'#

(!''%(%+12,1010

,..




,

 "',

)-



	,

"%# $'+&*(')%'#% #'# #%#

$%'!"'#	(!"%)&,"



	,

"%# $'+&*(')%#'# #%#
"' 

	 '
"&''(''( #,""'&-

 

FILED

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

DENVER, COLORADO 

JEFFREY P. COLWELL, CLERK 

1:56 pm, Mar 03, 2020

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 1 of 41
 I

+.+2IO4IGIG

/)'"!
"0551)1466871


!	('(+%. "'' 

'"---, ",-+-. 

",-+"-((%(+(

%+7++#'"---,(.+-!(.,

PGHHP-+-

'/+4OGIPK

. ' 4

!",+)(+-,+/,,(.++.+2IO4IGIG,--.,+)(+-&'-2-!(','-+"%

+!HL4IGHP).+,.'--(,(7H6HH</<GIIOL<7,2(.$'(04-!(','-+

>(%%(0"' 2(.++%"+(.+-(++?+*."+,.,-(&('"-(+)+( +,,')+(/"

+(&&'-"(',(+"&)+(/&'--(-!(%(+()+-&'-(	.&'+/",>	?,

-!2--&)--("&)+(/(&)-'2<+%-,+/",-(+"&"'%''-,0"-!),2!"-+"

"%%',,7)""%%24-!(','-+>)7IK?"'"-,4

/96'8:5,:.+*;:/+9:.+$6+)/'2'9:+89.'22685</*+:.+5;8:'4*:.+"'8:/+9=/:.9:':;9

8+658:9+<+8?5:.+8354:.,58:.+,/89:9/>354:.9'4*:.+47;'8:+82?:.+8+',:+8%.+$6+)/'2

'9:+8D99:':;98+658:='99;(3/::+*54'4;'8?	
1:

%.+4+>:8+658:9.'22(+

9;(3/::+*:5:.+5;8:'4*:.+"'8:/+954'8).	
'4*:.+4'?	
'4*:.+4

7;'8:+82?:.+8+',:+8$;).8+658:99.'22'**8+99:.++6'8:3+4:D9)5362/'4)+=/:.:.+

:/3+,8'3+8+7;/8+3+4:95,:.+549+4:+)8++)54)+84/4-536+:+4)?$+8</)+9'4*9.'22

685</*+'*+:'/2+*9;33'8?5,/4,583':/54'4*8+)533+4*':/549:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8(+2/+<+9

:.+5;8:'4*"'8:/+99.5;2*)549/*+88+2':/4-:5:.++6'8:3+4:D9)5362/'4)+=/:.:.+

549+4:+)8++:/3+,8'3+9)54)+84/4-536+:+4)?$+8</)+9

//%.+$6+)/'2'9:+8D98+658:9.'22/4)2;*+(;:/945:2/3/:+*:58+658:/4-54:.+4;3(+85,

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++958*+8+*:58+)+/<+536+:+4)?$+8</)+9'4'99+993+4:5,:.+

+6'8:3+4:D956+8':/5499?9:+39'4*'*3/99/54968'):/)+9'4*652/)/+98+2':/4-:5:.+

+6'8:3+4:D9'(/2/:?:5)5362?=/:.:.+549+4:+)8++:/3+,8'3+9'4*-;/*'4)+:5:.+

+6'8:3+4:,58/3685<+3+4:'4*/4)8+'9/4-+,,/)/+4)/+9/4:.+9+'8+'9

"'(.+))("'-&'-,)"%,-+(''.+2I4IGHP4-!)+-",'-+"'-(&"-"('4

+,.%-"' "'-!(','-+"%+!HL4IGHP7!",(','-+)+,+"/+"-2

(,-),-!)+-&'-&.,--$-("&)+(/-!(&)-'2,,,,&'-'+,-(+-"('

,2,-&"'(%(+(4'/'-.%%2--"'(&)%"'0"-!%%-"&+&,'%"',

&'-"'-!(','-+7!)+-&'-!,"'"-"-&'2(-!,,-),4

&(',-+-"' &'"' .%)+( +,,4"'02,0-"%-!+(. !-!+&"'+(-!",+)(+-7	!

#%'(%.'&%#"%'*"(&"!)"# !'&&!"(%#%"%$(%'%,%#"%'.**&

&( ''
") %68.64590



 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 2 of 41
 J










##############################################################################################################################'


)


	

********************************5


)


*******************************************************************6


)

***************************************************************..


)	



***************************************.1





######################################################################################%(












*******************************************************************************************************************************************.3

& %"$
!#&!&('&"!**************************************************************************************************.4

& %"$
!#&!&%&"$&"!************************************************************************************************.6




**************************************************************************/.





	
	*****************************************************************************************/1





+
*******************/4




*****************************************************************************************0.




+


	
*****************************************************************0/





#####################################################################################&'




***********************************************************************************************************************************01

	
	

************************************************************************************************02





*********************************************************************************03



################################################################################################################################'%

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 3 of 41
 K





,2(.$'(04-!(','-+"%+!HL4IGHP)+,+"&'2,-),-!)+-&'-

&.,--$4'-"&%"',"-&.,-&-4-("&)+(/-!(&)-'2,,,,&'-'+,-(+-"('

,2,-&"'(%(+(7-+-!(','-+0,"%"'+!4-!)+-&'- '-$"' 

&'2(-!,,-),>-"%-!+(. !(.--!",+)(+-?"'02,-!-0(',"+ '+%%2

+,)(',"/4'"'02,-!-))+-(+( '"3-! +/"-2'(&)%1"-2(-!!%%' ,

-!27

+(%2,)$"' 40(',"+-!+ (%,(-!(','-+-()+"&+26

?."' -!(/+%%!( %()()%('-!0"-%",-(+(&)-'+,-(+-"('

,+/",4

?."' -!*' ' &(+)()%('-!0"-%",-4)+-".%+%2)()%0"-!-!&(,-

.-),2!"-+""%%',,4'

?."' % >2)+(/""' %?-()()%('-!0"-%",-7

+( +,,('-!"+,- (%",%+5-!+!,'&(,-=.-,-2'&'"' .%=

+,"'-!0"-%",-(/++'-&('-!,7+( +,,('-!,(' (%!,',.,-'-"%4

-!(. !"!,(+)()%0"-!-!&(,-.-),2!"-+""%%',,5-!(,0"-!%,,.+ '-',,-"%%

1)+"'1,,"/%2,7
"$0",4)+( +,,('-!-!"+ (%!,'&"17!

)+-&'-!,)+(/")+(&)-+2!(,)"-%"3"' -!(,0!(+&(,-"%%4')+(/""' 

,(&,+/",-(-!(,0"-"' %(' +"'-!#"%,7!",+)(+--"%,)+( +,,('-!,-!+

)+"&+2&+$+,,0%%,(-!+$2/%()&'-,7

%"%&&/

!(','-+!,'(0'"'-(+%&(,-('2+7!+,-!"+,-!%(-!

2+0,%&(,-'-"+%2)%''"' '"&)%&'--"('4-!%,-,/+%&('-!,!/0"-',,

-!%.'!(,/+%'0"'"-"-"/,'4&(,-+'-%24-!())(+-.'"-2-((,+/-!+%2

,- ,(-!"+)+(+&'7+'(0 "''"' -(,-!(.-(&,(-!(,'0"'"-"-"/,

-!(','-+)+,+"7)""%%24-!)+-&'-!,6

• "'-"''"''(/-"/+" ,2,-&4$2(&)+(&",+(&-!(','-+4

0!"!+*."+,-!)+-&'--(+)"%2>"7740"-!"'N2,?&"-(+(&)-'

+,-(+-"('-!&(,-.-%2"%%''-,>9"+H:?'%,,+)"%2&"--!(,0!(

%,,.+ '-%2'!(,)"-%"3-"('>9"+I:?7



• &"---!,"+H''-,(+"')-"'-+,-(+-"('"')+(&)-&''+4

(',",-'-0"-!-!+*."+&'-,(-!(','-+7!",",-!&(,-," '""'-

"&)+(/&'--(-!(&)-'2,2,-&"',/+%2+,4'-!)+-&'-!,

('-"'.-(&"'-"''+%2)+-(&)%"'0"-!-!,,-+"-,/'<2

+*."+&'-,7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 4 of 41
 L

• ('-"'.-(+"'-!'0(+',".))(+-&>?4'(-!+$2(&)(''-(

-!(','-+7!&('"-(+,"'(&)-'-<-(<)+(>
?''-,"'#"%

0"-"' !(,)"-%"3-"('5-!2!/"'-+/'"',/+%+",",'&+ '2,"-.-"(',4

'-+',"-"(',(&''-,-((&&.'"-2,+/",7!)+,'(-&-(

&('"-(+-!''-,('-!0"-%",-",,.,-'-"%"&)+(/&'--(-!(%(+(

(&)-'2,2,-&7

• "'%"39(&)+!',"/'(!,"/)%':(+(&)-'2,+/","'(%(+(-!-

",/,-%2"&)+(/(/+-!)%'-!2)+)+"'%-IGHO7

• 
&)+(/-!(.+-+/",.'"-((+',"/%.-(+,2+,)('"' -(%(' ,-'"' 

('+',4!' "' ,-+.-.+')+,(''%4'+<"'/" (+-"' '/%.-(+-+"'"' 

)+( +&7

• )'JP'0,(+(&)-'2+,-(+-"('-	
4,-)-!-&

&'"' .%+,"'-!0"-%",-7

• "'%%24/"-!"',(&&"--)+,+"2-!(','-+>)7HN?4-!

)+-&'-4","%"-2
0(%(+(>
?4'-!)"%,-+(%%(+-0"-!-!

(%(+((%"-"('(+-!	(&%,,-(.'.'"-,"'.,"('-."(,40!"!", "''"' 

-()+(/"!(.,"' "'-!(&&.'"-2-(&'2!(&%,,(&)-'2<"'/(%/

"'"/".%,(/+-!'1-"/2+,7

,-"%"'(.+%,-+)(+-4-!,/%()&'-,!/2"%,(&)+( +,,-(0+, (%,(

-!(','-+7)""%%24-!0"-%",-!,+,2JI''-,(/+-!",J<&('-!

+)(+-"' )+"(>+)+,'-"' IHS+,?7''-,()"'-("+H('-"'.-(

&"---(	
)+(&)-%240"-!"'-!(','-+8,N<2-"&+&7	(0/+4-!0"-

(+"+I''-,!,"'+,,%" !-%27

!&/

!)+-&'-!,%,(1)+"'," '""'-,-$,'!%%' ,7! +-,-,-$

0,-!"+"%.+-(&--"&%"',(+&'2#"%<,(&)-'2/%.-"(',4-!(. !&-"' 

-!(,-"&%"',!',-+' -!(-!)+-&'-"'+'-2+,7

• (+-!"+,--"&"'2+,4-!)+-&'-!,"%-(&--"&%"',(+#"%<,

(&)-'2)('"!,+/",7,0'-"")-"'(.+%,-+)(+-4,-"' ,!(+- ,

'(-!+!%%' ,%--!)+-&'-.'%-(/%.-%%''-,"'#"%0"-!"'

IO2,(-!(.+-(++-((,(7
''.+24(+1&)%4KKS(-!,''-,

0+/%.--+-!IO<2%"'!),,7-"%%-+"'-!",+)(+--!

02,-!)+-&'-!,+,)('-(-!",!%%' #

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 5 of 41
 M

• !,%2,!/.'+,(+-!!%%' ,-!)+-&'-,"'++."-"' '

/%()"' '*.-0(+$(+((+',"/%.-(+,7(%+4-!)+-&'-

!,-$'," '""'-,-),-(+,,-!)+(%&,0)+/"(.,%2+,,"'-!(.+-

+/",.'"-((+',"/%.-(+,4'0!/,',-+(' "&)+(/&'-,"'&(+%4

%+,!")4'-+"'"' 7.--!)+-&'-0"%%'-(/(-," '""'-+,(.+,-(

/%()"' '*.-0(+$(+((.+-+/",/%.-(+,'('-+-(+',"

/%.-(+,7

2('-!",," '""'-,-$"'&-"' /%.-"('-"&%"',4,(&(-!)+"&+2!%%' ,

>"774-!+,(+%(,,-,+.-"'2',.))(+-?0"'-"""'(.+)+"(+*.+-+%2+)(+-

+&"'6

• %+-"' +,-(+-"(',+/",(+''-,," '-"+I7!)+-&'-!,

,!(0'"&)+(/&'-,"'-!(/+%%'.&+,("+I''-,'-!/+ 0"-

-"&,(+-!&, +(.)7	(0/+4-!(/+%%/+ 0"--"&,+,-"%%+-((%(' 

' +-%21-!&1"&.&-"&+&,,-2-!(','-+7"/+,"('

(+-,4,--.-(+2+(+&,4'!'(&&.'"-2,+/",4'"'+,"')-"'-

,)!!%)+,-!%(' 0"-%",-4.--!(,%(' <-+&,(%.-"(',('(-

"&&"-%2+,,-!',(
''-,.++'-%20"-"' (+&('-!,"'(.'-2

#"%,7

• ',.+"' -!-,!+"8,)+-&'-,'(.'-2#"%,+--+)+)+-()+(/"

'!'&'-%!%-!,+/",(+''-,0"-"' (&)-'2,+/","'%(%

(.'-2#"%,7!"%.'"' '-!'"%,,",-'!,'/"%%(+,/+%

&('-!,4-!,()'+-!(,+/",,-"%%/+",0"%2=,.!-!-,(&(.'-",

!/+.,-!.'"' 4',/+%,&-(()+-0"-!"'*.-"'<#"%&'-%

!%-!,+/",7

• ('"-(+"' (-!-!'-!.-)-"'-(&)-',-(+-"('+( +&>?

,2,-&,7!"%,.,-'-"%)+( +,,",))+'-"'(-!)+( +&,4(-!+,-"%%+%-"/%2

'0'('-"'.-(1)+"' +(0"' )"',7"-!+)+( +&!,'*.-

,2,-&(+-(%%-"('4-'%2,",4(+)+( +&/%.-"('7.+-!+4(.+-,'

(-!+)+,(''%('-"'.-(1)+,,('.,"('(.--!+(%,'1)--"(',(!

)+( +&4,(.+-!+.-"('(+-,0"%%',,+27

,"'(.+%,-*.+-+%2+)(+-40('-"'.-("+&-!)+-&'-8,(+-,-('--!

