9994111.1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Georgia A. Staton, Bar #004863

Ravi V. Patel, Bar #030184

JONES, SKELTON & HOCHULI P.L.C.

40 N. Central Avenue, Suite 2700

Phoenix, Arizona 85004

Telephone: (602) 263-1738

Fax: (602) 200-7859

gstaton@jshfirm.com

rpatel@jshfirm.com

Attorneys for Defendants City of Phoenix, an 

Arizona Municipal Corporation; Antonio 

Tarango; Officer Oswald Grenier; Officer 

Kevin McGowan; Officer Jason Hobe; Officer 

Ronaldo Canilao; Officer David Head; Officer 

Susan Heimbinger; Officer James Clark; 

Officer Dennis Lerous; Officer Ryan Nielson; 

Officer Steven Wong; and Doe Supervisors 1- 5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF ARIZONA

Mussalina Muhaymin as Personal 

Representative of the Estate of 

Muhammad Abdul Muhaymin Jr.,

Plaintiff,

v.

City of Phoenix, an Arizona Municipal 

Corporation; Antonio Tarango; Officer 

Oswald Grenier; Officer Kevin 

McGowan; Officer Jason Hobe; Officer 

Ronaldo Canilao; Officer David Head; 

Officer Susan Heimbinger; Officer James 

Clark; Officer Dennis Lerous; Officer 

Ryan Nielson; Officer Steven Wong; and 

Doe Supervisors 1-5,

Defendants.

No. 17-cv-04565-PHX-DLR

Notice of Filing and Serving Non- Electronic Exhibits

(Assigned to the Honorable

Douglas L. Rayes)

Pursuant to the Court’s December 1, 2021 Order [Doc. 383], Defendants give 

notice that they are on this date filing with the Clerk of the Court a CD/DVD containing 

redacted versions of Exhibits 62-74 to Defendants’ Statement of Facts in Support of Motion 

for Summary Judgment (as shown in the index below). Unredacted versions of these 

exhibits were previously filed under seal as Docs. 275-62 through 275-74. 
2

9994111.1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Index of Non-Electronic Exhibits

MSJ 

Exhibit No.

Description

62 BCV from Officer Oswald Grenier - COP 1

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-62)

63 BCV from Officer Jason Hobel - COP 2

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-63)

64 BCV from Officer Jason Hobel - COP 3

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-64)

65 BCV from Officer Ronaldo Canilao - COP 4

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-65)

66 BCV from Officer David Head - COP 5

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-66)

67 BCV from Officer David Head - COP 6

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-67)

68 BCV from Officer Ryan Nielsen - COP 8

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-68)

69 BCV from Officer Ryan Nielsen - COP 9

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-69)

70 BCV from Officer Ryan Nielsen - COP 10

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-70)

71 BCV from Officer James Clark - COP 12

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-71)

72 BCV from Officer Kevin McGowan - COP 7

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-72)

73 BCV from Officer Mark Aker - COP 11

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-73)

74 BCV from Officer Lance Miller - COP 13

(Redacted version of Doc. 275-74)

Concurrent to filing the non-electronic exhibits, a Judge's copy of the 

CD/DVD of exhibits is being delivered. In addition, Counsel for Defendants certify that 

true copies of the non-electronic exhibits listed above are being e-mailed to all counsel of 

record.
3

9994111.1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DATED this 14th day of December, 2021.

JONES, SKELTON & HOCHULI, P.L.C.

By/s/ Ravi V. Patel

Georgia A. Staton

Ravi V. Patel

40 N. Central Avenue, Suite 2700

Phoenix, Arizona 85004

Attorneys for Defendants City of Phoenix, 

an Arizona Municipal Corporation; 

Antonio Tarango; Officer Oswald Grenier; 

Officer Kevin McGowan; Officer Jason 

Hobe; Officer Ronaldo Canilao; Officer 

David Head; Officer Susan Heimbinger; 

Officer James Clark; Officer Dennis 

Lerous; Officer Ryan Nielson; Officer 

Steven Wong; and Doe Supervisors 1-5

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 14th day of December, 2021, I caused the 

foregoing document to be filed electronically with the Clerk of Court through the CM/ECF 

System for filing; and served on counsel of record via the Court’s CM/ECF system.

/s/ Lorraine Marques