**OFFICE OF**  **THE ATTORNEY**  **GENERAL OF**  **TEXAS AUSTIN** 
**GROVERSELLERS ATTORNEYGENERAL** 

*o bog te 8ekueQ? 8U aplnlsn eemoermlnl: tlte, 8

**lhrer** in1*tr8tieu **of 811**  **t8 in**  **oetm8etlo8** t0 **ttJ0** blind 8td

. n 8ul

**ffkWt t0**  **fml8tO pli-**  **~8tiOnO rOl'**  **tb0** bOU.flt **et** tb@ 8t8t8r ,e-isR 

### Witbiq fb+ f W&d a4U8tl 

### tttth , tm0 

### m8T& aiU.rti **the** bB4tit\tti~8~ &Mm&- mbritt8d to tb8 0~8OtOF8tO 4)

, and mm4

**alnow** we **ae** CR81rm8ur t4 submit **ror** four **aousidsr8tlcm** 8Ud apiai@l **th8** f-41 lowingt._

**Iogonblo fhonm**  l **He T8+lar**  **- Mu4**  *****

**tUlV cljd**  **-8Ot 8t8ttItO8**  Wttittg **UP ttA0**  **b** pwfrent er ttrblle **volhre 8na**  **Fl ’** **W1+55.lI( t4r**  **8 rJ4tU**  **Ot Old**  **8p 8m8i@t8W8,**  **81d to**  **the blht,**  **am8 85Q**  **to 6eymm9emt**  **0Mldrw; thlr**  **statute holnl;**  **RouX4 Pill**  611, Acts af **the 47th**  **t~og5m18turer** l n Maded **and Inown**  8* the **pub¶le** wsl?ere **8et** ot 1941. T?to**Be- ~t** **’ tmtstlt**  **Or** Ppblls **rOlf8tW 38**  **8(bill18tW log**  **tb8 tmrn**  **puBl50 88S5eJa4rmo**  **proxnma UtltiW88**  l

be+Q and 98 P4BVf4btit ethQr ad**mln54tr8tiro** rrspettdbititi8m **pWTid8d for**  **it! tb.**  **184.**



### l **‘ tiate.**  Sla. **330 tO~418tUrO**  **rh8ll h&V9**  **the** powor, **by gwaral**  **18+4 ta**  **pt%Wido~ wb**  **@at to**  **1 hltatiwo**  **and reatriotianw**  **hemim 4Wt8iR8&,**  ***ad** web ftth8t’ **?irtltAtiWB, F8-**  mttietlonm and n~l8tlons **88 up**  by **the t.t@S~8ttltW**  **be &OWN&**  WWdiWt **?8+ 88d8t**  **en48 to,**  **ad far**  **tha** pawmmtt **Of 84nirt8n40**  **tot** 

### 97



### I

### 98



### mata fumes eh811not ba ura tk8m hem ty **solI8ra t&20)**  **ror month.**  "(2) **Satly blind**  **p8rwmr 4ho**  **are 4atunl**  **b*n4** **fide 4ltlaaro**  **nf Tcstnw**  **on8 8m**  **aver the**  **8@!3** of twenty-owe (21) yewa; **pmri#od th8tno**  **4u4h** l**445at8ne4 stull**  **ho** paid to an? iammte of mw %-to mpportod inatltutlan, wbllo **4u4h** lnmmte, ar to any permew rho **shall not**  **ka+o 8otrulYy**  **mmid4!d ln**  **Pawa 8t**  **1884t** tit0 (3) years **nurlag** the **nine** (9) tare 5mmmdJatel~**pneadinn tho**  **4~ pliatitttt**  **r ’** **or WtOb**  **4Bi54t8484 md**  **OQntiftm** otwly far awe (1) **few** lmmodl~tot~ **~rwml** la2 eueb 

## l

ppllart5m. 