!' ,)+,+""'-!(','-+7!2!/&(',-+-%+,.,,"'

&"'-"'"' -!-+" ,2,-&4"&)+(/"' (.+-+/",>%+,!")4&(+%4'-+"'"' ?4



	"($'(/
'&&&(#(''&*''#!!)"(-''(#&(#"&(!"(:;/)(

(#*##")'#"+(#(&!&"$&#&!'/+"#+)'(!#&#!!#"(&!/
)($("(

#!$("'(#&(#"&#&!:
;2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 6 of 41
 N

&$"' (.-)-"'-(&)-'2+,-(+-"('>?&(+0"%2/"%%4'%.'!"' 

(+',".))(+-&>?7.-"-0"%%+."%-(*.-%2+,,-!,!(+- (

(&)-'/%.-(+,,0%%,,(&(-!&(+)+,",-'-)+(%&,6%(' 0"-%",-,(+"+I

"'"/".%,4)((+%/+ 0"-!"'-+"&#"%&'-%!%-!,+/",4)((+-&' &'-"'

+-"'+,4'((+"'-"(';.-"('&(' -!'+" ,)+( +&,7

,"'/+2*.+-+%2+)(+-40 "'2+,,"' -!)+-&'-8,(&)%"'0"-!-"&

+&+*."+&'-,4.,-!",",-!)+"&+2(.,(-!(','-+>'-!(.,-!-

-!(','-+)+,+",(+(.+*.+-+%2+)(+-,?7(',"+-!,-"&+&,(.+

9$2&-+",:=(+)+"&+2&+$+,()+( +,,=-!-0+/"0"'!*.+-+%2+)(+-7

	(0/+40-!'1)'-(+,,-!(-!+"'-+/'-"(',)+,+"2-!(','-+

.,)+( +,,"'-!,"'-+/'-"(',0"%%%"$%2('-+".--()+( +,,"'!"/"' -!(/+%%

 (%((&)%"'0"-!-"&+&+*."+&'-,#

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 7 of 41
 O


)


	



,)+,+""'-!(','-+4)+"&+2(.,(-!,*.+-+%2+)(+-,&.,--!

)+-&'-8,(&)%"'0"-!-"&+&+*."+&'-,6

/96'8:5,:.+*;:/+9:.+$6+)/'2'9:+89.'22685</*+:.+5;8:'4*:.+"'8:/+9=/:.9:':;9

8+658:9$;).


	

	
'4*9.'22685</*+'

*+:'/2+*9;33'8?5,/4,583':/54'4*8+)533+4*':/549:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8(+2/+<+9:.+5;8:

'4*"'8:/+99.5;2*)549/*+88+2':/4-:5:.++6'8:3+4:D9)5362/'4)+=/:.:.+549+4:+)8++

:/3+,8'3+9)54)+84/4-536+:+4)?$+8</)+9549+4:+)8++6


//%.+$6+)/'2'9:+8D98+658:9.'22/4)2;*+(;:/945:2/3/:+*:58+658:/4-54:.+4;3(+85,

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++958*+8+*:58+)+/<+536+:+4)?$+8</)+9'4'99+993+4:5,:.+

+6'8:3+4:D956+8':/5499?9:+39'4*'*3/99/54968'):/)+9'4*652/)/+98+2':/4-:5:.+

+6'8:3+4:D9'(/2/:?:5)5362?=/:.:.+549+4:+)8++:/3+,8'3+9'4*-;/*'4)+:5:.+

+6'8:3+4:,58/3685<+3+4:'4*/4)8+'9/4-+,,/)/+4)/+9/4:.+9+'8+'9

!+(+4)+"&+2(.,((.++/"0",-!)+-&'-8,)+( +,,"'&-"' -!-"&

+&,%"'-"'-!(','-+7!","'%.,(-!-"&+&,(+(&)-'

)('"!'(+(&)-'%&'"%'"!7'-"")--!--!,0"%%-!$2&-+",-(

&(',-+-)+( +,,(/+-!'1-02+,4,(-!2+(.+,-+-"' )("'-"'-!+)(+-4,

0%%,)+"&+2(.,7(.+,4)+(+&'"'&-"' -!,-"&+&,)', +-%2

(''-"' -!(-!+,-),)+,+""'-!(','-+4,(,.,*.'-,-"(',(-!

+)(+-+/"0-!(,,-),"' +-+-"%7

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 8 of 41
 P


)




,,.&&+"3"'-!-%%(04-!)+-&'-!,!",-(+"%%2&-/%.-"('-"&+&,4

/'0%%(+.'IGHP'/'-!+(. !-!"+,-,/+%&('-!,(-!(','-+7

"*)%..+"' -!),-*.+-+4-!)+-&'- '"%"' -(&--!,-"&+&,(+

-!"+,--"&"'&'24&'2&('-!,7



$ "! "$#"
 $!

)8
(

B@AI

#*

B@AI



B@AI


"

B@B@


")&-B@B@

%)&!"(


) -B@B@

%)&!"(


 8'

#!$("-

* )(#"'

B@2H BB2C< C@2B< CC2B< BH-' BA-'



	"$("(

#!$("-

* )(#"'



AG2A< AB2B AC2I AB2@ BA-' AD-'

@T			
	
		
	
	
		


	",-(+"%%24-"&%2(&)-'/%.-"('!,'+%-"/,-+' -!(-!)+-&'-7%%

(+-!+'-(','-+4-!2(%%(0-!'-"('%-+'(<'-+%"3"' 

/%.-"(',4&(/"' -!&+(&,(%%2'"')-"'-,+/"-(%(%"3,+/""'-!

(&&.'"-27.+"' +'-!",-(+24-!"+/%.-"(',!/%&(,-%02,&--!)+,+"-"&

+&,7'-%24!(0/+4-!"+)+(+&'-+"(+-,.,-'-"%%27,'-"")-"'-!

%,-*.+-+%2+)(+-4-!/%.-(+0(+$(+0,.'%"$%2,.""'--(&--!'(+-"&%2

/%.-"(',7
'&+JNS(#"%<,/%.-"(',1-!IO<2-"&+&'"'

'.+2KKS",(7

,0",.,,1-',"/%2%-+"'-!",+)(+->,%"% !"
" #'!,)('"!&.

)7II?-!",+'-"%.+,&,-(+%--!('%.'(,/+%-(+,7(&"'/(%/

"%.+-(/%()'*.-0(+$(+4',(&"'/(%/-$"' ))+()+"-,-),>0!"!

++",(&,!(+-<-+&(',*.',?-("&)+(/-!0(+$(+7!)+-&'-!,&

!' ,-(-!%+,!")((.+-+/",>-!.'"-+,)(',"%(+/%.-"(',?'4%-!(. !



#&"(#$ '(&#!$ " "&$#&(
")&-B@B@$2AG"$2BF/')!((&)&-G/

B@B@2*&+((!'#&
)"8
) B@AI& (&'#" $$&#,!(#"#(*&+((!'0

,('!$ '.'+&"#()'(# ) ($&'*&2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 9 of 41
 HG

%-%24-$',(&," '""'-,-),-("&)+(/-!0(+$(+7,-"%"'%-+,-"(',4

0"+&&'2(-!,,-),4'.+ -!)+-&'--()+"(+"-"3/%()"' ,-+(' 

0(+$(+(/%.-(+,7

	",-(+"%%24-!)+-&'-!,)+(+&0%%0"-!+,)--((&)-')('"!-"&

+&,4.--!",*.+-+0"-',,('%.'(%(' <-+&/%()&'-,-!-%-(

,.,-'-"%%2,''('(&)%"'7('-+".-"' -(+,"'%.++(+,"')%''"' '

0(+$(+/%()&'-4.-%,(,(&(/+.0(+$(+"&)+(/&'-,7"+&,-),-!

)+-&'-!,-$'-("&)+(/-!0(+$(+4.-%,(.+ -!&-(/(--!+,(.+,

',,+2-(/%(),-+(' +((+',"/%.-(+,7	(0/+4*%(%!'

#%' !''""!'!(%&&)"%'&'"%%('!*(1' !"!'%')('"%&'"

 '(%%!'!('(%)('"!!&7

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 10 of 41
 HH


)



!)+-&'-!,(',",-'-%2"%-()+(/")+(&)-%&'"%'"!,+/",7
'-!&('-!,

(+-!+" ,2,-&%.'!4''-,"'#"%0!(0+&"--(+"')-"'-

+,-(+-"('-+-&'--	
(+
0"-4('/+ 4NH2,7	

(.+,4-!"," .+

"'%.%%''-,+++(++,-(+-"('40"-!(.-",-"'-"('-0'-!(,0"-!&(+4

/+,.,%,,4.-',7"'-!'4!(0/+4-!)+-&'-%.'!('.'H4IGHP-!

(','-<+<&'--+" ,2,-&4
," '-()+"(+"-"3-!''-,0"-!-!&(,-

.-%"'"%',>9"+H:?(/+-!(,0"-!%,,.-%"'"%',>9"+I:?7"+H

''-,&.,-+"/,+/",0"-!"'N2,(-!(&)-'2!+"' 40!+,"+I

''-,''(-+"/,+/",(+KP<LM2,>LM2,-!+(. !&+IGHP4'KP

2, "''"' '.+2IGIG?7

/+%%4+'-	&('-!%2+)(+-,,+"1%%'-!+'-(-!N<2%"'(+

''-,0!(&-!(.+-!,," '-,"+H>"774/+ 0"--"&,0%%.'+N2,?7



	(0/+40"--"&,(+"+I''-,,-"%%+1-!-"&+&,)+,+""'-!

(','-+>"774/+ 0"--"&,1"' PN2,-!",*.+-+40%%2('-!

+*."+KP<LM2,?7



$ "! """!" "
 $!



)8
(

B@AI

#*

B@AI



B@AI


"

B@B@


")&-B@B@

%)&!"(


) -B@B@

%)&!"(



&A B2GD< B2E B2H B2C G-' G-'



&B IA2B<< HF2G<< AAG2C<< HE2G<< DI-' DB-'

@T			
	
		

	
	
	
	
	

%	
	
		

	
	
	
	
	

	(0/+4,"')+"(++)(+-,4!(-!,,.&&+2,--",-",+*."+,%+""-"('7"+,-4-!

" .+,(+"+H''-,+%-('%2"+H''-,,"'"'-!(','-+5

-!-",4!!'&*" '"(%'&&!'&%5!"%%'"'"&#'7



*&+("$&##*!&B@AH8$& B@AI/' ) (&#!($&#*-(

$&(!"(:'$2G#(&#"( -&$#&( -G/B@AI;2



#"'"(&$&&$DC2



#&"(#$ '(&#!$ " "&$#&(
")&-B@B@$2AA:')!((&)&-G/B@B@;2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 11 of 41
 HI

(-4-!)+-&'-+)(+-,-!--(-%(HIO"'"/".%,!/'()"',"+H2

(.+-+/",/%.-(+,'&"---(	
/"-!(','-++"-+"7-!,4HIM

0+&"--0"-!"'-!N<2&1"&.&-"&+&7
'&'2+,)-,4-!",,.&&+2(,

0%%(+-!-+" ,2,-&7(+"' -(	&"'",-+-(+,'-&' &'-)+,(''%4

-!/,-&#(+"-2(''-,0!(&/%.-(+,," '-,"+H+&"---(-!!(,)"-%

)+(&)-%2>"7740%%0"-!"',/'2,?4'(-'/'(+-!(.+-," '-,-!&,"+

H'(++,&",,"('7(+-!(,-!-!/'(-4	!,(+0!-))+-()%.,"%

1)%'-"(',7

%) ((*&*+#&A1

""(  "" )""(&'-'(!+'"')&"* )(#&'#) 

&  -"(-($$&#$&(""(''5&A26#&,!$ / "(#

"(-)( - ""(''&A+#)  *'#!#(!#'( ""('

(&#&("" /)(#*&8"(-"""(''&A!(&%)&!#&

)&"(!''#"'(""''&-/(&- )(")&"('&*'&#!(#'+#

"(!!#'(2	"&*+"&A!''#"'#*&&"(!#"('/#'$( '(

("(##"&!((('&/"/""('+#+&&"()&"(

#'$( .(#"2((&"( -/* )(#&'&"#(#*&8"(-"""('

'&A0(#'+#&*)&"(#'$( .(#""(2


#)&'/#'$( '(+#) "#("$#'(#"(#&#".(""-(#

# 8"(-""(''&A2''"&#'+#) '("(-

(#&"')$$#&(!:;/+#'('+(!#"(#&"&B""('

'(-+(" 2)'&/('"#("(((!"-&B""('

&"&''&%)&"#'$( .(#"2-# #+$&#)&'(#(&"'(#"(!

"(#	+"""('#$$&(#+&&"()&"(!''#"2)'/

$& !"&-&*+&#''(&'('*& !#"('#(&"'-'(!'

#'')'(((($&#'''"& -"(&""#!$("(""('

"(#($$&#$&( * #&2
#)&'/#"#"&*+"!#"(#&"

:$&() & -"#&! (&#!(;+ &) (#!#& #"8

(&!"&#&#)'&*+#((&'"(#"'2



 +"' "+I''-,4)+( +,,!,'%"&"-7/+ 0"--"&,,-"%%+1-!

-"&%"&"-,"'-!(','-+4#.,-,-!2"(+%%''-,"')+"(+&('-!,7"+I

''-,!/0"-PN7N2,('/+ -0'(/&+IGHP''.+2IGIG40!'

-!&1"&.&-"&+&(+-!--"&)+"(0,KP<LM2,7!.,4-!"+H" .+,,. ,-

-!--!+" 2,-&,+/,-!).+)(,(+0!"!"-0,," '6)+"(+"-"3"' -!&(,-

.-%2"%%''-,'&(/"' -!&"'-(-!!(,)"-%+)"%27	(0/+4-!"+I" .+,

+/%-!-	('-"'.,-(,-+. %0"-!,(&(-!)+"&+2!%%' ,-!-)+(&)--!

