ex4-2.htm


    EXHIBIT 4.2


    


    UST Seq. No.
290


    

      WARRANT
TO PURCHASE COMMON STOCK

       

      THE
SECURITIES REPRESENTED BY THIS INSTRUMENT HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE
SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, OR THE SECURITIES LAWS OF ANY STATE AND MAY
NOT BE TRANSFERRED, SOLD OR OTHERWISE DISPOSED OF EXCEPT WHILE A REGISTRATION
STATEMENT RELATING THERETO IS IN EFFECT UNDER SUCH ACT AND APPLICABLE STATE
SECURITIES LAWS OR PURSUANT TO AN EXEMPTION FROM REGISTRATION UNDER SUCH ACT OR
SUCH LAWS. THIS INSTRUMENT IS ISSUED SUBJECT TO THE RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFER AND
OTHER PROVISIONS OF A SECURITIES PURCHASE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE ISSUER OF THESE
SECURITIES AND THE INVESTOR REFERRED TO THEREIN, A COPY OF WHICH IS ON FILE WITH
THE ISSUER. THE SECURITIES REPRESENTED BY THIS INSTRUMENT MAY NOT BE SOLD OR
OTHERWISE TRANSFERRED EXCEPT IN COMPLIANCE WITH SAID AGREEMENT. ANY SALE OR
OTHER TRANSFER NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH SAID AGREEMENT WILL BE VOID.

       

      


      


      WARRANT

      to
purchase

      625,135

      Shares
of Common Stock

       

      of MutualFirst Financial, Inc.

       

      Issue
Date: December 23, 2008

       

      


      1.           Definitions.  Unless
the context otherwise requires, when used herein the following terms shall have
the meanings indicated.

       

      “Affiliate”
has the meaning ascribed to it in the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Appraisal Procedure” means a
procedure whereby two independent appraisers, one chosen by the Company and one
by the Original Warrantholder, shall mutually agree upon the determinations then
the subject of appraisal. Each party shall deliver a notice to the other
appointing its appraiser within 15 days after the Appraisal Procedure is
invoked. If within 30 days after appointment of the two appraisers they are
unable to agree upon the amount in question, a third independent appraiser shall
be chosen within 10 days thereafter by the mutual consent of such first two
appraisers.  The decision of the third appraiser so appointed and
chosen shall be given within 30 days after the selection of such third
appraiser. If three appraisers shall be appointed and the determination of one
appraiser is disparate from the middle determination by more than twice the
amount by which the other determination is disparate from the middle
determination, then the determination of such appraiser shall be excluded, the
remaining two determinations shall be averaged and such average shall be binding
and conclusive upon the

       


      
        
           


        

        
           


           


        

        
           


        

      


      Company
and the Original Warrantholder; otherwise, the average of all three
determinations shall be binding upon the Company and the Original Warrantholder.
The costs of conducting any Appraisal Procedure shall be borne by the
Company.

       

      “Board of Directors” means
the board of directors of the Company, including any duly authorized committee
thereof.

       

      “Business Combination” means
a merger, consolidation, statutory share exchange or similar transaction that
requires the approval of the Company’s stockholders.

       

      “Business day” means any day
except Saturday, Sunday and any day on which banking institutions in the State
of New York generally are authorized or required by law or other governmental
actions to close.

       

      “Capital Stock” means (A)
with respect to any Person that is a corporation or company, any and all shares,
interests, participations or other equivalents (however designated) of capital
or capital stock of such Person and (B) with respect to any Person that is not a
corporation or company, any and all partnership or other equity interests of
such Person.

       

      “Charter” means, with respect
to any Person, its certificate or articles of incorporation, articles of
association, or similar organizational document.

       

      “Common Stock” has the
meaning ascribed to it in the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Company” means the Person
whose name, corporate or other organizational form and jurisdiction of
organization is set forth in Item 1 of Schedule A hereto.

       

      “Conversion” has the meaning
set forth in Section 13(B).

       

      “Convertible securities” has
the meaning set forth in Section 13(B).

       

      “CPP” has the meaning
ascribed to it in the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Exchange Act” means the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, or any successor statute, and the
rules and regulations promulgated thereunder.

       

      “Exercise Price” means the
amount set forth in Item 2 of Schedule A hereto.

       

      “Expiration Time” has the
meaning set forth in Section 3.

       

      “Fair Market Value” means,
with respect to any security or other property, the fair market value of such
security or other property as determined by the Board of Directors, acting in
good faith or, with respect to Section 14, as determined by the Original
Warrantholder acting in good faith. For so long as the Original Warrantholder
holds this Warrant or any portion thereof, it may object in writing to the Board
of Director’s calculation of fair market value within 10 days of receipt of
written notice thereof. If the Original Warrantholder and the Company are unable
to agree on fair market value during the 10-day period following the delivery of
the Original Warrantholder’s objection, the Appraisal Procedure may be invoked
by either party to

       


      
        
           


        

        
          2

           


        

        
           


        

      


      determine
Fair Market Value by delivering written notification thereof not later than the
30th day after delivery of the Original Warrantholder’s objection.

       

      “Governmental Entities” has
the meaning ascribed to it in the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Initial Number” has the
meaning set forth in Section 13(B).

       

      “Issue Date” means the date
set forth in Item 3 of Schedule A hereto.

