# Patent

## Title
Automatic transcription of musical content and real-time musical accompaniment

## Abstract

In at least one embodiment, a method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device is provided. The method includes processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content and generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing alternative musical interpretations of the extracted musical information. The method further includes applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal.

## Background
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
This application claims the benefit of U.S. provisional application No. 62/105,521 filed Jan. 20, 2015, the disclosure of which is incorporated in its entirety by reference herein.


TECHNICAL FIELD
Aspects disclosed herein generally relate to signal processing, and more specifically, to various applications including processing musical content included in audio signals
BACKGROUND
With musical transcription, there may be multiple ways to interpret a piece of music. However, conventional implementations only provide one interpretation of the music (or audio) and rely on the user to fix or correct any mistakes that are performed during the transcription process.
SUMMARY
In at least one embodiment, a method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device is provided. The method includes processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content and generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing alternative musical interpretations of the extracted musical information. The method further includes applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal.
In at least one embodiment, a computer-program product to perform automatic transcription of musical content included in a received audio signal is provided. The computer-program product includes a computer-readable storage medium having computer-readable program code embodied therewith. The computer-readable program code is executable by one or more computer processors to: process the received first audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content and to generate a plurality of musical notations representing alternative musical interpretations of the extracted musical information. The computer-readable program code is also executable by one or more computer processors to apply a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal.
In at least one embodiment, a musical transcription device for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in a received audio signal is provided. The device includes one or more computer processors configured to process the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content and to generate a plurality of musical notations representing alternative musical interpretations of the extracted musical information. The one or more computer processors further configured to apply a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and to output the transcribed musical content.



BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The embodiments of the present disclosure are pointed out with particularity in the appended claims. However, other features of the various embodiments will become more apparent and will be best understood by referring to the following detailed description in conjunction with the accompany drawings in which:
FIG. 1 illustrates one example of a system for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal in accordance to one embodiment.
FIGS. 2A and 2B illustrate one example musical information and user profiles for use in a system for performing automatic transcription of musical content in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 3 illustrates a method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 4A illustrates a method of generating a plurality of musical notations for extracted musical information in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 4B illustrates a method of performing selection of one of a plurality of musical notations in accordance to one embodiment.
FIGS. 5A and 5B each illustrate alternative musical notations corresponding to the same musical information in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 6 illustrates selection of a musical notation and transcription using the selected musical notation in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 7 illustrates one example of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment for musical content included in a received audio signal in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 8 is a chart illustrating one example of timing of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 9 illustrates one example of an implementation of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment in accordance to one embodiment.
FIG. 10 illustrates a method of performing real-time musical accompaniment for musical content included in a received audio signal in accordance to one embodiment.