*&+((!'#&&B""('& (&'#" $$&#,!(#"#(*&+((!'0

,('!$ '.'+&"#()'(# ) ($&'*&2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 12 of 41
 HJ

(','-+6+,)('"' -(-!/(%.&(''-,+++(+"')-"'-+,-(+-"('4'

&"--"' -!&"'-(-!!(,)"-%0"-!"'+,('%-"&+&7

/+%%4"+H&",,"(',(.+('-"&40!"%"+I&",,"(',,-"%%+1&1"&.&

&",,"('-"&+&,7 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 13 of 41
 HK


6	





2('-!0"--"&,(++,-(+-"(',+/",>')+( +,,-(0+,-!-"&+&

+*."+&'-,(-!(','-+?4'(-!+$2&-+"(+ . "' -!)+-&'-8,)+( +,,

",-!*'!&'(+(&)-'+,-(+-"(',+/",7!-",4-!(','-+",," '

-(+.0"--"&,4.-%,(+.-!'.&+(''-,0"-"' 7
'-!&('-!,

)+"' %.'!(-!+" ,2,-&4-!0"-%",-/+ +(.'HLG-(HOG''-,7


.- "'40"-!-!"'"-"-"('(-!+" ,2,-&('.'H40&.,-(',"+-!0"-%",-

(+"' -("+,--.,7'-+%-(-!+" ,2,-&",'$'(0% &'--!-,(&

"'(&)-'-''-,+,(.-%2"%%-!--!2+*."+-+-&'-%&(,-"&&"-%2>"+

H40!(+*."+-+-&'-0"-!"'N2,?40!+,(-!+,',%20"--+-&'->"+I40!(

'0"-,/+%0$,?7




# "!"!" ""!" "

 

 &B@AI 
(B@AI #*B@AI B@AI 
"B@B@

#!" AEG

&A 7C A A A

&B 7AEB ADA ABB AAB

/+-!),-*.+-+4'#%' !'  !!(#%"%&&!%(!'*'&'7

"-%",-" .+,+1HLG"'-!.&&+(IGHP4'-!2+,%(0HLG.+"' 

-!%%(IGHP7%-!(. !-!'.&+("'"/".%,('-!0"-%",-+&"',!" !"',(%.-

-+&,>HHI"''.+2?4-!"," .+!,+,,-"%2(/+-!),-,/+%&('-!,'

+!"-,%(0,-)("'-"'-!),-2+7!+,''(-1)%"'2+,

+++%,(+/%.-"('(++,-(+-"('5-!,/+2,.,-'-"%%2&('-!<-(<&('-!7-!+4-!

+,))+,"+-%2--+".-%-()+-&'-"'-+/'-"(',7!&(,-)(-'-(-!,

"'-+/'-"(',0,-!()'"' (JP'0"')-"'-,>+,.%-"' "''-"'+,(KI,?

-!-(&)+",'0"')-"'-(&)-'+,-(+-"('.'"--	
70&('-!,+%"+4-!

)+-&'-%,(()',('
>#"%<,4"')-"'-<%"$(&)-'+,-(+-"('

,+/",?(&)+","' HO,)"%%2," '-,"'-!(.%+#"%7%-!(. !%%)+-",+

0+-!--!)+-&'-''(-9."%-!"+02(.-:(-!(&)-'0"-%",-'0"-




($&'"(/($&(!"($&#*'+( '((' -)&'/'#(!#"( -)&'"(( 

& (*& -)&'2

 #&"(#($&(!"(4'$ '(&#!$ " "&$#&(
")&-B@B@$2AA:')!((

&)&-G/B@B@;2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 14 of 41
 HL

-"&,4/%()"' "-"('%)"-2(+"')-"'-+,-(+-"('",',,"-2"',2,-&0"-!,(

&'2.-%2"%%"'(&)-'-''-,7

/+%%4-!+!,'&'"' .%+,"'-!'.&+("'"/".%,('-!0"-%",-(+

+,-(+-"(',+/",(/+-!),-*.+-+7!",+,",'(-,"&)%2.-(+,"'

+++%,7-!+4-!+,))+, '."'%2--+".-%-()+-&'-"'-+/'-"(',6

()'"' '0"')-"'-+,-(+-"('.'"-4()'"' '0#"%<,+,-(+-"('.'"-4"'+,"' 

"('#'!'(&)-'+,-(+-"(',+/",4'(-!+(+-,7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 15 of 41
 HM



 














'*3/99/545,"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9,5846':/+4:536+:+4)?<'2;':/549'4*#+9:58':/54

%8+':3+4:%.++6'8:3+4:9.'22!,,+8*3/99/54:5"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9:5:.+596/:'2,5846':/+4:

#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:5846':/+4:536+:+4)?<'2;':/5496;89;'4::5:.+'::').+*:'(2+%'(2+


5362/'4)+=/:.:./93+'9;8+9.'22(+)'2);2':+*('9+*54:.+4;3(+85,'?9&'/:/4-,58+').

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++

!(','-+)+,+",-!(%%(0"' -"&+&,(+&"--"' ''-,-("')-"'-

(&)-'+,-(+-"(''(+)+(+&"' (&)-'/%.-"(',>0!-!+"')-"'-(+"'

#"%?7&",,"('-"&+&,(&)+( +,,"/%2,!(+-+-!,"1<&('-!"'+&'-7

/%.-"('-"&+&,++."'.%2IGIG7





 "'

&A1,!)!

!(#
&

!''#"#&

	"$("(

'(#&(#"

&B1,!)!

!(#
&

!''#"#&

	"$("(

'(#&(#"

,!)!!(#


&!''#"

#&	"$("(

#!$("-

* )(#"'

,!)!(!(#

#!$ (
 

#!$("-

* )(#"'


)"A/B@AI G-' EF-' BA-' BH-'


")&-A/B@B@ G-' DI-' BA-' BH-'


) -A/B@B@ G-' DB-' AD-' BA-'


")&-A/B@BA G-' CE-' AD-' BA-'


) -A/B@BA G-' BH-' AD-' BA-'

,,.&&+"3+%"+"'-!",+)(+->92-+",:?4'#%' !' '&'' % "%

 ''!%5!!'&'"%&'"%'"!!"%)('!!!'&!!#'!'&''!&0

('',%+'' % &"%%6 &&"!&'"" #'!,%&'"%'"!.!"%'

%&'' !&)%,%&',+'' % &"%" #'!,)('"!&0







5&(& ("6!"'$&'#"+#'" "()'(#-##)"(-
 "+#!#)&(

'#&&(#)"&##!$("-&*'2&'#"''&*"'"(""($&(!"(#

#&&(#"'")*" '&, )&#!('#"'"(&2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 16 of 41
 HN

& %"$
!#&!&('&"!

,-"%%(04-!)+-&'-!,'*."-,.,,.%"'-"&%2&",,"('(+"')-"'-

(&)-')('"!&>/+,.,+,-(+-"('?6



""! ""$#"



#"( )!&!(((#

	#&"$("(

* )(#"

*&-'+(

$&#&(#!''#"(#

	#&	



#$ +#+(!#&

("BH-'


"B@B@ H AB2@ @

B@AI H AC2I @

#*B@AI E AB2B @

)8
(B@AI*&



E2C AG2A< C

&B@AI(#(  AH AF2D A

@T			
	
		
	
	


		
	
	

/+-!),--!+&('-!,4'/+ (M7J)()%)+&('-!0+&"--(+'"')-"'-

/%.-"('-	
>(&)+-(L7J/+ (+-!)+/"(.,*.+-+4'-(HK7N/+ 

(+-!.%2<)-&+IGHP*.+-+?7!/+ 0"--"&(+&",,"('-(	
(+

"')-"'-(&)-'2/%.-"('0,HJ7I2,>(.-K2,,!(+-+-!'-!/+ (+-!

)+/"(.,*.+-+?7!",",'"&)+(/&'-(/+)+/"(.,0"--"&,4/'-!(. !-!'.&+(

"')-"'-/%.-"(',!,,%" !-%2"'+,7/+%%40/"0-!",,)(,"-"//%()&'-7
'

,!(+-40+)()%+"' +++-(	
(+"')-"'-(&)-'2/%.-"(',-!'

0+,'-)+"(+-(-!(','-+4'-!0"--"&,-(&",,"('+,.,-'-"%%2%(0+7

!)--+'!,',-"%2"&)+(/"' ,"'"&)%&'--"('(-!(','-+',&,

-(!/%+ %2)%-.7('(-1)-"')-"'-/%.-"(',-(+,-(3+(7


'/"-%240''-,+,(.-%2"%%-!-)+(&)-"')-"'-/%.-"('",',,+24'

#. ,&2(++"')-"'-/%.-"(',.-(,8,!" !)+("%(+(-!+-(+,7

/+-!%,,40+)%,-!-"')-"'-/%.-"(',+%,,(&&(''&(++)"7

"!#)"('&((# -'-#"#((!&!' '(2#+*&/('"'&

')'' '+&"('&$#&(2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 17 of 41
 HO

.+-!+&(+4(+"' -(	+)(+-,4(+-!"+,--"&,"'-!"&)%&'--"('(-!

(','-+4&#(+"-2(-!(,''-,(++(+"')-"'-/%.-"('-.%%2&-

-!,-+"-+"-+"(+"'/(%.'-+2!(,)"-%"3-"('>777AIN<ML<HGL?7)""%%24	

+)(+--!-.+"' -!),-J&('-!,4NH7KS(&",,"(',(+"')-"'-/%.-"('&--!-

,-+"-9IN<ML:+"-+"(+"'/(%.'-+2!(,)"-%"3-"('7!",('-+,-,0"-!+%"++-,,%(0,

HMS!",-(+"%%24'+(.'LGS.+"' -!&(,-+'-*.+-+7
'4+-,!/,-"%2

"'+,,"''.+2IGHP7"'4-!",",)(,"-"/-+'+%-"' &(+))+()+"-.,(

!(,)"-%"3-"('60+''-,+,'-(+"')-"'-/%.-"('4'(-!-,&%%+ +(.)4

&(+&-"')-"'-&",,"('+"-+"7!-",4-!(,(++-(-!!(,)"-%0+&(+%"$%2

-(-!(,0!(&-+"-+"(+!(,)"-%"3-"('' '."'%2+*."+-!",&(+"'-',"/

,+/"7

" !'"!"*%!!'&%%%"%!#'!')('"!.&"%'%*'' &"%

 &&"!.! "%##%"#%'%%%&200.'"& '!!)"(!'%,"&#'-'"!%'%3

%'&&(&'!'#%"%&&"%'#%' !'.!'%!'%'"!*''""%""(%'&7







222=BG8FE8A@E1:A; !&"-$&#)&!-"*#)"&(&#"#(# #+"(+#

#"(#"'1

:;:	; ""-$&'#"$$&'(#*!"(  ('#&&"/'&') (#')!"(  (

'#&&/$$&'(#"!!""("&(##(&'#&(#!' #&&' #&$$&'(#&* -

' /("""(&*""$&#''#" /''$"')'(#":A;:;:		;#(''(#"/)$#"

$&# )'"+(')'''("'!-&%)&/!-(($&'#""(#)'(#-/#&)'

($&'#"(#(""(#)'(#-/"$ " (-'"(#&$$&#*-(,)(*

&(#&#&'*"(-8(+#8#)&(&(!"("* )(#"3

:; $#""*('+#&"(##&&!#&)((& ('')"(('(#'( '((

$&'#"$$&'(#*!"(  ('#&&"/'&') (#(!"(  ('#&&/$$&'

(#"!!""("&(##(&'#&(#!' #&&' #&$$&'(#&* -' /(#)&(

!-#&&($&'#"'&"(*((#(""(#)'(#-"$ " (-

'"(#&$$&#*-(,)(*&(#&#&'*"(-8(+#8#)&(&(!"("* )(#"2 

&#!(&)&-G/B@B@#"( -#!$ " "$#&(:$2B@;2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 18 of 41
 HP

& %"$
!#&!&%&"$&"!

(&)+-(-!-"&%2"')-"'-/%.-"(',4-!+++&(+('+',+ +"' "')-"'-

%&'"%'"!-	
7/+-!),-02+,40"--"&,(',",-'-%21-!JG<2-"&

+&,&'-2'+%"+--%&'-+&'-7	(0/+4-!+*."+-"&+&,

!' ,(.'H4IGHP4)+-!(','-+7!&1"&.&-"&+&(+&'2

''-,>-!(,%%,"+I?0"-"' "'#"%,0,1-'-(LM2,7.-,('.+2H4

IGIG4-!(','-++.-!",&1"&.&-"&+&-(KP2,7!-"&+&(+

''-,0"-!-!&(,-.+ '-%"'"%',>-!(,%%"+H?",'(0('%2N2,7



""! ""!" "

#"( )!&#$#$ 

!(((#	#&

"$("(&'(#&(#"

*&-'+(

#&!''#"(#

	"$("(

&'(#&(#"

#$ +#+(!#&

("(!,-'#&

!''#"(#	

"$("(&'(#&(#"



&A&B &A&B &A&B


"B@ AHFA B2CHE2G @<

AI AFFC B2HAAG2C @<

#*AI AFDF B2EHF2G @<

&*#)')&(&

#"( -*&

:)8
(AI;

AI2GED2G B2GEIC2B A<

&AI

:#&(&

'("(#"';

DD EH2B CA

*
!" $" "'  ""#  +$#!%%" "

"&#%'! !!"	  !" ")$ #!""!")

,-!-%+/%,4&(,-(-!''-,'(0," '-,"+I0"-&.!%(' +-!'-!

+*."+KP<LM2,(+&",,"('7(+1&)%4"''.+24-(-%(MH"+I"'"/".%,

0+&"---(	
'-!"+0"-"' -"&(+&",,"('/+ OL7N2,7	(0/+4-!

&.!,&%%+ +(.)()-"'-,," '-,"+H0+&"--+)"%24(',",-'-0"-!-!

&'-,(-!(','-+7
''.+24-(-%(HO"+H"'"/".%,0+&"---(

	
40"-!-!"+0"-)+"(+-(&",,"('/+ "' I7J2,7(-4-(-%(HIM"'"/".%,

," '-,"+H!/'&"--0"-!"'N2,("' #."-,
7


Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 19 of 41
 IG

,'(-"'(.+%,-*.+-+%2+)(+-4-!)+-&'-8,+)"+,)(',-(-!(,"'-"","+

H",+&+$%'(&&'%7
'&'202,4-!"+H"'"/".%,+-!!" !,-)+"(+"-2

(+-!(','-+'-!	(&)-'2,2,-&7!(,0!(&	- (+"3,

"+H=.,.%%2-!(,0!(&(,-'.+ '--+-&'-=0+"'&"--+)"%27

'-!(-!+!'4-!)+( +,,-(0+,&-"' "+I-"&%"',+&"',)+(%&-"7"+I

"'"/".%,+&'--(	
4.-0"-!%,,.+ '27	
!,('-"'.-('"&%2

+-,)(+"+H"'"/".%,4"'/"-%22)+"(+"-"3"' -!&(/+"+I"'"/".%,7

	(0/+4"+I"'"/".%,&.,-%,(&"--0"-!"'+-"'-"&+&,7!('%2()-"(',

(++."' -!"+0"--"&,",-("/+-''-,02+(&-!(&)-'2)+(,,

%-( -!+>-!+(. !+%2"/+,"('(+-,2)(%"'(.+-,?4+-,)(+-!&"'	


>2+."' +,-(+-"('%' -!,(,-2(++-"' '0,?4(+-+',+-!&-((&&.'"-2<

,+,-(+-"('-+-&'->"-!2+))+()+"-(+(&&.'"-2-+-&'-?7!

