The Clerk of Court is directed to amend the official caption in this case to conform to the * lis ti ng o f the p ar ti es abo ve . 1 07-5707-pr Unit ed S tat es v. K ey UN ITED STA TES CO URT OF AP P EALS F OR TH E S ECO N D CI RCU IT 

## AM ENDED SUMMARY ORDER Rul in gs by s um mar

y or der do no t h ave p r eced ent

ial ef fe ct . Cit ati onto a s um mar y or der filed on or after J anuary 1, 2007, is permitted and is governed by Fede ral Rule of Appella te Procedure 32. 1 an d thi s cou r t’ s Lo cal Rule 3 2.1 .1. Whencit in g a s um mar

y or der ina do cum ent

filedwith thi s court, a party must cite either the Federal A ppendix or an el ectronic data base (with the notation “summary order”). A party citing a summary order must serve a copy of it on any

party not r epr es ent ed b y co un s el. At a stated term of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, he ld at the Daniel Pa trick Moynihan United Sta tes Courthous e, 500 Pea rl Street, in the City of New Y ork, on the 30 day of April, two thousand and te n.

th PR E SE NT: R O GE R J. M I NER , J OS É A. C AB R ANES , RI C HA R D C. W ES L EY , Circuit Jud ges .

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x U NI T ED S TATES O F A M ERI CA ,

Appellee ,
v. No. 07-5707-pr R O GE R K

EY , De

fe ndant -A ppella nt . *

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x F OR AP P ELLAN T: Roge r Key , pro se , Ray B r oo k, N ew Yo r k.2

F OR AP P ELLEE : Ni cho las J . L ewinandMich ael A . L evy; As s is tan t U ni te d S tat es At to r ney s , an d L ev L . D as s in , Act in g Unit ed S tat es At to r ney , Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern Dis trict of New Yor k, N ew Yo r k, N ew Yo r k. Appea l from a December 4, 2007 order of the United Sta tes Dis trict Court for the Southern Di s tr ict of New Yor k ( Denis e Cot e, Judge

). UPON CONSIDERAT ION WHEREOF, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJ UDGED, AN D D ECREED tha t th is a pp ea l i s DISMI SSED as moot. Def end ant -a pp ell ant

Roge r Key , pro se , appea ls fr om an order of the Dis trict Court denying his request

to modify his s entence to reflect the time he spent in federal custody from (a) the date he was tr ans fe r r ed f

r om s tat e t o f

ede r al cu s to dy t o (

b) th e dat e he was s ent enc ed o n f ede r al ch arges . We as s um e the p ar ti es ’ f

amilia r it y with the u nd erlyi ng f

act s andpr oce du r al his to ry of this cas e. While this appeal w as pending, de fendant wa s r elea sed fr om pris on. He is currently serving a s tatut or y mi ni mu m f

ive -y ear te r m o f s up er

vis ed r elea s e. See

21 U .S. C. § 8 41(

b) (1 )( A)

. An ap pellat e ch all eng e t o a cr im in al s ent enc e is “r end er ed m oo t” whe n the d ef end ant has been “rele ase[d] from pr

ison” and when the re is either “no poss ibility” or only a “‘remote and speculative ’” possibility that “the distr ict court could [or would] impose a reduced te rm of s up er vis ed r elea s e wer e we t o r ema ndfo r r es ent enc in g.” Uni

te d St ate s v . Wil liams, 47 5 F .3d468 , 47 9 (2 d Ci r . 20 07) (quo ti ng United Sta tes v. B lackbu rn , 46 1 F .3d259 , 26 2 ( 2dCir . 20 06) ). Her e, as we di s cus s ina s epar ate ly f

ile d o pi ni onadd r es s in g a dif fe r ent as pec t o f thi s cas e, see United States v. Key , No. 08-3218-cr (2d Cir. Apr . 28 , 20 10) , ev en i f i t w ouldbe p os s ib le, onr ema nd , f or th e Di s tr ict Court to terminate defendant’s supervis ed relea se under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(e)(1), that possibility is too “remote and specula tive” to “satisf[y] the case-or-contr oversy requirement of Art icle III, Section 2 of th e Con s ti tu ti on .” Will

iams , 47 5 F .3dat 4 78- 79 (qu ot ati onmar ks omit te d) ; accord Blackburn , 46 1 F. 3dat 2 62. T hi s app eal i s th er ef or e mo ot . CONCLUSI ON For t he fore go in g re a son s, t hi s a pp ea l i s DIS MISS ED as moot.

FOR THE C OU R

T, Ca therine O’Haga n Wolfe, C lerk of Court