Attachment B – Irrelevant, misleading, and cumulative

Defense Date Topic

5555 3/14/2012

Emails between Detective Larson and Backpage about ads on other sites 

related to subpoena

5556 3/15/2012

Emails between Detective Barnard and Backpage about ads on other sites 

related to subpoena

5558 3/14/2012

Emails between Detective Cudd and Backpage about ads on other sites 

related to subpoena

5559 3/16/2012

Emails between Detective Nash and Backpage about ads on other sites 

related to subpoena

5560 3/16/2012

Emails between assistant federal public defender and Backpage about ads on 

other sites related to subpoena

5561 3/20/2012

Emails between special agent Vienneau and Backpage about ads on other 

sites related to subpoena

5562 3/1/2012

Email from Aaron Dennis, Columbus PD, to Backpage Help re Subpoenas Ohio 

030912 Posts 9299389%2C, 9338458%2C, 9334474%2C

5563 3/22/2012 Email from John L. Morgan to Backpage Help re Subpoena 821698

5564 3/22/2012

Email from Dustin B. Duff, Denver PD, to Backpage Help re Warrant, Denver 

County 031912

5565 3/23/2012

Email from Anthony Gigliotti, Suffolk County PD, to Backpage Help re 

Information Request 032012

5566 3/23/2012 Email from Detective Jason Howard to Backpage Help re Subpoena 032012 

5567 3/26/2012 Email from Eric Christiansen to Backpage Help re Warrant 179-12

5568 3/27/2012 Email from Michael P. Adams, HSI, to Backpage Help re Subpoena 10-1-01861

5569 3/28/2012 Email from Kate N. Reilly, HSI, to Backpage Help re Subpoena BA-12-838

5570 3/28/2012 Email from Marc Jose, San Diego PD, re Warrant 42453

5574 3/31/2012 Email from Michelle N. Burroughs to Backpage Help re Warrant 031912

5576 4/2/2012 Email from Edgar G. Fritz to Backpage Help re Subpoena 00059088

5578 4/4/2012 Email from Michael Fraggetta to Backpage Help re Subpoena 032312

5579 4/4/2012 Email from Jeff Rich to Backpage Help re Court Order 032312

5580 4/5/2012 Email from Colin McLachlan to Backpage Help re Request 032812

5183 Email re ads on other sites

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 1 of 18
5582 4/9/2012 Email from Colette E. Ruich, FBI, to Backpage Help re Subpoena 030912

5583 4/9/2012

Email from Louis H. Morlier, DHS, to Backpage Help re Subpoena 

HB15HS11HB0002

5584 4/9/2012 Email from Aaliyah Muhammad to Backpage Help re Subpoena 032012

5585 4/10/2017 Email from Sean McDermott, FBI re Subpoena KC-2012R00294-02

5586 4/9/2012 Email from Ryan Dwyer to Backpage Help re Subpoena P-12-0620

5588 4/12/2012

Email from Andrew D. Hall, Lakewood PD, to Backpage Help re Subpoena 

041012

5589 4/23/2012 Email from Steven J. Vienneau, FBI, to Backpage Help re Subpoena 00064941

5590 4/23/2012 Email from Dara Bowlin to Backpage Help re Subpoena 041912

5594 4/26/2012 Email from Dara Bowlin to Backpage Help re Subpoena 041912

5596 5/2/2012 Email from Jeanine McWilliams to Backpage Help re Subpoena 04262012

5597 5/3/2012 Email from Laura Graham to Backpage Help re Subpoena 04302012

5599 5/3/2012

Email from Ralph DeFelice, HSI,to Backpage Help re Subpoena 196-12 Ottawa 

04302012 post 10661733

5601 5/3/2012 Emails from Det. Simpson thanking Backpage for sending ads

5603 5/10/2012 Emails from Det. Larson thanking Backpage for sending ads

5604 5/10/2012 Emails from ADA Chang thanking Backpage for sending ads

5605 5/15/2012 Emails from SA Wrathall thanking Backpage for sending ads

5606 5/16/2012 Emails from ADA Petri thanking Backpage for sending ads

5608 5/16/2012 Emails from Corporal Gonzalez thanking Backpage for sending ads

5610 5/21/2012 Emails from SAUP Chase thanking Backpage for sending ads

5612 5/31/2012 Emails from Agent Spadafora thanking Backpage for sending ads

5613 6/1/2012 Emails from SA Llenas thanking Backpage for sending ads

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 2 of 18
5616 6/4/2012 Emails from officer Bartels thanking Backpage for sending ads