       

      “Market Price” means, with
respect to a particular security, on any given day, the last reported sale price
regular way or, in case no such reported sale takes place on such day, the
average of the last closing bid and ask prices regular way, in either case on
the principal national securities exchange on which the applicable securities
are listed or admitted to trading, or if not listed or admitted to trading on
any national securities exchange, the average of the closing bid and ask prices
as furnished by two members of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.
selected from time to time by the Company for that purpose. “Market Price” shall
be determined without reference to after hours or extended hours trading. If
such security is not listed and traded in a manner that the quotations referred
to above are available for the period required hereunder, the Market Price per
share of Common Stock shall be deemed to be (i) in the event that any portion of
the Warrant is held by the Original Warrantholder, the fair market value per
share of such security as determined in good faith by the Original Warrantholder
or (ii) in all other circumstances, the fair market value per share of such
security as determined in good faith by the Board of Directors in reliance on an
opinion of a nationally recognized independent investment banking corporation
retained by the Company for this purpose and certified in a resolution to the
Warrantholder.  For the purposes of determining the Market Price of
the Common Stock on the "trading day" preceding, on or following the occurrence
of an event, (i) that trading day shall be deemed to commence immediately after
the regular scheduled closing time of trading on the New York Stock Exchange or,
if trading is closed at an earlier time, such earlier time and (ii) that trading
day shall end at the next regular scheduled closing time, or if trading is
closed at an earlier time, such earlier time (for the avoidance of doubt, and as
an example, if the Market Price is to be determined as of the last trading day
preceding a specified event and the closing time of trading on a particular day
is 4:00 p.m. and the specified event occurs at 5:00 p.m. on that day, the Market
Price would be determined by reference to such 4:00 p.m. closing
price).

       

      “Ordinary Cash Dividends”
means a regular quarterly cash dividend on shares of Common Stock out of
surplus or net profits legally available therefor (determined in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles in effect from time to time), provided that Ordinary Cash
Dividends shall not include any cash dividends paid subsequent to the Issue Date
to the extent the aggregate per share dividends paid on the outstanding Common
Stock in any quarter exceed the amount set forth in Item 4 of Schedule A hereto,
as adjusted for any stock split, stock dividend, reverse stock split,
reclassification or similar transaction.

       

      “Original Warrantholder”
means the United States Department of the Treasury. Any actions specified
to be taken by the Original Warrantholder hereunder may only be taken by such
Person and not by any other Warrantholder.

       


      
        
           


        

        
          3

           


        

        
           


        

      


      “Permitted Transactions” has
the meaning set forth in Section 13(B).

       

      “Person” has the meaning
given to it in Section 3(a)(9) of the Exchange Act and as used in Sections
13(d)(3) and 14(d)(2) of the Exchange Act.

       

      “Per Share Fair Market Value”
has the meaning set forth in Section 13(C).

       

      “Preferred Shares” means the
perpetual preferred stock issued to the Original Warrantholder on the Issue Date
pursuant to the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Pro Rata Repurchases” means
any purchase of shares of Common Stock by the Company or any Affiliate thereof
pursuant to (A) any tender offer or exchange offer subject to Section 13(e) or
14(e) of the Exchange Act or Regulation 14E promulgated thereunder or (B) any
other offer available to substantially all holders of Common Stock, in the case
of both (A) or (B), whether for cash, shares of Capital Stock of the Company,
other securities of the Company, evidences of indebtedness of the Company or any
other Person or any other property (including, without limitation, shares of
Capital Stock, other securities or evidences of indebtedness of a subsidiary),
or any combination thereof, effected while this Warrant is outstanding. The
“Effective Date” of a
Pro Rata Repurchase shall mean the date of acceptance of shares for purchase or
exchange by the Company under any tender or exchange offer which is a Pro Rata
Repurchase or the date of purchase with respect to any Pro Rata Repurchase that
is not a tender or exchange offer.

       

      “Purchase Agreement” means
the Securities Purchase Agreement – Standard Terms incorporated into the Letter
Agreement, dated as of the date set forth in Item 5 of Schedule A hereto, as
amended from time to time, between the Company and the United States Department
of the Treasury (the “Letter
Agreement”), including all annexes and schedules thereto.

       

      “Qualified Equity Offering”
has the meaning ascribed to it in the Purchase Agreement.

       

      “Regulatory Approvals” with
respect to the Warrantholder, means, to the extent applicable and required to
permit the Warrantholder to exercise this Warrant for shares of Common Stock and
to own such Common Stock without the Warrantholder being in violation of
applicable law, rule or regulation, the receipt of any necessary approvals and
authorizations of, filings and registrations with, notifications to, or
expiration or termination of any applicable waiting period under, the
Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976, as amended, and the rules
and regulations thereunder.

       

      “SEC” means the U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission.

       

      “Securities Act” means the
Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or any successor statute, and the rules and
regulations promulgated thereunder.

       

      “Shares” has the meaning set
forth in Section 2.

       

      “trading day” means (A) if
the shares of Common Stock are not traded on any national or regional securities
exchange or association or over-the-counter market, a business day or (B) if the
shares of Common Stock are traded on any national or regional securities
exchange or

       


      
        
           


        

        
          4

           


        

        
           


        

      


      association
or over-the-counter market, a business day on which such relevant exchange or
quotation system is scheduled to be open for business and on which the shares of
Common Stock (i) are not suspended from trading on any national or regional
securities exchange or association or over-the-counter market for any period or
periods aggregating one half hour or longer; and (ii) have traded at least once
on the national or regional securities exchange or association or
over-the-counter market that is the primary market for the trading of the shares
of Common Stock.

