Exhibit B

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 1 of 9
/LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 2E@?HBFH 9?E; -;L;

0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI ,;I?> FE 0BCJ?H 8MG?

HcTeT] ;' 9Tb^% C9*?QaPWX\ 6' ?SPZ^YX% C9% CF>* LX[[XP\ I' Ad^% C9*

*9XeXbX^] ^U KPbRd[Pa P]S ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh% HcP]U^aS J]XeTabXch

CTSXRP[ 8T]cTa% HcP]U^aS% 8P[XU^a]XP

HT\X] ?]cTaeT]c GPSX^[ +)*/4,,32,(*))

+>>H?II @FH =FHH?IGFE>?E=? HcTeT] ;' 9Tb^% C9% 9XeXbX^] ^U KPbRd[Pa

P]S ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh% HcP]U^aS J]XeTabXch CTSXRP[ 8T]cTa% ,))

FPbcTda 9aXeT% >&,/.*% HcP]U^aS% 86 2-,).

"T&\PX[3 bSTb^5bcP]U^aS'TSd#'

#%$ &(-+)1,2+! J_^] R^\_[TcX^] ^U cWXb PacXR[T$ cWT aTPSTa

bW^d[S QT PQ[T c^ SXbcX]VdXbW cWT ePaX^db aTcaXTePQ[T P]S

_Ta\P]T]c >K7 ![cTa STbXV]b$ P]S Tg_[PX] cWT \^bc R^\\^]

R^\_[XRPcX^]b Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT ePaX^db STbXV]b&

"))0+*,1'1,/.! IWXb PRcXeXch WPb QTT] _[P]]TS P]S

X\_[T\T]cTS X] PRR^aSP]RT fXcW cWT 9bbT]cXP[ 5aTPb P]S

E^[XRXTb ^U cWT 5RRaTSXcPcX^] 7^d]RX[ U^a 7^]cX]dX]V BTSXRP[

9SdRPcX^] "577B9# cWa^dVW cWT Y^X]c _a^eXSTabWX_ ^U

IdUcb J]XeTabXch HRW^^[ ^U BTSXRX]T "IJHB# P]S IWXT\T

BTSXRP[ EdQ[XbWTab$ CTf N^aZ& IJHB Xb PRRaTSXcTS Qh cWT

577B9 c^ _a^eXST R^]cX]dX]V \TSXRP[ TSdRPcX^] U^a

_WhbXRXP]b&

#0+*,1! IdUcb J]XeTabXch HRW^^[ ^U BTSXRX]T STbXV]PcTb cWXb

Y^da]P[%QPbTS 7B9 PRcXeXch U^a P \PgX\d\ ^U ! "$" %&"

#'.)*,-/ ! #-)(+.!& EWhbXRXP]b bW^d[S R[PX\ ^][h cWT RaTSXc

R^\\T]bdaPcT fXcW cWT TgcT]c ^U cWTXa _PacXRX_PcX^] X] cWT

PRcXeXch&

IWT dbT ^U X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ">K7# ![cTab WPb SaP\PcXRP[[h

X]RaTPbTS ^eTa cWT _Pbc cWaTT STRPSTb X] cWT J]XcTS HcPcTb$ P]S

cWT ]d\QTa ^U ![cTa X]bTacX^]b S^dQ[TS QTcfTT] )110 P]S

*((0&*%+ 6h *()*$ P] TbcX\PcTS *-1$((( >K7 ![cTab fTaT _[PRTS

X] cWT J]XcTS HcPcTb P[^]T$,R^X]RXSX]V fXcW P Va^fX]V ]d\QTa ^U

;^^S P]S 8adV 5S\X]XbcaPcX^] ";85#%P__a^eTS STeXRTb& 7^]bT%

`dT]c[h$ cWT X]RaTPbX]V ePaXTch ^U ![cTab P[^]V fXcW aXbX]V ^eTaP[[

dbT WPb aTbd[cTS X] X]RaTPbTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b Ua^\ X]SfT[[X]V >K7

![cTab3 cWXb _a^\_cTS cWT ;85 c^ XbbdT P bPUTch P[Tac daVX]V P[[

_WhbXRXP]b RPaX]V U^a _PcXT]cb fXcW X]SfT[[X]V ![cTab c^ R^]bXSTa

aT\^eX]V cWT ![cTa Pb b^^] Pb _a^cTRcX^] Ua^\ _d[\^]Pah

T\Q^[Xb\ "E9# Xb ]^ [^]VTa ]TTSTS&- 8Tb_XcT cWXb aTR^\\T]SP%

cX^]$ \P]h STeXRTb PaT ]^c PST`dPcT[h U^[[^fTS U^a aT\^eP[$ P]S

cWT [PaVT ]d\QTa ^U ![cTa ch_Tb ]^f T]R^d]cTaTS ^] a^dcX]T

X\PVX]V WPb \PST _a^_Ta STeXRT XST]cX!RPcX^] SXU!Rd[c& IWT

_da_^bT ^U cWXb bcdSh fPb c^ TeP[dPcT cWT ePaX^db ;85%P__a^eTS

>K7 ![cTa STbXV]b c^ STcTa\X]T STeXRT%b_TRX!R aXbZb$ Pb P fPh ^U

3@POHJ?K

! ?K8 ![cTab

! ]^]cWa^\Q^cXR

R^\_[XRPcX^]b

! X]cTaeT]cX^]P[

aPSX^[^Vh

,=KLJ<>L CP]h X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP "?K8# ![cTa ch_Tb% P[^]V fXcW cWTXa b_TRX!R aXbZb P]S R^\_[XRP&

cX^]b% PaT ]^c aTR^V]XiTS' IWT _da_^bT ^U cWXb bcdSh fPb c^ TeP[dPcT cWT ePaX^db <96&

P__a^eTS ?K8 ![cTa ch_Tb c^ STcTa\X]T STeXRT&b_TRX!R aXbZb% Pb P fPh c^ WT[_ XST]cXUh

_PcXT]cb fW^ \Ph QT]T!c Ua^\ ^]V^X]V U^[[^f&d_ eTabdb _a^\_c ![cTa aTcaXTeP[' 6]

TeXST]RT&QPbTS T[TRca^]XR bTPaRW "<96 FaT\PaZTc D^cX!RPcX^]% C;9B?D;% <96 C6J9;#

fPb _TaU^a\TS c^ XST]cXUh P[[ ?K8 ![cTa ch_Tb P]S STeXRT&b_TRX!R R^\_[XRPcX^]b Ua^\

*21) c^ +)*-' IfT]ch&cWaTT ?K8 ![cTa ch_Tb "*- aTcaXTePQ[T% 2 _Ta\P]T]c# fTaT

XST]cX!TS' IWT STeXRTb fTaT RPcTV^aXiTS Pb U^[[^fb3 R^]XRP[ "# ! *-#% R^]XRP[ fXcW

d\QaT[[P "# ! *#% R^]XRP[ fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[ T[T\T]c "# ! +#% QXR^]XRP[ fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[

T[T\T]c "# ! +#% WT[XRP[ "# ! *#% b_XaP[ "# ! *#% P]S R^\_[Tg "# ! *#' FdaT[h R^]XRP[

![cTab fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS aXbZb ^U _T]TcaPcX^] "2)(*))!#' <X[cTab

fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[ ^a d\QaT[[P T[T\T]cb fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS aXbZ ^U

?K8 cWa^\Q^bXb ",)(.)!#' 8^]XRP[ 7PaS ![cTab fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS

aXbZb ^U UaPRcdaT "-)!#' IWT ePaX^db <96&P__a^eTS ?K8 ![cTa ch_Tb fTaT TeP[dPcTS U^a

STeXRT&b_TRX!R R^\_[XRPcX^]b QPbTS ^] QTbc RdaaT]c TeXST]RT' IWXb X]U^a\PcX^] RP] QT

dbTS c^ VdXST P]S ^_cX\XiT R[X]XRP[ \P]PVT\T]c X] _PcXT]cb fXcW X]SfT[[X]V ?K8 ![cTab'

2IIK? 8A?D? ?]UTaX^a KT]P 8PeP <X[cTab4

=dTbc ;SXc^ab% AdbW G' 9TbPX% C9% P]S

G^QTac @' BTfP]S^fbZX% C9

8^_haXVWc j +)*/ Qh IWXT\T CTSXRP[

FdQ[XbWTab% ?]R'% ,,, HTeT]cW 6eT]dT%

DTf N^aZ% DN *)))*% JH6'

IT[3 $*"+*+# .1-&-//+'

.42 Wcc_3((Sg'S^X'^aV(

*)'*)..(b&)),/&*.1,+)1'

2773 )0,2&2.+2'

*$

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 2 of 9
WT[_X]V c^ XST]cXUh _PcXT]cb fW^ \Ph QT]T!c Ua^\ ^]V^X]V

