6794148.1 27656/130254

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN

PERFECTING CHURCH, MARVIN

WINANS, and CYNTHIA FLOWERS

Case No. 2:09-cv-13493

Plaintiffs,

Hon. Gerald E. Rosen

vs.

ROYSTER, CARBERRY, GOLDMAN

& ASSOCIATES, INC., MARTIN ROYSTER,

SHANNON STEEL, LLOYD BANKS,

TOINE MURPHY, and SHALAC HOLDINGS LLC

Defendants.

Charles E. Murphy (P28909) Martin Royster

Eric K. Shih (P71326) 19710 Chesterfield

CLARK HILL PLC Detroit, MI 48221

Attorneys for Plaintiffs (313) 587-0392

151 South Old Woodward Ave., In Pro Per

Suite 200

Birmingham, MI 48009 Richard G. Convertino (P62829)

(248) 642-9692 CONVERTINO & ASSOCIATES

(248) 642-2174 (fax) Attorneys for Defendants Lloyd Banks and

cmurphy@clarkhill.com Tonie Murphy

801 W. Ann Arbor Trail, Suite 233

Ann Arbor, MI 48170

(734) 927-9900

(734) 927-9904 (fax)

rgc@convertino.net

Shannon Steel

In Pro Per

PLAINTIFFS’ PRELIMINARY WITNESS LIST

Plaintiffs Perfecting Church, Marvin Winans, and Cynthia Flowers, by their attorneys

Clark Hill PLC, respectfully submit the following preliminary list of witnesses that may be

called to provide testimony in this matter:

Case 2:09-cv-13493-GER-MKM ECF No. 64 filed 11/10/10 PageID.552 Page 1 of 4
2

6794148.1 27656/130254

1. Marvin Winans;

2. Cynthia Flowers;

3. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of the Perfecting

Church;

4. Martin Royster;

5. April Royster;

6. Shannon Steel;

7. Lloyd Banks;

8. Toine Murphy;

9. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of Royster,

Carberry, Goldman & Associates, Inc.;

10. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of RCG

Financial Group, LLC;

11. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of RCG

Management, Inc.;

12. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of RCG

Partners;

13. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of Shalac

Holdings LLC;

14. Agents, employees, keepers of records, and other representatives of the State of

Michigan Department of Energy, Labor and Economic Growth, Office of Financial and

Insurance Regulation and/or other government agencies that have investigated this matter;

Case 2:09-cv-13493-GER-MKM ECF No. 64 filed 11/10/10 PageID.553 Page 2 of 4
3

6794148.1 27656/130254

15. All witnesses identified by any other party to this action, not otherwise objected to

by Plaintiffs;

16. Persons and representatives of entities identified during the course of discovery,

which is ongoing;

17. Persons identified by Plaintiffs for purposes of rebuttal.

Plaintiffs reserve the right to amend their Witness List as discovery in this matter

progresses.

Respectfully submitted,

CLARK HILL PLC

By: /s/ Eric K. Shih____________________

Charles E. Murphy

151 South Old Woodward Ave., Suite 200

Birmingham, MI 48009

(248) 642-9692

cmurphy@clarkhill.com

Eric K. Shih

500 Woodward Ave., Suite 3500

Detroit, MI 48226-3435

(313) 965-8813

eshih@clarkhill.com

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Date: November 10, 2010

Case 2:09-cv-13493-GER-MKM ECF No. 64 filed 11/10/10 PageID.554 Page 3 of 4
6794148.1 27656/130254

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I state that on November 10, 2010, the foregoing paper filed with the Court via the ECF

system which will send notification to all attorneys of record.

By: /s/ Eric K. Shih________________________

Eric K. Shih (P71326)

500 Woodward Ave., Suite 3500

Detroit, MI 48226-3435

(313) 965-8813

eshih@clarkhill.com

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Case 2:09-cv-13493-GER-MKM ECF No. 64 filed 11/10/10 PageID.555 Page 4 of 4