LODGED 

PROPOSED

Doc. 292-21

 (redacted)
EXHIBIT T 
In the Matter Of:

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

17-cv-04565-PHX-SMB

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376) 

EsquireSolutions.com 
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN 

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX 

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA 

MUSSALINA MUHAYMIN AS PERSONAL 

REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF 

MUHAMMAD ABDUL MUHAYMIN, JR., 

Plaintiff, 

December 06, 2019 

1 

vs. CASE NO: 

17-cv-04565-PHX-SMB 

CITY OF PHOENIX, AN ARIZONA 

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION; ANTONIO 

TARANGO; OFFICER OSWALD GRENIER; 

OFFICER KEVIN MCGOWAN; OFFICER 

JASON HOBE; OFFICER RONALDO 

CANILAO; OFFICER DAVID HEAD; 

OFFICER SUSAN HEIMBINGER; 

OFFICER JAMES CLARK; OFFICER 

DENNIS LEROUS; OFFICER RYAN 

NIELSON; OFFICER STEVEN WONG; 

AND DOE SUPERVISORS 1-5, 

Defendants. 

The Video Deposition of: 

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN 

Pursuant to stipulations herein 

Taken at the offices of 

5051 Peachtree Corners Circle 

Suite 200 

Norcross, Georgia 30092 

Before Crystal Brumbelow, CCR 

December 6, 2019 

Commencing at 10:20 a.m. 

800.211.DEPO (3376) 

EsquireSolutions.com 
 A P P E A R A N C E S

ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF:

David A. Chami, Esquire

Price Law Group, APC

8245 North 85th Way

Scottsdale, Arizona 85258

(818) 600-5515

ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANTS:

Karen Stillwell, Esquire

O'Connor & Dyet, P.C.

7955 South Priest Drive

Tempe, Arizona 85284

(602) 241-7000

ALSO PRESENT:

Doneilea Williams, Videographer

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

2

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 I N D E X O F E X A M I N A T I O N S

________________________________________________________

Cross-Examination by Ms. Stillwell Page 8

 A T T A C H M E N T S

Errata Sheet

Court Reporter's Disclosure Statement

 T R A N S C R I P T C O D E S:

-- interruption/change in thought

. . . incomplete thought

(sic) denotes word/phrase that may seem strange or

incorrect has been written verbatim

(ph) phonetically spelled

(indiscernible) not capable of being understood

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

3

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 I N D E X O F E X H I B I T S

Number Description Page

________________________________________________________

D-1 Medical Examiner's Report 92

D-2 Toxicology Report 94

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

4

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 P R O C E E D I N G S

2 10:20 a.m.

3 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This is Tape Number 1 to

4 the videotaped deposition of Muhammad Muhaymin on

5 Friday, December 6th, 2019. The time is now

6 10:20 a.m.

7 My name is Doneilea Williams. I am the

8 videographer. The court reporter is Crystal

9 Brumbelow.

10 Will the attorneys please introduce

11 themselves, state their affiliations and place any

12 necessary stipulations on the record, after which

13 the witness will be sworn.

14 MS. STILLWELL: Hi, Karen Stillwell. I

15 represent the City of Phoenix and the individual

16 police officers, as well as Antonio Tarango.

17 MR. CHAMI: I'm David Chami with the Price Law

18 Group, and I represent the estate of Muhammad

19 Muhaymin and the witness, Muhammad Muhaymin, Jr. --

20 III --

21 THE WITNESS: Uh-huh.

22 MR. CHAMI: III.

23 MS. STILLWELL: Sir, I introduced myself

24 earlier. If -- yes, please.

25 (Witness sworn.)

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

5

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 MS. STILLWELL: All right. Sir, I introduced

2 myself to you earlier this morning. Thank you for

3 coming today.

4 Have you ever had your deposition taken

5 before, sir?

6 THE WITNESS: No.

7 MS. STILLWELL: Have you ever had a lawsuit

8 before?

9 THE WITNESS: No.

10 MS. STILLWELL: And I'm sure that Mr. Chami,

11 the estate's attorney, has kind of given you a

12 background or a rundown of what to expect today.

13 But I wanted to kind of go through some of the

14 ground rules just to make sure that you and I are

15 on the same page. Okay?

16 THE WITNESS: Okay.

17 MS. STILLWELL: I'm -- I'm going to ask you

18 some questions today. Some of them will be kind of

19 difficult, and it's truly not meant to offend or be

20 disrespectful to you or to your family.

21 If you need to take a break at any time, I ask

22 that you take that break. Okay?

23 THE WITNESS: Uh-huh.

24 MS. STILLWELL: If -- the one caveat, though,

25 is that if I have a question pending, I ask that

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

6

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 you ask that question before we take the break --

2 I'm sorry -- answer that question before we take

3 the break. And -- and then we can take the break

4 and come back and resume. Fair?

5 THE WITNESS: Okay.

6 MS. STILLWELL: While I'm asking you

7 questions -- sometimes I ask some bad questions, so

8 I ask that you tell me that you don't understand

9 the question or that it's just a bad question, and

10 I'll try to reword it so you and I understand each

11 other.

12 But if you answer that question, I'm going to

13 assume a few things. I'm going to assume that you

14 understood the question, and I'm going to assume

15 that you heard it accurately. And I'm also going

16 to assume that you're answering it truthfully and

17 accurately; is that fair?

18 THE WITNESS: Yes.

19 MS. STILLWELL: Now, you'll notice she's

20 taking down every word that everybody is saying and

21 that there is also a video player running.

22 I ask that you give me verbal answers. It's

23 common to get kind of in a conversation where you

24 nod your head or shake your head. I just ask that

25 it be verbal so she can get that information down.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

7

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 THE WITNESS: Okay.

2 MS. STILLWELL: Okay.

3 Whereupon,

4 MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN, JR.,

5 was called as a witness herein and, having

6 been first duly sworn, was deposed and testified as

7 follows:

8 CROSS-EXAMINATION

9 BY MS. STILLWELL:

10 Q. Now, I -- I'm sure that you met with Mr. Chami

11 prior to today's deposition; is that right?

12 A. Uh-huh.

13 Q. And how many times did you meet with him?

14 A. A few times.

15 Q. What is a few? Do you remember?

16 MR. CHAMI: I'm going to object to the form.

17 Do you mean in -- in preparation for the

18 deposition?

19 MS. STILLWELL: Yes, sir.

20 THE WITNESS: Once.

21 BY MS. STILLWELL:

22 Q. Was that this morning prior to the deposition,

23 or did you meet with him prior to today?

24 A. Are you asking --

25 Q. For purposes of preparing for the deposition.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

8

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Oh, yeah. Once.

2 Q. Was that this morning, sir?

3 A. Yesterday.

4 Q. And how long do you think you met with

5 Mr. Chami?

6 A. Maybe an hour, couple of hours.

7 Q. And was anybody else present during that

8 meeting with Mr. Chami?

9 A. No.

10 Q. Was anybody present with your meeting with

11 Mr. Chami this morning?

12 A. My wife.

13 Q. And what's your wife's name?

14 A. Zhane Muhaymin.

15 Q. Can you spell her first name for me?

16 A. Z-h-a-n-e.

17 Q. Thank you.

18 Did you review any documents in preparation

19 for your deposition today?

20 A. Just the document for the deposition, I guess.

21 Q. Are you referring to the notice of deposition?

22 A. Yes.

23 Q. Okay. Did you review any pleadings, any

24 complaints or discovery responses?

25 A. No.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

9

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Did you review any videotapes?

2 A. No.

3 Q. Did you review any recordings or other

4 communications?

5 A. No.

6 Q. Is there anything about your physical

7 condition that would affect your ability to testify

8 today?

9 A. No. Not that I can think of.

10 Q. Is there anything about your mental condition

11 that would affect your ability to testify?

12 A. No.

13 Q. Are you on any medications that would affect

14 your ability to understand the questions and testify

15 truthfully?

16 A. No. I mean, I have asthma, but that's it, if

17 that's what you're asking, but no.

18 Q. Okay. And for asthma, you just take --

19 A. Inhaler.

20 Q. And no other medications, correct?

21 A. Yes, that is correct.

22 Q. And you understand that when you took the

23 oath, when you got sworn in by the court reporter, that

24 you avowed to answer the -- the questions that I asked

25 today, or if Mr. Chami asks any questions, that you'll

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

10

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 answer them truthfully and accurately, correct?

2 A. Yes.

3 Q. And that's the same as testifying in the

4 court, you understand that, correct?

5 A. Yes. To the best of my abilities.

6 Q. Okay. I just want to go through some of your

7 general background.

8 What is your date of birth?

9 A. .

10 Q. Did you say '83 or '93?

11 A. '93.

12 Q. Thank you.

13 And you live in Norcross, Georgia, correct?

14 A. Uh-huh.

15 Q. When did you move here?

16 A. A little over a year ago.

17 Q. What brought you to Norcross?

18 A. Well, I made a promise to myself and my family

19 that after I graduated from college, that I would pursue

20 my dream. And so my dream is to do acting and stuntman

21 work and actually has a lot of influence on a lot of

22 background from the stuff of when I was younger, when I

23 grew up, spending time with my dad and spending time

24 with my grandfather. Because martial arts is a huge

25 part of tradition in our family.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

11

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 And as I grew older -- at first I went to high

2 school, then I went to college, and -- and I got my

3 degree. But I always felt like something was missing.

4 So I definitely wanted to give it a shot, to

5 pursue my dream. And I know that a lot of the work out

6 here is for acting and stuntman work, so that's why I

7 came out here.

8 Q. So are you now employed in acting or stuntman

9 work?

10 A. No. Right now I do insurance sales, because

11 moving out here was hard. I -- I actually took a pay

12 cut moving out here. But I -- when I got older, I

13 didn't want to regret what could have happened, what

14 could have been, so --

15 Q. So when did you start -- you said you're

16 working in insurance sales, correct?

17 A. Yeah. I've been doing insurance for -- for a

18 while now, a couple of years. I -- on the side, I've

19 had some part-time gigs for acting and stuntman work,

20 but I haven't had the time to completely pursue it, just

21 because I want to get my finances in order.

22 And this year was a lot. Just got married.

23 Just bought a house in Georgia.

24 Q. Congratulations.

25 A. Thank you.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

12

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Yeah. So I wanted to get all that, my -- my

2 roots down in Georgia, in Atlanta, before I went full

3 time at that.

4 Q. Okay. So when you moved out here, did you

5 take a job in insurance sales?

6 A. Uh-huh.

7 Q. And you said that was roughly a year, year and

8 a half ago; is that right?

9 A. Yeah.

10 Q. Okay.

11 A. Yeah.

12 Q. So who did you work for when you moved here?

13 A. I worked for State Farm.

14 Q. Okay. State Farm here in Atlanta?

15 A. Uh-huh. Yeah. Because I worked for State

16 Farm in Arizona, and then I moved out here.

17 Q. Were you able to do a transfer within State

18 Farm, then?

19 A. No.

20 Q. Okay. You had to apply for a whole new

21 position?

22 A. Yeah. Because they didn't have my position --

23 Q. Okay.

24 A. -- out here, so -- and plus, I wanted to try

25 something different. So instead of working for the

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

13

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 corporate company, I had been working for an agency.

2 Q. Oh.

3 A. But it -- just in case my stunt work and

4 acting didn't pan out, I wanted to have enough to build

5 my resume and my portfolio. So now I've obtained a

6 couple different positions in insurance, but --

7 Q. What are your positions in insurance?

8 A. I've worked -- well, at first I worked at

9 Humana, when I -- because I had to find a full-time

10 position. So when I was in college, I worked for health

11 insurance.

12 Q. Oh, we'll get to college. I'm -- I'm just

13 talking about here, in Georgia.

14 A. Okay.

15 Q. What are your positions here? You said you're

16 working for an agency now?

17 A. Yeah. Selling insurance.

18 Q. Okay.

19 A. That's it. Yeah.

20 Q. So you're a selling agent?

21 A. Like, sell -- yeah. Sales policy -- selling

22 policies.

23 Q. Okay. And you said you had a couple

24 positions. Couple positions while you've been here, or

25 a couple of positions over your career?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

14

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Over my career.

2 Q. Okay. And so when you moved to Georgia, you

3 started with State Farm. And have you remained with

4 State Farm this whole time?

5 A. Uh-huh. Yeah. State Farm agents.

6 Q. Okay. How many agents do you work for?

7 A. It -- I --

8 Q. Or with?

9 A. I worked with a couple, because it can be kind

10 of like what they label as, like, a floater. So for

11 example, if I need to work with one agent but they have

12 a friend that has a business need at that agency, then I

13 go over there and work over there, so -- but it's been

14 the same position. It's been the same role.

15 Q. Can you tell me the agents that you work with?

16 A. Right now, I just work with one.

17 Q. Okay. Who is that?

18 A. Barbara Collins.

19 Q. Okay. And who did you work with before that?

20 A. Brenda Montgomery.

21 Q. And just those two?

22 A. No. I've worked with a couple, because a lot

23 of times, they are friends, and, like, they know each

24 other. Like I said, where the business need is needed,

25 so --

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

15

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Okay.

2 A. And how -- how is that relevant, or...

3 Q. Well, I -- I'm asking the questions. I'm sure

4 Mr. Chami can make his objections. But I'm -- I'm just

5 asking who you've worked with since you've been to --

6 back in Georgia.

7 A. Okay.

8 Q. So I have Barbara and Brenda.

9 Were there any others?

10 A. Uh-huh. Barbara and Brenda were friends. And

11 so I worked with Brenda for a little while, and she said

12 that Barbara needed some assistance in her office

13 because they were short. So I moved over there.

14 Before Brenda, I was working with Charisse

15 Hunter. And I also was working with Andre Cleveland.

16 Andre Cleveland retired, though. I was with him for a

17 while. But then because of his retirement, then the --

18 my team had to find work at other agents, but he -- he

19 knew a couple of the other agents as friends.

20 Q. Okay.

21 A. So...

22 Q. And is that then when you went to Barbara

23 Collins?

24 A. No. I went from Andre Cleveland to Charisse

25 Hunter.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

16

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Okay.

2 A. And then from Charisse to Brenda, and Barbara.

3 But it's -- like I said, it's all the same position.

4 Q. You just float between them?

5 A. Yeah.

6 Q. Whatever the need is?

7 A. Yeah.

8 Q. Okay. And then your part-time gigs for acting

9 and stunt work, who have you done those through? Is it

10 an agency?

11 A. Yeah. Yeah. It's -- it's -- it's a couple of

12 different agencies, because I've done a couple of extra

13 roles --

14 Q. Okay.

15 A. -- and stuff.

16 Q. Which agencies are those?

17 A. I -- I'd have to look through -- through my

18 e-mail. I'm not sure.

19 Q. Okay. When you're doing the acting/stuntmen,

20 what -- what kind of product is that? Is it for a

21 commercial? Or is it for a TV show?

22 A. It can be for anything, really. I mean, you

23 can do -- well, acting is like everything, you know,

24 TVs, movies, short films, what have you.

25 And then the stuntman work is anybody that's

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

17

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 doing fight choreography, falls, flips, driving,

2 anything like that.

3 But -- but mainly, I would be doing, like,

4 fight choreography, falls and flips, those -- those

5 three.

6 Q. Okay.

7 A. So -- yeah.

8 Q. How much time would you say you devote to

9 either of those?

10 A. You mean practicing?

11 Q. No, no. The actual gigs, the actual paying

12 employment that you receive from it.

13 A. I haven't had much time, because like I said,

14 I've been focusing more on getting my financial

15 situation structured first. Because I have received

16 a -- a couple of paychecks, but they -- they pay you

17 like six weeks later. It's a long time.

18 Q. Okay.

19 A. Yeah.

20 Q. So how many gigs would you say you've had

21 since you moved back here?

22 A. Maybe only three or four.

23 Q. Okay.

24 A. So...

25 Q. And if you don't mind me asking, how much do

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

18

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 you get paid for those gigs?

2 A. Because they were extra roles, maybe a couple

3 hundred dollars.

4 Q. Okay. And you said it's pretty much a scene,

5 like a fighting scene or a rolling or flipping? Is that

6 what you said?

7 A. Those are -- that's the acting or that's

8 the -- the stuntman portion, but -- yeah. That's the --

9 the stuntman -- because I'm trying to do stuntman and

10 acting work.

11 Q. Okay. And so the acting, does that compensate

12 you differently, or is it still the same?

13 A. Well, the roles that I've gotten were extra

14 roles. Those are the ones that I've gotten actually

15 paid for.

16 I haven't done any stuntman work yet, just

17 because there is -- it's not so straightforward. Like,

18 you have to know the right people. You have to learn

19 the industry, how the industry works. You have to

20 create a stunt reel and headshots and a resume. You

21 have to network with people.

22 So I've been doing that behind the scenes, as

23 well as doing my day job selling insurance, so...

24 Q. So you've been busy?

25 A. Yeah.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

19

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. And you have to, I'm sure, train and practice

2 a lot for the stunt work too.

3 A. Uh-huh.

4 Q. And I know you talked a little bit about

5 martial arts, and I'd like to talk about that more.

6 But are you still in martial arts training?

7 A. Yeah.

8 Q. Okay. And where do you do your martial arts

9 training?

10 A. I actually just go to some stuntman gyms and

11 stuff, and -- well, because I -- I've always done

12 martial arts.

13 Q. Uh-huh.

14 A. And now I'll just call some people or, you

15 know, some of my friends that I've made out here that

16 are also stuntmen.

17 Q. Okay.

18 A. And see if they want to train. And sometimes

19 they'll teach me, or -- and sometimes I'll teach them,

20 so...

21 Q. So I'm curious. What are the stuntman gyms

22 that you go to?

23 A. One is called SMASH, and that's like -- yeah.

24 One's called SMASH. Another one is called ACTION DOJO.

25 Q. And this is just places where you can spar,

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

20

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 or...

2 A. Yeah. It's like -- it's like a warehouse, and

3 they have padded flooring. They have heavy bags. They

4 have a lot of different stuff. And the people that do

5 movies, that do casting, are friends with some of the

6 people that own those gyms.

