EXHIBIT A 

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 914-1 Filed 03/01/16 Page 1 of 5
Status of Mature Cases 

Plaintiff Original 

Jurisdiction 

Discovery that Remains to be Completed 1 Motion Pending 

Transfer that Ma

1. Cason, 

Pamela 

GA – N.D. Ga. 1:12-cv-1288 

Discovery regarding new medical claims and damages alleged 

by plaintiff that occurred in Spring of 2015, including: 

• Updated deposition of Plaintiff. 

• Updated medical records. • Depositions of newly identified treaters. • Supplemental medical expert reports and medical 

expert depositions, as necessary. 

• None. MS

motions pruled upon Court. 

2. Coker, 

Jennifer 

GA – N.D. Ga. 1:13-cv-515

Fact discovery not completed; deadline at time of MDL transfer was August 17, 2015. Expert discovery had been completed but Plaintiffs supplemented expert reports. Discovery remaining:

• Re-deposition of Dr. Patterson and deposition of Dr. Sing 

on their supplemental reports submitted on August 10 and 11, 2015, respectively

• Submitting supplemental reports from both of Bard's case 

specific medical experts, Dr. Sobiesczyk and Dr. Fischman, responding to Plaintiffs’ Experts Supplemental Reports. 

• Bard's deposition of Plaintiffs Expert McMeeking. 

• Deadline for fil

not passed. Bafiling Summary Daubert motion

1 In all cases, Plaintiffs records need to be updated. In some cases, updated records may trigger the need for an additional treater deposition 

deposition. 

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 914-1 Filed 03/01/16 Page 2 of 5
2 

Plaintiff Original 

Jurisdiction 

Discovery that Remains to be Completed 1 Motion Pending 

Transfer that Ma

3. Ebert, 

Melissa 

PA – E.D. Pa. 5:12-cv-1253

Fact and expert discovery complete. • Bard's Motion f

Judgment 

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Ro& Matthew Beg

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Mi

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Wi

4. Fox, 

Susan 

TX– N.D. Tex. 3:14-cv-133 

Fact discovery completed. Expert discovery was due June 23, 2015, and the parties had agreed to request an extension of time for expert reports through July 20, 2015. Discovery remaining: 

• Exchange expert reports• Expert depositions

• Deadline for fil

not passed. Bafiling Summary Daubert motion

5. Henley, 

Angela 

WI – E.D. Wis. 2:14-cv-59

Fact and expert discovery completed, except for substitution of a new case specific medical expert by Bard. Bard's case specific medical expert died after submitting his report in this case. Discovery remaining : 

• Bard to provide case specific medical expert report

• Expert depositions

• Deadline for fil

not passed. Bafiling Summary Daubert motion

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 914-1 Filed 03/01/16 Page 3 of 5
3 

Plaintiff Original 

Jurisdiction 

Discovery that Remains to be Completed 1 Motion Pending 

Transfer that Ma

6. Keen, 

Harry 

PA – E.D. Pa. 5:13-cv-5361 

Fact and expert discovery complete. • Bard's Motion f

Judgment 

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Su

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Wi

7. Ocasio, 

Denise 

FL – M.D. Fla. 8:13-cv-1962 

Fact and expert discovery completed, except Bard to identify rebuttal material s engineering expert and provide expert 

report. 

• Summary Judg

Motions filed a

8. Rivera, 

Vicki 

MI—E.D. Mich Fact and expert discovery completed, except: 

• Deposition of additional treaters on medical issues 

identified at Ms. Rivera's deposition taken shortly before MDL transfer.

• Deadline for fil

not passed. Bafiling Summary Daubert motion

9. Smith, 

Erin 

TX – E.D. Tex. 1:13-cv-633 

Fact and Expert discovery not completed at time of transfer to MDL. Discovery remaining: 

• Deposition of sales rep • Expert depositions 

• Summary Judg

pending 

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Su(briefing on mocomplete at tim

• Bard's Motion t

Opinions of Wi

(briefing on moti

complete at tim

• Plaintiffs Motio

Opinions of FreM.D. (briefing 

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 914-1 Filed 03/01/16 Page 4 of 5
4 

Plaintiff Original 

Jurisdiction 

Discovery that Remains to be Completed 1 Motion Pending 

Transfer that Ma

complete at tim

10. Tillman FL – M.D. Fla. 

3:13-cv-222

Fact and expert discovery completed, except for substitution of a new case specific medical expert by Bard. Bard's case specific medical expert died after submitting his report in this case. Discovery remaining: 

• Bard to identify new medical expert and provide 

report

• Expert depositions including deposition of Dr. Hull 

regarding supplemental report submitted in the case

• Bard's Motion t

Determination of Punitive Dam

• Motions in Lim• Bard's Emergen

Leave to File uPlaintiff's Exhib

• Bard's Motion f

under Seal PursApril 15, 2015 

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 914-1 Filed 03/01/16 Page 5 of 5