)+-&'-!,&)+( +,,"',(&(-!,+,4.-0"%%'-()+"(+"-"3"-"('%

,-),-!-+-,)(+"+I''-,7
',!(+-40!"%"+H"'"/".%,&.,-

)+"(+"-"3(+&",,"('>-!+2-+-"' -!(,0!('"-&(,-?4,.,,.%(&)%"'0"-!

-!(','-+&.,-&"+."+I-"&+&,5,.!(&)%"'0"%%&(',-+--!-

-!	(&)-'2,2,-&!,+-*.-)"-2(+%%%/%,((&)-'2<

+,-(+-"('',7


*"%'&/

	
!,"'"-"-9,-+$:)+(#--(%+--!,!.%"' (,(&

(&)-'2+,-(+-"('/%.-"(',7%-!(. !''-,+-2)"%%2/%.--PG<

2"'-+/%,4''-,('(-'-.+%%2 "'-!)"-",',,+2(+(&)-'

--"2PG<2"'-+/%,5&'2&2(&)-'-0%%(+>(+,!(+-%2-+?-!,

(.+-<,--,7!'''-,+"'-""(+-!)+( +&4,(&+,-"%"3"' +

"'/'(-!"+)+/"(.,%2<,!.%)(,-<+,-(+-"('(&)-'2/%.-"('7
'

-!,,,4/%.-(+,+'(-""-(('.--!/%.-"(',(('4,(-!-"-!

/%.-(++'+,'()"'"('-!--!''-!,'+,-(+4-!,'

+-.+'-((.+-"'/'(-!"+)+/"(.,%2,!.%!+"' >,(&-"&,0$,-(

&('-!,"'-!.-.+?'-.+'(/+'(.+7(-4JI''-,!/'

()"',(&)-'-,(('+-!'-!"+,!.%PG<2/%.-"('-4+-.+'"' 

-!&-(#"%,(('+>-(0"--!"+!+"' ,?'-!.,,(('+()'"' -!"+!(,)"-%,

(+(-!++,-(+-"(')-"'-,7!",-2)()+-"%"'-+/'-"('!,(&(&&('"'

,(&(-!+,--,4'",,"&)%,-+- 2-(+..'',,+2%' -!(,-27

#&"(#($&(!"(4'$ '(&#!$ " "&$#&(
")&-B@B@$2I8AA:')!((

&)&-G/B@B@;2


 #!&A"*) '!(((#	&"#(& ("(( )(#(!"#!''#"'

:$&!& -$&'#"'!(("& -&)&-;2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 20 of 41
 IH






("+8,583'4)+5,'/2536+:+4)?<'2;':/549%.++6'8:3+4:9.'22)5362+:+'22'/2

536+:+4)?<'2;':/5495,'"8+:8/'2+:'/4++6;89;'4::5:.+'::').+*:'(2+%'(2+
',:+8:.+

+6'8:3+4:D98+)+/6:5,'5;8:!8*+8*/8+):/4-:.++<'2;':/54'4*8+)+/6:5,522':+8'2':+8/'29

%./9:/3+,8'3+8+7;/8+3+4:9.'22'662?:5:.+,5225=/4-)5;4:/+9*'392'359'8'6'.5+

5;2*+88553,/+2*85=2+?;9:+8+4<+85;-2'92"'952(+8:8+354:;+8,'45

+,,+8954'8/3+8+9'!:+85";+(25%+22+8'4*&+2*5;4:/+945:96+)/,/)'22?/*+4:/,/+*'8+

)5;4:/+9:.':;9+:.+B52*'4*&'/:C)5;8:58*+8+*685)+995;4:/+9;:/2/@/4-:.+52*'4*&'/:

<'2;':/54685)+99=/22(+5,,+8+*'3++:/4-*':+=/:./4	*'?95,:.++6'8:3+4:D98+)+/6:5,:.+

5;8:!8*+8'4*522':+8'2':+8/'29'4*:.++<'2;':/54=/22(+)5362+:+*=/:./4	*'?95,:.+

3++:/4-+-/44/4-'4;'8?
		)5;4:/+9;:/2/@/4-:.+52*'4*&'/:<'2;':/54685)+99=/22(+

5,,+8+*'3++:/4-*':+=/:./4	*'?95,:.++6'8:3+4:D98+)+/6:5,:.+5;8:!8*+8'4*522':+8'2

':+8/'29'4*:.++<'2;':/54=/22(+)5362+:+*=/:./4

*'?95,:.+3++:/4-

!&'--"&%"&"-(+#"%<,/%.-"('",'(0IO2,4)+-!(','-+4'

0"%%+,-(IH2,"'.'(IGIG7,&'-"('+%"+"'-!",*.+-+%2+)(+->,,

'%&/" #'!)('"! % &4)7P?-!)+-&'-!,!",-(+"%%2&--!",

-"&+&('(',",-'-,",4.).'-"%+(.'-!"+(/&+IGHP+)(+-7

	(0/+4+(.'(/&+IGHP"-0,(&"' %+-!--!)+-&'-8,0(+$(+(

/%.-(+,0,'(-,.""'--(&--!/(%.&(+++%,"').'-.%&''+7
'

&+JNS(#"%<,/%.-"(',1-!IO<2-"&+&'"''.+2KKS

1-!-"&+&7!.,4-!",*.+-++%--+&'(.,,-$"'(&"'-!-!

'!",-(+"%,-+' -!(+-!)+-&'-7

"!'%('!'"%&/


'(.+/"04-!","%.++,.%-+(&('%.'(,/+%-(+,7"+,-4%+,!")"'(.+-

+/",!))+'-%2'(-.%%2'-"")-0(+$(+',(+)+)+(+,(&(+,%

!' ,"',-"' >7 74&-+'"-2%/4/%.-(+)+-.+?7,,-0'-%%4++."-&'-4

!"+"' 4'+-'-"('(+-,0+'(-)+-".%+%2/" (+(.,4'-!+0+&'2'(-,(

)(-'-"%/%.-(+,",,.2%2,(+",(+ '"3-"('7/%.-"(',+/",!/'

,)++(,,(.+-+/",>.'"-(.%%<-"&/%.-(+,&)%(22-!)+-&'-?'

('-+-/%.-(+,4.-%+,!")!/%()'"-!+0(+$(+-(-!1-'-',,+24

)+-".%+%2"'%" !-('.)(&"' +,"'/%.-"('-"&+&,"'.'(IGIG7

.+-!+&(+4,-"%"')+"(++)(+-,4&(+%0,%(0&(' (.+-+/",/%.-(+,4"'

)+-.,(!(0%+,!")!!'%!' ,)+(&)-2-!(','-+7!(. !

-!",%(0&(+%"'(-(&-!0(+$(+,!(+- 4,/+%'(-,,. ,-"-&2!/

!&)+++."-&'-('0/%.-(+,7"'%%24(/&+>.-(!(%"2,'&'-(+2

-+"'"' ?'&+>.-(!(%"2,?+*."++.-"('"'/%.-(+*.(-,7(.+,4

'"-!+,!(.%#()+"3).'-.%"-2&(' '*.-0(+$(+>!(%"2,'-+"'"' ,+

'(-.'(+,%?4.--!,+(.-"'+,,"'0(+$2,+/%-!"',.""'2(-!

0(+$(+7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 21 of 41
 II

%,(&)!,"34!(0/+4-!-&" (-!-(+,('-+".-"' -(-!,+'-%2,+4"'

-4*."-)(,"-"/7!-",4,(&-(+,+%-%(' <(/+."&)+(/&'-,-((.+-+/",7

,)+"&+21&)%4-!)+-&'-!%(' (/+<+%"(',"' %('-+-/%.-(+

>0!(%,(!%," '""'-%"'"%)(,"-"('-	
?-()+(+& +(,,%2",)+()(+-"('-

,!+(/%.-"(',>&'2(3',?)+&('-!4(+"-"('%"'(&2('!",)+"&+2.-",7

!",++' &'-0,)+(%&-""'%&(,-/+2+,)-=+)(+-*.%"-20,)((+4(,-,0+

1,,"/4+)(+-*.'-"-20,"&)(,,"%2!" !4'(&)%"'-,+(&-!+0+(&&('=

+#'-!--!++' &'-!%)-!)+-&'-&-/%.-"('-"&%"',7(.+-+/",

%+,!")--!-"&,&.'0+(-!1-'-(-!",(/+<+%"'(+-!,/++",$,"-

)(,7,!+(.+ +/('+',(.--!",++' &'-'-!)+-&'-.%-"&-%2

+,-!"+(/+<+%"'('-!",)+(%""/%.-(+7"+&-!","".%-,-)2-!

)+-&'-4'.'+,-'"-++"," '""'-,!(+-<-+&(,->"774&$"' "-!++-(&-

/%.-"('-"&+&,"'-!(%%(0"' &('-!(+-0(?7.--!"+","('-(,+"",!(+-<

-+&4%(0<*.%"-2(&)%"',-+- 2-("',-"'/,-"'%(' +<-+&4!" !<*.%"-2(&)%"'

,-+- 2",1-%2-!-2)(!' -!-&$,.,&(+()-"&",-"(.--!)+-&'-8,

)+(,)-,(+/%()"' ,-+(' (&)-'2,2,-&'(&)%2"' 0"-!-!(','-+"'

-!%(' <-+&7

	!'%)!'"!&/

(-!"++"-4-!)+-&'-!,+'-%2-$',-),-(+,,-!0(+$(+,!(+- -!-

('-+".--(-!,/%.-"('%2,7!2&,.,-'-"%!' ,"'-!%+,!")(

(.+-+/",4'!/+<"'/" (+-'/%.-(+-+"'"' '(/+," !-)+(,,-!-&$,

.,(% "-"&-1)+-",0"-!"'(.+-+/",7!)+-&'-!,).+,.,%+2"'+,,

(+/%.-(+,').+,.(-!++,(.+,-(,.))(+--+"'"' 7
''.+24-!)+-&'-

!"+-!+'0/%.-(+,4''%",--!+'0('-+-/%.-(+,7(,-+'-+)(+-,

"'"--!--(-%(,"1"-"('%('-+-(+,,!(.%('.-"' (&)-'2/%.-"(',

 "''"' "'+!IGIG7%-!(. !-!2!/'(-'%-(+.%%(-!.+.+-"

++"+,'%2,-(!"+"' >,(&))+(&&('+(,,-!)+-&'-(+/'+(,,,--

 (/+'&'-?4-!2!/))+-(+.,(&(-! + "(.,%2,')((+

(&&.'"-"('-!-.'+&"')+"(+(+-,-(++."-'!"+7

#"(")(#"#)&($&(!"((#"(!)'(&#"&#*&'("')$&*'#"#('

 ""#'#"(")(#$&#&!"-* )(#"'2'(  '+&/)(#""#*&'(

& '#!$&#*""#)&(&*'2

		"/($&(!"(4''#"(#&)( #+8%) (-/8%)"((-* )(#"'&#!$&# 

* )(#&& (',( -("# #"8(&!$$&#+"#)&+"+&*+(&#&" 

$ "" (B@AH2(&("$&#&(." #+8%) (-'(&(-#&'(-#!$ "((&''

,&("$&# !'/($&(!"(''&'#!&##!$ ""('#&(8(&!(#

$&#&(.((&8%) (-'&*'((&&!#&#")*(# #"8(&!#!$ "+((#"'"(

&"+('($&('2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 22 of 41
 IJ

!.,4-!+'-"%.+-(&-/%.-"('-"&+&,+%-,-%,--0(+(-!&,7!

"+,-",.'&" .(.,%2' -"/6(&"'-"('()((+0(+$(+/%()&'-'"%.+-(

'-"")-(+,%',7
'(.+/"04-!",+%-,"%.+4.--!)+-&'-!,

!' %+,!")"'(.+-+/",',&,&.!&(++,)(',"/-(-!,%+','

!%%' ,7!,('('-+".-"' -!&",.'&" .(.,%2)(,"-"/7
&)+(/"' -!/%.-(+

0(+$(+++",(&,!(+-<-+&(,-,0"-!+,)--(-"&%2/%.-"(',7!"%"-0(.%!/

'"%-('--!,"&)+(/&'-,%('  (40(',"+-!,"&)+(/&'-,9--+%-

-!''/+:'0!/'(+"-"",&(+0!-/+)(+-"('(-!%2,0,)+(&)-2

+."' )((+<*.%"-2/%.-"(','"&)+(/"' -!/%.-(+0(+$(+7

(%+4-!%2,+'(-+,(%/''#%' !' (&' ")%&&),'""!'!(

)"#!!$('*"%"%")('"%&7!+'-"&)+(/&'-,"',%+",4"''-"/

)2(+"-"('%/%.-"(',4('-+-(+)24'++."-&'-(+-,,!(.%('-"'.4,

,!(.%-!+'-"&)+(/&'-,"'%+,!")4-+"'"' 4'(/+," !-7!(. !",))("'-

-!-,(&(-!,"'-+/'-"(',0+%(' (/+.40"+&-!,+'-"&)+(/&'-,'

.+ -!)+-&'--(('-"'.,"&"%+"'-+/'-"(',70"%%+&"',.))(+-"/(('-"'.