U^[[^f%d_ ^a _a^\_c ![cTa aTcaXTeP[&

4<L@JD<EK <G? 4@LCH?K

2?@GLD!><LDHG HA 2;. 1DEL@J 9PI@K

IWT ;85 EaT\PaZTc C^cX!RPcX^] 8PcPQPbT. fPb bTPaRWTS

T[TRca^]XRP[[h c^ XST]cXUh P[[ >K7 ![cTab aTRTXeX]V -)("Z# R[TPa%

P]RT "_a^SdRc R^ST 8I@%![cTa$ X]caPePbRd[Pa$ RPaSX^ePbRd[Pa#

QTcfTT] )10( P]S *(),&

.E<KKD!><LDHG HA 1DEL@J .HFIED><LDHGK

>K7 ![cTa R^\_[XRPcX^]b fTaT R[PbbX!TS PRR^aSX]V c^ cWT H^RXTch

^U >]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh "H>G# VdXST[X]Tb/Pb U^[[^fb2

#3')563*! 6aTPZPVT ^a bT_PaPcX^] ^U P]h ![cTa R^\_^]T]c

SdT c^ bcadRcdaP[ UPX[daT&/IWT UaPRcdaTS R^\_^]T]cb RP]

aT\PX] X] bXcd ^a d]STaV^ SXbcP[ T\Q^[XiPcX^] "!1DB$ %#&

$04*35-10'. 231(.*/4! BP[Ud]RcX^]b X] ![cTa ST_[^h\T]c

X]R[dSX]V cX[cX]V ^U cWT ![cTa \^aT cWP] )- STVaTTb Ua^\ cWT

>K7 PgXb$ X]R^\_[TcT ^_T]X]V$ P]S _a^[P_bT ^U ![cTa R^\_^%

]T]cb/"!1DB$ &#&

$&" 2*3+13'5-10! KXbdP[XiPcX^] ^U ^]T ^a \^aT ![cTa R^\%

_^]T]cb TgcT]SX]V VaTPcTa cWP] + \\ QTh^]S cWT RPeP[ fP[[

^a X]c^ P] PSYPRT]c bcadRcdaT/bdRW Pb cWT Sd^ST]d\$ P^acP$

_b^Pb \dbR[T$ ZXS]Th$ ^a eTacTQaP[ Q^Sh& <aPSX]V bRWT\Tb

ST!]X]V cWT STVaTT ^U _TaU^aPcX^] WPeT QTT] STbRaXQTS X] cWT

[XcTaPcdaT0"!1DB$ '#&

%-,3'5-10! B^eT\T]c ^U P] >K7 ![cTa VaTPcTa cWP] * R\

P[^]V cWT >K7 QTh^]S cWT X]XcXP[ _[PRT\T]c _^bXcX^]&/;X[cTa

\XVaPcX^] \Ph aTbd[c X] ![cTa T\Q^[XiPcX^] X]c^ cWT aXVWc

PcaXd\$ aXVWc eT]caXR[T$ ^a _d[\^]Pah PacTaXTb "!1DB$ (#&

1DB$ % <[d^a^bR^_XR X\PVT bW^fX]V P =+ ![cTa fXcW \d[cX_[T UaPRcdaTS

R^\_^]T]cb'

1DB$ & <[d^a^bR^_XR X\PVTb bW^fX]V P bTeTaT[h cX[cTS P]S cX_ T\&

QTSSTS 8T[TRc ![cTa'

1DB$ ' 6gXP[ 8I X\PVT bW^fX]V P *+< HcPX][Tbb HcTT[ =aTT]!T[S ![cTa X]

_[PRT R^\_[XRPcTS Qh R^\_^]T]c _TaU^aPcX^] "Paa^f#'

1DB$ ( <[d^a^bR^_XR X\PVT ST\^]bcaPcX]V P] ?K8 ![cTa cWPc WPb

\XVaPcTS X]c^ cWT aXVWc eT]caXR[T'

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

*% /LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P['

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 3 of 9
$&" 1)).64-10! 5RdcT ^a RWa^]XR cWa^\Q^cXR ^RR[dbX^] ^U cWT

>K7 U^[[^fX]V ![cTa _[PRT\T]c/"!1DB$ )#&

0ND?@G>@#-<K@? 8@<J>C HA 1DEL@J .HFIED><LDHGK

5] T[TRca^]XR B98A>C9 bTPaRW fPb _TaU^a\TS dbX]V cWT

U^[[^fX]V X]STg bTPaRW cTa\b2 ">K7 ![cTa# DG "X]UTaX^a eT]P

RPeP ![cTa# DG "5AC ![cTa# DG "6PaS 9R[X_bT# DG "6PaS <*# DG

"6PaS <*M# DG "6PaS GTR^eTah# DG "6PaS 8T]P[X# DG "6PaS

BTaXSXP]# DG "HX\^] CXcX]^[# DG "KT]P ITRW A<B# DG "KT]P

ITRW AE# DG "<aTT]!T[S ![cTa# DG "6XaS!b CTbc ![cTa# DG

"7T[TRc ![cTa# DG # <m]cWTa Id[X_# DG "D_cTPbT# DG "IaP%

_TPbT# DG "HPUT"^# DG "D_cX^] ![cTa# DG "7adg eT]P RPeP

![cTa&# IWT aTbd[cb fTaT ![cTaTS U^a 9]V[XbW [P]VdPVT$ R[X]XRP[

caXP[ bcdSh ch_T$ Wd\P] b_TRXTb$ P]S SPcT aP]VT Ua^\ )10( c^

*(), "!1DB$ *#& 5[[ _^cT]cXP[[h aT[TeP]c PacXR[Tb fTaT R^[[TRcTS

U^a P]P[hbXb& IWT aTUTaT]RTb fXcWX] cWTbT PacXR[Tb fTaT aT%

eXTfTS c^ ^QcPX] PSSXcX^]P[ aT[TeP]c PacXR[Tb U^a P]P[hbXb& 5

SPcP TgcaPRcX^] U^a\ fPb dbTS c^ aTR^aS cWT U^[[^fX]V X]U^a%

\PcX^]2 ![cTa ch_T$ aTcaXTeP[ aPcT$ R^\_[XRPcX^]b$ P]S UaT`dT]%

Rh ^U R^\_[XRPcX^]b _Ta ![cTa ch_T& If^ aTeXTfTab eTaX!TS cWT

PRRdaPRh ^U P[[ SPcP _aX^a c^ P]P[hbXb& IWT ;85 BP]dUPRcdaTa

P]S JbTa ;PRX[Xch 8TeXRT 9g_TaXT]RT "B5J89# SPcPQPbT1 fPb

`dTaXTS T[TRca^]XRP[[h ")11*$*(),# c^ XST]cXUh PSSXcX^]P[

PSeTabT TeT]cb Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW >K7 ![cTa dbT "_a^SdRc R[Pbb

%![cTa$ X]caPePbRd[Pa$ RPaSX^ePbRd[Pa#&

7@KMELK

IfT]ch%U^da >K7 ![cTab fTaT XST]cX!TS& ;a^\ cWXb Va^d_$ cWT

9SfPaSb B^QX]%JSSX] STeXRT fPb TgR[dSTS Pb Xc fPb aT%

\^eTS Ua^\ cWT \PaZTc X] )10.&2;a^\ cWT aT\PX]X]V Va^d_$

]X]T ![cTab R[TPaTS U^a _Ta\P]T]c dbT$ P]S ), ![cTab R[TPaTS

U^a aTcaXTePQ[T ^a _Ta\P]T]c dbT$ fTaT XST]cX!TS "!9<=E@ %#&

IWT STeXRT SXbcaXQdcX^] QPbTS ^] VT^\Tcah fPb Pb U^[[^fb2

R^]XRP[ "0 ! )-#$ R^]XRP[ fXcW d\QaT[[P "0 ! )#$ R^]XRP[ fXcW

Rh[X]SaXRP[ T[T\T]c "0 ! *#$ QXR^]XRP[ fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[

1DB$ ) 8^a^]P[ 8I X\PVT bW^fX]V P 7PaS ![cTa "^_T] Paa^f# X] _[PRT

fXcW PRdcT cWa^\Q^cXR ^RR[dbX^] ^U cWT ?K8 "b^[XS Paa^f#'

1DB$ * BXcTaPcdaT bRaTT]X]V "^fRWPac'

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

/LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P[' *&

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 4 of 9
T[T\T]c "0 ! *#$ WT[XRP[ "0 ! )#$ b_XaP[ fXcW d\QaT[[P "0 ! )#$

P]S R^\_[Tg "0 ! )# "!1DB$ +#&

GT_^acTS STeXRT%b_TRX!R R^\_[XRPcX^]b fTaT XST]cX!TS

P\^]V P[[ ![cTa ch_Tb$ P]S cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b

