this** **cait^oiice :~o** 

# and**for all.** **Let it** **be known** **that respondents** **first attorney** **RANDOLPH V.** **GONfZ^LEZ =■';** **SBN:08131200 appeared** **October 17** **and filed** **motion for** **continuance statingjjiat** **no s»** **'■€: -i** **notice had** **been given** **per Tex.** **R. Civ.** **P. 21** **and that** **he needed** **more time** **to pre£&re** **im ^p _■'_** **answer .since** **he was** **unfamiliar with** **the particulars** **of the** **filed suit.** **Plaintiff will** **show ca** **: ■ E-file** **and E-serve** **confirmation on** **October 06.** **2014 to** **Attorney General** **who sent** **Mr.**

### GONZALEZ**because he** **had represented** **the defendant** **in Justice** **Court, Comal** **County. Texas** **on September** **20th, 2014** **regarding this** **exact issue.** **Plaintiff never** **having had** **to**

### plea**civil case** **and who** **had not** **been in** **civil courtr** **since 2002** **was unfamiliar** **with the** **TexasRules of** **Civil Procedure** **when he** **filed in** **small claims** **court for** **S10.000 plus** **damages and** **other relief** **as the** **court would** **see fit.** **Because there** **was lack** **of concurrent** **inherent jurisdiction** **the Justice** **slated she** **was not** **eligible to** **make any** 

### rulings**and had** **to grant** **the defendants** **motion to** **dismiss for** **lack of** **jurisdiction. Again** **being novice** **Propia Persona** **litigant Plaintiff** **was unaware** **regarding the** **legalese**

### language**when the** **judge granted** **the motion** **with prejudice** **vs. no** **prejudice, or he** **would ha\e** **objected to** **the motion.** **Plaintiff stopped** **at the** **clerks office** **before leaving** **the facility** **as to** **enquire of** **the Judge** **if he** **needed to** **file in** **Bexar County** **which was the** 

### correct**court having** **jurisdiction or** **was an** **appeal necessary** **first. The** **clerk returned** **and stated** **that the** **judge said** **if he** **wanted to** **file an** **appeal it** **must be** **done within** **10 days** **page of** 

### and**he was** **freeto make** **his own** **decision since** **they could** **not give** **legal advice.** **Plaintiff believing** **that he** **just needed** **to file** **in the** **proper court** **that retains** **jurisdiction in** **family**

### court**cases as** **dedicated by** **the Judicial** **Court System** **in TEXAS** **and the** **states constatulion** **designating the** **225th of** **Bexar county** **as family** **court and** **was the** **originating court** **being the** **court of** **inherant and** **concurrent jurisdiction** **making it** **the**

### only**court allowed** **to hear** **pleadings regarding** **this cause.** **Plaintiff attempted** **to efilc** **the ncessarydocumentation** **to reopen** **the initial** **cause which** **is the** **subject of** **this suit** **but was** **deniedby the** **clerks office** **on more** **than one** **occasion. The** **First time** **was told** **that**

### this**cause isclosed** **and that** **new affidavit** **of Indigency** **had to** **be submitted** **to file** **in**

### original**cause. Plaintiff** **filed in** **person and** **submitted new** **affidavits of** **inability to** **pay court** **costs stamped** **September 22.** **2014 with** **two stamped** **copies sent** **for service** **of notice** **by the** **Sheriff and** **set the** **matter for** **hearing October** **5th. The** **next afternoon** **the Plaintiff** **receives an** **email from** **the district** **clerks office** **stating that** **the petition** **submitted had** **nothing to** **do with** **the original** **divorce and** **it was** **being issued** **new**

### cause**number. Plaintiff** **replied to** **the email** **stating that** **the petition** **was everything** **to do** **regarding thedivorce** **proceeding and** **if the** **clerks office** **attempted to** **bypass the** **record**

### then**plaintiff would** **be forced** **to report** **the issue** **for judicial** **review. October** **05th. 2014** **healing in** **presiding was** **scheduled when** **initial filing** **was done** **September, 22.** 

### 2014.**Plaintiff wasnot** **on the** **docket for** **the case** **he filed** **into but** **instead had** **received new** **case number** **from the clerks** **office and** **was asked** **if he could** **show service** **to the** 

### opposing**party. Plaintiff** **didn't receive** **the return** **of service** **from the** **sheriff as** **required**

### so**he asked** **for the** **courts leave** **to return** **to the** **District Clerk** **who was** **to effect** **service where** **he was** **told that** **since the** **cause number** **was new** **one he** **would need** **to refile** **requests for** **service under** **the new** **number as** **the notices** **were not** **served. Plintiff** **enquired to** **the clerk** **he sent** **the reply** **email to** **on September** **23 and** **was told** **by the** **clerk**

### that**he was** **told to** **do it.** **Plaintiff demanded** **the filing** **be placed** **into the** **original cause** **and had to** **complete another** **setof request** **for service** **which was** **duplicate to** **what was** **filed on** **September 22,** **2014. Plaintiff** **returned to** **presiding court** **and made** **formal complaint** **to the** **court clerk** **regarding the intentional** **misfiling of** **his petition** **and**

### requests**for service** **and asked** **if the** **judge would** **sec him.** **Because the** **presiding judge** **was still** **on the** **bench and** **hadoverheard the** **conversation she** **agreed to** **hear from** **the plaintiff** **but stated** **she could make** **no ruleings** **regarding the** **petition for** **temporary**

### injunction**and declaratory** **relief without** **showing proof** **of service.** **page of** 

## After**reading the** **petition and** **seeing the** **attached exhibits as** **evidence regarding** **the petition** **for declaratory** **relief and** **temporary injunction** **the presiding** **judge stated** **that theplaintiff** **should go** **out front** **and file** **selling for** **new dale.** **Plaintiff did** **as insiructedand** **was giving** **the earliest** **date October** **17. that** **the court** **was hearing** **newly docketed** **pleas then** **proceeded to** **give notice tothe** **defense regarding** **the new** **date.**

### There**has been** **multiple attempts** **to keep** **this case** **from being** **justly adjudicated** **and plaintiff** **contends that** **the district** **clerks office** **including the** **staff attorney** **are corrupt** **and have** **violated procedures** **and even** **laws regarding** **the theft** **of Federal** **Benefits in** **excess**

### of**$11.600 from** **plaintiffs Social** **Security Disability.** **Plaintiff learned** **through the** **staff attorney** **before she** **knew whom** **he was.** **that there** **had been** **no filings** **in the** **original case** **since the** **divorce decree** **of May** **2002. Upon** **learning this** **information plaintiff** **began to** 

### suspect**that there** **was more** **than just** **the intentional** **filing of** **civil judgment** **claiming he** **owed $5,140.00** **to the** **state and** **it appeared** **on his** **credit reports** **causing emotional** **distress, pain** **and suffering** **and his** **public image** **was so** **defamed to** **make him** **appear as** **DEAD BEAT** **DAD for** **not paying** **his child** **support as** **ordered by** **the court.** **The only** **problem with** **that is** **Termination Order** **relinquishing the** **parent child** **relalionshipwith**

### his**daughter that** **ordered ex** **partc in** **December of** **2004 ending** **with "no** **other relief** **so ordered."** **Had the** **plaintiff been** **so behind** **in his** **support to** **the child** **it would** **have been** **pleaded heavily** **by the** **state and** **request for** **an order for** **contempt to** **compel payment** **issued. Yet** **the state** **made no** **claims and** **the Oblige** **also made** **no claims** **as to** **not receiving** **support payments.** **Then months** **after the** **termination the** **US Social** **Security**

### Administration**receives second** **writ for** **withholding for** **garnishment of** **wages that** **continue through** **2008 when** **plaintiff finally** **learns that** **the withholding** **was being** **paid**

### to**the state** **of Texas** **and not** **his son** **in California,** **accumulating to** **$11,600 as** **reported by** **an audit** **he initiated** **after providing** **the order** **to the** **administration from** **the December** 

### 2004**termination which** **slopped the** **garnishments administratively** **from further** **payment. Plaintiff** **then received** **court stamped** **judgment for** **an additional** **$5140.00**

### lien**and was** **issued against** **REAL property** **had the** **plaintiff had** **any. Plaintiff** 

### telephoned**the District** **clerk and** **stated that** **he owed** **nothing and** **that he** **was victim** **of theft** **by deception** **and that** **the lien** **was not** **dully owed.** **The clerkstated** **that he** **needed to** **contact the** **attorney generals** **office directly** **which is** **what he** **didand was** **immediately told** **that they** **wouldconducl an** **internal investigation** **and would** **get back** **with him.** **But**

### more**than likely** **the money** **had been** **paid to** **the oblige,** **plaintiffs ex wife** **and that** **if that** **were the** **case then** **he would** **need to** **take her** **to court** **to recover** **his money.** **page of** 

### Every**time plaintiff** **would call** **Austin to** **the office** **of the** **attorney general** **to inquire** **of the** **investigation he** **was placed** **on hold** **lor 15** **io twenty** **minutes before** **anyone would** **reply and** **their answer** **was always** **we slill** **are doing** **an investigation** **but rest** **assured as** 

### soon**as we** **determine what** **has happened** **you will** **be the** **first to** **know. Then** **in 2013** 

### Plaintiff**learns that** **the civiljudgment** **had been** **reported to** **all three** **major credit** **bureaus and** **when he** **would inquire** **they would** **always state** **that they** **had verified** **the claim** **and he** **owed it.** **Plaintiff requested** **investigations to** **the factual** **legitimacy of** **the lien** **but was** **never given** **any reply.** **Then in** **2014 when** **il was** **still appearing** **on his** **credit reports,** 

