A!Smart!Manufacturing!Public2Private!Partnership!Program!

Jim!Davis!UCLA!&!Smart!Manufacturing!Leadership!Coalition

Version!1/3/11

Wh

man

a

u

t

f

%i

o

a

s

c

Sm

n

turi

a

n

rt

g!a

Ma

p

nd

n

!s

u

u

f

p

a

p

ct ri g

envir men ! rodu

s

c

t!qu

ly

u

l

!c

i

h

n

y,

ain

?

e r n !

g

en

m a u ur !a !e e

ta

ec

r e

o

ng a!d

t

r

, c a

f

t an

!e

d

n

!p

t

ro

rp

d

i

c

se

s

i

.!I

i

s

g

m

ame h

u vi y!

!th

m

e

p

h

t t

nuf

ro

or

vem

t!ter

t

,

s

!s

.!

m

L

ar

at an t

on

t!

er!ter

n

m

fa

,

c

sm

t

a

i

rt

ng d

nuf

dres

c

es

ng

ffici

s

ncy,!

an

o

ti

mic , flex

am

ible

i

!s v

und tal i t!i c ng pr

!ma

d

a turi !i !

sh

m

n

re

ufactu

s

r n om

er

d

ice=ori

h

ente

n dy

a

(

lt

! usi

i

e

g!

ss!

en

in

c

ra

pass

c

es!t e!(1

d

)!

!f

t

a

e

c

c

to

f

d

n

rie

n!

s

m

n

a

d!de

a

ma

ur

nd

i

=dri

o

h ology,

!a u

ri

e ab

ve

i

n!

ce

s

ss

l

p

e

p

s

l

!t

y

o

!c

w

h

a

a

r

in

d!d

se

e

r

m

v

al

ic

an

e!e

=

ture n w

n

hich a ufac

(2

tu

)!in i

c !

n

t

g!

r

in

op

te

e

y,

l

r

lig

ity, 3)!operation !prac

nte

na

t c

rp

m

ris

ic

e

e!and!

s

(

.

4

!S

)

mart!

mu u

ru ! m n

Wha

i

t

p

!a

le

b

re

me

n

aningf

f

!u

st

e!ar s!

c

t

!o

t

hat i clude!economi , energ ! H

n

&

c

!a

c

n

a

d

n

s s

!g

ta

e

i

n

n

e

abi

t

l

e

l s

l

ea ! E

e

S

e! b

u

e ra

o

it

d

y!

!a

p

n

er

d

f

!a

a

the

t

!P t

g

entia !Impa s

o

p

rm

pl

a

ie

n

d

ce.

to

fiv

wo

e

rk

m

!of

n

!2

u

0

fa n

estim ted!m

!c

c

o

u

m

r

p

in !consortia,!six

n

!u

?!

n

Th

iv

e

er

S

s

m

it

a

ie

r

s

t

,

M

o

a

e

nuf

!go

a

v

c

e

t

r

ur

anies!an

p

d!20! iversities to! eve op!a!r

n

o

m

ing

ad

e

m

n

!L

t

e

ap

la

ad

!f

b

e

o

)

r

r

h

s

!s

a

h

m

s

ip!

a

b

r

u

C

t!

ilt

oa

m

l

a

o

it

u n

n

i

u

o

th

n!

d a

e

[

l c

!e

SM

t

a

r

r

L

l

a

n

i

C

e

]

g

r!N

(2

T

S

5

a

nd dri

eani gful!i

e

m

our

c

c

ts:

. he

F

!c

!S

!f

o

De

n

M

u

m

n

pa

L

d

C

e

ni

!h

d

a

es,!

f u i s!

ef

imp

fi

m

c

l

i

a

e

en

me

c

'

y

n

;

t

10%

in

ve

g

n

!mo

u

im

s

d

e

p

e

of

r

l

ov

in

r

g

e

s

m

an

e

d

nt

!s

e

i

i

s

mu

n!

