EXHIBIT A 

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 9879-2 Filed 01/26/18 Page 1 of 3


,17+(&,5&8,7&28572)7+(6(9(17((17+-8',&,$/

&,5&8,7,1$1')25%52:$5'&2817<)/25,'$

&$6(12&$&(',9

&/$5($867,1

3ODLQWLII

YV

&5%$5',1&DIRUHLJQ

FRUSRUDWLRQDQG%$5'3(5,3+(5$/

9$6&8/$5,1&DQ$UL]RQD

FRUSRUDWLRQ0$77+(:52%%,16

0'DQG&/(9(/$1'&/,1,&

)/25,'$



'HIHQGDQWV

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

9,'(27$3('(326,7,212)

3$75,&.0&'21$/'

)ULGD\-XO\

DPSP

3DQ]D0DXUHU	0D\QDUG (DVW&RPPHUFLDO%RXOHYDUG

)RUW/DXGHUGDOH)ORULGD

6WHQRJUDSKLFDOO\5HSRUWHG%\

.LPEHUO\)RQWDOYR535&/5

5HDOWLPH6\VWHPV$GPLQLVWUDWRU





















































$33($5$1&(6

2QEHKDOIRI3ODLQWLII

*$//$*+(5	.(11('<3$ (&DPHOEDFN5RDG6XLWH

3KRHQL[$=

%<0$5.62
&21125(64

PDUNRFRQQRU#JNQHWFRP

+($9,6,'(5(('=$,&

%URDGZD\6XLWH

/DJXQD%HDFK&$

%<-8/,$5(('=$,&(64

MXOLD#KU]ODZFRP



2QEHKDOIRI'HIHQGDQWV

1(/62108//,165,/(<	6&$5%2528*+//3 WK6WUHHW1:

$WODQWD*$

%<0$77+(:%52:1(64

PDWWKHZEURZQ#QHOVRQPXOOLQVFRP



$/6235(6(176DQGUD6ROLV9LGHRJUDSKHU





















































,1'(;

([DPLQDWLRQ3DJH

'LUHFW  %\0U2
&RQQRU 'LUHFW  %\0V=DLF &URVV  %\0U%URZQ 5HGLUHFW  %\0V=DLF

&HUWLILFDWHRI2DWK 

&HUWLILFDWHRI5HSRUWHU 

5HDGDQG6LJQ/HWWHUWR:LWQHVV 

(UUDWD6KHHWIRUZDUGHGXSRQH[HFXWLRQ 

3/$,17,))(;+,%,76

1R3DJH

O  (PDLOGDWHG

  (PDLOGDWHG

  'RFXPHQWWLWOHG*XLGLQJ3ULQFLSOHV

  &RPSRVLWHGRFXPHQWSDJHV

  (PDLOGDWHG

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &203/$,175(&25''(7$,/5(3257

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW





















































  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  &RPSODLQW5HFRUG'HWDLO5HSRUW

  :DUQLQJ/HWWHUGDWHG

  (PDLOGDWHG



















































Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 9879-2 Filed 01/26/18 Page 2 of 3


4 2ND\7KDQN\RX$OOULJKW$QGLQWKLV

HPDLOH[FKDQJH'U&LDYDUHOODVWULNHWKDW

(DUOLHUZKHQ\RXZHUHZLWKP\FROOHDJXH

0U2
&RQQRU\RXPHQWLRQHGWKDW\RXZHUHPDUNHWLQJ

WKH61)DQGWKH*ILOWHUVDWWKHVDPHWLPH"

$ 7KDW
VFRUUHFW

4 &RUUHFW"$QGLI\RXORRNWRZDUGVWKH

ERWWRPRIWKLVHPDLOWKHUH
VDVHQWHQFHWKDW

VWDUWV7KH*LVDSHUPDQHQWILOWHU

'R\RXVHHWKDW"

