Attachment A – Stipulated Defense Exhibits

Defense Date Topic

5174 None Chart of law enforcement response, contact, agency, and date

5175 2/16/2011 Emails between Ferrer and Barker about sting response

5220 5/15/2013

Emails between Backpage and Detective Mazure about the ads for the 

investigation

5222 6/11/2013 Emails between Backpage and Det. Petrie about ads for the investigation

5223 8/9/2013 Emails between Backpage and Dollear about ads and the subpoena

5224 8/27/2013 Emails between Backpage and Det. Zeller about ads and Tulsa subpoena

5225 9/18/2013 Emails between Backpage and SA Donaghy about ads and RI subpoena

5226 11/12/2013

Emails between Backpage and Det. Purlee about ads and Grand Rapids search 

warrant

5227 1/21/2014 Emails between Backpage and Det. Adcock about ads and Texas subpoena

5228 1/24/2014 Emails between Padilla and Constable Bercovici about removing ads

5229 2/3/2014 Emails between Backpage and Det. Osborn about subpoena

5230 2/5/2014 Emails from Det. Ring thanking Backpage for help

5231 3/13/2014 Emails from Det. Weiss thanking Backpage for response

5232 2/4/2014 Emails from Gordon from FBI thanking Backpage for help

5233 5/13/2014 Emails from Stapleton thanking Backpage for quick response

5234 5/20/2014 Emails from SADA Gasper thanking Backpage for quick response

5235 5/22/2014 Emails between TFO Wood and Backpage about subpoena

5236 5/27/2014 Emails from Dorsey thanking Backpage for help

5237 6/3/2014 Emails between Det. Thompson and Backpage about subpoena response

5238 6/9/2014 Emails from Det. Wall thanking Backpage for quick response

5239 6/14/2012 Emails from Trask (DAA) thanking Backpage for help

5240 6/17/2014 Emails from Allen thanking Backpage for quick reply

5241 6/23/2014 Emails from Lobb thanking Backpage for help

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-1 Filed 09/20/23 Page 1 of 5
5242 6/26/2014 Emails between Det. Engstler and Backpage about subpoena response

5243 7/1/2014 Emails from Wood thanking Backpage for subpoena response

5244 7/29/2014

Emails between ASA Longhitano and Padilla about reporting ads and 

subsequent identification and recovery

5245 8/1/2014

Emails between Knutson from FBI and Backpage about quick subpoena 

response and recovery of individual from ad

5246 8/13/2014

Emails between Penrod from MD gov and Padilla about placing ads in their 

respective town's escort section

5247 9/3/2014 Emails between Det. Martin and Backpage about timely subpoena response

5248 9/15/2014 Emails between Det. Landamia and Backpage about fast subpoena response

5249 9/17/2014 Emails between TFO Panico and Backpage about timely subpoena response

5250 10/10/2014 Emails between Officer Lansdown and Backpage about quick response

5251 10/27/2014

Emails between Steele and McDougal about Backpage being law enforcement 

friendly

5252 10/28/2014 Emails from Nieto of Houston PD thanking Backpage for speedy response

5253 10/28/2014 Emails from sheriff Burks thanking Backpage for quick response

5254 11/4/2014 Emails from Gordon from FBI thanking Backpage for help

5255 11/19/2014 Emails from Pereira thanking Backpage for quick response

5256 12/6/2014 Emails from Panico thanking Backpage for speedy response

5257 12/18/2014 Emails from VanBrunt from FBI thanking Backpage for quick response

5258 1/2/2015 Emails from Det. Barnard thanking Backpage for help

5260 1/28/2015 Emails from Schantzen thanking Backpage for assistance

5261 1/30/2015 Emails from SA Wrathall thanking Backpage for speedy assistance

5262 2/11/2015 Emails from Panico thanking Backpage for speedy response

5263 2/18/2015 Emails from SA Williger thanking Backpage for help

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-1 Filed 09/20/23 Page 2 of 5
5264 2/27/2015 Emails from ASA Longhitano thanking Backpage for prompt response

5265 2/27/2015 Emails from ASA Longhitano thanking Backpage for prompt response

5266 3/5/2015 Emails from investigator Crano thanking Backpage for help

5267 3/16/2015 Emails from sheriff Kozlar thanking Backpage for fast response

5268 17-Mar Emails from officer Carson thanking Backpage for info

5269 3/17/2015 Emails from Barker (FBI) thanking Backpage for help

5270 3/31/2015 Emails from ASA Brown thanking Backpage for quick response

5271 4/17/2015 Emails from Granit thanking Backpage for help

5272 4/22/2015 Emails from SA Impola thanking Backpage for quick reply

5274 4/30/2015 Emails from Haungs (FBI) thanking Backpage for helping and being quick