 +,,"/(+-,-("''-"/"3('-+-'.%%<-"&0%%<*.%""/%.-(+,,-!'1-

,-,-)(++,,"' .++'-0(+$(+ ),4'00"%%/" "%'-%2&('"-(+-!-"/',,

(-!,))+(!,7

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 23 of 41
 IK





	
	


4:+8/3'/2+4:'2+'2:.%8+':3+4:,:.+)5;8:*5+945:8+2+'9+:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++:5

533;4/:?'9+*#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:'4*:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++/9'='/:/4-8+)+/6:5,46':/+4:

#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4::.++6'8:3+4:9.'22=581=/:.:.+5;4:?'/29:5*+<+256'685-8'3:5

'99/9:/4:.+685</9/545,)558*/4':+*9+8</)+9,58/4*/</*;'29/4'))58*'4)+=/:.#$AA	


	:59)8++4:8+':'99+99'4*354/:58,58:8/'-+6;8659+9"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9/4:.+2+'9:

8+9:8/):/<+9+::/4-6599/(2+%./96'8'-8'6.*5+945::522585:.+8=/9+35*/,?:.++6'8:3+4:D9

5(2/-':/54:5!,,+8*3/99/54:5:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9,5846':/+4:#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:4:+8/3

'/2+4:'2+'2:.%8+':3+4:9.'2245:8+62')+58(+;9+*'9'9;(9:/:;:+,5846':/+4:#+9:58':/54

%8+':3+4:(;:*5+945:68+)2;*+:.++6'8:3+4:,853685</*/4-#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:3+3(+8

5,:.+58+49/)$;6658:%+'39.'228+658::5:.+5;8:/'/954+<+8?
	*'?9)54)+84/4-:.+)2/4/)'2

9:':;9'4*685-8+99:5='8*9)536+:+4)?5,:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++

,0!/",.,,"')+"(++)(+-,4-!)+-&'-",+*."+-()+-'+0"-!(.'-2#"%,-(

/%())+( +&(((+"'-,+/",(+"'"/".%,+"/"' (&)-'2<+%-,+/",7

!,,+/",+.++'-%2&' ,--0"-!+(. !-!"%<,!/"(+%+/",

)+( +&>?'+.'))+(1"&-%2DI7L&"%%"(')+2+2-!+'-%2))+()+"-

2HP<IIJ7,,'-"%%24-!)+-&'-.-"%"3,,!.(+((+"'-"' ,.('-+-

,+/",+(,,(%(+(7!,,.('-+-)+(/"+,+'(0,$-()+(/"*.-

&'-%!%-!,+/",-("'&-,"'/(%/0"-!(&)-'2<+%-,+/",7
'-+"&&'-%

!%-!-+-&'-",+"-"%-(,+'4&('"-(+4,,,,4'-+--!(,+"/"' (&)-'2<

+%-,+/","'(.'-2#"%,,(-!--!2+&"')!2,"%%2,'%"'"%%2,-%.'-"%-!"+

-+',+-((&)-'2+,-(+-"(',+/",7

	(0/+4-!,-+.-.+(+-,,(&!%%' ,7.,-!<,.('-+-

)+(/"+,"++(,,(.'-",'#.+","-"(',4-!"+,+/","+7(&)+(/"+,!/

,-+(' (''-"(',0"-!%(%')+"/-"')-"'-!(,)"-%"3-"('"%"-",40!"%(-!+,!/

0$+-",7(+$(+'*.%""-"(',%,("+&(' )+(/"+,7!",)(,,,(&

!%%' ,(+-!)+-&'-50!"%"'"/".%"3,+/",+'!'2-!%(%'-.+(

-!)+(/"+,0"-!"'4.'"(+&"-2'%/+ +(,,)+(/"+,+&(+"".%-7

"'(.+%,-*.+-+%2+)(+-4&(,-(.'-",!/"-!+)--!",'!'.'"' (++

"'-!)+(,,().+,."' "-7	(0/+40.+''+.+%(.'-",!/+#--!

.'"' 7+"&+2+,(',(++#-"' .'"' 4(+"' -(,7!!'+7+-!0"'>	

"+-(+?4+-!--!.'"' (&,0"-!-((&'2+)(+-"' +*."+&'-,(+-!--!,!+",

%+2)+"/-!2!/*.-#"%&'-%!%-!+,(.+,"')%7,7!!'+7


5	"(&!
 "(  (&(!"(6!"'!"(  ((&(!"(#&(& ("(('

$&#&!"(#)"(-
 +&(&(& ("' + (&(& ("+('

#!!)"(-8'#&	"$("('(#&(#"&(!"($&#)&(
&&#"''("(+(((!&!'"

(#"'"(&2	('
$&#,-#&')'(()(#&#!$("-&'(#&(#"'&*'2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 24 of 41
 IL

+-!0"'!/('-"'.(.-+!(+-,-(-!0+&"'"' ,!+"8,(",40"-!,(&

)+( +,,"''(.+ "' ,(&+%.-'-,!+",-(,,-!1-+.'"' 7


'"-"('4	8,"((&&.'"-2+/",4"'('#.'-"('0"-!%+ &.%-"<&"%%"('(%%+

 +'-'"'(%%(+-"('0"-!-!'"/+,"-2((%(+(8,)+-&'-(&"%2""'4!,

 .'(+"' -!'"%,,",-''.-"('-(#"%,,--0"+ +"' -!",'!'

.'"' 7!",-!'"%,,",-'!,(.,(''.&+(+,4"'%."' "'-$,+'"' ,4

(+&.%+",4+&' &'-.+"' -+',"-"('$-(-!(&&.'"-24'"'-"2"' 

(&&.'"-2)+(/"+,(+-++7!/'(.+ -!","-()+"(+"-"3''(.+ 

,!+",-(.-"%"3-!'!'.'"' (+1)'"' ),2!"-+"&"-"('(+&.%+",

'-(,.+"-"('%),2!"-+2,+/",7,2!"-+",+/"",-!,-+(' ,-('-+".-(+-(

+%2(&)-'2+,-(+-"(''0(.%%"$%2)+(/"-!%+ ,-+-.+'('"'/,-&'-+(&-!

'!'.'"' 7

!"((&&.'"-2+/",'	&"'",-+-"('+%,().+,."' ,--0"-%<

!%-!,+/",7%<!%-!(.%!%).%"-"('(+(&)-'2/%.-"(','(' ("' 

,,,,&'-(+-+"%-"',50,.))(+-',,+-"/1)%(+-"('(-%<!%-!,-+- ",7

%-!(. !(.-+!(+-,('-"'.4"-&2-!-	!,+!-!&1"&.&'.&+(

,!+"8,)+-&'-,0"%%"' -(.-"%"3-!",'!'.'"' 7!",4((.+,4%,-(

*.,-"(',(.-!(0-"/&'-%!%-!,+/",0"%%(++-+"%-"',"'-!(,#"%,

-!-!/+#--!'!'.'"' 4'0!-%-+'-,-+- ",-!)+-&'-&2

).+,.7

	(0/+4/'0"-!"'-!#"%,-!-*.-"%"3-!",'!'.'"' 4," '""'-!%%' ,

+&"'7('-+-,0"-!(.'-2#"%,/+2 +-%2"')-!'+-!(,+/",7(+(/+4

	!,/+2%"--%%/+ (/+-!,,+/",,"+(&-!('-+-7.%"-2(,+/",4

+*.'2((&&.'"-"('4'"%"-2-(1)--"(',++-!+%((,%2,,.+0"-!(.-

,-+"' '-('-+-"' '*.%"-2&' &'-(/+," !-7'(+-.'-%24	!,0+,(.+,

-()+(/"-!",(/+," !-4,("'+%"-2-!-.%&'-%!%-!,+/",/"%%"'(.'-2#"%,

"("'*.-7	)+()(,-(/%()'9"'-+< '2 +&'-:2+!IGIG

0!"!0(.%%%(0(+&(+(/+," !-'&(+%1""%"-2"',+/"!' ,4+-!+-!'.-"%"3"' 

"'"/".%('-+-,7	(0/+40!/'(-+"/.)-,(.--!","'-+< '2 +&'-

'+'(-()-"&",-"-!-"-0"%%-"/"'+-"2"' -!(/!%%' ,7!+",#.,--((

&.!/+""%"-2+(,,#"%,(+	-(&('"-(+,+/",-"/%27

0()(-'-"%,(%.-"(',+.'+(',"+-"('7!"+,-"'/(%/,-(%%-"('7!/

'(.+ 	-(.,1",-"' -+(&(.'-2#"%,(.--!"+&'-%!%-!,+/"

)+(/","('7	!,,---!-))+(1"&-%2-'#"%,.,,!+-,2,-&7!"+-

(.%'%23-(-+&"'!(0+*.'-%2(&)-'2<"'/(%/"'"/".%,+-+-

/+,.,(-!+"'&-,0"-!&'-%!%-!',40!-&"-"(',+)+,+"40!-

)+( +&,(+,+/",+)+(/"4!(0(-'+",",,+/",++*."+4',(('7!",-2)(

'%2,",0(.%>(+-!(,-'#"%,?!%)	--+.'+,-'!(0.'"' ",.,'

0!-(.-(&,+"' +%"37,'#.'--(-!",-'%2,",4-!(+',"+/",

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 25 of 41
 IM

&/" -(+,+ "''"' -((%%--('-!"++-+"%-"',7%-!(. !-(.,,

)+"&+"%2('%"'"%,--.,')+( +,,-(+,-(+-"('>)+(','-++*."+&'-,?4,(&

"'(+&-"('' -!+-(+,,-!*.'-"-2'*.%"-2(,+/",&(' "+'-#"%,7

('%240+1)%(+"' -!)(,,""%"-2(.,"' .'"' +(&-!(','-+"',-(.'


<('-+-."-(+-(+/"0,,',+/","'#"%,-!-!/)--!'!'

.'"' 7!",(+-",0"-!"'-!).+/"0(
'0(.%!+',,-!- '28,1)+-",

"'&('"-(+"' '/+"2"' ('-+-.%(%" -"(',7!9"',(&&"--:",.''"&(.,%2

,.))(+-"/(-!","'0"%% "')+-"%,-),-(+-"' ,()(0(+$0"-!"'-!

(&"' &('-!,7

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 26 of 41
 IN





*




#+2+'9+5,"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9,58533;4/:?'9+*#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:,:.+)5;8:8+2+'9+9

:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++54(54*:5)533+4)+533;4/:?'9+*#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4::.+

+6'8:3+4:9.'22)558*/4':+=/:.:.+5;8:/'/954:5*+<+256'*/9).'8-+62'4/4',583':'6685<+*

(?:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8=/:./49+<+4*'?95,:.+58*+8:5'226'8:/+9/4<52<+*/4:.+533;4/:?'9+*

$+8</)+9#+)/6/+4:D9)'9+'4*:.+5;8:/'/954'4*)533;4/:?('9+*685</*+8

!)+-&'-!,&.+-!+)+( +,,('-!+*."+&'--(/%()",!+ )%',(+

)+,(',"'-"",))+()+"-(+.-)-"'-(&)-',-(+-"(')+( +&&"' >?7

+( +,,",%+='"&)(+-'-0(+$+&"',="'(.++,6

H7 %!&'"!"%'&'	/	
!,"'-""HG)-"'-,.++'-%2-+--	


-!-(.%)(-'-"%%2-+',"-"('-("'-!'+.-.+7	
",)%''"' -(

-+',"-"('-!&-(,-(+-"('	(.,"' >(+&+%2%%.,"('-."(,?4-!(. !

,-(+-"('	(.,"' ",()'"' !"',!.%'&2'(-)-&",,"(',.'-"%

&"<+!7!"%,-"%%.'+,-(+4-!"+"&)+(/%"'"%,--.,'&"'"&%).%"

,-2('+',&$-!&&(+))+()+"-(++%,-(4+-!+-!'+&"'"' 

-	
7"+&-!)+-&'--$"' -!","'"-"-"/'.%%2,.))(+--!-+',"-"('

0!'))+()+"-7-"%%4!(0/+4'(,.!-+',"-"(',!/(.++7'-"")-

-!-,(&"'(&)-'-''-,-	
0(.%!/'-+',"-"('2'(04,

	
&"'",-+-(+, '-"/%20(+$"' ('-!,,,(+(.+%,-*.+-+%2

+)(+-7!",-2)(9,-)(0':))+(!0(.%!%)+,%' -!(,-2"'-!

!(,)"-%'%%(0(+&(++)"&",,"(',+(&-!0"-%",-7'(.+ 	
-(

&(+,,+-"/"'-!"+(+-,-(&$",!+ ,-.%%2(.+7

I7 	 #'"'"%!&(##"%' 23/,-"%"'(.+'.+2IGHP+,)(',-(

-!)+-&'-8,)%'(+(&)%"'40'/","('&.%-")%+(%,(+-!7

+"&+"%24-!0,&'--(&('"-(+%"'"%'+,-(+-"(')+( +,,(+

"'(&)-'-''-,"'(.'-2#"%,0"-"' -+',+-(	
7('+"%24-!+

(-!++(%,0+,+"6&('"-(+"' '((+"'-"' ,,"'4"%"--"' 

-+',+,+(&#"%-(0!'))+()+"-4',+/"' ,-!)("'-(('--(+

,%(,+ +%,,(+,-(+-"('%(-"('7

(-4	!,(.,('-!"+,-+(%.-!, "/'%,,--'-"('-(-!(-!++(%,7

/" -(+,!/,)'-&(,-(-!"+-"&0(+$"' 0"-!,,"-!+"'#"%,(+"'

	
7/" -(+,!/&('"-(+%"'"%,--.,'+,-(+-"(')+( +,,(+-!(,

5#!!)"(-8''(#&(#"&(!"(6!"''(#&(#"&(!"(##!!)"(-8'

$"((('#&&(#$&#&!#)(#)'(#-""#")"(#"+(#!!)"(-8'

!"(  ("(&#&#!!)"(-#&".(#"2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 27 of 41
 IO

"'#"%,0"-"' -+',+-(	
=)+"&+"%2''-,0!(!/'- (+"3,

"+I7/" -(+,!/%,(0(+$0"-!	
-( "'"%"--"' -+',+(

"'(&)-'-''-,-(4-!(. !>,-"%(/?'(,.!-+',+,!/2-

(.++7/" -(+,!/%,(+)(+-%2'-"/"',.+"' &+ '2!(%,4

&+ '2-+',+,4''  "' "'(-!++",",+,)(',,(+!'.%(,,7

"+&-!","&)(+-'-0(+$7

	(0/+40!/('-"'.-(1)+,,('+',(.--!%%(-"('(/" -(+

+,)(',""%"-",7/" -(+,+0(+$"' %&(,-1%.,"/%20"-!"'<#"%''-,40!"!

%/,'(())(+-.'"-2-(,,",-''-,-+',"-"('"' -(-!(&&.'"-2(+7

 +-!--!)+"(+"-2(+/" -(+,&.,--!(,''-,0!(+&"'"'.,-(27

!(,''-,+4, +(.)4&(,--+",$(++",",7!(','-+&'-,

-!-/" -(+,&('"-(+-!,"'<#"%''-,-%,-('/+2-'2,(+%"'"%

,--.,'+,-(+-"(')+( +,,5-!",&('"-(+"' +,,,(.+-!"+(/++!"'  (%(

+."' !+&>2)+(/""' +?-(-!(,('-!0"-%",-7	(0/+4(-!+ (%,(-!

(','-++-(+.-!'.&+()+,(',('-!0"-%",-'+.-!-"&

,)'-('-!0"-%",-7!, (%,+,.))(+-2"%"--"' -+',"-"(',-('

'!'"' ,+/",7/" -(+,,!(.%)%2+"-"%+(%,"'(-!7

,)(-'-"%,(%.-"('-(-!", )40+)%,0"-!	(+-,-(((+"'-

+,-(+-"(''+",",,+/",('-+-,0"-!	,+(.'-!,--4,0%%,-!