       

      “U.S. GAAP” means United
States generally accepted accounting principles.

       

      “Warrantholder” has the
meaning set forth in Section 2.

       

      “Warrant” means this Warrant,
issued pursuant to the Purchase Agreement.

       

      2.           Number of Shares; Exercise
Price.  This certifies that, for value received, the United
States Department of the Treasury or its permitted assigns (the “Warrantholder”) is entitled,
upon the terms and subject to the conditions hereinafter set forth, to acquire
from the Company, in whole or in part, after the receipt of all applicable
Regulatory Approvals, if any, up to an aggregate of the number of fully paid and
nonassessable shares of Common Stock set forth in Item 6 of Schedule A hereto,
at a purchase price per share of Common Stock equal to the Exercise
Price.  The number of shares of Common Stock (the “Shares”) and the Exercise
Price are subject to adjustment as provided herein, and all references to
“Common Stock,” “Shares” and “Exercise Price” herein shall be deemed to include
any such adjustment or series of adjustments.

       

      3.           Exercise of Warrant;
Term.  Subject to Section 2, to the extent permitted by
applicable laws and regulations, the right to purchase the Shares represented by
this Warrant is exercisable, in whole or in part by the Warrantholder, at any
time or from time to time after the execution and delivery of this Warrant by
the Company on the date hereof, but in no event later than 5:00 p.m., New York
City time on the tenth anniversary of the Issue Date (the “Expiration Time”), by (A)
the surrender of this Warrant and Notice of Exercise annexed hereto, duly
completed and executed on behalf of the Warrantholder, at the principal
executive office of the Company located at the address set forth in Item 7 of
Schedule A hereto (or such other office or agency of the Company in the United
States as it may designate by notice in writing to the Warrantholder at the
address of the Warrantholder appearing on the books of the Company), and (B)
payment of the Exercise Price for the Shares thereby purchased:

       

      (i)           by
having the Company withhold, from the shares of Common Stock that would
otherwise be delivered to the Warrantholder upon such exercise, shares of Common
stock issuable upon exercise of the Warrant equal in value to the aggregate
Exercise Price as to which this Warrant is so exercised based on the Market
Price of the Common Stock on the trading day on which this Warrant is exercised
and the Notice of Exercise is delivered to the Company pursuant to this Section
3, or

       

      (ii)           with
the consent of both the Company and the Warrantholder, by tendering in cash, by
certified or cashier’s check payable to the order of the Company, or by wire
transfer of immediately available funds to an account designated by the
Company.

       


      
        
           


        

        
          5

           


        

        
           


        

      


      If the
Warrantholder does not exercise this Warrant in its entirety, the Warrantholder
will be entitled to receive from the Company within a reasonable time, and in
any event not exceeding three business days, a new warrant in substantially
identical form for the purchase of that number of Shares equal to the difference
between the number of Shares subject to this Warrant and the number of Shares as
to which this Warrant is so exercised. Notwithstanding anything in this Warrant
to the contrary, the Warrantholder hereby acknowledges and agrees that its
exercise of this Warrant for Shares is subject to the condition that the
Warrantholder will have first received any applicable Regulatory
Approvals.

       

      4.           Issuance of Shares;
Authorization; Listing.  Certificates for Shares issued upon
exercise of this Warrant will be issued in such name or names as the
Warrantholder may designate and will be delivered to such named Person or
Persons within a reasonable time, not to exceed three business days after the
date on which this Warrant has been duly exercised in accordance with the terms
of this Warrant. The Company hereby represents and warrants that any Shares
issued upon the exercise of this Warrant in accordance with the provisions of
Section 3 will be duly and validly authorized and issued, fully paid and
nonassessable and free from all taxes, liens and charges (other than liens or
charges created by the Warrantholder, income and franchise taxes incurred in
connection with the exercise of the Warrant or taxes in respect of any transfer
occurring contemporaneously therewith). The Company agrees that the Shares so
issued will be deemed to have been issued to the Warrantholder as of the close
of business on the date on which this Warrant and payment of the Exercise Price
are delivered to the Company in accordance with the terms of this Warrant,
notwithstanding that the stock transfer books of the Company may then be closed
or certificates representing such Shares may not be actually delivered on such
date. The Company will at all times reserve and keep available, out of its
authorized but unissued Common Stock, solely for the purpose of providing for
the exercise of this Warrant, the aggregate number of shares of Common Stock
then issuable upon exercise of this Warrant at any time. The Company will (A)
procure, at its sole expense, the listing of the Shares issuable upon exercise
of this Warrant at any time, subject to issuance or notice of issuance, on all
principal stock exchanges on which the Common Stock is then listed or traded and
(B) maintain such listings of such Shares at all times after issuance. The
Company will use reasonable best efforts to ensure that the Shares may be issued
without violation of any applicable law or regulation or of any requirement of
any securities exchange on which the Shares are listed or traded.

       

      5.           No Fractional Shares or
Scrip.  No fractional Shares or scrip representing fractional
Shares shall be issued upon any exercise of this Warrant. In lieu of any
fractional Share to which the Warrantholder would otherwise be entitled, the
Warrantholder shall be entitled to receive a cash payment equal to the Market
Price of the Common Stock on the last trading day preceding the date of exercise
less the pro-rated Exercise Price for such fractional share.