5275 5/4/2015 Emails from Hart (FBI) thanking Backpage for information

5276 5/6/2015 Emails from Sidoti thanking Backpage for quick response

5277 4/13/2015 Emails from Melendez thanking Backpage for quick response

5278 5/27/2015 Emails from Ryder thanking Backpage for fast response

5279 5/28/2015 Emails from Haungs (FBI) thanking Backpage for info

5280 5/28/2015 Emails from Haungs (FBI) thanking Backpage for help

5281 7/9/2015 Emails from Mcdermott (FBI) thanking Backpage for help

5282 6/12/2015 Emails from Panico thanking Backpage for speedy response

5283 6/23/2015 Emails from SA Masutani thanking Backpage for info

5284 8/7/2015 Emails from Gebo (USAVT) thanking Backpage for quick response

5285 8/7/2015 Emails from Det. Wood thanking Backpage for help

5286 8/10/2015 Emails from Jacobs (USANYE) thanking Backpage for fast turnaround

5287 8/17/2015 Emails from Dervish (FBI) thanking Backpage

5288 8/19/2015 Emails from SA Jansky thanking DOJ for quick response

5289 8/20/2015 Emails Det. Frascone thanking Backpage for quick response

5290 8/31/2015

Emails from Officer Townsend thanking Backpage for info that resulted in 

rescue

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-1 Filed 09/20/23 Page 3 of 5
5291 9/13/2015 Emails from SA Delgado thanking Backpage for fast response

5292 9/14/2015 Emails from Gordon (FBI) thanking Backpage

5293 9/14/2015 Emails from Gordon (FBI) thanking Backpage

5294 9/15/2015 Emails from Officer Herman thanking Backpage for timely response

5295 9/15/2015 Emails from Det. Bollas thanking Backpage for fast replies

5297 9/18/2015 Emails from Jacobs (USANYE) thanking Backpage for fast turnaround

5298 9/25/2015 Emails from SA Dugan thanking Backpage for prompt reply

5299 10/30/2015 Emails between Dennis and Backpage about positive trial results

5300 9/28/2015 Emails from Kirby (2015) thanking Backpage for helping quickly

5301 10/8/2015

Emails from DDA Rodriguez thanking Backpage for help that resulted in 

conviction

5302 10/16/2015 Emails from Gordon (FBI) thanking Backpage for being an asset

5303 10/16/2015 Emails from Gordon (FBI) thanking Backpage

5304 10/22/2015 Emails from SA Anderson thanking Backpage for quick subpoena return

5305 10/30/2015 Emails from SA Kindell thanking Backpage for assistance

5306 11/12/2015 Emails from Haungs thanking Backpage for tip and attention to subpoena

5307 11/24/2015 Emails from officer Kaluza thanking Backpage prompt response

5308 12/9/2015 Emails from Det. Gibbs thanking Backpage for help 

5309 12/14/2015 Emails from Scaramucci thanking Backpage for timely responses

5310 1/25/2016 Emails from SA Delgado thanking Backpage 

5311 2/10/2016

Email from Matthew B. Goeckel, Gainesville PD to Backpage Records re 

Backpage Subpoena 2/9/16 asking if it's possible to tell when an ad was 

deleted and what IP address was used for deletion 

5312 3/1/2016

Email from Kimberlie A. Laff to Backpage Records thanking them for help with 

several subpoenas sent in 12/2014

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-1 Filed 09/20/23 Page 4 of 5
5313 3/1/2016

Email response from Joseph Wechsler to Backpage Records thanking them for 

providing records related to a subpoena received 3/1/2016

5314 4/13/2016

Letter from Office of the Prosecutor, County of Gloucester Justice Complex to 

Issa Martin, Backpage re prosecution of Jennie Norcross

5315 4/21/2016

Email from Kelly Harrison, DHS, to Nathan J. Yockey, Backpage Subpoena 

Compliance Specialist, re Charlotte trial - US v. Kenwaniee Vontorian Tate

5316 4/26/2016

Email from Michael C. McKeen, DHS, to Backpage Records re Supboena from 

2012

5317 5/6/2016

Email from Amy A. Storer, HSI, to Backpage Records thanking them for a 

subpoena response 

5318 5/9/2016

Email from David Weiss, Brooklyn DA, to Issa J. Martin re Subpoena 

GJ#10223/15

5319 5/10/2016

Email from Amy A. Storer, HIS, to Backpage Records re Subpoena ICE-HSI-SV2016-00111

5320 5/12/2016

Email from Dan Gaughan, Tempe PD to Backpage Records re POST ID's 

#39624816m #66190508, #38446417

5321 5/17/2016

Email from Elizabeth Noonan, MA DA's Office to Backpage Records re Records 

related to Subpoena received 5/16/16

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-1 Filed 09/20/23 Page 5 of 5