# Patent

## Title
Patient selection using a transluminally-applied electric current

## Abstract

Apparatus for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of a subject is provided, comprising (1) an ablation unit, configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a first portion of the nerve tissue; (2) at least one electrode unit, coupled to the ablation unit, and configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a second portion of the nerve tissue, and to initiate unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue, such that the unidirectional action potentials propagate toward the first portion of the nerve tissue; and (3) a control unit, configured: (a) to drive the ablation unit to ablate, at least in part, the first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject, and (b) to drive the at least one electrode unit to initiate the unidirectional action potentials by applying an excitatory current to the second portion of the nerve tissue.

## Background
CROSS-REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
The present application claims priority from U.S. Provisional Patent Application 61/722,293 to Gross, filed Nov. 5, 2012.


FIELD OF THE INVENTION
Applications of the present invention relate generally to ablation of tissue. Some applications of the present invention relate more specifically to ablation of tissue of the renal artery.
BACKGROUND
Hypertension is a prevalent condition in the general population, particularly in older individuals. Sympathetic nervous pathways, such as those involving the renal nerve, are known to play a role in regulating blood pressure. Ablation of renal nerve tissue from the renal artery is a known technique for treating hypertension.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Some applications of the invention comprise detecting one or more values indicative of blood pressure of the subject while blocking endogenous action potentials and/or initiating induced action potentials in the renal nerve of the subject. Based on these one or more values, the potential benefit of a first and/or a successive application of ablative energy to the renal nerve may be predicted. For some applications of the invention, a control unit controls the blocking, initiating, and ablating, and automatically applies (or automatically does not apply) the first and/or successive application of ablative energy.
There is therefore provided, in accordance with an application of the present invention, apparatus for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of a subject, the apparatus including:
an ablation unit, configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject;
at least one electrode unit, coupled to the ablation unit, and configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a second portion of the nerve tissue of the subject, and to initiate unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue, such that the unidirectional action potentials propagate toward the first portion of the nerve tissue; and
a control unit, configured:

    
    
        to drive the ablation unit to ablate, at least in part, the first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject, and
        to drive the at least one electrode unit to initiate the unidirectional action potentials by applying an excitatory current to the second portion of the nerve tissue.
    
    


In an application, the at least one electrode unit includes a first electrode unit and a second electrode unit, the first electrode unit being coupled to the ablation unit on a first side of the ablation unit, and the second electrode unit being coupled to the ablation unit on a second side of the ablation unit, each electrode unit being configured to initiate unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue, such that the action potentials propagate toward the first portion of the nerve tissue.
In an application, the ablation unit includes a radio-frequency ablation unit, and the control unit is configured to drive the radio-frequency ablation unit to ablate the first portion of the nerve tissue by applying an ablative radio-frequency current to the first portion of the nerve tissue.
In an application, the ablation unit includes an ultrasound ablation unit, and the control unit is configured to drive the ultrasound ablation unit to ablate the first portion of the nerve tissue by applying ablative ultrasound energy to the first portion of the nerve tissue.
In an application, the electrode unit is configured to apply a non-ablative blocking current to the second portion of the nerve tissue of the subject, the non-ablative blocking current being configured to reversibly block endogenous action potentials from propagating through the second portion of the nerve tissue, and the control unit is configured to drive the at least one electrode unit to apply the non-ablative blocking current.
In an application, the nerve tissue includes nerve tissue of a blood vessel of the subject, and at least the ablation unit is configured to be transluminally delivered to the blood vessel of the subject.
In an application, the electrode unit is configured to be transluminally delivered to the blood vessel of the subject.
In an application, the blood vessel includes a renal artery of the subject, and at least the ablation unit is configured to be transluminally delivered to the renal artery of the subject.
In an application, the apparatus further includes a longitudinal member, having a distal portion that is configured to be percutaneously advanced toward the nerve tissue of the subject, and the ablation unit and the electrode unit are coupled to the longitudinal member.
In an application, the distal portion of the longitudinal member is bifurcated so as to have two distal portions, each distal portion being configured to be transluminally advanced into a respective renal artery of the subject.
In an application, the apparatus further includes a sensor, configured to detect a physiological response of the subject to the unidirectional action potentials initiated by the electrode unit.
In an application, the apparatus further includes a longitudinal member, configured to be percutaneously advanced toward the nerve tissue of the subject, and the ablation unit, the electrode unit, and the sensor are coupled to the longitudinal member.
In an application, the sensor is configured to be disposed in an aorta of the subject.
In an application, the sensor includes a blood pressure sensor.
In an application, the control unit is configured to receive information indicative of the detected physiological response, and to drive the ablation unit at least in part responsively to the information indicative of the detected physiological response.
In an application, the control unit is configured:
to drive, during a first period, the at least one electrode unit to apply a non-ablative blocking current to the second portion of the nerve tissue of the subject, the blocking current being configured to temporarily block endogenous action potentials from propagating through the second portion of the nerve tissue,
to receive a first value of a factor indicative of the response, the first value being detected after a start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current, and
to drive the ablation unit at least in part responsively to the received first value.
In an application, the control unit is configured:
to drive, during a second period, the at least one electrode unit to apply the excitatory current,
to receive a second value of the factor, the second value being detected after a start of the application of the excitatory current, and
to drive the ablation unit at least in part responsively to the received second value.
In an application, the sensor is configured to detect the first value of the factor after the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current, and to provide the first value of the factor to the control unit.
There is further provided, in accordance with an application of the present invention, apparatus for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of a subject, the nerve tissue conducting endogenous action potentials to an anatomical structure of the subject, the structure being capable of altering a parameter of the subject at least in part responsively to the endogenous action potentials, the apparatus including:
a sensor, configured to detect a factor indicative of the parameter of the subject;
an ablation unit, configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject;
at least one electrode unit, configured to be percutaneously advanced to a site adjacent to a second portion of the nerve tissue of the subject; and
a control unit, configured to:

    
    
        drive the electrode unit to initiate induced action potentials in the second portion of the nerve tissue of the subject by applying an excitatory current to the second portion of the nerve tissue, the action potentials inducing the structure to alter the parameter of the subject,
        receive, from the sensor, information indicative of the factor, and
        at least in part responsively to the information, drive the ablation unit to apply ablative energy to the first portion of the tissue.
    
