Page 1 of 6

Exhibit 1:

A partial list of non-Scottsdale presenters of the legislative prayer ceremony

No. Name Organization Address Date Source

1 Katie Kahle

Arizona 

Community Action 

Assoc.

2700 N. 3rd St.,

Phoenix, AZ 

Not

available

(“N/A”)

Doc. 32-4 

at 2

2

Renee 

Ouellet

Arizona 

Community Action 

Assoc.

2700 N. 3rd St.,

Phoenix, AZ 

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 2

3 Tricia Hoyt

Catholic Charities 

Parish & Comm. 

Eng

4747 North 7th Ave.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 2

4

Diana 

Stickney

Catholic Charities 

Parish & Comm. 

Eng

4747 North 7th Ave.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 2

5

Bob 

Montheard

Church of the 

Nativity

7010 E Chauncey 

Ln #100

Phoenix, AZ 

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 2

6

Angel 

Juarez Comtrans, Inc.

2336 E. Magnolia St.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A Doc. 32-4 

at 2

7

Chuck 

Fitzgerald

Dept. of Economic 

Security

1789 W. Jefferson 

St.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 3

8

Nancy 

Splain DUET

555 West Glendale 

Ave.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc. 32-4 

at 3

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 1 of 6
Page 2 of 6

9

Hazel 

Chandler First Things First

1921 S. Alma School 

Rd.

Mesa, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 3

10

Joanne 

Floth First Things First

1921 S. Alma School 

Rd.

Mesa, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 3

11 Teri Duhart First Things First

1921 S. Alma School 

Rd.

Mesa, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 3

12

Debbra 

Diterman

Foothills Caring 

Corp

P.O. Box 5892

Carefree, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

13

Carol 

Hampton

Foothills Caring 

Corp

P.O. Box 5892

Carefree, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

14

Virginia 

Workman

Foothills Caring 

Corp

P.O. Box 5892

Carefree, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

15

Peter 

Kirwin

Franciscan Renewal 

Center

5802 E. Lincoln Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

16

Patti SillsTrauschFranciscan Renewal 

Center

5802 E. Lincoln Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

17

Charlie 

Brown

Franciscan Renewal 

Center

5802 E. Lincoln Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

18 Dell Piech

Franciscan Renewal 

Center

5802 E. Lincoln Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 3

19

Mary 

Schraven

Jewish Family & 

Children Services

4747 N. 7th St., 

Suite 100

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 3

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 2 of 6
Page 3 of 6

20 Kim Ballein

Jewish Family & 

Children Services

6376 W. Bell Road

Glendale, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 4

21

Kimberly 

Piehl Maggie’s Place

P.O. Box 1102

Phoenix, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 4

22

Theresa 

Price

Native American 

Edu. Prog.

1025 North Country 

Club Dr.

Mesa, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 4

23 Neil Tift

Native American 

F&F Assoc.

123 N. Centennial 

Way

Mesa, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 4

24

Tawn 

Watkins

Paradise Valley 

United Methodist 

Church

4455 E. Lincoln Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 5

25

Marisue 

Garganta

St. Joseph Hospital 

& Medical Center

350 West Thomas 

Road

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 6

26

Blue 

Swadener

St. Joseph the 

Worker

P.O. Box 13503

Phoenix, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 6

27

Nina 

Lindsey

St. Joseph the 

Worker

P.O. Box 13503

Phoenix, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 6

28

Carrie 

Vinesky

St. Theresa 

Catholic Church

5045 E. Thomas 

Road

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 6

29

Cheryl 

Lienan

St. Theresa 

Catholic Church

5045 E. Thomas 

Road

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 6

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 3 of 6
Page 4 of 6

30

Charles 

Kieffer

St. Theresa 

Catholic Church

5045 E. Thomas 

Road

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 7

31

Brian 

O’Donnell SVDP - District 5

420 W. Watkins 

Road

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 7

32

Mary 

Hutchinson

Tempe Community 

Action

2150 E. Orange St.

Tempe, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 7

33

Stephanie 

Bridgeo

The Salvation 

Army

714 S. Myrtle Ave.

Tempe, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 7

34

George 

Eastlick

The Salvation 

Army

714 S. Myrtle Ave.

Tempe, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 7

35

James 

Campbell, 

M.D.

The Wellness 

Center

360 E. Palm Lane

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 7

36

Marleigh 

Parker Valle del Sol

1209 S. 1st Ave.

Phoenix, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 7

37

Marleigh 

Parker Valle del Sol

509 S. Rockford Dr.

Tempe, AZ

N/A Doc 32-4 

at 7

38 Joe Rubio

Valley Interfaith 

Project

1802 E. Thomas 

Suite 15

Phoenix, AZ

N/A

Doc 32-4 

at 7

39 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 2/28/2012

Doc. 35-3

at 2

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 4 of 6
Page 5 of 6

40 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 3/20/2012

Doc. 35-3

at 2

41 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 5/22/2012

Doc. 35-3 

at 2

42

Bryan 

McAnnaly

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 6/5/2012

Doc. 35-3 

at 2

43 Tom Sharda

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 6/19/2012

Doc. 35-3 

at 2

44 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 8/27/2012

Doc. 35-3

at 2

45

Susan 

FrederickGrayUnitarian 

Universalists

4027 E Lincoln Dr, 

Paradise Valley, AZ 9/11/2012

Doc. 35-3

at 2

46 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 2/15/2011

Doc. 35-3

at 3

47

Rabbi 

Linder Temple Solel

6805 E. McDonald 

Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ 8/23/2011

Doc 35-3 

at 3

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 5 of 6
Page 6 of 6

48 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 10/11/2011

Doc. 35-3

at 3

49

Benjamin 

Lundquist

Camelback 

Adventist Church

5902 E. Camelback 

Road Phoenix, AZ 12/13/2011

Doc. 35-3

at 3

50 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 3/23/2010

Doc. 35-3

at 4

51

Rabbi 

Linder Temple Solel

6805 E. McDonald 

Dr.

Paradise Valley, AZ 5/4/2010

Doc 35-3 

at 4

52 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 6/16/2009

Doc. 35-3

at 7

53 Paula Webb

Interfaith Council 

Arizona

2406 South 24th St., 

Suite 214

Phoenix, Arizona 9/8/2009

Doc. 35-3

at 8

54

Charles 

Schreibman Temple Chai

4645 East Marilyn 

Road, 

Phoenix, Arizona 3/18/2009

Doc. 35-3

at 9

Case 2:18-cv-00621-DGC Document 57-1 Filed 08/30/19 Page 6 of 6