5617 6/4/2012 Emails from Det. McMurray thanking Backpage for sending ads

5618 6/6/2012 Emails from Det. Manz thanking Backpage for sending ads

5619 6/7/2012 Emails from SA Gutierrez thanking Backpage for sending ads

5620 6/7/2012 Emails from officer Meierding thanking Backpage for help

5621 6/7/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Sergeant Daniel 

Steel regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Denver County 053112

5622 6/8/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA Maria E. 

Johnson regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena 00068535

5623 6/8/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA James J. Melia 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Eastern Dist. of Virginia 060412; Email response from 

SA Melia requesting Backpage re-send bodies of emails it sent to him on 

6/7/2012

5624 6/8/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA Shaughna B. 

Loncar regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Eastern Dist. of Wisconsin 053112

5625 6/11/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Investigator Mark 

Brydges of the Anaheim Police Department Vice Detail regarding ads found 

on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in Warrant 

Orange County 060712

5626 6/13/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Ashley 

Metzger-Robillard of the Tacoma Police Department, Special Investigations 

Unit regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Pierce County 061212

5628 6/15/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective 

Christopher Ferreira regarding ads found on other websites with the same 

phone numbers as included in Subpoena Snohomish County 061212

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 3 of 18
5631 7/9/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kathleen Mullan and 

Jeff Perry regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Worcester County 070212

5632 7/10/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Jeremy 

Free of the Vancouver Police Department, Digital Evidence Cybercrime Unit 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Clark County 070912

5199 7/13/2012 Email re ads on other sites

5198 7/12/2012 Email re ads on other sites

5635 7/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA Carla J. Croft 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 00071828

5636 7/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Julie M. Aveitia 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena ICE-HSI-EP-2012-03384

5637 7/23/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA Patricia A. Calleri 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena BU15HS12BU0006 log 201

5638 7/23/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Melissa 

Borquez regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Maricopa County 071212

5641 7/27/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Robert Ballow

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena HT-12-1046

5643 8/1/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Brendan 

McGuire of the Portland Police Bureau regarding ads found on other websites 

with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Multnomah County 

071112

5644 8/1/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA Alan J. Heng 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 12SE-IMM-571

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 4 of 18
5645 8/1/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Investigator Mark 

Pulli of the Massachusetts AGO regarding ads found on other websites with 

the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Suffolk County 071612

5646 8/3/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and ADA Marnie Lobel of 

the Queens County NY DA's Office regarding ads found on other websites 

with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Queens County 

073112 Post 30226208

5647 8/6/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kathleen Trask 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Massachusetts 080312 Post 20337933

5649 8/9/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA Martha E. 

Parker regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena 00071702

5650 8/9/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA James Stamas 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena DAL-2012

5651 8/16/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer David Nieto 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Harris County 081012

5652 8/17/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Cpl. Jason Skrabanek 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Lubbock County 081412

5653 8/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and ASA Rachel Ballard 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Montgomery County 080812 Post 7761833

5654 8/21/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and FBI SA Barry W. 

Couch regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena 00070319

5657 8/29/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA Patricia A. Calleri 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena BU15HS12BU0006 log 210

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 5 of 18
5658 9/6/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Robert 

McFarland regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Nueces County 082912

5661 9/19/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Leon 

Guinn regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Warrant Bell County 091312

5662 9/21/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and ADA Lauren Abinanti 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Westchester County 091312

5663 9/26/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Robert Ballow 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena HT-12-1232

5664 9/26/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Elizabeth Stammo 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Worcestor County 092012 Post 19193546

5665 10/2/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer David Nieto 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Harris County 092112

5666 10/3/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Andy Lau regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Subpoena DOJ 092612

5668 10/8/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and William Halpern 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Bronx County 100112 Post 33362144

5669 10/9/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Andrew Hall 

of the Lakewood WA Police Department regarding ads found on other 

websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Lakewood 

100312 Post 10712402

5670 10/9/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Michael Anthony 

Panico regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena 3014

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 6 of 18
5671 10/8/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Mark C. Leslie of 