    


In an application, the electrode unit is configured to be positioned with respect to the ablation unit such that the induced action potentials propagate toward the first portion of the nerve of the subject.
In an application, the control unit is further configured to drive the electrode unit to apply a non-ablative blocking current to the second portion of the nerve.
There is further provided, in accordance with an application of the present invention, a method for ablating nerve tissue of a renal artery of a subject, the method including:
applying a non-ablative electrical current to the nerve tissue;
subsequently applying a first application of ablative energy to the nerve tissue;
receiving (1) a first value of the subject, the first value being indicative of a blood pressure of the subject after a start of the application of the non-ablative electrical current and before the first application of the ablative energy, and (2) a second value of the subject, the second value being indicative of the blood pressure of the subject after the first application of the ablative energy; and
at least in part responsively to a difference between the first value and the second value, applying a second application of the ablative energy to the nerve tissue.
In an application, applying the second application of the ablative energy includes applying a second application of ablative energy that has an intensity that is greater than an intensity of the first application of the ablative energy.
In an application, receiving the first value includes receiving a first value that is indicative of a blood pressure of the subject after an end of the application of the non-ablative electrical current.
In an application, the method further includes receiving a preliminary value indicative of the parameter of the subject before the application of the non-ablative electrical current, and applying the ablative energy includes applying the ablative energy at least in part responsively to (1) the difference between the first value and the second value, and (2) the preliminary value.
In an application, receiving the first value indicative of the parameter of the subject after the start of the application of the non-ablative electrical current includes receiving the first value indicative of the parameter of the subject during the application of the non-ablative electrical current.
In an application, receiving the first value indicative of the parameter of the subject after the start of the application of the non-ablative electrical current includes receiving the first value indicative of the parameter of the subject after the application of the non-ablative electrical current.
In an application, the non-ablative electrical current includes an excitatory current, and applying the non-ablative electrical current includes initiating action potentials in the first portion of the nerve tissue using the excitatory current.
In an application, the non-ablative electrical current includes a blocking current, and applying the non-ablative electrical current includes blocking action potentials in the first portion of the nerve tissue using the blocking current.
There is further provided, in accordance with an application of the present invention, a method for use with nerve tissue of a subject, the nerve tissue conducting endogenous action potentials to an anatomical structure of the subject, the structure being capable of altering a parameter of the subject at least in part responsively to the endogenous action potentials, the method including:
during a first period, blocking the endogenous action potentials from propagating through the nerve tissue by applying a non-ablative blocking current to the nerve tissue and, after the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current, detecting a first value of a factor indicative of the parameter of the subject; and
during a second period, initiating unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue by applying an excitatory current to the nerve tissue and, after the start of the application of the excitatory current, detecting a second value of the factor indicative of the parameter of the subject.
In an application, the method further includes, during a third period, detecting a third value of the factor indicative of the parameter of the subject in the absence of the non-ablative blocking current and the excitatory current.
In an application, the method further includes, responsively to the first and second values, determining a sensitivity of the parameter to action potentials in the nerve tissue.
In an application, the method further includes, responsively to the first and second values, selecting the subject for a treatment including ablation of the nerve tissue.
In an application, detecting the first value after the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current includes detecting the first value during the application of the non-ablative blocking current.
In an application, detecting the first value after the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current includes detecting the first value after the application of the non-ablative blocking current.
In an application, detecting the second value after the start of the application of the excitatory current includes detecting the second value during the application of the excitatory current.
In an application, detecting the second value after the start of the application of the excitatory current includes detecting the second value after the application of the excitatory current.
In an application, the nerve tissue includes nerve tissue of a blood vessel of a subject, and blocking and initiating include blocking and initiating using an electrode unit disposed within the blood vessel of the subject.
In an application, the nerve tissue includes a renal nerve of the subject, the blood vessel includes a renal artery of the subject, and blocking and initiating include blocking and initiating using an electrode unit disposed within the renal artery of the subject.
In an application, the factor includes a factor indicative of a blood pressure of the subject, detecting the first value includes detecting a first value of the factor indicative of the blood pressure of the subject, and detecting the second value includes detecting a second value of the factor indicative of the blood pressure of the subject.
In an application:
the method further includes applying ablative energy to a first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject,
initiating the unidirectional action potentials during the second period includes initiating the unidirectional action potentials in a second portion of the nerve tissue by applying a first application of the excitatory current to the second portion of the nerve tissue prior to the application of ablative energy, and detecting the second value of the factor includes detecting the second value of the factor prior to the application of ablative energy, and
the method further includes, during a third period, subsequently to the application of ablative energy, initiating unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue by applying a second application of the excitatory current to the second portion of the nerve tissue and, after the start of the second application of the excitatory current, detecting a third value of the factor indicative of the parameter of the subject.
In an application:
applying ablative energy includes applying a first application of ablative energy, and
the method further includes, at least in part responsively to the second value and the third value, applying a second application of ablative energy to the first portion of the nerve tissue of the subject.
In an application, applying the second application of ablative energy includes applying the second application of ablative energy at least in part responsively to the first value.
In an application, applying the second application of ablative energy includes applying a second application of ablative energy that has an intensity different from an intensity of the first application of ablative energy.
There is further provided, in accordance with an application of the present invention, a method for use with a renal artery of a subject, the renal artery including nerve tissue, the method including:
ablating a lesion in the renal artery of the subject;
initiating first unidirectional action potentials on a first side of the lesion, such that the action potentials propagate toward the lesion; and
initiating second unidirectional action potentials on a second side of the lesion, such that the action potentials propagate toward the lesion.
The present invention will be more fully understood from the following detailed description of applications thereof, taken together with the drawings, in which:



BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of a system for ablating nerve tissue of a blood vessel of a subject, in accordance with some applications of the invention;
FIGS. 2A-H are schematic illustrations of a technique for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of the blood vessel of the subject, in accordance with some applications of the invention;
FIG. 3, is a schematic illustration of some techniques for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of the renal artery, in accordance with some applications of the invention;
FIG. 4 is a flow diagram of at least some steps in the techniques described with reference to FIGS. 2A-H and 3; and
FIGS. 5A-B are schematic illustrations of systems for ablating nerve tissue of at least one renal artery of a subject, in accordance with some applications of the invention.



DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
Reference is made to FIG. 1, which is a schematic illustration of a system 20 for ablating nerve tissue of a blood vessel of a subject, in accordance with some applications of the invention. System 20 comprises at least one electrode unit 22, an ablation unit 24, and a sensor 26. Sensor 26 is configured to detect a parameter of the subject, such as a parameter indicative of blood pressure and/or blood flow. Ablation unit 24 is configured to ablate the nerve tissue of the blood vessel, so as to block endogenous action potentials from propagating through the nerve tissue (e.g., to ablate nerve tissue in a first portion of the nerve tissue, so as to permanently block pathogenic action potentials from propagating past the first portion of the nerve tissue). Electrode unit 22 is configured to apply a non-ablative electrical current to the nerve tissue, typically so as to initiate and/or block action potentials in the nerve tissue (e.g., to apply the non-ablative electrical current to a second portion of the nerve tissue, so as to initiate and/or temporarily block action potentials in the second portion of the nerve tissue). Typically, when electrode unit 22 is configured to initiate action potentials in the nerve tissue, it is configured to initiate action potentials that have similar characteristics and/or effects as the endogenous action potentials that the ablation unit is configured to block by ablating the nerve tissue. The parameter that sensor is configured to detect is typically a parameter that changes in response to action potentials in the nerve tissue (e.g., in response to the endogenous action potentials and the induced action potentials, and in response to the blocking of the endogenous action potentials). That is, sensor 26 is configured to detect a physiological response to electrode unit 22 blocking the endogenous action potentials and/or initiating the induced action potentials, and/or to ablation unit 24 ablating the nerve tissue, and thereby blocking the action potentials.
Typically, at least electrode unit 22 and ablation unit 24 are coupled to a single longitudinal member 28, such as a catheter, and member 28, electrode unit 22, and ablation unit 24 are advanceable together, such as within and/or through a sheath 29. For some applications, and as shown in FIG. 1, sensor 26 is also coupled to longitudinal member 28 and is advanceable therewith.
For some applications, and as shown in FIG. 1, system 20 comprises two electrode units 22 (e.g., electrode unit 22a and electrode unit 22b). Electrode unit 22a is disposed proximally from ablation unit 24, and electrode unit 22b is disposed distally from ablation unit 24. Typically, each electrode unit 22 is configured to initiate unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue, such as by providing an excitatory current adjacent to a blocking current, e.g., as is known in the nerve cuff art. For example, each electrode unit 22 may comprise three or more electrodes 30 (e.g., electrodes 30a, 30b, and 30c), electrodes 30a and 30b being driven (e.g., by a control unit 32) to apply a non-ablative blocking current, such as a high-frequency (HF) blocking current, and electrode 30c being driven to apply an excitatory current that initiates action potentials that thereby propagate only in the direction away from the other two electrodes (i.e., the action potentials are blocked from propagating past the other two electrodes). Typically, the excitatory current has a lower frequency than the blocking current. When each electrode unit 22 is configured to initiate unidirectional action potentials, the electrode units are oriented on longitudinal member 28 such that the unidirectional action potentials initiated by each electrode unit propagate toward the nerve tissue that is adjacent to ablation unit 24 (e.g., toward the first portion of the nerve tissue).
For applications in which system 20 comprises two electrode units, the electrode units are thereby also oriented such that the unidirectional action potentials initiated by each electrode unit propagate toward the other electrode unit. For applications in which system 20 comprises only one electrode unit, that electrode unit may comprise electrode unit 22a or 22b (e.g., that electrode unit may be disposed in the position and/or orientation described for electrode unit 22a or 22b). It should be noted that, although control unit 32 is shown in FIG. 1 as being outside of the blood vessel(s) in which the electrode units and ablation unit are disposed (e.g., outside the body of the subject), for some applications, control unit 32 and/or other controllers are configured to be intracorporeal (e.g., to be disposed within the blood vessel(s) in which the electrode units and ablation unit are disposed).
For some applications, ablation unit 24 comprises one or more electrodes, and is configured to ablate the nerve tissue by applying radio frequency (RF) current to the nerve tissue (e.g., by comprising an RF ablation unit that is configured to be driven by control unit 32 to apply the RF current). For some applications, ablation unit 24 comprises one or more ultrasound transducers, and is configured to ablate the nerve tissue by applying ultrasound energy to the nerve tissue (e.g., by comprising an ultrasound ablation unit that is configured to be driven by control unit 32 to apply the ultrasound energy). Ablation unit 24 may alternatively or additionally be configured to ablate the nerve tissue cryogenically, using laser, using resistive heating, using chemical ablation, or via another ablation mechanism.
Reference is now made to FIGS. 1 and 2A-H, FIGS. 2A-H being schematic illustrations of a technique for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of the blood vessel of the subject using system 20, in accordance with some applications of the invention. In FIGS. 1 and 2A-H, the blood vessel comprises a renal artery 8 of the subject, disposed between a kidney 10 and the aorta 12 (e.g., the abdominal aorta) of the subject, and system 20 is configured to ablate nerve tissue of the renal artery, so as to treat hypertension. However, for other applications, system 20 may be used to ablate nerve tissue of another blood vessel, such as the carotid artery (e.g., the carotid sinus) or the aortic arch. For example, hypertension may alternatively or additionally be treated by ablation of chemoreceptors and/or baroreceptors in the carotid sinus, and/or nerve tissue associated therewith, and/or ablation of sympathetic nerve tissue of the aortic arch. Furthermore, system 20 may be used to ablate nerve tissue at other sites, such as at a pulmonary vein ostium.
System 20 is advanced percutaneously (e.g., transluminally, such as transfemorally) such that at least electrode units 22a and 22b, and ablation unit 24 are disposed within renal artery 8. Thereby, electrode units 22a and 22b, and ablation unit 24 are adjacent to respective portions of the nerve tissue of the renal artery. Typically, sensor 26 is configured to detect a parameter indicative of blood pressure of the subject (e.g., sensor 26 may comprise a pressure sensor). Typically, sensor 26 is coupled to longitudinal member 28 such that when the electrode units and ablation unit are disposed in renal artery 8, the sensor is disposed in aorta 12. Alternatively, system 20 may be configured such that sensor 26 is disposed in renal artery 8. Sensor 26 may alternatively be configured to detect a parameter indicative of blood flow of the subject. For example, sensor 26 may comprise an ultrasound transceiver, configured to detect the blood flow using Doppler ultrasound. For some such applications, sensor 26 may be extracorporeal (e.g., not coupled to longitudinal member 28).
Following delivery to renal artery 8, electrode units 22a and 22b are typically expanded from a compressed delivery state, to an expanded state in which electrodes 30 are placed in contact with the wall of the renal artery, and in which fluid communication is maintained between the aorta 12 and kidney 10. For example, and as shown in FIGS. 1 and 2A-H, each electrode unit may comprise a tubular element 23, such as a stent, on which electrodes 30 are disposed. Alternatively, each electrode unit may comprise discrete “lasso”-type electrodes that are not coupled to a tubular element. For some applications (e.g., for applications in which ablation unit 24 comprises an RF ablation unit), ablation unit 24 is also expanded from a compressed delivery state to an expanded state thereof. For some such applications, electrode units 22 and ablation unit 24 are disposed on a single tubular element, and/or comprise an integrated device. Alternatively (e.g., for applications in which ablation unit 24 comprises an ultrasound ablation unit), ablation unit 24 is not expanded (e.g., does not require contact with the wall of renal artery 8).
FIGS. 2A-H show sequential steps in a technique of ablating nerve tissue of renal artery 8, using system 20, in accordance with some applications of the invention. Each of FIGS. 2A-H shows a state of system 20 for a respective step, and a corresponding illustrative chart of blood pressure detected up until, and including, the respective step.
Following placement of system 20 in the body of the subject (e.g., as described hereinabove), sensor 26 detects a blood pressure p_A of the subject (FIG. 2A). For some applications, detected blood pressure p_A represents an “untreated” blood pressure. Endogenous efferent action potentials 40 and endogenous afferent action potentials 42 are shown propagating along nerve tissue of renal artery 8 (e.g., between kidney 10 and the central nervous system (CNS) of the subject). It is to be noted that blood pressure p_A, and the other detected blood pressures described herein, are typically each detected while the subject is in the same state (e.g., reclining and/or sedated), so as to reduce variability.
FIG. 2B shows electrode units 22a and 22b each applying a non-ablative blocking current to the nerve tissue of renal artery 8. It is to be noted that throughout the specification, the blocking current is referred to as the “non-ablative blocking current,” so as to be distinct from any current of ablative energy applied by the ablation unit, which may otherwise be considered a “blocking current” because of the blocking effect of the resulting ablation. It is to be further noted that, although the excitatory current applied by the electrode units is also non-ablative, it is generally referred to as the “excitatory current”.
As described hereinabove, for some applications, the electrode units drive the non-ablative blocking current via electrodes 30a and 30b. For some applications, only one of the electrode units applies the non-ablative blocking current. Endogenous efferent action potentials 40 and endogenous afferent action potentials 42 are shown being blocked from propagating along nerve tissue of renal artery 8, by the non-ablative blocking current. It is hypothesized that this blocking of endogenous action potentials has similar effects to ablation of nervous tissue of the renal artery (e.g., to decrease systemic blood pressure), as is known in the art.
After the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current (e.g., while the non-ablative blocking current is being applied, or after it has stopped being applied) sensor 26 detects a blood pressure p_B of the subject. (In general, sensing may also be performed at any other time, e.g., continuously.) For example, the blood pressure may be detected after a duration in which blood pressure is allowed to respond to the reduction in renal nerve activity. The non-ablative blocking current may be calibrated in real-time (e.g., by adjusting amplitude, frequency and/or duty cycle), so as to establish the current that results in the lowest blood pressure in the subject. In general, p_B represents a hypothetical lowest blood pressure achievable by a hypothetical perfect ablation of the nerve tissue of renal artery 8, that blocks all action potentials from propagating therealong.
FIG. 2C shows electrode units 22a and 22b initiating respective action potentials 50 and 52 (i.e., induced action potentials) in the nerve tissue of renal artery 8, by applying an excitatory current to the nerve tissue. As described hereinabove, for some applications, each electrode unit drives the excitatory current via electrode 30c. As also described hereinabove, the electrode units are typically configured to initiate unidirectional action potentials, and are oriented such that the unidirectional action potentials propagate toward the nerve tissue adjacent to ablation unit 24 and toward the other electrode unit. That is, (1) action potentials 50, initiated by electrode unit 22a are typically efferent, and propagate from unit 22, past ablation unit 24, and toward kidney 10, and (2) action potentials 52, initiated by electrode unit 22b are typically afferent, and propagate from unit 22, past ablation unit 24, and toward aorta 12 and the CNS of the subject.
It is hypothesized that, by contrast to the blocking of endogenous action potentials, initiation of action potentials 50 and 52 has similar effects to increased endogenous action potentials (e.g., to increase systemic blood pressure). For example, it is hypothesized that action potentials 50 induce kidney 10 to increase systemic blood pressure via the sympathetic pathway, and action potentials 52 induce the CNS to increase systemic blood pressure via the sympathetic pathway. It is further hypothesized that the magnitude of the effects of action potentials 50 and 52 may be greater than those of the endogenous action potentials, and/or that action potentials 50 and 52 are configurable to have such greater effects.
After the start of the application of the excitatory current (e.g., while the excitatory current is being applied, or after it has stopped being applied), sensor 26 detects a blood pressure p_C of the subject. For example, the blood pressure may be detected after a duration in which blood pressure is allowed to respond to the increase in renal nerve activity. The excitatory current may be calibrated in real-time (e.g., by adjusting amplitude, frequency and/or duty cycle), so as to establish the current that results in the highest blood pressure in the subject. For some applications, p_C represents a hypothetical highest blood pressure achievable by a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity (e.g., the highest blood pressure achievable by the body of the subject via renal nerve activity).
Although FIG. 2C shows two opposite-facing unidirectional electrode units, it is noted that for some applications, only one electrode unit is used, and for some applications, the electrode unit(s) are not unidirectional. For applications in which two electrode units are used, the operation of the electrode units may be temporally offset with respect to each other, so as to reduce interference therebetween. For example, although on a relatively large timescale, electrode unit 22a may initiate induced action potentials 50 at generally the same time as electrode unit 22b initiates induced action potentials 52, nevertheless, on a relatively small timescale, the action potentials are typically alternated (e.g., as indicated by action potentials 50 and 52 being labeled as being applied at “time=t” and “time=t+delta t”, respectively).
It is to be noted that, although FIGS. 2A-H show sequential steps, the steps described with reference to FIGS. 2A-C may be performed in a different order (e.g., the step described with reference to FIG. 2C may be performed before the step described with reference to FIG. 2B).
FIG. 2D shows ablation unit 24 applying a first application of ablative energy 60 (e.g., ablating RF energy) to the nerve tissue of renal artery 8. It is desirable to ablate renal artery tissue to a degree that is sufficient to achieve a desired decrease of renal nerve activity, but not to a greater degree. The first application of ablative energy 60 is typically configured to be insufficient to ablate the nerve tissue to the desired degree (e.g., insufficient to completely ablate the nerve tissue). For example, first application 60 may be configured to be sufficient to fully ablate nerve tissue in less than 50% (e.g., less than 20%, such as less than 10%) of the general population. That is, first application 60 generates, in the wall of renal artery 8, a lesion 62 (e.g., a circumferential lesion) that is sufficient to completely block renal nerve activity in less than 50% (e.g., less than 20%, such as less than 10%) of the general population.
FIG. 2D does not show the non-ablative blocking current being applied by electrode units 22a and 22b during the application of the ablative energy by ablating unit 24. However, for some applications, the non-ablative blocking current is applied at this time. For some such applications, the application of the non-ablative blocking current during the application of the ablative energy reduces pain experienced by the subject, e.g., by inducing local paresthesia and/or anesthesia. The non-ablative blocking current that is used to induce this pain relief may have the same characteristics as, or different characteristics from, the non-ablative blocking current used to block endogenous signals in the nerve tissue being ablated. For some applications, a distinct electrode unit is used for application of the pain-relieving non-ablative blocking current. For some applications, another pain-relief method (e.g., providing an analgesic drug) is alternatively or additionally used.
Subsequent to first application 60, electrode units 22a and 22b again initiate induced action potentials 50 and 52, by again applying the excitatory current (FIG. 2E). Action potentials 50 and 52 are at least in part blocked from propagating past lesion 62 in the nerve tissue (illustrated by the portions of the arrows of the action potentials that are disposed past lesion 62 being broken). After the start of the application of the excitatory current (e.g., while the excitatory current is being applied, or after it has stopped being applied) sensor 26 detects a blood pressure p_D of the subject. For example, the blood pressure may be detected after a duration in which blood pressure is allowed to respond to action potentials 50 and 52. Detected blood pressure p_D may thereby represent a hypothetical highest blood pressure achievable by a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity, following first application of ablative energy (e.g., a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity in the presence of lesion 62). Due to the reduced propagation of induced action potentials 50 and 52 caused by lesion 62, detected blood pressure p_D is typically lower than detected blood pressure p_C. Pressure p_D is typically greater than pressure p_B (e.g., due to the typical configuration of first application of ablative energy 60 to be typically insufficient to completely ablate the nerve tissue).
Subsequently, ablation unit 24 typically applies a second application of ablative energy 60′ to the nerve tissue of renal artery 8, thereby increasing the degree of ablation of the lesion (now designated 62′ (FIG. 2F)). Second application 60′ may have the same characteristics (e.g., intensity) as first application 60, or may be different (e.g., may have a greater or lower intensity). For example, if sensor 26 determines that the reduction in systemic blood pressure due to first application of ablative energy 60 is significantly less than is desired, then second application of ablative energy 60′ may be set to have a higher intensity than first application of ablative energy 60. Similarly, if sensor 26 determines that the reduction in systemic blood pressure due to first application of ablative energy 60 is close to a desired level, then second application of ablative energy 60′ may be set to have an equal or lower intensity than first application of ablative energy 60. (In general, the intensity of applied energy may be varied using techniques known in the art, such as by varying amplitude, pulse width, frequency, duration of energy application, or duty cycle of energy application.)
Subsequent to second application of ablative energy 60′, electrode units again initiate action potentials 50 and 52 by applying the excitatory current (FIG. 2G). Due to the increased ablation of the lesion, action potentials 50 and 52 are blocked from propagating past lesion 62′, to a greater degree than they were from propagating past lesion 62 (illustrated by the broken portions of the arrows of the action potentials in FIG. 2G, being more broken than the same portions in FIG. 2G). After the start of the application of the excitatory current (e.g., while the excitatory current is being applied, or after it has stopped being applied) sensor 26 detects a blood pressure p_E of the subject. For example, the blood pressure may be detected after a duration in which blood pressure is allowed to respond to action potentials 50 and 52. Detected blood pressure p_D may thereby represent a hypothetical highest blood pressure achievable by a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity, following second application of ablative energy 60′ (e.g., a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity in the presence of lesion 62′). Due to the further reduced propagation of induced action potentials 50 and 52 caused by lesion 62′, detected blood pressure p_E is typically lower than detected blood pressure p_D.
The cycle of ablating nerve tissue, initiating action potentials, and detecting blood pressure (e.g., as described with reference to FIGS. 2D-E, and FIGS. 2F-G) may be repeated as necessary. FIG. 2H shows an example in which a further two such cycles have been performed, and respective detected blood pressures p_F and p_G have been obtained. Induced action potentials 50 and 52 are completely blocked from propagating past the lesion, which is now designated 62′′. It is to be noted that, for some applications and/or for some subjects, fewer or more cycles may be useful to achieve a desired degree of blocking (e.g., complete blocking). For example, for some subjects, only one application of ablation energy is applied.
Reference is again made to FIGS. 2A-H. For some applications, impedance between electrode units 22a and 22b is measured at each cycle, so as to further facilitate the determination of the achieved degree of ablation.
Reference is made to FIG. 3, which is a schematic illustration of some techniques for facilitating ablation of nerve tissue of the renal artery, in accordance with some applications of the invention. FIGS. 2A-H show a technique of using system 20 to repeatedly (e.g., cyclically) initiate induced action potentials in, and ablate, nerve tissue of the renal artery, and to repeatedly detect blood pressure of the subject (1) in the presence and absence of the induced action potentials, and (2) before and after the ablations. As described with reference to FIGS. 2A-H, this ablate-excite-detect cycle may be repeated as necessary to achieve a desired degree of ablation. FIG. 3 shows several techniques by which a suitable number of repetitions may be determined. Typically, this determination is performed after each detection of blood pressure subsequent to detection of blood pressure p_A. For illustrative purposes, FIG. 3 shows this determination being performed after four ablations and four respective blood pressure detections (p_D, p_E, p_F, and p_G).
For some applications, the ablate-excite-detect cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to the difference delta_1 between detected blood pressure p_G and detected blood pressure p_C. For example, difference delta_1 may be the difference between (1) the blood pressure detected after the most recent application of ablation energy, and (2) the highest blood pressure achievable by the high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity.
For some applications, the ablate-excite-detect cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to the difference delta_2 between detected blood pressure p_G and detected blood pressure p_B. For example, difference delta_2 may be the difference between (1) the blood pressure detected after the most recent application of ablation energy, and (2) the hypothetical lowest blood pressure achievable by the hypothetical perfect ablation of the nerve tissue of the renal artery. For some such applications, the cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to a difference in magnitude between difference delta_1 and difference delta_2. For example, if delta_1 is significantly greater (e.g., more than a threshold magnitude greater) than delta_2, the cycle may be stopped because a threshold proportion of a hypothetical possible effect on blood pressure is deemed to have already been induced.
It is hypothesized that delta_1 and delta_2 are indicative of the cumulative effect of the ablations up to, and including, the most recent ablation, on the maximum possible contribution by renal nerve activity to blood pressure.
For some applications, the ablate-excite-detect cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to the difference delta_3 between detected blood pressure p_G and detected blood pressure p_F. For example, difference delta_3 may be the difference between (1) the blood pressure detected after the most recent application of ablation energy, and (2) the blood pressure detected after the immediately-prior application of ablation energy. For some such applications, the cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to the difference delta_4 between detected blood pressure p_D and detected blood pressure p_C. For example, difference delta_4 may be the difference between (1) the blood pressure detected after the first application of ablation energy, and (2) the blood pressure detected before the first application of ablation energy. For some such applications, the cycle is stopped at least in part responsively to a difference in magnitude between difference delta_3 and difference delta_4. For example, if delta_3 is significantly smaller (e.g., more than a threshold magnitude smaller) than delta_4, the cycle may be stopped because it is deemed that the most recent application of ablative energy (i.e., that which resulted in difference delta_4) was significantly less effective in reducing blood pressure than was the first application of ablative energy, and thereby further applications of ablative energy are also unlikely to be significantly effective.