DETAILED DESCRIPTION
As required, detailed embodiments of the present invention are disclosed herein; however, it is to be understood that the disclosed embodiments are merely examples of the invention that may be embodied in various and alternative forms. The figures are not necessarily to scale; some features may be exaggerated or minimized to show details of particular components. Therefore, specific structural and functional details disclosed herein are not to be interpreted as limiting, but merely as a representative basis for teaching one skilled in the art to variously employ the present invention.
Automatic Transcription of Audio Signals
Several embodiments generally disclose a method, system, and device for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal. Information about musical content may be represented in a vast number of different ways, such as digital representations or analog (e.g., sheets of music), using musical symbols in a particular style of notation. Even within a particular style of notation (for example, the staff notation commonly used for written music), ambiguity may allow for alternative interpretations of the same musical information. For example, by altering time signature, tempo, and/or note lengths, multiple competing interpretations may be produced that represent the same musical information. Each of these interpretations may be technically accurate. Therefore, performing accurate transcription of musical content depends on a number of factors, some of which may be subjective, being based on a user's intentions or preferences for the musical information.
FIG. 1 illustrates one example of a system for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal, according to one embodiment. System 100 includes a computing device 105 that may be operatively coupled with one or more input devices 185, one or more output devices 190, and a network 195 including other computing devices.
The computing device 105 generally includes processors 110, memory 120, and input/output (or I/O) 180 that are interconnected using one or more connections 115. The computing device 105 may be implemented in any suitable form. Some non-limiting examples of computing device 105 include general-purpose computing devices, such as personal computers, desktop computers, laptop computers, netbook computers, tablets, web browsers, e-book readers, and personal digital assistants (PDAs). Other examples of the computing device 105 include communication devices, such as mobile phones and media devices (including recorders, editors, and players such as televisions, set-top boxes, music players, digital photo frames, and digital cameras). In some embodiments, the computing device 105 may be implemented as a specific musical device, such as a digital audio workstation, console, instrument pedal, electronic musical instrument (such as a digital piano), and so forth.
In one embodiment, the connection 115 may represent common bus(es) within the computing device 105. In an alternative embodiment, system 100 is distributed and includes a plurality of discrete computing devices 105 for performing the functions described herein. In such an embodiment, the connections 115 may include intra-device connections (e.g., buses) as well as wired or wireless networking connections between computing devices.
Processors 110 may include any processing elements that are suitable for performing the functions described herein, and may include single or multiple core processors, as well as combinations thereof. The processors 110 may be included within a single computing device 105, or may represent an aggregation of processing elements included across a number of networked computing devices.
Memory 120 may include a variety of computer-readable media selected for their size, relative performance, or other capabilities: volatile and/or non-volatile media, removable and/or non-removable media, etc. Memory 120 may include cache, random access memory (RAM), storage, etc. Storage included as part of memory 120 may typically provide a non-volatile memory and include one or more different storage elements such as Flash memory, a hard disk drive, a solid state drive, an optical storage device, and/or a magnetic storage device. Memory 120 may be included in a single computing device or may represent an aggregation of memory included in networked computing devices.
Memory 120 may include a plurality of modules used for performing various functions described herein. The modules generally include program code that is executable by one or more of the processors 110, and may be implemented as software and/or firmware. In another embodiment, one or more of the modules is implemented in hardware as a separate application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC). As shown, modules include extraction module 130, interpretation module 132, scoring module 134, transcription module 136, accompaniment module 138, composition module 140, instruction module 142, and gaming module 144. The modules may operate independently, and may interact to perform certain functions. For example, the gaming module 144 during operation may make calls to the interpretation module 132, the transcription module 136, and so forth. The person of ordinary skill will recognize that the modules provided herein are merely non-exclusive examples; different functions and/or groupings of functions may be included as desired to suitably operate the system 100.
Memory 120 includes one or more audio signals 125. As used herein, a signal or audio signal generally refers to a time-varying electrical signal corresponding to a sound to be presented to one or more listeners. Such signals are generally produced with one or more audio transducers such as microphones, guitar pickups, or other devices. These signals may be processed using, for example, amplification or filtering or other techniques prior to delivery to audio output devices such as speakers or headphones.
Audio signals 125 may have any suitable form, whether analog or digital. The audio signals may be monophonic (i.e., including a single pitch) or polyphonic (i.e., including multiple pitches). Audio signals 125 may include signals produced contemporaneously using one or more input devices 185 and received through input/output 180, as well as one or more pre-recorded files, tracks, streamed media, etc. included in memory 120. The input devices 185 include audio input devices 186 and user interface (UI) devices 187. Audio input devices 186 may include passive devices (e.g., a microphone or pickup for musical instruments or vocals) and/or actively powered devices, such as an electronic instrument providing a MIDI output. User interface devices 187 include various devices known in the art that allow a user to interact with and control operation of the computing device 105 (e.g., keyboard, mouse, touchscreen, etc.).
The extraction module 130 is configured to analyze some or all of the one or more audio signals 125 in order to extract musical information 160 representing various properties of the musical content of the audio signals 125. In one embodiment, the extraction module 130 samples a portion of the audio signals 125 and extracts musical information corresponding to the portion. The extraction module 130 may apply any suitable signal processing techniques to the audio signals 125 to determine characteristics of the musical content included therein. Musical information 160 includes time-based characteristics of the musical content, such as the timing (onset and/or duration) of musical notes. Musical information 160 also includes frequency-based characteristics of the musical content, such as pitches or frequencies (e.g., 440 Hz) of musical notes.
Interpretation module 132 is configured to analyze the musical information 160 and to produce a plurality of possible notations 133 (i.e., musical interpretations) representing the musical information. As discussed above, a vast number of ways exist to represent musical information, which may vary by cultural norms, personal preferences, whether the representation will be visually formatted (e.g., sheet music) or processed by computing systems (such as MIDI), and so forth. The interpretation module 132 may interact with other data stored in memory 120 to improve the accuracy of generated notations, such as user profile information 170 and/or musical genre information 175.
Turning to FIG. 2A, the interpretation module 132 may assess the musical information 160 of the audio signals 125 and attempt to accurately classify the information according to a number of different musical characteristics. Some of the characteristics may be predominantly pitch or frequency-based, such as key signatures 205, chords 220, some aspects of notes 225 (e.g., note pitches, distinguishing polyphonic notes), and so forth. Groups of notes 225 may be classified as melody 226 or harmony 227; these parts may be included together in notations 133 or may be interpreted separately. Other characteristics may be predominantly time-based, such as a number of measures or bars 207, time signatures 210, tempos 215, other aspects of notes 225 (e.g., note onsets and lengths), rhythms 230, and so forth. Rhythms 230 may correspond to an overall “style” or “feel” for the musical information, reflected in the timing patterns of notes 225. Examples of rhythms 230 include straight time 231, swing time 232, as well as other rhythms 233 known to a person of ordinary skill in the art (e.g., staccato swing, shuffle, and so forth). The interpretation module 132 may also include other characteristics 235 that would be known to the person of ordinary skill in the art, such as musical dynamics (e.g., time-based changes to signal volumes or amplitudes, velocities, etc.). Additional discussion of musical characteristics is provided with respect to FIGS. 5A and 5B below.
Returning to FIG. 1, the notations 133 generated by the interpretation module 132 may include a plurality of the musical characteristics discussed above. Each notation 133 generated for a particular musical information 160 may include the same set (or at least a partially shared set) of musical characteristics, but one or more values for the shared musical characteristics generally varies between notations. In this way, the notations 133 provide a plurality of alternative representations of the same musical information 160 that are sufficiently distinguishable. Providing the alternative representations may be useful for estimating the notation that the end-user is seeking, which may reflect completely subjective preferences. The alternative representations may accommodate the possibility of different styles of music, and may also be helpful to overcome the minor variability that occurs within a human musical performance. Example notations are discussed below with respect to FIGS. 5A and 5B.
In one implementation of the system 100, a typical scenario may include a musician using a musical instrument (e.g., a guitar) to provide the audio signal 125. To indicate that a musical phrase in the audio signal should be learned by an algorithm executed using processors 110, the musician may step on a footswitch or provide an alternate indication that the musical phrase is beginning about the time that the first notes are played. The musician plays the musical phrase having a particular time signature (e.g., 3/4 or 4/4) and a particular feel (e.g., straight or swing), with the associated chords optionally changing at various points during the phrase. Upon completion of the phrase, the musician may provide another indication (e.g., step on the footswitch again). The beginning of the phrase could also be indicated by instructing (i.e., “arming”) the algorithm to listen for the instrument signal to cross a certain energy level rather than using a separate indication. In one embodiment, a more accurate location for the start and end of the musical phrase can be determined by searching for a closest note onset within a range (e.g., +/−100 ms) of the start and end indicated by the user.
While the phrase is being played, real-time analysis of the audio signal 125 (e.g., the instrument signal from the guitar) is performed by the system 100. For example, polyphonic note detection can be used to extract the note pitches that are played (e.g., strums on the guitar) and onset detection can be used to determine the times at which the guitar was strummed or picked. In addition to determining the times of the strums, features can be extracted corresponding to each strum, which can later be used in a full analysis to correlate strums against each other to determine strum emphasis (e.g., bar start strums, downstrums or upstrums, etc.). For example, the spectral energy in several bands can be extracted as a feature vector for each onset.
When the musician indicates the end of the musical phrase, the interpretation module 132 can perform a full analysis to produce multiple notations corresponding to the phrase. In one embodiment, the full analysis works by hypothesizing a notation for the musical phrase and then scoring the detected notes and onsets against the hypothesis. For example, one notation might include 4 bars of 4/4 straight feel timing. In this case, we could expect to find onsets at or near the quarter and eighth note locations, which can be estimated by dividing the phrase into 32 sections (i.e., 4 bars×8 notes per bar). The notation will generally receive a higher score if the detected onsets occur at the expected locations of quarter notes/eighth notes. In one embodiment, a greater scoring weight is applied to the quarter notes when compared to the eighth notes, and an even greater scoring weight is applied to onsets corresponding to the start of a bar. Using the features extracted for each onset, a similarity measure can be determined for each of the onsets detected. The onset score is increased if the onsets associated with the start of a bar have a high similarity measure.
The notes may also be analyzed to determine whether specific chords were played. In one embodiment, an interpretation may be more likely where timing of the chord changes occurs near bar boundaries. In one embodiment, a chord change score may is included in the overall calculation of the notation score. In addition, a priori scores (or probabilities) can be assigned to each notation based on what is more likely to be played. For example, a larger a priori score might be assigned to a 4/4 notation over a 3/4 notation, or a larger a priori score may be assigned to an even number of bars over an odd number of bars. By appropriately scaling the scores (e.g., between 0 and 1), the overall score for a notation may be computed by multiplying the onset score by the chord change score and the a priori score. Due to the large number of possible notations for a musical phrase, standard methods of dynamic programming can be used to reduce the computational load.
In some cases, the scores for different notation hypotheses may be very close (see, e.g., FIG. 5A), making it difficult to choose a single “correct” notation. For this reason, a top-scoring subset of the notation hypotheses may be provided to an end-user with an easy method to select the notation hypothesis without tedious editing. In one embodiment, a single “alternate timing” button may be used to alternate between the notation hypotheses having the two greatest scores. In one embodiment, a user interface (UI) element such as a button or knob may be used to alternate from the best notation of a first particular type (e.g., a 4/4 notation) to the best notation of a first different type (e.g., a 3/4 notation). In addition, the user interface (UI) element such as the button or the knob may be used to alternate from the best notation of a second particular type (e.g., a half time notation) to the best notation of a second different type (e.g., a double time notation). Also, the user interface (UI) element such as the button or the knob may be used to alternate from the best notation of a third particular type (e.g., a half time notation) to the best notation of a third different type (e.g., a double time notation).
The plurality of notations 133 represents different musical interpretations of the musical information 160. The scoring module 134 is configured to assign scores to each of the generated notations 133 based on a measure of matching the audio signal 125 or a portion of the audio signal 125 (corresponding to the musical information 160). Any suitable algorithm may be used to determine or quantify the relative matching. In some embodiments, matching may be done directly, i.e., comparing the sequence of notes 225 and/or chords 220 determined for a particular notation 133 with the audio signal 125. In one embodiment, variations in timing and/or pitch of notes between the notation 133 and the audio signal may be determined. For example, the extraction module 130 during processing may determine a note included within the audio signal to have a particular time length (say, 425 milliseconds (ms)). Assume also that one of the notations generated by the interpretation module 132 includes a tempo of 160 beats per minute (bpm) in straight time, with a quarter note corresponding to one beat. For this example, a quarter note would be expected to have a time value of 0.375 s or 375 ms (i.e., 60 s/min divided by 160 bpm). The interpretation module may consider the 425 ms note to be sufficiently close to the expected 375 ms to classify the note as a quarter note (perhaps within a predetermined margin to accommodate user imprecision). Alternatively, the interpretation module may consider this classification as the best possible classification considering the particular notation parameters; for example, the next closest possible note classification could be a dotted quarter note having an expected time value of 562.5 ms (1.5×375 ms). Here, it is evident that the error is less when classifying the 425 ms note as a quarter note (50 ms) than when classifying as a dotted quarter note (137.5 ms). Of course, the interpretation module may apply additional or alternative logic to individual notes or groupings of notes to make such classifications. The amounts of error corresponding to the classification of individual notes or groupings of notes may be further processed to determine an overall matching score of the notation 133 to the audio signal 125. In some embodiments, the amounts of error may be aggregated and/or weighed to determine the matching score.
In some embodiments, the measure of matching and score calculation may also be based on information included in one or more user profiles 170, as well as one or more selected or specified genres 175 for the audio signal 125/musical information 160. Genres 175 generally include a number of different broad categories of music styles. A selected genre may assist the interpretation module 132 in accurately processing and interpreting the musical information 160, as genres may suggest certain musical qualities of the musical information 160 (such as rhythm information, expected groups of notes/chords or key signatures, and so forth). Some examples of common genres 175 include rock, country, rhythm and blues (R&B), jazz, blues, popular music (pop), metal, and so forth. Of course, these examples generally reflect Western music preferences; genres 175 may also include musical styles common within different cultures. In one embodiment, the genre information may be specified before the interpretation module 132 operates to interpret the musical information 160. In one embodiment, the genre 175 for the audio is signal is selected by an end-user via an element of the UI 187.
Turning to FIG. 2B, a user profile 170 may include preference information 250 and history information 260 (or history of use) specific to an end-user. History information 260 generally includes information related to the end-user's previous sessions using the system 100, and tends to show a user's musical preferences. History information 260 may include data that indicates previous instances of musical information 160, a corresponding genre 175 selected, a corresponding notation 133 selected, notations 133 not selected, and so forth. The end-user's preferences 250 may be explicitly determined or specified by the end-user through the UI 187, or may be implicitly determined by the computing device 105 based on the end-user's interactions with various functions/modules of the system 110. Preferences 250 may include a number of different categories, such as genre preferences 251 and interpretation preferences 252.
The scoring module 134 may consider user profiles 170 (for the particular end-user and/or other end-users) and the genre 175 when scoring the notations 133. For example, assume one end-user's history 260 indicates a strong genre preference 251 for metal. Consistent with the metal genre, the end-user may also have interpretation preferences 252 for fast tempos and a straight time feel. When scoring a plurality of notations 133 for the particular end-user, the scoring module 134 may generally give a lower score to those notations having musical characteristics that are comparable to different genres (such as jazz or R&B), having slower tempos, a swing time feel, and so forth. Of course, in other embodiments, the scoring module 134 may consider the history 260 of a number of different end-users to assess trends, similarities of characteristics, etc.
Returning to FIG. 1, the transcription module 136 is configured to apply a selected notation to the musical information 160 to produce one or more transcriptions 150. When a notation 133 is selected, the entire audio signal may be processed according to the characteristics of the notation. For example, an initial musical information 160 corresponding to a sampled portion of the audio signal 125 may be classified using a plurality of notations 133.
In some embodiments, selecting a notation from the plurality of generated notations 133 may include presenting some or all of the notations 133 (e.g., a highest scoring subset of the notations) to an end-user through UI 187, e.g., displaying information related to the different notations using a graphical user interface. The end-user may then manually select one of the notations. In other embodiments, a notation may be selected automatically and without receiving a selection input from the end-user. For example, the notation having the highest score may be selected by the transcription module.
When one of the notations 133 is selected, the musical characteristics of the selected notation (e.g., pitch/frequency and timing information) are applied to classify the musical information 160 corresponding to the full audio signal. In one embodiment, the musical information for the entire audio signal is determined after a notation is selected, which may save processing time and energy. This may be useful as the processors 110 may be required to perform significant parallel processing to generate the various notations 133 based on the initial (limited) musical information 160. In another embodiment, the musical information 160 for the entire audio signal is determined before or contemporaneously with selection of a notation 133.
The transcription module 136 may output the selected notation as transcription 150 having any suitable format, such as a musical score, chord chart, sheet music, guitar tablature, and so forth. In some embodiments, the transcription 150 may be provided as a digital signal (or file) readable by the computing device 105 and/or other networked computing devices. For example, the transcription 150 may be generated as a file and stored in memory 120. In other embodiments, the transcription 150 may be visually provided to an end-user using display device 192, which may include visual display devices (e.g., electronic visual displays and/or visual indicators such as light emitting diodes (LEDs)), print devices, and so forth.
In some embodiments, transcriptions 150 and/or the musical information 160 corresponding to the audio signals 125 may be used to generate complementary musical information and/or complementary audio signals 155. In one embodiment, the accompaniment module 138 generates one or more complementary audio signals 155 based on the completed transcription 150. In another embodiment, the accompaniment module 138 generates complementary audio signals 155 based on the musical information 160. In some implementations, discussed in greater detail with respect to FIGS. 7-10 below, the complementary audio signals 155 may be output contemporaneously with receiving the audio signal 125. Because musical compositions generally have some predictability (e.g., a relative consistency of key, rhythm, etc.), the complementary audio signals 155 may be generated as forward-looking (i.e., notes are generated with some amount of time before they are output).
The music information included within complementary audio signals 155 may be selected based on musical compatibility with the musical information 160. Generally, musically compatible properties (in timing, pitch, volume, etc.) are desirable for the contemporaneous output of the complementary audio signals with the audio signals 155. For example, the rhythm of the complementary audio signals 155 may be matched to the rhythm determined for the audio signals 125, such that notes or chords of each signal are synchronized or at least provided with harmonious or predictable timing for a listener. Similarly, the pitch content of the complementary audio signals 155 may be selected based on musical compatibility of the notes, which in some cases is subjective based on cultural preferences. For example, complementary audio signals 155 may include notes forming consonant and/or dissonant harmonies with the musical information included in the received audio signal. Generally, consonant harmonies include notes that complement the harmonic frequencies of other notes, and dissonant harmonies are made up of notes that result in complex interactions (for example beating). Consonant harmonies are generally described as being made up of note intervals of 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, and 12 semitones. Consonant harmonies are sometimes considered to be “pleasant” while dissonant harmonies are considered to be “unpleasant.” However, this pleasant/unpleasant classification is a major simplification, as there are times when dissonant harmonies are musically desirable (for example, to evoke a sense of “wanting to resolve” to a consonant harmony). In most forms of music, and in particular, Western popular music, the vast majority of harmony notes are consonant, with dissonant harmonies being generated only under certain conditions where the dissonance serves a musical purpose.
The musical information 160 and/or transcriptions 150 that are determined using certain modules of the computing device 105 may be interfaced with various application modules providing different functionality for end-users. In some embodiments, the application modules may be standalone commercial programs (i.e., music programs) that include functionality provided according to various embodiments described herein. One example of an application module is composition module 140. Similar to the accompaniment module 138, the composition module 140 is configured to generate complementary musical information based on the musical information 160 and/or the transcriptions 150. However, instead of generating a distinct complementary audio signal 155 for output, the composition module 140 operates to provide suggestions or recommendations to an end-user based on the transcription 150. The suggestions may be designed to correct or adjust notes/chords depicted in the transcription 150, add harmony parts for the same instrument, add parts for different instruments, and so forth. This may be particularly useful for a musician who wishes to arrange a musical piece but does not play multiple instruments, or is not particularly knowledgeable in music theory and composition. The end result of the composition module 140 is a modified transcription 150, such as a musical score having greater harmonic depth and/or including additional instrument parts than the part(s) provided in the audio signals 125.
Another example application module is instruction module 142, such as training an end-user how to play a musical instrument or how to score a musical composition. The audio signal 125 may represent the end-user's attempt to play a prescribed lesson or a musical piece on the instrument, and the corresponding musical information 160 and/or transcriptions 150 may be used to assess the end-user's learning progress and adaptively update the training program. For example, the instruction module 142 may perform a number of functions, such as determining a similarity of the audio signal 125 to the prescribed lesson/music, using the musical information 160 to identify specific competencies and/or deficiencies of the end-user, and so forth.
Another example application module is gaming module 144. In some embodiments, gaming module 144 may be integrated with an instruction module 142, to provide a more engaging learning environment for an end-user. In other embodiments, the gaming module 144 may be provided without a specific instruction module functionality. The gaming module 144 may be used to assess a similarity of the audio signal 125 to prescribed sheet music or a musical piece, to determine harmonic compatibility of the audio signal 125 with a musical piece, to perform a quantitative or qualitative analysis of the audio signal itself, and so forth.
FIG. 3 illustrates a method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal, according to one embodiment. Method 300 may be used in conjunction with the various embodiments described herein, such as a part of system 100 and using one or more of the functional modules included in memory 120.
Method 300 begins at block 305, where an audio signal is received by a computing device. The audio signal generally includes musical content, and may be provided in any suitable form, whether digital or analog. Optionally, in block 315, a portion of the audio signal is sampled. In some embodiments, a plurality of audio signals is received contemporaneously. The separate audio signals may represent different parts of a musical composition, such as an end-user playing an instrument and singing, etc.
In block 325, the computing device processes at least the portion of the audio signal to extract musical information. Some examples of the extracted information include note onsets, audio levels, polyphonic note detections, and so forth. In one embodiment, the extracted musical information corresponds only to the portion of the audio signal. In another embodiment, the extracted musical information corresponds to the entire audio signal.
In block 335, the computing device generates a plurality of musical notations for the extracted musical information. The notations provide alternative interpretations of the extracted musical information, each notation generally including a plurality of musical characteristics, such as time signature, key signature, tempo, notes, chords, rhythm types. The notations may share a set of characteristics, and in some embodiments the values for certain shared characteristics may differ between notations, such that the different notations are distinguishable for an end-user.
In block 345, the computing device generates a score for each of the musical notations. The score is generally based on the degree to which the notation matches the audio signal. Scoring may also be performed based on a specified genre of music and/or one or more user profiles corresponding to end-users of the computing device.
In block 355, one of the plurality of musical notations is selected. In one embodiment, the selection occurs automatically by the computing device, such as selecting the notation corresponding to the greatest calculated score. In other embodiments, two or more musical notations are presented to an end-user for receiving selection input through a user interface. In one embodiment, a subset of the plurality of musical notations is presented to the end-user, such as a particular number of notations having the corresponding greatest calculated scores.
In block 365, the musical content of the audio signal is transcribed using the selected musical notation. The transcription may be in any suitable format, digital or analog, visual or computer-readable, etc. The transcription may be provided as a musical score, chord chart, guitar tablature, or any alternative suitable musical representation.
In block 375, the transcription is output to an output device. In one embodiment, the transcription is visually displayed to an end-user using an electronic display device. In another embodiment, the transcription may be printed (using a printer device) on paper or another suitable medium for use by the end-user.
FIG. 4A illustrates a method of generating a plurality of musical notations for extracted musical information, according to one embodiment. The method 400 generally corresponds to block 335 of method 300, and may be used in conjunction with the various embodiments described herein.
At block 405, the computing device determines note values and lengths corresponding to the extracted musical information. The determination is based on the extracted musical information, which may include determined note onsets, audio levels, polyphonic note detection, and so forth. The determination may include classifying notes by pitch and/or duration using a system of baseline notation rules. For example, according to the staff notation commonly used today, note pitches are classified from A through G and modified with accidentals, and note lengths are classified relative to other notes and relative to tempo, time signature, etc. Of course, alternative musical notation systems may be prevalent in other cultures, and such an alternative system may accordingly dictate the baseline classification rules.
At blocks 410-430, the computing device determines various characteristics based on the note information determined in block 405. At block 410, one or more key signatures are determined. At block 415, one or more time signatures are determined. At block 420, one or more tempos are determined. At block 425, one or more rhythm styles or “feels” are determined. At block 430, a number of bars corresponding to the note information is determined. The blocks 410-430 may be determined in a sequence or substantially simultaneously. In one embodiment, a value selected corresponding to one block may affect values of other blocks. For example, time signature, tempo, and note lengths are all interrelated, such that adjusting one of these properties requires an adjustment to at least one other to accurately reflect the musical content. In another example, the number of bars may be determined based on one or more of the time signature, tempo, and note lengths.
At block 435, the computing device outputs a plurality of musical notations for the extracted musical information. The plurality of musical notations may include various combinations of the characteristics determined above.
Next, FIG. 4B illustrates a method of performing selection of one of a plurality of musical notations, according to one embodiment. The method 450 generally corresponds to block 355 of method 300, and may be used in conjunction with the various embodiments described herein.
At block 455, the computing device selects a subset of musical notations corresponding to the highest calculated scores. In some embodiments, the subset is limited to a predetermined number of notations (e.g., two, three, four, etc.) which may be based on readability of the displayed notations for an end-user. In another embodiment, the subset is limited to all notations exceeding a particular threshold value.
At block 465, the subset of musical notations is presented to the end-user. In one embodiment, this may be performed using an electronic display (e.g., displaying information for each of the subset on the display). In another embodiment, the musical notations are provided via visual indicators, such as LEDs illuminated to indicate different musical characteristics. At block 475, the computing device receives an end-user selection of one of the musical notations. In several embodiments, the selection input may be provided through the user interface, such as a graphical user interface.
As an alternative to the method branch through blocks 455-475, in block 485 the computing device may automatically select a musical notation corresponding to the highest calculated score.
FIGS. 5A and 5B each illustrate alternative musical notations corresponding to the same musical information, according to one embodiment. FIG. 5A illustrates a first set of notes 5201-8. For simplicity of the example, assume that each of the notes 520 corresponds substantially to the same frequency/pitch (here, “B flat” or “Bb”) and has substantially the same length.
Notation 500 includes a staff 501, clef 502, key signature 503, time signature 504, and tempo 505, each of which is known to a person of ordinary skill in the art. Measure 510 includes the notes 5201-8, which based on the time signature 504 and tempo 505 are displayed as eighth notes 5151, 5152, etc.
Notation 525 includes the same key signature 503 and time signature 504. However, the tempo 530 differs from tempo 505, indicating that 160 quarter notes should be played per minute (160 beats per minute (bpm), with one quarter note receiving one beat). Tempo 505, on the other hand, indicates 80 bpm. Accordingly, the notes 520 are displayed with different lengths in notation 525—quarter notes 5401, 5402, and so forth. In notation 525, the notes 520 are also divided into two bars or measures 5351 (for notes 5201-4) and 5352 (for notes 5205-8), as there can only be four quarter notes included per measure in a 4/4 song. Since tempo 530 has been increased to 160 bpm from the 80 bpm of tempo 505, this means that the length of the quarter notes has been cut in half, so that the eight quarter notes depicted in notation 525 represent the same length of time as the eight eighth notes depicted in notation 500.
Notations 500 and 525 display essentially the same extracted musical information (notes 5201-8); however, the notations differ in the tempo and note lengths. In alternative embodiments, the notations may include qualitative tempo indicators (e.g., adagio, allegro, presto) that correspond to certain bpm values. Of course, a number of alternative notations may be provided by adjusting time signatures (say, two beats per measure, or a half note receiving one beat) and note lengths. And while not depicted here, pitch properties for the notes may be depicted differently (e.g., D# or Eb), or a different key based on the same key signature (e.g., Bb major or G minor).
FIG. 5B illustrates notations 550, 575 corresponding to alternative musical interpretations of a second set of notes 5601-12. To highlight the timing aspects of musical interpretations, the notations 550, 575 are presented in a different style of transcription than the notations of FIG. 5A (e.g., without note pitch/frequency information depicted).
Notation 550 includes a time signature (i.e., 4/4 time 552), a feel (i.e., triplet feel 554), and a tempo (i.e., 60 bpm 556). Based on these characteristics, the notation 550 groups the notes 5601-12 as triplets 5651-4 within a single measure or bar 558, and relative to a time axis. Each triplet 565 also includes one triplet eighth note that corresponds to a major beat (i.e., 5601, 5604, 5607, 56010) within the bar 558.
Next, notation 575 includes a time signature (i.e., 3/4 time 576), a feel (i.e., straight feel 578), and a tempo (i.e., 90 bpm 580). Based on these characteristics, notation 575 groups the notes 5601-12 into eighth note pairs 5901-6 across two measures or bars 5821, 5822. Each eighth note pair 590 also includes one eighth note that corresponds to a major beat (i.e., 5601, 5603, 5605, . . . , 56011) within the bars 582.
As in FIG. 5A, the notations 550 and 575 provide alternative interpretations of essentially the same musical information (i.e., notes 5601-12). Using only note onset timing information, it may be difficult to identify a single “correct” interpretation of the notes 5601-12. However, the differences in the interpretations of the notes result in differences in numbers of bars, as well as the timing of major beats within those bars. The person of ordinary skill will appreciate that such differences in alternative notations may have an appreciable impact on the transcription of the musical content included in an audio signal, as well as on the generation of suitable real-time musical accompaniment, which is described in greater detail below. For example, a musician playing a piece of music (e.g., reproducing the musical content included in the audio signal, or playing an accompaniment part generated based on the musical content) that is interpreted according to notation 550 would play in a manner that is completely stylistically different than a piece of music interpreted according to notation 575.
While the examples provided here are relatively simple, the person of ordinary skill will also recognize that a plurality of notations may vary by a number of different musical characteristics, for example, a combination of different tempos and swing indicators, as well as pitch-based characteristics. And while the notations shown depict the musical notes objectively and accurately, an end-user will explicitly prefer (or at least would select) one of the notations for transcribing the musical content of the audio signal. Therefore, it may be beneficial to generate these multiple competing alternative notations in order to accommodate intangible or subjective factors, such as conscious or unconscious end-user preferences.
FIG. 6 illustrates selection of a musical notation and transcription using the selected musical notation, according to one embodiment. The display arrangement 600 may represent a display screen 605 of an electronic display device at a first time and a display screen 625 at a second time. The display screens 605, 625 include elements of a UI such as the UI 187.
Display screen 605 includes a number of notations 550, 575, and 610 corresponding to the notes 5601-12 described above in FIG. 5B, each notation displayed in a separate portion of the display screen 605. The notations may be displayed on the display screen in the transcription format (e.g., as the notations 550 and 575 appear in FIG. 5B) and/or may include information listed about the notation's musical characteristics (e.g., key of Bb major, 4/4 straight time, 160 bpm, and so forth).
The notations may be displayed in predetermined positions and/or ordered. In one embodiment, the notations are ordered according to the calculated score (i.e., notation 550 has the greatest score and corresponds to position 6061), with decreasing scores corresponding to positions 6062 and 6063.
Display screen 605 also includes an area 615 (“Other”) that an end-user may select to specify another notation for the audio signal. The end-user input may be selecting an entirely different generated notation (such as one not ranked and currently displayed on display screen 605) and/or may include one or more discrete changes specified by the end-user to a generated notation.
Upon selection of a notation, the computing device uses information about the selected notation to generate the transcription of the full audio signal. As shown, a user hand 620 selects notation 550 on display screen 605. Display screen 625 shows a transcription 640 of the audio signal according to the notation 550. In one embodiment, the notes 5601-12 that were displayed for end-user selection have already been transcribed 6301 according to the selected notation, and the computing device transcribes the portion 635 of transcription 640 corresponding to notes 56013-n (not shown but included in measures 6302-630k) after selection of the notation. While a sheet music format shown for the transcription 640, alternative transcriptions are possible. Additionally, the transcription 640 may include information regarding the dynamic content of the audio signal (e.g., volume changes, accents, etc.).
Generation of Real-Time Musical Accompaniment
Several embodiments are directed to performing real-time accompaniment for musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device. A musician who wishes to create a musical accompaniment signal suitable for output with an instrument signal (e.g., played by the musician) may train an auto-accompaniment system using the instrument signal. However, the musician typically must wait for completion of the processing before the accompaniment signal is suitable for playback, which causes an interruption in the performance of the instrument, if the process is not altogether asynchronous.
Auto-accompaniment devices may operate by receiving a form of audio signal or derivative signal, such as a MIDI signal, within a learning phase. In order to determine the most appropriate musical properties of the accompaniment signal (based on key, chord structure, number of bars, time signature, tempo, feel, etc.), a fairly complex post-processing analysis must occur after the musician indicates the learning phase is complete (e.g., at the end of a song part). This post-processing requires a significant amount of time, even on very fast modern signal processing devices.
FIG. 7 illustrates one example of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment for musical content included in a received audio signal, according to one embodiment. In some implementations, system 700 may be included within system 100 described above, for example, using extraction module 130 and accompaniment module 138.
System 700 is configured to receive, as one input, an audio signal 125 containing musical content. In some embodiments, the audio signal 125 may be produced by operating a musical instrument, such as a guitar. In other embodiments, the audio signal 125 may be in the form of a derivative audio signal, for example an output from a MIDI-based keyboard.
System 700 is further configured to receive one or more control inputs 735, 745. The control inputs 735, 745 generally cause the system 700 to operate in different modes. As shown, control input 735 corresponds to a “learning” mode of the system 700, and control input 745 corresponds to an “accompaniment” mode. In one embodiment, the system 700 during operation generally operates in a selected one of the available modes. Generally, the learning mode of operation is performed to analyze an audio signal before a suitable complementary audio signal is generated in the accompaniment mode. In one embodiment, an end-user may control the control inputs 735—and thus the operation of the system 700—using passive devices (e.g., one or more electrical switches) or active devices (e.g., through a graphical user interface of an electronic display device) associated with the UI of the system.
During operation, the audio signal 125 is received by a feature extraction module 705 of the extraction module 130, which is generally configured to perform real-time musical feature extraction of the audio signal. Real-time analysis may also be performed using the preliminary analysis module 715, discussed below. Many musical features may be used in the process of performing a more comprehensive musical information analysis, such as note onsets, audio levels, polyphonic note detections, etc. In one embodiment, the feature extraction module 705 may perform real-time extraction substantially continuously for received audio signals. In one embodiment, real-time extraction is performed irrespective of the states of the control input(s). The system 700 may use the feature extraction module 705 to extract useful information from the audio signal 125 even absent an end-user's explicit instructions (as evidenced by the control inputs). In this way, any events that happen prior to an end-user-indicated start time (i.e., at beginning of the learning mode) can be captured. In one embodiment, the feature extraction module 705 operates on received audio signals prior to operation of the system 700 in the learning mode.
During operation, an end-user may operate the UI to instruct the system 700 to transition into learning mode. For example, to transition to learning mode, the end-user may operate a switch, such as a footswitch of a guitar pedal, or make a selection using a GUI. In some embodiments, the system 700 may be configured to “auto-arm” such that the feature extraction module 705 enters the learning mode automatically upon detecting a first note onset of a received audio signal.
Upon entering the learning mode, the system may operate the preliminary analysis module 715, which is configured to perform a limited analysis of the audio signal 125 in real-time. An example of the limited analysis includes determining a key of the musical content of the audio signal. Of course, additional or alternative analysis may be performed—generally with respect to pitch and/or timing information—but the analysis may determine only a limited set of characteristics so that the analysis may be completed substantially in real-time (in other words, without an appreciable delay, and able to process portions of the audio signal as they are received). In one embodiment, the preliminary analysis module 715 also determines an intended first musical chord corresponding to the audio signal 125.
After the performance of a certain amount of a musical song, an end-user may indicate completion of the learning phase and beginning of the accompaniment phase. The performed amount contained in the audio signal 125 can reflect any amount of the song desired by the end-user, but in some cases it may feel more natural for an end-user to provide the transition indication at the end of a particular section (or other subdivision) of the song, e.g., before repeating the section or before beginning another section. In one embodiment, the end-user operates a footswitch to provide the appropriate control input 745 to the system to indicate that accompaniment should begin.
In one embodiment, accompaniment module 138 outputs one or more complementary audio signals 155 substantially immediately when the end-user provides the indication to transition to the accompaniment mode. “Substantially immediately” is generally defined based on the end-user's perception of the relative timing of the audio signal and the complementary audio signal 155. In one embodiment, “substantially immediately” includes outputting the complementary audio signal prior to or at the same time as a next beat within the audio signal. In one embodiment, “substantially immediately” includes outputting the complementary audio signal within an amount of time that is audibly imperceptible for the end-user, such as within 40 ms or less. By beginning output of the accompaniment signals “substantially immediately,” the system 700 gives an end-user the impression that the operation of the footswitch or other UI element has triggered an immediate accompaniment. This impression may be particularly important to end-users, who would prefer a continuous, uninterrupted musical performance instead of the disruption caused by stopping for completion of processing, and restarting when the accompaniment signal has been generated.
In some embodiments, the initial portion of the complementary audio signals, which are output “substantially immediately,” corresponds to the limited preliminary analysis of the audio signal performed by preliminary analysis module 715. Accordingly, those initial portions of the complementary audio signals 155 may be generated with less musical complexity than later portions that are produced after a full analysis is completed on the received audio signal. In one embodiment, a single note or chord is produced and output for the initial portion of the complementary audio signals 155, and which note or chord may or may not be held until completion of the full analysis of the audio signal. In one embodiment, the initial portion of the complementary audio signal is based on one of a determined key and a determined first chord of the audio signal.
The complementary audio signals 155 may be generated corresponding to one or more distinct instrument parts. In one embodiment, the accompaniment module 138 outputs the complementary audio signal for the same instrument(s) used to produce the audio signal 125. For example, for an input signal from a guitar, the output complementary audio signal may correspond to a guitar part. In another embodiment, the accompaniment module 138 outputs complementary audio signals 155 for one or more different instruments. For example, an input guitar signal may correspond to complementary audio signals generated for a bass guitar and/or a drum set. In this way, the system 700 may be used to effectively turn a single musician into a “one-man band” having several instrument parts. Additionally, the real-time accompaniment aspects make system 700 suitable for use in live musical performance or recording. The adaptive nature of the feature extraction and real-time accompaniment also makes system 700 suitable for musical performance that includes improvisation, which may be common within certain styles or genres of performed music such as jazz, blues, etc.
Beyond triggering the output of complementary audio signals 155, the end-user's indication to transition into accompaniment mode may also signal to the system 700 to begin a more complete analysis of the audio signal 725 (i.e., with full analysis module 725) in order to produce subsequent portions of the complementary audio signal that are more musically complex and that follow the initial portion of the complementary audio signal. For example, the features extracted within the learning mode may be analyzed to determine a number of parameters needed to produce suitable complementary audio signals. Examples of determined parameters include: a length of the song section or part, a number of bars or measures, a chord progression, a number of beats per measure, a tempo, and a type of rhythm or feel (e.g., straight or swing time).
In some embodiments, using efficient programming techniques (such as dynamic programming) on modern processors makes it possible to complete analysis of the extracted features before the next major beat within the audio signal occurs. In that way, it is possible for the subsequent portions to begin with the next major beat of the audio signal, giving the end-user an impression of continuous musical flow between learning mode and accompaniment mode. Even where processing requires additional time to complete, if at least the initial portion of the complementary audio signal begins in sync with the first beat of the audio signal, an end-user may still find this acceptably continuous for musical performance so long as the subsequent portions begin within a reasonably short amount of time. In one embodiment, the first subsequent portion following the initial portion begins corresponding to a subdivision of the musical content of the audio signal, such as synchronized with the next beat, the beginning of the next measure or section, etc.
FIG. 8 is a chart illustrating one example of a timing of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment, according to one embodiment. The chart 800 generally corresponds to operation of the system 700 and the description provided thereof.
Chart 800 shows, on a first plot, an audio signal 805. The audio signal may correspond to a guitar part or to another instrument part. The audio signal 805 includes four repeated sections 8101, 8102, 8103, 8104 (i.e., each containing similar musical information, with perhaps minor variability in the audio signal due to human performance, noise, etc.). Each of the sections 810 begins at a respective time t0, t1, t2, t3, which are depicted on a second plot (i.e., Time).
Another included plot, labeled Analysis, provides an overview of the signal processing performed across various modes of the system 700. A first period 815 includes a continuous extraction mode in which a particular set of musical features are extracted from received audio signals. In one embodiment, this mode begins prior to receiving the audio signal 805 (i.e., prior to t0). The set of musical features to be extracted may be limited from a full analysis of the audio signal performed later. Example features extracted during the period 815 include note onsets, audio levels, polyphonic note detection, and so forth. Within period 815, the system 700 may update the extracted features more or less continuously, or may update the features at one or more discrete time intervals (i.e., times A, B, C).
At time D, which corresponds to time t1, an end-user operates an element of the UI to instruct the system 700 to enter learning mode. In one embodiment, this includes the end-user operating an electrical switch (e.g., stepping on a footpedal switch). In another embodiment, this includes selecting the mode using a displayed GUI. The end-user may operate the UI at any time relative to the music of the audio signal, but in some cases may choose to transition modes at a natural transition point (such as between consecutive sections 810).
