U.S. flag
        An official website of the United States government
          Here’s how you know
        Here’s how you know**Official websites use .gov**
              
              A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
        **Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
              
              A **lock** (  A locked padlock
) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. https://www.nist.gov/itl/voting/vvsg-background
  Search NIST
    Search
              Menu

      


Close
    Topics
        All Topics
                                                        Advanced communications
                                                        Artificial intelligence
                                                        Bioscience
                                                        Buildings and construction
                                                        Chemistry
                                                        Climate
                                                        Cybersecurity
                                                        Electronics
                                                        EnergyEnvironment
                                                        Fire
                                                        Forensic science
                                                        Health
                                                        Information technology
                                                        Infrastructure
                                                        Manufacturing
                                                        Materials
                                                        Mathematics and statisticsMetrology
                                                        Nanotechnology
                                                        Neutron research
                                                        Performance excellence
                                                        Physics
                                                        Public safety
                                                        Resilience
                                                        Standards
                                                        Transportation
            Publications
            Labs & Major Programs
        Laboratories
                                Communications Technology Laboratory
                                  Engineering Laboratory
                                  Information Technology Laboratory
                                  Material Measurement Laboratory
                                  Physical Measurement LaboratoryUser Facilities
                                NIST Center for Neutron Research
                                  CNST NanoFab
                                                        Research Test Beds
                                                        Research Projects
                                                        Tools & InstrumentsMajor Programs
                                Baldrige Performance Excellence Program
                                  CHIPS for America Initiative
                                  Manufacturing Extension Partnership (MEP)
                                  Office of Advanced Manufacturing
                                  Special Programs Office
                                  Technology Partnerships Office
            Services & Resources
        Standards and Measurements
                                Calibration Services
                                  Laboratory Accreditation (NVLAP)
                                  Quality System
                                  Standard Reference Materials (SRMs)
                                  Standards.gov
                                  Time Services
                                  Office of Weights and MeasuresSoftware
                                                        Data
                                Chemistry WebBook
                                  National Vulnerability Database
                                  Physical Reference Data
                                  Standard Reference Data (SRD)
                                                        Storefront
                                                        License & PatentsComputer Security Resource Center (CSRC)
                                                        NIST Research Library
            News & Events
        News
                                                        Events
                                                        Blogs
                                                        Feature Stories
                                                        AwardsVideo Gallery
                                                        Image Gallery
                                                        Media Contacts
            About NIST
        About Us
                                Leadership
                                  Organization Structure
                                  Budget & Planning
                                                        Contact Us
                                                        Visit
                                                        Careers
                                Student programsWork with NIST
                                                        History
                                NIST Digital Archives
                                  NIST Museum
                                  NIST and the Nobel
                                                        Educational Resources
 
 Information Technology Laboratory
      Voting
    
      
  Research and Projects
                            Expand or Collapse
          VVSG
                      TGDC
                      Test Labs
                      Accessibility and Human Factors
                      Election Security
                      Interoperability
          Events
          About Us
          History of Voting
                            Expand or Collapse
          Archived Research Papers
          Contact UsVVSG Background

Share
  Facebook
                      Linkedin
                      Twitter
                      Email