U^a TPRW STeXRT PaT bd\\PaXiTS X] !9<=E@ && IWT aXbZ ^U

R^\_[XRPcX^]b fPb U^d]S c^ ePah fXST[h ST_T]SX]V ^] cWT

b_TRX!R >K7 ![cTa ch_T&

1J<>LMJ@

9Pa[h R^]XRP[ 6PaS ETaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa "IT\_T$ 5O# ![cTab

fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS aPcTb ^U UaPRcdaT&

IWT UaPRcdaT aPcT U^a cWT ^aXVX]P[ 6PaS GTR^eTah STeXRT fPb -&-

c^ *-! fXcW P] TbcX\PcTS X]RXST]RT ^U +1&-! Pc .-&/

\^]cWb&*)(*- IWT UaPRcdaT aPcT U^a cWT 6PaS <* STeXRTb "<*$

<*M$ 9R[X_bT$ BTaXSXP]# fPb X]XcXP[[h )&* c^ )*!$ Qdc cWT

WXVWTbc aT_^acTS aPcT fPb [PcTa U^d]S c^ QT +0! Pc

.( \^]cWb&**%*,%*.%*/ =XVW UaPRcdaT aPcTb fTaT P[b^ aT_^acTS

U^a cWT HX\^] CXcX]^[ ![cTa "6PaS# ")($).!#*0%*1 P]S cWT

D_cTPbT'IaP_TPbT "7^aSXb$ BXP\X APZTb$ ;A# "d_ c^ -(!#&*2

2GK@JLDHG<E 2KKM@K

;X[cTa cX[cX]V VaTPcTa cWP] )- STVaTTb SdaX]V X]bTacX^] fTaT

aT_^acTS P\^]V cWT U^[[^fX]V R^]XRP[ ![cTab2 6PaS GTR^eTah

"*&+$)-!#$+)%+* 6PaS <*'<*M'9R[X_bT "),$)0!#$*.%++%+, 7^^Z

"6[^^\X]Vc^]$ >C# <m]cWTa Id[X_ "))&-$*,!#$+-(+0 *,; <aTT]%

!T[S "6^bc^] HRXT]cX!R$ BPa[Q^a^dVW$ B5# "/$)*!#$+1%+2 )*;

HcPX][Tbb HcTT[ <aTT]!T[S "6^bc^] HRXT]cX!R# "1&1$--!#$,)%,*

P]S IXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S "6^bc^] HRXT]cX!R# "0&+$,)!#&,)%,+%,,

>] PSSXcX^]$ fXaT _a^[P_bT d_ c^ /(! fPb aT_^acTS U^a cWT 7^^Z

6XaS!b CTbc ![cTa&,-

2GA@JDHJ ;@G< .<N< 6@JAHJ<LDHG

EdaT[h R^]XRP[ ![cTab fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cWT WXVWTbc aT%

_^acTS aPcTb ^U >K7 _TaU^aPcX^] P]S fTaT aT_^acTS Pb U^[[^fb2

6PaS GTR^eTah "*/$)((!#$*+%*- 6PaS <*'<*M'9R[X_bT "*.$

,,!#$*.%+, 6PaS HX\^] CXcX]^[ "*-$1-!#$*0%*1 7^^Z <m]cWTa

Id[X_ "**$/0!#$0%,.(,0 7^^Z 7T[TRc "**$1+!#$0%,.%,1%,2 P]S

IXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S "_aX^a c^ W^^Z \^SX!RPcX^]# ")+$

-(!#&-)%-* >] PSSXcX^]$ >K7 bcadc _TaU^aPcX^] d_ c^ 0-! fPb

aT_^acTS U^a cWT 7^^Z 6XaS!b CTbc ![cTa&,-

4DBJ<LDHG

BXVaPcX^] aPcTbVaTPcTa ^a T`dP[ c^ )(! fTaT aT_^acTS P\^]V cWT

U^[[^fX]V STeXRTb2 6PaS GTR^eTah "($)(!#$*)%*+%+) 6PaS <* ")*$

*-!#$*.%+) IXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S "/&-$)-!#$,,%-+ 7^^Z <m]cWTa

Id[X_ "*&,$)*&-!#$+/%,/%-, P]S KT]P ITRW A<B ".$)0&,!#&,,%--%-.

2GA@JDHJ ;@G< .<N< 5>>EMKDHG

;X[cTab fXcW P Rh[X]SaXRP[ R^\_^]T]c "KT]P ITRW A<B$ IaP_TPbT'

D_cTPbT# ^a d\QaT[[P T[T\T]c "HX\^]%CXcX]^[# fTaT Pbb^RXPcTS

fXcW WXVW aPcTb ^U RPeP[ cWa^\Q^bXb& IWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS aPcT ^U

>K7 ^RR[dbX^] U^a cWT IaP_TPbT'D_cTPbT ![cTab fPb *0&.!&-/ IWT

aPcTb ^U RWa^]XR >K7 ^RR[dbX^] fXcW cWT HX\^] CXcX]^[ ![cTa aP]VT

Ua^\ +&- c^ -(!$*0%-0(-2 P]S U^a cWT KT]PITRW A<B$ cWT >K7

^RR[dbX^] aPcT Xb Pb WXVW Pb .-! Pc 1 hTPab&-.

9<=E@ % ?K8 <X[cTab X] cWT J]XcTS HcPcTb "*21)(+)*-#

5?HD;E?EJ @BCJ?HI 6?JHB?L;<C? @BCJ?HI;

" +-< bcPX][Tbb bcTT[ =aTT]!T[S "7^bc^] HRXT]cX!R% DPcXRZ% C6#Q

" *+< bcPX][Tbb bcTT[ =aTT]!T[S "7^bc^] HRXT]cX!R#

" IXcP]Xd\ =aTT]!T[S "7^bc^] HRXT]cX!R#

" KT]P ITRW B=C "7' 7aPd] CTSXRP[% 7TcW[TWT\% F6#Q

" KT]P ITRW BF "7' 7aPd] CTSXRP[#

" IaP_TPbT "8^aSXb ;]S^ePbRd[Pa% LPaaT]% D@#

" 7XaS&b DTbc "8^^Z% 7[^^\X]Vc^]% ?D#

" HX\^] DXcX]^[ "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa% IT\_T% 6O#

" HPUT<[^ "GPUPT[ CTSXRP[ ITRW]^[^VXTb% 9^eTa% 9;#Q

" 6BD "6BD ?]cTa]PcX^]P[% CXP\X% <B#

" GTR^eTah "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#Q

" =+ "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#Q

" =+M "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#Q

" ;R[X_bT "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#Q

" CTaXSXP] "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#Q

" 9T]P[X "7PaS FTaX_WTaP[ KPbRd[Pa#

" =l]cWTa Id[X_ "8^^Z#

" 8T[TRc "8^^Z#Q

" 8T[TRc F[PcX]d\ "8^^Z#

" E_cTPbT "8^aSXb ;]S^ePbRd[Pa% LPaaT]% D@#

" E_cX^] "6aV^]% F[P]^% IM#Q

" E_cX^] ;[XcT "6aV^]% F[P]^% IM#

" 8adg "K^[RP]^% HP] 9XTV^% 86#

P

6[[ aTcaXTePQ[T ![cTab PaT P[b^ P__a^eTS U^a _Ta\P]T]c dbT'

QD^ [^]VTa \P]dUPRcdaTS Qdc \Ph bcX[[ QT T]R^d]cTaTS Ua^\ _aX^a X\_[P]cPcX^]'

1DB$ + ?K8 ![cTa VT^\TcaXTb3 "+# R^]XRP[% ",# R^]XRP[ fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[

T[T\T]c% "-# QXR^]XRP[ fXcW Rh[X]SaXRP[ T[T\T]c% ".# R^]XRP[ fXcW

d\QaT[[P% "/# WT[XRP[% "0# R^\_[Tg% "1# b_XaP[ fXcW d\QaT[[P'

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

*' /LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P['

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 5 of 9
9<=E@ & >XVWTbc aT_^acTS aPSX^VaP_WXRP[[h XST]cX!PQ[T R^\_[XRPcX^]b U^a TPRW ![cTa ch_T

/@ND>@ !P@<J 1/

, >E@<J@?" 1J<>LMJ@ 2;

. I@JAHJ<LDHG 4DBJ<LDHG 2;

.

H>>EMKDHG

6BD "+))1# 8PbT aT_^acb

")!#

.-(./

,'-!",'-!#

.-

,!"*'-(,!#

.0%.1

8PbT aT_^acb")!#

.-%.1%.2

GTR^eTah "+)),(+)).

P

# ,2'.! Pc /.'0 \^

+.!".'.(+.!#

*)(*-

*))!"+0(*))!#

*+%*-

*)!")(*)!#

*)%*+%+)%+*

8PbT aT_^acb")!#

*-

=+ "+)).(+))1

P

#

=+M "+))1#;R[X_bT "+))1#CTaXSXP] "+)**#

,1! Pc /) \^*+!"*'+(*+!#

**%*,%*.%*/%+,%/)

--!"*1(--!#

*.%+,%/)%/*

+.!"*+(+.!#

*.%+)%+,

+'+!")(+'+!#

++%/)

9T]P[X "+)*,# 8PbT aT_^acb

/+

+'.!"+'.!#

/,

BX\XcTS SPcP BX\XcTS SPcP

HX\^] DXcX]^[ "*22)# */!