7 So when you go inside, sometimes they will

8 have like a portfolio or a book of actors where you put

9 your headshot, resume, action reel, all that into the

10 book. And then after a while, if you're good enough,

11 then they can introduce you to the casting directors.

12 Q. Okay.

13 A. So -- so -- yeah. You -- they --

14 Q. So it's good exposure?

15 A. Yeah. It's good exposure. It's a good place

16 to practice, good place just to train. They do a lot of

17 different stuff, so...

18 Q. But you're not doing any formal martial arts

19 training anymore, right?

20 A. No. Not right now.

21 Q. Okay. Now, you said you just got married.

22 When did you get married?

23 A. September? Yeah. Yeah.

24 Q. September of this year?

25 A. Uh-huh.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

21

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

Q. 

A. 

Do you remember what day? 

I believe it was -- it was -- well, I took a 

vacation out to Arizona and stayed there for like a 

week, and it was just really hectic, so -- I think it 

was like September 6th or something like that, yeah. 

Q. And you guys got married in Arizona, you said? 

A. Uh-huh. 

Q. What part of Arizona? 

A. The Gilbert area . 

Q. Is her family from out there too? 

A. Uh-huh. Yeah . We ' re both from out there. 

Q. And so did you both have family attend your 

wedding? 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

Yeah. 

And did your aunt attend? 

Yes . 

And did your half sister attend? 

Uh-huh. 

A ? 

Yes . 

And so how long were you in Arizona? 

Like I said earlier, about a week, I think . 

And then you came back to Georgia, correct? 

Yeah. 

And when did you buy your house? 
1 A. It was actually December. I think it was like

2 December or January, around that time.

3 Q. Of what year?

4 A. Of -- well, it was like December of 2018 or --

5 and -- or January of 2019. That's when we were booking

6 the house, finishing the real estate, finishing the

7 closing, all the paperwork. So it was my first house,

8 so it was a lot, yeah.

9 Q. Well, that's exciting.

10 A. Yeah.

11 Q. What does your wife do for employment?

12 A. She works at State Farm also.

13 Q. Okay.

14 A. Uh-huh.

15 Q. Is she also a selling agent?

16 A. No. She works in -- 'cause -- well, she's had

17 a couple of different positions as well.

18 Q. Okay.

19 A. So -- but it's been within the same company.

20 She works at corporate, as opposed to me working in the

21 agency.

22 Q. What does she do at corporate?

23 A. She has been a trainer for customer service.

24 Q. Okay.

25 A. Did that for a little while. Then got

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

23

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 promoted to specialist in claims. And then after that,

2 she got promoted again to being a manager for customer

3 service.

4 Q. And so is that what she does here?

5 A. Uh-huh.

6 Q. She's a manager for customer service?

7 A. Yes. Or not manager, supervisor. I'm sorry.

8 Q. Okay. So does she have family in Georgia too,

9 or did she just accompany you for --

10 A. She has a couple of -- yeah. I don't -- I

11 think it's like her -- her cousin. You know, they do

12 like second removed or something like that.

13 So she's got -- she's got some family out

14 here, but she's not too close to them or -- so --

15 building an -- a newer relationship.

16 Q. Okay.

17 A. Yeah.

18 Q. Do you still have some family that lives here?

19 A. Well -- so -- no. Not that I -- that I see

20 right now. No. Because I know that, like, Musi and

21 Zarinah had been out here a couple of times.

22 Q. When you say Musi, are you talking about

23 Ms. Muhaymin?

24 A. Yes.

25 Q. Okay.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

24

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Sorry. Yeah.

2 So they -- they've been out here, but while

3 we've been out here, haven't had the chance to -- to

4 meet up. But we've had a chance to meet up while we've

5 been in Arizona a couple of times.

6 Q. Okay. So does -- does your aunt live out in

7 Georgia now?

8 A. Well, last time I talked to them, they said

9 that they were -- she was getting ready to move back to

10 Arizona.

11 Q. Okay.

12 A. So...

13 Q. How long has she been back in Georgia?

14 A. I don't remember.

15 Q. Same amount of time as you?

16 A. I -- I don't remember how long because -- I --

17 I just know she's been back and forth between Arizona

18 and Georgia a couple of times.

19 Q. Okay.

20 A. So...

21 Q. Okay. With the majority of her time in

22 Georgia or Arizona? Do you know?

23 A. No -- not particularly, because most of the

24 time, like, if I would meet them, it would be in

25 Arizona.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

25

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. How often have you been back to Arizona in the

2 past year?

3 A. I think about maybe three times.

4 Q. And is that all with your wife?

5 A. Yeah. She's gone.

6 Q. And is it to visit her family as well?

7 A. She -- there's -- well, sometimes we'll be

8 together, and we'll visit her family; be together and

9 visit my family. Sometimes we'll split up for a couple

10 of days; she goes with her family, and I go with mine,

11 so...

12 Q. And who -- who else in your family would be in

13 Arizona?

14 A. Pretty much everybody. I mean, to be honest,

15 everybody on my mom's side of the family, on my dad's

16 side of the family, so...

17 Q. Okay. And do you see both sides, your mom's

18 side and your dad's side of the families?

19 A. More so, I grew up with my mother's side of

20 the family.

21 Q. Okay. And did she have a big family?

22 A. My mom?

23 Q. Uh-huh.

24 A. Not -- I don't -- not particularly, no.

25 Q. But they all still live local in Arizona?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

26

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Uh-huh.

2 MR. CHAMI: Say yes or no, instead of uh-huh.

3 THE WITNESS: Yes.

4 BY MS. STILLWELL:

5 Q. I know what you're saying.

6 A. Oh, okay.

7 Q. And she can still get down the, you know,

8 u-h-m.

9 A. Okay.

10 Q. But it's probably better to say yes.

11 A. Okay.

12 Q. Now, your mom, is that Tanya Kelley?

13 A. Yes.

14 Q. Okay. And she and your -- your dad, Muhammad,

15 they were married; is that right?

16 A. No.

17 Q. No, they were never married?

18 A. No.

19 Q. Did they live together?

20 A. Yes.

21 Q. And do you remember or do you know how long

22 they lived together?

23 A. I -- I was young at the time, so no, I'm not

24 sure how long of the time frame. But I do remember that

25 they did live together for a while. We all three did

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

27

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 together.

2 Q. Who is all three?

3 A. Me and my mom and my dad.

4 Q. Okay. Do you remem- -- do you remember when

5 that ended?

6 A. No. I was -- I was so young.

7 Q. How many siblings do you have?

8 A. Two brothers, one sister, two half brothers

9 and one half sister.

10 Q. Two brothers, one sister, one half brother?

11 A. No. Two half brothers and one half sister, if

12 we're being technical, but...

13 Q. Now, your two brothers, who are they?

14 A. Sean and Jayce.

15 Q. Same last name?

16 A. No. Foster, because they are -- my mom -- we

17 share the same mom and my stepdad.

18 Q. Okay. Who is your stepdad?

19 A. Patrick Foster.

20 Q. Foster.

21 And is Patrick still alive?

22 A. Yes.

23 Q. And your mom?

24 A. Yes.

25 Q. And Sean?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

28

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

Uh-huh. 

And you said the other one is Jayce? 

Yeah. 

Is that right? 

Do the four of them still live in Arizona? 

Yes . Everybody does. 

Okay. 

They live together. 

Okay. When did -- how old are Sean and Jayce? 

They're young . They're like 15; 14 and 15 . 

Okay. And the sister? 

A ? 

Well, you said you have two brothers, one 

sister, two half brothers, one half sister. 

A. No, no, no, no, no . I'm saying -- let me --

let me clarify. 

Q. Okay. 

A. So on my mom's side of the family, I have my 

two half brothers, which is Sean and Jayce . And their 

dad is Patrick Foster, and we share the same mom. 

Q. Okay. And then your 

A. And then on -- my -- my half sister is A 

so 

Q. 

A. 

And that's your only sister, correct? 

Yeah. 
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

Q. 

A . 

Q. 

A . 

Q. 

A . 

Okay. And do you know where A 

In Arizona . 

Do you know where she lives? 

She lives with my -- my aunt, so . . . 

With Mussalina? 

is? 

With -- well, with one of them. The only --

the only reason why I 'm saying I ' m -- I 'm not sure is 

because they -- they ' re together all the time, or 

they ' re -- they ' re together a lot of the time, so ... 

Q. 

A . 

Q. 

A . 

Q. 

A . 

Q. 

aunt? 

When you say they, who are you referring to? 

My sister, Zarinah, and Mussalina. 

Who is Zarinah? 

She is her sister. 

Whose sister? 

Well, she was - - she ' s Mussalina ' s sister. 

Okay. And do you refer to Zarinah as your 

A . Yeah. It gets confusing just because of the 

way everybody was raised. So there 's, like, the 

biological standpoint, and then there was, like, the 

situation of -- of how people were raised to address 

their family member. 

Q. 

A . 

Okay. 

So I know sometimes Mussalina has played like 

a mother figure and like a sister figure at the same 
1 time to Zarinah.

2 Q. Okay. Can you explain that to me a little

3 bit, how she acts as a mother and a sister to Zarinah?

4 A. I don't really know how to explain that,

5 like -- because Mussalina helped raise Zarinah, so...

6 Q. Who is -- biologically speaking, who is

7 Zarinah related to?

8 A. I'm not sure, to be honest.

9 Q. Do you remember when Zarinah became part of

10 the family or when you -- as you described, Mussalina

11 was raising her?

12 A. Yeah. Well, I mean, Zarinah and Mussalina has

13 always been involved in -- in the family. Like, they

14 have always been there. I remember even at a time when

15 I lived with my dad, Muhammad, and my mom, Tanya, that

16 there was a couple of times that Zarinah came over and

17 spend the night. So they -- they have always been

18 around. We've always been in each other's lives.

19 Q. As far as you know?

20 A. Yeah. As far as I can remember.

21 Q. Now, when you referred to Zarinah and

22 Mussalina coming over to the house that you lived in

23 with your mom and dad --

24 A. Uh-huh.

25 Q. -- you said that that ended when you were

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

31

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 really young?

2 A. Yeah.

3 Q. I'm -- I'm trying to figure out how old you

4 were when that happened. Were you in kindergarten yet?

5 A. I believe so.

6 Q. Were you in first grade?

7 A. Probably more so like the kindergarten age.

8 Q. Okay.

9 A. Yeah.

10 Q. Okay. So perhaps somewhere around four or

11 five?

12 A. Yeah. I guess, yeah.

13 Q. And you recall Zarinah coming to visit you

14 during that time period?

15 A. Uh-huh. I remember me, my mom and my dad

16 lived in -- it was in an apartment -- apartment complex.

17 And I remember even Zarinah coming over a couple of

18 times.

19 And one of the reasons why I remember it so

20 vividly being in that apartment complex is because me

21 and my dad caught chicken pox together at the same time.

22 Yeah -- so -- my mom was more so kind of babying me

23 tell -- but telling my dad that he could deal with it

24 type thing, so...

25 Q. Okay. Do you know if your dad had any

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

32

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

other -- well, you wouldn ' t know, but is it possible 

that your dad had other children not including you and 

-- ? 

MR . CHAMI: Object to foundation . 

You can answer, if you can . 

THE WITNESS : What was your question? 

BY MS . STILLWELL: 

Q. Is it possible that your father had other 

children other than you and your half sister? 

MR . CHAMI: Same objection . 

BY MS . STILLWELL: 

Q. If you know . 

A. 

Q. 

I'm not sure. 

Now, your grandparents, did you know either of 

your grandparents on your dad's side? 

A. Yeah. 

Q. And did you spend time with either of them? 

A. My grandfather, Muhammad, up until his 

passing . To be honest with you, a lot of the time when 

I spent time with my dad was with my grandfather. So it 

was all three generations of Muhammad . It was me, my 

father and my grandfather. 

Q. And your grandfather passed in 2006, correct? 

A. Yeah. About that time. 

Q. When you and your mom and dad all lived 
1 together, what was your dad's role? Did he spend a lot

2 of time with you? Was he working?

3 A. Like I said, I was -- I was so young that -- I

4 mean, I do remember us spending time together for sure,

5 me, my mom and my dad.

6 Q. Do you remember -- and I'm sorry, but at the

7 beginning, you said you did martial arts with your dad.

8 Did you start that at that point?

9 A. Me doing martial arts goes back to the

10 beginning of, like, some of my earliest memories. So

11 it's something that I remember always doing, because my

12 grandfather moved from New York to Arizona and opened up

13 some -- some dojos and did some teaching there.

14 And at that time -- so I remember being young,

15 and we all practiced together. That was one of the ways

16 that we spent time together. Just like some families,

17 you know, football is prevalent in their family or

18 basketball or baseball or something. Martial arts and

19 Islam was a huge part of my upbringing.

20 Q. Okay. And you said that was -- your -- your

21 grandfather had owned the dojos, correct?

22 A. Well, he -- yeah. Because he -- he opened up

23 a dojo inside of his garage in his house, taught some

24 local people around there. But at the same time, he

25 would go to some universities. I guess he had some type

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

34

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 of contract or deal with them, so he would teach at some

2 colleges as well. And then my -- my father would

3 assist -- assist him.

4 And then I would go spend time with them.

5 Q. Okay. What kind or what type of martial arts?

6 A. Aikodo. It was --

7 Q. Say that again.

8 A. Aikodo.

9 Q. Okay.

10 A. It was a -- it's a very soft, gentle version

11 of a Japanese martial arts style, so...

12 Q. Is that the only style --

13 A. Yeah.

14 Q. -- that you all practiced --

15 A. Uh-huh.

16 Q. -- or taught?

17 A. No. I -- I -- I went on to learn others,

18 because Aikodo is such a soft style that they don't even

19 believe in competitions or competing. So I wanted to --

20 as I got older, I wanted to learn how to compete. So I

21 did Aikodo for as long as I can remember with them.

22 That was the only thing that they did. And then I went

23 on to practice other styles of martial arts.

24 Q. And what did you go on to practice?

25 A. Well, my stepfather, Patrick, knows

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

35

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 kickboxing. So he taught me kickboxing, boxing, more

2 competitive styles of martial arts.

3 Q. And so did you compete in martial arts?

4 A. A couple of times. I also learned Tang Soo Do

5 as well. So I did a point fighting tournament. But

6 I -- I wanted to expand and learn more, so...

7 MR. CHAMI: I'm sure she's going to have to

8 ask you how to spell that. Tang Soo Do?

9 THE WITNESS: Tang Soo Do.

10 MR. CHAMI: Tang Soo Do.

11 THE WITNESS: Yeah. It's a Korean style of

12 martial arts. It's similar to Tae Kwon Do.

13 MS. STILLWELL: I got it.

14 MR. CHAMI: I didn't.

15 MS. STILLWELL: The court reporter might have

16 to ask you, but...

17 BY MS. STILLWELL:

18 Q. Now, how often would you spend time with your

19 dad and grandpa doing martial arts?

20 A. That was one of our pastimes, to be honest

21 with you. So almost every time I would see them.

22 Q. And how often was that?

23 A. It depends at what stage I was in my life. It

24 depends on how old I was.

25 Q. Okay. So from birth to four or five, when

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

36

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 your dad moved out of the home, how often did you guys

2 do martial arts together?

3 A. Well, from birth to four or five, nothing. I

4 think I started martial arts at, like, five.

5 Q. Okay. Do you recall whether you started

6 martial arts while your dad was still living there or

7 after he had gone? Or do you remember?

8 A. No. I don't remember that. I just remember

9 when I was with them, just like everything else, going

10 out to eat, going to the movies, spending time together.

11 Also was -- they had a huge aspect of Islamic

12 prayer and doing martial arts as well. It was -- the

13 martial art thing was -- it was something sacred. It

14 was something traditional.

15 So on top of practicing a lot of the time,

16 like right after, we would do prayer too, so -- it was

17 more so something to teach for, like I said, tradition.

18 Q. Were there times where you practiced with your

19 grandfather, but your dad wasn't there?

20 A. Yeah. There was times where I practiced with

21 my dad, and my grandfather wasn't there.

22 Q. Okay. From, let's say, you know, kindergarten

23 through junior high, how often would you see your dad?

24 And my next question is, how often would you

25 see your grandfather?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

37

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 MR. CHAMI: Do you want those broken up

2 into --

3 MS. STILLWELL: Yes.

4 THE WITNESS: I would see my dad -- well,

5 sometimes they were together, so that's kind of,

6 you know --

7 BY MS. STILLWELL:

8 Q. Okay.

9 A. Like, sometimes I would see them together.

10 Sometimes I would see them apart.

11 Q. How often did you see your dad by himself?

12 A. You said from what age to what age?

13 Q. Sure. Kindergarten to junior high.

14 A. Kindergarten to junior high, I probably see my

15 dad every couple -- well, at first, it was like every

16 week or every other week. And then it was like maybe

17 twice a month, around that time.

18 Q. Okay. And when you -- you said -- and some of

19 those times, when you saw your dad, you were also seeing

20 your grandpa; is that correct?

21 A. Yeah. Sometimes, yeah. A lot of the time,

22 because they were -- they were close. They were really

23 close.

24 Q. Can you estimate for me how -- the percentage

25 of time that you would see your dad every other week or

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

38

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 twice a month or what you had just testified, and how

2 many of those times your grandpa was present?

3 A. Up until the time of his passing?

4 Q. No, no, no. We're still kindergarten to

5 junior high.

6 A. Okay.

7 Q. Was it 50 percent of the time you --

8 A. Junior high is like kindergarten to eighth

9 grade, is that what you mean? Like --

10 Q. Yeah.

11 A. Probably, yeah, like 50 percent of the time.

12 Q. Okay. Junior high to starting college, how

13 often did you see your dad?

14 A. Not as -- not as much.

15 And you said junior high, so like eighth grade

16 to college?

17 Q. Yeah. Eighth grade to high school graduation.

18 A. I wouldn't see him as much. And I think that

19 one of the huge reasons is because my grandfather and my

20 dad were so close, that after my grandfather passed

21 away, it hugely impacted my father a lot. And he was --

22 he was really sad about it, so...

23 I don't know. It was -- it was -- it was kind

24 of like a part of my father had passed too, if that

25 makes sense. Because it -- it hit him heavy. That's

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

39

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 how close they were.