--((%(+(8,+',"-"(')"%",-+( +&4-()+(/"+",",,.))(+-'

),2!(,("%,+/",-(%%)+-"")'-,7!"%-!,('-+-,0"%%-$&('-!,-(

(&/"%40,.))(+--!)+-&'-8,(+-,-("'-"2').+,.%-+'-"/

+",",,+/",(+)+-"")'-,7


-))+,-!-/" -(+,!/ .'"'-"2"' "+I''-,0!(!/%"'"%%2

,-"%"30!"%"'#"%'+-"/%20(+$"' 0"-!,-$!(%+,-(-+',"-"('-!&-(

,+/",7,('.+2JG4/" -(+,"'-""))+(1"&-%2JH"'"/".%,

,--0"0!((.%%" "%(+-!"-"('!(.,"' -.,"('-."(,4'

-!2!/ .'-()%'(+-!"+(&&.'"-2-+',"-"('7"&"%+(+-,+.'+02

0"-!/-+',0!(+
,0%%,"'"/".%,%" "%(+'/+8,(&&.'"-2<,

'!',-(+-"(')+( +&7!",",'(.+ "' )+( +,,4'0"+&-!(,

(+-,7	(0/+4-(-'("'"/".%,!/-.%%2'&(/+(&"+I-(-!

(&&.'"-27
-0"%%"&)(+-'--(,-+',+,(.+0"-!"'-!'1-*.+-+7

 +"' -!/" -(+,8+(%,,'!'"' ,+/",4%"--%)+( +,,!,'

&7	&"'",-+-"('!,'%+-!--!HL/" -(+,+,-+-!-!"'4

%/"' '(-"&(+0(+$"'-!(&&.'"-27!",.'(+-.'-,'+"()+(%2+%-,

,(&"%.+-(-+&"''*.-0(+$(+.+"' -!+%"+. -

))+()+"-"(')!,7!/,.&"--+,)(',-(	-!-(.-%"',-!/","(''

+-"('%(+(&&.'"-2<,'-0(+$(/" -(+,7!"%	&"'",-+-"('!,

,--)!"%(,()!"% +&'-4-!2&"'-"'-!-+-+"%-"',+*."+&(,->"

'(-%%?(-!"+-"&70('0/" -(+,>-&)(++2)(,"-"(',?!/'0"-!"'

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 28 of 41
 IP

-!),-*.+-+-()+(/"$.)'(/+%(07	(0/+4-!"+-"&",%,("-

%&(,-1%.,"/%2-(+-+"%-"',7

!"%0.'+,-'-!+%"-",(/" -(+)"-240&"'-"'-!-/" -(+,

,!(.%-!)+-&'-8,9:(+,-(+-"('"'-!(&&.'"-2=/","%1)+-,"'

-!+,-(+-"(',2,-&0!(,+/,-!	)("'-(('--0!'/+',+

"'-""72,+/"' ,-!)+-&'-8,+,-(+-"('1)+-,"'-!(&&.'"-24

/" -(+,"'+,+,-(+-"(',.,,4-+(.%,!((-)+(%&,4+,,+",",,"-.-"(',4

'!'(&&.'"-2-'.+4'!%),$)-"%#. ,-+.,--!)+-&'-8,(.-)-"'-

+,-(+-"(',+/",7!',,"-2(-!,+(%,",!" !%" !-2-!%$(,--0"

+" ,%"",('0(+$(+>",.,,%-+"'-!",,-"('?7

+%,($'%20+-!-%%+)(+-,(/" -(+,-(-!/''(-%

"''-.+7!+",'(-",,&"'-"(',2,-&2-"')%7!"+-(+!,

 .'-("&)%&'-,(&,"-(%%-"('''%2,",0"-!-!7,.))(+-

-!,(+-,7	(0/+4&.!0(+$+&"',,-(+ .%+4(',",-'-4.'"(+&-

(%%-"('-' '2%/%7
'+%2'.+240)+(/",/+%1&)%,(-

&' &'-"',"&"%+(+',")+( +&,"'(-!+,--,7,(-!0+"-"' (-!",+)(+-4

'((.-(&,++ .%+%2+)(+-(+'%23-(',.+"%"-2'-"/',,7

+%"&"'+2'.&+,'*.%"--"/'(-,++,('%1)--"(',,!(+-%2-+

-!%.'!()+( +&4.-.-(8,%(' )%''"' !",-(+2'&)%(2

(+"'--"('40'-"")--!)+-&'-')+(/"+&(+--!'",

.++'-%2"' +)(+-(+",.,,7

"'%%24-!"+-(++'-%2)+(/"+-(1)--"(',+ +"' 

(.&'--"('4+",","'-+/'-"('4'<-(<('--0"-!%%+-+"%-"',7


',!(+-4-!(.&'-+*."+,-!-/" -(+,,!+-+"%-"'-(

('/+2-0(0$,7
'"'-+/'"' 0$,4-!/" -(+0"%%(&&.'"-0"-!

-!#"%8,&'-%!%-!&.%-"",")%"'+2-&41)-0!'+-"'"+.&,-',+",

>7 74+)(+-,(,.""%"-"('4-7?-!-0"%%',,"--0$%2<-(<('--7

!",",," '""'-,-)(+0+"'(+&%"3"' -!8,)(%"",')+(.+,

+ +"' -!(+'+,-('(-!6',.+"' -!-)+,(',('-!0"-%",-+"' 

*.-%2&('"-(+(+%"'"%,--.,'."-24'"%"--"' -+',+,-("+'-

%/%,(+0!'))+()+"-7!(.&'-","' +/"02
'0

'-"")--!-"-0"%%"'%"32%%)+-",0"-!"'-!'1--0(0$,7

J7 ""%!'"!*''%&#%"% /,&'-"('"')+/"(.,*.+-+%2+)(+-,4-!

+" ,+( +&'&.,-0(+$-( -!+-("%"--",!+ ',!+

+,)(',""%"-",(+(&)-'2<+%-,,7!2(-!+%2(',"&"%+>)+-"%%24.-'(-

'-"+%24(/+%))"' ?(",("'(+&-"('7!.,4-!)+-&'-'-!+" ,-&

!/'-"/%20(+$"' -(((+"'-,+/",4,(-!--!2'.%-"&-%2(%%(+-

"'02-!-&"'"&"3,+.''",' ),7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 29 of 41
 JG

/+%%40+)%,0"-!-!)+( +,,-!.,+"'-!",(&&.'"-"(''

(%%(+-"('7!&(+'.&(+&'--0'-!-0( '",!,'

%(,-("'%(+&'20$,5('," '4"-0"%%%%(0-'"'(+&-"(',!+"' -(

(.+-0'/" -(+,'%"",(',7%-"&-%2-!-0"%% +-%2"&)+(/-!"%"-2(

(-! '",-("%"--",!+ ,';(+-+',"-"(',("+I"'"/".%,(.-(#"%,

'"'-((&&.'"-2)%&'-,0!'))+()+"-7!"+-(++)(+-,4!(0/+4

-!-.,%"",(',+&(,-(-'!"',," '-("'(&)-'-''-,4

1)"-"' ",!+ ,'!(%"' ',,+2(.+-!+"' ,",(-'"".%-7

/" -(+,!/ .'--&)-"' -(,!.%!+"' ,'+"' +%/'-"'(+&-"('

-((.+-4.--!-)+(,,","".%-.,/" -(+,+'(-(.+-)+,(''%7(

%-!(. !-!-0()+( +&,))+-(!/&)+( +,,"',!+"' "'(+&-"(''

.'+,-'"' +(%,'1)--"(',(!(-!+4-!%$(%"",(',,," '-(

"'(&)-'-''-,!,.,++"+"'-+',"-"('"' "+I"'"/".%,-(-!

(&&.'"-27

K7 2" (!',1&!!&'"%'"!3/!)+( +&",)"%(-)+( +&

,"''/+-!-)+(/",'!'&'-%!%-!',&' &'-,+/",-(

(&&.'"-2<,+,-(+-"(')+( +&7	",.'"' -!)+( +&'!,

('-+-'-%	%-!'-+('/+-()+(/"-!0+)+(.''+,-(+-"('

,+/",7+-"")'-,0"%%+0'+(&&-+(<+(.'-2#"%,5"+I"'"/".%,+

-+ -(+"'%.,"('7(-4,"1"'"/".%,!/')%"'-(-!)+( +&4',"1

&(+"'"/".%,!/'"'-"",%"'"%%2%" "%'% %%2,."-%7	

&"'",-+-(+,!/"-'(. !.'"' (+-(-%(+(.'IL)+-"")'-,-

'2('-"&7



Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 30 of 41
 JH






%8'49658:':/545,"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9,'"8+:8/'2+:'/4++/9:8'49658:+*:5:.+596/:'2,58'4

46':/+4:536+:+4)?<'2;':/54'4*:.++6'8:3+4:58'3+*/)'2685,+99/54'256/4+9:.'::.+

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++/9/4)536+:+4:'4*:.+685</9/5495,#$A
.'<+(++43+::.+

+6'8:3+4:9.'2245::8'49658::.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++(')1:5./9.+858/-/4':/4-0'/2

/+-!),-*.+-+4-(-%(IH''-,0+&"---(	
(+'"')-"'-

(&)-'2/%.-"('4(0!(HJ&-777AIN<ML<HIL+"-+"4(+"' -(!(,)"-%,-7

('(-!,''-,0!(&-"/"%(&&"-&'-+"-+"0++-.+'-(%(%#"%7

 

,&'-"('"')+/"(.,*.+-+%2+)(+-,4HP<IIJ"'%.%' . -!-%%(0,	
-(

$)''-,(++(+"')-"'-/%.-"('-	
+(&-!-"&-!--!/%.-(+

()"',-!&"'(&)-'--()+(>+-!+-!'+*."+"' 777AIN<ML<HIL+"-+"&-4

(+-!--!(+" "'-"' (.+-#."-,-!''-,"'(&)-'-?7!",",'(0(.'"'

777AHM<O7L<HGL>
<<L?'+,,(%%(0,6

"# "  !""$#"("# "!$!""""

 !" "! $!'"'"$#"#!"""

"!""" (#!!"  "'"!""""

$!"( %",+# !" " ""% ""$#"!#""""

# ")

(%"",')+(.+, (/+'"' -!","('<&$"' "'-!,"+.&,-',+,-"%%"'

/%()&'-7--"&,4	
&2'-(%'-!,"'(&)-'-"'"/".%,%+2"'

-!!(,)"-%'"''(!(,)"-%<%/%+0"-!-!(,"+H(+"+I''-,"'(.'-2

#"%,))+(!"' -!"+%"',(+&",,"('7(-4","(',&(' -!,"'"/".%,!/

'&)+"&+"%2('%"'"% +(.',4.-0%,(.'+,-'-!'-(&"-"'"/".%,

0!(!/'0"-"' "'(.'-2#"%,(+1-')+"(,(-"&7",.,,"(',-0'	

'
!/'&"%')+(.-"/"'-!,!%%' "' ,"-.-"(',7

#&"(#(
")&-$ '(&#!$ "$#&(:$2B@;/')!((-#"&)&-G/

B@B@2

($&(!"(4'!#"( -&$#&(:$2C@; &)&-G/B@B@2

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 31 of 41
 JI




*


	


 5:/,/)':/545, 545362/'4)+=/:.%/3+,8'3+9%.++6'8:3+4:9.'2245:/,?:.+$6+)/'2

'9:+8'4*=++12?8+-'8*/4-'4?454)5362/'4)+=/:.:/3+,8'3+9

'!42?54+45:/)+6+8"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9.'22(+685</*+*'4*9.5;2*/4)2;*+/%.+4'3+5,:.+

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++//%.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++D925)':/54///%.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++D9).'8-+9('9+*54

/4,583':/54'<'/2'(2+:5:.++6'8:3+4:/<%.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++D9(54*'35;4:('9+*54

/4,583':/54'<'/2'(2+:5:.++6'8:3+4:<&.+:.+8',58+49/)'99+993+4:.'9(++43'*+54

=.+:.+88+9:58':/54/4:.+)533;4/:?/9'668568/':+</&.+:.+8:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++.'9

68+</5;92?(++4,5;4*/4)536+:+4:<//&.':+,,58:9'8+(+/4-3'*+:5685</*+:/3+2?536+:+4)?

$+8</)+9:5:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++/4)2;*/4-)533;4/)':/549=/:.:.+)5;8:5;8:/'/9549'4*

)533;4/:?3+4:'2.+'2:.685</*+89F

(%.++6'8:3+4:9.'22'))536'4?/:954:.2?':'#+658:9++"'8'-8'6.=/:.'9+6'8':+

B/4+9#+658:C=./).=/22/4)2;*+:.+4'3+95,:.+"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9,58=.53:.++6'8:3+4:.'9

'))8;+*',/4+*;8/4-:.+68+)+*/4-354:.:.+4;3(+85,*'?9+')."8+:8/'2+:'/4++='/:+*/4:.+

5;4:?'/296'9::.+:/3+,8'3+9,58)5362/'4)+'4*:.+:5:'2,/4+95=+*(?:.++6'8:3+4:,58:.+

68+)+*/4-354:.

)%.++6'8:3+4:9.'226'?:.+:5:'2,/4+95=+*54:.+*':+:.+/4+9#+658:/99;(3/::+*:5:.+

$6+)/'2'9:+8:5(+*+659/:+*/4':8;9:'))5;4:)8+':+*,58:.+6;8659+5,,;4*/4-454+6'8:3+4:

3+4:'2.+'2:.9+8</)+9%.+'))5;4:=/22(+3'4'-+*(?')5;8:'665/4:+*'*3/4/9:8':58+)/9/549

)54)+84/4-6'?3+4:95;:5,:.+'))5;4:=/22(+3'*+(?')533/::++)549/9:/4-5,'8+68+9+4:':/<+

,853:.+"2'/4:/,,'8+68+9+4:':/<+,853:.++6'8:3+4:'4*:.+$6+)/'2'9:+84?*/96;:+9

8+-'8*/4-:.+,/4+99.'22(+.'4*2+*:.85;-.:.+*/96;:+8+952;:/54685)+99/*+4:/,/+*/4"'8'-8'6.

!)+-&'-!,('-"'.-()+(/"+%"%'(-""-"('('('<(&)%"'(-"&+&,

('0$%2,",4,+*."+2-!(','-+>,"'.'H4IGHP?7
"$0",4-!

