Skip to Main Content

 Admission is always freeOpen today: 10:00  to 5:00  Directions             Play Artle            

                  -  Visit                      - Visit
                    - Getting Here
                    - Accessibility
                    - Tours, Guides & Maps
                    - Food & Drink
                    - Gallery Shops
                    - Visitor Policies 
                  -  Collection                      - Collection
                    - Highlights
                    - Search the Collection
                    - Artists Search
                    - Acquisition Highlights
                    - Stories
                    - Games 
                  -  Exhibitions                      - Exhibitions
                    - Current
                    - Special Installations
                    - Upcoming
                    - On Tour
                    - Past 
                  -  Calendar                      - Calendar
                    - Films
                    - Performances
                    - Talks
                    - Guided Tours
                    - After Hours
                    - Fun for Kids
                    - Festivals
                    - Workshops 
                  -  Learn                      - Learn
                    - Teachers
                    - Families
                    - Teens
                    - Adults
                    - Learning Resources
                    - Music Programs
                    - Film Programs 
                  -  Conservation                      - Conservation
                    - Projects
                    - Publications
                    - Resources 
                  -  Research                      - Research
                    - The Center
                    - Publications
                    - Make an Appointment
                    - Archives
                    - Library
                    - NGA Online Editions 
                  -  Support                      - Support
                    - Donate Now
                    - National Membership
                    - Circle Membership
                    - Leadership Groups
                    - Planned Giving
                    - Major Giving
                    - Gifts of Art 
                  -  Shop                      - Shop
                    - Books
                    - Jewelry
                    - Apparel & Accessories
                    - Kids
                    - NGA Custom Prints 
                  -  Play Artle

Home>Research>Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts>Research Projects>Members' Research Report Archive>Estelle Lingo, 2017–2018

About Fellowships

Senior Fellowships

Visiting Senior Fellowships

Postdoctoral Fellowships

Center/YCBA Postdoctoral Fellowships

Predoctoral Dissertation Fellowships

Center Members

Members’ Presentations

Former Members

Members’ Research Reports, 2011–2018

About Center Meetings

Recent & Upcoming Meetings

A. W. Mellon Lectures in the Fine Arts

Wyeth Foundation for American Art Programs

Sydney J. Freedberg Lectures on Italian Art

Research at the Center

The Index of American Design

History of Early American Landscape Design

The History of the Accademia di San Luca, c. 1590–1635

About the Center Publications

Recent & Upcoming Publications

Reflections on the Collection: The Edmond J. Safra Visiting Professors at the National Gallery of Art

Studies in the History of Art

Seminar Papers

*Center Report*

From the *Bulletin*

Research Publications

Special Publications

National Gallery of Art Shop

# Members' Research Report Archive

*Unbelievable: Rethinking Caravaggio's Religious Art***

**Estelle Lingo**, University of Washington, SeattleAndrew W. Mellon Professor, 2016–2018

Caravaggio, *The Fruit Basket*, c. 1595. Pinacoteca Ambrosiana, Milan; photograph: Scala / Art Resource, NY

The question of how to interpret the religious art of Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610) has divided the vast literature on the artist for decades. A large body of scholarship reads Caravaggio’s religious paintings as giving visual expression to aspects of Counter-Reformation Catholicism. In these accounts the perceived naturalism of Caravaggio’s style and the visual prominence in his works of studio models, who were invariably drawn from the lower classes, are linked to the sensory engagement emphasized in post-Tridentine devotional practices and concern with the plight of the poor among new religious orders. Many other scholars, however, take these same visual features as the basis for a diverging view of Caravaggio as a protomodern artist, whose painterly commitments are variously interpreted as a subversion of the authority of the institutional church, religious skepticism or atheism, or the visualization of libertine desires. Those scholars seeking a middle ground have usually found it by embracing an inherent ambiguity in Caravaggio’s religious painting, which is often construed as an aspect of the artist’s modernity. Such solutions are attractive but in general have not effectively situated the operations of Caravaggio’s paintings in their historical contexts.