### plaintiff**gave written** **notice to** **cure the** **defect or** **face civil** **penalty upon** **which the** 

### investigations**concluded that** **there was** **an error** **and the** **civil judgments** **were deleted.** **Plaintiff states** **Judgments as** **plurai since** **there was** **also fraudulent** **claim from** **Salano County** **California showing** **as receiving** **payments for** **child support** **and even** **had**

### claimed**some as** **30-60-90 late** **but the** **account was** **showing paid** **and current.** **That is** **why Plaintiff** **thought the** **payments were** **lor his son** **in California.** **The reporting** **bureau**

### has**sent letter** **showingcomplcte deletion** **of these** **false claims.** **It is** **at this** **point in** **time that** **plaintiff filed** **formally with** **the Attorney** **Generals Chief** **Ombudsman requesting** **relief to** **have what** **was removed** **from him** **returned. No** **statements of** **suit seeking** **extra damages** **just return** **what was** **wrongfully taken.** **Since**

### the**Office of** **the attorney** **general Chief** **Ombudsman is** **to initiate** **the report** **and contact** 

### the**reporting party every** **quarter until** **final resolution** **and no** **administrative claim** **can be** **made that** **the investigation** **is completed** **and close** **the complaint** **which is** **required by** **the Texas** **Government code.** **Plaintiff learned** **through the** **district clerks** **new online** **eservice**

### thai**the court** **record showed** **entries between** **2003 and** **2008 and** **plaintiff stated** **that no** 

## notice**had been** **given per** **Tex. R.** **Civ. P.** **21 not** **once but** **twice regarding** **the entries** **in**

## the**clerks database** **as to** **appear that** **orders were** **entered by** **judge. Plaintiff** **has since** **learned in** **the filing** **of this** **petition that** **the entries** **are just that.** **Entries with** **no supporting** **documentation or** **actual orders** **issued by** **district judge** **and the** **first was** 

### change**in place** **of payment** **and payee** **from 2003** **which led** **plaintiff to** **believe the** **entire time** **that the** **money was** **redirected to** **someone other** **than the** **original oblige** **and here** **he**

## was**being told** **up until** **September that** **he needed** **to try** **and get** **it from** **the oblige.** **page of** 

### The**OAG's office** **of child** **support enforcmcm** **and Mary** **Morton and** **her representing** **lawyer Mr.** **Randolph V.** **Gon/.alcs SBN** **08131200 filed** **their answer** **in Justice** **court stating** **that his** **only recourse** **is to** **sue the** **oblige as** **he has** **non other,** **because they** **didn't have** **his money.** 

### Between**the intentional** **deceptive tricks** **and tactics** **to keep** **plaintiff from** **recovering his** **money that** **was illegally** **seized and** **entries in** **the clerks** **database that** **have no** **basis in** 

### fact**other than** **they just** **appeared years** **ago when** **they weren't'** **there the** **year before.** **And payment** **record given** **lo plaintiff** **by the** **assistant attorney** **general Randolph** 

### Gonzalez**which states** **that only** **$7,462.89 was** **ever owed** **and collected** **by the** **OAG child** **support enforcement** **division is** **just another** **of the** **non truthes** **entered by** **the office** **ofthe attorney** **general in** **this cause** **especially since** **there was** **an official** **audit by** **the**

### Social**Security Administration** **and subsequent** **stamped copy** **of payments** **from local** **officeclearly showing** **$1 L600.00** **makes the** **entry of** **fraudulent court document** **filed**

### which**constitutes acommission** **of crime** **since the** **supposed judgment** **with lien** **was aginst** **real property** **in the** **state.**

### It**is at** **this point** **in time** **where plaintiff** **demands judicial** **review of** **the district** **clerks office** **of Bexar** **County Texas** **and there** **conspiracy to** **hide the** **truth and** **to continuously** **harass the** **plaintiff and** **file against** **known physically** **disabled and** **indigent citizen** 

## claiming**he is** **not indigent** **toprotect those** **that knowingly** **forged the** **electronic database.** 

### Plaintiff**further request** **sanctions against** **the District** **Court Attorney** **as well** **as sanctions** **against the** **office of** **the attorney** **generals which** **has and** **continues to** **file mis** 

### statements**of fact** **and will** **even have** **an assistant** **attorney general** **commit perjury** **in**

## open**court to** **delay the** **hearing so** **new motion** **can be** **filed and** **heard before** **retired comptroler** **ofthe State** **who ignores** **facts, has** **no record** **before him** **and doesn't** **recognize case** **law such** **as the** **stripping doctrine.** **Pending filed** **motions that** **needed to** 

## be**addressed were** **summerily over** **ruled before** **the defendants** **ineligible claim** **to sovereign** **immunity which** **was pleaded** **claiming there** **was never** **authorization nor** 

## agreement**by the** **state lo** **waive thier** **immunity and** **thus granted** **the dismissal** **of**

## plaintifs**claims with** **perjudice and** **stating that** **this case** **has been** **fully adjudicated** **and can** **not be** **heard again** **even though** **the state** **legislature has** **deemed the** **only reason** **for**

## suit**against the** **individual in** **his capacity** **as an** **employee ofthe** **state. The** **only real** **motion for** **dismissal is** **the one** **not attempted** **for limitations.** **But**

## Plaintiff**has been** **sent demand** **for payment** **from an** **automobile accident** **he had** **last June** **where the** **guard rail** **and cable** **was damaged** **when his** **automible struck** **the page** **of**

### center**devider on** **loop 1604** **and lh** **35 interchange** **totaling his** **2012 K.IA** **and leaving** **him no** 

### transportation.**The Department** **of Motor** **Vehicles demanded** **payment for** **said obligation** **and sent** **him demand** **for payment** **letter. Fortunatly** **the plaintiff** **had comprehensive** **and collission** **insurance which** **not only** **replaced his** **totaled vehicle** **but also** **paid the** **demand from** **the state** **which stated** **that there** **is no** **limitations to** **an obligation** **owed under** **Texas Civil** **Practice and** **Remedies Code** **chapter 16** **16.061 'Rights** **not Barred1.** 

### Wherefore**the Sovereign** **state assumes** **position when** **an obligation** **is due:** **Plaintiff now** **assumes that** **same position** **as afforded** **the sovereign** **since the** **plaintiff is** **sovereign himself** **least document** **can be** **produced by** **the State** **which clearly** **denies the** **plaintiff the** **right to** **soverignity.**

### Under**this premis of** **the same** **position as** **the state** **regarding an** **obligation to** **return said** **obligation owed** **for claim** **of damage** **to the** **sovereign. Plaintiff** **seeks return** **of**

### sovereign's**obligation to** **the plaintiff** **since there** **is nothing** **in the** **laws of** **texas that** **clearly states** **that the** **sovereign can** **keep property** **which clearly** **belongs to** **another. The** **plaintiff would** **pray this** **court to** **make all** **orders sought** **for the** **futherance of** **justice. And** **to notify** **all those** **that would** **use the** **power of** **this court** **to take** **advantage of** 

### others**through trickery** **and deception** **presented to** **this honerable** **court, that** **if coughl** **they will** **pay heavy** **price.**

### Pleader**attests that** **the statements** **made in this** **affadavit are** **truthful and** **accurate to** **the best** **of his** **knowledge and** **attests to** **the same** **here on.** 

### Sworn**this day** **20th December** **2014 in** **the county** **of Comal.** **Michael Thomas** **Pau**

### Propia**Persona 9123 Easy** **Street San** **Antonio, Tex** **78266**

### (210)294-4533**page of** **NOTICE. THIS** **FORM CONTAINS** **SENSITIVE DATA.** **Cause Number:** **2001-CI-16843 ...** **In Ihe** **••■■•-■ ■'** **Pelilioner/ Plaintiff** **MICHAEL THOMAS** **PAUL J25TH** **District Court** **•,..--::. County** **Court at** **Law Justice** **of the** **Peace Doleodant** **GREG ABBOTT** **ATTORNEY GENERAL** **Respondent/ FOR** **THE STATE** **OF TEXAS** **....BJ1XAR. County.** **Twos**

### Plaintiffs**Amended Affidavit** **of Indigency** **for APPEAL** **(Request to** **Not Pay** **Court Fees)** **:>******:ims w:** **!o ask** **trie cuur1** **'lot to** **Y«u nw.si** **eimei stye,** **this 'orm** **in You** **can be** **prosecuted if** **you lie** **on ■■'wge** ***cu ('■••** **cou'i fees** **'iis 'crm** **is front** **of no'ary** **puul.r or** **2; si:i:i** **'His this** **form. aisu** **calieii <ti** **'Vfidavit o'** **Inability to** **form am** **sign and** **attach completed** **M0 court** **may or** **may no!** **approve this** 