       

      6.           No Rights as Stockholders;
Transfer Books.  This Warrant does not entitle the
Warrantholder to any voting rights or other rights as a stockholder of the
Company prior to the date of exercise hereof. The Company will at no time close
its transfer books against transfer of this Warrant in any manner which
interferes with the timely exercise of this Warrant.

       

       

      
        
          
          

        

        
          6

          
          

        

        
          
          

        

      

       

       

      7.   Charges, Taxes and
Expenses.  Issuance of certificates for Shares to the
Warrantholder upon the exercise of this Warrant shall be made without charge to
the Warrantholder for any issue or transfer tax or other incidental expense in
respect of the issuance of such certificates, all of which taxes and expenses
shall be paid by the Company.

       

      8.           Transfer/Assignment.

       

      (A)           Subject
to compliance with clause (B) of this Section 8, this Warrant and all rights
hereunder are transferable, in whole or in part, upon the books of the Company
by the registered holder hereof in person or by duly authorized attorney, and a
new warrant shall be made and delivered by the Company, of the same tenor and
date as this Warrant but registered in the name of one or more transferees, upon
surrender of this Warrant, duly endorsed, to the office or agency of the Company
described in Section 3. All expenses (other than stock transfer taxes) and other
charges payable in connection with the preparation, execution and delivery of
the new warrants pursuant to this Section 8 shall be paid by the
Company.

       

      (B)           The
transfer of the Warrant and the Shares issued upon exercise of the Warrant are
subject to the restrictions set forth in Section 4.4 of the Purchase Agreement.
If and for so long as required by the Purchase Agreement, this Warrant shall
contain the legends as set forth in Sections 4.2(a) and 4.2(b) of the Purchase
Agreement.

       

      9.           Exchange and Registry of
Warrant.  This Warrant is exchangeable, upon the surrender
hereof by the Warrantholder to the Company, for a new warrant or warrants of
like tenor and representing the right to purchase the same aggregate number of
Shares. The Company shall maintain a registry showing the name and address of
the Warrantholder as the registered holder of this Warrant. This Warrant may be
surrendered for exchange or exercise in accordance with its terms, at the office
of the Company, and the Company shall be entitled to rely in all respects, prior
to written notice to the contrary, upon such registry.

       

      10.           Loss, Theft, Destruction or
Mutilation of Warrant.  Upon receipt by the Company of evidence
reasonably satisfactory to it of the loss, theft, destruction or mutilation of
this Warrant, and in the case of any such loss, theft or destruction, upon
receipt of a bond, indemnity or security reasonably satisfactory to the Company,
or, in the case of any such mutilation, upon surrender and cancellation of this
Warrant, the Company shall make and deliver, in lieu of such lost, stolen,
destroyed or mutilated Warrant, a new Warrant of like tenor and representing the
right to purchase the same aggregate number of Shares as provided for in such
lost, stolen, destroyed or mutilated Warrant.

       

      11.           Saturdays, Sundays,
Holidays, etc.  If the last or appointed day for the taking of
any action or the expiration of any right required or granted herein shall not
be a business day, then such action may be taken or such right may be exercised
on the next succeeding day that is a business day.

       

      12.           Rule 144
Information.  The Company covenants that it will use its
reasonable best efforts to timely file all reports and other documents required
to be filed by it under the Securities Act and the Exchange Act and the rules
and regulations promulgated by the SEC thereunder (or, if the Company is not
required to file such reports, it will, upon the request of any

       


      
        
           


        

        
          7

           


        

        
           


        

      


      Warrantholder,
make publicly available such information as necessary to permit sales pursuant
to Rule 144 under the Securities Act), and it will use reasonable best efforts
to take such further action as any Warrantholder may reasonably request, in each
case to the extent required from time to time to enable such holder to, if
permitted by the terms of this Warrant and the Purchase Agreement, sell this
Warrant without registration under the Securities Act within the limitation of
the exemptions provided by (A) Rule 144 under the Securities Act, as such rule
may be amended from time to time, or (B) any successor rule or regulation
hereafter adopted by the SEC. Upon the written request of any Warrantholder, the
Company will deliver to such Warrantholder a written statement that it has
complied with such requirements.

       

      13.           Adjustments and Other
Rights.  The Exercise Price and the number of Shares issuable
upon exercise of this Warrant shall be subject to adjustment from time to time
as follows; provided,
that if more than one subsection of this Section 13 is applicable to a
single event, the subsection shall be applied that produces the largest
adjustment and no single event shall cause an adjustment under more than one
subsection of this Section 13 so as to result in duplication:

       

      (A)           Stock Splits, Subdivisions,
Reclassifications or Combinations.  If the Company shall (i)
declare and pay a dividend or make a distribution on its Common Stock in shares
of Common Stock, (ii) subdivide or reclassify the outstanding shares of Common
Stock into a greater number of shares, or (iii) combine or reclassify the
outstanding shares of Common Stock into a smaller number of shares, the number
of Shares issuable upon exercise of this Warrant at the time of the record date
for such dividend or distribution or the effective date of such subdivision,
combination or reclassification shall be proportionately adjusted so that the
Warrantholder after such date shall be entitled to purchase the number of shares
of Common Stock which such holder would have owned or been entitled to receive
in respect of the shares of Common Stock subject to this Warrant after such date
had this Warrant been exercised immediately prior to such date. In such event,
the Exercise Price in effect at the time of the record date for such dividend or
distribution or the effective date of such subdivision, combination or
reclassification shall be adjusted to the number obtained by dividing (x) the
product of (1) the number of Shares issuable upon the exercise of this Warrant
before such adjustment and (2) the Exercise Price in effect immediately prior to
the record or effective date, as the case may be, for the dividend,
distribution, subdivision, combination or reclassification giving rise to this
adjustment by (y) the new number of Shares issuable upon exercise of the Warrant
determined pursuant to the immediately preceding sentence.

       

      (B)           Certain Issuances of Common
Shares or Convertible Securities.  Until the earlier of (i) the
date on which the Original Warrantholder no longer holds this Warrant or any
portion thereof and (ii) the third anniversary of the Issue Date, if the Company
shall issue shares of Common Stock (or rights or warrants or other securities
exercisable or convertible into or exchangeable (collectively, a “conversion”)
for shares of Common Stock) (collectively, “convertible
securities”) (other than in Permitted Transactions (as defined below) or
a transaction to which subsection (A) of this Section 13 is applicable) without
consideration or at a consideration per share (or having a conversion price per
share) that is less than 90% of the Market Price on the last trading day
preceding the date of the agreement on pricing such shares (or such convertible
securities) then, in such event:

       

       

      
        
          
          

        

        
          8

          
          

        

        
          
          

        

      

       

       

      (A)   the
number of Shares issuable upon the exercise of this Warrant immediately prior to
the date of the agreement on pricing of such shares (or of such convertible
securities) (the “Initial Number”)
shall be increased to the number obtained by multiplying the Initial
Number by a fraction (A) the numerator of which shall be the sum of (x) the
number of shares of Common Stock of the Company outstanding on such date and (y)
the number of additional shares of Common Stock issued (or into which
convertible securities may be exercised or convert) and (B) the denominator of
which shall be the sum of (I) the number of shares of Common Stock outstanding
on such date and (II) the number of shares of Common Stock which the aggregate
consideration receivable by the Company for the total number of shares of Common
Stock so issued (or into which convertible securities may be exercised or
convert) would purchase at the Market Price on the last trading day preceding
the date of the agreement on pricing such shares (or such convertible
securities); and

       

      (B)           the
Exercise Price payable upon exercise of the Warrant shall be adjusted by
multiplying such Exercise Price in effect immediately prior to the date of the
agreement on pricing of such shares (or of such convertible securities) by a
fraction, the numerator of which shall be the number of shares of Common Stock
issuable upon exercise of this Warrant prior to such date and the denominator of
which shall be the number of shares of Common Stock issuable upon exercise of
this Warrant immediately after the adjustment described in clause (A)
above.

       

      For
purposes of the foregoing, the aggregate consideration receivable by the Company
in connection with the issuance of such shares of Common Stock or convertible
securities shall be deemed to be equal to the sum of the net offering price
(including the Fair Market Value of any non-cash consideration and after
deduction of any related expenses payable to third parties) of all such
securities plus the minimum aggregate amount, if any, payable upon exercise or
conversion of any such convertible securities into shares of Common Stock; and
“Permitted
Transactions” shall mean issuances (i) as consideration for or to fund
the acquisition of businesses and/or related assets, (ii) in connection with
employee benefit plans and compensation related arrangements in the ordinary
course and consistent with past practice approved by the Board of Directors,
(iii) in connection with a public or broadly marketed offering and sale of
Common Stock or convertible securities for cash conducted by the Company or its
affiliates pursuant to registration under the Securities Act or Rule 144A
thereunder on a basis consistent with capital raising transactions by comparable
financial institutions and (iv) in connection with the exercise of preemptive
rights on terms existing as of the Issue Date. Any adjustment made pursuant to
this Section 13(B) shall become effective immediately upon the date of such
issuance.

       

      (C)           Other
Distributions.  In case the Company shall fix a record date for
the making of a distribution to all holders of shares of its Common Stock of
securities, evidences of indebtedness, assets, cash, rights or warrants
(excluding Ordinary Cash Dividends, dividends of its Common Stock and other
dividends or distributions referred to in Section 13(A)), in each such case, the
Exercise Price in effect prior to such record date shall be reduced immediately
thereafter to the price determined by multiplying the Exercise Price in effect
immediately prior to the reduction by the quotient of (x) the Market Price of
the Common Stock on the last trading day preceding the first date on which the
Common Stock trades regular way on the principal

       


      
        
           


        

        
          9

           


        

        
           


        

      


      national
securities exchange on which the Common Stock is listed or admitted to trading
without the right to receive such distribution, minus the amount of cash and/or
the Fair Market Value of the securities, evidences of indebtedness, assets,
rights or warrants to be so distributed in respect of one share of Common Stock
(such amount and/or Fair Market Value, the “Per Share Fair Market Value”)
divided by (y) such Market Price on such date specified in clause (x); such
adjustment shall be made successively whenever such a record date is
fixed.  In such event, the number of Shares issuable upon the exercise
of this Warrant shall be increased to the number obtained by dividing (x) the
product of (1) the number of Shares issuable upon the exercise of this Warrant
before such adjustment, and (2) the Exercise Price in effect immediately prior
to the distribution giving rise to this adjustment by (y) the new Exercise Price
determined in accordance with the immediately preceding sentence. In the case of
adjustment for a cash dividend that is, or is coincident with, a regular
quarterly cash dividend, the Per Share Fair Market Value would be reduced by the
per share amount of the portion of the cash dividend that would constitute an
Ordinary Cash Dividend. In the event that such distribution is not so made, the
Exercise Price and the number of Shares issuable upon exercise of this Warrant
then in effect shall be readjusted, effective as of the date when the Board of
Directors determines not to distribute such shares, evidences of indebtedness,
assets, rights, cash or warrants, as the case may be, to the Exercise Price that
would then be in effect and the number of Shares that would then be issuable
upon exercise of this Warrant if such record date had not been
fixed.