2 And then -- I mean, I was upset for a little

3 while that I didn't see him, and I -- I didn't really

4 understand why. I -- I wanted to spend time with him.

5 I wanted to see what he was doing but -- I don't know.

6 It was -- it was -- as I got older and look

7 back on it now, I -- I also know that he had mental

8 illness. So at first I was upset, but now I'm not sure

9 how long he had that mental illness. I'm not sure if it

10 was triggered after my grandfather passed away. I'm

11 not -- I'm not really sure what happened. So I think --

12 you know -- it was hard.

13 Q. I -- I want to go back to kindergarten.

14 A. Okay.

15 Q. Your mom remarried to Patrick Foster, correct?

16 A. Uh-huh.

17 Q. Do you remember what year that was or how old

18 you were?

19 A. Nine.

20 Q. Okay.

21 A. It was either nine or ten.

22 Q. And so you then lived with your mom and with

23 Patrick Foster, right?

24 A. Off and on, because the -- the other half of

25 the time, I lived with my grandparents on my mother's

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

40

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 side. But they were so close, it didn't really matter.

2 Like, sometimes -- because, like, for example,

3 I had to go to school. So half the week, I would stay

4 with my grandparents. The other half the week, I'd stay

5 with my parents, Patrick and my mom, so...

6 Q. Okay.

7 A. We were all close, like...

8 Q. Did you live close to -- close to each other?

9 A. No. But we visited all the time.

10 Q. Okay.

11 A. Yeah. So -- well, it actually depends on what

12 time in my life. There were some times that my parents

13 were in a different city and some times where they were

14 in the same city and then some times my grandparents and

15 my parents lived together.

16 Q. Okay. So the grandparents you're referring to

17 is the grandparents on your mom's side?

18 A. Yeah.

19 Q. What are their names?

20 A. Artist and Daniel Kelley.

21 Q. Artist?

22 A. Uh-huh.

23 Q. And so did you stay with your grandparents so

24 you could stay in the same school? Or why -- why did

25 you stay with your grandparents and not your mom or your

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

41

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 dad?

2 A. Well, I did stay with them. I stayed with

3 both of them. Like I was saying, like, half the week, I

4 might be with my grandparents, half the week I might be

5 with my parents. It just -- it just depend on their

6 schedule.

7 Q. Okay.

8 A. So -- but it -- it didn't matter, because

9 my -- my parents would go to my grandparents' house all

10 the time and vice versa. And then there was even

11 occasions where they -- they were living together.

12 Q. Okay.

13 A. Like, all four of them, my grandparents and

14 parents would live together sometimes.

15 Q. So even when your parents lived, I think you

16 said, in another city --

17 A. Uh-huh.

18 Q. -- did you stay with them and just travel to

19 school?

20 A. I would stay with them and -- yeah. They

21 would -- they would drop me off before they went to

22 work.

23 Q. Okay. And during that time, you were trying

24 to see your dad every other week or so?

25 A. Yeah.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

42

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. And in high school, who did you live with?

2 A. It was still the same. Like, maybe one week,

3 I'll stay at my grandparents', or one week I'll be with

4 my parents. Or maybe -- you know, so I lived with them

5 back -- I had a room at both -- both places.

6 Q. Okay.

7 A. So...

8 Q. And that was just because of your relationship

9 with your grandparents?

10 A. Yeah. We were just close all the time.

11 Q. What high school did you go to?

12 A. Westview in Avondale.

13 Q. Okay. And after high school, what did you do?

14 A. I went to college at ASU.

15 Q. And tell me the years that you were in college

16 at ASU.

17 A. What -- what are you asking? I'm sorry.

18 Q. What years were you in college at ASU?

19 A. From like 2011 to -- I think it was 2015,

20 around that time.

21 Q. And did you get a degree?

22 A. Yes.

23 Q. And what is your -- what is your degree in?

24 A. Bachelor's in criminal justice and

25 criminology.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

43

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. And so did you intend to start a career in

2 criminal justice, or was it just something that

3 intrigued you?

4 A. At the beginning, I was actually thinking

5 about either doing -- becoming a doctor or being a nurse

6 or also going into the criminal justice field of being a

7 police officer or an FBI agent.

8 I really felt like I -- at the time, I felt

9 like I didn't want to be behind a desk, ironically,

10 because that's what I'm doing now. But -- yeah.

11 So then after my freshman year, I decided that

12 I wanted to do criminal justice and criminology, so I

13 pursued that. And then I had -- a lot of my friends,

14 they switched majors. And they asked me if I wanted to,

15 but I said no, because I didn't want to get set back

16 again with the credits and doing college.

17 So even though my junior year, my senior year,

18 I decided that I didn't want to do criminal justice --

19 that I wanted to stick it out to finish the degree to

20 have a degree. Because at that point, it was just about

21 being competitive in the corporate market, so I just

22 wanted to make sure I had a degree.

23 Q. And was that -- was that the time you started

24 working for State Farm?

25 A. I worked at Humana first.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

44

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Okay.

2 A. So when I -- my senior year of college, I was

3 going to school -- yeah -- I was going to school -- my

4 senior year of college, I was going to school full time,

5 and also I was working full time as well until my -- my

6 last semester. Because I had landed a job working with

7 Humana.

8 Q. Uh-huh.

9 A. Yeah. That was rough.

10 So I was going to the school during the day --

11 or no, I'm sorry. I was going to work during the day.

12 And then I would get out, and I would go to school

13 during nighttime. And some of my classes were online.

14 So at times, I'd have, like -- I'd -- I'd be

15 working from like 7:00, get off -- let me think.

16 No. I'd work from like 9:00 to 5:00 and then

17 get off and then do school. And do school work from

18 like 6:00 to -- until I could fall asleep, so...

19 Q. So -- and that was when you were working at

20 Humana, right?

21 A. Uh-huh.

22 Q. What was your role at Humana at that time?

23 A. Pharmaceutical sales specialist.

24 Q. And how long did you work for Humana?

25 A. I think about a year and a half, maybe two

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

45

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 years.

2 Q. What made you leave?

3 A. My wife told me about State Farm and said

4 there was a better opportunity for growth.

5 Q. So you had already met your wife by then?

6 A. Yeah. We were -- we met in college. We -- we

7 both met at Arizona State. So we both met at ASU.

8 Q. And you've been dating since?

9 A. Uh-huh.

10 Q. Well, now you're married.

11 A. Yeah.

12 Q. What year did you guys meet in at ASU?

13 A. Been about five years. So I think it was

14 2015 -- no -- 2014.

15 Q. Okay.

16 A. Well -- 'cause I had known her for a while,

17 but we didn't actually start dating until later, so...

18 Q. So when she told you about State Farm -- and

19 if my math is right, that was maybe 2017 -- is that when

20 you started working for State Farm?

21 A. Yeah. I -- I think it was around that time.

22 You're making me want to get my resume. So...

23 Q. And so you've been with State Farm since?

24 A. Yeah.

25 Q. In the various roles?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

46

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Uh-huh.

2 Q. And you're now a sales agent. But before,

3 what were you doing?

4 A. Claims.

5 Q. Okay. Is that where you started?

6 A. Uh-huh. Entry-level claims.

7 Q. And when you were in college, where did you

8 live?

9 A. Again, that depends on what year of me being

10 in college. My freshman year -- well, actually, I went

11 to -- I got accepted into this program where when I was

12 starting out in college -- it was like a summer school.

13 They call it a Summer Bridge, or whatever.

14 So when I started out -- because I started --

15 I went from high school and started working in college,

16 like, that summer, taking summer classes in college.

17 Then did the Summer Bridge there. So I lived with my

18 parents.

19 And then after that, I got an apartment my

20 freshman year, lived by myself for a few years. Yeah.

21 And then I just -- I've had a apartment since then, I

22 guess.

23 Q. And is that during the time where you didn't

24 have much of a relationship with your dad?

25 A. Yeah. As I got older.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

47

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Did you -- how many times would you say you

2 saw him on a yearly basis in high school and college?

3 A. There was a time where I didn't see my dad for

4 a few years. Yeah.

5 Q. Do you remember when that was?

6 A. I think it was from the time I was around

7 16 -- sorry. It gets kind of hard to talk about. Just

8 because I -- I remembered seeing my dad when I was about

9 like 16 years old.

10 And then after that, I didn't see him a couple

11 of times. All right? I -- I didn't see him. But I

12 wanted to. I just didn't know what his situation was or

13 where he was.

14 And then I ended up finding out that later

15 on -- I ended up finding out that my grandfather Daniel

16 was still seeing him, was still helping him, was still

17 visiting him. And -- yeah -- so...

18 Q. And Daniel is your mom's dad?

19 A. Yeah. Because -- because my mom and my dad

20 grew up together, kind of, my grandfather Muhammad was

21 still very close to my mom, acted as a father figure in

22 that way.

23 And then vice versa, my grandfather Daniel,

24 which is my mom's dad, still acted as a father figure to

25 my dad, Muhammad.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

48

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 So they -- they would all, you know, visit or

2 spend time together even -- even -- even after my mom

3 and my dad broke up, basically, so...

4 Q. Now, I -- I want to ask more questions, but I

5 know you said it's getting hard.

6 Do you want to take a break, or do you want to

7 keep going?

8 A. Yeah. Maybe a couple-minute break, if that's

9 okay?

10 Q. Yeah.

11 MR. CHAMI: We'll take one now, that way I

12 won't have to take one in 15 minutes, so...

13 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is 11:11 a.m., and

14 we're off the record.

15 (Off the record: Brief recess.)

16 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is 11:27 a.m., and

17 we're on the record.

18 BY MS. STILLWELL:

19 Q. We took a short break.

20 One thing I wanted to clarify or at least get

21 on the record, you -- you recently got married

22 September 2018, correct?

23 A. Uh-huh. Yes. Yes.

24 Q. And what is her name? What's her maiden name?

25 A. Zhane Vincent.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

49

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Can you help me with that spelling?

2 A. Yeah. Z-h-a-n-e. Last name is V-i-n-c-e-n-t.

3 Q. And you said she's from Arizona too?

4 A. Yes.

5 Q. And do you know from what part of Arizona?

6 A. Yeah. It's -- it's -- well, because she kind

7 of lived back and forth with her mom and her dad too --

8 Q. Okay.

9 A. -- so...

10 I'm not really sure, because -- well, she just

11 stayed in the dorms. So I'm not really sure where her

12 mom exactly was from.

13 Q. Uh-huh.

14 A. Because, you know, she moved around a couple

15 of times.

16 Q. So was her dad from Gilbert, then, since

17 that's where you guys got married?

18 A. Oh, are you asking why we had the wedding in

19 Gilbert?

20 Q. Well, sure.

21 A. Okay. Yeah. Well, we had the wedding in

22 Gilbert because she had looked at which venues that she

23 wanted to go to, and she just decided it was that one.

24 And I just said okay. Yeah. That's all.

25 So -- but we definitely wanted to have the

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

50

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 wedding in Arizona as opposed to Georgia because most of

2 our family is in Arizona.

3 Q. Okay. So is she from Gilbert? Is that where

4 her dad lives? Or did you just choose that wedding

5 venue because that's where she wanted to go?

6 A. Yeah. That's her -- yeah. I just said, Okay.

7 Q. And you don't know where she went to high

8 school or anything?

9 A. I can't name it specifically, no.

10 Q. Okay. Was she up by you in Avondale?

11 A. No.

12 Q. Okay.

13 A. Her -- she lived -- her mom lived, like,

14 farther, I think, south -- southeast, as opposed to I

15 live in Avondale, which is really far west.

16 Q. Okay.

17 A. Yeah.

18 But then -- but we met at school, so we met in

19 college, which is in Tempe, and then downtown Phoenix.

20 Q. Okay. Does she have any children from a prior

21 relationship?

22 A. No.

23 Q. Okay. Do you have any children?

24 A. No.

25 Q. Okay. Do you have any criminal background?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

51

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Meaning have you ever been charged with a crime?

2 A. I got a misdemeanor at one point, but then I

3 filed for a motion to dismiss it or something like that.

4 But I think they don't dismiss it anymore. They call it

5 withdrawn in the state of Arizona.

6 Q. What was --

7 A. So...

8 Q. -- the misdemeanor for?

9 A. When I was in college, I got caught with a --

10 when I was in college, I got caught with a little bit of

11 weed. So that's it.

12 Q. Did you get pulled over? Or how did you get

13 caught?

14 A. Yeah. Yeah. I got pulled over.

15 Q. And did you --

16 A. So...

17 Q. How -- how much weed was it? Or --

18 A. It was a -- a little --

19 Q. I'm assuming that's marijuana?

20 A. Yes. Yes. A little bit of marijuana when I

21 was in college. I -- I experimented with a little bit

22 of marijuana in college, so...

23 Q. Okay. And did you -- did you enter a plea

24 agreement? Or what happened after that charge?

25 A. They charged me with a misdemeanor, and they

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

52

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 said I had to pay a fee and take a class. And that was

2 it.

3 And then after that, I filed for -- to dismiss

4 it. And I guess, like I said, they don't -- in Arizona,

5 they don't completely dismiss it. They call it

6 withdrawn, I think, something like that. So then we got

7 it withdrawn.

8 Q. Do you remember when that was?

9 A. No. I'm not sure. I -- yeah.

10 Q. Just sometime when you're in college, I think

11 you said between the years of 2011 and 2015?

12 A. Yeah.

13 Q. Any other crimes that you've been charged

14 with?

15 A. No.

16 Q. Any --

17 A. Nothing.

18 Q. -- civil citations that you can recall?

19 A. What is a civil citation? Like...

20 Q. Loitering, trespass- -- well, trespassing.

21 A. No, that was it. I mean, that's --

22 Q. That's -- that's the only --

23 A. That's the only thing I can think of.

24 That's...

25 Q. And you've never been a party to a lawsuit?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

53

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. No.

2 Q. You mentioned when we -- when we took our

3 break, you were talking about your relationship with

4 your dad. And you said around 16 years old, you kind of

5 stopped talking to him for a little bit --

6 A. Uh-huh.

7 Q. Is that right?

8 A. Yes.

9 Q. And you also mentioned that you're a little

10 upset because Daniel, your mom's dad --

11 A. Uh-huh.

12 Q. -- was still seeing him and helping him.

13 MR. CHAMI: Object. Mischaracterizes his

14 prior testimony.

15 BY MS. STILLWELL:

16 Q. What was -- what was your prior testimony

17 about Daniel helping and seeing him?

18 A. Are you asking, like, to clarify the

19 relationship? Is that what you're asking, or --

20 Q. No, sir. You mentioned that your -- you found

21 out that your grandfather was still seeing and helping

22 your dad.

23 A. Yeah. He just told me. It wasn't -- it

24 wasn't like a -- a secret or anything. My -- my

25 grandfather was just like, Oh, by the way, I'm -- you

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

54

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 know, I was seeing your dad because he needs some help.

2 He had asked for help. He's trying to get better. He's

3 trying to -- but that was -- I'm -- because he -- he had

4 always kept a relationship with him, but he didn't

5 really start helping him until later on in life.

6 So at that point, he was like, Oh, by the way,

7 you know, your -- your dad is -- he's -- because my dad

8 was -- he didn't really like to ask for help because,

9 you know, being -- being a man, I guess, being -- having

10 a little bit of pride, trying to do things by himself.

11 But he had actually reached out to Musi and my

12 grandfather for help, for them to help him get better,

13 get established, get a better life, so...

14 Q. Do you remember when that was?

15 A. I'm not sure.

16 Q. When your grandfather told you that he had

17 asked for help, did you then get involved too?

18 A. He asked me if I wanted to see him, and I said

19 yes. But I needed a little bit of time, because to

20 rekindle the relationship, it's like, where do you go

21 from there? But I did.

22 I mean, I wanted -- I wanted some of those

23 moments back, you know? Like, even -- even with me

24 getting married, I -- I remember being in the groom's --

25 the groomsmen room and putting on my tux, and I'm, you

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

55

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 know, getting ready to walk out, and I remember thinking

2 about moments like, This is supposed to be a happy day.

3 But I didn't want to make it about that, but I

4 wish he would have been there, you know. There was --

5 there was a -- plenty of times that I wanted to -- to

6 see my dad again.

7 I remember wanting to show him the results of

8 me becoming a man. Even though sometimes he wasn't

9 there, his presence was still there.

10 With me getting into college, with me getting

11 into high school, with me completing it. I wanted him

12 to be at those moments, so...

13 So I -- I kind of regret not immediately

14 jumping at the chance to -- to -- to reconnect, but I --

15 I was trying to build up the courage. I had some

16 conflicting emotions, you know?

17 Q. Uh-huh.

18 A. So...

19 Q. When was the last time that you saw your dad?

20 A. I think it was -- I was 16. And then after

21 that -- yeah -- seeing him at the funeral, so...

22 Q. And I know this is difficult, so if you want

23 to take another break, we can.

24 A. No. It's okay. I mean, we got to do this.

25 It's -- it's just -- it's not something that I open up

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

56

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 about. It's not something I like to talk to people

2 about, but because of the circumstances, I know you got

3 to address it, so...

4 Q. And -- and you understand why we're here

5 today?

6 A. Yeah.

7 Q. And that's based on a lawsuit that was filed

8 against the City of Phoenix --

9 A. Uh-huh.

10 Q. -- and against ten police officers and an

11 employee.

12 A. Uh-huh.

13 Q. And your aunt, Mussalina, is the personal

14 representative of your dad's estate, correct?

15 A. Yes.

16 Q. Is that your understanding?

17 And she has filed this lawsuit. And you are a

18 statutory beneficiary to his estate. Do you understand

19 that?

20 A. Yes.

21 Q. With regard to your aunt, you call her Musi?

22 A. Yeah. That's her -- her nickname around the

23 family.

24 Q. Okay. So I have a better idea of your -- your

25 central family here in Arizona, you have Mussalina --

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

57

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

Uh-huh. 

or Musi? 

Uh-huh. 

Zarinah? 

Yes . 

And how often do you see the two of them? or 

how often did you see them before you moved to Georgia? 

Let me start there . 

A. I -- I would see them -- well, to be honest 

with you, I would see them a lot of times that I would 

go spend time with my dad and my grandfather. And then 

kind of after my grandfather ' s passing, I started to see 

them less. 