"*)(*/!#

*0%*1

2.!"+.(2.!#

*0%*1

.!")(.!#

*1%-0

.)!",'.(.)!#

*0%-0(-2

B=

C(KT]P ITRW B=

C "*212# 8PbT aT_^acb

/-

8PbT aT_^acb ")!#

--%/.

*1'-!"/(*1'-!#

,,%--%-.%//

/.! Pc 2 h ",'0!(h#

-.

KT]P ITRW BF "+))*# BX\XcTS SPcP 8PbT aT_^acb ")!#

/0

8PbT aT_^acb ")!#

/0

BX\XcTS SPcP

+-< HH =aTT]!T[S "*20,# 8PbT aT_^acb

/1

*.!"+(*.!#

/2%0)

+!"+!#

/2

.!"+(.!#

+1%+2%0*%0+

*+< HH =aTT]!T[S "*22.# )',!

")',!#

0,

*!"*!#

0,

+'/!"+'/!#

0,

*+!".(*+!#

,*%0-

IXcP]Xd\

=aTT]!T[S "*212# ,'1!

",'1!#

0-

.)!"*,(.)! _aX^a c^ W^^Z \^SX!RPcX^]%*!

fXcW C> STbXV]#

-)%-*

*.!"0'.(*.!#

,,%-+

+)!",'.(+)!#

,+%0.

=l]cWTa Id[X_ "+)))(+)),

P

# )',!

")',!#

,/

01!"++(01!#

0%,.(,0

*+'.!"+'-(*+'.!#

+/%,/%-,

-'*!"+'-(-'*!#

,/%-,

8T[TRc "+))0(+))1

P

#

8T[TRc F[PcX]d\ "+)*+#

.'/!"-',(.'/!#

,2%0/

2,!"++(2,!#

0%,.%,1%,2

-',!")(-',!#

,1%0/%00

+'.!"+'.!#

,1

7XaS&b DTbc "*212# -!

",(-!#

-*

1.!"1.!#

,-

*'*!"*'*!#

01

-'0!"+'2(-'0!#

,-%01

E_cTPbT "+))+(+))-

P

#

IaP_TPbT "+)))#

.)!")(.)!#

*2%02&1-

8PbT GT_^acb ")!#

02%1,%1-

)'2!")()'2!#

02(1*%1,%1-

+2!")'1(+2!#

-/%02%1,&1/

E_cX^] "+))2# BX\XcTS SPcP *)!

"+'2(*)!#

,0%10

+!"+!#

10

-!"-!#

10

8adg "+)*+# BX\XcTS SPcP ")!#

11

BX\XcTS SPcP BX\XcTS SPcP

")!#

11

BX\XcTS SPcP"0'+! ]^]^RR[dbXeT ?K8 cWa^\Qdb#

11

6QQaTeXPcX^]b3 <96% <TSTaP[ 9adV 6S\X]XbcaPcX^]4 ?K8% X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP'!$%"3 <^a cWT HPUT<[^ ![cTa "+))2#% ]^ bXV]X!RP]c R[X]XRP[ SPcP PaT PePX[PQ[T% P]S cWT STeXRT Xb ]^ [^]VTa \P]dUPRcdaTS'P

HdQbT`dT]c hTPa fWT] ![cTa fPb R[TPaTS U^a aTcaXTeP[ X]SXRPcX^]'

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

/LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P[' *(

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 6 of 9
/DK>MKKDHG

DeTa cWT _Pbc UTf STRPSTb$ >K7 ![cTa dbT WPb aXbT] X] cWT

J]XcTS HcPcTb$*%+ fWXRW WPb [TS c^ X]RaTPbTS aTR^V]XcX^] ^U P

fXST aP]VT ^U _^cT]cXP[ ![cTa%aT[PcTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b& IWTbT

R^\_[XRPcX^]b X]R[dST UaPRcdaT$ >K7 _TaU^aPcX^]$ R^\_^]T]c

T\Q^[XiPcX^]$ STeXRT \XVaPcX^]$ P]S >K7 ^RR[dbX^]& >] aT%

b_^]bT c^ aXbX]V R^\_[XRPcX^] aPcTb$ cWT RdaaT]c ;85 HPUTch

5[Tac ^] >K7 ![cTab aTR^\\T]Sb ![cTa aT\^eP[ fWT] _a^cTR%

cX^] Ua^\ E9 Xb ]^ [^]VTa ]TTSTS& B^aT aTRT]c[h$ cWT ;85

aT[TPbTS P] PSSXcX^]P[ HPUTch 7^\\d]XRPcX^] bcPcX]V cWPc cWT

aXbZ%c^%QT]T!c aPcX^ QTVX]b c^ UPe^a >K7 ![cTa aT\^eP[ fXcWX]

*1 c^ -, SPhb PUcTa X\_[P]cPcX^]$ XU cWT aXbZ ^U E9 WPb

_PbbTS&.)%.*

IWT bhbcT\PcXR aTeXTf Qh 5]VT[ Tc P[.+ R^]R[dSTS cWPc ![cTa

R^\_[XRPcX^]b PaT P bTaX^db R^]RTa] Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW [^]V%

cTa\ ![cTa dbT$ Qdc cWT bcdSh SXS ]^c PSSaTbb STeXRT%b_TRX!R

aXbZb$ P]S cWTaT fPb ]^ P]P[hbXb b_TRX!RP[[h ^U R^\_[XRPcX^]b

Ua^\ _Ta\P]T]c >K7 ![cTab& 5 [PaVT ePaXTch ^U aTcaXTePQ[T P]S

_Ta\P]T]c >K7 ![cTab PaT R^\\^][h T]R^d]cTaTS ^] a^dcX]T

X\PVX]V bcdSXTb$ Qdc cWT \haXPS ]d\QTa ^U ![cTa ch_Tb P]S

cWTXa Pbb^RXPcTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b _aTeT]cb X]cTa_aTcPcX^] ^U

bdRW aPSX^VaP_WXR !]SX]Vb& ;X[cTa%aT[PcTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b \Ph

cWTaTU^aT V^ d]aTR^V]XiTS ^a d]STaP__aTRXPcTS Pb _^cT]cXP[

RPdbTb ^U \^aQXSXch X] _PcXT]cb$ X]R[dSX]V cW^bT _aTbT]cX]V

fXcW X]caPRcPQ[T PQS^\X]P[ _PX] Ua^\ ![cTa _T]TcaPcX^]&.,

IWT V^P[ ^U cWXb bcdSh fPb c^ TeP[dPcT cWT ePaX^db ;85%

P__a^eTS >K7 ![cTa STbXV]b c^ STcTa\X]T STeXRT%b_TRX!R aXbZb$

P]S c^ WT[_ XST]cXUh _PcXT]cb fW^ \Ph QT]T!c Ua^\ ^]V^X]V

U^[[^f%d_ eTabdb _a^\_c ![cTa aTcaXTeP[& ;Xabc$ fT XST]cX!TS

cWT *+ ![cTa ch_Tb RdaaT]c[h T]R^d]cTaTS X] cWT J]XcTS HcPcTb&

CTgc$ cWT R^\_[XRPcX^]b Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW TPRW ![cTa ch_T fTaT