It seems clear, then, that the interpretation of Caravaggio’s sacred art is largely inseparable from the question of the implications of his style. Caravaggio painted in a new way that art historians are still working to describe adequately—visually, technically, and historically—but that, as the seventeenth-century painter and art writer Joachim von Sandrart memorably put it, made “most other pictures appear to be composed of colored paper.” Both Caravaggio’s contemporaries and modern scholars have understood the artist’s method of painting directly from the model in a controlled studio environment, without the mediation of preparatory figure drawings or elaborate compositional studies, as the key to this startling effect. In early modern art writing and still today, Caravaggio’s style is most commonly—but too generically—described as naturalistic. This book project seeks to rethink the debate over Caravaggio’s religious art by developing a more precise account of his approach to the figure and the resulting visual characteristics of his painted surfaces.

I propose that Caravaggio approached figure painting from outside its traditions and methods, applying emerging illusionistic techniques for still life to representation of the human figure. The result was an uncanny new type of image that crossed the wires of much contemporary thinking about painted representation; early commentators on Caravaggio’s art articulated with striking clarity the gains and losses of approaching the human figure as still life and struggled to pinpoint what was natural and unnatural about it. Furthermore, while Caravaggio worked within the medium of painting, through his visual insistence upon the presence of the studio model and his evolution of a technique that artificially manipulated light in order to structure form, he created some of the conditions of viewing that would later be produced by photography. The early modern reception of Caravaggio’s art amply attests to the ways his paintings gave the question of the image’s relation to the real-world referent—the bodies of his models—a critical urgency that would not recur until the invention of photography. This urgency, I contend, stemmed from a sense that the different type of viewing enabled by this new form of image held significant risks in relation to the traditional functions of the religious image, functions that were under renewed scrutiny and institutional surveillance in the post-Tridentine era.

Moving away from attempts to reinscribe Caravaggio’s sacred art as either wholly orthodox or somewhat crudely subversive, my study explores the historical ramifications of this visual innovation, reconsidering Caravaggio’s religious paintings as evidence for the artist’s own searching exploration of the possibilities that this method of production and mode of viewership created for the early modern sacred image. I believe, moreover, that this work may be undertaken most fruitfully by thinking in unaccustomed ways across the historiographies of early modern painting and photography, not least because these histories are in fact related. The late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century debates about whether or not photography could be considered art were directly informed by academic conceptions of art that were first formalized and mobilized in the seventeenth century in response to the threat that Caravaggio’s painting was perceived to represent. From this wider vantage point, it is possible to recognize Caravaggio’s painterly experiments as a first tear in the screen of traditional representation, a wound sanitized and sutured by academic criticism, but definitively reopened by the advent of photography.

*Center 38*

*Mochi's Edge and Bernini's Baroque, Caravaggio's Religious Art, and The Grand Tour from the Italian Perspective***Estelle Lingo,**Andrew W. Mellon Professor, 2016–2018

*Francesco Mochi and the Edge of Tradition***Estelle Lingo**, Samuel H. Kress Senior Fellow, 2011–2012**

                  - Caravaggio
                  - Italian , 1571 - 1610

### Stay connected

Learn more about our exhibitions, news, programs, and special offers.

About
          - About the National Gallery
          - Stories
          - Press
          - FAQs
          - Contact Us

Plan a Visit
          - Getting Here
          - Accessibility
          - Today's Tours
          - Food & Drink
          - Calendar
          - Downloadable Map

Get Involved
          - Donate
          - Membership
          - Volunteer
          - Opportunities
          - Shop Online

Resources
          - Search the Collection
          - Conservation
          - Library
          - Archives
          - The Center
          - Film Programs
          - Music Programs
          - Audio/Video
          - Open Access Images

Hours: 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. daily

**West Building**6th St and Constitution Ave NW*Enter or exit from Constitution Avenue, 4th Street, or 7th Street. The Madison Drive entrance is currently closed.*

**East Building**4th St and Constitution Ave NW*Enter and exit from 4th Street.*

**Sculpture Garden**7th St and Constitution Ave NW*Enter and exit from 7th Street, Constitution Avenue, or Madison Drive.*

We are closed on December 25 and January 1.

*The National Gallery of Art serves the nation by welcoming all people to explore and experience art, creativity, and our shared humanity.*

          -  Twitter 
          -  Facebook 
          -  Instagram 
          -  Pinterest 
          -  YouTube 

© 2024 National Gallery of Art   Notices   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy