5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




<1(77( +$30$1

	






+( ,*%(( 203$1<

,//$5' (3$570(17

	725(6 
1&

	



 !"#$%&'!
()&!	&

#$&'!$&'!$()*&$)+&#

./012&$)+)!%

$4,!63$+'0

!+)!()"!6!

8!#$!63
')!#)$

	


8

3;(:







	  -)  :$(& "!-!"(')#$ !""(&5	"!-!"(')#
0 


 

-):$(&	3
<
"!-!"(')#$ !""(&  5'( 8 !=)* '%* 5 2)&? 8> <	 "!-!"( ') #$  !""!!  :)( 5	+$*!"")"!-!"(')3)+'!"@("*('%*3 $ 7 A;	 	 	;3
 < 2	",%,*')#$%)+),$)!

3
  5 !")-!$! &'!  )()( # &'! +,$& )(

=')+' 
:; 3  ; (:
3 55 B)(!  	


 5 C  D0E!")-!$!*! $&!)**!(&)(4 )()()(=')+'8::	(855B)(!







8;3
5')!#)$+,)&5,4!7(!&&!

' %($,4'&*,)&4)(*&&'!)4!!% (7)(4,*)(!** * )""$F* ! $&%!(& 	&$! #&!$  )""$F**!+,$)&7##)+!$*& !(*!$+'!'!$' %(""!4!*&'&&'!*& (*!$+'=!$!$+)""7%&)-&!(-)"&!'!$$)4'&&&'!G#,""(!H,"!(!#)&#&'!"=I,(!$/0
	J. ('!$ $)4'&&! #$!! #$%,($!*("!*!$+'(*!)K,$!,(!$&'!,$&'%!(%!(&!$+")%$)*!*&=)**,!*( !"6CE='!&'!$*!+&)(. $-)!*+,*!#+&)(4)(*& $)-&! $&7,(!$)&*!H,"!(!#)&+",*! ( C0E ='!&'!$&'! )""$F* *!+,$)&7 ##)+!$ +&!G,(!$+"$#"=I'!+,$&!"= #,(&'& *!+&)(.!*(& $&!+&4)(*& $)-&!)% )$%!(&#)&*!H,"!(!#)&+",*!(&'&&'!*!+,$)&7##)+!$)(&+&G,(!$+"$#"=I)-)! (!"#&')*+,$&##)$%!#&!$$!'!$)(4=!A	




( !$,$70' %( ( #$)+(%!$)+(

=* *' )(4 & )""$F* ! $&%!(& 	&$!)("!-!"(')  #&!$ +'*)(4 *%! +"&')(4 ' %( !(&!$! #)&&)(4$%#$%=')+',+*)(=%('B,*&!L)&!
 



@'!(' %(!(&!$!&'!#)&&)(4&4 +""!  G?(4I ( &'! #"+"&')(4' %(!+)!(&& &'!#)&&)(4$%&$!&,$(&'!+"&'

)""$F**"!***)*&(&(&)+!

' %(F* #)&&)(4 $% ( *' ")#&)(4(&)#)!)""$F**!+(##,&7*'!$)##F*! ,&7=*=! $&%!(&,()#$%4!(*))""$F*&'!*!+,$)&7##)+!$=*,"!*(2$+!,$!*#$	!+,$)&7&'! #""=)(4 )(*&$,+&)(* =)&' $+,*&%!$* *,* !+&! # *' ")#& $'))&!
#7,*,* !+&&'&*&N&'!*' !$F*O !$*(+""&'! 

'! *!+,$)&7 ##)+!$ *& ! 

+? & &'! #)&&)(4 $%  ! (*!$+'!' %(F* ,$*!#&! ,$*! +(&)(! ( )""$F* %)(#$%!' %(&'&)&=,"'!$+"&'!*&&'!##)+!$F*!'!&'!#!%"!%(4!$)(&&'!#)&&)(4*!$+'!' %(7'-)(4' *,)&B+?!& (")#& ,  '!$ *')$&  (&')(4*'! "4)K!(' 

*$!*,"&#&')*)(+)!(&' 

)""$F* *!!?)(4 $!")!# CE ,()% )$%!(&#'!$ $)4'&*,(!$&'+",*!(C0E,(!$/0
	J$)4'&&!#$!!#$%,($!*("!&'!,$&'%!(%!(&('!$$)4)#&'%!(%!(&%4)*&$&!B,+(*!(& 4$(&! *,%%$7 B,4%#)()(4CE' %(+,"(&*&&*!+&)( . !+,*! &'! *&&,&! $)-&! )% )$%!(& # )&* !HC0E' %(+,"(&*&&!+4(
/ 


 

.!+,*!&'!*!+,$)&7##)+!$=*(&+&)(4G,(!$+"$# *&&!"=I  #&!$&'! %4)*&$&! !()! '!$ %&)( #$$!+(*)!$&)(' %( !"!)-)! (!"#&')*+,$&##)$%!(=!4$(&!$!-)!=





@! $!-)!=  
  )*&$)+& +,$&F* 4$(& # *,%%$7

B,4%!(& -)!=)(4&'!!-)!(+!)(&'!")4'&%*&#-$"!&&'!((%-)(4 $&7
 
!"..//P CD&')$E	,%%$7B,4%!(&)* $ $)&!("7 ='!(&'!$!)*(4!(,)(!)**,! *& (7%&!$)"#+&(&'!%-)(4 $&7)*!(&)&"!&B,4%!(&*%&&!$#"=('  ,9 2PDC+E9	



#"$%./..CD&')$DECG@)&',&=!)4')(4&'!!-)!(+!$B,4)(4&'!+$!))")&7#=)&(!**!* ($=)(4 "")(#!$!(+!*)( #-$#&'!((%-)(4 $&7)*&$)+&+,$&,*,""7,(!$&?!*&!&!$%)(!='!&'!$ &'!$! )* *,##)+)!(& !-)!(+! & !$%)& $!*("!B,$$*&#)(#$&'!((%-)(4 $&7IE



'!-))")&7#' %(F* *!+&)(.+")%&,$(*(

='!&'!$*!+&)(. $&!+&*4)(*& $)-&!)% )$%!(&#)&*!H,"!(!#)&+",*!
($!"!-(& $&*!+&)(.$!**#""=*6

CE	&&!%!(&#!H,"$)4'&*	
&'()*

*&%?! ( !(#$+! +(&$+&* & *,! ! $&)!* 4)-!!-)!(+!((+(&
(


'&,(*'""!*,B!+&&")?! ,()*'%!(& )(* !("&)!* &L!* ")+!(*!* (!L+&)(*#!-!$7?)((&(&'!$QQQQC+E2$&!+&)(4)(*&)% )$%!(&

 

(& #!!$")K&)(#&$&"= 
*
 .  	,  &  !(+% **&')*?)(# +(,+&*!+&)(.+&)(='!(!-!$=%()($$%$="L&+",*!& $)-&!+(,+&=,"'-"" $+)""7%&)-&! *&&!"= *!+,$)&7# !$*(*( $ !$&7FI*&&! )(  GNO"&',4'(4$!** ")("7)$!+&**$,"!=&#!!$")K!F%&&!$*&$)&)(""7"=I/
	&.  
  / 
	 /D0 /

-!(4$!**)(& ")("7*&&!&$&"=C")?!)&)#$+(&$&'!*+ !##!!$""=&'!%B$)+,&)($7=$*




(*,%
=,"'"&'&((4

! *,! ,(!$ &'! !H," !(!#J.CE =')+'  ")!*("7&=,"'"&'&' %(#)"!&+")%!+,*!&'!""!4! $)-&!)*(&=)&')(&'! ,$-)!=#&'!!H,)( &'! %B$)&7F* ("7*)* # '
	J.!+,*!
!")!-!&'&='!&'!$)""$F*%7!+(*)(!L,*&!*& $&')*$!*(
$!* !+&#,""7

+")%
0. 


 

72576&,(!$*&(&'&&')*G")%)&&)(I)*(&&'&!+,*!)&!(+% **!*""#&$&"=6


(+",!,(!$&'!'!#&$&*$!%)*+!""(!,*+)-)"

=$(4*$(4)(4#$%*)% "!)$!+&)(&!$#!$!(+!*=)&'&'! !$*( *,+' * **,"& &&!$7 ( #"*!)% $)*(%!(&$=)&' $ !$&7*)(&'!+*!#&$!* **$+(-!$*)(, &'$,4'-$),*#$%*#(!4")4!(+!&)*&,$(+!*#)(&(4)"!)(&!$!*&**,+'*&'*!)(4$! ,&&)($)(+%%!$+)"$*+)"-(&4!'!$! $!%)(*  7 # "= ='+' N*)+O )* )$!+&!&=$&'!+% !(*&)(#)()-),"*$&'!$&'(&'! ,")+ #$"**!*=')+'&'!7'-! *,##!$!=)&')(&'!*+ ! # &'!)$ "!4""7 $!+4()K! )(&!$!*&* 4!(!$""7$&'!$&'((!)(&!$!*&("7='!$!&'!"=+(*)!$*&'&+% !(*&)()*$!H,)$!')*)*&'!"=#&$&*

'!"=#&$&*&'!()*+(+!$(!=)&'&'!""+&)(*

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

35266(5

< .((721 21 7+( /$: 2) 72576 J  C@24!

>!!&(@!*&2,")*')(4P&'!./E


(!$&'!%B$)&7F*)(&!$ $!&&)(&'!!H,"!(!#)&+",*!

+(+!)-"7+(! ")!&!-!$74$!(-$)!&7*&&!&$&"=+")%='!$!&'! $&)!*$!#)##!$!(&$+!*
#&')*)*

 



,Q  &RQJUHVV DPHQGHG  86

DOLD RI VXEVHFWLRQ F 3WR VWUHQJWKHQ H[DYDLODEOH XQGHU IHGHUDO FLYLO ULJKWV ODZ

GHWHUUHQFH DQG DGHTXDWH FRPSHQVDWLRQ +55HS 1R ,, DW  UHSULQWHG 

'!$)4'&* $&!+&!7&')**!+&))% )$%!(& 7 ((4-!$(%!()% )$%!(&,(!$+"$#	&&!

/0
	J.CEC+EC.EC!

G
(""+*!*#*&&,&$7+(*&$,

&'!"(4,4!!% "7!7(4$!*/"0D0.CD='!$!G&'!*&&,&!F*"(4,4!)* "+,$&*)*&!(#$+!)&++$)(4&
1 /.0D  0 0 C. ,(+&,&)(%)&&!E

	!+&)(.)*,(%)4,,*

&'! $)4'&* $&!+&!7 *!+&)()% )$%!(& 7 ((4-!$(%!(&" .!L ")+)&"7 $&!+&*&'!$)4'&G&#"""=*( $+!!)(4*#$&' $ !$&7*)*!(B7!7=')&!+)&))* G $&!+&! 4)(*& )% )$%!)*+$)%)(&)(I



)""$F* $4,!* &'& *,*!+&)

((4-!$(%!(&")*+$)%)(&)()*%?!(!(#$+!+(&$+&* $-)*

8!+,*!*,*!+&)(C+E"$!7!

&'*! $)4'&* G $&!+&! 7 &')* *2
((2((&')*+,$&#$%4$#&)(4)&)("
D 


 

@!%7'=!-!$"? *&&'! ")("(4,4!#*&&,&!

='!$!6CE&'! ")("(4,4!+$!&!*)(+(*)*&!(+)!*=)&')(&'!*&&,&!)&*!"#C0E ")+&)(#&'! ")("(4,4!$,(*+(&$$7 & +"!$"7 !L $!**! "!4)*"&)-! )(&!(& $CE ")+&)(#&'! ")("(4,4!=,""!&*,$$!*,"&*3
.1
 P.

CD&')$.EC+)&)(4)*
("/P0
	

PDP.	&0P0/D00/DC.EE9	" 
/D
	DD/.	&0PPD0PCDPECG')*,$&)()(&!$ $!&)(4&'! =$* #  *&&,&! '* *%! *+ ! #$  &)(4 $!*&$)+&!$&'!$&'(")&!$"$,*,"%!()(4#)&*=$*='!$! ++! &(+! # &'& %!()(4 =," "! & *,$$!*,"&*$=,"&'=$&&'!-),* ,$ *!#&'!*&&,&!,&)&)*&'!$=)*!='!$!(*,+'+(*!H,!(+!*=,"#""=(='!$! N")&!$" $!)(4O  !$*&! +(*((& =)&'&'! ,$ *!*#&'!+&IECH,&)(4
/&.
	PDP.P	&D0/0PCDPEC)(&!$("+)&&)(( ,(+&,&)(%)&&!EE9"
0.0
	PPPDP	&/PPDCE

0

!"7)(4 (  ')$ )$+,)& !+)*)( ,&'$! !#$!

(4$!**!&'!"(4,4!)( *,*!+&)( C+E4


%PD/0.C)$E)""$F**,44!*&*&'& ")( $!)(4 # *,*!+&)( C+E +$!&!* )(&!$(")(+(*)*&!(+)!*
(4&'!+,$&'!"&'&+% ")(&4)(*&+)&74-!$(%!(&#$-)"&)(#*!+&)(.M*!H,"!(!#)& +",*! *&&!  +4()K"! +,*! # +&)(!* ()(4)()+&&&'!+)&7F*+(&!(&)(&'&&'!+,$&F*$ +(*&$,+&)( # *!+&)( . =," 4)-! $)*! & #!!$"+,*!#+&)(#$!-!$7$+)""7%&)-&! $)-&!&$& &'! 4 +,$& *,44!*&! &'& *,+'  $!*,"& =*,(")?!"7!+,*!G&'!+(+! &#*&&!+&)()*)% ")+)&)(&'!!H,"!(!#)&+",*!I &0 &)(4&'!4

+,$&F* )+& )""$F* $4,!* &'&  ")( $!)(4 #*,*!+&)(C+E)*)(+(*)*&!(&=)&'*!+&)(.M*!H,"!(!#)&

 

 E :HVW 

(4$!**F*)(&!(&)(!(+&)(4*,

!!((7+"!$!$
&)(&!(!& $G)( "" +(&$+&*I !+,*! &'& )+(&$+&* (     %!(%!(&)* "*&!"")(4 * . C*&&)(4 &'& G&'! &)&"! #  *&&,$!*"-)(4(%)4,)&7)(&'!"!4)*)4'&* +& #  )* !(&)&"!2$'))&)(4)(*&""+)")*1IPC!% '*)*!E


(*'$&=!+(!&!$%)(!='

='&)&&",*( #$%='&)&=$!#(&'!%B$)&7!*(=')+' $!H,)$!*  +,$& & $! ,("!** &'! "!4)*"&,$! !L $!**"7 !* !+)""7='!(G(LI)*+(+! &,& ='& &'! %B$)&7 *7* &'& *)()&)*+!$&)("7(&(



'!%B$)&7F*)(&!$ $!&&)(#

&&'! !H," !(!#)& +",*! "* '#!!$")K)(4 *&&!&$&"='!%,(")?!"7&'& ")+&)(#*,*!=)"",("!*'&'!#"#+*!*)""N&O'!"(4,4!*,$$,()(4&'!R#,*!$-!*&+)(&'&'!(,%!$(!$,4'&,(!$)&*%)&I4'%B$)&7!")!-!*&'&&'!$)4'&)**,&'!"(4,4!G(
!(B7!7=')&!+)&)K!(*I")%)&*&&'&%7!$,4'&,(!$&'!!H,(!!"?(#,$&'!$&'(&'! !(
0D 


 

FRQIHUV D ULJKW XSRQ 3>D@OO SHUVRQV ́ DQG GRHV QRW VSHDN LQ WHUPV RISURKLELWLQJ SULYDWH LQGLYLGXDOV IURP FHUWDLQ FRQGXFW

$V VWDWHG WKH DPHQGPHQW ZDV LQ GLUHFW UHVSRQVH WR WKH 6XSUHPH

&RXUW¶V RSLQLRQ LQ 3DWWHUVRQ Y 0F/HDQ &UHGLW 8QLRQ  86  3DWWHUVRQ KHOG WKDW   SURKLELWHG GLVFULPLQDWLRQ RQO\ LQ WKH

PDNLQJ DQG HQIRUFHPHQW RI FRQWUDFWV DQG GLG QRW H[WHQG WR SUREOHPVDULVLQJ IURP FRQGLWLRQV RI FRQWLQXLQJ HPSOR\PHQW ,Q WKH &LYLO 5LJKWV$FW RI  &RQJUHVV H[SOLFLWO\ UHYHUVHG WKLV DVSHFW RI 3DWWHUVRQ E\

DGGLQJ VXEVHFWLRQ E WR   ZKLFK VWDWHV WKDW 3WKH WHUP μPDNH DQGHQIRUFH FRQWUDFWV¶ LQFOXGHV WKH PDNLQJ SHUIRUPDQFH PRGLILFDWLRQ DQGWHUPLQDWLRQ RI FRQWUDFWV DQG WKH HQMR\PHQW RI DOO EHQHILWV SULYLOHJHV

WHUPV DQG FRQGLWLRQV RI WKH FRQWUDFWXDO UHODWLRQVKLS ́  86&$

("7&)+"#$%!=$?("47&)$!+&*&'& $)-&!

+&)(=,"(&!$!)(&J.



'! %B$)&7 "* +")%* &'& (&')(4 )( &'! "!4)*"&)-!

')*&$7 #&'!  %!(%!(&* $!-!(&*&')*,$& #$% "7)(4*,*!+&)(C+EF* ")("(4,4!:$(&!(4$!**)(&*7&'&G7)(4&')**,*!+&)(=!%!(&'&&'!!H," !(!#)& +",*!  ")!* ("7 & *&&! ( (& $)-&!+&)(I=!-!$=!+(4"!(='&&'!"!4)*"&,$!)(&!(!#$%='&)&+&,""7*)6

')* *!+&)( %!(* /0 
	 J . C+%%("7$!#!$$!&*G	!+&)(.TE&-!$&,$(


4!)(&+)#7(
4

/0
	DD	&0P.D	,*!+&)( C+E 2$'))&)(4 )*+$)%)(&)( )( $)-&!+(&$+&)(4S')* *,*!+&)( )* )(&!(! & +)#7( 
 4 
( ( &'! ,$& '!" &'&	!+&)(. $'))&!)(&!(&)("$+)")*+$)%)(&)()( $)-&!*=!""* ,")++(&$+&)(4
&' ,")+( $)-&!! 0/C

E&P CE



	P/C!% '*)*!E

 



3KUDVHG GLIIHUHQWO\ 'LOODUG¶V DUJ

VXEVHFWLRQ F UHQGHUV WKH VWDWXWH LQWHUQDJDLQVW SULYDWH LPSDLUPHQW ULJKWV WKDW $OWKRXJK QRW JHUPDQH WR &KDSPDQ¶V FOEHQHILW FODXVH RQH FRXOG PDNH D VLPVXEVHFWLRQ D¶V OLNH SXQLVKPHQW FODXVH 

SHUVRQV ZLWKLQ WKH MXULVGLFWLRQ RI WKH 8QLOLNH SXQLVKPHQW SDLQV SHQDOWLHV WD[HV ONLQG DQG WR QR RWKHU ́

7KHUH LV QRWKLQJ XQZRUNDEOH KRZHY

JLYHQ VWDWXWH PD\ SURVFULEH FRQGXFW E

SHUVRQV WKH VWDWXWH UHJXODWHV DUH DFWXDOO\ FGULYHU RI DQ LQGXVWULDO GXPSWUXFN PDVHYHQW\ILYH PLOHVSHUKRXU VSHHG OLPLDSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKDW OLPLW ,QGHHG LI D QHFRQVLVWHQF\ ZDV D UHJXODWHG JURXS FDSDESURVFULSWLRQV VHFWLRQ  FRXOG QRW EH FDFWRUV WKH YDVW PDMRULW\ RI ZKRP DUH LQ 

GHQ\ OLFHQVHV WR DQ\ SHUVRQ SURWHFWHG E\ +",*! =')+' )% ")+)&"7 )(+$ $+&)(

'!	, $!%!,$&F*!+)*)()

/
	..	&0 $!+",!* &')* +,$& #$% #)()("(4,4! )(+(*)*&!(& =)&' &'! $-)*)(
(&'!,$&#("4,*!H," $&!+&)( $-)*)=!"" * ##)+)" +&)(   & DJ.PCEC $-))(4+,*!# !$*(*)((7	&&!$!$$)&$7+&'!')4'=7$(&'! $!%)*!*#! $)-)(4!)&'!$)$!+&"7$)()$!+ !$*(* # &'! !H," $&!+&)(  $)-)"!4!*()%%,()&)!*,(!$&',$&!L $!**"7$!B!+&!&'!*&&!+&)()*)% ")+)&)((!H,+!(&,$7#,$&!!(&'%!(%!(&)& ,(!$*&("7 )##)+,"& & ++(*&)&,&!! $)-&)(#&'!!H, $)-&! !$*(*;!&
. 


 

7KH GLIIHUHQFHV LQ JURXSV UHJXODWHG E\ VHFWLRQ  ± JURXSV RI

WZR RU PRUH SHUVRQV ± DQG VHFWLRQ  ± HLWKHU LQGLYLGXDOV RU JURXSV ±LQ QR ZD\ DIIHFWV ZKHWKHU WKH FRQFHSW RI VWDWH DFWLRQ LV LPSOLFLW LQ WKHVWDWXWHV¶ DQDORJRXV HTXDO SURWHFWLRQ SURYLVLRQV 6HH *ULIILQ  86 DW

 UHMHFWLQJ WKH DUJXPHQW WKDW VHFWLRQ  FRQWHPSODWHG 3DSULYDWH FRQVSLUDF\ VR PDVVLYH DQG HIIHFWLYH WKDW LW VXSSODQWV WKRVH >VWDWH@DXWKRULWLHV DQG WKXV VDWLVILHV WKH VWDWH DFWLRQ UHTXLUHPHQW ́

+(&"

*I &C!% '*)*!E


(!!F*)(&!$ $!&&)(#*!+&)(.PCEF*!H,"

 $&!+&)( $-)*)(*,44!*&*&'&*!+&)(.M*("4,*+",*!=," $&!+&4)(*& $)-&!)% )$%!(&!-!(*!(&*,*!+&)(C+EF*!L ")+)&)(*&$,+&)(6GNO'!#)",$!&%!(&)((7 *,+' N*&&! +&)(O $!H,)*)&! +( ! -)!=! * ()% $&(& )()+&)( # +(4$!**)(" )(&!(& & * !? )(*!+&)(.PCE#""! $)-&)(*#R!H," $&!+&)(#&'!"=*F(R!H," $)-)"!4!*()%%,()&)!*,(!$&'!"=*F&
(I/
	& C!% '*)*

!E9)*
%/
	D 	& P. P  P. CPE C ",$")&7  )()( #$(?#,$&!$ 5E C#)()(4 ( *&&! +&)( $!H,)$!%!(& )(("4,* !H," $&!+&)( $-)*)( # +$)%)(" *&&,&!E9)*
D
	D0D	&D00C..EC*%!E.

:)-!(&'!	, $!%!,$&F*$!B!+&)(#&'!(&)(&'&*&&!

+&)( )* )% ")+)& )( &'! +(+! & # !H," $&!+&)( =!+((&#)(&'! ")("(4,4!#*,*!+&)(C+E)(+(*)*&!(&=)&'&'!*&&,&!F*!H,"!(!#)&+",*!



'!$! )* (&')(4 )( &'! "!4)*"&)-! ')*&$7 # &'! 

%!(%!(&*& *!+&)(.&'& $!-!(&*&')* +,$& #$% "7)(4*,*!+&)(C+EF* ")("(4,4!#&'!&=,*!%%)&&!!! $&*(&'!)-)")4'&*+&#("7(!!-!(%!(&)(* *,*!+&)( C+E (&'&)*+,**)()*&!$*!'!,*!5,)+)$7%%)&&!!,&'$!! $&

 



,Q RWKHU ZRUGV UDWKHU WKDQ EHLQ

SURYLGLQJ D FDXVH RI DFWLRQ 3>L@I WZR RU PLQ GLVJXLVH RQ WKH KLJKZD\ RU RQ WKH SUHPRI GHSULYLQJ    DQ\ SHUVRQ RU FODVV RI SHWKH ODZV RU RI HTXDO SULYLOHJHV DQG LPPX

)(&!$ $!&&)( H,)&! )(+(*)*&!J.PCE)(
(+(*&$+,(&!$ $&#J.PCE&'!(
*!$-!&'&&'!&&?!!##!+&("7)(+*!N#*&,&G=*#$%!& $&!+&# !$*(*&'!!H," $)-)"!4!*("=* # "" !$*(* ( +"**D
()*
%&'!,$&+(*)!$!&'!+"("4,!& J .PCE. 
	$(?#,$&!$F* ",$")&7  )()(#$% &'! +(+,$$!(+! $ )**!"(4,4!)*&+$$7(7%!()(&'&&'! $)(+) " ,$ *!#NJJ0/0O=*&$!+' $)-&!+&) 	&&! +&)(4 ,(!$ )&* ,&'((

(& .   " 
I/
	&DN#J0/O)()+&!*&'& +"$$!"!-(&& $*!+,&)(,(!$)&

 / 
	 & D. C#&!E C-!$$,")(4 =')+$!H,)$)(4 $!*!(+!#*&&!+&)(E

@'!($!)(#,""+(&!L&$&'!$

 $-)!7&'!%B$)&7)&)*+"!

# $)-&! !$*(*(&'!#+!#&' +,$&F* '")(4 &'& J +&)('&)*,(")?!J.J $)-&!+&)(7!L ")+)&"7$!#!$$)(='+(* )$!'!$!#$!)#(!
0/ 


 

(
(2
&  &

((( 
  

 (  
(6789)*:;9<9=;9>?	@(A
((

       &  

''(
(+(



'! $-)*)( +(&)(,!* * !+)#7)(4 &'! %&)-&)(

$!H,)$!G#$&'! ,$ *!#! $)-)(4!)&'!$)$!+&"7$)()$!+&"7(7 !$*($+"**# !$*(*#&'!!H," $&!+&)( # &'! "=* $ # !H," $)-)"!4!* ()%%,()&)!*,(!$&'!"=*I')*"(4,4!)*#+,$*!*)%)"$ & &'& # J  # &'! ,$&!!(&' %!(%!(&=')+')(&!$%* * !?*("7&&'! 	&&!* (B,)+)"&')(?)(4,&='&+(+(*&)&,&!(!H," $&!+&)(! $)-&)('*!+,*!#&'!%!(%!(&F*=$)(4#+,*! "%*& !(&)$!"7 , ( )!(&)#7)(4 &'! $!H,)*)&!G*&&!+&)(I(!#)()(4&'!##!()(4#$%*#*&&!"= ( ##)+)" +(,+&   +!(&,$7 # ,$&!!(&'%!(%!(&B,)+&)('*)(&'!$=$*%!)&,(!$*&("7 )##)+,"& & +(+!)-! # ='& %)4'&+(*&)&,&!! $)-&)(#&'!!H," $&!+&)(#&'!"=*7 $)-&! !$*(*;!&&'!$!)*(&')(4)('!$!(&)(&'! '$*! &'& $!H,)$!* &'! +&)( =$?)(4 &'!! $)-&)(& +%! #$%&'! 	&&!*)

*
D
	D0D/N..O
(!!&'!#)",$!&%!(&)((7*,+'$!H,)*)&!+(!-)!=!* ( )% $&(& )()+&)( # +(4$!**)(" )(&!(& &* !?)(J.PCE#! $)-&)(#G!H," $&!+&)(#&'!"=*I(G!H," $)-)"!4!*()%%,()&)!*,(!$&'!"=*I='&!-!$&'!)$*,$+!

'!  $+' #&')*,$&& &'!$!+(*&$,+&)(

+)-)"$)4'&**&&,&!*)(&'!7!$**)(+!'*!!(&

G++$ N&'!%O  *=!!  * $ * N&'!)$O"(4,4!I     3$!-!$ -!$7 *)%)"$ "(4,4! )(+"*!"7 $!"&!*&&,&!* '* !$"7 ( "&! $!+!)-! (

 



2I FRXUVH 3ZH VKRXOG EH DQG DUH 

WUDGLWLRQDOO\ FRYHUHG E\ VWDWH FRPPRQ ODZ8QLRQ  86    6&W 

LQWHUQDO TXRWDWLRQ RPLWWHG 7KLV UHOXFWDFRXUW OHHZD\ WR LJQRUH &RQJUHVV¶V SODLQ 

0 /C

E =')+' *&&!* ("7 &'+)#7( 
4/0
0/PCDE()(&!(!$+)")*+$)%)(&)()(""+(&$+&!   0/C

E &  C
	P/(4$! ")+&)(#*,*!+&)(C+E&&'!*,*!+&)(CE!*(& $ !$"74)*,*!+&)( C+EF* $!#!$!(+! & G&'+&,""7 $!#!$* & G&'! +(&$+&,(4$!**F* #)",$! & +%%!(& *)% "7!*(&+(*&)&,&!$!B!+&'&"(4,4!-!(-)!=!)(&')""$F*&'!"!4)*"&)-!')*&$7#*',* =! +((& *7 &'& 4)-)(4  ")("(4,4!#",&*(4$!**F*%!(%!(&

/

)""$F*"*$4,!*&'& ")

 ")("(4,4!=)&' $!* !+&&*!+",*!=,"'-!&'!G*,$I$!*"=

$!*,"&'=!-!$)*(&*,$

+% $&=)&'(!F*(&)(#='@!&7 )+""7!%$?, (&'!!L(4$!**F*)(&!(&,&*)!&'!")&!$("7='!(&'!*&&,&! $,+!*$,& =')+' )* &!(&"7 )""4)+" )(&!(&  * " 0.0 
	 

! $&,$!#$%&'!"!&&!$#&'!"=*4$***&*'+?&'!4!(!$"%
 


 

6HYHUDO FDVHV WKDW KDYH DOORZHG 3IXOO DQG HTXDO EHQHILW ́ FODLPV WR

JR IRUZDUG ZLWKRXW VWDWH DFWLRQ KDYH LQYROYHG VHULRXV WKUHDWV WR D SHUVRQ¶VVHFXULW\ LQ WKH IRUP RI SK\VLFDO YLROHQFH 6HH HJ &DUH\ Y 5XGHVHDO

 ) 6XSS   Q 1' *D  QRWLQJ WKDW FRXUW KDG DOORZHG3IXOO DQG HTXDO EHQHILW ́ FODLP DJDLQVW SULYDWH DFWRU LQYROYHG LQ .X .OX[.ODQ LQFLGHQW EHFDXVH VHFWLRQ  3SURYLGHV D FDXVH RI DFWLRQ DJDLQVWSULYDWH LQGLYLGXDOV IRU UDFLDOO\PRWLYDWHG LQWHQWLRQDOO\LQIOLFWHG LQMXU\DQG GRHV QRW UHTXLUH VWDWH DFWLRQ LQ WKH GHSULYDWLRQ RI ULJKWV ́ +DZNV Y3HULOOR  ) 6XSS    1' ,OO  FRQVWUXLQJ

ODQJXDJH DQG KLVWRU\ RI VWDWXWH WR DOORZ FODLP DJDLQVW SULYDWH LQGLYLGXDOZKR HQJDJHG LQ YLFLRXV EHDWLQJ RI SODLQWLIIV PRWLYDWHG E\ UDFLDO DQLPXV

&'!$!%,*&!*%!&')(4&%?! ")(&'!)(&!(&#(4$!**&'&&'!"!&&!$#&'!*&&,&!)*(&& $!-)"IE

*)*+,**!-!&'!"!4)*"&)-!')*&$7#*,*!+&)(

C+E )* & %*& !H,)-+"  '!$! )* (&')(4 )( &'& ')*&$7!-)!(+)(4 (4$!**F* )(&!(& &'&  ")( $!)(4 #*,*!+&)( C+E (& $!-)"  3$!-!$ )& )* ,(")?!"7 &'& ")+&)(#*,*!+&)(C+EF* ")("(4,4!=)"",("!*'&'!#"#+*!*)""$F* $!)+&*'!"(4,4!*,$$,()(4&'!G#,""(!H,"!(!#)&I+",*!*!$-!*&+)(&'&'!(,%!$((&,$!#+")%*&'&%7!$,4'&,(!$)&*%)&'!!H,"!(!#)&+",*!%7("7!)(-?!='!((! $&7!()!*(&'!$&'!G#,""(!H,"!(!#)&#"""=*( $+!!)(4*(


*)*

!(B7!7=')&!+)&)K!(*I/0
	J.CEC!% '*)*!E  '! G*!+,$)&7 # !$*(* ( $ !$&7I "(4,4!")%)&*&'! &!(&)"+"**#+*!*&'&%7!$,4'&,(!$&'!!H,"!(!#)& $-)*)(")&)4(&%,*&!%(*&$&!&'!!()"#&'!!(!#)&#"=$ $+!!)(4 $&!+&)(4')*$'!$ !$*("*!+,$)&7$+4()K"! $ !$&7$)4'&,$&'!$

& $!-)" (  *!+&)( . +")%  ")&)4(& %,*& $-!)(&!(&)(")*+$)%)(&)((&'!*)*#$+!=')+')(-"-!* ')4' &'$!*'" # $#  8!+,*! # &'!*! *)4()#)+(&")%)&&)(* =!  (& !")!-! &'& &'! ")( "(4,4! #*,*!+&)( C+E #!!$")K!*  =)! *=&' # +(,+&&$)&)(""7+-!$!7*&&!+%%("=

8!+,*!*!+&)(. ")("7 $&!+&*4)(*&)% )$%!(&

# )&* !H," !(!#)& +",*! 7 $)-&! )*+$)%)(&)( (

 

)()$!+&"7 (7 !$*( $ +"**  $&!+&)(#&'!"=*$#!H," ,(!$&'!"=*I/0
	J%B$)&7(&!*&'&&'!

(&)(&'&&'!+(+! &#*&&!+& $&!+&)( $-)*)($!"7)(4(&'+!(&,$7#,$&!!(&'%!(%!(&)& ,(!$*&("7 )##)+,"& & ++(*&)&,&!! $)-&)(#&'!!H, $)-&! !$*(*;!&&'!$!)*(&'&'&$!H,)$!*&'!+&)(=$?)(4&'!&'!	&&!I/
	 &

 !4)( &'! "(4,4! # &'!

)!(&)+"	)4()#)+(&"7J.PCE$ %$! !$*(*I  	!+&)( J *)%)"$$!#!$!(+!,&*)% "7*&&!*&'!*%!$)4'&&&'!#,""(!H $+!!)(4* #$ &'! *!+,$)&7 # !(B7!7=')&!+)&)K!(*I*

0 ( CG
(")?! J . '=!L $!**"(4,4!!(+% **)(4R&R4(&'!')4'=7F&! $)-!&'*

.PP0

C*!$-)(4&'&GN&O')**&&,&!$!)*4,)*!(&'!')4'=7F)*$!#!$>",L>"(S7!&+(!%(*("7!!#&'!R!H," $&!+&)(#&'!"=*)%%,()&)!*,(!$&'!"=*F*%!&4-!$(%!(&!L+",*)-!"7')*%+&)('*!#,"!+,$&*!-!$*))% $&(& ( ?!7 & &'! ("7* **4!#$%$!-!"*6

@!&,$(&'!(&(!L%)(

J.PCE(&'!)$#+!&'!=!(+% **&'!+(,+&# $)-&!* !?**)% "7#G&=$%$! !$$)&$7I =' G+(* )$! $ ')4'=7 $ ( &'! $!%)*!* 
00 


 

DQG DUH HTXDOO\ LQFDSDEOH±ORJLFDOO\ DQG FDWHJRULFDOO\RI GHSULYLQJDQRWKHU RI WKH IXOO DQG HTXDO EHQHILW RI DOO ODZV DQG SURFHHGLQJV IRU WKHVHFXULW\ RI SHUVRQV DQG SURSHUW\ 2QO\ JRYHUQPHQWDO DFWRUV DUH FDSDEOHRI WKDW

6WDWH DFWRUV DQG SULYDWH DFWRUV DUH GLIIHUHQW VSHFLHV LQ WKH H\HV RI WKH

ODZ ZLWK GLVVLPLODU OHJDO SURSHUWLHV 7KXV ODZV WKDW UHJXODWH RQH RI WKHVHJURXSV RU FODVVHV XVXDOO\ DUH LQDSSOLFDEOH WR WKH RWKHU JURXS 7KDW LVSUHFLVHO\ WKH VLWXDWLRQ LQ WKLV FDVH -XVW EHFDXVH &RQJUHVV GLG QRWH[SUHVVO\ VWDWH WKLV GRHV QRW PHDQ LW LVQ¶W VR &RQJUHVV DOVR GLG QRW VWDWHWKDW   GRHV QRW DSSO\ WR DQLPDOV EXW , GR QRW WKLQN DQ\RQH ZRXOG±RUKDV DW OHDVW DV RI \HW± VXJJHVWHG WKDW LW GRHV$!%$?!6  G("7 &'! *&&! )% *!* $ $!H,)$!* R&L!*")+!(*!* ( !L+&)(*F ( &'! %L)%  (  *,44!*&*&'&&'!R ,()*'%!(& )(*N(O !("&)!*F&=')+'&'!+",*!$!#!$*$!&'*!)% *!7&'!*&&!I4PD/ 0 & 0    &$!&)*! '* *)%)"$"7 *!$-!6G@'!&'!$&')*+",*!#*!+&)(.)*")%)&!&*&&!+&)()& )* -)$&,""7 )(!-)&"! &'& (7 +")% *! , ( R")?! ,()*'%!(& )(* !("&)!*&L!*")+!(*!(!L+&)(*#!-!$7?)(F=)"")(-"-!4-!$(%!(&"!(&)&7I-26(3+

*

&22.

< -2+1 / 62%,(6., -5 0 &,9,/ 5,*+76 $&7,216

UPCEC3&&'!=8!(!$<0E

'!%B$)&7F*$!)(4)*)(&!$(""7)(+(*)*&!(&,("!**(!

$!**,*!+&)(C+E* "7)(4&!-!$7+",*!#*,*!+&)(CE')*)(&,$("!*&&'!!H,""7*,$$!*,"&#'")(4&'&&'!")?! ,()*'%!(&+",*! ")!*& $)-&!+(,+&*=!""**&&!+&)(



'!%B$)&7+")%*&'&
/"/
	

.. CE $!+",!*  #)()(4 &'& *,*!+&)( C+EF* ")("(4,4! )* )(+(*)*&!(& =)&' &'! *&&,&!F* !H," !(!#)& $-)*)(
(&'!	, $!%!,$&'!"&'&/0
	J.PCE!*(& $!H,)$!*&&!+&)(,& $!+'!* $)-&!+(* )$+)!*  	!+&)( .PCE $-)!*  +,*! # +&)(='!$! G&= $ %$! !$*(* )( (7 	&&! $ !$$)&$7+(* )$!$4)()*4,)*!(&'!')4'=7$(&'! $!%)*!*# (&'!$ #$&'! ,$ *!#! $)-)(4 !)&'!$)$!+&"7$

 



,Q VR GHFLGLQJ WRGD\ ZH DJUHH ZL

GHFLVLRQ LQ 3KLOOLS Y 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 5RFK

 G &LU -DQ   7ZR VLV0RUULV ,QF  )G  G &LU )RRG 6WRUHV ,QF  )G  WK &LU RQ RXU ZLWKGUDZQ SDQHO GHFLVLRQ LQ WKLV GHFLVLRQV DQG RQ GLFWD LQ 0DKRQH

6HFWLRQ  SURYLGHV 3(YHU\ SH

VWDWXWH RUGLQDQFH UHJXODWLRQ FXVWRP RU RU WKH 'LVWULFW RI &ROXPELD VXEMHFWV RFLWL]HQ RI WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV RU RWKHU SHUVRWR WKH GHSULYDWLRQ RI DQ\ ULJKWV SULYLOHJH&RQVWLWXWLRQ DQG ODZV VKDOO EH OLDEOH WR ODZ VXLW LQ HTXLW\ RU RWKHU SURSHU SURF  

!+,*!&'!$!)*($!*(&"?"(4,4!=!#)(&'&' %(*.+")%

8


()&)(&'!$*!+&)(.+"

,(!$/0
	J.#$-)"&)#$%,($!*("! *!$+'!* ( %!(%!(& ( '!$ ,! $+!*%!(%!(&*&&!+")%,(

%,*&*'=&'&)""$F*&'$,4')&'!$ #  $)4'& *!+,$! 7 &'! 
()&!	&&!*=')"!+&)(4G,(!$%"
(D0

 $)-&! $&7F* +&)(* +(*

*!+&)(.='!$!&'*!+&)(*%&&'!*&&!I!(
100	&0//0/.0C'* !-!" !&'$!!&!*&* #$ !&*&&!+&)()( $&)+,"$+*!6CC0E &'! *&&! +% ,"*)( &!*& 
0 


 

&LWLQJ :HVW Y $WNLQV  86    6&W  

/(GG   SXEOLF IXQFWLRQ WHVW )ODJJ %URV Y %URRNV  86

   6&W   /(GG   VDPH $GLFNHV Y 6+.UHVV 	 &R  86    6&W   /(G G  VWDWH FRPSXOVLRQ WHVW %XUWRQ Y :LOPLQJWRQ 3DUNLQJ $XWK  86

   6&W   /(GG   V\PELRWLF UHODWLRQVKLS

WHVW

$!"&)(*') $(!L,*&!*&*%"D0&P( !"' %($4,!*&'&*,%%$7B,4%!(&*',"'-! !!( !()! !+,*! &'!$! =*  4!(,)(! )**,! #%&!$)" #+& $!4$)(4 &'! !L)*&!(+! # *&&! +&)( ,(!$!)&'!$&'! ,")+#,(+&)(&!*&$&'!(!L,*&!*&




(!$&'! ,")+#,(+&)(&!*& $)-&! $&7)*!!%!

*&&!+&$)#'!$*'!!L!$+)*! =!$*&$)&)(""7$!*!$-!!L+",*)-!"7&&'!*&&!'! ,")+ #,(+&)(&!*&'*!!()(&!$ $!&!($$="7("7#,(+&)(*")?!'")(4!"!+&)(*-/
/"/D
	/PP..	&

0PD0.PC.E!L!$+)*)(4!%)(!(&%)(

B"
4
1/
	/PP0PP 	& // /0 0 / C/E (  !$&)(4 +% (7=(!&=(4
	0D
	PPPDD	&0D0DP C/DE #"",(!$&')*+&!4$7#*&&!+&)(,$*)*&!$+)$+,)&*'-!+(*)*&!(&"7'!"&'&&'!%!$!#+&&'&&'! !$#$%(+!# $)-&!*!+,$)&7#,(+&)(*%7 !(&)"&'!)(-!*&)4&)(#  +$)%!!*(&&$(*#$%&'!+&)(*# $)-&!*!+,$)&7##)+!$)(&*&&!+&)(*%
/.0PC&')$DE9


#C(-///0

/PC&')$PE9%
*

P/0/

/0/CP&')$E


( % #$ !L% "! &'! )#&' )$+,)& '!" &'& &'!

!&!(&)(#*,* !+&!*' ")#&!$)*(&(!L+",*)-!*&&!#,(+&)(

 



,URQLFDOO\ WKH PDMRULW\ DFWXDOO\ PD

 Q 3$OWKRXJK QRW JHUPDQH WR &KDSPHTXDO EHQHILW FODXVH RQH FRXOG PDNH D VVXEVHFWLRQ D¶V OLNH SXQLVKPHQW FODXVH ́3>W@KHUH LV QRWKLQJ XQZRUNDEOH KRZHYHJLYHQ VWDWXWH PD\ SURVFULEH FRQGXFW ESHUVRQV WKH VWDWXWH UHJXODWHV DUH DFWXDOO\ 

SURYLGHV WKH H[DPSOH RI DQ LQGXVWULDO G

LQFDSDEOH RI YLRODWLQJ D KLJKVSHHG OLPIDOODFLRXV +HUH XQOLNH WKH LQGLYLGXDO LQGWUXFN PLJKW QRW EH DEOH WR H[FHHG  PLODUH FRQFHSWXDOO\ LQFDSDEOH RI LPSRVLQJ WD

#$ !()" # ++%%&)( (   	,  0 C !$%)&&)(4+,*!#+&)(,(!4)(*&%!%!$*#&'!>,>",L>D/0	, .0C+,*!#+&)(,(!$&'!!H,"!##)+!$*='!&%)($)&7-)+&)%* * &'! 4 +,$&F* +%%$!)(4#*,*!+&)(C+E)*)(+(*!(!#)&+",*!=')+')% ")+)&"7)(*&&!+&)(("7&'!*&&!+( $*&&!+(! $)-!()()-),"#(+&7 $)-&!)()-),"=')#(&'!$)*(&&'!!H,)-"!(&#!H," !(!#)& # &'! "= -)"&!)()-),")*("7! $)-!#&'!#"=*( $+!!)(4*)#'!$*'!#$%!(#$+)(4&'$,4'"!4" $+$)4'&*$!&'!*&&,&!(7)##


#&'!%B$)&7F*-)!=)*+$$!+&

$! *,*!+&)( C+E *  "7)(4*,*!+&)(CE&'!")?! ,()*'%!(GNO"" !$*(**'""!*,B!+& !("&)!*&L!*")+!(*!(!L+*!$),*"7&'&()()-),"+(*,,(!H," ,()*'%!(& $ &L!* 
0 


 

)(&!$("H,&&)(%)&&!+)&)(4 4E

00	&DDC00E9	2
/*(	"&(0D C.&')$0EC*%!+)&)(4C((4E9/&

4 0P.C)$0EC)+&EC*&&)(4&'&G!-!()#=!$!&+(*)!$&'!%*,+'R#,""(!H,"!(!#)&F+")%*=,"#)")(")4'&#*,*&(&)"")(!#,&'$)&7'")(4&'&("7*&&!+&$*+(!*,!,(!$&'!R#,""(!H,"!(!#)&F+",*!#	!+&)(.T9+)&)(44E9*
.P0P0

P0P0DC/&')$.DEC'")(4&'&)&4$!!G=)&'&'!')$)$+,)&F*)(&!$ $!&&)(#&'!R#,""(!H,"!(!#)&F+",*!(+(+",!&'&*&&!+&)()*$!H,)$!)($!$&**!$&+")%,(!$&'&*&&,&!I9+)&)(44E
.
(/.
	DPC.E	)%)"$"7(,%!$#&'!$+,$&*&'&'-!+(*)!$!&'!)**,!&'!#$!(#&!$&'!%!(%!(&'-! #""=!&'!$!*()(4#4* 4("
%"6A3

0@DP&/C!L5,"70/0ECG*!(&*&&!+&)(2")(&)##F*	!+&)(.+")%N,(!$&'!#,""(!H," !(!#)& +",*!O )* ,(&!("! ( *  $!*,"& )& )*#$)-",*IE9*
D,,".	, .D0C
""E9!&
B/.	, D

C!"DE9*


.	, /.C	;ECG3*&#&'!!+)*)(*'-!'!"&'&*&&!+&)()*$!H,)$!&*&&!+")%,(!$&'!R!H,"!(!#)&F(R")?! ,()*'%!(&F+",*!*#J.IE9/"
	/ 	, ///C')E
 
   ( 0 0 /P CD&' )$ E9
	, D0C
"".E9
 
%  
   	,  ./ .PC@ A .E . .D 0 P/ C/&' )$ E9



.
(#&	"
	/ 

D	, /C.PE91
1&3((*+( PD	, //PCA.E./00//.C/&')$./E9

% 
 # 4(  * P/  	, 

0 C3**.E/(-

.0	, 00/C20EC""=)(4+,*!#+&)(,(!$&'!!H,"!(!#)&+",*!4)(*& $)-&!'&!"

 



%!$+'(&F*!&!(&)(# !$**&$! $ !$&7 *)% "7 )* (& **+)&!=)&'&'! *&&!L  $)%!$!* (*))")&7#$ $&!+&)$!%)(* =)&' &'! )()-),"  %&)-&)()(!&)()(4 !$*()(&'!+&#*&!")(4')* $ !$&"&$,)*%	,+'+&)(+((&"&'!*&&!

P/0&/0C+)&&)(%)&&!E& ' %(F* +")% =! $! **!+,$)&7##)+!$ =*(& !$#$%)$!*!$-!&&'!	&&!='!('!*& 
(!$&'! ,")+#,(+&)(&!*&&'!

0


(!$&'!*7%)&)+$(!L,*&!

%,*& !%(*&$&! &'& &'!$! )* !&=!!(&'!4-!$(%!(&(&'! &'&&'!+(,+&%7!#)$"7&&$)%" D 0 & P9 **	0 	& 0/ /. 0 .+'""!(4!+&)-)&7%7!*&&!=)&'4-!$(%!(&" ")+)!*$='!)(N)&*O%(4!%!(&$+(&$"IEC)!
*
D000&'&##)+!$='*'& ")(&)##=')"!,(!$+"$#*&&!"=!+,*!=! ( !$)-! #$% ')* *&&,* !&=!!(##)+!$ ( ")(&)## $*,&)!* ( ")(&)## &'$!&!(! + +)&7E9 * 
 / P00PEC+(+",)(4&'&##,&7 ?)""!&=%!(( $"7K!&')$,(!$+"$#"=!+,*!%+!)**,!7 ")+!! $&%!(&()(&!$-!(!)()* ,&! ,$*,(&&
/ 


 

'LOODUG¶V SROLF\ GRHV QRW GHILQH VWULS VHDUFKLQJ %HFDXVH &KDSPDQ

ZDV IRUFHG WR UHPRYH KHU FORWKLQJ LH VKH ZDV IRUFHG WR UHPRYH KHU FRDWDQG VXLW MDFNHW DQG OLIW XS KHU VKLUW D MXU\ FRXOG UHDVRQDEO\ GHWHUPLQH

WKDW VKH ZDV VWULS VHDUFKHG XQGHU WKH 'LOODUG¶V SROLF\

'!)(H,)$7)*#+&* !+)#)+(&'! $!*!(+!#*&&!+&)(

)* !&!$%)(! (  +*!7+*! *)*  * /( 


% " 	( DP 
	 P . 	& .PD D0/PCDE"&',4'G)&)* **)"!&!&!$%)(!='!&'!$ !$*(+&!,(!$+"$#*&&!"=*%&&!$#"= &'!$! %7 $!%)( )( *%! )(*&(+!* ,((*=!$!H,!*&)(*##+&$!4$)(4&'! $ !$+'$+&!$)K&)(#&'!+&)(* #$ &'! B,$7 & !+)!I  ! D0 0 & C)(&!$("+)&&)(*(H,&&)(*%)&&!E

!$! &'! )""$F* *!+,$)&7 ##)+!$ =' *& ! (

*!$+'!' %(=*(##,&7*'!$)##M*! ,&7=!$)(4')*##)+)"*'!$)##F*! $&%!(&,()#$%4!(*)!$%3$!-!$&'!)""$F**!+,$)&7##)+!$=*")4&!&!7)""$F* ")+)!*($!4,"&)(*=')"!(,&7&&'!*&$!"&',4'&'!*&&! "7!( $&)(&'! $%,"4&)(#&'!*! ")+)!*&'!)$*&$) *!$+')(4 $-)*)()$!+&"7)% ")+&!*&'!*&&!6G	&$) *!$+'!*$! $'))&!
#7,*,* !+&&'&*&"!(B!+&*$!')!((N&'!*' !$F*O !$*(+""&'! ")+!I

,$)(4&'!)(+)!(&&)**,!&'!)""$F**!+,$)&7##)+!$

)(&$! $!*!(&')%*!"#* ")+!##)+!$&'$!&!(&$$!*&' %(=-!')*4!$=! ($!*&")*'(7+(&+&=)&'&'!*'!$)##M*! $&%!(&!)'=!-!$)()&)&!*&$) *!$+'7$!H,)$)(4' %(&!(&!$#)&&)(4$%=)&'&'!*"!*%(4!$&)(* !+&'!$ +"&')(48!+,*! )""$F*

 ")+7 ")+!)(&!$-!(&)()(*&$) *!$+'*)&,&)(*$!*("!B,$7+,"-!$7=!""#)(&'&&'!)()&)&)(#*&$)  *!$+' 7 ( $%! ,()#$%! *'!$)##F* ! ,&7+(*&)&,&!(+&&'&%7#)$"7!&&$),&!&&'!*&&!)&)(""7)#' %()(&#!!"#$!!&"!-!*$!*,"&#&'!*!+,$)&7##)+!$F**'!$)##F*,()#$%')*4!$')**)!$%$!*("!B,$7+,"#)(&'!!&!(&)(=*&+)&$$!*&(#)$"7&&$),&"!&&'!*&&!

 



+$)(&)(4 &'!% =)&' &'! #+&*%?!&'!%,(+"!$IE

'! $)4'&* )( *,*!+&)( CE $

'=!-!$9 *%! $&!+& 4)(*& +%%)&&!7&' ,")+( $)-4)(*&+(,+&&'&(!+!**$)"7)(-!L% "! &' $)-&! ( ,")+(&$+&*
(#+&GN)O&)*,*,""7=&'!*&&!&'&"+? !$*(=,")&)*&'&&'!$)()-),"F*$+)""7 +(&$+& =')+' +( +,*! '$4 
 % PD/ 0 C)+&E  ',* *,*!+&)( C+E %+(&$+&+",*!#CE

;!&)&+((&*!*)"7!*)&'

&'!!H,"!(!#)&+",*!#CE)$+,)&6

'! =$* G#,"" ( !H," 


 #$&'! *!+,$)&7 #C!% '*)**, ")!E(&'!&'!$=)&'$!"&)(*!&=!!(&'!)()-!&=!!(&=)()-),"*'!*)*&'!*"!*,$+!#"=()&&'$,4')&*4!(&*(&&'! $)-+ "!#!(7)(4&"+?*&'!&'! "=  ',* =')"! $)-&! )% ")+&!7&'! +(&$+& +",+(+! &# *&&! +&)()*)% ")+",*!

 &0C)+&E

-!$7+,$&# !"*&'&'*

 $)$(*,*!H,!(&&&'!4 +,$&F* -)!=  * C(* 0DD.P.PPC.GNO!+,*!&'!*&&!)*&'!*"!*,$*&&!&'& +( !(7&'! #,"" ( !
. 


 

 !"#$%&'(

"" !$*(*=)&')(&'!B,$)*)+&)(#&'!
()&!	&&!*

*'""'-!&'!*%!$)4'&)(!-!$7	&&!(!$$)&$7&%?! ( !(#$+! +(&$+&* & *,! ! $&)!* 4)-!!-)!(+!((+(&
(


'&,(*'""!*,B!+&&")?! ,()*'%!(& )(* !("&)!* &L!* ")+!(*!* (!L+&)(*#!-!$7?)((&(&'!$)*+,- $..$.(/- %-

$ ,$ *!* # &')* *!+&)( &'! &!$% G%?! (

!(#$+! +(&$+&*I )(+",!* &'! %?)(4 !$#$%(+!%)#)+&)( ( &!$%)(&)( # +(&$+&* ( &'!!(B7%!(& # "" !(!#)&* $)-)"!4!* &!$%* (+()&)(*#&'!+(&$+&,"$!"&)(*') .$.%&%(%0%$

'! $)4'&* $&!+&! 7 &')* *!+&)( $! $&!+&!

4)(*&)% )$%!(&7((4-!$(%!(&")*+$)%)(&)(()% )$%!(&,(!$+"$#	&&!"=

/0 
	 J C.E C@!*& /E C!% '*)* !E(4$!** %!(! J . )(  7 )(4 *,*!+&)(*CE(C+E(!*)4(&)(4&'!$)4)("*!+&)(**,*!+&)(CE2,0DDJP	&&CE

1

' %(F*$4,%!(&')(4!*(*,*!+&)(C+E
(&

)*4$!! &'& *,*!+&)( C+E *&()(4 "(! ")("7 *&&!*GN&O'! $&!+&!7&')**!+&)($! $&!+&!4)(*&)% )$%!(&7((4-!$(%!(&")*+$)%)(&)(I!)()*"&)(*,*!+&)(C+E)*,(%)4,,*8,&*,*!+&)(C+E$!H,)$!*(!&"?!"*!='!$!S $!*,%"7*,*!+&)(CES&!&!$%)(!&G$)4'&*I$! $&!+&!#$%((4-!$(%!(&"

)*+$)%)(&)(

,()  $57(5 < +20$6  885.(

5($621 ,1 /$: /PC(4%(D&'!00ECG-!(='!(

=$* )( )*"&)(  *!!% ,(%)4,,* &'! $+!** #

 



'!$!#$!=!#)(&'&&'!$!)*

#+&*&='!&'!$&'!*!+,$)&7##*&&!"=I='!('!*?!' %=)&'&'!*"!*%(4!$*&'&' +,"!*!$+'!






$&'!#$!4)(4$!*(*=!

#$#,$&'!$ $+!!)(4*+(*)*&!(&
D 


 







	


)$+,)&5,4!)**!(&)(4




# &'!$! )*  #)$*& $)(+) "! %(4 +((* # *&&,&$7

)(&!$ $!&&)()&)*&'&*&&,&!)*&!!(#$+!++$)(4&&'! ")(%!()(4#)&*&!$%**)*


1 /.
	0P0/C.E93
.

1 P. CD&')$.E *%!!L&!(&&',4'&'! ")(%!()(4$,"!)*&,&"476G@$**'," ! $! * *7)(4 ='& &'!7 *7I   *

(('

,&.(5621 7+( ,17(535(7$7,21 $1' $33/,&$7,21 2)

67$787(6 00C)&&"!8$=(<PE
(&'!$=$*

GN&O'!$,"!&!""*,*&$!* !+&%!()(4,&)&!**=)&',&)*+"*)(4='&&'!* !+)#)+%!()(4)*I ',**(!

+%%!(&&$'**!$-!6

& !*& N&'! ")( %!()(4 $,"!O $!##)$%* &'! $!!%)(!(+!#&'!*&&,&!-!$%&!$)"*!L&$)(*)+&)&
()&*(!4&)-! * !+&(&'!&'!$ '(&'! $,"!'**%!&)%!*!!(,*!&$!)(! &"7!L $!**!"(4,4!,& # )&* $ !$ +(&!L& )( -)"&)( # !*&")*'! $)(+) "!* # %!()(4 ( +%%,()+&)(   &')*!L&!(&)&)*()% !)%!(&&)(&!$ $!&&)(

 

)?!%*&$,"!*)("='=!-!$&')*!$+? $)(+) "!#

*&&,&$7 +(*&$,+&)( )* H,")#)! * $!#"!+&! )( ( !$"7)(-+&)(#&'!+&$)(!6


#&'!=$*+(-!7!#)()&!%!()(4=')+')(-"-!*(*,$)&7($(7+(&$)+&)(#&'!$ $&*#&'!)(*&$,%!(&&'!(&'&%!()(4 $!(&(&'!#+!#&'!)(*&$,%!(&%,*&!++! &!((!)&'!$&'!+,$&*($&'!"!4)*"&,$!'-!&'!$)4'&&&)&$&?!#$%)&

 

!"(

	=$* &'! ")( %!()(4 +%((!&'!"!** *,B!+& & &' )(&!$,&.(5621(
&0C*&&)(4!* GN(O& H,)&!I !%( ")&!$+(&!L&)*(&!L+",!(!L&!$)(& ++,(& & &'! !L&!(& # =*,$)&7IE

'!%B$)&7+?(="!4!*&'&

)**,B!+&&!L+! &)(**4'$!*$& & &'*! !L+! &)(* '=!J.)*,(%)4,,*)(&'&*,$)4'&* $&!+&! 7 &')* *!+&)()% )$%!(&7((4-!$(%!(&"&'!$)4'&*!(,%!$&!)(*,*!+&)($)4'&R&&'!#,""(!H,"!(!#)&#$&'!*!+,$)&7# !$*(*( $ +)&)K!(*FI $%&')*&'!%B$)GR $&!+&! 4)(*& )% )$%!()*+$)%)(&)(FI 8!+,*! 
)(&!$ $!&&)(#&'!*&&,&!+$!&!*)(+(*)*&!(&=)&'&'!"!4)*"&)-!'$!*,"&*3P&+,$&*%7"?!7("(4,4!



	

G
(""+*!*#*&&,&$7+(*&$,

&'!"(4,4!!% "7!7(4$!*

 CD&' )$ .E C)(&!$(" H,	!+&)(.*%!(!)(