Explore Search
 
 News & Events
											News & Events
															All NASA News
															Video Series on NASA+
															Podcasts
															Blogs
															Newsletters
															Social Media
															Media Resources
															Upcoming Launches & Landings
															Virtual Events
					Multimedia
											Multimedia
															NASA+
															Images
															NASA TV
															Sounds and Ringtones
															Interactives
															NASA Apps
															Podcasts
															e-Books
															STEM Multimedia
					NASA+


Search
 Suggested Searches Climate Change
								Artemis
								Expedition 64
								Mars perseverance
								SpaceX Crew-2
								International Space Station
							View All Topics A-Z


HomeMissionsHumans in SpaceEarth & ClimateThe Solar SystemThe UniverseScienceAeronauticsTechnologyLearning ResourcesAbout NASAEspañol			News & Events
			Multimedia
			NASA+
 Featured NASA/JAXA’s XRISM Mission Captures Unmatched Data With Just 36 Pixels3 min readNASA/JAXA’s XRISM Mission Captures Unmatched Data With Just 36 Pixelsarticle3 days ago This coronal mass ejection, captured by NASA’s Solar Dynamics Observatory, erupted on the Sun Aug. 31, 2012, traveling over 900 miles per second and sending radiation deep into space. Earth’s magnetic field shields it from radiation produced by solar events like this one, while Mars lacks that kind of shielding.6 min readNASA Scientists Gear Up for Solar Storms at Marsarticle4 days ago A person stands next to a small jet engine inside a soundproofed room.3 min readNASA Uses Small Engine to Enhance Sustainable Jet Researcharticle4 days ago
 Back
 Missions Search All NASA MissionsA to Z List of MissionsUpcoming Launches and LandingsSpaceships and RocketsCommunicating with MissionsArtemisJames Webb Space TelescopeHubble Space TelescopeInternational Space Station
 Humans in Space Why Go to SpaceAstronauts HomeCommercial SpaceDestinationsSpaceships and RocketsLiving in Space
 Earth & Climate Explore Earth ScienceClimate ChangeEarth, Our PlanetEarth Science in ActionEarth MultimediaEarth DataEarth Science Researchers
 The Solar System The SunMercuryVenusEarthThe MoonMarsJupiterSaturnUranusNeptunePluto & Dwarf PlanetsAsteroids, Comets & MeteorsThe Kuiper BeltThe Oort CloudSkywatching
 The Universe ExoplanetsThe Search for Life in the UniverseStarsGalaxiesBlack HolesThe Big BangDark Energy & Dark Matter
 Science Earth SciencePlanetary ScienceAstrophysics & Space ScienceThe Sun & HeliophysicsBiological & Physical SciencesLunar ScienceCitizen ScienceAstromaterialsAeronautics ResearchHuman Space Travel Research
 Aeronautics Science in the AirNASA AircraftFlight InnovationSupersonic FlightAir Traffic SolutionsGreen Aviation TechDrones & You
 Technology Technology Transfer & SpinoffsSpace Travel TechnologyTechnology Living in SpaceManufacturing and MaterialsRoboticsScience InstrumentsComputing
 Learning Resources For Kids and StudentsFor EducatorsFor Colleges and UniversitiesFor ProfessionalsScience for EveryoneRequests for Exhibits, Artifacts, or SpeakersSTEM Engagement at NASA
 About NASA NASA's ImpactsCenters and FacilitiesDirectoratesOrganizationsPeople of NASACareersInternshipsOur HistoryDoing Business with NASAGet InvolvedContact
 Español CienciaAeronáuticaCiencias TerrestresSistema SolarUniverso
 News & Events All NASA NewsVideo Series on NASA+PodcastsBlogsNewslettersSocial MediaMedia ResourcesUpcoming Launches & LandingsVirtual Events
 Multimedia NASA+ImagesNASA TVSounds and RingtonesInteractivesNASA AppsPodcastse-BooksSTEM Multimedia
 Highlights Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

	2 min read

		Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

		article

			6 hours ago A HI-C launches with trees in the background.

	4 min read

		Hi-C Rocket Experiment Achieves Never-Before-Seen Look at Solar Flares

		article

			23 hours ago NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

	4 min read

		NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

		article

			1 day ago
 Highlights 4 min read

		NASA Mission Strengthens 40-Year Friendship

		article

			1 day ago 4 min read

		NASA Selects Commercial Service Studies to Enable Mars Robotic Science

		article

			2 days ago NASA’s Boeing Crew Flight Test astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams prepare for their mission in the company’s Starliner spacecraft simulator at the agency’s Johnson Space Center in Houston.