### Pay**Co-..r; Cusis"** **or 'Paupers** **Oatf "Unsvto:r.** **Declaration' form.** **By req'uss!** **10 not** **ooy court** **'ees rh«A.'.;urr** **You can** **only i>se Shis** **fonri if.** **(1) you** **signing in** **fron! of** **;j inj'.ary.** **you suvar** **:t,nv Jr.-e,** **y0,, |O** **arrive' (|iiOS'.!0'^** **.iiv ;;.::;;«** **fe-i-'-s becai;sc** **yo.i art** **«'i'J#« o.if.':** **:na: !i«:** **inlormaiion ^t3OL-1** **your financos** **a; hearmc.** **A: :ii«M** **,.:-j yoi** **en-', pay** **nourt foes** **jtrovirifin 'f.** **Ii.o .in;!** **i-ursn By** **!Ms, deaniHj** **you will** **hove lo** **present -id** **!'ifiv-r-ai-..a you** **g;vii on** **llvs forf** **.'-.itji'iii!! .iii<!** **attnr.r.m-.j ;«i** **Uriswoci ovidvnoi1** **■,•:> the** **itidqp of** **your inco^i'?** **•;■'.;•:» bi"** **■:''•> "o:rt!l«li!** **true anri Osci.-ir.vio'i** **'onr> vim** **..'er.'.-./c- j'io'c** **.-jsir expenses** **!t. [jrr.vp'-iar** **v.i.*****iflvf--X11 .^•:J';va'SL»;t;.-/i1.a!tr.t.r:{;imJitio'»** **.oiHy :■;.** **^sy "ourt** **fees ri'O.'IOK!** **>S ;.';(C-** **?ilx.(i (if'SCl** **The person** **who signed** **this affidavit** **appeared, in** **porson, before** **me, the** **undersigned notary,** **and stated** **under oath:** **"My name** **is MICHAEL** **THOMAS PAUL** **My phone** **number is** **ro 294** **-4533 -My** **mailing address** **is 9123_EASY** **STREEJ_ SAN** **ANTONIO, TEXAS** **78266 "My** **email address** **is MTP73H9@HOTMAIL.COM** **am above** **me age** **of eighteen** **(18) years,** **and am** **fully competent** **to make** **this affidavit.** **am unable** **to pay** **court costs** **The nature** **and amount** **cf rny** **income, resources,** **debls. and** **expenses are** **described in** **this form.** **'.. .'■..•** **"I. i.y-.,** **.,t.!f.i****;■■:*;■****.;■:><-& j.V.-.** **.••.-••»;.•.• Cf.** **■.■..'.-. ;.■** **.-i-;-;.-: ;••'** **.-,».' «.r.w** **recsive these** **public benefits/government** **entitlements that** **are based** **on indigency:** **SSI WIC** **Pood Slamps/SNAP** **TANF Medicaid** **CHIP AABO** **Needs-based VA** **Pension County** **Assistance. County** **Health Care,** **or General** **Assistance (GA)** **US in** **Medicare ('Extra** **Help") Community** **Care via** **DADS Low-Income** **Energy Assistance** **Emergency Assistance** **;""• Child** **Care Assistance** **under Child** **Care and** **Development Block Grant** **Public Housing** **Olher:****,;*••..****••.;. 'My** **income sources** **are staled** **below ..:.■•■.** **.i« ■,■■ -:l•;..-,** **Unemployed since:** **■uw 20Q2** **-or Wages:** **work as** **for Child/spousal** **support .J** **My spouse's** **income or** **income from** **another member** **of my** **household****•</*«»/»»■•,****Tips, bonuses** **Military Housing** **Workers Ccmp** **'.*'■****Disability Unemployment** **X. Social** **Security Disability** **Relirement/Pension Dividends,** **interest, royalties** **2"" job** **or other** **income: (5** **"My income** **amounts are** **stated below.** **(■r.-.s.ij;,.. (a)** **My monthly** **net income** **after (axes** **are taken** **out is:** **'w.-c****■><>*;.•*::..;;!•.,****■> $795.00** **(b) The** **amount receive** **each month** **in public** **benefits is.** **•■.•mi ,.iUi..-** **mei*-.****(c) The** **amount of** **income from** **olher people** **in rny** **household is:'** **j.-ja'-H»\j:«.' -..cr** **.■■ i«** **-. (d)** **The anount** **receive each** **month from** **other sources** **is: .-,,•.«.»••.■** **»■>v.-,-..-..•-• 100** **00 (e)** **My TOTAL** **monthly income** **is Md** **311 sources** **cf income** **acovo- K95.00** **■!.-;"•■ .•■•:•<:.•** **c'-A- ,•(** **.M.'.t'r i»:f."'.V(.-•■** **•:••-•;./• :.** **...• ■.....** **a-"i.:j :<:':•:■:>.'.:** **TeiasLawHe.o.org Affidavit** **ol Indigency.** **February 2014** **About my** **dependants: 'The people** **who depend** **on me** **financially are** **listed below:** **■Vvf'O Ay:-** 

# I.J"**_1_ '____"'"** **_[ '"""** **.Mr '•My** **property includes:** **Value*****Cash L__-r_M.** **Bank accounts** **other financial** **assets ■;** **-; RBFCU** **CHECKING ACCT** **98.00 ©'My** **monthly expenses** **are. Rent/house** **payments/ma inlena** **nee Food** **and household** **supplies Utilities** **and telephone** **.Ml^.SAYJNGA... 5.00** **Clothing and** **laundry Vehicles** **(cars, boats)** **■.•.•xmuwaii.iya&i 1QJ** **4.KIA.R!O_FJ, LJ** **Real estate** **(house or** **land) (Donot«si** **me house** **younvo m.)** **Other property** **(like jewelry,** **stocks, etc.)** **■■oeicmo; 2002** **PROWLER 32'** **RV S_2J)00** **Medical and** **dental expenses** **Insurance (life,** **health, auto,** **etc) School** **and child** **care Vehicle** **payments Gas.** **b.is fare,** **auto repair** **Child spousal** **support Wages** **withheld by** **court order** **Debt payments** **Other expenses** **lOoscnbe) L_** **Amount 45.00** **200.00 127.00** **30..00 88.48** **FINGERHJJT FUEL** **FOR CAR** **AND HOME** **25.00 200.00** **Total value** **of property** **16,105 "My** **debts include;** **Total monthly** **Expenses 750.48** **jliQDjSTJ.TONE QAIULQSPITAL** **5850.00, NIJ^** *****due totjle** **size limit** **online documentation** **will be** **provided at** **hearing 12** **22; 14 as** **required any** **aintrr iscts** **you ivacif** **the court** **to >".>i>iv** **■.•lye'! a-.** **n;ii'Si/;i' motl'S!)-** **kV'u.'.'M.'S. family** **vaii'Hjupruw o'-** **.i!;m-, h-i:'!"—** **<;e ;o** **this fe-in** **.-ifirf'aos; <!** **'Exhibit AilM:or>&** **Supvoiitaq Facts** **Check nore** **if you** **attach another** **page.. "1** **am unable** **to pay** **court costs.** **vorify that** **the statomonts** **mado in** **this affidavit** **are true** **and correct."** **Your Signature.** **•■ Sworn** **to and** **subscribed before me** **today.**

### ..by**\Y\iCX\C\C ~rTvJ>"vvL>** **-9<r. MICHAEL** **PAUL Affidavit** **tnctigoncy rebmary** **201^ Edit** **View History** **Bookmarks Iools** **Help f.** **.■■;J^1! ■"■** **t&*y"^.****^y^^i^A^ >cT:;** **|/ eFiling** **lor Texas** **<3*****tMl JL** **£1 ■■''.** **■ ■ t»coutts.gov** **;P; Most** **visited ^_** **Getting Started** **2001****Fo*d****Ranger Wiri...** **2a-subj«t-rr>atter-juri... .;»1^:** **Details BenefitsChecktp** **Bexar County** **County... []** **CashNetUSA (2)** **CashNetUSA ['"_** **CIVIl PRACTICE** **AND _.** **coa.tx Oefamation** **da... Precept** **Without Hearing** **Precept Without** **Hearing Abstract** **of Judgment** **Notice of Hearing** **Served Temporary** **Injunction S«rv** **Abstract of** **Judgment Notice** **of Hearing** **Served Precept Without** **Hearing Temporary** **Injunction Scrv** **Rejection Information** **$0.00 S0.00** **so.oo so.oo** **$0.00 so.oo** **$0.00 $0.00** **$0.00 Rejection** **Reason Date** **Time Incorrect/Incomplete** **10/6/2014 8:58** **AM Rejection** **Comment THE** **LEAD DOCUMENT** **IS CCIS** **FORM, NOT A** **REQUEST. SELECT** **THE CORRECT** **RUNG CODE.** **ALSO THE** **CASE IS** **CLOSED, SO** **NEW AFFIDAVIT** **OF INABILITY** **IS NEEDED.** **MARC Documents** **Lead Document** **Attachments Attachments** **eService Details** **Civ1ICase_lrrfomwtfonSheetSIGNED.pdf [Original]** **Requeet_At>stract_Judgment_WritOfExeeution for** **presidfng.pdf [original]** **Status Sent** **Sent Nome/Email** **Firm office** **of attorney** **general esd-filer-303@texasattorney** **DRO Legal** **Enforcement Tarrant** **County Domestic** **DRO-LegaK&tarrantcounty.o Relations** **Office Served** **Date/Time Opened** **Log Yes** **Not Opened** **View Yes** **10/6/2014 10:15:04** **View Request** 

### SERVICE**ATTNY GENERAL** **j" sjjjJSiS** **5^ ^ ;'"** **^^ NOTICE:** **THIS DOCUMENT** **COM AINS** **SENSITIVE DATA** **N(.l'N«:nc MICHAEL** **I'M I.** **CP Nairn.-.** **URASDYL il'OOUFRTO.X** **OAO Number:** **0»>lW2IW (AlSK** **NUMBER S2I4025** 

### M1CIIM.I**IHOMASi'AII s-** **INTIIEJI'STICECOl.RI ;\** **I'KLCINC NUMUI-.K** **WO OriKI** **O!: [HF** **AilOKNhYC.LMRALCIlll.l) .** ***SUPPORT DIVISION** **AND MARY** **MORION ."** **C0MA1. COUNTY.** **II..VAN OKOF.R** **DENYING PLAINTIFF'S** **REVISED PETITION:** **SMALL CLAIMS** **COURT AND** **GRANTING THE** 