+&

ov

l

h

a

i

e

t

g

r

i

h

o

a

l

n

l

y

l

;!

op

opt

25%

e

i

r

m

a

!r

t

i

i

z

e

ng

e

du

d+

!e

c

pl

f

t

f

i

an

i

on!

Pr

!w

d

a

uc

te

t

r

s

!u

a

s

fe

a

t

g

ci

t

e

s

i

nc

n!

an

s

y

a

d+

;!4

f

s

e

u

0

ty

ppl

%

!inc

re

y+

i

n

d

de

e

u

t

c

nt

w

ti

or

s

o

;!

n

ks

25%

+'+80%

!in!cy

!i

c

m

le

p

!r

r

e

ti

ov

du

m

e

c

e

m

ti

s;!

e

on!

40%

nt!

i

i

n!

n!

c

in

!r

e

os

e

ne

t

du

r

!of

e

c

gy

tion!

o +

s

Su

man

tai

ag

n

e

abl

d!d

e

y

+pr

n

y

a

'

mi

Pr

c

o

c

a

duc

t

l

i

ly;!

t

p

!t

pr

ro

ra

oc

d

cki

u

s

c

ng

s

t

e

!t

s

ru

and!

+for

st

market!

c

wo

tra

ur

r

c

r

t

e

e

h

a

n

i

t

n

b

+an

e

il

s

ity!throughout!the!supply!chain;!pinpoint!product!recalls!

s odu on e +

ng

Maintain

in

+a

!t

n

a

d

rg

+e

e

x

t

;!m

p

!i

a

n

n

d

d

u

+e

st

x

r

is

ie

ti

s

n

;!

g

25%

U.S

re

in

d

u

u

s

c

t

t

r

io

ia

n

l i

i

n

n

n

!c

d+

o

v

n

fu

a

su

tu

t o

m

re

n

e

+c

+b

r!

r

a

p

it

s

a

i

e

c

c

'+

k

al

ag

in

i

dustries'+10x!improvement!in!time!to!

re

ma

ve

k

n

e

u

t

e!in

or

!ne

e

w!p

ghl

ro

y

d

!s

u

k

ct

il

s!

l

a

d

n

!s

d

u

!se

st

rv

a

.

in

ic

a

d

e

b

s

l

;!

e

2x

!job

curre

o

nt!s

i

mall!and!medium!enterprises!

c

(S

e

M

nt

E

!i

s)!

ndu

ad

s

d

tr

e

25%!revenue!in!adja

r hi

re

ie

ssi

s;!25%

ng!to

What%is%the%Marke

l

t%Failure

s!created

tal!

di

"h

s

o

i

m

nc

e

e

g

nt

ro

iv

w

es

"!

!a

cu

nd

s

!s

to

o

m

w

ize

,!incre

T

m

he

en

!c

ta

u

l

r

!a

re

d

nt

d!so twa e!or!m

op

!m

a

t

n

io

a

u

n

rke

a

.!

l!p

Mo

t cr

in

ap

s

e

t

e

r

U

at

=in

.S

e

.

s

t

!ma

!a!cy

ens

n

iv

u

cl

e

f

e

a

!p

c

o

r

t

f

o

u

!s

c

r

m

e

e

s

r

a

s

s

r

e

!c

t!

u

m

.!

r

W

r

a

e

n

n it

n

u

h

t

f

ou

l

a

y

ct

f

!ma

ur

r t!the

n

in

a

g

at!

d

c

u

u

s

r

t

r

r

e

y!st

t!gr

anda

s

t

rd

h!