       

      (D)           Certain Repurchases of
Common Stock.  In case the Company effects a Pro Rata
Repurchase of Common Stock, then the Exercise Price shall be reduced to the
price determined by multiplying the Exercise Price in effect immediately prior
to the Effective Date of such Pro Rata Repurchase by a fraction of which the
numerator shall be (i) the product of (x) the number of shares of Common Stock
outstanding immediately before such Pro Rata Repurchase and (y) the Market Price
of a share of Common Stock on the trading day immediately preceding the first
public announcement by the Company or any of its Affiliates of the intent to
effect such Pro Rata Repurchase, minus (ii) the aggregate purchase price of the
Pro Rata Repurchase, and of which the denominator shall be the product of (i)
the number of shares of Common Stock outstanding immediately prior to such Pro
Rata Repurchase minus the number of shares of Common Stock so repurchased and
(ii) the Market Price per share of Common Stock on the trading day immediately
preceding the first public announcement by the Company or any of its Affiliates
of the intent to effect such Pro Rata Repurchase. In such event, the number of
shares of Common Stock issuable upon the exercise of this Warrant shall be
increased to the number obtained by dividing (x) the product of (1) the number
of Shares issuable upon the exercise of this Warrant before such adjustment, and
(2) the Exercise Price in effect immediately prior to the Pro Rata Repurchase
giving rise to this adjustment by (y) the new Exercise Price determined in
accordance with the immediately preceding sentence. For the avoidance of doubt,
no increase to the Exercise Price or decrease in the number of Shares issuable
upon exercise of this Warrant shall be made pursuant to this Section
13(D).

       

      (E)           Business
Combinations.  In case of any Business Combination or
reclassification of Common Stock (other than a reclassification of Common Stock
referred to in Section 13(A)), the Warrantholder’s right to receive Shares upon
exercise of this Warrant shall be converted into the right to exercise this
Warrant to acquire the number of shares of stock or other securities or property
(including cash) which the Common Stock issuable (at the time of such Business
Combination or reclassification) upon exercise of this Warrant immediately prior
to such

       


      
        
           


        

        
          10

           


        

        
           


        

      


      Business
Combination or reclassification would have been entitled to receive upon
consummation of such Business Combination or reclassification; and in any such
case, if necessary, the provisions set forth herein with respect to the rights
and interests thereafter of the Warrantholder shall be appropriately adjusted so
as to be applicable, as nearly as may reasonably be, to the Warrantholder’s
right to exercise this Warrant in exchange for any shares of stock or other
securities or property pursuant to this paragraph. In determining the kind and
amount of stock, securities or the property receivable upon exercise of this
Warrant following the consummation of such Business Combination, if the holders
of Common Stock have the right to elect the kind or amount of consideration
receivable upon consummation of such Business Combination, then the
consideration that the Warrantholder shall be entitled to receive upon exercise
shall be deemed to be the types and amounts of consideration received by the
majority of all holders of the shares of common stock that affirmatively make an
election (or of all such holders if none make an election).

       

      (F)           Rounding of Calculations;
Minimum Adjustments.  All calculations under this Section 13
shall be made to the nearest one-tenth (1/10th) of a cent or to the nearest
one-hundredth (1/100th) of a share, as the case may be. Any provision of this
Section 13 to the contrary notwithstanding, no adjustment in the Exercise Price
or the number of Shares into which this Warrant is exercisable shall be made if
the amount of such adjustment would be less than $0.01 or one-tenth (1/10th) of
a share of Common Stock, but any such amount shall be carried forward and an
adjustment with respect thereto shall be made at the time of and together with
any subsequent adjustment which, together with such amount and any other amount
or amounts so carried forward, shall aggregate $0.01 or 1/10th of a share of
Common Stock, or more.

       

      (G)           Timing of Issuance of
Additional Common Stock Upon Certain Adjustments.  In any case
in which the provisions of this Section 13 shall require that an adjustment
shall become effective immediately after a record date for an event, the Company
may defer until the occurrence of such event (i) issuing to the Warrantholder of
this Warrant exercised after such record date and before the occurrence of such
event the additional shares of Common Stock issuable upon such exercise by
reason of the adjustment required by such event over and above the shares of
Common Stock issuable upon such exercise before giving effect to such adjustment
and (ii) paying to such Warrantholder any amount of cash in lieu of a fractional
share of Common Stock; provided, however,
that the Company upon request shall deliver to such Warrantholder a due
bill or other appropriate instrument evidencing such Warrantholder’s right to
receive such additional shares, and such cash, upon the occurrence of the event
requiring such adjustment.