And then after -- as -- as I got older, I --

we would still text or call or message, stuff like that . 

But I didn't get a chance to -- to see them as much. 

Q. When had you met your half sister, •• ? 

A. A 

Q. ••■ Thank you . 

Had you met her prior to your dad's death? 

A. Yes . I remember holding her when she was 

young, like, when she was, like, just born, so -- yeah . 

I -- I remember seeing her a couple of times . I mean, I 

would like to have seen her more, but because I'm --

growing up a little closer to my mom ' s side of the 
1 family, didn't really get the chance to.

2 Q. How often do you think you saw her? Or can

3 you recall?

4 A. I don't remember.

5 Q. Now, my understanding is that she was placed

6 in foster care --

7 A. Yeah.

8 Q. -- a little after a year old?

9 A. Yeah. Her mom was not the best parent, not

10 the -- the fittest parent. And so I know that they had

11 to have a custody battle and all that stuff, because her

12 mom wasn't a very good example or a very good role

13 model. And my Auntie Pooch and my -- that's her nick --

14 her name as well, around the family. But her --

15 Q. Which -- which aunt?

16 A. Her -- well, we just -- we just call her

17 Aunt -- Auntie Pooch.

18 Q. Who is Auntie Pooch?

19 A. She's -- how do I say this? She is somebody

20 that's always been around the family as well. And she

21 was raised with my father, Mussalina, Zarinah. So I

22 remember a lot of the time, my Aunt Mussalina and Pooch

23 would also be looking after my sister.

24 MR. CHAMI: Is that Tonya Davis?

25 THE WITNESS: Yeah. To -- I -- to be

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

59

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 honest -- I -- because she always goes by -- I --

2 I'd have to -- yeah.

3 BY MS. STILLWELL:

4 Q. Do you know what her name is?

5 A. I don't remember right now because that's just

6 what she's always gone by. That's always been her

7 nickname.

8 Q. You -- you don't know your Auntie Pooch's real

9 name?

10 A. No. Because a lot of times that -- you know,

11 that's just how it's always been. She's -- yeah.

12 Q. Do you know how old she is? Could you guess?

13 A. Like around her 40s.

14 Q. Now, when -- when your half sister went into

15 foster care, she did not live with your aunt, correct?

16 A. I'm not sure.

17 Q. Had you seen her -- strike that.

18 You first saw her after she was born, correct?

19 A. Yeah. Like, I seen her when she was, like, a

20 few months old, like -- so yeah.

21 Q. And then when was the next time you saw her?

22 A. I'm not -- I'm not sure. Maybe, like, two,

23 maybe.

24 Q. Do you remember the circumstances under which

25 you would have seen her when she was two?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

60

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Well, I mean, a lot of the time I only seen

2 her when -- when my dad was there. So he would bring me

3 over, or -- well, I remember him introducing her to

4 me -- because she was young, a few months old. And I

5 held her, spent the night with -- with my dad, and spent

6 time with her, my sister's mom, my sister and my dad,

7 you know, trying to grow that relationship.

8 And then the next time I seen her, she was a

9 little bit older. Maybe like two. And then -- yeah...

10 Q. And then what about after that?

11 A. I hadn't seen her that many times after that

12 because it was kind of hard. Her -- her -- her mom,

13 like I said, wasn't, like, the best role model, so I

14 know she was moving around. She was having a hard time

15 with stuff.

16 Q. Uh-huh.

17 A. She was having a hard time with getting

18 stable, so...

19 Q. So as far as you know, she was still in foster

20 care at that point?

21 A. Yeah. I'm not -- I'm not sure. I do know

22 that after being in foster care, she went to live with

23 my Aunt Musi -- or Mussalina. Sorry.

24 Q. And that -- that was recent, though, correct?

25 A. Yeah.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

61

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Is she still living with her?

2 A. Yes.

3 Q. And so does she pop back and forth between

4 Georgia and Arizona? Do you know?

5 A. No. So to -- to kind of clarify, Musi has

6 been in Arizona, but Zarinah has been back and forth

7 between Georgia and -- and Arizona. Because my Aunt

8 Musi -- or Mussalina moved back to Arizona to help my

9 dad, really. Because he was trying to get better, so...

10 Q. But that was three years ago, right?

11 A. Yeah. And -- yeah.

12 Q. So...

13 A. And I guess she just also stayed behind and

14 helped try to take care of my sister.

15 Q. And what you testified earlier was that you

16 were trying to visit with her while she's out here,

17 with -- you were trying to visit with Mussalina while

18 she was out here in Georgia?

19 MR. CHAMI: Objection, mischaracter- --

20 MS. STILLWELL: And you saw -- I'm sorry. Go

21 ahead.

22 BY MS. STILLWELL:

23 Q. And you saw her more frequently in Georgia

24 than you did in Arizona?

25 A. I seen who more frequently?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

62

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Mussalina.

2 A. In Arizona?

3 Q. No. In Georgia.

4 MR. CHAMI: Objection. That mischaracterizes

5 his prior testimony.

6 BY MS. STILLWELL:

7 Q. Is that accurate?

8 A. Okay. So to clarify, because I'm not sure

9 what you're asking. Mussalina is in Arizona along with

10 my sister and Zarinah has moved back and forth between

11 Arizona and Georgia. And any of the times that I seen

12 Mussalina was in Arizona. I had never seen Mussalina

13 here in Georgia.

14 But meanwhile, we would still call or text or

15 message, see how each other were doing.

16 But the last time that I seen them is when

17 they came to the wedding.

18 Q. Thank you.

19 A. Uh-huh.

20 Q. And you said Mussalina and Zarinah...

21 A. They're -- they're close.

22 Q. They're close?

23 A. Yeah.

24 Q. So you said they're all three usually

25 together?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

63

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Yeah. Usually when I see them, yeah. Because

2 Mussalina is kind of like a mother figure to a couple

3 different family members, my sister being one of them,

4 and then Zarinah being another. But she's kind of just

5 looked at as like a mother figure.

6 Q. Okay. But Zarinah doesn't have any biological

7 connection to you, correct? As far as you know?

8 A. To be honest, it gets kind of hard, because I

9 asked about our connection, because they were always

10 there, but they didn't really explain it until around

11 the -- the funeral.

12 Because I didn't-- I didn't really want to

13 ask, because I didn't -- you know, I was a kid. You

14 know, I didn't want to be disrespectful.

15 But -- no. I think -- I think Zarinah --

16 yeah. I don't think she has a biological connection to

17 me, now that I think about it.

18 Q. So what did you learn about the relationship

19 at the funeral?

20 A. Well, it's confusing, because I -- I'd

21 actually have to ask, because -- because I know -- let

22 me think. Hold on.

23 I just know that -- that Mussalina has always

24 raised Zarinah or always been around with her, really.

25 Q. Now, Mussalina, as far as you remember, had

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

64

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 she always been in Arizona, or did she move out here in

2 Georgia too?

3 A. The only times I remember seeing her was being

4 in Arizona.

5 Q. Okay. Did you ever live with her?

6 A. No.

7 Q. Did you have a -- a good relationship with her

8 prior to your dad's death?

9 A. I mean, it was good. She was always

10 respectful. She was always welcoming, always kind,

11 always caring. I didn't see her as much as I'd liked

12 to, because to be honest with you, my father and my

13 grandfather were like the gateway to that side of the

14 family, so...

15 After my grandfather's passing, I seen them

16 less. And then because of some complications with my

17 father, I seen them less as well as I got older, so...

18 Q. And the complications with your father, you're

19 talking about the -- kind of the breakdown in

20 relationship between you and your dad?

21 A. Yeah.

22 Q. Do you have -- but you saw Mussalina at

23 Christmas or -- not Christmas. I'm sorry. Any holidays

24 or birthdays or celebrations?

25 A. I would see her, like, big gatherings, when I

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

65

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 would visit my dad's side of the family.

2 Q. Okay. And do you have any pictures for those

3 big gatherings?

4 A. The last one is the wedding. The time before

5 that -- I could look and try and find some.

6 Q. Okay.

7 A. But...

8 Q. Do you have any pictures of you and your dad?

9 A. Yes.

10 Q. And do you remember the -- the last picture

11 you have?

12 A. I have a book of pictures of my dad. So I

13 mean, I'd have to look in -- in the book. If you need

14 it, I could bring it.

15 Q. Okay. And I'll talk to Mr. Chami about that

16 later.

17 What about when you saw your half sister when

18 she was a few months old and again at two, do you have

19 any pictures with her?

20 A. No. Because they didn't really take pictures

21 back then, to be honest.

22 Q. That was before the cell phone photos were

23 really --

24 A. Yeah.

25 Q. -- popular?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

66

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Yeah. That was -- I mean, that was, like,

2 back in the day when people had flip phones or like --

3 you know, it was -- yeah.

4 MR. CHAMI: Ancient times?

5 THE WITNESS: Yeah.

6 BY MS. STILLWELL:

7 Q. So -- give me one second.

8 Okay. I want to talk a little bit more about

9 your relationship with your dad.

10 A. Okay.

11 Q. You indicated that he and your grandfather and

12 you all did the -- the soft martial arts.

13 A. Yes.

14 Q. I'm going back so I can remember the name of

15 it.

16 A. Aikodo.

17 Q. Thank you.

18 And that was the only martial arts that your

19 dad and your grandfather studied; is that correct?

20 A. That's the only one that they practiced with

21 me. That's the only one I -- I remember them ever

22 doing.

23 Q. So would it be possible, though, that they

24 would have practiced other forms of martial arts without

25 you around --

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

67

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 MR. CHAMI: Objection.

2 BY MS. STILLWELL:

3 Q. -- given your age?

4 MR. CHAMI: Objection. Calls for speculation,

5 lacks foundation.

6 You can answer, if you can.

7 THE WITNESS: I only remember them doing

8 Aikodo.

9 BY MS. STILLWELL:

10 Q. Do you recall if -- what level of education

11 your dad had?

12 A. No.

13 Q. Do you recall whether he was employed during

14 your earlier years when you lived with him?

15 A. I don't remember.

16 Q. Do you recall whether he worked with your

17 grandfather teaching martial arts or karate?

18 A. You mean, like, would he go with him to

19 assist?

20 Q. Yeah. You said that he assisted.

21 A. Yeah.

22 Q. Was he also teaching?

23 A. More like assisting, to be honest. It was

24 more so --

25 Q. What do you mean by assisting?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

68

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Like, if my grandfather wanted to do a

2 demonstration, he would call him up front to do a

3 demonstration on him.

4 Q. So he would not be hands-on teaching children

5 or adults?

6 A. Not really. It was more so my grandfather.

7 Q. And you do not recall where your father worked

8 or if he worked or how he made a living?

9 A. I mean, it depends on what type of my -- what

10 period of --

11 Q. The time --

12 A. Yeah.

13 Q. -- that you lived with him?

14 A. Oh, no. I was -- no. I don't remember.

15 Q. You did not live with him for any length of

16 period after he and your mom broke up?

17 A. No.

18 Q. Okay. I assume then you would see him every

19 other week or something like --

20 A. Uh-huh.

21 Q. It would -- would it just be a visit?

22 A. Like, coming over and spending the night.

23 There would be a good amount of times where I would come

24 over to spend the night at my grandfather's house. My

25 dad was there too. There would be times where wherever

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

69

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 my dad was living, I would spend the night at his -- his

2 house or maybe for, like, the weekend, so...

3 Q. Okay. And when you say, you know, wherever

4 your dad was living -- because he had lived in a couple

5 different places --

6 A. Uh-huh.

7 Q. -- right?

8 So if he -- I think Tonya Thompson was one of

9 his ex-girlfriends. Do you remember her?

10 A. Yes.

11 Q. And so if you visited your dad, would you have

12 stayed at the residence that he shared with Tonya?

13 A. Yes.

14 Q. Are you familiar with your dad's criminal

15 background?

16 A. Not too much.

17 Q. Are you aware that he was arrested for

18 aggravated assault on a police officer and resisting

19 arrest in the late '90s?

20 A. No. I -- I didn't know that.

21 Q. He was living with Antonie Sweeney in the late

22 '90s. Do you remember who she is?

23 A. I don't remember.

24 Q. Do you know whether he had a child with

25 Ms. Sweeney?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

70

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

A. The only child I know about is my sister. 

Q. In the late '90s, you said that, you know, at 

four or five, your parents had broken up. So that would 

have taken you to about 1997 or '98. 

Would you recall whether you stayed at 

Ms . Sweeney's home? 

A. I'm not sure who Ms . Sweeney is. 

Q. Okay. 

A. I mean, I'd have to see a picture or 

something . I don ' t . .. 

Q. Your half sister's mom is Muslim- -- Muslimah? 

A. Yeah. 

Q. Is that right? 

A. 

Q. 

A. 

Q. 

Yeah. It gets confusing . 

And her last name is Shaheed? 

I'm not sure. 

Are you aware that there was another domestic 

violence incident with her, with A 's mom, in 2005? 

A. No . 

Q. When she was pregnant with your sister? 

A. No . I was unaware or don't remember . 

Q. And at that time and later on, your -- your 

dad was living with Tonya Thompson . You remember 

Ms . Thompson, correct? 

A. Uh-huh. 
1 Q. And do you recall staying the night at her

2 house?

3 A. Yeah.

4 Q. And you recall that Ms. Thompson had other

5 children, correct?

6 A. Yes.

7 Q. And she had a few children, right?

8 A. Uh-huh.

9 Q. Did you have any kind of a relationship with

10 Ms. Thompson?

11 A. No.

12 Q. Was she kind to you? Did you have any issues

13 with her?

14 A. I didn't really spend time with her --

15 Q. Okay.

16 A. -- you know, so...

17 Q. So when you'd stay a night or a weekend at her

18 home, it was more with your dad and with the other kids?

19 A. Yeah. I mean -- well -- yeah. Most of the

20 time, it was with my dad, though.

21 Q. In 2007, your -- your dad was arrested again

22 for a domestic violence incident where he allegedly

23 punched Ms. Thompson.

24 Were you present for that incident?

25 A. No.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

72

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Are you aware of that incident?

2 A. No.

3 Q. There were quite a few instances, actually, of

4 assault/domestic violence between your dad and

5 Ms. Thompson.

6 Do you recall any of those incidents?

7 A. No. Not -- not while I was around. I never

8 experienced anything or seen anything like that.

9 Q. Are you aware of any of them?

10 A. No.

11 Q. Were you aware of any of the domestic violence

12 charges or assault charges or convictions against your

13 dad?

14 A. No.

15 Q. Now, it seems that your dad moved out of

16 Ms. Thompson's residence in 2008. 2008, you would have

17 been around 15, correct?

18 A. Okay. Yeah. Okay.

19 Q. Did you still have a relationship with your

20 father at that time?

21 A. Yeah. You said -- in what -- in what year?

22 Q. 2008.

23 A. 2008. Yeah.

24 Q. So you still saw him --

25 A. Every so often.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

73

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. And when you say every so often, how often

2 would that be?

3 A. At that time, maybe once a month, once every

4 couple of months.

5 Q. Okay. After he moved out of Ms. Thompson's

6 house, there was another incident where he had a samurai

7 sword and made several threats and assaults against

8 Ms. Thompson, and I believe it was her sister.

9 Are you aware of that incident?

10 MR. CHAMI: Object to the question as it lacks

11 foundation, calls for speculation and assumes facts

12 not in evidence.

13 MS. STILLWELL: I'm asking if he's aware.

14 BY MS. STILLWELL:

15 Q. Are you aware of that incident?

16 A. I don't remember.

17 Q. Do you recall whether your father had a

18 samurai sword?

19 A. No.

20 Q. She expressed concerns to the officers because

21 of --

22 MR. CHAMI: He's already said he's not even

23 aware of it. What -- what are we doing?

24 MS. STILLWELL: Let me -- let me get to my

25 next question.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

74

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 MR. CHAMI: Okay.

2 BY MS. STILLWELL:

3 Q. She expressed concern to the officers because

4 of his samurai sword and because of his martial arts

5 experience.

6 Did you ever share that concern about your

7 father's martial arts experience?

8 A. What do you mean, share concern?

9 Q. Did you ever have a concern or fear of your

10 father?

11 A. No.

12 Q. Because of his martial arts?

13 A. No.

14 Q. Did your father -- do you recall or know

15 whether he had a history of cage fighting?

16 A. No.

17 Q. Now, there were several other charges of

18 resisting arrest or running from officers involving your

19 father.

20 October 2000 -- or I'm sorry. October 1998,

21 he was combative and punching officers.

22 Are you aware of that instance?

23 A. I mean, '98, I was -- I was born in '93. So

24 how old was I, like five? Like -- no, I'm not -- no.

25 Q. In 2008, when you would have been 15, there

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

75

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 was an incident where your dad took off on a bicycle and

2 ran from officers through backyards refusing to stop.

3 Are you aware of that?

4 A. No.

5 Q. Four days later, Ms. Thompson called the

6 police on your father again, and she indicated to the

7 officers that she believes your father would fight with

8 them because he has former karate experience.

9 Number one, are you familiar with that

10 incident?

11 A. No.

12 Q. Number two, do you have -- or are you aware

13 whether your father had karate experience?

14 A. I'm unaware.

15 Q. Do you know whether your father had any other

16 martial arts training other than Aikodo?

17 A. The Aikodo? Uh-huh.

18 MR. CHAMI: Asked and answered.

19 THE WITNESS: I -- I'm only aware of him

20 practicing Aikodo. I don't -- I don't remember him

21 like that, as -- as -- well, when he was around me,

22 you know, if any -- if anything, I remember him

23 being -- trying to teach me patience, trying to

24 teach me about being spiritual, trying to teach me

25 about discipline.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

76

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 So -- so the -- the martial art thing was more

2 so -- and also, I -- like, I had really, really bad

3 asthma growing up. So he was teaching me that to

4 control my breath to help me with breathing, to

5 help me with -- to fighting asthma, the disease.

6 You know, and -- and then he would also teach

7 me the principles that martial arts taught. Not so

8 I -- anytime we did that, it was -- it was more for

9 -- for that type of foundation.