!a

at

pp

e

ro

s. At

aches,!no!single!vendor!has!been!able!to!profit bly!develop via

!s

g

b

c

e

in

a l

al

!p

v

e!

ab

r

e

o

s

! bu

i

d

tm

si

li

u

t

n

y!

c

e

t

n

e

of

io

t!

ss!

n!with!

n ow r the!company!and!factory!level,!vertically!segmented!investments

op

compartmentalized!infrastructure,!(2)!uncoordinated!applications!on!replicated!infrastructu

!i

volume!

r

n

e,

(1

!an

)!

d!(3)!

ri

eration

ma

sky,!expe

al

nsi

as

v

s

e

im

,!in

il

c

at

re

ion

men

!of

t

!n

al

on

!an

!s

d

tan

slo

dar

w!r

ds

etu

b

r

as

n

e

!s

d!

m

m

ar

ode

t!m

l

a

in

n

g!

uf

an

ac

d!

tu

s

r

i

i

m

ng

ul

i

at

nf

i

r

on

ast

r

r

e

u

m

ct

ai

ur

n

e!

!m

in

or

ves

e!e

tm

as

en

ily!

ts

ju

.!

s

De

tif

s

i

p

ed!

ite

over

$5

to

0

jo

=

r

!$

!i

6

n

0

d

!b

us

il

t

l

r

io

y!

n

p

!i

r

n

o

!2

je

0

ct

=

e

!4

d

0

!imp

!yea

a

r

c

!o

ts

ld

o

!m

f!s

a

ma

in

r

fr

t

a

!ma

me

n

!d

u

i

f

s

a

t

c

r

t

i

u

b

r

u

i

t

n

e

g

d

,!

!c

it

o

!i

n

s!

t

u

r

n

ol

p

!s

r

ys

ofi

t

t

em

abl

s

e

!in

to

U.

!re

S

p

.!m

lac

a

e

nu

th

fa

e

c

!s

t

t

u

i

r

ll

in

se

g

r

!p

v

l

i

a

c

n

ea

ts

ble!

dig

d

i

a

t

y

al

e

!a

v

g

e

e

n

!m

!th

a

o

nu

ug

fa

h

c

!t

t

he

ur

s

ing

e!s

.

ystems embody!the!production!technologies!adapted!to!the!old!regime!of!pre=

Lar

ar

ge!companies!that!are!applying!enterprise!smart!manufacturing!within!their!boundaries!see!benefit!but!

in

e!not!able!to!reap!the!more!significant!rewards!of!a!demand=dynamic!economy!without!the!broader!

en

frastructure!inv

m

estment!across!the!supply!chain.!Simultaneously,!the!market!creates!a!prohibitive!cost!of!

try!into!smart anufacturing!for!small!and!

1

medium!size!companies,!resulting!in!slow!adoption!within!

Smart!Manufacturing!is!the!dramatically!intensified!application!of!

manufacturing!intelligence!using!advanced!data!analytics,!modeling!and!simulation!throughout!the!
2

the!supply!chain!and!impacting!the!investment!return!for!both!the!large!and!small!companies!that!do!

ef

in

f

v

ec

es

t

t

i

.

ven

U.S

es

.!s

s

m

!a

a

l

rt!manufacturing!infrastructure!remains!balkanized!with!limited!factory!and!supply!chain!

th

for

at!

n

r

e

e

w

tr

,!

o

g

f

r

i

e

t!

e

a

n

p

fie

p

o

l

n

ic

g

a

!w

tio

it

n

h

o

s

f

ig

s

n

m

if

a

i

r

c

t!

an

m

t

a

!r

n

ep

uf

l

a

ic

c

a

tu

ted!but!u

ld!plants!which!are!mostly!

r

d

ing!in!U

n

.

c

S

o

.!b

o

r

r

o

d

w

in

n

a

f

t

i

ed

eld

!in

p

ves

lan

t

ts

m

!i

en

s!a

t.

m

!T

o

h

r

is

e

i

d

s!

i

a

ff

g

ic

g

u

ra

lt!

va

in

t

v

ed

es

!b

tm

y!

e

th

n

e!

t!th

fac

a

t

n

in

viab

fra

l

s

e

t

!a

ru

t!a

ct

!t

u

i

r

m

e

e

!fo

!w

r!