       

      (H)           Completion of Qualified
Equity Offering.  In the event the Company (or any successor by
Business Combination) completes one or more Qualified Equity Offerings on or
prior to December 31, 2009 that result in the Company (or any such successor )
receiving aggregate gross proceeds of not less than 100% of the aggregate
liquidation preference of the Preferred Shares (and any preferred stock issued
by any such successor to the Original Warrantholder under the CPP), the number
of shares of Common Stock underlying the portion of this Warrant then held by
the Original Warrantholder shall be thereafter reduced by a number of shares of
Common Stock equal to the product of (i) 0.5 and (ii) the number of shares
underlying

       


      
        
           


        

        
          11

           


        

        
           


        

      


      the
Warrant on the Issue Date (adjusted to take into account all other theretofore
made adjustments pursuant to this Section 13).

       

      (I)           Other
Events.  For so long as the Original Warrantholder holds this
Warrant or any portion thereof, if any event occurs as to which the provisions
of this Section 13 are not strictly applicable or, if strictly applicable, would
not, in the good faith judgment of the Board of Directors of the Company, fairly
and adequately protect the purchase rights of the Warrants in accordance with
the essential intent and principles of such provisions, then the Board of
Directors shall make such adjustments in the application of such provisions, in
accordance with such essential intent and principles, as shall be reasonably
necessary, in the good faith opinion of the Board of Directors, to protect such
purchase rights as aforesaid. The Exercise Price or the number of Shares into
which this Warrant is exercisable shall not be adjusted in the event of a change
in the par value of the Common Stock or a change in the jurisdiction of
incorporation of the Company.

       

      (J)           Statement Regarding
Adjustments.  Whenever the Exercise Price or the number of
Shares into which this Warrant is exercisable shall be adjusted as provided in
Section 13, the Company shall forthwith file at the principal office of the
Company a statement showing in reasonable detail the facts requiring such
adjustment and the Exercise Price that shall be in effect and the number of
Shares into which this Warrant shall be exercisable after such adjustment, and
the Company shall also cause a copy of such statement to be sent by mail, first
class postage prepaid, to each Warrantholder at the address appearing in the
Company’s records.

       

      (K)           Notice of Adjustment
Event.  In the event that the Company shall propose to take any
action of the type described in this Section 13 (but only if the action of the
type described in this Section 13 would result in an adjustment in the Exercise
Price or the number of Shares into which this Warrant is exercisable or a change
in the type of securities or property to be delivered upon exercise of this
Warrant), the Company shall give notice to the Warrantholder, in the manner set
forth in Section 13(J), which notice shall specify the record date, if any, with
respect to any such action and the approximate date on which such action is to
take place. Such notice shall also set forth the facts with respect thereto as
shall be reasonably necessary to indicate the effect on the Exercise Price and
the number, kind or class of shares or other securities or property which shall
be deliverable upon exercise of this Warrant. In the case of any action which
would require the fixing of a record date, such notice shall be given at least
10 days prior to the date so fixed, and in case of all other action, such notice
shall be given at least 15 days prior to the taking of such proposed action.
Failure to give such notice, or any defect therein, shall not affect the
legality or validity of any such action.

       

      (L)           Proceedings Prior to Any
Action Requiring Adjustment.  As a condition precedent to the
taking of any action which would require an adjustment pursuant to this Section
13, the Company shall take any action which may be necessary, including
obtaining regulatory, New York Stock Exchange, NASDAQ Stock Market or other
applicable national securities exchange or stockholder approvals or exemptions,
in order that the Company may thereafter validly and legally issue as fully paid
and nonassessable all shares of Common Stock that the Warrantholder is entitled
to receive upon exercise of this Warrant pursuant to this Section
13.

       

       

      
        
          
          

        

        
          12

          
          

        

        
          
          

        

      

       

       

      (M)         
Adjustment
Rules.  Any adjustments pursuant to this Section 13 shall be
made successively whenever an event referred to herein shall occur. If an
adjustment in Exercise Price made hereunder would reduce the Exercise Price to
an amount below par value of the Common Stock, then such adjustment in Exercise
Price made hereunder shall reduce the Exercise Price to the par value of the
Common Stock.

       

      14.           Exchange.  At
any time following the date on which the shares of Common Stock of the Company
are no longer listed or admitted to trading on a national securities exchange
(other than in connection with any Business Combination), the Original
Warrantholder may cause the Company to exchange all or a portion of this Warrant
for an economic interest (to be determined by the Original Warrantholder after
consultation with the Company) of the Company classified as permanent equity
under U.S. GAAP having a value equal to the Fair Market Value of the portion of
the Warrant so exchanged. The Original Warrantholder shall calculate any Fair
Market Value required to be calculated pursuant to this Section 14, which shall
not be subject to the Appraisal Procedure.

       

      15.           No
Impairment.  The Company will not, by amendment of its Charter
or through any reorganization, transfer of assets, consolidation, merger,
dissolution, issue or sale of securities or any other voluntary action, avoid or
seek to avoid the observance or performance of any of the terms to be observed
or performed hereunder by the Company, but will at all times in good faith
assist in the carrying out of all the provisions of this Warrant and in taking
of all such action as may be necessary or appropriate in order to protect the
rights of the Warrantholder.