DHS regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena SU-12-058

5672 10/10/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Gabriel Morris 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant 12-689 King County

5673 10/10/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Mike J. Kiokow of 

the King's County WA Sheriff's Office regarding ads found on other websites 

with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena 2012R00711 16841

5676 10/16/2012

Heading lines of an email from Taylor Glynn to help@Backpage.com, subject 

line "RE: Ads on other sites related to Subpoena Suffolk County 101112" sent 

10/16/2012 9:31:52 AM

5677 10/17/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Andrew Hall 

of the Lakewood WA Police Department regarding ads found on other 

websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Lakewood 

101612

5678 10/17/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Olivia D. Olson 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Southern Dist. of New York 101012

5679 10/18/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and David W. Brown 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena DeKalb County 101212

5680 10/18/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective 

Christopher Ferreira regarding ads found on other websites with the same 

phone numbers as included in Subpoena Snohomish County 101812

5681 10/19/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Matthew 

Dixon regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Davidson County 101612 Post 6270248

5682 10/24/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Catherine 

Clogher Bartels regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Harris County 101212

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 7 of 18
5683 10/25/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Agent Montie Cutlip

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Cobb County 101812

5684 10/26/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Holly Welsh 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Cuyahoga County 102212

5685 11/1/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA Ben F. Bauman of 

DHS-ICE regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena CH13IM0114

5686 11/6/2012

Email from Backpage Help Staff to SA Sarah Gioielli regarding ads found on 

other websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena 4132; 

Email response from SA Gioielli asking whether Backpage removed all of the 

advertisements from their website

5687 11/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Edgar Roman 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone number related 

to username perezjessica949@gmail.com 

5688 11/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jean Phillips of the 

Plymouth Co. DA's Office regarding ads found on other websites with the 

same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Massachusetts 111412

5689 12/6/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Amber 

Schlote regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Douglas County 112712

5690 12/7/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Mitchell J. 

Wright regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena RE-13-157778

5691 12/10/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Jessica R. 

Bartholomew regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Hennepin County 112812 Post 8836268

5692 12/10/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Deputy Public 

Defender Sangeeta Sinha regarding ads found on other websites with the 

same phone numbers as included in Subpoena San Francisco County 112912

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 8 of 18
5693 12/12/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Barbara Pacheco 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 12-11-023 Miami-Dade County

5694 12/15/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Blake A. Allbritton

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Fairfax County 120512

5695 12/17/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Donald F. Roman 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena ICE-HSI-CR-2013-00117

5696 12/18/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff to Detective Randy 

Hansen regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Dist. of Colorado 120612

5697 12/18/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kevin Crittenden 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Wayne County 112812

5698 12/19/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Mark C. Leslie 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena SU-13-053

5699 12/19/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Alyssa Baumann of 

the Duluth MN PD regarding ads found on other websites with the same 

phone numbers as included in Subpoena St Louis County 121012

5700 12/20/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Christopher Ferreira 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Snohomish County 121112

5701 12/21/2012

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Frank Guarino 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Riverside County 121212

5702 12/27/2012

Email from Backpage Help Staff to Amanda C. Smith regarding ads found on 

other websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena NO2013-129; Email response from Smith asking if there is a way to tell if an ad is 

new or is automatically posted

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 9 of 18
5703 1/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Susan Terrey and 

boylej.bpd@cityofboston.gov regarding ads found on other websites with the 

same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Suffolk County 121712

5704 1/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Nathan Fay 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Orange County 121712

5705 1/8/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Robert Ballow 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena HT-13-375

5706 1/9/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Fernando R. 