XST]cX!TS& 5[cW^dVW fT X]XcXP[[h bTPaRWTS cWT ;85 B5J89

SPcPQPbT$ fT b^^] aTP[XiTS cWTbT SPcP fTaT QPbTS ^] e^[d]%

cPah aT_^acX]V P]S cWTaT fPb Va^bb d]STaaT_^acX]V ^U R^\%

_[XRPcX^]b& IWTaTU^aT$ fT RW^bT c^ dbT TeXST]RT%QPbTS

\TcW^Sb c^ XST]cXUh cWT WXVWTbc aT_^acTS R^\_[XRPcX^] aPcTb

X] cWT [XcTaPcdaT U^a TPRW ![cTa ch_T "!9<=E@ &#&

IWTbT SPcP aTeTP[TS P WXVW aXbZ ^U UaPRcdaT P\^]V 6PaS P]S

7^aSXb "BXP\X APZTb$ ;A# >K7 ![cTab$ X]R[dSX]V P UaPRcdaT

X]RXST]RT ^U +1&-! Pc .-&/ \^]cWb fXcW cWT 6PaS GTR^eTah

STeXRT$*)(*- P +0! aXbZ ^U UaPRcdaT Pc .( \^]cWb P\^]V cWT

6PaS <* ch_T ![cTab$**%*,%*.%*/ P]S P -(! aXbZ ^U UaPRcdaT fXcW

7^aSXb D_cTPbT'IaP_TPbT STeXRTb&*2 5 WXVW aXbZ ^U >K7 _TaU^%

aPcX^] fPb aT_^acTS fXcW cWT 6PaS GTR^eTah P]S 7^^Z 7T[TRc

![cTab$ fXcW _T]TcaPcX^] aPcTb TgRTTSX]V 1(! U^a Q^cW&0%*+ ;^a

_Ta\P]T]c ![cTa ch_Tb$ P WXVW aXbZ ^U >K7 ^RR[dbX^] fPb

aT_^acTS P\^]V cWT HX\^] CXcX]^[ P]S KT]P ITRW A<B$2

![cTab fXcW ^RR[dbX^] aPcTb ^U -( P]S .-! "Pc 1 hTPab#$-.%-2

aTb_TRcXeT[h& DeTaP[[$ Pb cWTbT R^\_[XRPcX^]b P__TPa c^ QT

aT[PcTS c^ ![cTa VT^\Tcah$ ^]T bW^d[S P[fPhb PbbTbb U^a >K7

_TaU^aPcX^]$ fWT] P R^]XRP[ STeXRT Xb XST]cX!TS$ P]S >K7

^RR[dbX^]$ fWT] P Rh[X]SaXRP[ ^a d\QaT[[P ![cTa R^\_^]T]c

Xb XST]cX!TS&

IWXb bcdSh Xb [X\XcTS Qh cWT `dP[Xch ^U PePX[PQ[T SPcP ^] >K7

![cTab$ P]S b^\T ![cTa ch_Tb X] cWXb bcdSh fTaT [X\XcTS

_dQ[XbWTS SPcP& >] PSSXcX^]$ \P]h bcdSXTb WPS [X\XcTS [^]V%

cTa\ U^[[^f%d_3 cWTaTU^aT$ Xc Xb _^bbXQ[T cWPc cWT cadT aXbZ ^U

R^\_[XRPcX^]b U^a cWTbT ![cTa ch_Tb R^d[S QT TeT] WXVWTa cWP]

RdaaT]c[h aT_^acTS$ Pb R^\_[XRPcX^]b cT]S c^ X]RaTPbT PUcTa

[^]VTa SfT[[ cX\Tb& CTeTacWT[Tbb$ \XcXVPcX^] PVPX]bc cWTbT

TUUTRcb fPb PccT\_cTS Qh XST]cXUhX]V cWT WXVWTbc R^\_[XRPcX^]

aPcTb aT_^acTS b^ UPa X] cWT [XcTaPcdaT& ;dcdaT bcdSXTb bW^d[S

X]e^[eT \TcW^Sb c^ _a^eXST R^]bcP]c d_SPcX]V ^U ![cTa R^\%

_[XRPcX^] aPcTb Pb ]Tf SPcP T\TaVT X] [PaVTa R^W^acb&

7@A@J@G>@K

* 8dbiPZ G ?a$ EPaZTa A$ ATeX] 87$ GP^ KB& E[PRT\T]c P]S aT\^eP[ ^U

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 ]PcX^]P[ caT]Sb X] cWT BTSXRPaT _^_d[P%

cX^]& ? 5\ 7^[[ GPSX^[ *())30"/#2,0+$,01

+ HcTX] E8$ @PhP[X ;$ D[b^] G9& IfT]ch%^]T%hTPa caT]Sb X] cWT dbT ^U

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab& 5aRW >]cTa] BTS *((,3).,"),#2

)-,)$)-,-

, H\^dbT 6?& >b \PaZTc Va^fcW ^U eT]P RPeP ![cTab YdbcX!TS4 9]S^%

ePbR I^SPh *()(2/,$//

- ;^^S P]S 8adV 5S\X]XbcaPcX^]& GT\^eX]V GTcaXTePQ[T >]UTaX^a

KT]P 7PeP ;X[cTab2 >]XcXP[ 7^\\d]XRPcX^]& EdQ[XbWTS 5dVdbc 1$

*()(& 5ePX[PQ[T Pc2 Wcc_2''fff&USP&V^e'BTSXRP[8TeXRTb'HPUTch'

5[TacbP]SC^cXRTb'dR\**)./.&Wc\& 5RRTbbTS ?d[h +($ *()-

. ;^^S P]S 8adV 5S\X]XbcaPcX^]& -)("@# EaT\PaZTc C^cX!RPcX^]

8PcPQPbT& EdQ[XbWTS *(),& 5ePX[PQ[T Pc2 Wcc_2''fff&PRRTbbSPcP&

USP&V^e'bRaX_cb'RSaW'RUS^Rb'RU_\]'_\]&RU\& 5RRTbbTS ?P]dPah )$

*()-

/ 7P_[X] 8B$ CXZ^[XR 6$ @P[eP HE$ <P]Vd[X H$ HPPS L9$ OdRZTa\P] 853

H^RXTch ^U >]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh HcP]SPaSb ^U EaPRcXRT 7^\\Xc%

cTT& FdP[Xch X\_a^eT\T]c VdXST[X]Tb U^a cWT _TaU^a\P]RT ^U

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa _[PRT\T]c U^a cWT _aTeT]cX^] ^U _d[\^%

]Pah T\Q^[Xb\& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *())3**"))#2),11$)-(.

0 8daPRZ ?7$ LTbc_WP[T] 57$ @TZd[PfT[P H$ Tc P[& ETaU^aPcX^] ^U cWT

>K72 ad[T aPcWTa cWP] TgRT_cX^] PUcTa [^]VTa X]SfT[[X]V cX\Tb U^a

cWT <m]cWTa Id[X_ P]S 7T[TRc aTcaXTePQ[T ![cTab& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTa%

eT]c GPSX^[ *()*3+-"*#2*11$+(0

1 ;^^S P]S 8adV 5S\X]XbcaPcX^]& B5J89 % BP]dUPRcdaTa P]S JbTa

;PRX[Xch 8TeXRT 9g_TaXT]RT 8PcPQPbT& EdQ[XbWTS *(),& 5ePX[PQ[T Pc2

Wcc_2''fff&PRRTbbSPcP&USP&V^e'bRaX_cb'RSaW'RUS^Rb'RU\PdST'

bTPaRW&RU\& 5RRTbbTS ?P]dPah )$ *()-

2 6PZP[ 7L$ HX[QTaifTXV ?9& KPbRd[Pa P]S >]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh2

EaX]RX_[Tb P]S EaPRcXRT& CTf N^aZ$ CN2 IWXT\T3 *())

*) IP\ B8$ H_PX] ?$ AXTQTa B$ <TXbX]VTa B$ HP]Sb B?$ LP]V L&

;aPRcdaT P]S SXbcP]c \XVaPcX^] ^U cWT 6PaS GTR^eTah ![cTa2 P

aTca^b_TRcXeT aTeXTf ^U +.+ X\_[P]cPcX^]b U^a _^cT]cXP[[h [XUT%

cWaTPcT]X]V R^\_[XRPcX^]b& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *()*3*+"*#2

)11$*(-&T)

** CXRW^[b^] L$ CXRW^[b^] L?$ I^[TaXR^ E$ Tc P[& EaTeP[T]RT ^U UaPRcdaT

P]S UaPV\T]c T\Q^[XiPcX^] ^U 6PaS aTcaXTePQ[T eT]P RPeP ![cTab

P]S R[X]XRP[ X\_[XRPcX^]b X]R[dSX]V RPaSXPR _TaU^aPcX^] P]S cP\%

_^]PST& 5aRW >]cTa] BTS *()(3)/("*(#2)0*/$)0+)

*+ =d[[ ?9$ G^QTacb^] HL& 6PaS GTR^eTah ![cTa2 TeP[dPcX^] P]S

\P]PVT\T]c ^U eT]P RPeP [X\Q _TaU^aPcX^]$ UaPRcdaT$ P]S \XVaP%

cX^]& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*(")#2-*$.(

*, KXYPh @$ =dVWTb ?5$ 6daSTccT 5H$ Tc P[& ;aPRcdaTS 6PaS GTR^eTah$ <*$

P]S <* Tg_aTbb X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 X]RXST]RT$ R[X]XRP[

R^]bT`dT]RTb$ P]S ^dcR^\Tb ^U aT\^eP[ PccT\_cb& ? KPbR >]cTae

GPSX^[ *()*3*+"*#2)00$)1,

*- @P[eP HE$ 5cWP]Pb^d[Xb 75$ ;P] 7B$ Tc P[& "GTR^eTah# eT]P RPeP

![cTa2 Tg_TaXT]RT X] 1. _PcXT]cb& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTaeT]c GPSX^[ *((.3

*1",#2--1$-.,

*. 6X]ZTac 75$ 8a^^i 5I$ 7PaXSX ?<$ Tc P[& ITRW]XRP[ bdRRTbb P]S bPUTch

^U aTcaXTeP[ ^U cWT <* ![cTa X] P _a^b_TRcXeT$ \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh& ?

KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("))#2),,1$),-+

*/ 5] I$ B^^] 9$ 6d[[T] ?$ Tc P[& EaTeP[T]RT P]S R[X]XRP[ R^]bT`dT]RTb

^U UaPRcdaT P]S UaPV\T]c \XVaPcX^] ^U cWT 6PaS <* ![cTa2 X\PVX]V

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

*) /LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P['

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 7 of 9
P]S R[X]XRP[ U^[[^f%d_ X] .0, X\_[P]cPcX^]b& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

*(),3*-".#21,)$1,0

*0 E^[TccX E5$ 6TRZTa 78$ EaX]P A$ Tc P[& A^]V%cTa\ aTbd[cb ^U cWT HX\^]

]XcX]^[ X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa& 9da GPSX^[ )11030"*#2*01$*1,

*1 BR7^fP] I7$ ;TaaXb 9?$ 7PaeTa 8@$ B^[_db LB& 7^\_[XRPcX^]b ^U

cWT ]XcX]^[ eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )11*3+"*#2

,()$,(0

*2 HP]^ B$ J]]^ C$ NP\P\^c^ C$ IP]PZP =$ @^]]^ =& ;aT`dT]c

UaPRcdaT ^U IaP_9PbT X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 P [^]V%cTa\ U^[[^f%

d_ PbbTbb\T]c& 5aRW >]cTa] BTS *()*3)/*"*#2)01$)1)

+) 7P]cfT[[ 7E$ ET]]h_PRZTa ?$ HX]VW =$ HR^aiP A6$ LPhQX[[ EC$

Ah]RW ;7& 7^\_PaXb^] ^U cWT aTR^eTah P]S <* ![cTa Pb aTcaXTe%

PQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("1#2

))1+$))11

+* 6X]ZTac 75$ HPbPSTdbi @$ HcPea^_^d[^b HL& GTcaXTePQX[Xch ^U cWT

aTR^eTah eT]P RPeP ![cTa PUcTa SfT[[ cX\Tb [^]VTa cWP] )0( SPhb& ?

KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((.3)/"*$ Ec )#2*11$+(*

++ 7WPa[Tb =L$ 6[PRZ B$ @^ePRb H$ Tc P[& <* X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2

aTcaXTePQX[Xch P]S bPUTch& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("0#2

)(,.$)(-)

+, Ah]RW ;7$ @TZd[PfT[P H& GT\^eP[ ^U cWT <* ![cTa2 SXUUTaT]RTb

QTcfTT] X\_[P]cPcX^] cX\Tb VaTPcTa P]S [Tbb cWP] )0( SPhb& ?

KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("1#2)*(($)*(1

+- BPa`dTbb ?H$ 6daZT 7I$ 6TTRWP\ 5=$ Tc P[& ;PRc^ab Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW

UPX[TS aTcaXTeP[ ^U cWT <m]cWTa Id[X_ X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa& ? KPbR

>]cTae GPSX^[ *((03)1"1#2)+*)$)+*/

+. H\^dbT =6$ G^bT]cWP[ 8$ IWd^]V K=$ Tc P[& A^]V%cTa\ aTcaXTeP[

bdRRTbb aPcT _a^![T U^a cWT <m]cWTa Id[X_ eT]P RPeP ![cTa& ? KPbR

>]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("/#20/)$0//$ `dXi 0/0

+/ LXRZh H$ 8^T]i ;$ BTdf[h ?%N$ E^acXTa ;$ HRW]hSTa E$ 8T]hb 5&

7[X]XRP[ Tg_TaXT]RT fXcW aTcaXTePQ[T <m]cWTa Id[X_ eT]P RPeP

![cTab& ? 9]S^ePbR IWTa *((+3)("-#211,$)(((

+0 MXP^ A$ =dP]V 8H$ HWT] ?$ I^]V ??& >]ca^SdRTa RdaeX]V cTRW]X`dT U^a

cWT _aTeT]cX^] ^U cX[cX]V ^U caP]bUT\^aP[ <m]cWTa Id[X_ X]UTaX^a

eT]P RPeP ![cTa& @^aTP] ? GPSX^[ *()*3)+",#2,0+$,1)

+1 <aTT]!T[S A?$ EThc^] G$ 7adcT H$ 6Pa]Tb G& <aTT]!T[S eT]P RPeP[

![cTa Tg_TaXT]RT2 [PcT aTbd[cb X] )-. _PcXT]cb& 5aRW HdaV )10)3

))."))#2),-)$),-.

+2 BTbb\Ta ?B$ <aTT]!T[S A?& <aTT]!T[S RPeP[ ![cTab2 [^]V%cTa\

aPSX^VaP_WXR U^[[^f%d_ bcdSh& GPSX^[^Vh )10-3)-."+#2.)+$.)0

,) @X]]Th I6$ G^bT H7$ LTX]VPacT] @9$ KP[YX @$ DV[TeXT H6$ G^QTacb 57&

>K7 ![cTa cX[c P]S Pbh\\Tcah2 R^\_PaXb^] ^U cWT ^eTa%cWT%fXaT

bcPX][Tbb%bcTT[ P]S cXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S >K7 ![cTab& ? KPbR >]cTae

GPSX^[ )11/30".#2)(*1$)(+/

,* ?^W]b^] HE$ GPXZT] 8E$ <aTQT E?$ 8XU!] 87$ AThT]STRZTa ?G& HX]V[T

X]bcXcdcX^] _a^b_TRcXeT TeP[dPcX^] ^U cWT ^eTa%cWT%fXaT <aTT]!T[S

eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )11031"-#2/..$//+

,+ HfTT]Th I?$ KP] 5\P] B9& 8T_[^h\T]c _a^Q[T\b fXcW cWT

cXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )11+3,"-#2.1)$.1,

,, LXccT]QTaV <$ @dT__Tab K$ IbRWP\\[Ta 5$ HRWT__PRW L$ @T]] L$

=PW] 8& A^]V%cTa\ aTbd[cb ^U eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 Tg_TaXT]RTb fXcW

cWT A<B P]S cWT IXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S STeXRTb& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTa%

eT]c GPSX^[ )1103*)"+#2**-$**1

,- CXRW^[b^] 55$ 9cc[Tb 8;$ EPSS^] 5?$ 8hTc ?;& A^]V%cTa\ U^[[^f%d_ ^U

cWT QXaS!b ]Tbc >K7 ![cTa& 7[X] GPSX^[ )1113-,"))#2/-1$/.,

,. BRA^]Th 98$ @aXbW]PbP\h KE$ 7Pbc[T ?7$ NP]V M$ <dh <& 7^\_[X%

RPcX^]b ^U 7T[TRc$ <m]cWTa cd[X_$ P]S <aTT]!T[S X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP

![cTab ^] 7I U^[[^f%d_2 P bX]V[T%X]bcXcdcX^] Tg_TaXT]RT& ? KPbR

>]cTae GPSX^[ *()+3*,"))#2)/*+$)/*1

,/ =^UUTa 9@$ BdT[[Ta G?$ AdRXP]^ BG$ ATT CC$ BXRWPT[b 5I$ <T\Tah

?B& HPUTch P]S TU!RPRh ^U cWT <d]cWTa Id[X_ aTcaXTePQ[T eT]P RPeP

![cTa2 \XScTa\ ^dcR^\Tb& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTaeT]c GPSX^[ *()+3

+.",#2110$)((-

,0 D[^ad]b^[P D<$ @^WX BE$ ;XST[\P] C$ Tc P[& 7PeP[ _T]TcaPcX^] Qh

aTcaXTePQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 P aTca^b_TRcXeT R^\_PaXb^]

^U D_cX^] P]S <m]cWTa Id[X_ ![cTab& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *()+3

*,",#2-..$-/)

,1 OW^d 8$ H_PX] ?$ B^^] 9$ BR[T]]P] <$ HP]Sb B?$ LP]V L&

GTca^b_TRcXeT aTeXTf ^U )*( 7T[TRc X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa aT%

caXTeP[b2 Tg_TaXT]RT Pc P bX]V[T X]bcXcdcX^]& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

*()*3*+")*#2)--/$)-.+

,2 HP]VfPXhP B?$ BPaT]cXb I7$ LP[ZTa I<$ HcTRZTa B$ LXRZh HI$ @P[eP

HE& HPUTch P]S TUUTRcXeT]Tbb ^U cWT RT[TRc X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2

_aT[X\X]Pah aTbd[cb& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("1#2))00$))1*

-) <aTT]!T[S A?$ 7W^ @?$ Ea^Rc^a B$ Tc P[& GTbd[cb ^U P \d[cXRT]cTa

bcdSh ^U cWT \^SX!TS W^^Z%cXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S ![cTa& ? KPbR HdaV

)11)3),"+#2*-+$*-/

-* ;TaaXb 9?$ BR7^fP] I7$ 7PaeTa 8@$ BR;Pa[P]S 8G& ETaRdcP]T^db

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP[ ![cTab2 U^[[^f%d_ ^U bTeT] STbXV]b X] +*(

_PcXT]cb& GPSX^[^Vh )11+3)00"+#20-)$0-.