It is hypothesized that delta_3 and delta_4 are indicative of the effect of the most recent ablation, and the first ablation, respectively, on the maximum possible contribution by renal nerve activity to blood pressure. It is thereby hypothesized that delta_4 alone, and when compared to delta_3, is indicative of the efficacy of the most recent application of ablation energy.
For some applications, at least in part responsively to one or more blood pressure detections, no ablation is performed. For example, if, in a given subject, a difference delta_5 between detected “untreated” blood pressure p_A and the hypothetical lowest blood pressure achievable by the hypothetical perfect ablation of the nerve tissue p_B, is lower than a threshold difference, it may be determined that renal nerve ablation is not an appropriate treatment for that subject. A similar determination may be made alternatively or additionally in response to (1) a difference delta_6 between blood pressure p_A and blood pressure p_C, and/or (2) a difference delta_7 between blood pressure p_C and blood pressure p_B. It is hypothesized that differences delta_5, delta_6, and/or delta_7 are indicative of the potential efficacy of renal nerve ablation on hypertension for the given subject, and thereby, at least in part responsively to these differences, patient selection may be performed. For example, a high value of delta_7 may be indicative of a relatively high sensitivity of blood pressure to renal nerve activity in the given subject, and therefore the given subject is more likely to be selected for renal nerve ablation.
It is to be noted that, for some applications, one or more of the blood pressure measurements described hereinabove may be omitted from the procedure. For example, if it is known in advance which of differences delta_1 through delta_7 are to be used to determine when to stop the ablate-excite-detect cycle, a measurement that is not to be used may be omitted. Typically, however, only a maximum of two of the pre-ablation blood pressures (e.g., p_A, p_B, and p_C) are omitted, and none of the post-ablation blood pressures (e.g., p_D, p_E, p_F, and p_G) are omitted. For some applications, the determination of when to stop the ablate-excite-detect cycle is based solely on the blood pressure achieved following the most recent ablation.
Reference is made to FIG. 4, which is a flow diagram, illustrating at least some steps in the techniques described with reference to FIGS. 2A-H and 3. Step 102 comprises detecting a preliminary value of a parameter indicative of blood pressure, e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 2A.
Step 104 comprises (1) blocking endogenous action potentials in the nerve by applying a non-ablative blocking current to the nerve and (2) after the start of the application of the non-ablative blocking current, detecting a value of the parameter (i.e., a “blocked” value), e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 2B. The “blocked” value may be greater or smaller than the preliminary value, depending on the parameter and nerve being ablated. For example, for applications in which the renal nerve is being ablated so as to treat hypertension, blocking of endogenous action potentials in the renal nerve typically reduces blood pressure. As also described with reference to FIG. 2B, a calibration step 106 is optionally performed, so as to establish the characteristics of the non-ablative blocking current that will have the greatest effect on the detected parameter.
Step 108 comprises (1) initiating action potentials in the nerve by applying an excitatory current to the nerve and (2) after the start of the application of the excitatory current, detecting a value of the parameter (i.e., an “excited” value), e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 2C. Similarly to the “blocked” value, the “excited” value may be greater or smaller than the preliminary value, depending on the parameter and nerve being ablated. As also described with reference to FIG. 2C, a calibration step 110 is optionally performed, so as to establish the characteristics of the non-ablative blocking current that will have the greatest effect on the detected parameter.
As described hereinabove, steps 102, 104, and 106 may be performed in a different order from that shown in FIG. 4. However, step 102 is typically performed subsequent to the delivery of the apparatus (e.g., system 20) into the subject, and prior to steps 104 and 106.
Step 112 comprises ablating the nerve tissue by applying ablative energy, e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 2D (and as subsequently described with reference to FIG. 2F). Subsequently, step 114 is performed, which comprises (1) initiating action potentials in the nerve by applying an excitatory current to the nerve and (2) after the start of the application of the excitatory current, detecting a value of the parameter, e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 2E. For some applications, step 114 is identical to step 108, except that the nerve tissue in which the action potentials are being initiated has been at least in part ablated. The value detected in step 114 is thereby an “ablated” value.
Subsequently, the “ablated” value is compared to at least one of: the preliminary value, the “blocked” value, and the “excited” value (step 116), and a decision 118 to continue ablating, or to stop, is made, e.g., as described with reference to FIG. 3. If it is decided to continue ablating, steps 112, 114, 116, and 118 are repeated, optionally after an adjustment step 120 in which one or more characteristics (e.g., the intensity) of the ablation energy is adjusted. This part of the technique thereby represents a cycle 122, which may comprise the ablate-excite-detect cycle described hereinabove (e.g., with reference to FIGS. 2A-H and 3).
For some applications, the initiation of action potentials and the ablation steps shown in FIG. 4 (e.g., within steps 108 and 114) may be performed using a single electrode unit. For example, a single electrode unit may be moved back and forth through a blood vessel, alternating between applying an excitatory current and applying ablative energy (e.g., an ablating RF current). The single electrode unit may also be used to perform the blocking of endogenous action potentials (e.g., within step 104), by applying a non-ablating blocking current.
Reference is again made to FIGS. 2A-4. System 20, and the techniques described herein, may be performed with varying degrees of automation, in accordance with various applications of the invention. For example:

