·,-.. .J 

United States 

PLAINTIFF 

V. 

Scott Daniel Warren 

DEFENDANT 

PRESIDING JUDGE 

Raner C. Collins 

HEARING([RIAL DATE(S) 

November 12-22, 2019 

PLF DFT DATE ADMITTED 

NO. NO. 

1 

2 

3 

3A 

3B It(, ~j 1c 1 

3C ,,l,'"'1'°' 

4 

4A 

5 \i/ ,~he, 

6 Id I:>/ ,q 

7 ,1(,~J,q 

8 1il11/,q 

9 1, /, ,d," , 

10 1, / ro l1ci 

11 11 / 1 3 / I c, 

12 I 1 / 13 I I() 

13 iii 13 /,~ 

14 1il131Jr; 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

DISTRICT OF ARIZONA 

FILED 

- f=.!:R!!2EC~E,!!';IVE~D~-===-~LODGED copy 

NOV 2 0 2019 

CLERK US DIST 

BY DISTRICT OF ~~118~RT 

DEPUTY 

COURTROOM DEPUTY 

Sherry Gammon 

PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY(S) 

Anna R. Wright 

Nathaniel Walters 

Glenn McCormick 

GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBIT LIST 

CASE NUMBER: CRl 8-223-TUC-RCC(DTF) 

COURT REPORTER 

Erica McQuillen 

DEFENDANT ATTORNEY(S) 

Amy Knight 

Gregory Kuykendall 

EXHIBITS 

Driver's license photograph oflreneo Mujica 

Screen shot of image search results (Bates #512) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #118) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #119) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #116) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #117) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #120) 

Still image from Why Not Travel Center security camera (Bates #121) 

Screen shot from Perez-Villanueva's phone 

Photograph of front exterior of "The Barn" (Bates #302) 

Photograph of back exterior of "The Barn" (Bates #307) 

Photograph of back exterior of"The Barn" (Bates #301) 

Photograph of front door to "The Barn" (Bates #308) 

Photograph of common area in "The Barn" (Bates #310) 

Photograph of common area in "The Barn" (Bates #312) 

Photograph of kitchen area in "The Barn" (Bates #313) 

Photograph of kitchen area in "The Barn" (Bates #314) 

Photograph of common area and sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #317) 
GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBIT LIST -- CONTINUATION 

CASE NO. 

United States vs. Scott Daniel Warren CR18-00223-TUC-RCC (DTF) 

I PLF 

NO. I~~ I DATEADMITTED I EXHIBITS I 

15 1il1Jl,, Photograph of common area and sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #318) 

16 11/131!1 Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates # 185) 

16A Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #186) 

17 11 I I 3} 1 o Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #192) 

17A 

wifhd.re-WA 11/11i)~ 

~· Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates # 191) 

17B 

1-1, /-holrt11-vl"\ 11/it:i/ii 

._..... rr.,_,,c,,, I -- Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates # 189) 

17C 

~iti-\e 

. LL, ~ Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #215) 

18 l 1(13 )1q Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #190) 

19 11/,3)19 Photograph of bathroom door in "The Barn" (Bates #269) 

20 I l I L"l I, 1 Photograph of bathroom in "The Barn" (Bates #270) 

21 I I I I~ I I~ Photograph of bathroom in "The Barn" (Bates #273) 

22 11 /,3J11 Photograph of bathroom in "The Barn" (Bates #274) 

23 I I 113 /, c, Photograph of bathroom in "The Barn" (Bates #275) 

24 Photograph of bathroom in "The Barn" (Bates #277) 

25 Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #245) 

' 

25A Photograph of sleeping area in "The Barn" (Bates #242) 

26 Photograph of common area in "The Barn" (Bates #378) 

27 Photograph of common area in "The Barn" (Bates #379) 

28 Photocopy of sign in common area in "The Barn" (Bates #481) 

28A Photocopy of sign in common area in "The Barn" (Bates #520) 

29 Photograph of hand-drawn map found in "The Barn" (Bates #216) 

30 Photograph of hand-drawn map found in "The Barn" (Bates #217) 

31 Photograph of hand-drawn maps found in "The Barn" 9Bates #218) 

32 Photocopy of hand-drawn map found in "The Barn" (Bates #530) 

33 Photocopy of hand-drawn map found in "The Barn" (Bates #531) 

34 11/13/1q Perez-Villanueva "selfie" 
35 ll 11~1,ci Perez-Villanueva "selfie" (Bates #519) 

36 11 /1,l,c; Perez-Villanueva "selfie" (Bates #518) 

37 ,ti, 1l,9 Sacaria-Goday "selfie" (Bates #517) 

38 I ii d l,C\ Sacaria-Goday "selfie" (Bates #516) 

39 \l I I) l I 9 Perez-Villanueva "selfie" (Bates #515) 

40 li/,3J1e; Perez-Villanueva and Sacaria-Goday "selfie" (Bates #514) 

41 11113/iei Sacaria-Goday "selfie" 

42 11/1:ih°I Perez-Villanueva and Sacaria-Goday "selfie" (Bates #417) 

42A Perez-Villanueva "selfie" (Bates #419) 

43 \l\dli9 Perez-Villanueva "selfie" 

44 1!11'.\lit.1 Perez-Villanueva "selfie" 

45 I I l I"' hci Perez-Villanueva and Sacaria-Goday "selfie" 

46 \ I I 13 /, Cj Sacaria-Goday "selfie" 

47 ll / I JI I Ci Perez-Villanueva "selfie" 

48 1iJ1,litj Photograph of Ajo Chevron (Bates #102) 

49 1i/1s/1c1 Photograph of Ajo Chevron (Bates #103) ,, 

50 Still image from Ajo Chevron security camera (Bates #104) 

51 Still image from Ajo Chevron security camera (Bates #105) 

52 Still image from Ajo Chevron security camera (Bates #106) 

53 Still image from Ajo Chevron security camera (Bates #107) 

54 Still image from Ajo Chevron security camera (Bates #108) 

55 Transcript of Sacaria-Goday interview with Border Patrol on January 17, 

2018 (Bates #532-95) 

56A Recording of Sacaria-Goday video deposition with closed captioning 

,56B Recording of Perez-Villanueva video deposition with closed captioning . 