### OFFICE**OFTHF. ATTORNEY GENERAL** **AND MARY** **MORTON'S MOTION** **TO DISMISS** **AND MOTION** **TO DISMISS** **ON PLF.A** **TO THF.** **.11 RISDIt** **T1ON On** **the 18"** **da\ of** **September. 20N** **ir.e Conn** **held hcatinu** **in -Ins** **cau->c The** **ATTOKNI-Y OKNLRAl** **and MARY** **MORTON. Defendants,** **appeared hv** **an Assi^ianl** **Altoric> Genera!. VUC** **HALL THOMAS** **PAl.'l I'lnimill.** **uppcaivii Pro** **So**

### The**Cour: heard** **and coiiMdcrcd** **the ;ilc.ii)im!s.** **the ariiiimciUi** **of Counsel,** **and the** **e\iocncc pronerl>** 

### and**finds ihiinlK-Plaimilfs** **Rev ised** **I'ciiiion Small** **Clir.ms Counts** **DFNIF.l). he** **Conn further** **GRANTS ilxOlllC** **OP Tilt** **ATTORNEY (iF.NKRAI** **:md MARY** **Ml»RTON's Motion** **to Dismiss** **and Molion** **lo Oiimiss** **on ?lc»** **In ihe** **IT ISTIIfcRI.IORH** **OROF.RED :hat** **MICHAEL HOMAS** **PALI.'s Hclition** **at-d 1'lcHilir.gsarcnll** **hereb>**

### nil**pfv-iudicc IT** **IS Ft IK** **11IER ORDDRCU** **that all** **any nnd** **all relic:** **requeued but** **nol granted** **hereby UliNIFD.** 

## inal**Signed by:** **JIDGU PRESIDING** **APPROVED AS** **10 FORM ONLY** **RANUOLPII V.** **CiON/ALE/ SUN** **\rtorney of** **Record Child** **Support Divisior.** **lOSS.St Marv'sSt..** **Stc -4S** 

### San**Anionio. n20f<** **Telephone No.** **(2l<h 804-640(1** **ax No.** **(210) V30-3625** 

### EXHIBIT:**ASSISTANT ATTORNY** **GENERAL GONZALEZ** **PURJURY CLAIM** **TO JUDGE** **MERY.NO SERVICE,** **DONT KNOW** **ANYTHING ABOUT** **THIS CASE** **TO DELAY** **THE COURTON** **NOVEMBER 17,** **2014.**

### NOTICE:**THIS DOCUMENT** **CONTAINS SENSITIVE** **DATA NCP** **Name: .KUCHA** **El. PA** **VL CV** **Name: BRANDY** **L. WOOL** **VERTON OAG** **Number: 0010017209** **CADSF. NUMBER** **S214025 MICHAEL** **THOMAS PAUL** **IN THE** **JUSTICE COURT** 

### VS.**PRECINCT NUMBER** **TWO OFFICE** **OF TlIE** **ATTORNEY GENERAL** **CHILD SUPPORT** **DIVISION AND** **MARY MORTON** **>' COMAI.** **C:OUNTY. TEXAS** 

### THE**OFFICE OF** **THE ATTORNEY** **GENERAL CHILD** **SUPPORT DIVISION** **AND MARY** **MORTON'S TRIAL** **BRIEF IN** **SUPPORT OF** **THE OFFICE** **OF THE** **ATTORNEY GENERAL AND** **MARY MORTON'S** **MOTION TO** **DISMISS ON** **PLEA TO** **THE JURISDICTION** **TO THE** **HONORABLE JUDGE** **OF SAID** **COURT: The** **OFFICn OF** **THK ATI** **ORNEY GENERAL** **CHILD SUPPORT** **DIVISION and** **it's employee,** **MARY MORTON,** **(hereinafter Movanls)** **filed plea** **to the** **jurisdiction objecting** **ro the** **court's excrciso** **of subject** **mutter jurisdiction** **over the** **cause of** **action as** **alleged by** **Plaintiffs, MICHAEL** **THOMAS PAUI.'s.** **(hereinafter Non-Movam)** **Revised Petition** **and requests** **the Court** **to dismiss** **Plaintiffs cau.se** **of action** **on the** **Plea to** **the Jurisdiction,** **and in** **support thereof,** **shows the** **Court the** **following: I.** **FACTS/PROCEDURAL HISTORY** **A. On** **August 11,** **2014, Non-Movant.** **\\ICHAP.I. THOMAS** **PALI., filed** **his lawsuit** **alleging over** **payments on** **court ordered** **child support** **payments to** **the custodial** **parent for** **over three** **year period.** **Non-Movant seeks** **monetary relief** **from the** **Movanls. in** **the amount** **of $10,000** **plus damages** **for 'REAL** **PHYSICAL HARM"** **and statutory** **interest and** **court costs.** **H. Non-Movanl** **alleges thai** **Movjiiiw provided child** **support services** **to the** **custodial parent** **and continued** **u, withhold** **support after** **the support** **obligation legally** **:minnted. C.** **Non-Movant further** **alleges that** **MovanLs Hied** **false claim** **in State** **District Court** **to "gamer** **Civil Judgment** **that appears/appeared** **on personal** **Credit Bureau".** 

### D.**Non-Movant does** **not plead** **facts indicating** **constitutional provision** **or statute** **that clearly** **and unambiguously** **waives sovereign** **immunity in** **these various** **claims.**

### E.**Non-Movanl does** **not plead** **facts indicating** **the Legislature's** **consent to** **pursue this** **suit against** **the stale** **or public** **official. F.** **In heir** **individuul capacities,** **the Movants,** **and all** **persons acting** **on behalf** **of the** **State of** **Texas**

### participating**in ihi.s** **cause have** **sovereign und** **official or** **quasi-judicial immunity** **from .suits** **or liability** **for attorney's** **fees. EXHIBIT:** **ASSISTANT ATTORNY** **GENERAL GONZALEZ** **PURJURY CLAIM** **TO JUDGE** **MERY.NO SERVICE,** **DONT KNOW** **ANYTHING ABOUT** **THIS CASE** **TO DELAY** **THE COURT** **-NOVEMBER-17^044=—**

### monetarv**judgments, damages** **or other** **monetary relief,** **except as** **provided by** **law, when** **aeting within** **the discretion,** **course, and** **scope of** **their official** **duties at** **all times** **relevant to** **Non-Movanl's claims.** **II. ARGUMENTS** **ON PI** **PA TO** **THE .nmiSDICTlON** 

### A.**Movants can** **demonstrate that** **ihis Court** **does not** **have suhjeel** **mailer jurisdiction** **over this** **cause of** **action and** **thai****Non-Movant*s****cause of** **action should** **be dismissed** **on the** **plea lo** **the jurisdiction** **on the** **contentions and** **affirmative defenses** **set forth** **herein based** **on the** **doctrine of** **sovereign immunity.** **B. Movants** **pled both** **plea to** **the jurisdiction** **on the** **doctrine of** **sovereign immunity** **and raised** **the affirmative** **defense of** **sovereign immunity** **to Non-Movanl's** **claims. The** **doctrine of** **sovereign immunity** **appliesto**

### lawsuits**seeking lo** **award monetary** **relief against** **governmental entities** **and their** **employees or** **public officials** **unless constitutional** **provision or** **statute clearly** **and unambiguously** **waives sovereign** **immunity from** **suit. This** **is true** **regardless of** **whether Movant** **has asserted** **valid claim** **or ultra** **vires conduct;** **violation of** **due process** **rights; or** **ihe intentional** **tort of** **fraud. No** **matter how** **Non-Movant couches** **his pleading,** **what is** **sought is** **money judgment** **for the** **alleged overpayment** **of child** **support in** **an amounl** **in excess** **of SI** **0,000 plus** **damages tor** **'REAL PHYSICAL** **HARM'" and** **statutory interest** **and court** **costs from** **Movants, undisputedly** **governmental emily** **and its** **employee. Non-Movant.** **however, has** **failed to** **identify any** **constitutional provision** **or statute** **that clearly** **and unambiguously** **waives sovereign** 

### immunity**from suit.** **ITie Non-Movant** **is precluded** **from seeking** **monetary relief** **from the** **Movant or** **any of** **its employees** **on any** **of his** **alleged claims.** **C. Non-Movant's** **exclusive remedy** **for support** **paid in** **excess of** **the support** **order is** **found in** **Texas Family** **Code Provision** **154.012. This** **provision provides** **thai if** **an Obligor** **is not** **in arrears** **and the** **Obligor's child** **support**

### obligation**has ended, the** **Obligee shall** **return excess proceeds** **to the** **obligor. An** **Obligor can** **file suit** **to recover** **child support** **payment in** **excess of** **Ihe support** **obligation against** **the Obligee.** **Movants had** **closed its** **case in** **April 2009,** **shortly after** **being informed** **lhal Non-Movanfs** **parental rights** **had been terminated** **in 2005.** **Neither the** **Non-Movant or** 

### the**Obligee had** **previously informed** **the Movants** **of said** **termination order** **prior lo** **2008. There** **is no** **legal basis** **for payment** **by Non-Movant** **of the** **excess proceeds.** **Non-Movanl's sole** **remedy is** **suit against** **the Obligee** **pursuant to** **Section 154.012.** **III. AUTHORITIES** **ON PLEA** **TO THE** **JURISDICTION SOVEREIGN** **IMMUNITY GENERALL** **A. Governmental** **immunity from** **suit defeats** **trial court's** **subject matter** **jurisdiction and** **is properly** **asserted by** **plea to** **the jurisdiction.** **Texas Dcpl.** **of Transportation** **v. Jones,** **S.W. 3d** **636. 637** **(Tex. 1999).** **Whether court** **has subject** **matter jurisdiction** **is question** **of law.** **Texas Natural** **Resources Conservation Comm'u** **v. IT-Davy,** **74 S.W.** **3d 849.** **855 (Tex.** **2002). Sovereign** **immunity deprives** **trial court** **of subject** **matter jurisdiction** **in suits** **against**

