EXHIBIT 57


G

City of Phoenix
To: Jeri L. Williams Date: July 26, 2018
Police Chief
From: Use Of Force Review Board

Subject: USE OF FORCE INCIDENT REVIEW RESULTS (PSB17-0004)

EMPLOYEES INVOLVED: Sergeant Steven Wong #7298 (800); Officer Ronaldo Canilao
#7439 (800); Officer James Clark #5708 (900); Officer David Head #6119 (800); Officer
Susan Heimbigner #6291 (800); Officer Jason Hobel #7012 (800); Officer Dennis Leroux
#7699 (DEB); Officer Kevin McGowan #6788 (600); Officer Ryan Nielsen #8028 (900)

The use of force incident occurred on January 4, 2017, at 9:30 a.m. at 4420 N. 51%
Avenue.

The Use of Force Review Board met on Wednesday, July 25, 2018, at 1:00 p.m. in
the 1S Floor Conference Room at 620 W. Washington. The Board consisted of
Chairperson/Assistant Chief John Collins, Commander Anthony Vasquez, Sergeant
Brian Rimsza, Officer Kevin Ham, Mr. Carl Lange, Mr. Richard Smith and Mr.
Ronald Tweedy.

After careful consideration of the presentation given by the investigating supervisor
from the Professional Standards Bureau and statements from the officers involved,
the Board recommends that this use of force be designated as in accordance with

the Department's policy. lo
We S a iy ae e

John Collins, Assistant Police Chief
Use of Force Review Board Chairperson

A4837\o0a\l:\Use of Force\2018 In Policy\PSB17-0004.doc

cc: Assistant Chief Sandra Renteria (CHF) Sergeant Steven Wong (800)
Assistant Chief Mary Roberts (CHF) Officer Ronaldo Canilao (800)
Commander Edward DeCastro (800) Officer James Clark (900)
Commander Charles Consolian (900) Officer David Head (800)
Commander Steve Martos (600) Officer Susan Heimbigner (800)
Commander Sean Connolly (DEB) Officer Jason Hobel (800)
Sergeant Tadd Cline (PSB) Officer Dennis Leroux (DEB)
Ms. Elisa Rodriguez (PSB) Officer Kevin McGowan (600)
Ms. Ruth Anna LaCoss (FMB) Officer Ryan Nielsen (900)

7- 207K

Oten, VE
and
CONFIDENTIRIO, Oo COP 011009



C

City of Phoenix
To: Jeri L. Williams Date: December 6, 2018
Police Chief
From: Use Of Force Review Board

Subject: USE OF FORCE INCIDENT REVIEW RESULTS (PSB17-0004)

EMPLOYEE INVOLVED: Officer Oswald Grenier #7080 (800)

The use of force incident occurred on January 4, 2017, at 9:30 a.m. at 4420 N. 513t
Avenue.

The Use of Force Review Board met on Wednesday, December 5, 2018, at 2:00
p.m. in the 1S Floor Conference Room at 620 W. Washington. The Board consisted
of Chairperson/Assistant Chief John Collins, Commander Anthony Vasquez,

Sergeant Brian Rimsza, Officer Kevin Ham, Mr. Carl Lange, Mr. Richard Smith and
Mr. Ronald Tweedy.

After careful consideration of the presentation given by the investigating supervisor
from the Professional Standards Bureau and statements from the officer involved,
the Board recommends that this use of force be designated as in accordance with

the Department's policy. Ae
ALE SCS

John Collins, Assistant Police Chief
Use of Force Review Board Chairperson

A4837\o0a\I:\Use of Force\2018 In Policy\PSB17-0004 Grenier.doc

ce: Assistant Chief Sandra Renteria (CHF)
Commander Edward DeCastro (800)
Sergeant Tadd Cline (PSB)

Officer Oswald Grenier (800)
Ms. Elisa Rodriguez (PSB) D bebreve Yo str

Ms. Ruth Anna LaCoss (FMB) pute beer hducl lel Geffer~
10 tee yniteep amtarcl ute

Grener, Thet Sacd DP weit

Une, Wt. fa. Bool.

a

CONFIDENTIAL COP 010501.1