)+-&'-!,(&)%-9"',)(+-4:,)+,+"2-!(','-+7"'%%24,

)+,+"2-!(','-+4-!)+-&'-!,')2"' -!,"',"'-(-+.,-

(.'->&' 2(+,B(&)'24

?7

!.',+(&-!,"',+%+2 ("' -( ((.,7,&%%(&&"--(&)+","' 

)+-&'-&"'",-+-"('>(+-!0"'4!!?4+)+,'--"/+(&-!%"'-">"774","%"-2


0(%(+(%+4
/'"$?4'-!)"%,-+,!,&-+ .%+%2(+,/+%&('-!,-(

+,,.,(-!,"',7!+( (%",-(.,-!.',"'02,-!-!%)-!(,"'/(%/"'

-!&'-%!%-!'+"&"'%#.,-",2,-&,>"774-!(,0!(+4(++%"$%2-((&4

"'/(%/"'(&)-'2<+%-,+/",?4'-(+.(%(+(8,9(&)-'2+",",4:2

)+(/""' '0,+/",(+"'-+/'-"(',-!-(!"'%+2%%0"-!"'-!)+-&'-8,

+,)(',""%"-",7
'(-!+0(+,4.',+(&-!"',,!(.%,.))%&'-''(-+)%1",-"' 

,+/",7

!"+,-())(+-.'"-2-(.,-!,.',(+)+(&)-,+/",&+ 0!'-!(%(+(

(%"-"('(+-!	(&%,,>	?0,+'(/-"' !(-%-(+-(&"!'("&.0!"!

(&)+",HOI,"' %<.'"-+,"',(+!(&%,,"'"/".%,7.,	!,,-+(' +(+

(",%+,)(',""%"-2',.,,.%!(.,"' "'-+/'-"(',4-!)+-&'-1)%(+

(%%(+-"('-("-'0+,"',-(-!(,"'/(%/"'-!(&)-'2,2,-&4

)+-".%+%2''-,0!((.%%" "%(+(&&.'"-2<,(&)-'+,-(+-"('

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 32 of 41
 JJ

-!2!,,-(!(.,"' >%$(!(.,"' ",(&&('++"+-((.-)-"'-+,-(+-"('

-+-&'-?7%-"&-%24"''++' &'-"'%"3('-(+I4IGHP4-!"',(&&"--

('-+".-DJ7L&"%%"('-(-!9.,"('-."(,:)+(#->'(0%%,-(+-"('	(.,"' ?4"'

1!' (+IO"-+,"',(+(&)-'<"'/(%/"'"/".%,0!(&-!

)+-&'-++,4(/+-!'1-"/2+,7.,"('-."(,()'(''.+2IH4IGIG'

 '-$"' +++%,2,-+0+7!(+',".))(+-&'	
+(-!

"'-"2"' ''-,0!((.%-+',"-"('-(-!!(.,"' )+(#-7!2+-+ -"' 

''-,0!(++2-(-+',"-"('(.-(-!!(,)"-%(+#"%'('-"'.+,-(+-"('

,+/","'-!(&&.'"-27"+,-)%&'-,,!(.%(.+"'+!IGIG40!"!",,(&0!-

%-+-!''-"")-7

!(. !-!"',(&&"--!,'(-"'%"3-!'1-.'"' )+"(+"-",4-!(&&"--",

"'/,-" -"' )"%(--,-(9(&)-'2($-:(+9(&)-'2%'+:"'(%(+(

",-+"-7!/+,+!'(',.%-0"-!(-!+#.+","-"(',+(.'-!(.'-+24'"-",

%+(&)-'2<,)""($-,(+'.&+(/'- ,-((.+-,'''-,4'

-'-(1)"-(&)-'2<+%-)+(.+,"'02,0(.%!%)''-,'-!

)+-&'-0"-%",-,7.+-!+&(+4. ,"'(%(+(8,HO.""%",-+"-+!" !%2

&(-"/--(,-%",!(&)-'2($-7!2!/' "/',.))(+-+(&-!!"

.,-"'!/1)'-!)"%(--("'%.(-!+)!('(. %,(.'-2(.+-,7!2

!/,$(+%"--%"'-+&,(.'"' 4,"+(&(.+-<,/%.-(+)(,"-"('-()+(/"

*."$-.+'+(.'(&)-'2/%.-"(',')+(/"/",-(-!%" ""%"-2(+(&&.'"-2<

,+,-(+-"('-+-&'-7!)%''"' ",,-"%%.'+0250'-"")--!",0"%%(.+'1-

!" !)+"(+"-2(+.'"' 4'%"$%2&$," '""'-('-+".-"('-(1)"-"' (&)-'2<

+%-,+/","'-!",",-+"->'%"$%22('4-(-!1-'--!",,+/,,&(%(+(-!+

",-+"-,-(+)%"-?7

"-"('%",(+.'"' "'%.,&' +(+-!.,"('-."(,
)().%-"('4'

."-('!'.'"' +(,,-!,--4"'<)-!-'%2,",((+',"--+',

0"-!"'	4'/%()&'-(,)"%"3.++".%.&(+)+(/"+,')+-"")'-,7

0"%%('-"'.-().+,.-!,",,!+(-!+%-"/%2,!(+-<-+&'(+%7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 33 of 41
 JK











/</2+*8++@+%.++6'8:3+4:D9	
"2'4/4)2;*+*'4+,,58::5,8++@+)/</2'*3/99/549:5/:9

(+*9:5*+<5:+596/:'2(+*9:56+8,58346':/+4:#+9:58':/54%8+':3+4:9+8</)+9!4+(8;'8?

	
:.++6'8:3+4:'-8++*:59:56:./968'):/)+%.++6'8:3+4:=/22)54:/4;+:52+'<+:.+9:':+D9

)/</2'4*0;<+4/2+(+*9'225)':+*'95,:.++>+);:/545,:./9549+4:+)8++,58)/</2'4*0;<+4/2+

69?)./':8/)'*3/99/549'4*=/2245:,8++@+58)54<+8::.59+(+*9:5685</*+)536+:+4)?9+8</)+9,58

"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9;42+99:.++6'8:3+4:8+)+/<+968/58'-8++3+4:,853:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8:5;9+

;4;:/2/@+*(+*9,589;).6;8659+9%./99:8':+-?:5,')/2/:':+)5362/'4)+=/:.:.+549+4:+)8++

9.'22542?(+8+/362+3+4:+*/4:.+,;:;8+;654'-8++3+4:5,:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8

!)+-&'-('-"'.,-(+)(+--!--!2!/+&(/-!9"/"%+3:,&'-

2-!(','-+7!-",4-!2!/'(-+<).+)(,-!"/"%,-	

(+

(&)-'+,-(+-"('4,-!2!(')+()(,7+(.++*.,-4-!)+-&'-

('-"'.,-()+(/"',.,+)(+-('-!	

)-"'-,"'-!"+&('-!%2+)(+-7,(-!"+

&(,-+'-+)(+-4-!	

)().%-"('"'%.-(-%(PG)-"'-,4OP(0!(&0+"/"%

)-"'-,7

.+"' &('-!%2&.%-"<)+-2&-"' ,4-!)+-&'-!,",.,,'2)(-'-"%!' ,-(

-!.,('2	

,>7 74%%(-"' 0'0,-	

-((&&(-

"')-"'-(&)-'/%.-"(',='(-+,-(+-"('=0!"!&2+.-!'-(-+',)(+-

'/+<+''-,-(	
(+"')-"'-/%.-"('?7'+%%24-!%"'-",')"%

,-+,!/ +0"-!-!&"'(+!' ,-!2!/)+()(,4.,-!,-'-(+%-

""'-,-),-!---+,+/-!)+-&'-,8(',.&+,7

(+-!(+,%.-.+4-!)+-&'-0"%%('-"'.-(0+,-%0"-!-!+%"-2-!--((0

"/"%,1",-"'(%(+(7)(-'-"%4%"-"'"+-4'"-(-!(','-+&2-(

"'+,"/"%)"-2-!+(. !-!+.'(+(+',",5-!)+-&'-0"%%'-(

('-"'.-(&('"-(+-!",-+''-!(.-(&,((','-+"'"-"-"/,-(-+&"'-!

(' ("' '.-.+',(+"/"%,7





Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 34 of 41
 JL

	
	




	5368+.+49/<+'4*5.+9/<+"2'4%.+$6+)/'2'9:+8D9,/89:8+)533+4*':/54='9:58+</9+:.+

+6'8:3+4:D9	
"2'4/4:5'358+)5368+.+49/<+'4*)5.+9/<+62'41:

?58'(5;:

'4;'8?		:.++6'8:3+4:=/22685*;)+'4/4/:/'262'48+9;2:/4-,853'254-:+83</9/54/4-

685)+99=/:.:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8'4*9:'1+.52*+89:.':=/22)54952/*':+*/96'8':+6/+)+95,:.+

+6'8:3+4:D9);88+4:62'4'254-=/:.2+-/92':/<+/4/:/':/<+9/4')5.+9/<+6')1'-+,58)5;8:9

'*3/4/9:8':5899+8</)+685</*+89'4*2+-/92':589:5)549/*+898+,+8+4)+*/4:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8D9

#+)533+4*':/54 ;3(+8:.+		"2'4=/22./-.2/-.::.+3+:.5*9:568/58/:/@+7;'2/:?'3/*

7;'4:/:?'4*:/3+68+99;8+91:

':
!4'4'44;'2('9/9:.+8+',:+8:.++6'8:3+4:=/22

8+</+='4*8+</9+:.+62'4'9'668568/':+('9+*;654*':'685</*+*(?:.++6'8:3+4:

!)+-&'-!,"'%"3(&)+!',"/4(!,"/)%',(+.+2IN4IGIG7,0

-"%"')+"(+*.+-+%2+)(+-,4-!)+-&'-&-+(.-"'%20"-!,-$!(%+,4'

((+"'--!"+0(+$0"-!-!(/+'(+8,%.)+"'-,$(+,.(&&"---!-",

+,,"' (&)-'<+%-",,.,7+."%%24-!)+-&'-!,(')-.%"3

(&)-'2<+%-,+/","'++(+02-!'-!2!"'-!"+&+IGHO+)(+-7

!2-"%&.!(-!"+)+( +,,-(-4'+&"'"'  (%,4%%(0!"!+%-&.!

&(+(&)+!',"/4&.%-"<-))+(!-(-!(&)-'2+",",4,(&)+-(-!"+

+%"+(+-,7

%--(-!(&)+!',"/)%'40'(.+ -!)+-&'--(('-"'.#!!!"%'

6464&')&&&"!0!2!/'1)%(+"' )(-'-"%% ",%-"('-!-&2"&)+(/

(&)-'2,+/",'--++,,-!)().%-"('("'"/".%,%"$%2-("'/(%/"'-!

(&)-'2,2,-&7
&)(+-'-%24-!2!/(',(&(-!","'(%%(+-"('0"-!
'

(-!+,-$!(%+,7(-4)(-'-"%% ",%-"('"'%.,"'+,"' 	(/+," !-+ +"' 

#"%<,&'-%!%-!,+/",4+,"' (&)-'2&'-,(+%(0,-<%/%('+,4

'#.,-"' (&)-'2+</%.-"('-"&+&,7-!+% ",%-"('-!)+-&'-",

(',"+"' 0(.%1)'-!)((%((&)-'/%.-(+,-("'%.%"',%"'""',0"-!

,-+8,<%/% +,>/+,.,('%2(-(+% +,?7!"%-!",))+(!&2.%-"&-%2)+(/

',,+2-(/%()-!0(+$(+'(+"'+,"' (&)-'2/%.-"(',>)+-".%+%2

(&&.'"-2<,(&)-'2/%.-"(',?40+'(-('/"'"-",',,+2--!",-"&7

-!+40!/'(.+ -!)+-&'--(/" (+(.,%2).+,.,/+%,-+- ",-(1)'

-!0(+$(+((-(+%<%/%/%.-(+,7!2!/ +-((,(4.-+%,(

,"&.%-'(.,%2).+,."' -!",% ",%-"(',!(.%1)'"' -(,-+8,<%/%/%.-(+,/'-.%%2

(&',,+27

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 35 of 41
 JM









'362+3+4:')558*/4':+*=/*+9)'2+5;:6':/+4:)533;4/:?('9+*)536+:+4)?8+9:58':/54

!#9?9:+3%./99?9:+39.'22(+/4:+-8':+*'4*9;(3/::+*=/:.:.+B5368+.+49/<+'4*

5.+9/<+"2'4C8+,+8+4)+*/4"'8'-8'6.
	.+8+/4%./962'49.'22(+'6685<+*(?:.+$6+)/'2

'9:+8

,+%-"'),-*.+-+%2+)(+-,4-!)+-&'-('-"'.,/%()"' 0"<,%

(.-)-"'-(&)-'+,-(+-"('-+-&'-)+( +&>?7!"+(+&%)+( +&

 '"'+!(IGHO4'+++%,(+(.-)-"'-+,-(+-"('+' +(&IM<KM''-,

)+&('-!.+"' -!),-*.+-+>0"++' 4',&%%+'.&+4-!'-!)+"(+*.+-+?7

--!",)("'-4",'+"' "-,-0(<2+''"/+,+27,,.!4&(,-(.'-",'(&&.'"-2

&'-%!%-!'-+,>	,?+(,,(%(+('(0(+,(&(+&(7!++LJ

('-+-,"')%+(.'-!,--7!",,--0",2,-&","+%2.'"*."'-!5/+20

(-!+,--,!/,.!+(.,-,--0")+,'7'%2('	",+.,"' -((+

"'(%(+(4'('%2(.+(.'-",+&"'0"-!(.-/"%()-"(',>, +)!"

%(04()"+(&-!'.+2IGIG('-!%2(&)%"')(+-?6

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 36 of 41
 JN

!)+-&'-('-"'.,-().+,.('-+-,',+/",(+-!(,+,"'0!"!,+/",+

'(-2-/"%%7	(0/+40+(&&',!"-"'(+-,(+--!",-0(<2+

''"/+,+27!"%,(%""-"' ,+/","'.',+/+,40'(.+ 	-( "',!"-"' 

(.,-(',.+"' *.%"-2&(' -!"+.++'-)+(/"+,7!",",(&)%",!2"+,-/%()"' 

'.-"%"3"' +(.,--(%%-"('''%2,",)%'7&"'",-+-(+,!/)+(.-!

"+,-"-+-"('(-5!(0/+4-!-",,)+'"+%2 '+%7'(.+ &(+

-"%-&'%-(.+-!+'%2,",50%,(+*.,--!--!-)+(/""'-!