VVSG BackgroundThis section contains background summary information on the VVSG, including the legislation responsible for its writing and a history of previous versions of the VVSG.**Earlier NIST Involvement**In 1974, the National Bureau of Standards (now the National Institute of Standards and Technology) began a research project under computer scientist Roy G. Saltman, funded by the Office of Federal Elections of the General Accounting Office.  This project resulted in a 1975 NBS Interagency Report, later reprinted as SP 500-30, Effective Use of Computing Technology in Vote-Tallying.  The report provided findings and conclusions about improving the accuracy and security of the vote-tallying process, about improving the management of the election preparation process, and about institutional factors affecting accuracy and security.  The report also pointed out the lack of systematic research on election equipment and systems, and on human engineering of voting equipment, and it concluded that the setting of national minimum standards for federal election procedures would serve a valuable function.**The 1990 VSS**In 1984, Congress appropriated funds for the FEC to develop voluntary national standards for computer-based voting systems.  The FEC formally approved the Performance and Test Standards for Punchcard, Marksense and Direct Recording Electronic Voting Systems in January 1990, which became known as the 1990 Voting Systems Standard (VSS).The national testing effort was developed and overseen by the National Association of State Election Director's Voting Systems Board, which is composed of election officials and independent technical advisors.  NASED's testing program was initiated in 1994 and more than 30 voting systems or components of voting systems have gone through the NASED testing and qualification process.  In addition, many systems have subsequently been certified at the state level using the Standards in conjunction with functional and technical requirements developed by state and local policymakers to address the specific needs of their jurisdictions.**The 2002 VSS**As the qualification process matured and qualified systems were used in the field, the Voting Systems Board, in consultation with the testing labs, identified certain testing issues that needed to be resolved.  Moreover, rapid advancements in information and personal computer technologies introduced new voting system development and implementation scenarios not contemplated by the 1990 VSS.In 1997, NASED briefed the FEC on the necessity for continued Commission involvement, citing the importance of keeping the Standards current in its reflection of modern and emerging technologies employed by voting system manufacturers.  Following a Requirements Analysis released in 1999, the Commission authorized the Office of Election Administration to revise the Standards to reflect contemporary needs of the elections community.  This resulted in the 2002 Voting System Standards, or 2002 VSS.**HAVA and VVSG 2005**In 2002, Congress passed the Help America Vote Act (HAVA) [HAVA02], which created a new process for improving voluntary voting system guidelines.  A new federal entity was created, the Election Assistance Commission (EAC), to oversee the process. The EAC established the Technical Guidelines Development Committee (TGDC) in accordance with the requirements of Section 221 of HAVA pursuant to the Federal Advisory Committee Act, 5 U.S.C. App. 2.  The objectives and duties were to act in the public interest to assist the EAC in the development of the voluntary voting system guidelines.  The membership, as defined by HAVA, includes:The Director of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) who shall serve as its chair,Members of the EAC Standards Board,Members of the EAC Board of Advisors,Members of the Architectural and Transportation Barrier, and Compliance Board (U.S. Access Board),A representative of the American National Standards Institute (ANSI),A representative of the Institute of Electrical & Electronics Engineers (IEEE),Two representatives of the NASED selected by such Association who are not members of the Standards Board or Board of Advisors, and who are not of the same political party, andOther individuals with technical and scientific expertise relating to voting systems and voting equipment.The TGDC first met in July 2004 and delivered its initial set of recommendations to the EAC in April 2005.  Operating as a Federal Advisory Committee, the TGDC formed three working subcommittees:Security and Transparency (STS),Human Factors and Privacy (HFP), andCore Requirements and Testing (CRT).The three subcommittees in collaboration with NIST recommended requirements for adoption by the full Committee at public plenary sessions. The TGDC's initial set of recommendations, VVSG 2005, augmented the VSS 2002 by including security measures for auditability, wireless communications and software distribution and set up, and improvements for the accessibility guidelines and usability design guidelines for voting systems.The TGDC also recommended that the VVSG 2005 be replaced with a far-reaching guideline that would address in-depth security, performance-based guidelines for usability testing and an overhaul of the standards and test methods to meet today's more rigorous needs for electronic voting systems.  This new VVSG, applied to the next generation of voting equipment, addresses those needs.**Relationship of HAVA and the VVSG**Although both HAVA and the VVSG contain requirements, the scope and application are quite different in the two cases.  HAVA is a Federal law that, among other things, provides to the states financial aid for the purchase of new voting equipment. In section 301 it also sets forth broad functional standards for voting systems as used in Federal elections. That is, it governs the systems as actually deployed in polling places throughout the country. Violation of these standards may result in adverse action by the Department of Justice against a State or other voting jurisdiction. The standards encompass procedures as well as equipment, e.g. the requirement that each state adopt a uniform definition of a "vote".The VVSG is a set of highly detailed technical requirements in support of the broad goals of HAVA. These requirements apply only to voting equipment, not to procedures in the polling place. If a type of voting system (i.e. a particular make and model) meets all of the VVSG requirements (as determined by conformance testing conducted by an accredited laboratory), then that type is eligible to be certified as being compliant with the VVSG. Thus the VVSG is addressed to vendors of voting equipment, not to states. Finally, although many states will purchase only equipment that has been certified, the guidelines are voluntary in that states are free to purchase and use non-certified systems, as long as they comply with the HAVA standards.Table 1: HAVA and the VVSGCharacteristicHAVAVVSGStatusFederal LawFederal GuidelinesScopeVoting Systems and ProceduresVoting EquipmentPrimary AudienceStatesEquipment VendorsEnforcementDept of JusticeEACPhase of Life-cycleProcurement/DeploymentConformance TestingLevel of SpecificationBroad/FunctionalDetailed/Technical
  Information technology and Voting systems

    
    Created September 28, 2010, Updated May 25, 2017
 HEADQUARTERS
            100 Bureau Drive
              Gaithersburg, MD 20899301-975-2000
            Webmaster | Contact Us | Our Other Offices
        Twitter
            
Facebook
            
LinkedIn
            
Instagram
            
YouTube
            
Giphy
            
RSS Feed
            
Mailing List
                              How are we doing? Feedback

  
  Site Privacy
                      Accessibility
                      Privacy Program
                      Copyrights
                      Vulnerability Disclosure
                      No Fear Act Policy
                      FOIA
                      Environmental Policy
                      Scientific Integrity
                      Information Quality Standards
                      Commerce.gov
                      Science.gov
                      USA.gov
                      Vote.gov