-+ <aTT]!T[S A?$ 7W^ @?$ EPXb HD$ KP] 5\P] B& EaT[X\X]Pah R[X]XRP[

Tg_TaXT]RT fXcW cWT cXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& 5aRW

HdaV )1013)*,".#2.-/$.-1

-, =^__T =$ CdccX]V 7L$ H\^dbT =G$ Tc P[& <m]cWTa Id[X_ ![cTa

aTcaXTePQX[Xch \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh X]R[dSX]V 7I U^[[^f%d_2 !]P[

aT_^ac& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((.3)/".#2)()/$)(*+

-- BX[[fPaS H;$ ETcTab^] G5$ B^WTa 8$ Tc P[& A<B "KT]P ITRW# eT]P

RPeP[ ![cTa2 Tg_TaXT]RT Pc P bX]V[T X]bcXcdcX^]& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

)11,3-"*#2+-)$+-.

-. 7a^RWTc 8E$ 6ad]T[ E$ Ia^Va[XR H$ <a^bbTckcT G$ 5dVTc ?%A$ 8Pah 7&

A^]V%cTa\ U^[[^f%d_ ^U KT]P ITRW%A<B ![cTa2 _aTSXRc^ab P]S

UaT`dT]Rh ^U RPeP[ ^RR[dbX^]& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )1113)("*$ Ec

)#2)+/$),*

-/ 7^aaXTaT B5$ HPdeT @?$ 5hTaSX ?$ Tc P[& KT]P RPeP ![cTab P]S X]UTaX^a

eT]P RPeP cWa^\Q^bXb& ? KPbR HdaV *((/3,-",#2/01$/1,

-0 HX\^] B$ 5cWP]Pb^d[Xb 75$ @X\ 8$ Tc P[& HX\^] ]XcX]^[ X]UTaX^a eT]P

RPeP ![cTa2 X]XcXP[ R[X]XRP[ Tg_TaXT]RT& L^aZ X] _a^VaTbb& GPSX^[^Vh

)1013)/*")#211$)(+

-1 @X\ 8$ 9ST[\P] GG$ BPaV^[X] 7?$ Tc P[& IWT HX\^] ]XcX]^[ ![cTa2

TeP[dPcX^] Qh BG P]S d[caPb^d]S& 5]VX^[^Vh )11*3,+"/#2-,)$-,0

-2 <aPbbX 7?$ BPcbd\^c^ 5=$ ITXcT[QPd\ <E& KT]P RPeP[ ^RR[dbX^]

PUcTa HX\^] ]XcX]^[ ![cTa _[PRT\T]c2 XST]cX!RPcX^] fXcW BG

X\PVX]V X] _PcXT]cb fXcW \P[XV]P]Rh& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )11*3

+"+#2-+-$-+1

.) ;^^S P]S 8adV 5S\X]XbcaPcX^]& GT\^eX]V GTcaXTePQ[T >]UTaX^a

KT]P 7PeP ;X[cTab2 ;85 HPUTch 7^\\d]XRPcX^]& EdQ[XbWTS *(),&

5ePX[PQ[T Pc2 Wcc_2''fff&USP&V^e'BTSXRP[8TeXRTb'HPUTch'5[Tac%

bP]SC^cXRTb'dR\+1.+//&Wc\& 5RRTbbTS ?P]dPah )$ *()-

.* B^aP[Tb ?E$ AX M$ >a^]h IO$ >QaPWX\ C<$ B^h]PWP] B$ 7PeP]PdVW @?

?a& 8TRXbX^] P]P[hbXb ^U aTcaXTePQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab X]

_PcXT]cb fXcW^dc _d[\^]Pah T\Q^[Xb\& ? KPbR HdaV KT]^db Ah\%

_WPc 8Xb^aS *()+3)",#2+/.$+0,

.+ 5]VT[ A;$ IP_b^] K$ <P[V^] G9$ GTbcaT_^ B>$ @PdU\P] ?& HhbcT\PcXR

aTeXTf ^U cWT dbT ^U aTcaXTePQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab& ? KPbR

>]cTae GPSX^[ *())3**"))#2)-**$)-+(&T+

., BThTa 5$ HRWl][TQT] ;$ =TX]i B$ AP]V L& ETaU^aPcTS X]UTaX^a eT]P

RPeP ![cTab Pb cWT RPdbT ^U d]R[TPa PQS^\X]P[ _PX]& 5]] KPbR HdaV

*()+3*/"+#2+-,&T1$+-,&T)*

.- ET[[TaX] D$ SX EaX\X^ B$ HP]RWTi D$ BThTa <$ HP_^eP[ B& HdRRTbbUd[

aTcaXTeP[ ^U *1 5AC X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab Pc P \TP] ^U *-&.

\^]cWb PUcTa _[PRT\T]c& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *()+3*,"*#2*0,$*00

.. ET[[TaX] D$ 6PaaP[ ;<$ AX^]b 7$ C^eT[[X A$ 6TaTVX ?E$ HP_^eP[ B& 9Pa[h

P]S [PcT aTcaXTeP[ ^U cWT 5AC aT\^ePQ[T eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 aTbd[cb

Ua^\ P \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTaeT]c GPSX^[ *((03+)"-#2

001$01.

./ @d^ LI$ G^QTacb^] HL$ DSTVPPaS ?>$ =^U\P]] AK& 7^\_[Tg

aTcaXTeP[ ^U UaPRcdaTS$ T\QTSSTS$ P]S _T]TcaPcX]V X]UTaX^a eT]P

RPeP ![cTab2 P _a^b_TRcXeT bcdSh fXcW WXbc^[^VXR P]S T[TRca^]

\XRa^bR^_XR P]P[hbXb& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *()+3*,"-#2.**$.+(&

T)$ `dXi .+)

.0 BXb\TccX E$ GXea^]%<dX[[^c @$ FdT]Tc H$ Tc P[& 5 _a^b_TRcXeT [^]V%

cTa\ bcdSh ^U **( _PcXT]cb fXcW P aTcaXTePQ[T eT]P RPeP ![cTa U^a

bTR^]SPah _aTeT]cX^] ^U eT]^db cWa^\Q^T\Q^[Xb\& 7WTbc *((/3

)+)")#2**+$**1

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

/LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P[' **

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 8 of 9
.1 >\QTacX 8$ 6XP]RWX B$ ;PaX]P 5$ HXaPVdbP H$ HX[X]VPaSX B$ 5VT]^ L&

7[X]XRP[ Tg_TaXT]RT fXcW aTcaXTePQ[T eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 aTbd[cb ^U P

_a^b_TRcXeT ^QbTaePcX^]P[ \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh& ? IWa^\Q =PT\^bc

*((-3+"/#2)+/($)+/-

.2 7Pa^]]^ G$ EXUUPaTccX <$ I^iiX B$ Tc P[& BXS%cTa\ Tg_TaXT]RT

fXcW cWT 5AC aTcaXTePQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa& 9da^_TP]

Y^da]P[ ^U ePbRd[Pa P]S T]S^ePbRd[Pa bdaVTah2 cWT ^U!RXP[ Y^da%

]P[ ^U cWT 9da^_TP] H^RXTch U^a KPbRd[Pa HdaVTah *((.3+*"-#2

-1.$1

/) OWd M$ IP\ B86H$ 6PacW^[^\Tf ?$ CTf\P] ?H$ HP]Sb B?$ LP]V L&

GTcaXTePQX[Xch P]S STeXRT%aT[PcTS R^\_[XRPcX^]b ^U cWT <* ![cTa2 P

aTca^b_TRcXeT bcdSh ^U )+1 ![cTa aTcaXTeP[b& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

*())3**".#20(.$0)*

/* D[XeP KA$ ETaaTPd[c E$ <Xa^dg B%;$ 6^dRWPaS A$ IWTaPbbT 9$ H^d[Ti <&

GTR^eTah <* X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 cTRW]XRP[ bdRRTbb P]S bPUTch

^U aTcaXTeP[& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((03)1".#200,$001

/+ @d^ LI$ G^QTacb^] HL& 6PaS 8T]P[X >K7 ![cTa UaPRcdaT P]S

T\Q^[XiPcX^] aTbd[cX]V X] RPaSXPR cP\_^]PST2 P STeXRT UPX[daT

P]P[hbXb& ?^da]P[ ^U ePbRd[Pa P]S X]cTaeT]cX^]P[ aPSX^[^Vh& ? KPbR

>]cTae GPSX^[ *(),3 >] _aTbb

/, HcPea^_^d[^b HL$ HX]V G;$ 9[\PbaX ;$ Tc P[3 89C5A> IaXP[ >]eTb%

cXVPc^ab& IWT 89C5A> IaXP[2 P] X]cTaX\ P]P[hbXb ^U P _a^b_TRcXeT$

\d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh ^U cWT 8T]P[X aTcaXTePQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP

![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *(),3*-")(#2),1/$)-(-$ )-(-&T)

/- 5fW B=$ IPh[^a ;7$ Ad 7I& H_^]cP]T^db UaPRcdaT ^U P KT]P%ITRW

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& 5?G 5\ ? G^T]cVT]^[ )11)3)-/")#2

)//$)/0

/. GXRR^ ?%6$ 8dQaTdX[ ;$ GTh]PdS E$ Tc P[& IWT A<B KT]P%ITRW RPeP[

![cTa2 aTbd[cb ^U P \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh& 5]] KPbR HdaV )11-31"Hd__[#2