### EXHIBIT:**ASSISTANT ATTORNY** **GENERAL GONZALEZ PURJURY** **CLAIM TO** **JUDGE MERY.NO** **SERVICE, DONT** **KNOW ANYTHING** **ABOUT THIS** **CASE TO** **DELAY THE** **COURT NOVEMBER** **17.2014.**

### the**State and** **its agencies** **and officials,** **unless the** **State has** **clearly and** **unambiguously consented** **to be** **sued..See Tex.** **Dep't of** **Parks and** **Wildlife v.** **Miranda. 133** **S.W.ld 217,224** **(Tex. 2004).** **Moreover, because** **sovereign immunity** **from**

### suit**deprives trial** **court of** **subject-matter jurisdiction,** **it cannot** **he waived and** **may be** **raised at** **any time.,SV<?** **Miranda. \tt** **SW 3&a\** **22*;****Texas Ass'n** **of Bus.** **v. Texas** **Air Control** **Bd.. 852** **S.W.2d at** **445 (Tex.** **1993).**

### B.**Sovereign immunity** **encompasses two** **principles: immunity** **from suit** **and immunity** **from liability.** 

### Travis**Cowuy vs.** **Petztsl and** **Aiawiaies, 77** **SW3d 216** **(Tex. 2001).** **Rven if** **the legislature** **consents to** **suit, the** **government is** **srill protected** **from liability.** **Putzel, supra.** **C. Sovereign** **immunity also bars** **suits that** **seek to** **control state** **action. See** **Fouler v.** **Teacher Ret.** **Sys.. 273** **S.W.3d 883.886** **(Tex. App.-Austin** **2008, no** **pet.). Absent** **an express** **waiver of** **its sovereign** **immunity, the** **State is** **immune from** **suit. See** **Stale v.** **Holland, 221** **S.W.3d 639,** **643 (Tex.** **2007). D.** **It is** **the plaintiff's** **burden to** **establish the** **State's consent** **to suit.** **IT-Davy, 74** **S.W.3d at** **855. First,** **only the** **Legislature may** **waive sovereign** **immunity..See IT-Oavy.** **857 (reaffirming** **thai it** **is the** **Legislature's sole** **province to** **waive or** **abrogate sovereign** **immunity). Second,** **any waiver of** **sovereign immunity** **must be** **in clear** **and unambiguous** **language. See** **Tonka v.** **City ofMexiu.** **197 S.\V.3d** **325. 332-33** **(lex. 2006).** **E. Non-Movant** **does not** **plead waiver** **of sovereign** **immunity for** **any of** **his claims** **(overpaid child** **support payments:** **"Real Physical** **Harm" and** **court costs),** **nor does** **he request** **prospective injunctive** **relief or** **declaratory relief.** **See City** **of El** **Paw v.** **Heinrich. 284** **S.\V.3d 366,** **369 (Ten.** **2009). This** **Court should** **dismiss Non-Movant's** **cause of** **action because** **his suit** **for damages** **is not** **recognized by** **any textual** **exception to** **Movanfs sovereign** **immunity. See** **Fed. Sign** **v. Tex.** **.*>'.****t/niv., 951** **5>.W.2ci 401.** **405 (Tex. 1997)** **(.state agencies** **are immune** **from liability** **in Texas** **unless the** **Legislature waives** **that immunity):** **\ee ahu** **TF.X. GOV'T** **CODE 311.034** **(codifying common-law** **standard for** **immunity waiver:** **"[A] statute** **shall not** **he construed** **as waiver** **of sovereign** **immunity unless** **the waiver** **is affected** **by clear** **and unambiguous** **language."). CLAIM AGAINST** **MARY MORTOX** **A. Absent** **waiver by** **the legislature,** **sovereign immunity** **generally deprives** **courts of** **subject-matter jurisdiction** **over suits** **against the** **State., its** **agencies, or** **officer*****or employees** **acting within** **heir official** **capacity. See** 

### Citv**of F.I** **Paw v.** **Heinrich, 284** **S.W.3d 366,** **369-76 (Tex.** **2009). In** **its attempt** **to invoke** **this court's** **subject-matter jurisdiction.** **Ntm-Movant, sues** **MARY MOR** **ION, an** **employee of** **the OFFICE** **OK THK** **ATTORNEY GENERAL** **CHILD SI.IM'ORTDI** **VISION. See** **id. at** **372-73, 377.** **Sovereign immunity** **does not** **bar suits** **for prospective** **injunctive or** **decluraton relief** **to restrain** **the official** **from violating** **statutory or** **constitutional provisions** **because, in** **concept, acts** **of stale** **official*****ihat are** **not lawfully** **.iiithoi \/tn\** **nru nui** **considered to** **be acts** **of" the** **State, and** **ihe remedy** **of compelling** **EXHIBIT: ASSISTANT** **ATTORNY GENERAL** **GONZALEZ PURJURY** **CLAIM TO** **JUDGE MERY,NO** **SERVICE, DONT** **KNOW ANYTHING** **ABOUT THISjCASE** **TQ DELAYTHE** **COURT NOVEMBER** **17,2014.**

## such**officials to** **comply with** **(he law,** **while binding** **on the** **Slate, does** **not attempt** **to exert** **control over** **the State,** **Id. at** **372-73 (emphasis** **added).**

### B.**To assert** **such a valid** **ultra vires** **claim, the** **claimant "must** **not complain** **of government** **officer's exercise** **of discretion,** **but rather** **must allege,** **and ultimately** **prove, that** **the officer** **acted without** **legal authority** **or failed** 

### lo**perform purely** **ministerial act."** **Id. at** **372. Otherwise,** **the suit,** **even if** **seeking only** **prospective declaratory** **or injunctive** **relief, implicates** **sovereign immunily** **because it** **seeks to** **control state** **action.."ke id.** **However, even** **if the** **suit complains of** **ultra vires** **actions, the** **remedy .sought** **cannot have** **the effect** **of awarding** **retrospective monetary** **relief against** **the State** **or oilier** **relief that** **would independently** **implicate sovereign** **immunity. S^** **id. at** **369-76; Creedmoor** **Maha Water** **Supply Corp.** **v. Texas** **Coimn'ii on** **Envtl Quality,** **307 S.W.3d** **505, 515** **(lex. App.-Austin** **2010. no** **pet.).**

### C.**Thus, sovereign** **or governmental** **immunity deprives** **trial courts** **of subject-matter** **jurisdiction over** **suits**

### for**monetary damages** **or other** **retrospective monetary** **relief against** **government entities** **and their** **officers and** **employees, acting** **in their** **official capacity,** **unless the** **State expressly** **consents. See** **Heinrich. 284** **S.\V.3d at** **368, 380** **(Tex. 2009);** **Texus Dep't** **of Trump,** **v. Jones.** **S.\V.3d 636,** **638 (lex.** **1099) (per** **curiam). This** **is true** **regardless whether** **the claimant** **has otherwise** **asserted valid** **claim of** **ultra vires** **conduct. See** **Heinrich, 284** **S. VV.3d** **at 369-76;** **Cn-i'dtnoor Maha** **Water Supply** **Corp. Texas** **Comm'n on** **Envtl. Quality.** **307 S.WJd** **505, 515** **(Tex. App.«Austin** **2010, no** **pet.). Kastnvr** **vs. Texas** **Board of** **Law Examiners,** **2010 Tux.** **App. Lexis** **6076 (Tex.** **App.—Austin 2010,** **no pet.).** **FRAUDULENT CIVIL** **JUDGMENT CLAIM** **A. The** **Texas Tort** **Claims Act** **provides for** **limited waiver** **of sovereign** **immunity for** **non-intentional torts.** **Miranda. 133** **3dat 224: TEX.** **CIV. PR,IC.** **REM. CODE#** **10J.0OI 109.** **However, under** **TEX. CIV.** **PRAC. ti** **REM CODE** **10l.057(2j. claims** **arising from** **intentional torts** **arc excluded** **from the** **waiver of** **immunity. TEA".** **CIV.**

### PRAC.**REM. CODE** **101.057(2). In** **Non-Movanl's Revised** **Petition Non-Muvanl** **pled cause** **of action** **for "filing** **false claim"** **and filing** **"fraudulent civil** **judgment". Fraud** **is an** **intentional tort** **See Texas** **River Rargex** **v. City** **ofSan**

### Amonio.Ti**S.W.3d 347.** **356 (lex.** **App. San** **Antonio 2000,** **pet. denied).** **Additionally, Non-Movant"s** **intentional tort** 

### claim**of fraud** **or "raise** **claims'are barred** **by sovereign** **immunity because** **the Texas** **Tut Claim** **Act docs not** **provide waiver** **of sovereign** **immunity to** **these types** **of claims.** **Under the** **Texas Tort** **Claims Act.** **there are** **only three** **areas in** **which the State** **and its** **agencies waive** **immunity for** **torts..we TF.X.** **CIV. PRAC.** **REM. CODE** **101.021. (1)** **the operation** **or use** **of motor** **vehicle, (2)** **premises tlelect,** **or (3)** **the use** **or misuse** **of property** **owned or** **controlled by** **the State.** **Sec Old** **South Amusements.** **Inc. 2010** **Tex. App.** **Lexis 5450.** 