    
    
        System 20 may display the blood pressures detected by sensor 26 (e.g., on a display, in numerical and/or graphical format), such that an operating physician may determine when to stop the ablate-excite-detect cycle. For example, a graph similar to that shown in FIG. 4 may be displayed.
        System 20, at least in part based on the detected blood pressures, may display an instruction or suggestion to the physician, as to whether to continue or stop the ablate-excite-detect cycle. Similarly, audio instructions/suggestions may be provided by system 20.
        System 20 (e.g., control unit 32 thereof) may automatically control the electrode units and ablation unit, at least in part based on the detected blood pressures. For example, control unit 32 may receive, from sensor 26, information indicative of the detected blood pressures, and responsively control (e.g., stop) the ablate-excite-detect cycle.
    
    


Reference is again made to FIGS. 2A-4. For some applications of the invention, one or more drugs may be administered to the subject so as to modulate the blood pressure of the subject, in order to facilitate one or more of the steps described hereinabove. For example, a blood pressure-reducing drug may be administered to the subject throughout the entire procedure, so as to reduce all the detected values of blood pressure (e.g., p_A, p_B, etc., shown in FIG. 3). For some such applications, the differences between these detected values (e.g., delta_5, delta_6, etc., shown in FIG. 3) remain relatively constant (i.e., shift, but generally do not change in magnitude) as the detected values change. It is hypothesized that, for some such applications, administering such a blood pressure-reducing drug allows the determination of the hypothetical highest blood pressure achievable by a high-level (e.g., hypothetical maximum) renal nerve activity (e.g., p_C) without increasing the blood pressure of the subject to more than a desired (e.g., safe) threshold. Similarly, a blood pressure-increasing drug may be administered to increase the detected values of blood pressure, such as to allow the determination of the hypothetical lowest blood pressure achievable by a hypothetical perfect ablation of the nerve tissue (e.g., p_B, shown in FIG. 3), without reducing the blood pressure of the subject to below a desired (e.g., safe) threshold.
Reference is made to FIGS. 5A-B, which are schematic illustrations of systems for ablating nerve tissue of at least one renal artery of a subject, in accordance with some applications of the invention. For some applications, it is desirable to ablate nerve tissue of both renal arteries 8a and 8b of the subject. For example, it is hypothesized that, for some applications, it is advantageous to ablate the nerve tissue incompletely in both renal arteries (e.g., as opposed to completely ablating the nerve tissue in only one renal artery), so as to retain at least some nerve activity in each renal nerve, e.g., such that each kidney retains at least some blood pressure control. FIG. 5A shows a system 140, comprising two ablation units 24 (i.e., ablation units 24a and 24b), and two pairs of electrode units 22 (one pair comprising electrode units 24a and 24b, and the other pair comprising electrode units 24c and 24d). One ablation unit and one pair of electrode units are disposed in each renal artery, and are configured to ablate nerve tissue of the respective renal artery.
For some applications of the invention, when initiating induced action potentials in nerve tissue of one renal artery, the endogenous action potentials in the nerve tissue of the other renal artery are blocked using the non-ablative blocking current, e.g., so as to reduce obfuscation of any effect seen. Alternatively, induced action potentials are initiated in the nerve tissue of both renal arteries simultaneously. For some applications, it is desirable to perform this blocking and/or initiating in the nerve tissue of the other renal artery even when the nerve tissue of the other renal artery is not to be ablated. For some such applications, system 160, shown in FIG. 5B, is used. System 160 comprises a third electrode unit 162 (which may comprise electrode unit 22c), but typically does not comprise electrode unit 22d or ablating unit 24b. Systems 140 and 160 are typically used as described hereinabove for system 20, mutatis mutandis.
For some applications, longitudinal member 28 of systems 140 and 160 has two distal portions thereof: longitudinal member first distal portion 28a, and longitudinal member first distal portion 28b. That is, for some applications, the distal portion of longitudinal member 28 is bifurcated into distal portions 28a and 28b, each of the distal portions being configured to be advanced into a respective renal artery, as shown in FIGS. 5A-B.
It will be appreciated by persons skilled in the art that the present invention is not limited to what has been particularly shown and described hereinabove. Rather, the scope of the present invention includes both combinations and subcombinations of the various features described hereinabove, as well as variations and modifications thereof that are not in the prior art, which would occur to persons skilled in the art upon reading the foregoing description.

## Claims

1. A method, comprising:
transluminally advancing a distal portion of a longitudinal member of a device into a renal artery of a subject;
operating the device to drive an electrode disposed on the distal portion of the longitudinal member to apply a non-ablative electrical current to nerve tissue of the renal artery;
receiving (i) a first value, the first value being indicative of a blood pressure of the subject before a start of the application of the current, and (ii) a second value, the second value being indicative of the blood pressure of the subject after a start of the application of the current;
determining if a difference between the first value and the second value is smaller than a threshold difference; and
in response to the determining, selecting the subject for performance or non-performance of ablation of a renal artery of the subject, wherein selecting comprises:
if the determined difference is greater than the threshold difference, operating the device to apply ablation energy to the renal artery; whereas
if the determined difference is smaller than the threshold difference, withdrawing the longitudinal member from the subject without having applied ablation energy to the renal artery.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the non-ablative electrical current is a non-ablative blocking current, and wherein driving the electrode to apply the non-ablative electrical current to the nerve tissue comprises driving the electrode to apply the non-ablative blocking current to the nerve tissue.

3. The method according to claim 1, wherein the non-ablative electrical current is an excitatory current, and wherein driving the electrode to apply the non-ablative electrical current to the nerve tissue comprises driving the electrode to apply the excitatory current to the nerve tissue.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein driving the electrode to apply the excitatory current to the nerve tissue comprises inducing unidirectional action potentials in the nerve tissue.

5. The method according to claim 1, wherein transluminally advancing the longitudinal member into the renal artery of the subject comprises transfemorally advancing the longitudinal member into the renal artery of the subject.

6. The method according to claim 1, wherein the electrode is a first electrode, and operating the device to drive the electrode to apply the non-ablative current comprises operating the device to drive the non-ablative current between the first electrode and a second electrode disposed on the distal portion of the longitudinal member.

7. The method according to claim 1, wherein the steps of receiving and determining comprise operating the device to (i) receive the first value and the second value, and (ii) determine if the difference is smaller than the threshold difference.