10 BY MS. STILLWELL:

11 Q. And to address Mr. Chami's objection, I was

12 asking what he had training in, not what he practiced.

13 You had already testified --

14 A. Yes. Just the Aikodo, that's the only thing.

15 Q. -- what he practiced around -- you had already

16 testified what he had practiced around you.

17 A. Uh-huh.

18 Q. And you don't know what he practiced when he

19 wasn't around you.

20 But my question was, do you know of any other

21 training that he may have had?

22 A. Just that, just the Aikodo.

23 Q. And -- and I'm just going to run through

24 these, and tell me if one of them -- if you know of one

25 of them.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

77

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 In July 2009, your dad ran from officers and

2 resisted arrest by pulling from officers.

3 In November 2009, resisted arrest with

4 physical force and unlawful flight.

5 In 2010, he was charged with aggravated

6 assault and resisting officers. He grabbed officers,

7 tensed up, struggled and pulled away.

8 Are you aware of any of those instances?

9 A. No. I only know about him going to jail, but

10 I didn't know why. I mean, nobody really told me.

11 Q. So he was sentenced to the Department of

12 Corrections. Is that what you're referring to?

13 A. Yes, I believe so.

14 Q. He was sentenced there for a year and a half

15 in May of 2011. So you would have been 18?

16 A. Okay.

17 Q. And that was around the time you weren't

18 speaking with your father, correct?

19 A. Uh-huh.

20 Q. And is this one of the influences? You said

21 that you had -- there were concerns or other issues that

22 caused you not to have a relationship with your father.

23 Was that part of it, the criminal background or the

24 criminal history?

25 A. No. I didn't really consider -- are you

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

78

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 asking, like, did I not want to see him because I was

2 worried about --

3 Q. Because he was in prison.

4 A. Oh, yeah. I mean, I didn't see him because he

5 was in prison, yeah. And then I had heard that he got

6 out.

7 Q. And so he got out in January 2012.

8 In May 2012, there was another aggravated

9 assault against officers and resisting arrest incident

10 where he took off after shoplifting, turned and faced an

11 officer with fighting stance and a citizen had to help

12 the officer detain him.

13 Do you have any knowledge of that instance?

14 A. No.

15 Q. He -- your dad went back to prison again from

16 July to December 2012.

17 You never visited him at DOC, right?

18 A. Uh-uh.

19 Q. Were you aware that he had gone back in?

20 A. I had heard about it.

21 Q. And did you talk to him before or after he was

22 sentenced or served the time in DOC?

23 A. No. I remember -- I think it was the last

24 time that I had spoken to him was when I was around,

25 like, 16.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

79

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. Okay.

2 A. And then after that -- because a few years

3 down the line, to be honest, I became busy. I mean, I

4 graduated from high school. I had scouted out several

5 different colleges. And then I finally went to Arizona

6 State and graduated from there, and I was trying to

7 finish doing that.

8 And then at the same time, later on, getting a

9 full-time job while doing full time in schooling.

10 So it became a point to where I did want to

11 see him at certain moments, but I heard that he was in

12 prison, or -- yeah. Then he -- then he would get out,

13 and then I'd have to find out where he was.

14 I didn't really know where he was. It's

15 not -- I didn't know, like, his cell phone number or

16 anything. But then I had heard about -- then my

17 grandfather Daniel had told me about him getting out and

18 if I wanted to visit him later on. And -- and I said

19 yeah, but...

20 Q. And so -- I'm trying to figure out when that

21 conversation with -- with Daniel, with your grandfather,

22 would have occurred. Because your -- your dad had

23 another drug offense in 2013, and he was sentenced to

24 prison from July 2013 through April 2015.

25 So you think the conversation with your

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

80

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 grandfather would have been 2015/2016?

2 A. I'm not sure of what -- how old I was. I just

3 remember having that conversation.

4 Q. Oh, no, no, 2015-2016 years, whether that

5 would have been when your -- your grandfather was

6 helping your dad, when he got out of prison the most

7 recent time.

8 A. I don't know how long he was helping him.

9 Q. Are you -- are you aware at all that your dad

10 had been arrested at least 24 times?

11 A. I don't remember.

12 Q. Or that he had four separate prison stays?

13 MR. CHAMI: Object to form.

14 THE WITNESS: I -- I don't -- I don't

15 remember.

16 BY MS. STILLWELL:

17 Q. And you testified earlier that you had not

18 seen your dad since you were 16, correct?

19 A. Around that time. I'm -- I'm guessing. But I

20 think it was around that time.

21 Q. So that would have been 2009 -- right? -- ish?

22 Give or take?

23 A. Could be around that time.

24 Q. You mentioned the discussion with your

25 grandfather about how -- him helping. Were you aware

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

81

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 that your dad was homeless?

2 A. No. Not until recently or around the time of

3 his passing. I -- I didn't know that.

4 Q. Your grandfather didn't share that with you?

5 A. When -- at what time would that -- are you

6 saying he was homeless?

7 Q. Do you know how long he had been homeless?

8 A. No. Because it was -- like I said earlier, it

9 was kind of hard trying to keep in contact with him,

10 with him in and out of prison a couple of times, so...

11 Q. So it wouldn't surprise you if he had various

12 stints of homelessness between those prison stays?

13 A. I only knew about him being homeless before he

14 passed because -- but before that, anytime I had visited

15 him or spent time with him, a lot of the time, he was --

16 he would live with my grandfather, because he had a room

17 there. Or he would be -- I'd be spending the night with

18 him and his girlfriend at the time.

19 Q. Well, that was 2009, right? Because that was

20 the last time you had seen your dad?

21 A. Yeah. The -- the last time I seen him, he

22 came over to my grandparents' -- my grandparents' house.

23 Q. Okay.

24 A. The last couple of times.

25 Q. Okay. In 2009-ish?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

82

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Around that time, I guess.

2 Q. Were you aware of or did you participate in

3 any efforts to help your father out of the homelessness?

4 A. Are you asking if I tried to help my father

5 out of homelessness when I was, like, 15?

6 Q. No, no, no, no, no. In the most recent years.

7 A. In --

8 Q. In 2016, you mentioned Mussalina had moved

9 back here?

10 A. Yeah, yeah. So not at the time, but that was

11 because -- I wasn't really sure of his situation. Like

12 I said, I hadn't seen him so long that the -- what I

13 would hear about him would be through my family. For

14 example, like, my -- my grandfather or -- I was -- I was

15 confused about his situation.

16 Q. Uh-huh.

17 A. So it would be when I would be ready to visit

18 him or -- or try to visit him or try to get ahold of

19 him, it was kind of hard to track him down sometimes.

20 And then as I got older, I was trying to focus

21 on my situation in life, finishing high school,

22 finishing college, getting a job, getting married, stuff

23 like that.

24 Q. And you mentioned earlier, your dad and your

25 grandfather were kind of like the gatekeeper to your

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

83

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 relationship with Mussalina and Zarinah.

2 A. A lot of the time.

3 Q. So after your grandpa had passed away, had you

4 had any communications with Mussalina?

5 A. Sometimes, but --

6 Q. Like by text or a phone call?

7 A. Yeah. It wasn't common all the time. If

8 anything, I just remember, like I said, like, big family

9 gatherings, stuff like that.

10 Q. And so you would still see her at big family

11 gatherings even though you weren't talking to your dad?

12 A. I'm -- I'm just thinking.

13 Yeah, yeah. There was a couple of times.

14 Q. Do you remember those years, or...

15 A. No.

16 Q. Did Mussalina contact you when she moved back

17 to Arizona in 2016?

18 A. I believe so.

19 Q. And do you remember that conversation?

20 A. No.

21 Q. Do you recall whether she asked for your

22 assistance in helping your dad?

23 A. No.

24 Q. Did she ask for your opinion or input?

25 A. No. Not that I remember.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

84

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Q. How did you learn about the incident on

2 January 4th, 2017, with your dad?

3 A. You mean how did I find out about him passing

4 away? Is that what you're asking?

5 Q. Yes, sir.

6 A. I was at work. I was -- I was working at

7 Humana at the time, and I remember -- I was at work. I

8 remember my mom calling me, and she was crying. And she

9 was like, Mu, are you okay? Are you okay?

10 And I was like, Mom, I'm just at -- I'm

11 sitting at a desk. I'm fine. What's wrong?

12 And, you know, she's -- she's bawling her eyes

13 out. And she's like, Well, I -- I have to tell you

14 something. You know, let me know as soon as you get off

15 work.

16 And I knew at that time that something was

17 wrong.

18 And she -- she was just like, I was so worried

19 about you. So -- so I'm glad that you're doing okay.

20 I'm glad that you're having a normal day. Let me know

21 when you get off work.

22 So I let her know. I call my mom, tell her I

23 get off work. I know something horrible has happened.

24 I drive home or go to my apartment. And my --

25 my mom and my stepfather come in. And they are like,

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

85

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Well, we have something to tell you.

2 Me, my wife, my stepfather and my mom are

3 there. And then they -- they told me the news. And you

4 know, we were crying. We were sad together.

5 And my mom was like -- she was like, I heard

6 that Muhammad had gotten hurt, and I wasn't sure which

7 one. So she's like -- she's like, I'm -- I'm really sad

8 about what happened to your father, but she's like, I am

9 glad that -- that you're okay.

10 And you know, that's -- at that time, that's

11 when I had found out that he passed away. And I -- I

12 was so frustrated, because I had felt like I had just

13 gotten myself somewhat established enough to build up

14 the courage to see him. I remember -- yeah.

15 That's not my phone. I don't know whose phone

16 that is.

17 Yeah -- so...

18 Q. Have you -- as -- as a statutory beneficiary

19 in this case, have you reviewed the complaint? Did you

20 review the complaint that was filed?

21 A. What complaint? You mean, like an actual

22 document, or --

23 Q. Yes, sir.

24 A. No, I haven't.

25 Q. Are you aware of or are you familiar with the

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

86

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 allegations that have been alleged in this case?

2 A. Some of them. The -- the information that was

3 told to me was more so what Mussalina had told me and my

4 other family members, so...

5 Q. Okay. When you say your other family members,

6 who -- who are you talking to -- or talking about?

7 A. To be honest with you, I don't know all of the

8 situation, because I know that they have a videotape of

9 it. And I know that they have some documents and some

10 recording. But I don't really want to watch it too

11 much, because that's hard.

12 I mean, it's -- it's -- I remember I was -- I

13 was Googling or YouTubing my name, and then he -- you

14 know, his video popped up on YouTube. And -- and I --

15 yeah. I just -- I haven't seen the video. I refuse to

16 watch it. I mean, I can't watch my father's last

17 breath. I can't watch up until leading to that moment.

18 It's too hard, so...

19 Q. Is that why you haven't read the complaint or

20 any of the documents or pleadings in this case?

21 A. Yeah. Because it's -- it's just hard.

22 Q. Have you reviewed the medical examiner report?

23 A. I've heard what other people have told me.

24 But no, I haven't directly reviewed it.

25 Q. And --

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

87

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Because -- I mean, it's hard to talk about.

2 It's hard -- I remember all of a sudden, I had to go to

3 sit down with the mortician and talk about how we're

4 going to -- what we're going to do with the body, bury

5 it, cremate it. Because he's Islamic, they have to bury

6 it within a certain amount of days.

7 But then we have to try and get the money for

8 that, but he didn't have life insurance.

9 Like, it was -- it was -- it was -- all of a

10 sudden, I hadn't talked to my dad in a while, and now

11 we're trying to figure out what to do with his body.

12 And then we're trying to figure out, you know, what he's

13 going to wear or what songs they are going to play at

14 the funeral or how much money we have to -- to -- to

15 respect him, to pay respects.

16 So, no. I mean, that was kind of traumatizing

17 to me.

18 And then the hard -- another hard part is the

19 fact that he looks so much like me. Seeing him -- you

20 know, going to the casket, I was -- I was just confused.

21 I was looking at him, and -- and we look so much alike,

22 it's like, This could have been me, you know?

23 I don't know. It was a lot. It was -- it was

24 too much for me to deal with it sometimes.

25 Q. Were you a part -- then, you were a part of

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

88

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 the funeral arrangements?

2 A. Yeah.

3 Q. Were you a part of the GoFundMe page that was

4 created so you could get funds to pay for it?

5 A. Yeah. Some -- some of it, yeah.

6 Q. Do you recall how much you guys were able to

7 earn through the GoFundMe?

8 A. I just remember that we didn't have enough to

9 do burial. We had enough to do cremation, and -- you

10 know, so...

11 Q. Do you -- what one of the allegations in the

12 Plaintiff's complaint or one of the damages that's being

13 sought is the cost for the funeral and burial.

14 Do you have any idea what the cost is?

15 A. No. Because it -- I mean, because we did the

16 GoFundMe, it had changed. But it wasn't -- it wasn't

17 enough. I mean, it was expensive trying to -- I --

18 well, I had never realized how expensive it was to

19 arrange a funeral.

20 Q. Do you -- do you remember if you had to pay

21 anything for it? Are you asking for recovery in this

22 lawsuit for what you had to pay for it?

23 A. Are you asking -- can you -- can you rephrase

24 that?

25 Q. Sure.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

89

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 One of the claims in the complaint is

2 demanding reimbursement for funeral and burial expenses.

3 I'm asking, are you asking for that?

4 MR. CHAMI: Object to the form.

5 THE WITNESS: To be honest with you, I haven't

6 really asked for anything, you know? This is -- it

7 was something that my aunt was taking care of or

8 that -- that she was handling. And -- but I -- I

9 haven't really asked for anything.

10 BY MS. STILLWELL:

11 Q. Did you want the lawsuit to be filed?

12 A. I wanted some type of justice for my father.

13 I mean, I didn't really know in which way, shape or form

14 that would take -- because it is intimidating filing --

15 filing a lawsuit on another person but let alone a

16 police department.

17 So it's kind of where do you go from there?

18 How do you -- how do you go about doing that?

19 So it's -- it's not something that I directly

20 asked for, but I wanted some type of justice.

21 Q. And this lawsuit has been filed against 10 --

22 11 individuals too. You realize that?

23 A. Say that again.

24 Q. The lawsuit was filed against 11 individuals

25 too.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

90

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Okay. Yes.

2 Q. There is another demand for medical fees and

3 expenses incurred in connection with your dad.

4 Are you aware of those fees and expenses?

5 A. No.

6 Q. Is that something that you're requesting in

7 the lawsuit?

8 A. If you're asking me what I want, to -- to

9 rephrase, to be honest, what I would want with -- is

10 time, time to get back with my father, time -- I would

11 want time back with him that I never got to show him all

12 the moments, from the day that he was passing until now,

13 of the things that I've accomplished, or, when I have

14 kids, his grandchildren.

15 I mean, there are people that are, like, 40

16 years old, and their parents are still alive, and their

17 grandparents are still alive. I mean, I think I was

18 like 24 when he passed. You know?

19 So I would want time back with him to be able

20 to rekindle that relationship, just when we were on the

21 verge to, if -- I mean, if I could have two things, it

22 would be the time back that was stolen and the people

23 who did this to him in prison.

24 I'm not really sure about the money or the

25 funds, but I would want justice with him -- for him

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

91

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 and -- and time back that I know I'm not going to get.

2 Q. Going back to the medical examiner's report --

3 and I -- I understand you haven't read it, and I

4 understand it is difficult to read. The -- the loss of

5 a parent is difficult under any circumstances.

6 Do you understand that your father's death was

7 caused by cardiac arrest in the setting of a coronary

8 artery disease, psychiatric disease, acute

9 methamphetamine intoxication and physical exertion?

10 MR. CHAMI: Objection. Calls for speculation,

11 lacks foundation.

12 MS. STILLWELL: Can I have this marked as

13 Exhibit 1, please? Thank you.

14 (Whereupon, Defendants' Exhibit No. 1 was

15 marked for identification.)

16 MR. CHAMI: It also calls for -- oh, go ahead.

17 I'll wait until you're done.

18 MS. STILLWELL: Go ahead.

19 MR. CHAMI: I don't need it.

20 MS. STILLWELL: I have a copy for you.

21 MR. CHAMI: Sure.

22 Also calls for expert testimony.

23 MS. STILLWELL: Can I ask the question first?

24 MR. CHAMI: Didn't you already ask it?

25 MS. STILLWELL: No.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

92

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 MR. CHAMI: I'm continuing my prior

2 objection --

3 BY MS. STILLWELL:

4 Q. Sir, you have in front of you what's been

5 marked Exhibit 1, correct?

6 A. Yes.

7 Q. And on the front page, you see medical

8 examiner report, correct?

9 A. Yes.

10 Q. Date of examination, 1/5/2017?

11 A. Yes.

12 Q. And the name of the decedent, that is your

13 father's name, correct?

14 A. Yes.

15 Q. And you see underneath -- I'm not asking you

16 to make any opinions; I'm asking for the accuracy.

17 The cause of death: Cardiac arrest in the

18 setting of coronary artery disease, psychiatric disease,

19 acute methamphetamine intoxication and physical exertion

20 during law enforcement's subdual.

21 Did I read that accurately?

22 A. Yes.

23 Q. I'm going to hand you what's going to be

24 marked as Exhibit Number 2.

25 A. But then below that it says, Manner of death:

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

93

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 Homicide.

2 Q. And below that, where it says, Manner of

3 death: Homicide, do you know what that classification

4 means?

5 A. When somebody else is killed.

6 Q. Do you know what that classification means as

7 a medical examiner? Are you a medical examiner, sir?

8 A. No.

9 Q. In terms of manner of death, as classified by

10 a medical examiner, you're not here to testify about

11 that, are you, sir?

12 A. No.

13 Q. What you have in front of you is Exhibit

14 Number 2.

15 (Whereupon, Defendants' Exhibit No. 2 was

16 marked for identification.)

17 BY MS. STILLWELL:

18 Q. It's the toxicology report.

19 Same thing, date of exam, January 5th, 2017.

20 Did I read that correct?

21 A. You said January 5th, 2017?

22 Q. Yes.

23 A. Yes.

24 Q. And the name of the decedent is your dad,

25 correct?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

94

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. Yes.