Responsive to the end-user input, the system enters learning mode and begins a preliminary analysis of the received audio signal during a first subperiod 825 of the period 820A. The preliminary analysis may be performed using the features extracted during the period 815 and may include determining an additional set of features of the music content of audio signal 805. Some examples of determined features from the preliminary analysis include a key of the music content of the audio signal 805, a first chord of the audio signal, a timing of major beats within the audio signal, and so forth. In one embodiment, the set of features determined during preliminary analysis (i.e., subperiod 825) may require more processing than the set of features determined during period 815. Making a determination of the particular set of features may be completed prior to entering an accompaniment mode (i.e., at a time E). In one embodiment, completion of the preliminary analysis triggers entering the accompaniment mode (i.e., time F). In another embodiment, the system remains in learning mode, awaiting input from an end-user to transition to accompaniment mode, and may perform additional processing on the audio signal 805. The additional processing may include updating the set of features determined by the preliminary analysis (continuously or periodically) and/or may include performing a next phase (e.g., corresponding to some or all of the “full analysis,” discussed below) of feature determination for the audio signal.
One example method suitable for use in a preliminary analysis of audio signals includes:
First, the system determines the nearest note onset following the time at which the end-user started the learning mode. Next, during a predetermined interval (e.g., an “early” learning phase), the system analyzes detected musical notes and specifically attempts to group the detected notes into chords that have a similar root.
Next, the system applies a second grouping algorithm that combines disjointed chord segments having the same root, even where the chord segments may be separated by other segments. In one embodiment, the other segments may include one or more unstable segments of a relatively short duration.
Next, the system determines whether, during the predetermined interval, a suitably stable chord root was found. If the stable chord root was found, the note may be saved as a possible starting note for complementary audio signals.
If the chord root was not sufficiently stable, the system may continue monitoring the incoming musical notes from the audio signal and use any known techniques to estimate the key of the musical content. The system may use the root note of this estimated key as the starting note for complementary audio signals. The example method ends following this step.
At time F, the system 700 enters the accompaniment mode, during which one or more complementary audio signals 840, 850 are generated and/or output to associated audio output devices such as speakers or headphones. The transition of modes may be triggered by an end-user operating an element of the UI, which generally indicates an end of the learning mode to the system 700. An explicit signaling of the end of learning mode allows the system to make an initial estimate of the intended length of the musical performance captured in the audio signal 805. The system may thus generally associate a greater confidence with the musical features determined during the learning mode (or at least the state of the musical features at the time of transition, time F) when compared with earlier times in the analysis where it was unsure whether the audio signal would include significantly more and/or significantly different musical content to be analyzed.
Upon entering the accompaniment mode (or alternately, upon terminating the learning mode), the system 700 performs a full analysis of the musical content of the audio signal 805. The full analysis may include determining yet further musical features, so that the amounts of features determined increases for each stage or mode in the sequence (e.g., continuous extraction mode to learning mode to accompaniment mode). In the full analysis, the system may determine a number of musical parameters necessary to produce suitable complementary audio signals. Examples of determined parameters include: a length of the song section or part, a number of bars or measures, a chord progression, a number of beats per measure, a tempo, and a type of rhythm or feel (e.g., straight or swing time). In one embodiment, full analysis begins only after the transition from learning mode into accompaniment mode. In another embodiment, some or all of the feature determination for full analysis begins in the learning mode following completion of the feature determination of the preliminary analysis.
To provide an end-user the impression that operation of the UI element triggers an immediate accompaniment that is suitable for musical performance without interruption, the system may begin output of the complementary audio signal(s) substantially immediately (defined more fully above) at time G upon receiving the input at time F to transition into the accompaniment mode. In one embodiment, the interval between times F and G is audibly imperceptible for the end-user, such as an interval of 40 ms or less.
However, in some cases, the time required to complete the full analysis on the audio signal 805 may extend beyond time G. This time is shown as subperiod 820B. In some embodiments, in order to provide the “immediate accompaniment” impression to the end-user despite the full analysis being partially complete, the system 700 generates an initial portion of the complementary audio signal based on the analysis completed (e.g., the preliminary analysis or a completed portion of the full analysis). The initial portion is represented by subperiod 842 of complementary audio signal 840. In one embodiment, the initial portion may include a single note or chord, which in some cases may be held for the length of the subperiod 842.
Upon completion of the full analysis at time H, the system may generate subsequent portion(s) of the complementary audio signal that are based on the full analysis. One subsequent portion is depicted for time subperiods 844 and 854 of complementary audio signals 840 and 850, respectively. Generally, the subsequent portions may be more musically complex than the initial portion because the full musical analysis is available to generate the complementary audio signal. To provide the impression of seamlessness to an end-user, in one embodiment the system 700 may delay output of the subsequent portions of the complementary audio signal to correspond with a next determined subdivision (e.g., a next beat, major beat, measure, phrase, part, etc.) of the audio signal. This determined delay is represented by the time interval between times H and I.
In one embodiment, a plurality of complementary audio signals 840, 850 are generated, each of which may correspond to a different instrument part (such as a bass guitar, or a drum set). In one embodiment, all of the complementary audio signals generated include an initial portion (e.g., simpler than subsequent portions) of the same time length. In other embodiments, however, one or more of the complementary audio signals may have different lengths of initial portions, or some complementary audio signals do not include an initial portion at all. If certain types of analysis of the audio signal 805 differ in complexity or are more or less processor intensive, or if generating certain parts in the complementary audio signal is more or less processor intensive, the system 700 may corresponding prioritize the analysis of the audio signal and/or generation of complementary audio signals. For example, producing a bass guitar part requires determining correct frequency information (note pitches) as well as timing information (matching the rhythm of the audio signal), while a drum part may require only timing information. Thus, in one embodiment, the system 700 may prioritize determining beats or rhythm within the analysis of the input audio signal, so that even if the processing needed to determine the bass guitar part requires generating an initial, simpler portion (e.g., complementary audio signal 840), the drum part may begin full performance and need not include an initial, simpler portion (e.g., complementary audio signal 850). Such a sequenced or layered introduction of different musical instruments' parts may also enhance the realism or seamless impression to an end-user. Of course, in another embodiment, the system 700 could prioritize those parts requiring additional analysis, so that all the musical parts are completed at an earlier time without having staggered introductions. In one embodiment, layered or same-time introduction may be end-user selectable, e.g., through the UI.
FIG. 9 illustrates one example of an implementation of a system for performing real-time musical accompaniment, according to one embodiment. The implementation depicts a guitar footpedal 900 having a housing 905 with circuitry enclosed therein. The circuitry may generally correspond to portions of the computing device 105 that are depicted and described for systems 100 and 700 (e.g., including processors 110, memory 120 with various functional modules). For simplicity, portions of the footpedal may not be explicitly depicted or described but would be understood by the person of ordinary skill in the art.
Footpedal 900 supports one or more inputs and one or more outputs to the system. As shown, the housing 905 may include openings to support wired connections through an audio input port 955, a control input port 960, one or more audio output ports 9701, 9702, and a data input/output port 975. In another embodiment, one or more of the ports may include a wireless connection with a computing device, a musical instrument, an audio output device, etc. The audio output ports 9701, 9702 may each provide a separate output audio signal, such as the complementary audio signals generated corresponding to different instrument parts, or perhaps reflecting different processing performed on the same audio signal(s). In one embodiment, the data input/output port 975 may be used to provide automatic transcription of signals received at the audio input port 955.
The housing 905 supports one or more UI elements, such as a plurality of knobs 910, a footswitch 920, and visual indicators 930 such as LEDs. The knobs 910 may each control a separate function of the musical analysis and/or accompaniment. In one embodiment, the genre selection knob 910A allows the user to select the type of accompaniment to match specific musical genres, the style selection knob 910B indicates which styles best match the automatic transcription (for example, using colors or brightness to indicate how well the particular style matches), and the tempo adjustment knob 910C is used to cause the accompaniment being generated to speed up or slow down, for example, to facilitate practicing. The bass (volume) level knob 910D and drum level knob 910E control the level of each instrument in the output mix. Of course, alternative functions may be provided. Knobs 910 may include a selection marker 915 (e.g., selection marker 915A) whose orientation indicates a continuous (bass level knob 910D or drum level knob 910E) or discrete selected position (genre knob 910A). Knobs 910 may also correspond to visual indicators (e.g., indicators 9179-11 are shown), which may be illuminated based on the position or turning of the knob, etc. The colors and/or brightness levels may be variable and can be used to indicate information such as how well as a style matches a learned performance.
The footswitch 920 may be operated to select modes such as a learning mode and an accompaniment mode. In one configuration, the footpedal 900 is powered on and by default enters a continuous extraction mode. An end-user may then press the footswitch 920 a first time to cause the system to enter the learning mode (which may be indicated by illuminating visual indicator 930A), and a second time to cause the system to terminate the learning mode and/or to enter the accompaniment mode (corresponding to visual indicator 930B). Of course, other configurations are possible, such as time-based transitions between modes.
The housing 905 also supports UI elements selecting and/or indicating other functionality, such as pushbutton 942 which in some cases may be illuminated. The pushbutton 942 may be used to select and/or indicate the application of desired audio processing effects using processors 110 to the input signal (“Guitar FX” 940). In one embodiment, pressing the Guitar FX 940 button one time will illuminate the button as green and result in effects which are most appropriate for strumming a guitar, and pressing the button again will turn the button to red and result in effects most appropriate for lead guitar playing. Similar pushbuttons or elements may also be provided to select and/or indicate one or more musical parts 945 (which may be stored in memory 120), as well as an alternate time 950. In one embodiment, the alternate time button 950 can be illuminated such that it can flash green at the current tempo setting as determined by the automatic transcription and setting of the tempo knob 910C. When pressed, the indicator can flash red at a tempo that is an alternate tempo that still provides a good match to the automatic transcription, for example a tempo that is double or half of the original tempo.
FIG. 10 illustrates a method of performing real-time musical accompaniment for musical content included in a received audio signal, according to one embodiment. The method 1000 may generally be used with systems 100, 700 and consistent with the description of FIGS. 7-9 described above.
Method 1000 begins at block 1005, where an audio signal is received by a system. The audio signal includes musical content, which may include a vocal signal, an instrument signal, and/or a signal derived from a vocal or instrument signal. The audio signal may be recorded (i.e., received from a memory) or generated live through musical performance. The audio signal may be represented in any suitable format, whether analog or digital.
At block 1015, a portion of the audio signal is optionally sampled. At block 1025, the system processes at least the sampled portion of the audio signal to extract musical information from the corresponding musical content. In one embodiment, the system processes the entire received audio signal. In one embodiment, the processing and extraction of musical information occurs during a plurality of stages or phases, each of which may correspond to a different mode of system operation. In one embodiment, the musical feature set increases in number and/or complexity for each subsequent stage of processing.
At block 1035, the system optionally maintains the extracted musical information for a most recent period of time, which has a predetermined length. Generally, this may correspond to updating the musical information at a predetermined interval. In one embodiment, updating the musical information may include discarding a previous set of extracted musical information.
At block 1045, the system determines complementary musical information that is musically compatible with the extracted musical information. This may be performed by an accompaniment module. At block 1055, the system generates one or more complementary audio signals corresponding to the complementary musical information. In one embodiment, the complementary audio signals correspond to different musical instruments, which may differ from the instrument used to produce the received audio signal.
At block 1065, the complementary audio signals are output contemporaneously with receiving the audio signal. Generally, the complementary audio signals are output using audio output devices coupled with the system. The beginning time for the output complementary audio signals may be controlled by an end-user through a UI element of the system. The timing of the complementary audio signals may be determined to provide an impression of a seamless, uninterrupted musical performance for the end-user, who in some cases may be playing a musical instrument corresponding to the received audio signal. In one embodiment, the complementary audio signals include initial portions having a lesser musical complexity and subsequent portions having a greater musical complexity, based on an ongoing completion of processing of the received audio signal. In one embodiment, the output of the complementary audio signals occurs within a short period of time that is audibly imperceptible for an end-user, such as within 40 ms of the indicated beginning time. In one embodiment, the system may delay output of portions of the complementary audio signal to correspond with a determined subdivision of the audio signal, such as a next major beat, a beat, a phrase, a part, and so forth. Method 1000 ends following block 1065.
The descriptions of the various embodiments of the present disclosure have been presented for purposes of illustration, but are not intended to be exhaustive or limited to the embodiments disclosed. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of the described embodiments. The terminology used herein was chosen to best explain the principles of the embodiments, the practical application or technical improvement over technologies found in the marketplace, or to enable others of ordinary skill in the art to understand the embodiments disclosed herein.
In the preceding, reference is made to embodiments presented in this disclosure. However, the scope of the present disclosure is not limited to specific described embodiments. Instead, any combination of the preceding features and elements, whether related to different embodiments or not, is contemplated to implement and practice contemplated embodiments. Furthermore, although embodiments disclosed herein may achieve advantages over other possible solutions or over the prior art, whether or not a particular advantage is achieved by a given embodiment is not limiting of the scope of the present disclosure. Thus, the preceding aspects, features, embodiments and advantages are merely illustrative and are not considered elements or limitations of the appended claims except where explicitly recited in a claim(s). Likewise, reference to “the invention” shall not be construed as a generalization of any inventive subject matter disclosed herein and shall not be considered to be an element or limitation of the appended claims except where explicitly recited in a claim(s).
Aspects of the present disclosure may take the form of an entirely hardware embodiment, an entirely software embodiment (including firmware, resident software, micro-code, etc.) or an embodiment combining software and hardware aspects that may all generally be referred to herein as a “circuit,” “module” or “system.”
The present disclosure may be embodied as any of a system, a method, and/or a computer program product. The computer program product may include a computer readable storage medium (or media) having computer readable program instructions thereon for causing a processor to carry out aspects of the present disclosure.
The computer readable storage medium can be a tangible device that can retain and store instructions for use by an instruction execution device. The computer readable storage medium may be, for example, but is not limited to, an electronic storage device, a magnetic storage device, an optical storage device, an electromagnetic storage device, a semiconductor storage device, or any suitable combination of the foregoing. A non-exhaustive list of more specific examples of the computer readable storage medium includes the following: a portable computer diskette, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or Flash memory), a static random access memory (SRAM), a portable compact disc read-only memory (CD-ROM), a digital versatile disk (DVD), a memory stick, a floppy disk, a mechanically encoded device such as punch-cards or raised structures in a groove having instructions recorded thereon, and any suitable combination of the foregoing. A computer readable storage medium, as used herein, is not to be construed as being transitory signals per se, such as radio waves or other freely propagating electromagnetic waves, electromagnetic waves propagating through a waveguide or other transmission media (e.g., light pulses passing through a fiber-optic cable), or electrical signals transmitted through a wire.
Computer readable program instructions described herein can be downloaded to respective computing/processing devices from a computer readable storage medium or to an external computer or external storage device via a network, for example, the Internet, a local area network, a wide area network and/or a wireless network. The network may comprise copper transmission cables, optical transmission fibers, wireless transmission, routers, firewalls, switches, gateway computers and/or edge servers. A network adapter card or network interface in each computing/processing device receives computer readable program instructions from the network and forwards the computer readable program instructions for storage in a computer readable storage medium within the respective computing/processing device.
Computer readable program instructions for carrying out operations of the present disclosure may be assembler instructions, instruction-set-architecture (ISA) instructions, machine instructions, machine dependent instructions, microcode, firmware instructions, state-setting data, or either source code or object code written in any combination of one or more programming languages, including an object oriented programming language such as Smalltalk, C++ or the like, and conventional procedural programming languages, such as the “C” programming language or similar programming languages. The computer readable program instructions may execute entirely on the user's computer, partly on the user's computer, as a stand-alone software package, partly on the user's computer and partly on a remote computer or entirely on the remote computer or server. In the latter scenario, the remote computer may be connected to the user's computer through any type of network, including a local area network (LAN) or a wide area network (WAN), or the connection may be made to an external computer (for example, through the Internet using an Internet Service Provider). In some embodiments, electronic circuitry including, for example, programmable logic circuitry, field-programmable gate arrays (FPGA), or programmable logic arrays (PLA) may execute the computer readable program instructions by utilizing state information of the computer readable program instructions to personalize the electronic circuitry, in order to perform aspects of the present disclosure.
Aspects of the present disclosure are described herein with reference to flowchart illustrations and/or block diagrams of methods, apparatus (systems), and computer program products according to embodiments of the disclosure. It will be understood that each block of the flowchart illustrations and/or block diagrams, and combinations of blocks in the flowchart illustrations and/or block diagrams, can be implemented by computer readable program instructions.
These computer readable program instructions may be provided to a processor of a general purpose computer, special purpose computer, or other programmable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such that the instructions, which execute via the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing apparatus, may be implemented to execute or perform the functions/acts specified in the flowchart and/or block diagram block or blocks. These computer readable program instructions may also be stored in a computer readable storage medium that can direct a computer, a programmable data processing apparatus, and/or other devices to function in a particular manner, such that the computer readable storage medium having instructions stored therein comprises an article of manufacture including instructions which implement aspects of the function/act specified in the flowchart and/or block diagram block or blocks.
The computer readable program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer, other programmable data processing apparatus, or other device to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer, other programmable apparatus or other device to produce a computer implemented process, such that the instructions which execute on the computer, other programmable apparatus, or other device implement the functions/acts specified in the flowchart and/or block diagram block or blocks.
The flowchart and block diagrams in the Figures illustrate the architecture, functionality, and operation of possible implementations of systems, methods, and computer program products according to various embodiments of the present disclosure. In this regard, each block in the flowchart or block diagrams may represent a module, segment, or portion of instructions, which comprises one or more executable instructions for implementing the specified logical function(s). In some alternative implementations, the functions noted in the block may occur out of the order noted in the figures. For example, two blocks shown in succession may, in fact, be executed substantially concurrently, or the blocks may sometimes be executed in the reverse order, depending upon the functionality involved. It will also be noted that each block of the block diagrams and/or flowchart illustration, and combinations of blocks in the block diagrams and/or flowchart illustration, can be implemented by special purpose hardware-based systems that perform the specified functions or acts or carry out combinations of special purpose hardware and computer instructions.
Embodiments of the disclosure may be provided to end users through a cloud computing infrastructure. Cloud computing generally refers to the provision of scalable computing resources as a service over a network. More formally, cloud computing may be defined as a computing capability that provides an abstraction between the computing resource and its underlying technical architecture (e.g., servers, storage, networks), enabling convenient, on-demand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction. Thus, cloud computing allows a user to access virtual computing resources (e.g., storage, data, applications, and even complete virtualized computing systems) in “the cloud,” without regard for the underlying physical systems (or locations of those systems) used to provide the computing resources.
Typically, cloud computing resources are provided to a user on a pay-per-use basis, where users are charged only for the computing resources actually used (e.g., an amount of storage space consumed by a user or a number of virtualized systems instantiated by the user). A user can access any of the resources that reside in the cloud at any time, and from anywhere across the Internet. In context of the present disclosure, a user may access applications (e.g., that include one or more of the functional modules shown in memory 120) or related data (e.g., information from user profiles 170) available in the cloud. For example, the scoring module 134 could execute on a computing system in the cloud and its scoring algorithms may be adaptively updated based on aggregated data from different user profiles, genres, etc. In such a case, the scoring module 134 could store iterations of the scoring algorithms at a storage location in the cloud, which may be accessed by end-users' various computing devices to provide the most advanced or improved performance of the system 100. Doing so allows a user to access this information from any computing system attached to a network connected to the cloud (e.g., through the Internet).
While example embodiments are described above, it is not intended that these embodiments describe all possible forms of the invention. Rather, the words used in the specification are words of description rather than limitation, and it is understood that various changes may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Additionally, the features of various implementing embodiments may be combined to form further embodiments of the invention.