Gutierrez regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena 00082060

5710 1/15/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Heather 

Kendall regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Warrant 12-1110 Jefferson County

5711 1/18/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kay Richard 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Dist. of Maryland 011613

5712 1/25/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Donna Gavin 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Suffolk County 012313 8574926648

5713 1/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Donald F. Roman 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena ICE-HSI-CR-2013-000174

5714 1/31/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Tonya M. Price 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 2013-I-042

5715 1/31/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jaclyn Morrill 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Suffolk County 012213

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 10 of 18
5716 2/4/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Rebecca J. Jolliff 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Kitsap County 012513

5717 2/6/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kathleen Rieman 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Western Dist. of New York 013013 MC 0994

5718 2/5/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Dave 

Mason regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Las Vegas 012513

5719 2/19/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jason Laws regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Subpoena ICE-HSI-GF-2013-00068

5720 2/25/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Welford Dunn 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Virginia 021113 Post 9395458

5721 2/26/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Roberto 

Cotto of the Phoenix Police Department regarding ads found on other 

websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Maricopa 

County 012313

5722 2/26/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Bob Lynn regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Subpoena Ohio 011813

5723 2/27/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Michael Costello of 

NYPD regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Records Request 022213

5725 3/6/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Aaron 

Dennis regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena Ohio 021313 Post 12738976

5728 3/25/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Deborah A. Freier 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Essex County 031213

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 11 of 18
5729 4/2/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Stefania Iannacco

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena New Castle County 032113

5730 4/2/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Wendy Lehner 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Anoka County 032113 Post 8474048

5731 4/2/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Ivan K. Young 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 2013-067

5732 4/2/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Heather L. Gordon 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 00085147

5733 4/2/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jennifer M. Schorn 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Bucks County 031813

5734 4/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Chris Maes 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Bernalillo County 032513 Post 4775980

5737 4/8/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Robert Ballow

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena HT-13-771

5738 4/8/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Stephen Fox 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Baltimore County 032713 Post 6771290

5739 4/9/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Scott D. Demeester 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Fulton County 040113 Post

5740 4/11/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Carissa K. Bowling 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Records Request 040413 Tallahassee Bowling

5741 4/23/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective Lebryan 

Sperling regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Warrant Fulton County 041513

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 12 of 18
5742 4/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Paul McKean 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 13SE-IMM-276

5743 4/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and ADA Jennifer L. 

Sprague regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena Plymouth County 042613 Post 21883995

5744 4/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Elaine Coyman

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Plymouth County 042613 Post 21883995

5745 4/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Michael Frank 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Eastern Dist. of Virginia 041913

5746 5/1/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and SA Matthew M. 

Perkins regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena 22892

5747 5/1/2013

Email from Backpage Help Staff to Mark Buehler regarding ads found on other 

websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Camden 

County 042913 Post 13618719; Email response from Buehler asking if there 

were new Backpage ads since the date of the subpoena

5748 5/7/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective James 

Barrette regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Warrant Riverside County 050113 Post 24324192

5749 5/9/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Sergeant John 

Chapman regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Warrant Clark County 050813 3604338925

5750 5/14/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Detective John 

Sydow regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers 

as included in Subpoena 24307

5751 5/14/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and IA Tamara 

Wiesmann regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena DEA 050913

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 13 of 18
5753 5/15/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Michelle Gilliard 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Ohio 051313 6146035122

5754 5/17/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and James Rankin 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena San Diego County 050913 star.palmer@rocketmail.com

5756 5/20/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Ylanda Pena 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Lubbock County 051613

5757 5/20/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Gerard Devine 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Bergen County 051413 Post 6103519

5758 5/21/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Barry Couch 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 25812

5759 5/29/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Officer Mike 

Gallagher of the Portland Police Bureau regarding ads found on other 

websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena Multnomah 

County 052313 Post 8956107

5760 5/31/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Joe Gamboa 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Tulsa County 052913 Post 6135358

5761 5/31/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Patrick T. Winn 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 26592

5762 6/4/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jose Estevez 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Miami-Dade County 060313 Post 19547656

5763 6/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Anthony 

Householder regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone 

numbers as included in Subpoena 27370

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 14 of 18
5765 6/12/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Gigi M. Scoles

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Essex County 060713 8625889653

5766 6/12/2013

Email from Backpage Help Staff to Patrick M. Mitchell regarding ads found on 

other websites with the same phone numbers as included in Subpoena 

DeKalb County 061013 Visas

5767 6/14/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Maurice Washington 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant King County 061113 Post 11942206

5768 6/21/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Rick Wright 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Denver County 061313

5769 6/25/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Shannon E. Brill 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 00087429