2 Q. And you see in there that in the blood sample,

3 Positive for methamphetamine and amphetamine, correct?

4 A. Yes.

5 Q. Now, as a beneficiary, are you telling me,

6 sir, that you do not seek to recover any monetary

7 damages from the Defendants?

8 MR. CHAMI: Objection; calls for

9 attorney-client privilege and communications.

10 THE WITNESS: I mean --

11 MR. CHAMI: Don't disclose anything that we've

12 talked about.

13 BY MS. STILLWELL:

14 Q. I'm asking what you are asking for, sir.

15 MR. CHAMI: He's not a Plaintiff in the case.

16 MS. STILLWELL: He is a statutory beneficiary

17 who stands to recover from anything that is

18 awarded, if anything.

19 THE WITNESS: What's your -- could you

20 rephrase the question?

21 BY MS. STILLWELL:

22 Q. Sure.

23 What monetary damages -- I'm sorry. Strike

24 that.

25 Earlier, you said that you were not requesting

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

95

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 monetary damages. Did I understand that correctly?

2 A. What I was saying is that if I could choose --

3 if I could choose to have the police officers who did

4 this in jail or in prison over money, I would choose

5 that anytime. If I could choose to get time back with

6 my father, I would choose that over money, if that's

7 what you're asking me.

8 Q. And, sir, you're making that choice, you

9 haven't read any of the complaints, correct?

10 A. (No response.)

11 Q. Correct?

12 A. I haven't read any -- any of them officially,

13 no.

14 Q. You haven't read any of the depositions,

15 correct?

16 A. Yes.

17 Q. You haven't read any of the reports that have

18 been disclosed, correct?

19 A. No. Because after doing the funeral, I mean,

20 I was -- I was just traumatized.

21 Q. And it is understandably hard to lose a

22 parent.

23 But in this instance, you have not reviewed

24 the use of force report or the PSD investigation,

25 correct?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

96

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. No. I mean -- no.

2 Q. So your conclusion about the police officers

3 is based off of what other people have told you; is that

4 correct?

5 A. Yes. Because, I mean, it's -- it's

6 traumatizing to know that I can just go on YouTube and

7 click and watch the whole video of the final moments

8 that my dad died. Or -- yeah. I -- I could have access

9 to go read the reports, but I think if -- it -- anybody

10 would be understanding why I wouldn't -- they wouldn't

11 want to read that.

12 Q. Well -- and -- and my question, sir, is your

13 conclusion of -- of what you're demanding in this

14 lawsuit is based off of what other people told you,

15 correct?

16 A. Yes.

17 Q. I have -- I have one last very off-the-wall

18 question.

19 Do you know about your dog's -- your dad's

20 dog, Chiquita?

21 A. The chihuahua?

22 Q. Yes.

23 A. Yes. I know about it.

24 Q. Is it true that you were asked to take the dog

25 and you didn't want to take it?

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

97

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
1 A. No. I don't remember -- I -- I don't remember

2 having that conversation with anyone.

3 Q. Do you recall having a conversation with

4 anyone about Chiquita?

5 A. They told me that he did have a dog and

6 that -- that he was really close to it, because, I mean,

7 he owned the dog and -- but that was it.

8 Q. And -- and you didn't have -- you never met

9 the dog?

10 A. No.

11 Q. Okay. And you weren't, according to you,

12 asked to take the dog, correct?

13 A. I don't remember anybody asking me that.

14 Q. Okay. Okay.

15 MS. STILLWELL: I have no further questions.

16 MR. CHAMI: I don't have any questions.

17 MS. STILLWELL: You want him to read and sign?

18 MR. CHAMI: Yeah. We'll read and sign. You

19 can send the transcript to my office.

20 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This concludes this

21 videotaped deposition. The time is 12:29 p.m., and

22 we're off the record.

23 (Whereupon, the proceedings were concluded at

24 12:29 p.m.)

25

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

98

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
Janice S. Baker & Associates, Inc.

JOB ID: 2089

CASE CAPTION: Mussalina Muhaymin vs. City of Phoenix

 DECLARATION UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY

I declare under penalty of perjury that I have read the

entire transcript of my deposition taken in the

above-captioned matter or the same has been read to me

and the same is true and accurate, save and except for

changes and/or corrections, if any, as indicated by me

on the Janice S. Baker & Associates, Inc., Errata Sheet

hereof, with the understanding that I offer these

changes as if still under oath.

Signed on the ______ day of _________,

20____.

SIGNATURE:____________________________ DATE:____________

 MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

99

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 DEPOSITION ERRATA SHEET

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

SIGNATURE:____________________________ DATE:____________

 MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

100

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 DEPOSITION ERRATA SHEET

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

Page No._______Line No._______Change to: _______________

________________________________________________________

Reason for change:______________________________________

SIGNATURE:____________________________ DATE:____________

 MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

101

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 D I S C L O S U R E

 Pursuant to Article 8.B of the Rules and

Regulations of the Board of Court Reporting of the

Judicial Council of Georgia, I make the following

disclosure:

 I am a Georgia Certified Court Reporter. I am

here as an independent contractor of Janice S. Baker &

Associates, Inc. The firm was contacted by Esquire

Deposition Solutions to provide court reporting services

for this deposition. I am not disqualified for a

relationship of interest under the provisions of

O.C.G.A. § 9-11-28 (c).

 Janice S. Baker & Associates, Inc., will not

be taking this deposition under any contract that is

prohibited by O.C.G.A. § 15-14-37 (a) and (b).

 Janice S. Baker & Associates, Inc., does not

have a contract to provide reporting services with any

party to the case, any counsel in the case, or any

reporter or reporting agency from whom a referral might

have been made to cover this deposition. Janice S.

Baker & Associates, Inc., will charge its usual and

customary rate to all parties in the case.

 CRYSTAL BRUMBELOW

CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER

GA Cert# 4896-5849-1967-8976

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

102

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
 C E R T I F I C A T E

STATE OF GEORGIA )

COUNTY OF PAULDING)

 I hereby certify that the foregoing transcript was

taken down, as stated in the caption, and the questions

and answers thereto were reduced to typewritten form

under my direction; that the foregoing pages represent a

true and correct transcript of the evidence given upon

said hearing.

 And I further certify that I am not related to said

parties or counsel of said parties in the case; am not

in the regular employ of counsel for any of said

parties; nor am I in any way interested in the result of

said case.

 This, the 6th day of January, 2020.

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

103

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN December 06, 2019 

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX Index: 1 .. actors 

71:4 46: 14 39:7,11 5:2,6 

1 1998 53:11 5:00 49:13,16 

75:20 80:24 45:16 abilities 

1 2015-2016 5th 11:5 

5:3 81:4 94:19,21 ability 92:13,14 2 

2015/2016 10:7,11, 93:5 81:1 14 

1/5/2017 

2 6 

93:24 2016 accepted 93:10 94:14,15 83:8 47:11 6:00 

10 2000 84:17 45:18 access 

90:21 75:20 2017 97:8 6th 10:20 2005 46:19 5:5 22:5 accompany 5:2,6 71:18 85:2 24:9 

11 94:19,21 

2006 2018 7 accomplishe 90:22,24 33:23 d 

11:11 23:4 91:13 2007 49:22 7:00 

49:13 72:21 45:15 2019 accuracy 

11:27 93:16 2008 5:5 23:5 49:16 73:16,22, accurate 24 8 

12:29 23 75:25 63:7 

98:21,24 81:10 

2009 91:18 83 accurately 

14 78:1,3 11:10 7:15,17 

29:10 81:21 11:1 

82:19 3 93:21 15 9 

29:10 2009-ish acted 

49:12 82:25 30th 48:21,24 11:9 90s 73:17 2010 70:19,22 acting 75:25 78:5 71:2 11:20 

83:5 4 12:6,8,19 2011 93 16 43:19 11:10,11 14:4 

48:7,9 53:11 40 75:23 17:8,23 

54:4 78:15 91:15 19:7,10, 

56:20 40s 98 11 

79:25 2012 71:4 

79:7,8,16 60: 13 75:23 acting/ 81:18 

4th stuntmen 

18 2013 9:00 17:19 

80:23,24 85:2 

78:15 45:16 action 

1993 2014 20:24 

11:9 46:14 5 A 21:9 

1997 2015 actors 

43:19 50 

a.m. 

@ ESQQ!J}J;~ 800.211.DEPO (3376) 

EsquireSolutions. com 
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 21:8

acts

 31:3

actual

 18:11

 86:21

acute

 92:8

 93:19

address

 30:21

 57:3

 77:11

adults

 69:5

affect

 10:7,11,

 13

affiliation

s

 5:11

age

 32:7

 38:12

 68:3

agencies

 17:12,16

agency

 14:1,16

 15:12

 17:10

 23:21

agent

 14:20

 15:11

 23:15

 44:7 47:2

agents

 15:5,6,15

 16:18,19

aggravated

 70:18

 78:5 79:8

agreement

 52:24

ahead

 62:21

 92:16,18

ahold

 83:18

Aikodo

 35:6,8,

 18,21

 67:16

 68:8

 76:16,17,

 20 77:14,

 22

alike

 88:21

alive

 28:21

 91:16,17

allegations

 87:1

 89:11

alleged

 87:1

allegedly

 72:22

 22:19

 29:12,22

 30:1 33:3

 58:17,18,

 19

's

 71:18

amount

 25:15

 69:23

 88:6

amphetamine

 95:3

Ancient

 67:4

Andre

 16:15,16,

 24

answering

 7:16

answers

 7:22

Antonie

 70:21

Antonio

 5:16

anymore

 21:19

 52:4

anytime

 77:8

 82:14

 96:5

apartment

 32:16,20

 47:19,21

 85:24

apply

 13:20

April

 80:24

area

 22:9

Arizona

 13:16

 22:3,6,8,

 21 25:5,

 10,17,22,

 25 26:1,

 13,25

 29:5 30:2

 34:12

 46:7

 50:3,5

 51:1,2

 52:5 53:4

 57:25

 62:4,6,7,

 8,24

 63:2,9,

 11,12

 65:1,4

 80:5

 84:17

arrange

 89:19

arrangement

s

 89:1

arrest

 70:19

 75:18

 78:2,3

 79:9 92:7

 93:17

arrested

 70:17

 72:21

 81:10

art

 37:13

 77:1

artery

 92:8

 93:18

Artist

 41:20,21

arts

 11:24

 20:5,6,8,

 12 21:18

 34:7,9,18

 35:5,11,

 23 36:2,

 3,12,19

 37:2,4,6,

 12 67:12,

 18,24

 68:17

 75:4,7,12

 76:16

 77:7

asks

 10:25

asleep

 45:18

aspect

 37:11

assault

 70:18

 73:12

 78:6 79:9

assault/

domestic

 73:4

assaults

 74:7

assist

 35:3

 68:19

assistance

 16:12

 84:22

assisted

 68:20

assisting

 68:23,25

assume

 7:13,14,

 16 69:18

assumes

 74:11

assuming

 52:19

asthma

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: acts..asthma

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

-

-
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 10:16,18

 77:3,5

ASU

 43:14,16,

 18 46:7,

 12

Atlanta

 13:2,14

attend

 22:12,15,

 17

attorney

 6:11

attorneyclient

 95:9

attorneys

 5:10

August

 11:9

aunt

 22:15

 25:6

 30:4,17

 57:13,21

 59:15,17,

 22 60:15

 61:23

 62:7 90:7

Auntie

 59:13,17,

 18 60:8

Avondale

 43:12

 51:10,15

avowed

 10:24

awarded

 95:18

aware

 70:17

 71:17

 73:1,9,11

 74:9,13,

 15,23

 75:22

 76:3,12,

 19 78:8

 79:19

 81:9,25

 83:2

 86:25

 91:4

B

babying

 32:22

Bachelor's

 43:24

back

 7:4 16:6

 18:21

 22:23

 25:9,13,

 17 26:1

 34:9

 40:7,13

 43:5

 44:15

 50:7

 55:23

 62:3,6,8

 63:10

 66:21

 67:2,14

 79:15,19

 83:9

 84:16

 91:10,11,

 19,22

 92:1,2

 96:5

background

 6:12

 11:7,22

 51:25

 70:15

 78:23

backyards

 76:2

bad

 7:7,9

 77:2

bags

 21:3

Barbara

 15:18

 16:8,10,

 12,22

 17:2

baseball

 34:18

based

 57:7

 97:3,14

basically

 49:3

basis

 48:2

basketball

 34:18

battle

 59:11

bawling

 85:12

beginning

 34:7,10

 44:4

believes

 76:7

beneficiary

 57:18

 86:18

 95:5,16

bicycle

 76:1

big

 26:21

 65:25

 66:3

 84:8,10

biological

 30:20

 64:6,16

biologicall

y

 31:6

birth

 11:8

 36:25

 37:3

birthdays

 65:24

bit

 20:4 31:3

 52:10,20,

 21 54:5

 55:10,19

 61:9 67:8

blood

 95:2

body

 88:4,11

book

 21:8,10

 66:12,13

booking

 23:5

born

 58:22

 60:18

 75:23

bought

 12:23

boxing

 36:1

break

 6:21,22

 7:1,3

 49:6,8,19

 54:3

 56:23

breakdown

 65:19

breath

 77:4

 87:17

breathing

 77:4

Brenda

 15:20

 16:8,10,

 11,14

 17:2

Bridge

 47:13,17

bring

 61:2

 66:14

broke

 49:3

 69:16

broken

 38:1 71:3

brother

 28:10

brothers

 28:8,10,

 11,13

 29:13,14,

 19

brought

 11:17

Brumbelow

 5:9

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: ASU..Brumbelow

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

build

 14:4

 56:15

 86:13

building

 24:15

burial

 89:9,13

 90:2

bury

 88:4,5

business

 15:12,24

busy

 19:24

 80:3

buy

 22:25

C

cage

 75:15

call

 20:14

 47:13

 52:4 53:5

 57:21

 58:15

 59:16

 63:14

 69:2 84:6

 85:22

called

 8:5

 20:23,24

 76:5

calling

 85:8

calls

 68:4

 74:11

 92:10,16,

 22 95:8

cardiac

 92:7

 93:17

care

 59:6

 60:15

 61:20,22

 62:14

 90:7

career

 14:25

 15:1 44:1

caring

 65:11

case

 14:3

 86:19

 87:1,20

 95:15

casket

 88:20

casting

 21:5,11

caught

 32:21

 52:9,10,

 13

caused

 78:22

 92:7

caveat

 6:24

celebration

s

 65:24

cell

 66:22

 80:15

central

 57:25

Chami

 5:17,22

 6:10

 8:10,16

 9:5,8,11

 10:25

 16:4 27:2

 33:4,10

 36:7,10,

 14 38:1

 49:11

 54:13

 59:24

 62:19

 63:4

 66:15

 67:4

 68:1,4

 74:10,22

 75:1

 76:18

 81:13

 90:4

 92:10,16,

 19,21,24

 93:1

 95:8,11,

 15 98:16,

 18

Chami's

 77:11

chance

 25:3,4

 56:14

 58:16

 59:1

changed

 89:16

charge

 52:24

charged

 52:1,25

 53:13

 78:5

charges

 73:12

 75:17

Charisse

 16:14,24

 17:2

chicken

 32:21

chihuahua

 97:21

child

 70:24

 71:1

children

 33:2,9

 51:20,23

 69:4

 72:5,7

Chiquita

 97:20

 98:4

choice

 96:8

choose

 51:4

 96:2,3,4,

 5,6

choreograph

y

 18:1,4

Christmas

 65:23

circumstanc

es

 57:2

 60:24

 92:5

citation

 53:19

citations

 53:18

citizen

 79:11

city

 5:15

 41:13,14

 42:16

 57:8

civil

 53:18,19

claims

 24:1

 47:4,6

 90:1

clarify

 29:16

 49:20

 54:18

 62:5 63:8

class

 53:1

classes

 45:13

 47:16

classificat

ion

 94:3,6

classified

 94:9

Cleveland

 16:15,16,

 24

click

 97:7

close

 24:14

 38:22,23

 39:20

 40:1

 41:1,7,8

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: build..close

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 43:10

 48:21

 63:21,22

 98:6

closer

 58:25

closing

 23:7

college

 11:19

 12:2

 14:10,12

 39:12,16

 43:14,15,

 18 44:16

 45:2,4

 46:6

 47:7,10,

 12,15,16

 48:2

 51:19

 52:9,10,

 21,22

 53:10

 56:10

 83:22

colleges

 35:2 80:5

Collins

 15:18

 16:23

combative

 75:21

commercial

 17:21

common

 7:23 84:7

communicati

ons

 10:4 84:4

 95:9

company

 14:1

 23:19

compensate

 19:11

compete

 35:20

 36:3

competing

 35:19

competition

s

 35:19

competitive

 36:2

 44:21

complaint

 86:19,20,

 21 87:19

 89:12

 90:1

complaints

 9:24 96:9

completely

 12:20

 53:5

completing

 56:11

complex

 32:16,20

complicatio

ns

 65:16,18

concern

 75:3,6,8,

 9

concerns

 74:20

 78:21

concluded

 98:23

concludes

 98:20

conclusion

 97:2,13

condition

 10:7,10

conflicting

 56:16

confused

 83:15

 88:20

confusing

 30:18

 64:20

 71:14

Congratulat

ions

 12:24

connection

 64:7,9,16

 91:3

contact

 82:9

 84:16

continuing

 93:1

contract

 35:1

control

 77:4

conversatio

n

 7:23

 80:21,25

 81:3

 84:19

 98:2,3

convictions

 73:12

copy

 92:20

coronary

 92:7

 93:18

corporate

 14:1

 23:20,22

 44:21

correct

 10:20,21

 11:1,4,13

 12:16

 22:23

 29:24

 33:23

 34:21

 38:20

 40:15

 49:22

 57:14

 60:15,18

 61:24

 64:7

 67:19

 71:24

 72:5

 73:17

 78:18

 81:18

 93:5,8,13

 94:20,25

 95:3

 96:9,11,

 15,18,25

 97:4,15

 98:12

Corrections

 78:12

correctly

 96:1

cost

 89:13,14

couple

 9:6 12:18

 14:6,23,

 24,25

 15:9,22

 16:19

 17:11,12

 18:16

 19:2

 23:17

 24:10,21

 25:5,18

 26:9

 31:16

 32:17

 36:4

 38:15

 48:10

 50:14

 58:23

 64:2 70:4

 74:4

 82:10,24

 84:13

coupleminute

 49:8

courage

 56:15

 86:14

court

 5:8 10:23

 11:4

 36:15

cousin

 24:11

create

 19:20

created

 89:4

credits

 44:16

cremate

 88:5

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: closer..cremate

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MU AMMA MU AYM

MU AYM vs Y O P OE X

c b r 06, 201

800 211 DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions com

cremation

 89:9

crime

 52:1

crimes

 53:13

criminal

 43:24

 44:2,6,

 12,18

 51:25

 70:14

 78:23,24

criminology

 43:25

 44:12

CROSSEXAMINATION

 8:8

crying

 85:8 86:4

Crystal

 5:8

curious

 20:21

custody

 59:11

customer

 23:23

 24:2,6

cut

 12:12

D

dad

 11:23

 27:14

 28:3

 29:20

 31:15,23

 32:15,21,

 23,25

 33:2,20,

 25 34:5,7

 36:19

 37:1,6,

 19,21,23

 38:4,11,

 15,19,25

 39:13,20

 42:1,24

 47:24

 48:3,8,

 18,19,24,

 25 49:3

 50:7,16

 51:4

 54:4,10,

 22 55:1,7

 56:6,19

 58:11

 61:2,5,6

 62:9

 65:20

 66:8,12

 67:9,19

 68:11

 69:25

 70:1,4,11

 71:23

 72:18,20,

 21 73:4,

 13,15

 76:1 78:1

 79:15

 80:22

 81:6,9,18

 82:1,20

 83:24

 84:11,22

 85:2

 88:10

 91:3

 94:24

 97:8

dad's

 26:15,18

 33:15

 34:1

 57:14

 58:20

 65:8 66:1

 70:14

 97:19

damages

 89:12

 95:7,23

 96:1

Daniel

 41:20

 48:15,18,

 23 54:10,

 17 80:17,

 21

date

 11:8

 93:10

 94:19

dating

 46:8,17

David

 5:17

Davis

 59:24

day

 19:23

 22:1

 45:10,11

 56:2 67:2

 85:20

 91:12

days

 26:10

 76:5 88:6

deal

 32:23

 35:1

 88:24

death

 58:20

 65:8 92:6

 93:17,25

 94:3,9

decedent

 93:12

 94:24

December

 5:5 23:1,

 2,4 79:16

decided

 44:11,18

 50:23

Defendants

 95:7

Defendants'