	4 min read

		NASA’s Commercial Partners Deliver Cargo, Crew for Station Science

		article

			1 week ago
 Highlights NASA Is Helping Protect Tigers, Jaguars, and Elephants. Here’s How.

	5 min read

		NASA Is Helping Protect Tigers, Jaguars, and Elephants. Here’s How.

		article

			1 day ago Two Small NASA Satellites Will Measure Soil Moisture, Volcanic Gases

	4 min read

		Two Small NASA Satellites Will Measure Soil Moisture, Volcanic Gases

		article

			2 days ago Colorado River

	5 min read

		NASA-Led Study Provides New Global Accounting of Earth’s Rivers

		article

			7 days ago
 Highlights NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

	4 min read

		NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

		article

			1 day ago Orbits and Kepler’s Laws

	9 min read

		Orbits and Kepler’s Laws

		article

			1 day ago 4 min read

		NASA Selects Commercial Service Studies to Enable Mars Robotic Science

		article

			2 days ago
 Featured Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

	2 min read

		Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

		article

			6 hours ago Multiwavelength image of the Cloverleaf ORC

	5 min read

		X-ray Satellite XMM-Newton Sees ‘Space Clover’ in a New Light

		article

			1 day ago NASA/JAXA’s XRISM Mission Captures Unmatched Data With Just 36 Pixels

	3 min read

		NASA/JAXA’s XRISM Mission Captures Unmatched Data With Just 36 Pixels

		article

			3 days ago
 Highlights Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

	2 min read

		Hubble Hunts Visible Light Sources of X-Rays

		article

			6 hours ago A scientist examines a sample through a microscope while backlit by a red and white image on the screen behind her.

	3 min read

		Researchers Develop ‘Founding Document’ on Synthetic Cell Development

		article

			23 hours ago NASA Is Helping Protect Tigers, Jaguars, and Elephants. Here’s How.

	5 min read

		NASA Is Helping Protect Tigers, Jaguars, and Elephants. Here’s How.

		article

			1 day ago
 Highlights A person stands next to a small jet engine inside a soundproofed room.

	3 min read

		NASA Uses Small Engine to Enhance Sustainable Jet Research

		article

			4 days ago Inside of an aircraft cockpit is shown from the upside down perspective with two men in tan flight suits sitting inside. The side of one helmet, oxygen mask and visor is seen for one of the two men as well as controls inside the aircraft. The second helmet is seen from the back as the man sitting in the front is piloting the aircraft. You can see land below through the window of the aircraft.

	2 min read

		NASA Photographer Honored for Thrilling Inverted In-Flight Image

		article

			2 weeks ago 5 min read

		NASA’s Ingenuity Mars Helicopter Team Says Goodbye ... for Now

		article

			2 weeks ago
 Highlights 4 min read

		NASA Selects Commercial Service Studies to Enable Mars Robotic Science

		article

			2 days ago A stack of computer components on a white background - CGI

	4 min read

		Big Science Drives Wallops’ Upgrades for NASA Suborbital Missions

		article

			2 days ago An astronaut aboard a space shuttle points a video camera out the window.

	2 min read

		Tech Today: Stay Safe with Battery Testing for Space

		article

			3 days ago
 Featured NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

	4 min read

		NASA Selects Students for Europa Clipper Intern Program

		article

			1 day ago Julia Chavez

	5 min read

		NASA Grant Brings Students at Underserved Institutions to the Stars

		article

			1 week ago 2 min read

		Washington State High Schooler Wins 2024 NASA Student Art Contest

		article

			1 week ago
 Highlights A man talks at a podium in an aircraft hangar.

	5 min read

		NASA’s Commitment to Safety Starts with its Culture

		article

			3 days ago An astronaut aboard a space shuttle points a video camera out the window.