### EXHIBIT:**ASSISTANT ATTORNY** **GENERAL GONZALEZ** **PURJURY CLAIM** **TO JUDGE** **MERY.NO SERVICE,** **DONT KNOW** **ANYTHING ABOUT** **THIS CASE** **TO DELAY** **THE COURT** **NOVEMBER 17,** **2014. ss** **PRAYER**

## WHEREFORE,**PREMISES CONSIDERED,** **Movonts pray** **that the** **Court grant** **Movants' Motion** **to Distni** **on Pica** **10 the** **Jurisdiction, and** **that this** **Honorable Court** **will dismiss** **Non-Movant's cause** **<>r action** **with prejudice** **as to** 

## the**Movants and** **any funher** **relief, special** **or general,** **at law** **or in** **equity, as** **may be** **shown that** **Movants are** **justly entitled** **lo receive.** 

### Respectfully**submitted, Greg** **Abboit Allomey** **General of** **Texas**

### Daniel**T. Hodge** 

### First**Assistant Attorney** **General**

### Randolph**V. Gonzalez** **SUN: 08131200** **Melissa Ramos** **Munoz SBN:** **00786186 Attorney** **of Record** 

### Child**Support Division** **CHILD SUPPORT** **UN!T 02Q1E** 

### fO6S.**ST. MARY'SST..** **STE. 445** **SANAKTOMO TX** **78205-3614 Telephone** **No. 210-804-6416** 

### Fax**No. 210-930-3625** **EXHIBIT: ASSISTANT** **ATTORNY GENERAL** **GONZALEZ PURJURY** **CLAIM TO** **JUDGE MERY.NO** **SERVICE, DONT** **KNOW ANYTHING** **ABOUT THIS** **CASE TO DELAY** **THE COURT** **NOVEMBER 17,2014.** 

### CERTIFICATE**OF SERVICE** 

### certify**that true** **and correct** **copy of** **the foregoing** **has been** **served on** **the below** **listed parties** **or representatives** **pursuant Rule** **21 a,** **Texas Rules** **of Civil** **Procedure, on** **the. 5** ***day of** **September. 2014.** **RANDOLPH GONZALEZ** **Attorney of** **Record**

### Early:**MlCHAliL TPAUI.** **BRANDY WOOLVERTON** 

### Attorney**for Party:** **EXHIBIT: ASSISTANT** **ATTORNY GENERAL** **GONZALEZ PURJURY** **CLAIM TO** **JUDGE MERY.NO** **SERVICE, DONT** **KNOW ANYTHING** **ABOUT THIS** **CASE TO** **DELAY THE** **COURT NOVEMBER** **17, 2014.** 

### LIABILITY**A:. ':„-■.;** **■..-:.,- 1410010194** **Sta:e:n»n: Da-.i** **12/05/14 1,188.80** **A-i. Paymyms** **and Charges** **after th«** **.td c'ate** **Aiil appear** **on rext** **statement To** **Pay Online** **Visit www** **bpservice.com; Control** **#14279013123 City** **of San** **Antonio Emergency** **Medical Service** **621 N.** **Alamo San** **Antonio, TX** **78215 We** **Accept Most** **Major Credit** **Cards For** **Assistance: Telephone** **(210) 227-7252** **10/01/14 1410010194** **Patient MICHAEL** **PAUL Unless** **pa It** **will be** **transferr lisU** **Current EMS** **SERVICE***********FINAL NOTICE** *********yment is** **received on** **this past-due** **accoun FIFTEEN** **(15) DAYS** **ed to** **our collection** **agency. Delinquent** **ace >d** **with the** **credit bureaus** **serving this** **area 1.188.80** **within ounts** **may be** **..... _—** **1.188J30 1,188.80** **b.uir;e Due** **City of** **San Antonio** **Emergency Medical** **Service 621** **N. Alamo** **San Antonio,** **TX 78215** **EDP# 142790131** **MICHAEL PAUL** **9123 EASY** **ST SAN** **ANTONIO TX** **78266-2647 To** **Pay Online** **Visit www** **bpservice.com; Control** **14279013123**

# SPn**S^iaHB City** **of San** **Antonio P.O** **Box 158** **San Antonio.** **TX 78291-0158** **AMujNT PAID** **LIABILITY**

### NPAS,**Inc. PO,** **BOX 99400** **LOUISVILLE. KY** **40269 031322-430510686-A1** **Services Provided** **by: METHODIST** **STONE OAK** **HOSPITAL Patient** **Name: Account** **Number: Service** **Date(s): Statement** **Date: Placement** **Date:**

### Michael**Paul 502157591** **10/01/2014 -10/02/2014** **12/01/2014 11/01/2014** **MICHAEL PAUL** **9123 EASY** **ST SAN** **ANTONIO, TX 78266-2647** **Contact Us** **NPAS, Inc** **Toll Free** **1-800-223-9899 Espanol** **1-80C-681-9692 MON-FRI** **8AM-9PM SAT** **9AM-1PM ET** **Please bo** **prepared to** **provide the** **patient/responsible party** **lull name,** **date of** **birth and** **mailing address.** **All calls** **may be** **recorded. PAYMENT** **REQUEST Total** **Charges 43,773.79** **Total Pymt** **Adi 42.SS3.34** **Current Balanco** **820.45 Payment** **Duo By** **12/16/14 Amount** **You Owo** **$820.45 Our** **records reflect** **that you** **were previously** **contacted regarding** **the unpaid** **balance of** **the account.** **We urge** **you to** **send payment** **in full** **today. In** **the event** **you are** **unable to** **pay the** **balance in** **full, please** **contact us** **to discuss** **options for** **resolving your** **account. METHODIST** **STONE OAK** **HOSPITAL; METHODIST** **HOSPITAL FACILITY** **Insurance Information** **If the** **insurance information** **on file** **is incorrect,** **please contact** **us at** **the toll-free** **number above.** **Primary: TRAILBLAZER** **Payment Options** **®PAY ONLINE** **at your** **provider's weosite.** **www.saheallrt.com/billinginqasp OPAY** **BY PHONE** **at no** **additional cost** **through our** **automated system** **during or** **after normal** **business hours.** **©MAIL PAYMENT** **lo the** **provider win** **the attached** **coupon at** **tno payment** **address specified** **Please do** **net send** **cash PLEASE SEE** **REVERSE SIDE** **FOR IMPORTANT** **INFORMATION I'** **your****Main*.*****cftanqec ciuick** **>.hii box** **urtd complete** **torn at** **DJCli MICHAEL** **PAUL 9123** **EASY ST** **SAN ANTONIO. TX** **78266-2647 PLEASE** **DETACH THIS** **COUPON AND** **RETURN WITH** **PAYMENT TO** **ADDRESS BELOW:** **METHODIST STONE** **OAK HOSPITAL** **P.O. BOX** **740794 CINCINNATI,** **OH 45274** 

### I'Xhil'H**Thr. imi** **'.Viltl Your** **P/iyimnl Statement** **Date 12/01/2014** **Account Number** **Payment Due** **Date Balance** **Due Payment** **Amount Enclosed** **502157591 12/16/14** **820.45 Ploaso** **do not** **send cash,** **if paying** **by chock** **or monoy** **order, please** **indicate account** **number and** **mako payable** **to tho** **provider. C.tuon** **Cart Numtwr** **CcfCirernbur'A Signature** **am Au'JKwi/dJon** **(ptoase 2hccK** **one) Amount** **PAUL MICHAEL** 

### LIABILITY**STATE FARM** **INSURANCE COMPANIES** **RECEIPT OF** **PAYMENT PAYMENT** **DATE/TIME: 12-03-2014** **11:54AM POLICYHOLDER(S)** **MICHAEL PAUL** **9123 EASY** **ST SAN** **ANTONIO, TX** **78266-2647 POLICY** **DESCRIPTION/POLICY NUMBER** **SFPP PAC** **SUSP-SEE 1115-5352-25** **CHECK/ REF** **000003T3257N2 AMOUNT** **$88.48 TOTAL** **AMOUNT PAID:** **$88.48 AUTHORIZED** **SIGNATURE: NICOLE** **GONZALES AGENT** **Rick Cantara** **Agent 14791** **IH 35** **N, STE** **105 Selma,** **TX78154 (210)656-3276** **THANK YOU** **FOR YOUR** **PAYMENT ON** **THE ABOVE** **POLICY(IES). PAYMENTS** **ARE RECEIVED** **SUBJECT TO** **COLLECTION AND** **POLICY PROVISIONS** **WE APPRECIATE** **YOUR BUSINESS.** **1004258 2002** **142682 201** **0502-2012**

### LIABILITY**PO BOX** **200143 San** **Antonio, TX** **78220 (210)** **333-4287 Fax:** **(210) 333-6287** **11/14/2014**

## i'i**5774 T15** **AUTO"3-DIGIT 782** **Michael Paul** **9123 Easy St** **Garden Ridge** **TX 78266-2647** **RE: MICHAEL** **PAUL, 059174,** **$74.58 Dear** **Valued Customer** **Our records** **indicate that** **your account** **is currently** **past due. Please** **remit your** **payment by** **the 15th** **of this** **month to** **avoid any** **interruption in** **service. If** **payment in** **full cannot** **be made** **at this** **time, please** **contact our** **office at** **(210) 333-4287** **to make** **payment arrangements.** **Failure to** **do so** **will result** **in suspension** **of your** **services. DATE** **INVOICE AMOUNT** **10/1/2014 0000685260** **74.58 Total** **Balance if** **you have** **already remitted** **your pay,** **please disregard** **this notice.** **We appreciate** **your business** **and thank** **you for** **your cooperation** **with this** **matter. Sincerely,** **The Staff** **at Tiger** **Sanitation Inc.** **$74.58**