 92:14

 94:15

degree

 12:3

 43:21,23

 44:19,20,

 22

demand

 91:2

demanding

 90:2

 97:13

demonstrati

on

 69:2,3

department

 78:11

 90:16

depend

 42:5

depends

 36:23,24

 41:11

 47:9 69:9

deposed

 8:6

deposition

 5:4 6:4

 8:11,18,

 22,25

 9:19,20,

 21 98:21

depositions

 96:14

desk

 44:9

 85:11

detain

 79:12

devote

 18:8

didn't--

 64:12

died

 97:8

differently

 19:12

difficult

 6:19

 56:22

 92:4,5

directly

 87:24

 90:19

directors

 21:11

discipline

 76:25

disclose

 95:11

disclosed

 96:18

discovery

 9:24

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: cremation..discovery

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

discussion

 81:24

disease

 77:5 92:8

 93:18

dismiss

 52:3,4

 53:3,5

disrespectf

ul

 6:20

 64:14

DOC

 79:17,22

doctor

 44:5

document

 9:20

 86:22

documents

 9:18

 87:9,20

dog

 97:20,24

 98:5,7,9,

 12

dog's

 97:19

dojo

 20:24

 34:23

dojos

 34:13,21

dollars

 19:3

domestic

 71:17

 72:22

 73:11

Doneilea

 5:7

dorms

 50:11

downtown

 51:19

dream

 11:20

 12:5

drive

 85:24

driving

 18:1

drop

 42:21

drug

 80:23

duly

 8:6

E

e-mail

 17:18

earlier

 5:24 6:2

 22:22

 62:15

 68:14

 81:17

 82:8

 83:24

 95:25

earliest

 34:10

earn

 89:7

eat

 37:10

education

 68:10

efforts

 83:3

eighth

 39:8,15,

 17

emotions

 56:16

employed

 12:8

 68:13

employee

 57:11

employment

 18:12

 23:11

ended

 28:5

 31:25

 48:14,15

enforcement

's

 93:20

enter

 52:23

Entry-level

 47:6

established

 55:13

 86:13

estate

 5:18 23:6

 57:14,18

estate's

 6:11

estimate

 38:24

evidence

 74:12

exgirlfriends

 70:9

exam

 94:19

examination

 93:10

examiner

 87:22

 93:8

 94:7,10

examiner's

 92:2

exciting

 23:9

exertion

 92:9

 93:19

Exhibit

 92:13,14

 93:5,24

 94:13,15

expand

 36:6

expect

 6:12

expenses

 90:2

 91:3,4

expensive

 89:17,18

experience

 75:5,7

 76:8,13

experienced

 73:8

experimente

d

 52:21

expert

 92:22

explain

 31:2,4

 64:10

exposure

 21:14,15

expressed

 74:20

 75:3

extra

 17:12

 19:2,13

eyes

 85:12

F

faced

 79:10

fact

 88:19

facts

 74:11

fair

 7:4,17

fall

 45:18

falls

 18:1,4

familiar

 70:14

 76:9

 86:25

families

 26:18

 34:16

family

 6:20

 11:18,25

 22:10,12

 24:8,13,

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: discussion..family

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 18 26:6,

 8,9,10,

 12,15,16,

 20,21

 29:18

 30:22

 31:10,13

 34:17

 51:2

 57:23,25

 59:1,14,

 20 64:3

 65:14

 66:1

 83:13

 84:8,10

 87:4,5

Farm

 13:13,14,

 16,18

 15:3,4,5

 23:12

 44:24

 46:3,18,

 20,23

farther

 51:14

father

 33:8,22

 35:2

 39:21,24

 48:21,24

 59:21

 65:12,17,

 18 69:7

 73:20

 74:17

 75:10,14,

 19 76:6,

 7,13,15

 78:18,22

 83:3,4

 86:8

 90:12

 91:10

 96:6

father's

 75:7

 87:16

 92:6

 93:13

FBI

 44:7

fear

 75:9

fee

 53:1

fees

 91:2,4

felt

 12:3 44:8

 86:12

field

 44:6

fight

 18:1,4

 76:7

fighting

 19:5 36:5

 75:15

 77:5

 79:11

figure

 30:25

 32:3

 48:21,24

 64:2,5

 80:20

 88:11,12

filed

 52:3 53:3

 57:7,17

 86:20

 90:11,21,

 24

filing

 90:14,15

films

 17:24

final

 97:7

finally

 80:5

finances

 12:21

financial

 18:14

find

 14:9

 16:18

 66:5

 80:13

 85:3

finding

 48:14,15

fine

 85:11

finish

 44:19

 80:7

finishing

 23:6

 83:21,22

fittest

 59:10

flight

 78:4

flip

 67:2

flipping

 19:5

flips

 18:1,4

float

 17:4

floater

 15:10

flooring

 21:3

focus

 83:20

focusing

 18:14

football

 34:17

force

 78:4

 96:24

form

 8:16

 81:13

 90:4,13

formal

 21:18

forms

 67:24

foster

 28:16,19,

 20 29:20

 40:15,23

 59:6

 60:15

 61:19,22

found

 54:20

 86:11

foundation

 33:4 68:5

 74:11

 77:9

 92:11

frame

 27:24

frequently

 62:23,25

freshman

 44:11

 47:10,20

Friday

 5:5

friend

 15:12

friends

 15:23

 16:10,19

 20:15

 21:5

 44:13

front

 69:2

 93:4,7

 94:13

frustrated

 86:12

full

 13:2

 45:4,5

 80:9

full-time

 14:9 80:9

funds

 89:4

 91:25

funeral

 56:21

 64:11,19

 88:14

 89:1,13,

 19 90:2

 96:19

G

garage

 34:23

gatekeeper

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: Farm..gatekeeper

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 83:25

gateway

 65:13

gatherings

 65:25

 66:3

 84:9,11

general

 11:7

generations

 33:21

gentle

 35:10

Georgia

 11:13

 12:23

 13:2

 14:13

 15:2 16:6

 22:23

 24:8

 25:7,13,

 18,22

 51:1 58:7

 62:4,7,

 18,23

 63:3,11,

 13 65:2

get all 

 13:1

gigs

 12:19

 17:8

 18:11,20

 19:1

Gilbert

 22:9

 50:16,19,

 22 51:3

girlfriend

 82:18

give

 7:22 12:4

 67:7

 81:22

glad

 85:19,20

 86:9

Gofundme

 89:3,7,16

good

 21:10,14,

 15,16

 59:12

 65:7,9

 69:23

Googling

 87:13

grabbed

 78:6

grade

 32:6

 39:9,15,

 17

graduated

 11:19

 80:4,6

graduation

 39:17

grandchildr

en

 91:14

grandfather

 11:24

 33:18,20,

 22,23

 34:12,21

 37:19,21,

 25 39:19,

 20 40:10

 48:15,20,

 23 54:21,

 25 55:12,

 16 58:11

 65:13

 67:11,19

 68:17

 69:1,6

 80:17,21

 81:1,5,25

 82:4,16

 83:14,25

grandfather

's

 58:12

 65:15

 69:24

grandpa

 36:19

 38:20

 39:2 84:3

grandparent

s

 33:14,15

 40:25

 41:4,14,

 16,17,23,

 25 42:4,

 13 43:9

 91:17

grandparent

s'