('-!%2(&)%"')(+-7!/)+(/"-!)+-&'-0"-!&(+-!'(3'

/+"%,0+(&&'(+-(%%-"(''+)(+-"' 5-!,/+"%,+(&&('&-+",

+(,,(-!+,--,8(.-)-"'-+,-(+-"(')+( +&,7

('%240'(.+ -!)+-&'--(/%(),(&,)"%"3)+( +&,=

9'-+,(+,-(+-"('1%%'7:!"%-!++,(&(&&('%"-",+(,,''-,4

-!++%,(",-"'- +(.),0"-!,"&"%+++"+,-((&)-'7)"%)().%-"(',

>''-,0"-!"'-%%-.%","%"-",4-+.&-"+"'"'#.+",(+(-!+( '"-"/","%"-",4

,1.%(',!+ ,4(+#./'"%''-,?!/',-!-"+'-"--!&+(&(-!+

 +(.),7(&)+(/"+,&20",!-(,)"%"3"'('(+&(+(-!,,)"%-2+,>'

,(&&2&(+(+%,,,$"%%0"-!+-"' +(.),(''-,?40!"!0(.%()-"&"3

+,-(+-"('(+-,"'&.!-!,&02,)"%-2(.+-,+,,,)""'"!,"'+"&"'%%07

.!,)"%"3)+(/"+,0(.%%,(&$+++%,'(&&.'"-"('&(+""'-7

(-4	!,(.,('-+"'"' )+(/"+,-("%"-2-(-!9(&)"-:&(%(+,-(+-"('5

0!"%-!",",'(+&-"//%()&'-%)+(,,4--!",,- 4(%(+(8,,!(.% "'-(

,!"-02+(&"'"-"%.'"(+&-+"'"' '"'-(&(+,()!",-"-4'.'&(%,(

+,-(+-"('7"+&(+-,-!-&"'",-+-(+,')+-'+(+ '"3-"(',!/

0(+$-('!'0+)<+(.''),2!(,("%,+/",(+)+-"")'-,>7 74!(.,"' 4

,&' &'-4&(' (-!+,?7'(.+ -!/%()&'-(-!",91)'/"0:(

"'(%(+(=2('.'"(+&+,-(+-"('%,,,'+*."+'.&+,(/","-,'"'-(

&(+"'"/".%%2<-"%(+))+(!-!-+,,,(-!+,-(+-"(''+(+&'-%!%-!

',7

'(-!+)(,"-"//%()&'-!,'-!('/'"' (-!9%&'-(&&"--4:-&(

1)+-/",(+,&'-2HP<IIJ7!",(&&"--0"%%!%)"'%"'"%+"-+"-!-

(.+-+/",/%.-(+,0"%%.,-(-+&"'"'"'(&)-'-''-&+"-,"')-"'-(+

(&&.'"-2<,+,-(+-"('-+-&'-7 "''"' "'.%2IGIG4,--.-0"%%+*."+/%.-(+,

-((+-!,)%&'-()"'"(',7!(&&"--",,(%""-"' "').-+(&(.+-+/",

/%.-(+,-(/%())%&'-+"-+"'","(')("'-,5('"'%"34-!",,!(.%!%)

+.-!'.&+()()%('-!0"-%",-,"'/%.-(+,0"%%+*."+-(&$-!(,

"+'-"%+(&&'-"(',>(&&.'"-2<,/,7"')-"'-+,-(+-"('?7.+)+/"(.,+/"0

(-!-+" ,-"(',(/%.-(++)(+-,0,'(.+ "' "'-!-,/+%/%.-(+,!/'

+,,"' -!)%&'-","('%+25&(+(/+4-!"++-"('%'+"-+".,!/

 '+%%2',(%"7%(($(+0+-(0(+$"' 0"-!-!%&'-(&&"---(.+-!+

+"'-!,+"-+"7

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 37 of 41
 JO

%-%24,(&,-$!(%+,++-"' % ",%-"('-!-0(.%&$(&&.'"-2<,

+,-(+-"('-!.%-,--"' (++,-(+-"('4,.!-!-/%.-(+,0(.%'-(9&$-!

,:(+"')-"'-+,-(+-"('7/+%,--,!/()--!",))+(!0"-!(.-)+(%&7

,.))(+--!",% ",%-"/"'"-"-"/7



(%.++6'8:3+4:3'?;:/2/@+68/<':+.596/:'2(+*9:53++::.+4++*95,"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9

3++:/4-#$A
	')/</2)533/:3+4:)8/:+8/''4*=/:.68/58/:/@':/54:5"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9

'28+'*?8+9/*/4-=/:./4:.+9'3+-+5-8'6./)25)':/54%.++6'8:3+4:9.'22)8+':+'62'4:5

/362+3+4::./99;(9+):/54(:5(+'6685<+*(?:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8

!)+-&'-!,('-+-0"-!%(%!(,)"-%-()+(/"-'"')-"'-,(+,!(+-<-+&

(&)-'2+%-,+/",7!,,+.++'-%2"%%7	",%(,-("'%"3"' 

('-+-0"-!'"-"('%)+"/-!(,)"-%"'-!'/+&-+(+(+J<L"-"('%,4'

'(-!+('-+-",.'+"'"-"%",.,,"('(+M<HG,-)+"/-!(,)"-%('-!,-+'

%()7"%"--",.,,"('0"-!	'
-(('"+&-!--!","'+,",0++'-

'+,('%5%%)+-", +"'-!(+2-(-!"'+,"')+"/-!(,)"-%,7!

)+-&'-!,+,)('0%%-((.+'.+2IGHP+(&&'-"('-(,,+-"/%2/%()

(&&.'"-2()-"(',+-!+-!'+%2(',"&)%2)+(.+"' &(+"')-"'-,7.,(-!",

)+( +,,4-!+","')+"/-%2<('-+-,,&,))+()+"->''',,'-"%

+,(.+"',(&,,?7+"/-!(,)"-%,&2',)"%%2/"%+,(.+(+&%

+-+"%-"',4.,&%,-'-(%(' +0"-,(+"')-"'-,+/",-	
7



)%.++6'8:3+4:);88+4:2?+9:/3':+9:.':
		5,"8+:8/'2+:'/4++9'*3/::+*,58/46':/+4:

8+9:58':/54*545:4++*.596/:'22+<+2)'8+1:

':%.++6'8:3+4:=/223'1+(+9:+,,58:9:5

8+*;)+/46':/+4:8+9:58':/54.596/:'2/@':/549(?
	'4*/4)8+'9+)533;4/:?8+9:58':/549(?
	/4

9/>354:./4)8+3+4:9(+-/44/4-;4+
	
%.+('9+2/4+,58:.+68+)+*/4-9+4:+4)+=/22(+

*+:+83/4+*(?:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8(?;4+
	
;:/2/@/4-*':'685</*+*(?:.++6'8:3+4:!4

;4+
		:.+$6+)/'2'9:+8=/22+9:'(2/9.'35*/,/)':/545,:./9-;/*+2/4+('9+*;654'9;8<+?5,

:.+*':')522+):/54'4*/362+3+4:':/545,:.++6'8:3+4:D9"2'4

,)+,+""'-!(','-+40,-%",!,%"'(+"&)+(/&'-2%.%-"' 

,"1<&('-!)+"((/"%%->"774(/IGHO<)+"%IGHP?)+"(+-(-!.'H4IGHP%"'7

%,(+(&&'.,"' )+()(+-"('%&-+",0!').+,."'  (%,-!-+.'&'-%%2

)+()(+-"('%"''-.+>"774HGS"'+,"'(&&.'"-2<,+,-(+-"(''HGS+,

"'"')-"'-+,-(+-"('?7
'(-!+0(+,40!"%-!)+-&'-&2'(-!/.%%('-+(%(/+

-!-.%'.&+(+++%,4-!2!/ +-+('-+(%(/+-!)+()(+-"('(+++%,-!2

"+--((.-)-"'-/+,.,"')-"'-+,-(+-"('7!+(+40!(,-(,--!,%"'

" .+,4',-%",!,.,*.'-)+(+&' (%,.&"!#%"#"%'"!&!&'"%*

!( %&7!.,4%.%-"' -+ - (%,(++,-(+-"(',('-!,#%!'&"!)(&

+++-("')-"'-/+,.,(.-)-"'-,+/",2"%,-!(%%(0"'  (%,6

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 38 of 41
 JP

 

	"$("('(#&(#"'






)($("('(#&(#"'



	"( ' "



" !#
" !$ FIL " !#
" !$ CAL

!&A/B@AI# 



FIL		 A@LMFBL CAL
		 A@LMCDL

!&A/B@AI")!&' 
)"A9A/B@AIMFBL 
)"A9A/B@AIMCDL




)"A/B@B@#  FBL		 A@LMEFL CDL
		 A@LMCGL



"($&#&'':$'(F!#"('; !" !$	!" "  FFL !" !$	!" "  CDL

		







!)+-&'-&--!"+ (%-("'+,+++%,2HGS"'-!,"1&('-!,-+2

IGHP7!)(+-"('(''-,+++-(-0'.''&+/+ JKS7

!(','-+'(0&'-,'(-!+HGS,!"-"'+++%,-0'"')-"'-'

(.-)-"'-+,-(+-"('4,(-!-2.'H4IGIG-(-%(JNS(%%+,-(+-"('(++,,!(.%

+++-(7!&(,-+'-,"1&('-!,>. IGHP<'IGIG?,!(0'/+ (JKS(

+,-(+-"(',,(++-(7'(+-.'-%24-+,-2 "',+(&.'-!+(. !

(/&+IGHP4-!)+-&'-!,,'+,-"%"'"'-!)+'- (.%-,+++

-("'-!),--0(&('-!,7

.-(-!,+'-"),"'(++,40(.--!--!)+-&'-0"%%%-(--"'

(&)%"'0"-!+ +)!KH(-!(','-+2"'+,"' (.-)-"'-+,-(+-"('-(

JNS4('/+ 4(+-!)+"(,)''"' &+H4IGHP-!+(. !.'H4IGIG7!"%0

('-"'.-(/"0-!JNS,)"+-"('% (%,%+ %2+,('%4"-,&,.'%"$%2-!--!

)+-&'-0"%%+!"-.'%,,+&-""'+,,(.+,(('='+&"'-"'

(',",-'-%27	(0/+4/'0"-!-!+'-"),4-!)+-&'-",,-"%%&"'-"'"' JKS+-

(.%-,(++-(.+"' -!),-,"1&('-!,7!",",,.,-'-"%"'+,,(&)+

-(-!+-"'-!,"1&('-!,,.++(.'"' "&)%&'--"('(-!(','-+>IOS?7

"-"('%%240!/'(.+ -!)+-&'--(+.%%2,,,,0!"!)+-"")'-,+

))+()+"-%2)(,"-"('(+,.,,"'-!,2,-&4'('%2++-!(,-2),()+,(',

-(-!)+( +&7
-!-+++%+-",.%-"&-%2%,,-!'JNS(-!-(-%'.&+(.'
40

,.))(+-%(0+"' -!,)"+-"('% (%(+"' %27"&-()%-!&1"&.&'.&+(

##%"#%')+,(',"'4.-+'(-0-()+-+&"'+-""-1,-!

-.%'.&+(''-,))+()+"-(+7!/+(!-!",,.#-0"-!(-!

)+-",4'(-!+&'%-(&+ "'%%2,&%%+)+'-  (%""'%%))+()+"-

+++%,+&70"%%('-"'.-(&('"-(+-!+-50%"/"-'+-"'%2

"'+,0"-!('-"'.#.""%.-"('4((+"'-"('0"-!-!+" ,)+( +&4('(+"' 

('0)+(/"+,4'%++ ."%"',(+(.+-+/",/%.-(+,7(.+,4"

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 39 of 41
 KG

+-IGIG% ",%-"('),,,4+++%+-,&2"'+,/'.+-!+",--.-,"'

,-!.%-,--"' (++,-(+-"('4(+"%(0%/%!+ ,+,--.-(+"%21%.+(&

"')-"'-+,-(+-"('"'&(,-,,7

"'40+"'(+-!'(+	-()+(/"(.-(&-('7!/+"/('

,"+)(+-((.-(&,-(-7!"%!%).%4&(++ .%++)(+-"' '&(+

,()!",-"--'%2,,++"-"%%2'7!/,'-+*.,-(-%&'-,

-(	500"%%",.,,-!,+*.,-,"'&"<+.+2IGIG7%-!(. !	!,&'2

('.++'--+*.,-,40('-"'.-(,-+(' %2+*.,-&)"+"%(.-(&-(+

>'-!4,&'-"('+%"+?7

 

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 40 of 41
 KH




,-"%-!+(. !(.--!",+)(+-40)+"/-!)+-&'-!,&," '""'-'

&'"' .%)+( +,,"''-"' !' ,)+,+""'-!(','-+7
'4,/+%$2

"'-+/'-"(',)+,+"2-!(','-+>7 74-!-+" ,2,-&4-!(+',".))(+-

&?!/(&.%%2()+-"('%.+"' -!",+)(+-"' )+"(7!,!/ .'-(

," '""'-%2!' -!(/+%%$2&-+",4"'-!--!)+-&'-", '+%%2+,)('"' 

)+(&)-%2-(-!(,"'-"","+H7.-,"&)%24-!&(,-.-%2"%%''-,=-!(,

0!(,0%+0,)+"&+2(.,"'-!.++'-% ",%-"(''(','-+=(& '"

%)! "%#%" #''%' !'(#"!(!"'%,&' 7-!+"&)+(/&'-,+

%,(%+4,-!(/+%%0"-%",-!,+,&'"' .%%2"'-!),-*.+-+4'",%(0+

-!'-'2)("'-"'+'-!",-(+27'-!(-!+!'4"-+&"',(+-!)+-&'--( "'

%+-"' "')-"'-+,-(+-"('-+-&'-(+"+I''-,40!(,',&2%,,

.+ '-4.-'/+-!%,,"&)(+-'-7"'%%24-!)+-&'-&.,-0(+$ +,,"/%2-(/%()

'*.-0(+$(+((+',"/%.-(+,4'(/+(&-!+'-4," '""'-,-$"'

&-"' /%.-"('%"',70"%%('-"'.-(0(+$0"-!-!)+-&'-('-!,'

+%-&--+,4'0'(.+ 2(.-(('--.,0"-!'2*.,-"(',(++*.,-,7

))+"--!())(+-.'"-2-(,+/-!(.+-4'-!,--((%(+(4"'-!,"&)(+-'-

(+-,7


!"##

"! #

	"##

Case 1:11-cv-02285-NYW Document 189 Filed 03/03/20 USDC Colorado Page 41 of 41