### BENEFIT

# Blue**Cross MedicareRx** **(pdp)" 23999** **P.O. Box** **3897 Scranton,** **PA 18505** **Effective Date:** **January 01,2015** **Evidence of** **Coverage Rider** **for People** **Who Get** **Extra Help** **Paying for** **Prescription Drugs** **(also called** **Low Income** **Subsidy Rider** **or LIS** **Rider)**

### 011552/PDPTX**Please keep** **this notice** **it is** **part of** **Blue Cross** **MedicareRx Basic** **(PPP)SM's Evidence** **of Coveraiie.** **Our records** **show that** **you qualify** **for extra** **help paying** **for your** **prescription drug** **coverage. This** **means that** **.you will** **get help** **paying your** **monthly premium** **and prescription** **drug co-payments.** **As member** **of our** **Plan, you** **will receive** **the same** **coverage as** **someone who** **is not** **getting extra** **help. Your** **membership in** **our Plan** **will not** **be affected** **by the** **extra help.** **This also** **means that** **you must** **follow all** **the rules** **and procedures** **in the** **Evidence of** **Coverage. Please** **see the** **chart below** **for description** **of your** **prescription drug** **coverage: Your** **monthly plan** **premium is** **S0.00*****Your yearly** **deductible is** **S0.00 Your** **co-payment amount** **for generic/preferred** **multi-source drugs** **is no** **more than** **S2.65 (each prescription)** **Your co-payment** **amount for** **all other** **drugs is** **no more** **than S6.60** **(each prescription)** **The monthly** **plan premium** **does not** **include any** **Medicare Part** **premium that** **you may** **still need** **to pay.** **The plan** **premium you** **pay has** **been calculated** **based on** **the Plan's** **premium and** **the amount** **of extra** **help you** **get. Please** **refer to** **your Evidence** **of Coverage** **for more** **information on** **paying your** **plan premium.** **You must** **continue to** **pay your** **Medicare Part** **premium. The** **benefit information** **provided is** **brief summary,** **not complete** **description of** **benefits. For** **more information** **contact the** **plan. Limitations,** **copayments, and** **restrictions may** **apply. Benefits,** **formulary, pharmacy** **network, provider** **network, premium** **and/or copayment/co-insurance** **may change** **on January** **of each** **year. Blue** **Cross MedicareRx** **is prescription** **drug plan** **provided by** **HCSC Insurance** **Services Company** **(HISC), an** **Independent Licensee** **of the** **Blue Cross** **and Blue** **Shield Association.** **Medicare-approved Part** **sponsor. Enrollment** **in IllSC's** **plan depends** **on contract** **renewal.**

### ;Y0096_liNR_TMP_LIS**Rider PDP** **15 Accepted** **100120!4 BENEFIT** **Regarding Mr. Michael** **Paul with** **telephone number** **210-294-4533, this** **is to** **confirm his** **application and** **certification form** **have been** **approved by** **the Texas** **Low Income** **Discount Administrator.** **Mr. Paul** **is eligible** **for both** **the Lifeline** **(telephone) and** **electric discounts.** **Note the** **electric discount** **runs from** **May through** **August of** **each year.** **His certification** **is valid** **to May** **of 2015.** **Upon recertification,** **more months'** **benefit will** **be extended** **per program** **rules. Note** **his telephone** **carrier (Cricket)** **has not send** **the LIDA** **is customer** **record. Therefore,** **he is** **not receiving** **the Lifeline** **discount. And** **his energy** **company (CPS** **Energy) does** **not participate** **in the** **program. In** **order to** **receive the** **energy discount,** **he would** **need to** **sign up** **with participating** **energy company.** **Dan Marion,** **PMP Account** **Manager-Texas LIDA** **Solix, Inc.** **30 Lanidex** **Plaza West** **Parsippany, NJ** **07054 T:** **973.581.5052 M:** **973.769.7587 www.sollxlnc.com** **Solix on** **Facebook Solix** **on Twitter** **Transparent Solutions.** **Visible Results** **(RBFCUt rbfcu.org** **Statement Period** **11/01/2014 through** **11/30/2014 ,>ersal** **City. TX** **78148-2097 ADDRESS** **SERVICE REQUESTED** **MICHAEL PAUL** **9123 EASY** **ST SAN** **ANTONIO TX** **78266-2647 Direct** **Inquiries to** **Member Services:** **P.O. Box** **2097, Universal** **City, TX** **78148-2097 1-800-580-33001** **rbfcu.org Routing** **#; 314089681** **Thank you** **for your** **membership! We're** **dedicated to** **helping members** **like you** **save time,** **save money** **and earn** **money. CHECKING** **SUMMARY 9656057** **Previous Statement** **Balance Checking** **Rate 0.05** **'APYE 0.00** **S3.99 Total** **Credits $1,385.00** **Total Debits** **-$1,383.89 Current** **Statement Balance** **S5.10 Checking** **Account Deposits** **Date Description** **Amount 11** **/02 Deposit** **Internet Transfer** **from 379907** **CK 11/03** **ACH Deposit** **SSA TREAS** **310 XXSOC** **SEC 11/12** **Deposit CashNetUSA9!411131PAYDAYADV** **$100.00 S79S.00** **S450.00 Date** **Description 11/24** **Deposit Internet** **Transfer from** **184402803 SAV** **11/24 Deposit** **Internet Transfer** **from 184402803** **SAV 11/29** **Deposit Internet** **Transfer from** **184402803 SAV** **Freedom Check** **Card Other** **Transactions Date** **Description Amount** **11/02 Withdrawal** **Internet Transfer** **to 184402803** **SAV -510.00** **11/03 Point** **Of Sale** **Withdrawal NORTHERN** **TOOL 2505** **-$260 00** **NW Loop** **410 SAN** **ANTONIO 11/03** **ACH Withdrawal** **PB 855-306-9430 855-306-9430** **$29 95** **WEBPAYMENT 11/04** **ATM Withdrav/al** **RBFCU 12307** **NACOGDOCHESSAN $40.00** **ANTONIOTXUS 11/06** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **WMSUPERCENTER6102FM -$151.24** **3009 SCHERTZTX** **USA 11/06** **PointOf Sale** **Withdrawal TWOTIME** **WARNER 1565** **-$145.88 fhpnaiilt** **<t flflW.TWrtBI** **1/uo Point** **Of Sale** **Withdrawal STATE** **FARM INSU** **STATE FARM** **PLAZA 800-956-63** **■$88.48 /u/** **vviinorawai 11/09** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **HEB #555** **UNIVERSAL CITTXUS** **11/10 Point** **Of Sale** **Withdrawal CORNER** **STORE 20** **17599 IH** **35 SCHERTZTX** **USA 11/10** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **MCDONALD'S F140** **8631 BROADWAY** **SAN ANTONIO** **TX 11/10** **Withdrawal 11/11** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **JACK IN** **THE BOX** **2235 NE** **LOOP 410** **SAN ANTONIO** **•i40.00 •$46.13** **$17.84 $8.12** **-$12.00 •$4.20** **Date Description** **Ill/ll Point** **Of Sale** **Withdrawal RING** **RING WIREL** **5580 FM** **STF 114** **SCHFKT7 point** **ui bale** **wntiarawal CORNER** **STORE 2017599** **IH (i/iz** **tn. 11-iu/U.n** **Withdrawal PAYPAL** **CREDIT -CONS** **BS -1** **t\\.n wiinurawai** **rHYrML CntUI** **LONb DRS** **(Rejected) 11/12** **ATM Withdrawal** **RBFCU 12415** **OLD CONVERSE** **rrryTvii<: 1/14** **ACH Withdrawal** **CashNetUSA 914111317P4340980-** **PAYDAYADV 11/16** **ATM Withdrawal** **RBFCU 4980** **FM 3009SCHERTZTXUS** **11/17 Withdrawal** **Internet Transfer** **to 184402803** **SAV 11/19** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **Super Nova** **10703 PERRIN** **BEITEL RD** **San Antonio** **11/19 Point** **Of Sale** **Withdrawal CORNER** **STORE 2017599** **IH 35** **N SCHERTZTX USA 11/20** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **WAL Wal-Mart** **Super 92** **SCHERTZTXUS 11/22** **Point Of** **Sale Withdrawal** **FEDEX OFFICE** **11745 WIH** **10 SAN** **ANTONIO TX** **Checks Cleared** **No activity this** **statement period.** **Amount $1.00** **$1.00 $3.00** **Amount $45.00** **-$1.07 -$35.00** **535700 -$160.00** **-$88.27 -S40.00** **-$100.00 $5.00** **-$13.00 $2** **99 -$38** **72 $100** **PAGE OF** **Description Courtesy** **Pay Fees** **Insufficient Funds** **Fees Dividends** 

### Previous**Statement Balance** **S6.00 Other** **Information This** **Period Checking** **$0.00 $0.00** **$0.00 PRIMARY** **SAVINGS SUMMARY** **184402803 Savings** **Rate 0.20** ***APYE 0.00** **Total Credits** **Total Debits** 