# l 'ts) Bw chlldnn **Wt.0 8m**  **84tu81 b4.m**  **rida 4itiSm4**  **Of 70X84**  l d **8m Utt&8r**  **th0** l**P Of**  **d%tOOU (la)**  **f48N ’** **88 jWt.Vidti**  **th8t a4**  **attob 8.4-28tM40**  **sh813** be -Id an **8OWU?lt Of**  **my Ohi?&**  **OIOF tme**  **(1) ‘** **fO8F old**  **who b88**  **ttOt OsllthtWUdY**  raoided in 7-a **fQr On0**  **(1) yO8r**  **5RIDOd58t8ly w848&5Dg**  **th8 8pp1548t14EI**  **rot ’**  **atah 88iiSt8Fl44,**  **Ot- WJ**  **84-** ommt of rs~ eblld **under** tbo **868** of on0 (1) jeer **When WthW**  **b88 SOt**  **O+mdhUOUmfy I+**  05Qod 

### in **Tox8n** for me (1) **yO8r** 1snHdlntely **plW4&ina 448b**  **8ppf588t54U.** 

## l **‘ %%fi**  **%.#5818tU?4 sb811**  **h8+8 tha**  **8UtRor itr**  **t0 8448pt**  **?T ’** **4R tb4**  **P8d8ml PO+OtWUOFlt**  **Ot** the Cnlted Btator mob tlnnma5~1 aid **ror** tbo **84454tin44 Oi**  **th. MI8487**  **8@r** W0.t~ bllnde urd **naody** <dmn as r06h ~CW*8weont r*lr **afTor not**  **5nson454tent with**  **m4tr5atlan4 b8r8-**  **in** nt forth: prerldod bowever **th8t tha**  @8MQtt **or much**  **88Rlrnt8wm8 out**  **or Otak**  **fbnd*** **to 884ll**  perran **attrl8teU** rF%lt **newor** dmeod tb8 uuntnt m oxpmded ant of Podoral Fundat and* wo

### vi&eQ further tht 

### the **tit41** llasunt **4f ~rmw**  **to be**  **expewded out**  **or** 8tats **f%mdn for**  **lnab 44alnt8ncs**  **to the**  **n44Qy am&,**  **n84bj blind,**  **and ~3~8**  **4bildrra iR811**  **utW@r axoeod**  **the tmm**  **eT 2**  **frty-tlrs** Vllllf8n **Dall4r4 (#2Qll,OM)~OoO)**  **per far.**  **’**gDleud aill (I& Amtm of tbm 4Ttb tm~fmImturm, a* rn~dm#?‘ Pectimm 

### ll,~m¶thrempmst tn the mm3omrlt of 

### l mmlmtmnme **to** be **vnted ta**  **the nmedy**  

### hllnd, vrorldem mm inllmwmr

w*
l l ***** **The 8uWnt**  **mf** 

### l **mmlmtmnme drmm**  sbeY7 7w0rt6e ~071 b?iad peteon wfth a roe&onab7.0 8&dmtme0 ammpmfibla ritb de-’ 4emelr and RmmltRp **rlthin tbo**  lir~tmtionm~ and ptwimlmnr **at the**  uom8titoti6n oi Tesmn tm 81% @mm ptwidod, or any hmrm

## 8f**for** ~0 

## 7btorie0d. *


### l 

### #!Jmmtlom

II, with tempmst ta mid to dopemdemt 

## OhllQtmn

**pM13~dmm**

**88 tO7lorm;** 

l * 

### **. tar, ona unt o?l mditmnmm &iVal &mSl ~tdr mush (IO-d-t ekild rltb l Pmmpnmb70 albdmtalmm mmqlalIb70 mltb UC enay ml **brtth, within**  t7m **SMtat~ao** 

### SlMY prmrrmlmam 

### Of tba Genatitutlim or Turn* mm mrb **nw** 7wmridmc7, **4t** ry 78mrmmftmr bm 

### Qrmwldmdb

‘8soti4n ai mttb tempwt t4 Old 

### l #m mmmimtmnmo pwvld*m mm roSlowr

.* 

### . i be

mtmt 

### ofluhta eoHra ~whrnl7 ptm tia *

mum h *#Ma 

### perm a

wltll 8 r6oa4nmble mablmtmmoo **mo57Jellrlo** ***CA da;**  **ommay end**  **hmmlth, wltbln**  **t7m lim~tmtlonm**  

### ma ~wi.mimflm 

### er tbo 

### Coamtltutlmm or Tmsms **08 8~**  **tt68** pt4viaoa. bt **WY horwttor**  **80 pt4~fdOd**  **“** *In rim of the trregdnfc we rat06 like t.0 m7mit. **the fal7arlng**  qraartimnmr *(I)- Is **the Commtitutionml**  **Asssndnant, Art¶s?s**  **JIX, -Fiietlw,**  Aim, **vh3sh** mm8 **Mfb+md mm**  **Aqmmt 45,**  1.845, anIf-mnmotiag?