h

s

e

m

n

a

!t

r

h

t

e

!m

!U

an

.S.!i

uf

n

ac

du

tu

s

r

t

i

r

n

y

g,

!ne

n

e

e

d

w

s!t

m

ep

od

loy

el

e

i

d

ng!

in

an

!ot

d

h

!s

e

i

r

m

!c

u

o

l

u

at

n

i

t

on

rie

!i

s

n

.

d

Wi

us

t

t

h

r

o

ie

u

s

t

ar

a!b

e

a

!n

s

ot

ic!i

ec

nd

o

u

n

s

o

t

m

ria

ic

l

ally!

de

What%is%needed?%

o!move!aggressiv

mand=dynamic!

M

m

an

anu

uf

f

ac

ac

t

t

u

u

r

r

i

i

n

ng

g!

.!

d

Ne

ata!

w

is

in

!th

d

e

us

e

t

s

r

s

y

e

=

n

su

ce

pp

of

ort

ma

ed

nu

o

f

rg

ac

a

t

e

u

ly

ri

!i

n

n

g

to

in

!s

t

m

ell

a

i

r

g

t

e

!m

nc

a

e

nufacturing.!

nization,!business,

an

!in

d

te

!t

ro

he!key!to!new!

te

th

ch

e!e

n

n

o

tr

lo

y

g

!o

y

f

!m

!e

odels!and!infrastructure!across!multiple!industry!segments!are!needed!to!si

p

g

e

n

ra

ifi

b

c

i

a

l

n

it

tl

y!

y

an

lo

d

wer!

se

mo

rv

re

ic

!e

e

a

=or

sil

i

y

ent

n

e

t

d

ry

!f

!t

ac

o

t

!p

o

e

ry

rv

!e

a

n

s

t

i

e

v

r

e

p

!a

r

p

is

p

e

l

!m

ica

o

t

d

io

e

n

ls

!o

.!Da

f!da

ta

ta

!n

!a

e

n

e

a

d

l

s

yt

t

i

o

cs

b

,!m

e!m

o

o

d

r

e

e

li

!e

n

a

g

s

!a

il

n

y

d

!o

!s

b

i

t

mulation!and!to!demonstrate

selectively!sh

co

a

l

re

le

d

ct

!a

e

m

d,

o

!c

n

o

g

ns

c

i

o

s

m

te

p

n

a

tl

n

y

ie

d

s.

ef

Cor

ined

e!

,!

ca

ma

pa

n

b

a

i

g

li

e

t

d

ie

!a

s

s

!w

!a

i

n

th

!o

!m

pe

o

r

d

a

e

ti

li

n

n

g

g

!a

!a

s

n

se

d

t,

s

!s

ai

im

ha

n

re

e

d

d

w

vi

i

a

th

lo

in

w

!c

!c

o

o

mp

st!s

a

e

n

n

ie

s

s

o

,

r

!a

s

n

,!

d!

im

and

pl

be

em

co

en

m

ta

e

t

!b

io

r

n

oa

n

d

e

l

e

y

d

!a

s

c

!t

c

o

es

b

s

e

ib

!c

l

u

e

t

!t

!in

o!s

!h

m

a

a

lf!

ll,!m

ulation!must!be!developed!

by!s

e

h

d

a

i

r

u

in

m

g

!a

!p

n

r

d

e=

la

co

rg

m

e

p

!e

e

n

t

t

it

e

i

r

v

p

e

r

!co

ise

s

s

t

.

s

T

.!

he!cost!of!operational!

si

Th

m

e

u

se

la

!g

ti

o

o

a

n

ls

pl

!a

at

re

for

fac

m

ili

th

ta

a

te

t

d

fu

!by

nct

a

io

n!

n

in

s!a

du

s!a

st

+c

ry

le

=di

ar

r

in

ec

g

t

h

e

o

d,

u

!c

se

o

an

mm

d+

u

g

n

at

it

e

y

w

!s

ay

ou

!f

r

o

ce!data!analytics,!modeling!and!

infrastructure,!practices!and!workforce!needs.!A!community!source!p

r

l

!c

a

o

tf

r

o

e

r

,!p

m

r

wo

e=co

ul

m

d!p

pe

r

t

o

i

v

ti

i

v

s

e

io

!t

n

o

:

ols,!