$ ,GRVHHWKDW

4 2ND\$QGLWVD\V7KH*LVDSHUPDQHQW

ILOWHU:HDOVRKDYHRQHWKH61)WKDWKDV

YLUWXDOO\QRFRPSODLQWVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKLW:K\

VKRXOGQ
WGRFWRUVEHXVLQJWKDWRQHUDWKHUWKDQWKH

*"&DQ\RXVHQG&DQ\RXDOVRVHQGPHWKH

WRWDOFRPSODLQWVUDWHDQG0'5FRPSODLQWUDWHIRU

61)"

+DYH\RXHYHUVHHQWKDWHPDLOH[FKDQJH

EHIRUH"

$ 2WKHUWKDQWKHODVWGHSRVLWLRQ,EHOLHYH

LWZDVVKRZQDVHYLGHQFHEXW,KDGQ
WVHHQLWSULRU

WRWKDW

4 2ND\+DYH\RXDVNHGDQ\TXHVWLRQ

DERXWTXHVWLRQVDERXWWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQLQWKLV

 13:00:40



 13:00:45





 13:00:55

 13:00:55





 13:01:02

 13:01:03

 13:01:04













 13:01:21



 13:01:23





 13:01:28





HPDLOVLQFH\RXVDZLWLQ\RXUODVWGHSRVLWLRQ"

$ 1R

4 <RXKDYHQ
WEHHQFXULRXVDVWRZK\WKH

PHGLFDOGLUHFWRUZRXOGPDNHDVWDWHPHQWDERXWWKDW"

$ ,IHHOFRPIRUWDEOHWKDWWKDWDORWRI

WKLVLQIRUPDWLRQIURPXQGHUVWDQGLQJEDVLFDOO\DQG

JRLQJWKURXJKWKHODVWGHSRVLWLRQWKDWWKHUDWHV

WKDW0U&LDYDUHOODZDVUHIHUULQJWRZHUHFRPLQJ

IURPWKH0$:GDWDEDVH

4 2ND\7KDW
VORYHO\EXWLW
VQRW

UHVSRQVLYHWRP\TXHVWLRQ

+DYH\RXDVNHGVLQFH\RXUODVW

GHSRVLWLRQDERXWDQ\RIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQFRQWDLQHG

LQWKLVHPDLOVSHFLILFDOO\WKHVHQWHQFH,MXVW

UHDG"

$ 1R

4 $QGDJDLQ\RXZHUHVHOOLQJWKH61)DQG

WKH*DWWKHVDPHWLPHFRUUHFW"

$ &RUUHFW

4 $QGGR\RXNQRZLISURGXFWVVXFKDVWKH*

DQGWKH61)VWULNHWKDW

'R\RXNQRZLI*DQG61)SURGXFWVWKDW

\RXVROGLQ\RXUWHUULWRU\DUHVWLOOLPSODQWHGLQ

SDWLHQWVWRWKLVGD\"

$ ,GRQRWNQRZ 13:02:32



 13:01:36

 13:01:37



 13:01:41









 13:02:00



 13:02:03







 13:02:09

 13:02:11



 13:02:16

 13:02:17



 13:02:25









4 2ND\

$ ,ZRXOG6LPRQ1LWLQROILOWHU,ZRXOG

LPDJLQHWKDWWKH\ZHUHXVHGDVSHUPDQHQWGHYLFHV

WKDWWKHUHFRXOGEHVRPHRXWWKHUHLPSODQWHG

4 2ND\%XWWKH*ZDVDOVRDSHUPDQHQW

GHYLFHFRUUHFW"

$ <HV

4 2ND\$QGLWODWHUUHFHLYHGWKHRSWLRQWR

UHWULHYHLWFRUUHFW"

$ &RUUHFW

4 $QGWKHVDPHZLWKWKH*;

$ &RUUHFW

4 FRUUHFW"

06=$,& ,WKLQN,
PGRQH*RDKHDG

7KDQN\RX

7+(:,71(66 6XUH

&5266(;$0,1$7,21

%<05%52:1

4 3DWULFN,KDYHDIHZTXHVWLRQVIRU\RX

$ 6XUH

4 ,ZRXOGOLNHWRJHWDOLWWOHELWRI

EDFNJURXQGLQIRUPDWLRQIURP\RX)LUVWZKHUHGR

\RXOLYH"