**‘ tel.**  **IF thi,**  **Canmtltationml Ammud11~4~,**  **brtlaYe 1x1,**  **6i3otian** IUrn, 3.8 **Wnoiht647** **mm3f-~mat~fn*r** **SO t)ret** * 

### any

part orthe l!a!emtimmmt

rnbi4h 8S77 toquito 

### a n 

### mnmhllnu l



### tmtuta t-4 rak0 it m?rmotlro? 

### 99**soaotablo** Xhmmmm I:* tmflor - pmga 4



### pllt8pph Or 

### #Ofi@? of'**thb mmWmdlm(J:**  fWNlw 6lm 18 mm tmllmrmt

**'?be Le~lm7mtaro**  mhmll hare **the pmwot**  **Isf gmrimrml**  lams to **prmv14mr mubjmmt**  to **limltmtlons** mrafl rmmtri0tlmatm horein asn8mlnmdmaw7 muehother llritmtlmnrr remtt~stlmmm and tm~l8tlatm 81 an3 It7 the Lo~imlmtaro b6 dOan om$oUlmat **for** mmdmtioo to, 666 iat 

### tbo plymast of momimtmmoo

. . 

### l m t0 the germOn* therein rrde b0mmtiOlmrl68~

**To mum13**  

### muob **1lritmtlmmm~** nmttimtl6mm mnd rogtOmtiona thm 49th T~e(yJmtmturm did **mmmat** Mmww Bl77 411 ocmtmlaln~ the prmrlmimam quotd 717 30ue It mill %m momm t7tom6 prmViml0nm lro 88 **pmrtinomt** mud 

### l pppllOmb70 to the pteoant mmJw6la6 Conat*- tution mm thy **worm** to tbo orlt;inml or m-06&d 0mo. Pho mwmdrrbntkmVln6 -60 87-t tb6 @moFmf 186 mm6 

### pO71S3 Ot' **the** Cou~tltutleu, red tbo Leglmlmtwm bmviat m6motod 

### l tmt6tom 

### l

pp7iOmbt6 

### l

llkm tm the mdm7 and **tbm** usndlng m6mmt~tuti6mm1 prm~lmimmm~ **all** O0mmt~tmti0uml rO@rcrratm **?Ot** 16gl810tStO 

### l btimu t8 **mk6** the **8mmuQ*mt** OffOOt~Vo QU prO-t13 ulbl0, 

### bmvo 7ma till3 wt.

tba m+ldmm ot leoa@ 6111 611 qemtd ia m let**tar, it**  t7my 

### baa **baa3 p60OOd**  **8rt4w the**  **6iMption or**  tbo ut8baatent, 

### um&mmbt4k7l3 romld bm all tbmt omnld ho bhmugbt 

### to bo neoom**ml ’**  **3 t0**  **848kO** th0 8D8Dgklt **6ttOOtiVO.** ft **6mu nka**  **m0 di?f~rmoo**  thmttbmy~ota **8?T68t@in th8**  **8kfot68-** tb6f 

### l wtb o m ppFUp Fimto **7ogSmlmtiro mm8atumrttm**  **mttltlrimmt tm**  **mmkm t?J6** **mamn4mmat of**  **tmmtirm mubd**  pro-t13 mmrtmbY6*



### me wea or Btmto 

### to brana by tbr faapnw Court 

### of 3ortb~ Cnrollnm, 116 8. Bi. lrNI 18 8 Ymmdnmum ano Oi **peeulimr, pertlnamb**  mo **7ripptoen$h nmeu4Iwnt;**  **¶t** Ml.7 be t6nnbo~, aautmiae~ *he 7an(rrrrgOe "The COngrmmmmdthe Wti-7 mtrtom mhm77 hmra eoasuttent pm60r t6 arf0ro6 tblm Art1016 b3 mpw~- pt%mts le~l6lmtlon~ * * *** ti3n the nort.Q'C*ra?tnm oplnloms

. l .. . T7m uo rda ~wueo rtmt perorí lro 8ot um0d her6 **in ttm**  m0mmm **ot** denoting or dsmi~mtfn~ **the m0urOO**  **nf** the 

### l **tmtmm ’**  **WWmF to**  **lm~ol8to mr**  **thm** muttjeW **of ptohihitiw~**  Wt **ma irMltartti,ng**  that **the** pore of Congremm ah877 net hs Uofo