### SI**5.60 -$20.60** **YTD-Checking $0.00** **-$24.00 $0.01** **Current Statement** **Balance**

### $1.00**Primary Savings** **Account Deposits** **Other Transactions** **Date Description** **Amount 11/02** **Deposit Internet** **Transfer from** **9656057 CK** **11/10 Withdrawal** **11/17 Deposit** **Internet Transfer** **from 9656057** **CK 11/18** **ACH Deposit** **LENDING CLUB** **-8885963157 Description** **$10.00 ■$15.00** **55.00 $0.60** **Date Description** **Amount 11/16** **ACH Withdrawal** **LENDING CLUB** **-8885963157 11** **/24 Withdrawal** **Internet Transfer** **to 96560S7** **CK 11** **/24 Withdrawal** **Internet Transfer** **to 9656057** **CK 11179** **Withdrawal Internet** **Transfer to 9656057** **CK -50.60** **$1.00 -$1.00** **$3.00 Other** **Information This** **Period Savings** **YTD Savings** **Courtesy Pay** **Fees Insufficient** **Funds Fees** **Dividends $0.00** **$0.00 $0.00** **$0.00 S72.00** **S0.03 'APYE:** **Annual Percentage** **Yield Earned.** **APYE is** **calculated based** **upon account** **activity and** **average monthly** **balance. Please** **examine your** **statement upon** **receipt and** **report any** **differences, irregularities,** **or discrepancies** **as specified** **in the** **RBFCU Membership** **Agreement PAGE** **OF BENEFIT** **Michael T.** **Paul Sign** **Out Need** **Larger Text?** **Accessibility Help** 

# vfe^;**my Social** **Security My** **Home Overview** **Benelit Payment** **Details Earnings** **Record My** **Profile Note:** **If your** **benefit has** **changed in** **recent months,** **your Payment** **Details may** **not show** **the most** **current amounts.** **You can** **view your current** **amounts by** **using the** **link below** **to "Get** **Benefit Verification** **Letter." Benefit** **Details Monthly** **Benefit Amount** **Payment Schedule** **Next Pay~eni** **Date $835** **00 (before** **any deductions)** **3rd of** **the month** **January 3.2015** **The following** **information should** **not be** **used as** **proof of** **coverage It** **Is provlaed** **by the** **Center for** **Medicare Medlcaid** **Services (CMS)** **and may** **not reflect** **recont updates.** **Active Enrolled** **Part (Hospital** **Insurance) Coverage** **Started: Monthly** **Premium' Part** **(Medical Insurance)** **Coverage Started.** **Monthly Premium.** **January 2005** **SO 00 (as** **of January** **2005) November** **2011 $0.00** **(as of** **November 2011)** **Part (Medicare** **Advantage) Please** **contact Medicare** **for the** **status of your** **enrollment. Part** **(Medicare Prescription** **Drug Coverage)** **Please contact** **Medicare for** **the status of** **your enrollment** **team aDout** **replacing your** **Medicare card.** 

### Medicare**Questions? Please** **calLmnQ.fi33*l?27****or visltvA'.w.mediraiaiifiyfor** **assistance Ifvou** **are deaf** **Use the** **browser print** **button to** **print this** **page. Payment** **Method: Direct** **Deposit Your** **monthly payments** **will be** **deposited to** **your account** **automatically.**

### Update**Direct Deposit~]** **Envelope Details'** **https://efile. txcourts.gov/EnvelopeDe** **tails.aspx?envelopeguid= 14ce74cf** 

### Print**this page** 

# Case#2001CI16843**Case Information** **Location**

### Date**Filed Case** **Number Case** **Description**

### Assigned**to Judge** **Attorney**

### Firm**Name**

### Filed**By Filer** **Type Fees** 

### Convenience**Fee Total** **Court Case** **Fees Total** **Court Filing** **Fees Total** **Court Service** **Fees Total** **Filing Service** **Fees**

### Total**Service Tax** **Fees Total** **Provider Service** **Fees**

### Total**Provider Tax** **Fees Grand** **Total Payment** **Account Name** 

### Transaction**Amount**

### Transaction**Response Transaction** **ID Order** **Bexar County** **District Clerk** **12/20/2014 03:59:59** **PM 2001CI16843** **Individual michael** **paul Not** **Applicable**

### $0.06**$0.00 $0.00** 

### $2.00**$0.00 $0.00** 

### $0.00**$0.00 $2.06** **bexar county** **cash account** **for appeal** **$2.06 5866037** **003553213-0 Affidavit** **of Inability** **To Pay** **Indigency Filing** **Type**

### Filing**Code**

### Filing**Description Reference** **Number Comments** **Courtesy Copies** 

### Status**Fees**

### EFilcAndServc

### Affidavit**of Inability** **To Pay** **Indigency**

### AMMENDED**AFFIDAVIT OF** **INABILITY TO** **PAY COURT** **COSTS FOR** **APPEAL 2001-CI-16843/14-14-0791** 

### APPEAL**AFFIDAVIT AMMENDED** **WITH CONTRIBUTING** **DOCUMENTS**

### James.Abanaka@bexar.org**Submitting of** **12/20/2014 4.02** **PM Envek-v** **Details' lutps://cfile.txcourts.gov/EnvclopeDetails.aspx?** **cnvelopcguid= 14ce74cl'-..** 

### Name/Email**Firm SCOT** **GRAYDON**

### SCOT.GRAYDON@TEXASATTORNEYGENERAL.GOV**GREG ABBOTT** 

### greg.abbott@texasattorneygeneral.gov**Service Type** **EServe TEXAS** **ATTORNEY EServe** **GENERAL**

### Status**Served No** **No**

### Sent**Not**

### Sent

### Date/Time**Opened Not** 

### Opened**Not**

### Opened**of 12/20/2014** **4:02 PM** 

### CERTIFICATE**OF SERVICE** 

### hereby**certify that** **on the** **20th day** **of December,** **2014, copy** **of the** **foregoing was** **served on** **the following** **pursuant to** **the Texas** **Rules of** **Civil Procedure:** *********COPIES WILL** **BE GIVEN** **IN COURT** **MONDAY MORNING** **AT 9:00** **AM SINCE** **THESE EMAIL** **DELIVERY NOTICES** **WILL STILL** **BE IN** **TRANSIT. Scott** **M. Graydon** 

### Assistant**Attorney General** **P.O.Box 12584** 

### Austin,**Texas 78711,2548** **Donna Kay** **McKinney**

### Bexar**County District** **Clerk**

### 101**WNueva, Suite** **217 San** **Antonio, TX** **78205-3411 (210)335-2113** **Isl Michael** **Thomas Paul** 

### Michael**Thomas Paul** **9123 Easy Street** 

### San**Antonio, Texas** **78266 210-294-4533** **75.00004500372.vl 995** **vhier1ne stone** **chief justice** **;aken angf.lini** **andee bkvan** **marion <1arialynrarnard** **tl-BHCAC. MARTINEZ** **'ATKICIAO ALVAREZ** **.1.7 l-.l** **i;NA D.** **CIIAPA JLS** **IIC.1;.S**

# COURT**OF APPEALS** **FOURTH COURT** **Of" APPEALS** **DISTRICT CADENA-REEVES** **JUSTICE CENTER** **300 DOLOROSA,** **SUITE 3200** **SAN ANTONIO,** **TEXAS 78205-3037** **WWWTXCOURTS.GOVMTIICOA.ASPX KEITH** **E. MOTTLE** **CLERK OF** **COURT TELEPHONE** **(210)335-2635 FACSIMILE** **NO. (210)335-2762** 

### December**15, 2014** 

### Scot**Macdonald Graydon** 

### Office**of the** **Attorney General** **PGBox 12548** **Austin, TX** **78711-2548 DELIVERED** **VIA E-MAIL** **Michael Thomas** **Paul 9123** **Easy Street** 

### San**Antonio, TX** **78266 04-14-00791-CV** 

### 2001-CI-16843

### RE:**Court of** **Appeals Number:** **Trial Court** **Case Number:** 

### Style:**Michael Thomas** **Paul v.** 

## Greg**Abbot Attoreny** **General for** **the State** **of Texas** 

## The**copy of** **appellant notice** **of appeal** **in the** **above styled** **and numbered** **cause has** **this date** **been filed** **or conditionally** **filed.**

## The**fee for filing** **appeals in** **this court** **from the** **district or** **county is** **$195.00. The** **fee must** **be paid** **at the** **time the** **notice of** **appeal is** **filed. In** **addition, this** **court charges** **an additional** 

## fee**of $10.00** **for the** **filing of** **any motion.** **Any delay** **in remitting** **filing fee** **will delay** **the processing** **of your** **appeal and** **the court's** **ruling on** **pending motions.** **See Tex.** **R. Apr** **P. 5.** 

## Our**records do** **not reflect** **payment of** **the $195.00** **fee. Please** **remit the** **filing fee** **no later** **than December** **29, 2014.** **If the fee** **is not** **paid within** **the time** **allotted, the** **matter will** **be**

## referred**to the** **court, and** **the appeal** **is subject** **to being** **stricken by** **the court.** **See Tex.** **R. App.** **P. 5.** **In accordance** **with Tkx.** **R. App.** **P. 32** **and 4th** **Tex. App.** **(San Antonio)** **Loc. R.** **5.2., docketing** **statement must** **be filed** **with the** **notice of** **appeal. Our** **records do** **not contain** 

## docketing**statement for** **this appeal.** **Please ensure** **that docketing** **statement is** **immediately**

## filed**to ensure** **prompt processing** **of the** **appeal. The** **Appellant's docketing** **statement is** **due from** **Michael Thomas** **Paul. The** **docketing statement** **is to** **be filed** **with this** **court by** **December 29,2014.** **The appellate** **record generally** **must be** **filed in** **this court** **within 60** **days after** **the date** **of judgment** **is signed.** **See Tex.** **R. App.** **P. 35.1.** **Very truly** **yours,**

### KEITH**E. HOTTLE,** **CLERK cc:** 

### Deputy**Clerk. Ext.** **3219**

### Donna**Kay McKinney** **(DELIVERED VIA** **E-MAIL) Dinah** **L. Gaines** **(DELIVERED VIA** **E-MAIL) '.** **■..**