(1)

as

A!t

s

e

im

st!

i

b

lat

ed

ion

!en

!of

vir

e

o

xi

n

s

m

ti

e

n

n

g!

t,

m

!fu

od

lly

el

a

in

v

g!

ai

an

lab

d

le

si

t

m

o!

u

sm

lat

a

i

ll,

on

!m

!ap

ed

p

i

r

u

oac

m!a

h

n

e

d

s,

la

!th

r

e

ge

d

!c

e

o

ve

m

lop

pan

m

i

e

e

n

s,

t

to

!an

!a

d

cc

te

e

s

le

ti

r

n

a

g!

te

of

!testing!and!

products,!and!demand!dynamic!manufacturing!innovations.

!new!

(2)

pl

fa

St

c

an

ilit

d

ie

ar

s

d

!(

iz

e

e

.g

d

.!r

,!i

i

nteroperable!an

ug!and!play!func

sk!management

d

,!e

!s

n

u

e

s

r

t

g

ai

y

n

!m

ab

a

l

n

e

a

!b

g

u

e

s

m

in

e

e

n

s

t

s

,!e

!d

m

ec

is

is

s

i

i

on

ons

m

!c

od

om

e

p

li

l

n

ia

g!

n

an

ce

d

!st

s

a

im

tis

u

t

l

i

at

cs

i

)

on

!in

!t

!a

ool

!lib

s

r

!a

a

n

ry

d

!of!

da

wi

s

th

hb

!a

oa

!sh

r

a

ds

re

!f

d

or

!da

indu

tio

s

ns

try

.!Th

wi

e

de

se

!ke

!to

y

ols!would!be!de

ta!access!program

!p

.

erformance!indi

velo

ca

p

t

e

or

d!

s

fo

!(

r

K

!e

PI

n

s

te

)!

r

t

p

ha

ris

t!

e

ar

r

e

ea

de

l=

v

ti

e

m

lope

e,!d

d!

ata

in!

=dr

com

ive

b

n!

ination!

(3) Sh

(de

ar

m

e

a

d

n

!s

d

u

=dr

pp

i

l

v

y!

e

c

n!

h

p

ai

r

n

odu

!mod

cti

e

on

ls!

)

with!end=to=end!visibility!aimed!at!dramatically!reduced!inventories!

ch

tra

a

c

i

k

n

i

,

n

!im

g/

p

tr

r

a

o

c

v

e

e

a

d

b

!p

il

r

ity

od

!th

uct

ro

!a

u

v

g

a

h

i

,

la

dyn

bili

am

ty,!

i

f

c

a

!i

s

n

te

vol

r!p

ve

ro

m

d

e

u

n

ct

t

i

!of

on

!s

!o

m

f!

al

cu

l!

s

an

to

d!

m

m

ize

edi

d!p

u

r

m

od

e

u

n

ct

te

s

r

,

p

!a

r

n

is

d

e

!i

s

n

!i

s

n

t

!t

a

h

n

e

t!

!supply!

out!the!supply!chain.

te

Wh

ch

y

n

!a

o

!P

lo

ubl

gy,!(2

ic2

)!

Pr

in

i

te

va

ro

te

pe

Pa

ra

r

b

t

i

ne

lity

rs

,!(3

hi

)!

p!

o

M

p

ode

erati

l?

o

The!U.S.!needs!inv

which!manufacturing!intelligence!can!be!gene

n

r

a

a

l!

t

p

e

r

d

a

!a

cti

nd

ce

!a

!a

p

n

p

d

estment!in!t

lie

(4

d

)!