H01$H)((

// Bda_Wh IE$ 8^aU\P] <H$ NTS[XRZP ?L$Tc P[& A<B eT]P RPeP ![cTa2

^QYTRcXeT TeP[dPcX^] ^U TPa[h aTbd[cb& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ )11)3

*")#2)(/$))-

/0 AT 6[P]RWT 5;$ 6T]Pii^di 5$ GTh]PdS E$ Tc P[& IWT KT]PITRW AE

_Ta\P]T]c RPeP[ ![cTa2 TUUTRcXeT]Tbb P]S bPUTch X] cWT _aTeT]cX^]

^U _d[\^]Pah T\Q^[Xb\$P 9da^_TP] \d[cXRT]cTa bcdSh& ?^da]P[ ^U

ePbRd[Pa P]S X]cTaeT]cX^]P[ aPSX^[^Vh& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((03

)1",#2-(1$-)-

/1 IPWTaX H5$ @d[Ph[Pc BC$ ?^W]b^] 9$ =^^eTa 9& 5 R^\_[XRPcX^] ^U cWT

<aTT]!T[S ![cTa2 UaPRcdaT P]S SXbcP[ \XVaPcX^] ^U cf^ bcadcb%P

RPbT aT_^ac& ? KPbR HdaV )11*3).")#21.$11

/2 7PaPQPbX G5 >>>$ B^aXci B?$ ?PaaT[[ 69& 7^\_[XRPcX^]b T]R^d]cTaTS

fXcW cWT dbT ^U cWT <aTT]!T[S ![cTa& 5\ ? HdaV )10/3)-,"*#2

).+$).0

0) LX]VTaS B$ 6Ta]WPaS KB$ BPSSXb^] ;$ I^f]T ?6& 7^\_PaXb^] ^U

RPeP[ ![cTab X] cWT \P]PVT\T]c ^U eT]^db cWa^\Q^T\Q^[Xb\&

5aRW HdaV )1/03))+"))#2)*.,$)*/)

0* <aTT]!T[S A?$ BXRW]P 65& IfT[eT%hTPa R[X]XRP[ Tg_TaXT]RT fXcW cWT

<aTT]!T[S eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& HdaVTah )1003)(,",#2/(.$/)*

0+ <aTT]!T[S A?$ Ea^Rc^a B7& IfT]ch%hTPa R[X]XRP[ Tg_TaXT]RT fXcW

cWT <aTT]!T[S ![cTa& 7PaSX^ePbR HdaV )11-3+"*#2)11$*(-

0, <aTT]!T[S A?$ Ea^Rc^a B7& IWT _TaRdcP]T^db VaTT]!T[S ![cTa2

^dcR^\Tb P]S _aPRcXRT _PccTa]b& ? KPbR HdaV *(((3+*"-#2000$01+

0- 7W^ @?$ <aTT]!T[S A?$ Ea^Rc^a B7$ Tc P[& 9eP[dPcX^] ^U P ]Tf

_TaRdcP]T^db bcPX][Tbb bcTT[ <aTT]!T[S ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

)11/30"*#2)0)$)0/

0. <aTT]!T[S A?$ Ea^Rc^a B7$ 7W^ @?$ Tc P[& 9gcT]STS TeP[dPcX^] ^U cWT

cXcP]Xd\ <aTT]!T[S eT]P RPeP[ ![cTa& ? KPbR HdaV )11,3*("+#2

,-0$,.,$ SXbRdbbX^] ,.,$,.-

0/ LP]V L$ OW^d 8$ DQdRW^fbZX C$ H_PX] ?$ 5] I$ B^^] 9& ;aPRcdaT

P]S \XVaPcX^] ^U 7T[TRc X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTab2 P aTca^b_TRcXeT

aTeXTf ^U /,) R^]bTRdcXeT X\_[P]cPcX^]b& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[

*()+3*,"))#2)/)1$)/**

00 Ah^] HB$ GX^YPb <9$ JQTa^X G$ Tc P[& HW^ac% P]S [^]V%cTa\ aTcaXTe%

PQX[Xch ^U cWT 7T[TRc eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 aTbd[cb Ua^\ P \d[cX%X]bcXcd%

cX^]P[ aTVXbcah& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((13*("))#2),,)$),,0

01 G^TW\ ?D ?a$ ?^W]badST >H$ 6PacW B=$ <XP]cdaR^ 7& IWT QXaS!b ]Tbc

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 _a^VaTbb aT_^ac& GPSX^[^Vh )1003).0"+#2

/,-$/,1

02 OXTV[Ta ?L$ 8XTcaXRW <?$ 7^WT] H5$ HcTa[X]V @$ 8d]RP] ?$ HP\^c^fZP

B& EGDD; caXP[2 _a^cTRcX^] Ua^\ _d[\^]Pah T\Q^[Xb\ fXcW cWT

D_c9PbT ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((03)1"0#2)).-$))/(

1) D[XeP KA$ HiPc\PaX ;$ <Xa^dg B%;$ ;[T\\X]V 6@$ 7^WT] H5$ H^d[Ti

<& IWT ?^]Pb bcdSh2 TeP[dPcX^] ^U cWT aTcaXTePQX[Xch ^U cWT 7^aSXb

D_c9PbT X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *((-3)."))#2

),+1$),,-$ `dXi ),,-

1* G^bT]cWP[ 8$ HfXbRWdZ ?A$ 7^WT] H5$ LT[[^]b 98& D_c9PbT aTcaXTe%

PQ[T X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 X]XcXP[ \d[cXRT]cTa Tg_TaXT]RT&

KPbRd[Pa *((-3)+"-#2*0.$*01

1+ @P[eP HE$ LXRZh H$ LP[c\P] 57$ 5cWP]Pb^d[Xb 75& IaP_9PbT eT]P

RPeP ![cTa2 Tg_TaXT]RT X] /-) _PcXT]cb& ? 9]S^ePbR IWTa *((.3

)+"+#2+.-$+/*

1, AXd L7$ 8^ NH$ 7W^^ HL$ Tc P[& IWT \XS%cTa\ TU!RPRh P]S bPUTch ^U P

_Ta\P]T]c ]XcX]^[ >K7 ![cTa"IaP_9PbT#& @^aTP] ? GPSX^[ *((-3."*#2

))($)).

1- G^dbbTPd =$ ETaaTPd[c E$ DcP[ E$ Tc P[& IWT .%; ]XcX]^[ IaP_9PbT

X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 aTbd[cb ^U P _a^b_TRcXeT \d[cXRT]cTa caXP[& ?

KPbR >]cTae GPSX^[ *(()3)*"+#2*11$+(,

1. @P[eP HE$ BPaT]cXb I7$ NTSSd[P @$ H^\Pa^dcWd 6$ LXRZh H$ HcTRZTa

BH& A^]V%cTa\ bPUTch P]S TUUTRcXeT]Tbb ^U cWT "D_c9PbT# eT]P RPeP

![cTa& 7PaSX^ePbR >]cTaeT]c GPSX^[ *())3+,"*#2++)$++/

1/ Jb^W ;$ =X]V^aP]X 5$ 5bRWTa 9$ Tc P[& Ea^b_TRcXeT aP]S^\XiTS bcdSh

R^\_PaX]V cWT R[X]XRP[ ^dcR^\Tb QTcfTT] X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP

<aTT]!T[S P]S IaP_9PbT ![cTab& ? KPbR HdaV *()(3-*"*#2+1,$+11

10 ?^W]b^] BH$ CT\RTZ 55 ?a$ 6T]T]PcX ?;$ Tc P[& IWT bPUTch P]S

TUUTRcXeT]Tbb ^U cWT aTcaXTePQ[T ^_cX^] X]UTaX^a eT]P RPeP ![cTa2 P

J]XcTS HcPcTb _a^b_TRcXeT \d[cXRT]cTa R[X]XRP[ bcdSh& ? KPbR >]cTae

GPSX^[ *()(3*)"0#2))/+$))0,

11 H\^dbT =6$ BT]STb G$ 6^bXTab B$ KP] =P I<$ 7aPQcaTT I$ >]eTb%

cXVPc^ab G3 G9IG>9K9 >]eTbcXVPc^ab& IWT G9IG>9K9 caXP[2 bPUTch P]S

TUUTRcXeT]Tbb ^U cWT aTcaXTePQ[T Radg eT]P RPeP ![cTa& ? KPbR >]cTae

GPSX^[ *()+3*,"-#2.(1$.*)

HT\X]Pab X] ?]cTaeT]cX^]P[ GPSX^[^Vh K^[' ,, D^' +(+)*/

#"" /LB>?E=?!,;I?> /L;CK;JBFE F@ 29- 0BCJ?H -FDGCB=;JBFEI 9Tb^ Tc P['

This document was prepared for the exclusive use of Melanie Swaby. Unauthorized distribution is strictly prohibited.

Case 2:15-md-02641-DGC Document 8223-2 Filed 10/18/17 Page 9 of 9