## Claims

1. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generating for each of the plurality of musical notations, a respective matching score that indicates a measure of matching the received audio signal,
wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is based on the generated plurality of matching scores.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
presenting the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device,
wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed by the end-user using an input device coupled with the computing device.

3. The method of claim 2, further comprising:
presenting an alternative musical notation from the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device; and
selecting the alternative musical notation via an input device with the computing device.

4. The method of claim 3 wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a half time notation and a double time notation.

5. The method of claim 3 wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a 4/4 notation and a 3/4 notation.

6. The method of claim 3 wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a straight time and a swing time.

7. The method of claim 1 further comprising generating a score for each of the plurality of musical notations.

8. The method of claim 7 wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of notations is at least partially based on matching onset locations detected in the audio signal to expected beat locations of a particular musical notation.

9. The method of claim 7 wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on matching at least one of a time location and a duration of a note or a chord detected in the audio signal to at least one of an expected time location and a duration of a note or a chord in a particular musical notation.

10. The method of claim 7 wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is further based on (i) matching onset locations detected in the audio signal to expected beat locations of a particular musical notation and (ii) matching at least one of a time location and a duration of a note or a chord detected in the audio signal to at least one of an expected time location and a duration of a note or a chord in the particular musical notation.

11. The method of claim 7 wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on a priori probabilities of a particular musical notation.

12. The method of claim 7 wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on a history of use.

13. The method of claim 1, wherein the selected one of the plurality of musical notations corresponds to the largest matching score.

14. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
presenting, to an end-user of the computing device, a subset of the plurality of musical notations corresponding to two or more largest matching scores of the plurality of matching scores,
wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed by the end-user on the two or more largest matching scores using an input device coupled with the computing device.

15. The method of claim 1, wherein generating the plurality of matching scores is based on at least one of a specified musical genre and a profile of an end-user.

16. The method of claim 1, wherein the plurality of musical notations differ by at least one of key signature, time signature, meter, and note values.

17. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
determining, using the computing device, complementary musical information that is musically compatible with the extracted musical information,
wherein the transcribed musical content also includes the complementary musical information.

18. The method of claim 17, wherein the audio signal is generated using a first type of musical instrument, and wherein the complementary musical information is generated for a second type of musical instrument.

19. A computer-program product to perform automatic transcription of musical content included in a received audio signal, the computer-program product comprising:
a computer-readable storage medium having computer-readable program code embodied therewith, the computer-readable program code executable by one or more computer processors to:
process the received first audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generate a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
apply a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generate a score for each of the plurality of musical notations,
wherein the one or more computer processors execute the computer-readable program code to generate the score for each of the plurality of musical notations at least partially based on matching onset locations detected in the audio signal to expected beat locations of a particular musical notation.

20. A musical transcription device for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in a received audio signal, the device comprising:
one or more computer processors configured to:
process the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generate a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
apply a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
output the transcribed musical content,

wherein plurality of musical notations differ by at least one of key signature, time signature, meter, and note values.

21. The musical transcription device of claim 20, wherein output of the transcribed musical content is performed using a display device coupled with the one or more computer processors.

22. The musical transcription device of claim 20, wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed using an input device coupled with the one or more computer processors.

23. The musical transcription device of claim 20, wherein the one or more computer processors are further configured to:
determine complementary musical information that is musically compatible with the extracted musical information,
wherein output of the transcribed musical content also includes the complementary musical information.

24. The musical transcription device of claim 23, wherein the one or more computer processors are further configured to:
generate a complementary audio signal corresponding to the complementary musical information; and
output, contemporaneously with the received audio signal, the complementary audio signal using an audio output device coupled with the one or more computer processors.

25. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generating a score for each of the plurality of musical notations,
wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on matching at least one of a time location and a duration of a note or a chord detected in the audio signal to at least one of an expected time location and a duration of a note or a chord in a particular musical notation.

26. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generating a score for each of the plurality of musical notations,
wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is further based on (i) matching onset locations detected in the audio signal to expected beat locations of a particular musical notation and (ii) matching at least one of a time location and a duration of a note or a chord detected in the audio signal to at least one of an expected time location and a duration of a note or a chord in the particular musical notation.

27. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generating a score for each of the plurality of musical notations,
wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on a priori probabilities of a particular musical notation.

28. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
generating a score for each of the plurality of musical notations,
wherein generating the score for each of the plurality of musical notations is at least partially based on a history of use.

29. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
determining, using the computing device, complementary musical information that is musically compatible with the extracted musical information,
wherein the transcribed musical content also includes the complementary musical information.

30. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal;
presenting the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device, wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed by the end-user using an input device coupled with the computing device,
presenting an alternative musical notation from the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device; and
selecting the alternative musical notation via an input device with the computing device,
wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a half time notation and a double time notation.

31. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal;
presenting the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device, wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed by the end-user using an input device coupled with the computing device,
presenting an alternative musical notation from the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device; and
selecting the alternative musical notation via an input device with the computing device,
wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a 4/4 notation and a 3/4 notation.

32. A method of performing automatic transcription of musical content included in an audio signal received by a computing device, the method comprising:
processing, using the computing device, the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generating, using the computing device, a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
applying a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal;
presenting the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device, wherein selecting one of the plurality of musical notations is performed by the end-user using an input device coupled with the computing device,
presenting an alternative musical notation from the plurality of musical notations to an end-user of the computing device; and
selecting the alternative musical notation via an input device with the computing device,
wherein the alternative musical notation corresponds to one of a straight time and a swing time.

33. A musical transcription device for performing automatic transcription of musical content included in a received audio signal, the device comprising:
one or more computer processors configured to:
process the received audio signal to extract musical information characterizing at least a portion of the musical content;
generate a plurality of musical notations representing different musical interpretations of the extracted musical information;
apply a selected one of the plurality of musical notations for transcribing the musical content of the received audio signal; and
output the transcribed musical content; and
determine complementary musical information that is musically compatible with the extracted musical information;

wherein output of the transcribed musical content also includes the complementary musical information.