       

      16.           Governing
Law.  This
Warrant will be governed by and construed in accordance with the federal law of
the United States if and to the extent such law is applicable, and otherwise in
accordance with the laws of the State of New York applicable to contracts made and to be performed
entirely within such State.  Each of the Company and the Warrantholder
agrees (a) to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction and venue of the United States District Court for the
District of Columbia for any civil action, suit or proceeding arising out of or
relating to this Warrant or the transactions contemplated hereby, and (b) that
notice may be served upon the Company at the address in Section 20 below and
upon the Warrantholder
at the address for the Warrantholder set forth in the registry maintained by the
Company pursuant to Section 9 hereof.  To the extent permitted by
applicable law, each of the Company and the Warrantholder hereby unconditionally
waives trial by jury in any civil legal action or proceeding relating to the
Warrant or the transactions contemplated hereby or thereby.

       

      17.           Binding
Effect.  This Warrant shall be binding upon any successors or
assigns of the Company.

       

      18.           Amendments.  This
Warrant may be amended and the observance of any term of this Warrant may be
waived only with the written consent of the Company and the
Warrantholder.

       

      19.           Prohibited
Actions.  The Company agrees that it will not take any action
which would entitle the Warrantholder to an adjustment of the Exercise Price if
the total number of shares of Common Stock issuable after such action upon
exercise of this Warrant, together with

       


      
        
           


        

        
          13

           


        

        
           


        

      


      all
shares of Common Stock then outstanding and all shares of Common Stock then
issuable upon the exercise of all outstanding options, warrants, conversion and
other rights, would exceed the total number of shares of Common Stock then
authorized by its Charter.

       

      20.           Notices.  Any
notice, request, instruction or other document to be given hereunder by any
party to the other will be in writing and will be deemed to have been duly given
(a) on the date of delivery if delivered personally, or by facsimile, upon
confirmation of receipt, or (b) on the second business day following the date of
dispatch if delivered by a recognized next day courier service. All notices
hereunder shall be delivered as set forth in Item 8 of Schedule A hereto, or
pursuant to such other instructions as may be designated in writing by the party
to receive such notice.

       

      21.           Entire
Agreement.  This Warrant, the forms attached hereto and
Schedule A hereto (the terms of which are incorporated by reference herein), and
the Letter Agreement (including all documents incorporated therein), contain the
entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof
and supersede all prior and contemporaneous arrangements or undertakings with
respect thereto.

       

       

      [Remainder
of page intentionally left blank]


      
        
           


        

        
          14

           


        

        
           


        

      


      Form of
Notice of Exercise

      


      Date:
_________________

       

      TO:  MutualFirst Financial,
Inc.

       

      RE:  Election
to Purchase Common Stock

       

      


      The
undersigned, pursuant to the provisions set forth in the attached Warrant,
hereby agrees to subscribe for and purchase the number of shares of the Common
Stock set forth below covered by such Warrant. The undersigned, in accordance
with Section 3 of the Warrant, hereby agrees to pay the aggregate Exercise Price
for such shares of Common Stock in the manner set forth below. A new warrant
evidencing the remaining shares of Common Stock covered by such Warrant, but not
yet subscribed for and purchased, if any, should be issued in the name set forth
below.

       

      Number of
Shares of Common Stock_________________________

       

      Method of
Payment of Exercise Price (note if cashless exercise pursuant to Section 3(i) of
the Warrant or cash exercise pursuant to Section 3(ii) of the Warrant, with
consent of the Company and the
Warrantholder)___________________________

       

      Aggregate
Exercise
Price:                                                                                     ___________________________

       

      Holder: ______________________________

       

      By:        ______________________________

      Name:   ______________________________

      Title:     ______________________________

      



      
        
           


        

        
          15

           


        

        
           


        

      


      IN
WITNESS WHEREOF, the Company has caused this Warrant to be duly executed by a
duly authorized officer.

       

       

      Dated:  December
23, 2008

       

      

        
          	 
      	
                  COMPANY:   MutualFirst Financial,
      Inc.

                
	 
      	 
      	 
      
	 
      	
                  By:

                	
                  /s/
      David W.
      Heeter                                       
      

                
	 
      	 
      	
                  Name:  David
      W. Heeter

                
	 
      	 
      	
                  Title:  President  and
      Chief Executive Officer

                
	 
      	 
      	 
      
	 
      	 
      	 
      
	 
      	
                  Attest:

                
	 
      	 
      	 
      
	 
      	
                  By:

                	
                  /s/
      Rosalie
      Petro                                            
      

                
	 
      	 
      	
                  Name:  Rosalie
      Petro

                
	 
      	 
      	
                  Title:  Secretary

                


        



       

      [Signature
Page to Warrant]


      
        
           


        

        
          16

           


        

        
           


        

      


      SCHEDULE
A

      


      


      Item 1

      Name:                                                                           MutualFirst Financial,
Inc.

      Corporate
or other organizational
form:                       Corporation

      Jurisdiction
of
organization:                                         Maryland

      


      Item 2

      Exercise
Price:                                    $7.77

      


      Item 3

      Issue
Date:                                           December
23, 2008

      


      Item 4

      
        Amount of
last dividend declared prior to the Issue Date:    Quarterly dividend
of $0.16 per share.

      

      


      Item 5

      Date of
Letter Agreement between the Company and the United States Department of the
Treasury:    December 23,
2008

      


      Item 6

      Number of
shares of Common
Stock:                625,135

      


      Item 7

      Company’s
address:                110
E. Charles Street

      Muncie, Indiana 47305

      


      Item 8

      Notice
information:                 David
W. Heeter

      President and Chief Executive
Officer

      MutualFirst
Financial,
Inc.

      110 E. Charles Street

      Muncie, Indiana 47305

      (765) 747-2880

      Fax:  (765)
213-2981