5770 6/25/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and David Swan 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Bergen County 061113

5772 7/12/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Kristina DAmbra

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Middlesex County Subpoena 2013-153

5773 7/11/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Gabriel Morris 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in King County, Washington Subpoena 13-519

5774 7/16/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Isaac Wall regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Subpoena 523094129

5775 7/23/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Hakan A. Catalan 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Tyler Texas Subpoena 7-19-2013

5776 7/24/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and David Nieto 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 86588413T

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 15 of 18
5777 7/24/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Barbara J. Owen 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 33503

5778 7/24/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Brian Severs 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in New Jersey Subpoena 07-23-2013

5780 7/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Meghan Burkeen 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Portland Subpoena 7-24-2013

5781 7/30/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Lori Sendlak 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Erie County Subpoena 7-26-2013

5787 8/13/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Shaun King regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Warrant Los Angeles County 080713

5788 9/4/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Chris J. Maes 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Warrant Bernalillo County 090313

5789 9/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Luke Goldworm 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Suffolk County 082913

5790 9/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jennifer Doyle Batish 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Eastern Dist of Pennsylvania 082813

5791 9/3/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Michael A. Panico 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 37544

5793 9/11/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Brian A. Ozden 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 39830

5794 9/11/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Carol M. Lunday

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena 39284

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 16 of 18
5795 9/11/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Chad Optiz regarding 

ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as included in 

Subpoena Multnomah County 090913 Post 9027391

5796 9/18/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Jennifer M. Schorn 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Bucks County 5218

5798 10/9/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Katherine S. Goebel 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Records Request 093013 Wichita Goebel

5799 10/9/2013

Email correspondence between Backpage Help Staff and Joel A. Nelson 

regarding ads found on other websites with the same phone numbers as 

included in Subpoena Minnesota 092413 6129903494

5803 11/6/2013 Emails from Cairns thanking Backpage for sending ads

5804 11/12/2013 Emails from Milroy (FBI) thanking Backpage for sending ads

5805 11/7/2013 Emails from Jacob (FBI) thanking Backpage for sending ads

5806 11/6/2013 Emails from Caughey (DHS) thanking Backpage for sending ads

5808 11/19/2013 Emails from Officer Harper thanking Backpage for sending ads

5809 11/19/2013 Emails from Inv. Moran thanking Backpage for sending ads

5810 11/20/2013 Emails from SA Ramirez thanking Backpage for sending ads

5811 11/20/2013 Emails from Gordon (FBI) thanking Backpage for sending ads

5812 11/20/2013 Emails from Det. Miller thanking Backpage for sending ads

5813 11/21/2013 Emails from Bartlett (AGO) thanking Backpage for sending ad

5814 11/24/2013 Emails from Neito thanking Backpage for sending ad

5815 12/3/2013 Emails from Upton thanking Backpage for sending ad

5816 12/3/2013 Emails from Det. Ronson thanking Backpage for sending ad

5817 1/8/2014 Emails from Frey thanking Backpage for sending ad

5818 1/8/2014 Emails from Det. Long thanking Backpage for fast warrant response

5819 1/8/2014 Emails from Lick thanking Backpage for sending ad

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 17 of 18
5820 1/21/2014 Emails from Det. Adcock thanking Backpage for sending ad

5821 1/22/2014 Emails from Barba thanking Backpage for sending ad

5823 1/27/2014 Emails from Neito thanking Backpage for sending ad

5824 1/28/2014 Emails from Sgt Guckian thanking Backpage for sending ad

5826 2/4/2014 Emails from Knutson (FBI) thanking Backpage for help with ad

5828 1/26/2015 Emails from Det. Weiss thanking Backpage for help with conviction

5831 5/22/2014 Emails from SADA Gasper thanking Backpage for help with ad

5840 7/3/2014 Emails from Det. Wood thanking Backpage for help with ad

5841 7/3/2014 Emails from Medina thanking Backpage for help with ad

5842 8/28/2014 Emails from Det. Leung thanking Backpage for help

5849 9/29/2014 Emails from Det. McKloskey thanking Backpage help in a case

5887 9/18/2015 Emails from SA Burke thanking Backpage for response that aided in a recovery

Case 2:18-cr-00422-DJH Document 1801-2 Filed 09/20/23 Page 18 of 18