!to

sh

mu

are

l

d

tip

b

l

u

h

e

si

e

ne

(1

ss

)

IN

pr

F

e=

R

co

AS

m

T

p

R

e

U

ti

C

ti

T

v

U

e!

RE!on!

in

en

t

t

e

i

r

re!

ve

f

n

ac

tio

to

n

ry!

!w

a

il

n

l

d

!q

!s

u

u

ic

p

k

p

l

l

y

y!

!l

c

o

h

w

a

e

in

r!t

!en

he

t

!c

er

o

p

s

r

t

i

!o

ses

f!a

.

s

Go

sim

ve

il

r

a

n

ti

m

ng

e

!m

nt!

o

in

d

v

e

e

li

s

n

t

g

m

!a

e

n

n

d

t!

!s

th

im

ro

u

u

l

g

me

a

h!a

a

!p

n

u

in

b

g

tion!in

l

o

i

f

t

c

u

=

l

pr

!u

i

s

v

e

!enterp

a

!a

t

r

e

rea

is

!pa

s

r

!a

tne

cro

rs

s

h

s!

ip!

tw

by!

o

an!

fo

e

u

st

n

i

d

m

ati

at

o

e

n

d

a

!8

l!g

0

o

%

al

a

s

n

!o

d

f!th

wi

e

ll

!p

!p

a

ro

rtn

vi

e

de!the!demonstration!models!and!test!beds!to!help!lower!ri

e

sk

!o

.

p

!T

e

h

ra

e

t

se

ions!

in

ap

v

p

e

r

s

oac

tme

h

n

e

t

s

u

an

nc

d

e

!t

r

e

t

c

a

h

in

n

t

ol

y,

ogi

!pro

e

v

s!

id

th

e

at

!th

!c

e

an

r

v

s

e

h

h

i

ic

p!

l

w

e!

i

t

l

o

l!a

s

c

h

c

a

e

r

l

e

er

r

a

is

te

k

d

an

ev

d

e

!p

lo

r

p

odu

ment!and!demonstration,!reduce!

will!overcome!the!market!tendency!to

s

d

h

o

ow

!nu

!t

m

he

er

w

ou

ay!

s!l

t

o

o!

we

rai

r

s

!r

e

is

th

k!

e

in

m

cr

e

e

d

c

i

e

an

!com

!for

monly!used,!non=competitive!

risk!(currently)!step=changes.!It!provides!the!capacity!for!demonstra

m

tio

e

n

n

!m

tal!c

U

h

.S.

an

!i

g

n

e

d

s

u

!v

st

e

r

r

y.

su

!T

s

h

!la

e

r

!p

g

ar

er

t

,!

n

h

e

ig

rs

h

h

e

i

r!

p!

to

new

wo

w

rk

or

w

kf

i

o

th

r

in!

odel!and!test!beds!to!show!how!

tools!and!buil

c

d

e

i

e

s

n

ki

te

ll

r

ng!w

s

pris

o

.!S

rk

t

f

im

e!multi=plant,!mul

or

u

c

l

e

a

!s

ti

k

n

i

g

ll

!m

s!fo

o

r

r

!c

e!p

om

ri

t

v

i

a

=co

te

mpany,!multi=supply!chain!connectedness!and!to!focus!on!

investment!is!key!to!breaking!through!the!e

p

x

e

is

tit

!i

i

n

ve

v

!a

es

d

t

v

m

a

e

n

n

ta

t!i

g

n

e

!b

s!b

u

y

il

!l

d

o

in

w

g

e

!a

ri

n

n

d

g

!a

!t

c

h

c

e

e

!b

le

u

r

r

a

d

t

e

in

n

g

!o

!t

n

h

!i

e

n

!a

f

p

ra

p

s

li

t

c

r

a

u

t

c

i

t

o

u

n

r

!o

e!

f!

ting!market!barriers.!

http://smart=process=manufacturing.ucla.edu/