### l **lrm.** Gotmm~amtth v. Wiakmwon, 236 Biamr- S66, 126 Ft. U. 273, 10 A. 1.. Bt. Ibog. ZB6 88Wdnaat 

### in a **gpmnt bf**  pwot **@** far l@ thu Cmm&Fmrm la oonwttwBd, hut not so mm to the lt6tOm= 

### Iho7

## had the pwor to Iegtslete on the ubjsst prior to t&e ammQmont ant? they ati have **saneurwut** $lower rlth **tha** Qomgreon to anDot 8ppropri8te logi818tllm ror **it8** cmP0weDmlt. Mats T* ltar- ' rioen, 184 %. C. 'POR, 114 **6. R.**  **63n. lf**  t&e 

### uotlun **sow** ia gtumtiw had boon maotad 

### the 487 l

### tter

the l lo ptlon

nf tR8 t*g?ateantb Amendmnt, 0lw1ou81f it Wowfd hero l3om ‘*pPr0pr9*t. 10glnt*tiw' **?q tni** * **8kta in**  816 ot it* entawemaat. xt 18 net 1.u @ booauw ale datute W88 8IWBUj 353

ulatono* at tbe the Of tile 8doptiara or the *uenanmt. 

## twtsa RtNtes 1. t8nm et al, 43 rhp. 

## ct. 141, 

## uv 1.. Ha*-. mmr08mt b0 rylng.dqreem ot rpfwpr~8tene8r **In** th* l*giml8- fioa ou twr ma?Jjoot,Mlt 8 l t8te 8ktM.O WI11 not be d*olawU lneper8tlre ula raid umlem* *beI1~ inapproprl~te, nr mleor it k ln eontWet with the **pawmeaat** 38wew
00 heretp the ln1ti*1 pwrloion of 

## Reotieu Rl8, 88 

### l **mea$edr tbat**  ***the** T2eg18Yatuw 8h8lY brve paep by ;Cenewl 18~8 to pwriUe*, ia 

## set at 817 tTl0 **ewroe of**  **letia?otlr~**

- it had 

## thatp8rer under the rsaeral pwer (rrtisle 

## iTLetltt%n~ the m9pawte **%waeRen ot**  **t.he Qmemaeat**  **udla** 8iTelt to diff'emmt r(CixLnOiO8r **mud** eonhnriag up, the' Cedeletare the exofudre pwer t0 make Iwo.

State TO BwmeI eupwp oIoar1~ aauouaoe8 this pda**blplcr rrwd**  **80 1** **ikeri8a our**  **own eourt8**  **b8ve held**  **to** that **rule ia**  **Xott8 et**  **81 v.**  **Ymm et**  **81.** lQ? **8- We**  **(0)** 91?(l) (writ wip;n)(~d **~ilkeut8Yd et**  **8Y 1.**  **TJm** 

### @tate **of ‘** **&x88,**

**. .**  **.**

Of Oeursebr the flmit8tim8r remtristlcnrs 8md w@r**tinnn cfmtmined**  **ln** the aumdaent ltrrrlf 8w ~pwme~ 8nd at not 

## in aqwime rmignnoredr guafitiea 0~ abmgod, but teem, plan t&a exJ.atlng st8tutory llalt8tlare, wotriotionr **end** w ulrtlwtt, sake e **8eneiblcr** rorkehle whole , rattleten t to **rut** If-t-wire the rdmir~rtration or the 188 aa a prrsaant~v stteeti+e and rorkshle 

### nanaete **to** the adadnlstratlto offlaarr of **the State.** 

*Q are net unnindfu? bf the rcl?aOf WnstW~tiUn ttI8,t **the** ra~f~lt~y **nC a**  **&atute ln**  **4etewlnett 01**  **of its**  **etfeotlre** date, but t.h*trule dear not nrlllbta mprinnt 0 0WtOfUtiW hew. , ..i' .'. :~.*'**At thSm**  **p+t it**  **1s WOrtb?**  **Ot nOtO**  **that &OtiOB8** 

**14,** 18 mad Pl et rroad EllY 611 qaWte& W ?8a **aPn~8lY spuk**  **not M9Yf**  

### MtR Mm tlamal

utho rit~r

bslt 8 pt t8 t&O



### thm UtSt b#!

UINtitrr

l 

### ftu bo pwTiuo 4 *. tb WRpOat t0Wl tb*t-7 he r(l-

***ii0 w?40**  **knowoth aot**  **tke** 

### rearm **of the**  **law En0wet.R**  **not tb8**  **1&W. ’**