	2 min read

		Tech Today: Stay Safe with Battery Testing for Space

		article

			3 days ago Members of Team Miles with the CubeSat developed during the NASA Cube Quest Challenge. From left to right: Alex Wingeier, Don Smith, Wes Faler. Image Credit: Team Miles

	3 min read

		NASA Challenge Gives Space Thruster Commercial Boost

		article

			3 days ago
 Highlights 2021 Astronaut Candidates Stand in Recognition

	6 min read

		Diez maneras en que los estudiantes pueden prepararse para ser astronautas

		article

			1 month ago Astronaut Marcos Berrios

	4 min read

		Astronauta de la NASA Marcos Berríos

		article

			2 months ago image of an experiment facility installed in the exterior of the space station

	8 min read

		Resultados científicos revolucionarios en la estación espacial de 2023

		article

			2 months ago


7 min read Advances in Understanding COPV Structural Life


Meagan Chappell
 The Structures Technical Discipline Team (TDT) was involved in numerous investigations this past year, but composites, fracture mechanics, and pressure vessels dominate the list. All three of these specialties are important to composite overwrapped pressure vessels (COPV). One of the TDT’s most important findings this year was the exposure of an inherent vulnerability that underpredicts structural life, driven by current specifications and testing standards for COPVs. This NESC work and its recommendations will significantly improve safety and mission success for all current and future COPV operations throughout the aerospace community. Dr. David Dawicki employs digital image correlation to evaluate strain in metallic coupons.
 **Damage Tolerance Analysis Standard Can Be Unconservative for COPVs** COPVs consist of a metallic liner that contains the fluid or gas and a composite overwrap that provides strength (Figure 1). The operational pressure cycles for a spaceflight COPV generally starts with an initial overpressure, called an autofrettage cycle, that yields the metallic liner, while the stronger composite overwrap remains elastic. Liner yielding during autofrettage results in a small amount of liner growth, resulting in liner compression when the COPV is depressurized after autofrettage. The subsequent operational cycles can be either elastic (elastically responding COPV) or elastic-plastic (plastically responding COPV). Figure 1.Illustration of COPV major components.  The damage tolerance life evaluation of spaceflight COPVs is governed by the ANSI/AIAA-S-081B, Space Systems–Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels. This standard provides the baseline requirements for damage tolerance analyses (DTA) of COPVs with elastically responding liners. The standard allows the DTA to consider the influence of the elastic-plastic autofrettage cycle independently of the elastically responding cycles. The elastically responding cycles are permitted to be analyzed using linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) tools like the NASGRO crack-growth analysis software. The standard states that the DTA must not consider any beneficial influences of the autofrettage cycle on the subsequent elastically responding cycles but does not consider the possibility of detrimental influences of the autofrettage cycle. In the study, Unconservatism of Linear-Elastic Fracture Mechanics Analysis Post Autofrettage (NASA/TM-20230013348), an NESC team conducted a combined experimental and analytical investigation into the influence of the autofrettage cycle on subsequent elastic cycles. Tests were conducted on coupons with part-through surface cracks that were subjected to cyclic loading that was representative of the operational cycles of a COPV liner. Half of the tests were conducted with the full loading history (including the autofrettage cycle) and the other half were identical except that the autofrettage cycle was omitted. Cracks in the tests with the autofrettage cycle grew faster than cracks in the identical tests that excluded the autofrettage cycle, as shown by the fracture surfaces in the photomicrographs (Figure 2). The distance between the mark left by the autofrettage cycle and the ductile fracture region was the amount of crack growth (Δa=0.0077 inch) due to the LEFM cycles. Crack growth due to the LEFM cycles in the LEFM-only test was Δa=0.0022 inch, more than three times slower than that in the identical autofrettage plus LEFM test. Figure 2. Fracture surfaces from two identical tests showing crack growth (Δa), with and without an initial autofrettage cycle.  A validated finite element analysis and experimental measurements were used to evaluate the influence of the autofrettage cycle. The elastic-plastic autofrettage cycle was found to create a large region of plastic deformation ahead of the crack and blunted the crack tip. Previous fracture mechanics tests and analytical studies in the literature examined elastic overloads and found that plastic deformation ahead of the crack developed residual stresses that closed the crack surfaces, reducing the subsequent crack growth rate. However, the crack blunting allowed the crack to remain open for the entire loading, as illustrated by the finite element simulations of the crack surfaces at peak and minimum stress (Figure 3). The differences between the tests with and without the autofrettage cycle that were observed experimentally and simulated with a validated finite element analysis indicate that the damage tolerance analysis approach allowed by the standard can be unconservative. The NESC proposed an alternative damage tolerance analysis approach and recommended that the AIAA Aerospace Pressure Vessel Committee on standards update the ANSI/AIAA S-081B standard to address COPV liners with compressive stresses following the peak autofrettage stress. Figure 3. Abaqus finite element analysis of crack growth with and without an autofrettage cycle. Y-axis indicates crack opening displacement and x-axis indicates crack length.  **A Brief Introduction to Damage Tolerance for COPVs** ANSI/AIAA S-081B standard, Space Systems–Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels, is a compilation of accepted practices for COPVs used in space applications developed as a collaboration of industry, government, and universities. The standard covers many aspects of COPVs including damage tolerance life analyses that are used for flight qualification overseen by fracture control boards. The standard for damage tolerance requires that the COPV “...survive four operational lifetimes with the largest crack in the metallic liner that can be missed by a nondestructive evaluation (NDE) subjected to bounding stresses representative of what the COPV experiences in its life (manufacturing, integration, operational including thermal and residual).” The operational life of a COPV liner typically includes an initial elastic-plastic cycle (autofrettage or proof) followed by other cycles that may be elastic (elastically responding liners) or elastic-plastic (plastically responding liners). A representative load spectrum is shown at right. During autofrettage, the COPV is pressurized to at least proof pressure to compress the liner inner surface, making it less susceptible to operational stresses. COPVs with elastically responding liners may be damage-tolerance qualified using LEFM analysis tools, but plastically responding liners must be damage-tolerance qualified by testing. Guidance on evaluating the appropriateness of LEFM tools for COPV damage tolerance was provided in NESC Technical Bulletin No. 21-04, Evaluating Appropriateness of LEFM Tools for COPV and Metal Pressure Vessel Damage Tolerance Life Verification Tolerance Life Verification and NASA/TM-2020-5006765/Volumes 1/2. A COPV consists of a metallic liner with an exterior composite wrap. The composite provides strength, and the liner contains the compressed fluid or gas.
 Results of a failure test. COPVs contain high pressure gases or fluids that can have tremendous explosive energy.
 **Future of the Structures Discipline** As the Agency moves more toward forming strategic industry partnerships with commercial contracts for new programs, the Structures TDT has highlighted the need for proper focus on appropriate requirements as the Team’s strategic vector. Although NASA Standards are often provided for reference, their prescriptive nature is not necessarily appropriate for use with commercial contracts. Industry partners and/or NASA team members create alternative standards, unique for each program, but there is inconsistency across different programs with respect to detailed requirements in these standards. Emerging technologies such as soft goods, large-scale deployable structures, inflatables, probabilistic analysis techniques, and additive manufactured hardware all drive unique requirements. The TDT identified the need for a tailoring guide, tied to mission priorities and risk postures, to assist with insight/oversight strategies for NASA programs. Using industry partners also means less NASA-owned hardware, which can lead to a loss of institutional knowledge. Representative loading spectrum for an elastically responding COPV liner with an initial elastic-plastic cycle.
 Its imperative that Engineering Directorates at each center proactively look for in-house projects so the next generation of engineers have opportunities for hands-on experience developing, designing, and testing (DDT) flight hardware. This experience is the foundation necessary for NASA engineers to guide the commercial partners through their own DDT processes and to be able to provide appropriate verification and validation of NASA requirements. Structures TDT members form a diverse team crossing all centers and programs, facilitating good collaboration on requirement interpretation, which ultimately ensures safety of NASA crew and mission success of operations in these new commercial programs. Computed tomography scan of a metallic liner detecting a part-through crack.


The National Aeronautics and Space Administration NASA explores the unknown in air and space, innovates for the benefit of humanity, and inspires the world through discovery. About NASA's Mission Join Us
 Home
								News & Events
								Multimedia
								NASA+
								Missions
								Humans in Space
								Earth & Climate
								The Solar System
								The Universe
								Science
								Aeronautics
								Technology
								Learning Resources
								About NASA
								NASA en Español
 Follow NASA
 More NASA Social Accounts
                            NASA Newsletters
 Sitemap
						For Media
						Privacy Policy
						FOIA
						No FEAR Act
						Office of the IG
						Budget & Annual Reports
						Agency Financial Reports
						Contact NASA
						Accessibility
 Page Last Updated:
								Apr 04, 2024
							Page Editor:
								Meagan Chappell
												Responsible NASA Official:
							Abigail Bowman