$ ,OLYHKHUHLQ)RUW/DXGHUGDOHDFWXDOO\

QRWIDUIURPKHUH

 13:02:33

 13:02:33





 13:02:43



 13:02:46

 13:02:46



 13:02:49

 13:02:50

 13:02:52

 13:02:52

 13:02:56

 13:03:02

 13:03:07

 13:03:09

 13:03:10

 13:03:16

 13:03:18

 13:03:20





 13:03:25





4 +RZORQJKDYH\RXOLYHGLQ)RUW

/DXGHUGDOH"

$ :HPRYHGKHUHLQ
,ZDVERUQLQ

/RQGRQ0\IDWKHUZDVILQLVKLQJXSDVXUJLFDO

IHOORZVKLSLQ/RQGRQDQGZHPRYHGKHUHZKHQ,ZDVD

\HDUROGLQ


4 $UH\RXPDUULHG"

$ <HV,DPPDUULHG-XVWFHOHEUDWHGRXU

WHQ\HDUDQQLYHUVDU\$QGZHKDYHWZRFKLOGUHQ

$QGUHZZKRLVHLJKWDQG2OLYLDZKRLVVL[$QGWKH\

JRWR&KULVW&KXUFK6FKRROULJKWKHUHQH[WWRXVDQG

QRZLW
V&KULVW&KXUFK&DPSEHFDXVHZH
UHLQWKH

VXPPHUEXWZH
UHORFDO

4 $UH\RXDPHPEHURI&KULVW&KXUFK"

$ 1R$VDPDWWHURIIDFW,
PDPHPEHURI

6W-RKQ
V,
P5RPDQ&DWKROLFVRZHJRWR

6W-RKQ
VFKXUFK7KDW
VZKHUHP\SDUHQWVJRDQG

P\LQODZVJR:HKDSSHQWROLYHRQWKHVDPHVWUHHW

KHUH

-XVWDIHZPRQWKVDJRZHFHOHEUDWHGP\

VRQ
VILUVW+RO\&RPPXQLRQ:H
UHDQDFWLYHSDUWRI

LW

4 &DQ\RXWHOOXVDERXW\RXUHGXFDWLRQDO

EDFNJURXQG"

$ 6XUH,VWDUWHGFROOHJHXSLQ0DU\ODQG 13:04:22

 13:03:28



 13:03:31







 13:03:41

 13:03:42











 13:04:00

 13:04:01









 13:04:14





 13:04:20





$ <HV,DPPDUULHG-XVWFHOHEUDWHGRXU

WHQ\HDUDQQLYHUVDU\$QGZHKDYHWZRFKLOGUHQ

00$QGUHZZKRLVHLJKWDQG2OLYLDZKRLVVL[$QGWKH\

JRWR&KULVW&KXUFK6FKRROULJKWKHUHQH[WWRXVDQG

03QRZLW
V&KULVW&KXUFK&DPSEHFDXVHZH
UHLQWKH

VXPPHUEXWZH
UHORFDO

4 $UH\RXDPHPEHURI&KULVW&KXUFK"

$ 1R$VDPDWWHURIIDFW,
PDPHPEHURI

096W-RKQ
V,
P5RPDQ&DWKROLFVRZHJRWR

116W-RKQ
VFKXUFK7KDW
VZKHUHP\SDUHQWVJRDQG

P\LQODZVJR:HKDSSHQWROLYHRQWKHVDPHVWUHHW

16KHUH

-XVWDIHZPRQWKVDJRZHFHOHEUDWHGP\

VRQ
VILUVW+RO\&RPPXQLRQ:H
UHDQDFWLYHSDUWRI

25LW

4 &DQ\RXWHOOXVDERXW\RXUHGXFDWLRQDO

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 9879-2 Filed 01/26/18 Page 3 of 3