56C 

l 1 /19 / IOi 

Transcript of Sacaria-Goday video deposition (unredacted) Nol--~; llr-".1-

56D 11//""!L(l°t v Transcript of Perez-Villanueva video deposition ( unredacted) /\II\~ 'H'v t, 1r-1 

11/1'1I~ 

u 

56E Recording of Sacaria-Goday video deposition with closed captioning and 

f\fc,/..- +n //Ar<l retrial redactions 

u J 
5t G- 11),c,},ei 

56F 11/1q_/10i Recording of Perez-Villanueva video deposition with closed captioning and 

rvo+- ~ '111r<--1 

retrial redactions 

u J 

57 Affidavit of Dr. Scott Daniel Warren (17-MJ-341-BPV) 

58 Webpage - "About No More Deaths" 

59 Webpage - "Frequently asked questions about Desert Aid" 

60 Webpage-Ajo Ambulance Services 

61 No More Deaths' Recommended Packing List for Desert Volunteers 

62 1d1C)J1q Photograph of cabinet (Bates #244) 

63 Photograph of trash can lid (Bates #281) 

64 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #404) 

65 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #400) 

66 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #398) 

67 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #396) 

68 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #395) 

69 Photograph of The Barn (Bates #709) 

69A Photograph of The Barn (Bates #301) 

70 \i/1~1,q Photograph of The Barn (Bates #707) 

71 I I li3 I lq Photograph of The Barn (Bates #715) 

71A Photograph of The Barn (Bates #304) 

72 Transcript of evidentiary hearing held on May 11, 2018, in United States v. 

Scott Daniel Warren (18-CR-223) 

73 Satellite image of 1401 West Snyder Road, Ajo, Arizona (Bates #699) 

74 1 I 1,~),q Satellite image of 1401 West Snyder Road, Ajo, Arizona 

, 

It/ I 5hei 

> 

75 Diagram of The Barn 

76 Photograph of Sacaria-Goday in van (Bates #133) 

77 Photograph of Perez-Villanueva in van (Bates #134) 

78 Photograph of Sacaria-Goday and Perez-Villanueva in van (Bates #136) 

79 Photograph of van (Bates #501) 
, . 

80 Photograph of van (Bates #502) 

81 Photograph of van (Bates #505) 

82 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #259) 

83 Photograph of supply shed (Bates #260) 

84 Photograph of fire pit (Bates #295) 

85 Photograph of receipt (Bates #201) 

86 Photograph of The Barn (Bates #317) 

87 Id l'i ),a Ajo Chevron security camera footage 

88 Id ld I ,c, Why Not security camera footage 

89 1i/13l1ci Map of Ajo, Arizona (emailed 5/15/19) 

90 Summary exhibit of items found in Perez-Villanueva's cell phone 

91 Map of Ajo, Arizona 

92 Summary exhibit of items found in defendant's cell phone 

93 Report (Bates #1-5) 

94 Report (Bates #6) 

95 Report (Bates #7) 

96 Report (Bates #8) 

97 ·,·Report (Bates #9) 

98 Report (Bates #10-12) 

99 Report (Bates #91) 

100 Report (Bates #92) 

101 Report (Bates #100) 

102 Report (Bates #129-32) 

103 Binder-Results of extraction of defendant's cell phone 

104 Video of shelter recorded by Perez-Villanueva 

105 Still image from video of shelter recorded by Perez-Villanueva 

106 Still image from video of shelter recorded by Perez-Villanueva 
. .. 

107 Still image from video of shelter recorded by Perez-Villanueva 

108 Summary exhibit of Ajo Chevron security camera footage 

109 Summary exhibit of Why Not security camera footage 

110 Map of Border Patrol Tucson Sector Area 

111 Trial transcript for May 29, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) (afternoon session only) 

112 Trial transcript for May 30, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) 

113 Trial transcript for June 3, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) 

114 Trial transcript for June 4, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) 

115 Trial transcript for June 5, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) 

116 Trial transcript for June 6, 2019, in United States v. Scott Daniel Warren 

(18-CR-223) 

117 Transcript of evidentiary hearing held on June 14, 2018, in United States v. 

Scott Daniel Warren (18-CR-223) 

118 Timeline from forensic extraction of defendant's cell phone for January 14-

17,2018 

119 I I} /'-',I l t'i Photograph of area to northwest of the Barn 

120 11 /,31,q Photograph of area to northeast of the Barn 

121 I ( I 131 ,q Photograph of the Barn from distance 

122 11 /13/19 Photograph of the Barn zoomed in 

123 11/1?)/19 Satellite image of portion of SR 85 and surrounding area 

124 Map of intersection of SR 85 and Interstate 8 

125 II) 14)19 Perez-Villanueva "selfie" 

126 Summary of images from Perez-Villanueva's phone 

127 (/,m,.../.-.c {A v e..rn t>.C.S rAv:i. .,-./- kh- JI io 

u '--' 

128