 42:9 43:3

 82:22

grew

 11:23

 12:1

 26:19

 48:20

groom's

 55:24

groomsmen

 55:25

ground

 6:14

Group

 5:18

grow

 61:7

growing

 58:25

 77:3

growth

 46:4

guess

 9:20

 32:12

 34:25

 47:22

 53:4 55:9

 60:12

 62:13

 83:1

guessing

 81:19

guys

 22:6 37:1

 46:12

 50:17

 89:6

gyms

 20:10,21

 21:6

H

half

 13:8

 22:17

 28:8,9,

 10,11

 29:14,19,

 22 33:9

 40:24

 41:3,4

 42:3,4

 45:25

 58:17

 60:14

 66:17

 71:11

 78:14

hand

 93:23

handling

 90:8

hands-on

 69:4

happened

 12:13

 32:4

 40:11

 52:24

 85:23

 86:8

happy

 56:2

hard

 12:11

 40:12

 48:7 49:5

 61:12,14,

 17 64:8

 82:9

 83:19

 87:11,18,

 21 88:1,

 2,18

 96:21

head

 7:24

headshot

 21:9

headshots

 19:20

health

 14:10

hear

 83:13

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: gateway..hear

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

heard

 7:15

 79:5,20

 80:11,16

 86:5

 87:23

heavy

 21:3

 39:25

hectic

 22:4

held

 61:5

helped

 31:5

 62:14

helping

 48:16

 54:12,17,

 21 55:5

 81:6,8,25

 84:22

high

 12:1

 37:23

 38:13,14

 39:5,8,

 12,15,17

 43:1,11,

 13 47:15

 48:2 51:7

 56:11

 80:4

 83:21

history

 75:15

 78:24

hit

 39:25

Hold

 64:22

holding

 58:21

holidays

 65:23

home

 37:1 71:6

 72:18

 85:24

homeless

 82:1,6,7,

 13

homelessnes

s

 82:12

 83:3,5

Homicide

 94:1,3

honest

 26:14

 31:8

 33:19

 36:20

 58:9 60:1

 64:8

 65:12

 66:21

 68:23

 80:3 87:7

 90:5 91:9

horrible

 85:23

hour

 9:6

hours

 9:6

house

 12:23

 22:25

 23:6,7

 31:22

 34:23

 42:9

 69:24

 70:2 72:2

 74:6

 82:22

huge

 11:24

 34:19

 37:11

 39:19

hugely

 39:21

Humana

 14:9

 44:25

 45:7,20,

 22,24

 85:7

hundred

 19:3

Hunter

 16:15,25

hurt

 86:6

I

idea

 57:24

 89:14

identificat

ion

 92:15

 94:16

III

 5:20,22

illness

 40:8,9

immediately

 56:13

impacted

 39:21

incident

 71:18

 72:22,24

 73:1

 74:6,9,15

 76:1,10

 79:9 85:1

incidents

 73:6

including

 33:2

incurred

 91:3

individual

 5:15

individuals

 90:22,24

industry

 19:19

influence

 11:21

influences

 78:20

information

 7:25 87:2

Inhaler

 10:19

input

 84:24

inside

 21:7

 34:23

instance

 75:22

 79:13

 96:23

instances

 73:3 78:8

insurance

 12:10,16,

 17 13:5

 14:6,7,

 11,17

 19:23

 88:8

intend

 44:1

intimidatin

g

 90:14

intoxicatio

n

 92:9

 93:19

intrigued

 44:3

introduce

 5:10

 21:11

introduced

 5:23 6:1

introducing

 61:3

investigati

on

 96:24

involved

 31:13

 55:17

involving

 75:18

ironically

 44:9

ish

 81:21

Islam

 34:19

Islamic

 37:11

 88:5

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: heard..Islamic

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

issues

 72:12

 78:21

J

jail

 78:9 96:4

January

 23:2,5

 79:7 85:2

 94:19,21

Japanese

 35:11

Jayce

 28:14

 29:2,9,19

job

 13:5

 19:23

 45:6 80:9

 83:22

Jr

 5:19 8:4

July

 78:1

 79:16

 80:24

jumping

 56:14

junior

 37:23

 38:13,14

 39:5,8,

 12,15

 44:17

justice

 43:24

 44:2,6,

 12,18

 90:12,20

 91:25

K

karate

 68:17

 76:8,13

Karen

 5:14

Kelley

 27:12

 41:20

kickboxing

 36:1

kid

 64:13

kids

 72:18

 91:14

killed

 94:5

kind

 6:11,13,

 18 7:23

 15:9

 17:20

 32:22

 35:5 38:5

 39:23

 48:7,20

 50:6 54:4

 56:13

 58:12

 61:12

 62:5

 64:2,4,8

 65:10,19

 72:9,12

 82:9

 83:19,25

 88:16

 90:17

kindergarte

n

 32:4,7

 37:22

 38:13,14

 39:4,8

 40:13

knew

 16:19

 82:13

 85:16

knowledge

 79:13

Korean

 36:11

Kwon

 36:12

L

label

 15:10

lacks

 68:5

 74:10

 92:11

landed

 45:6

late

 70:19,21

 71:2

law

 5:17

 93:20

lawsuit

 6:7 53:25

 57:7,17

 89:22

 90:11,15,

 21,24

 91:7

 97:14

leading

 87:17

learn

 19:18

 35:17,20

 36:6

 64:18

 85:1

learned

 36:4

leave

 46:2

length

 69:15

let alone 

 90:15

level

 68:10

life

 36:23

 41:12

 55:5,13

 83:21

 88:8

live

 11:13

 25:6

 26:25

 27:19,25

 29:5,8

 41:8

 42:14

 43:1 47:8

 51:15

 60:15

 61:22

 65:5

 69:15

 82:16

lived

 27:22

 31:15,22

 32:16

 33:25

 40:22,25

 41:15

 42:15

 43:4

 47:17,20

 50:7

 51:13

 68:14

 69:13

 70:4

lives

 24:18

 30:3,4

 31:18

 51:4

living

 37:6

 42:11

 62:1 69:8

 70:1,4,21

 71:23

local

 26:25

 34:24

Loitering

 53:20

long

 9:4 18:17

 22:21

 25:13,16

 27:21,24

 35:21

 40:9

 45:24

 81:8 82:7

 83:12

looked

 50:22

 64:5

lose

 96:21

loss

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: issues..loss

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 92:4

lot

 11:21

 12:5,22

 15:22

 20:2

 21:4,16

 23:8 30:9

 33:19

 34:1

 37:15

 38:21

 39:21

 44:13

 58:10

 59:22

 60:10

 61:1

 82:15

 84:2

 88:23

M

made

 11:18

 20:15

 46:2 69:8

 74:7

maiden

 49:24

majority

 25:21

majors

 44:14

make

 6:14 16:4

 44:22

 56:3

 93:16

makes

 39:25

making

 46:22

 96:8

man

 55:9 56:8

manager

 24:2,6,7

manner

 93:25

 94:2,9

marijuana

 52:19,20,

 22

marked

 92:12,15

 93:5,24

 94:16

market

 44:21

married

 12:22

 21:21,22

 22:6

 27:15,17

 46:10

 49:21

 50:17

 55:24

 83:22

martial

 11:24

 20:5,6,8,

 12 21:18

 34:7,9,18

 35:5,11,

 23 36:2,

 3,12,19

 37:2,4,6,

 12,13

 67:12,18,

 24 68:17

 75:4,7,12

 76:16

 77:1,7

math

 46:19

matter

 41:1 42:8

Meaning

 52:1

means

 94:4,6

meant

 6:19

medical

 87:22

 91:2 92:2

 93:7

 94:7,10

medications

 10:13,20

meet

 8:13,23

 25:4,24

 46:12

meeting

 9:8,10

member

 30:22

members

 64:3

 87:4,5

memories

 34:10

mental

 10:10

 40:7,9

mentioned

 54:2,9,20

 81:24

 83:8,24

message

 58:15

 63:15

met

 8:10 9:4

 46:5,6,7

 51:18

 58:17,20

 98:8

methampheta

mine

 92:9

 93:19

 95:3

mind

 18:25

mine

 26:10

minutes

 49:12

mischaracte

r-

 62:19

mischaracte

rizes

 54:13

 63:4

misdemeanor

 52:2,8,25

missing

 12:3

model

 59:13

 61:13

mom

 26:22

 27:12

 28:3,16,

 17,23

 29:20

 31:15,23

 32:15,22

 33:25

 34:5

 40:15,22

 41:5,25

 48:19,21

 49:2

 50:7,12

 51:13

 59:9,12

 61:6,12

 69:16

 71:11,18

 85:8,10,

 22,25

 86:2,5

mom's

 26:15,17

 29:18

 41:17

 48:18,24

 54:10

 58:25

moment

 87:17

moments

 55:23

 56:2,12

 80:11

 91:12

 97:7

monetary

 95:6,23

 96:1

money

 88:7,14

 91:24

 96:4,6

Montgomery

 15:20

month

 38:17

 39:1 74:3

months

 60:20

 61:4

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: lot..months

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 66:18

 74:4

morning

 6:2 8:22

 9:2,11

mortician

 88:3

mother

 30:25

 31:3

 64:2,5

mother's

 26:19

 40:25

motion

 52:3

move

 11:15

 25:9 65:1

moved

 13:4,12,

 16 15:2

 16:13

 18:21

 34:12

 37:1

 50:14

 58:7 62:8

 63:10

 73:15

 74:5 83:8

 84:16

movies

 17:24

 21:5

 37:10

moving

 12:11,12

 61:14

Mu

 85:9

Muhammad

 5:4,18,19

 8:4 27:14

 31:15

 33:18,21

 48:20,25

 86:6

Muhaymin

 5:4,19

 8:4 9:14

 24:23

Musi

 24:20,22

 55:11

 57:21

 58:2

 61:23

 62:5,8

Muslim-

 71:11

Muslimah

 71:11

Mussalina

 30:5,11,

 24 31:5,

 10,12,22

 57:13,25

 59:21,22

 61:23

 62:8,17

 63:1,9,

 12,20

 64:2,23,

 25 65:22

 83:8

 84:1,4,16

 87:3

Mussalina's

 30:15

N

names

 41:19

needed

 15:24

 16:12

 55:19

network

 19:21

newer

 24:15

news

 86:3

nick

 59:13

nickname

 57:22

 60:7

night

 31:17

 61:5

 69:22,24

 70:1

 72:1,17

 82:17

nighttime

 45:13

nod

 7:24

Norcross

 11:13,17

normal

 85:20

notice

 7:19 9:21

November

 78:3

number

 5:3 76:9,

 12 80:15

 93:24

 94:14

nurse

 44:5

O

oath

 10:23

object

 8:16 33:4

 54:13

 74:10

 81:13

 90:4

objection

 33:10

 62:19

 63:4

 68:1,4

 77:11

 92:10

 93:2 95:8

objections

 16:4

obtained

 14:5

occasions

 42:11

occurred

 80:22

October

 75:20

off-thewall

 97:17

offend

 6:19

offense

 80:23

office

 16:12

 98:19

officer

 44:7

 70:18

 79:11,12

officers

 5:16

 57:10

 74:20

 75:3,18,

 21 76:2,7

 78:1,2,6

 79:9 96:3

 97:2

officially

 96:12

older

 12:1,12

 35:20

 40:6

 47:25

 58:14

 61:9

 65:17

 83:20

One's

 20:24

online

 45:13

open

 56:25

opened

 34:12,22

opinion

 84:24

opinions

 93:16

opportunity

 46:4

opposed

 23:20

 51:1,14

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: morning..opposed

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

order

 12:21

other's

 31:18

owned

 34:21

 98:7

P

p.m.

 98:21,24

padded

 21:3

paid

 19:1,15

pan

 14:4

paperwork

 23:7

parent

 59:9,10

 92:5

 96:22

parents

 41:5,12,

 15 42:5,

 9,14,15

 43:4

 47:18

 71:3

 91:16

part

 11:25

 22:8 31:9

 34:19

 39:24

 50:5

 78:23

 88:18,25

 89:3

part-time

 12:19

 17:8

participate

 83:2

party

 53:25

passed

 33:23

 39:20,24

 40:10

 82:14

 84:3

 86:11

 91:18

passing

 33:19

 39:3

 58:12

 65:15

 82:3 85:3

 91:12

past

 26:2

pastimes

 36:20

patience

 76:23

Patrick

 28:19,21

 29:20

 35:25

 40:15,23

 41:5

pay

 12:11

 18:16

 53:1

 88:15

 89:4,20,

 22

paychecks

 18:16

paying

 18:11

pending

 6:25

people

 19:18,21

 20:14

 21:4,6

 30:21

 34:24

 57:1 67:2

 87:23

 91:15,22

 97:3,14

percent

 39:7,11

percentage

 38:24

period

 32:14

 69:10,16

person

 90:15

personal

 57:13

Pharmaceuti

cal

 45:23

Phoenix

 5:15

 51:19

 57:8

phone

 66:22

 80:15

 84:6

 86:15

phones

 67:2

photos

 66:22

physical

 10:6 78:4

 92:9

 93:19

picture

 66:10

 71:9

pictures

 66:2,8,

 12,19,20

place

 5:11

 21:15,16

places

 20:25

 43:5 70:5

Plaintiff

 95:15

Plaintiff's

 89:12

play

 88:13

played

 30:24

player

 7:21

plea

 52:23

pleadings

 9:23

 87:20

plenty

 56:5

point

 34:8 36:5

 44:20

 52:2 55:6

 61:20

 80:10

police

 5:16 44:7

 57:10

 70:18

 76:6

 90:16

 96:3 97:2

policies

 14:22

policy

 14:21

Pooch

 59:13,17,

 18,22

Pooch's

 60:8

pop

 62:3

popped

 87:14

popular

 66:25

portfolio

 14:5 21:8

portion

 19:8

position

 13:21,22

 14:10

 15:14

 17:3

positions

 14:6,7,

 15,24,25

 23:17

Positive

 95:3

pox

 32:21

practice

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: order..practice

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 20:1

 21:16

 35:23,24

practiced

 34:15

 35:14

 37:18,20

 67:20,24

 77:12,15,

 16,18

practicing

 18:10

 37:15

 76:20

prayer

 37:12,16

pregnant

 71:20

preparation

 8:17 9:18

preparing

 8:25

presence

 56:9

present

 9:7,10

 39:2

 72:24

pretty

 19:4

 26:14

prevalent

 34:17

Price

 5:17

pride

 55:10

principles

 77:7

prior

 8:11,22,

 23 51:20

 54:14,16

 58:20

 63:5 65:8

 93:1

prison

 79:3,5,15

 80:12,24

 81:6,12

 82:10,12

 91:23

 96:4

privilege

 95:9

proceedings

 98:23

product

 17:20

program

 47:11

promise

 11:18

promoted

 24:1,2

PSD

 96:24

psychiatric

 92:8

 93:18

pulled

 52:12,14

 78:7

pulling

 78:2

punched

 72:23

punching

 75:21

purposes

 8:25

pursue

 11:19

 12:5,20

pursued

 44:13

put

 21:8

putting

 55:25

Q

question

 6:25 7:1,

 2,9,12,14

 33:6

 37:24

 74:10,25

 77:20

 92:23

 95:20

 97:12,18

questions

 6:18 7:7

 10:14,24,

 25 16:3

 49:4

 98:15,16

R

raise

 31:5

raised

 30:19,21

 59:21

 64:24

raising

 31:11

ran

 76:2 78:1

reached

 55:11

read

 87:19

 92:3,4

 93:21

 94:20

 96:9,12,

 14,17

 97:9,11

 98:17,18

ready

 25:9 56:1

 83:17

real

 23:6 60:8

realize

 90:22

realized

 89:18

reason

 30:7

reasons

 32:19

 39:19

recall

 32:13

 37:5

 53:18

 59:3

 68:10,13,

 16 69:7

 71:5

 72:1,4

 73:6

 74:17

 75:14

 84:21

 89:6 98:3

receive

 18:12

received

 18:15

recent

 61:24

 81:7 83:6

recently

 49:21

 82:2

recess

 49:15

reconnect

 56:14

record

 5:12

 49:14,15,

 17,21

 98:22

recording

 87:10

recordings

 10:3

recover

 95:6,17

recovery

 89:21

reel

 19:20

 21:9

refer

 30:16

referred

 31:21

referring

 9:21

 30:10

 41:16

 78:12

refuse

 87:15

refusing

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: practiced..refusing

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 76:2

regard

 57:21

regret

 12:13

 56:13

reimburseme

nt

 90:2

rekindle

 55:20

 91:20

related

 31:7

relationshi

p

 24:15

 43:8

 47:24

 51:21

 54:3,19

 55:4,20

 61:7

 64:18

 65:7,20

 67:9 72:9

 73:19

 78:22

 84:1

 91:20

relevant

 16:2

remained

 15:3

remarried

 40:15

remem-

 28:4

remember

 8:15 22:1

 25:14,16

 27:21,24

 28:4

 31:9,14,

 20 32:15,

 17,19

 34:4,6,

 11,14

 35:21

 37:7,8

 40:17

 48:5 53:8

 55:14,24

 56:1,7

 58:21,23

 59:4,22

 60:5,24

 61:3

 64:25

 65:3

 66:10

 67:14,21

 68:7,15

 69:14

 70:9,22,

 23 71:21,

 23 74:16

 76:20,22

 79:23

 81:3,11,

 15 84:8,

 14,19,25

 85:7,8

 86:14

 87:12

 88:2

 89:8,20

 98:1,13

remembered

 48:8

removed

 24:12

rephrase

 89:23

 91:9

 95:20

report

 87:22

 92:2 93:8

 94:18

 96:24

reporter

 5:8 10:23

 36:15

reports

 96:17

 97:9

represent

 5:15,18

representat

ive

 57:14

requesting

 91:6

 95:25

residence

 70:12

 73:16

resisted

 78:2,3

resisting

 70:18

 75:18

 78:6 79:9

respect

 88:15

respectful

 65:10

respects

 88:15

response

 96:10

responses

 9:24

results

 56:7

resume

 7:4 14:5

 19:20

 21:9

 46:22

retired

 16:16

retirement

 16:17

review

 9:18,23

 10:1,3

 86:20

reviewed

 86:19

 87:22,24

 96:23

reword

 7:10

role

 15:14

 34:1

 45:22

 59:12

 61:13

roles

 17:13

 19:2,13,

 14 46:25

rolling

 19:5

room

 43:5

 55:25

 82:16

roots

 13:2

rough

 45:9

roughly

 13:7

rules

 6:14

run

 77:23

rundown

 6:12

running

 7:21

 75:18

S

sacred

 37:13

sad

 39:22

 86:4,7

sales

 12:10,16

 13:5

 14:21

 45:23

 47:2

sample

 95:2

samurai

 74:6,18

 75:4

scene

 19:4,5

scenes

 19:22

schedule

 42:6

school

 12:2

 39:17

 41:3,24

 42:19

 43:1,11,

 13 45:3,

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: regard..school

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 4,10,12,

 17 47:12,

 15 48:2

 51:8,18

 56:11

 80:4

 83:21

schooling

 80:9

scouted

 80:4

Sean

 28:14,25

 29:9,19

secret

 54:24

seek

 95:6

sell

 14:21

selling

 14:17,20,

 21 19:23

 23:15

semester

 45:6

send

 98:19

senior

 44:17

 45:2,4

sense

 39:25

sentenced

 78:11,14

 79:22

 80:23

separate

 81:12

September

 21:23,24

 22:5

 49:22

served

 79:22

service

 23:23

 24:3,6

set

 44:15

setting

 92:7

 93:18

Shaheed

 71:15

shake

 7:24

shape

 90:13

share

 28:17

 29:20

 75:6,8

 82:4

shared

 70:12

shoplifting

 79:10

short

 16:13

 17:24

 49:19

shot

 12:4

show

 17:21

 56:7

 91:11

siblings

 28:7

side

 12:18

 26:15,16,

 18,19

 29:18

 33:15

 41:1,17

 58:25

 65:13

 66:1

sides

 26:17

sign

 98:17,18

similar

 36:12

sir

 5:23 6:1,

 5 8:19

 9:2 54:20

 85:5

 86:23

 93:4

 94:7,11

 95:6,14

 96:8

 97:12

sister

 22:17

 28:8,9,

 10,11

 29:11,14,

 22,24

 30:11,13,

 14,15,25

 31:3 33:9

 58:17

 59:23

 60:14

 61:6

 62:14

 63:10

 64:3

 66:17

 71:1,20

 74:8

sister's

 61:6

 71:11

sit

 88:3

sitting

 85:11

situation

 18:15

 30:21

 48:12

 83:11,15,

 21 87:8

SMASH

 20:23,24

soft

 35:10,18

 67:12

songs

 88:13

Soo

 36:4,8,9,

 10

sought

 89:13

south

 51:14

southeast

 51:14

spar

 20:25

speaking

 31:6

 78:18

specialist

 24:1

 45:23

specificall

y

 51:9

speculation

 68:4

 74:11

 92:10

spell

 9:15 36:8

spelling

 50:1

spend

 31:17

 33:17

 34:1 35:4

 36:18

 40:4 49:2

 58:11

 69:24

 70:1

 72:14

spending

 11:23

 34:4

 37:10

 69:22

 82:17

spent

 33:20

 34:16

 61:5

 82:15

spiritual

 76:24

split

 26:9

spoken

 79:24

stable

 61:18

stage

 36:23

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: schooling..stage

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

stance

 79:11

standpoint

 30:20

stands

 95:17

start

 12:15

 34:8 44:1

 46:17

 55:5 58:8

started

 15:3

 37:4,5

 44:23

 46:20

 47:5,14,

 15 58:12

starting

 39:12

 47:12

state

 5:11

 13:13,14,

 15,17

 15:3,4,5

 23:12

 44:24

 46:3,7,

 18,20,23

 52:5 80:6

statutory

 57:18

 86:18

 95:16

stay

 41:3,4,

 23,24,25

 42:2,18,

 20 43:3

 72:17

stayed

 22:3 42:2

 50:11

 62:13

 70:12

 71:5

staying

 72:1

stays

 81:12

 82:12

stepdad

 28:17,18

stepfather

 35:25

 85:25

 86:2

stick

 44:19

Stillwell

 5:14,23

 6:1,7,10,

 17,24

 7:6,19

 8:2,9,19,

 21 27:4

 33:7,11

 36:13,15,

 17 38:3,7

 49:18

 54:15

 60:3

 62:20,22

 63:6 67:6

 68:2,9

 74:13,14,

 24 75:2

 77:10

 81:16

 90:10

 92:12,18,

 20,23,25

 93:3

 94:17

 95:13,16,

 21 98:15,

 17

stints

 82:12

stipulation

s

 5:12

stolen

 91:22

stop

 76:2

stopped

 54:5

straightfor

ward

 19:17

strike

 60:17

 95:23

structured

 18:15

struggled

 78:7

studied

 67:19

stuff

 11:22

 17:15

 20:11

 21:4,17

 58:15

 59:11

 61:15

 83:22

 84:9

stunt

 14:3 17:9

 19:20

 20:2

stuntman

 11:20

 12:6,8,19

 17:25

 19:8,9,16

 20:10,21

stuntmen

 20:16

style

 35:11,12,

 18 36:11

styles

 35:23

 36:2

subdual

 93:20

sudden

 88:2,10

summer

 47:12,13,

 16,17

supervisor

 24:7

supposed

 56:2

surprise

 82:11

Sweeney

 70:21,25

 71:7

Sweeney's

 71:6

switched

 44:14

sword

 74:7,18

 75:4

sworn

 5:13,25

 8:6 10:23

T

Tae

 36:12

taking

 7:20

 47:16

 90:7

talk

 20:5 48:7

 57:1

 66:15

 67:8

 79:21

 88:1,3

talked

 20:4 25:8

 88:10

 95:12

talking

 14:13

 24:22

 54:3,5

 65:19

 84:11

 87:6

Tang

 36:4,8,9,

 10

Tanya

 27:12

 31:15

Tape

 5:3

Tarango

 5:16

taught

 34:23

 35:16

 36:1 77:7

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: stance..taught

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

teach

 20:19

 35:1

 37:17

 76:23,24

 77:6

teaching

 34:13

 68:17,22

 69:4 77:3

team

 16:18

technical

 28:12

telling

 32:23

 95:5

Tempe

 51:19

ten

 40:21

 57:10

tensed

 78:7

terms

 94:9

testified

 8:6 39:1

 62:15

 77:13,16

 81:17

testify

 10:7,11,

 14 94:10

testifying

 11:3

testimony

 54:14,16

 63:5

 92:22

text

 58:15

 63:14

 84:6

thing

 32:24

 35:22

 37:13

 49:20

 53:23

 77:1,14

 94:19

things

 7:13

 55:10

 91:13,21

thinking

 44:4 56:1

 84:12

Thompson

 70:8

 71:23,24

 72:4,10,

 23 73:5

 74:8 76:5

Thompson's

 73:16

 74:5

threats

 74:7

time

 5:5 6:21

 11:23

 12:20

 13:3 15:4

 18:8,13,

 17 23:2

 25:8,15,

 21,24

 27:23,24

 30:8,9

 31:1,14

 32:14,21

 33:17,19,

 20,24

 34:2,4,

 14,16,24

 35:4

 36:18,21

 37:10,15

 38:17,21,

 25 39:3,

 7,11

 40:4,25

 41:9,12

 42:10,23

 43:10,20

 44:8,23

 45:4,5,22

 46:21

 47:23

 48:3,6

 49:2,13,

 16 55:19

 56:19

 58:11

 59:22

 60:21

 61:1,6,8,

 14,17

 63:16

 66:4

 69:11

 71:22

 72:14,20

 73:20

 74:3

 78:17

 79:22,24

 80:8,9

 81:7,19,

 20,23

 82:2,5,

 15,18,20,

 21 83:1,

 10 84:2,7

 85:7,16

 86:10

 91:10,11,

 19,22

 92:1 96:5

 98:21

times

 8:13,14

 15:23

 24:21

 25:5,18

 26:3

 31:16

 32:18

 36:4

 37:18,20

 38:19

 39:2

 41:12,13,

 14 45:14

 48:1,11

 50:15

 56:5

 58:10,23

 60:10

 61:11

 63:11

 65:3 67:4

 69:23,25

 81:10

 82:10,24

 84:13

today

 6:3,12,18

 8:23 9:19

 10:8,25

 57:5

today's

 8:11

told

 46:3,18

 54:23

 55:16

 78:10

 80:17

 86:3

 87:3,23

 97:3,14

 98:5

Tonya

 59:24

 70:8,12

 71:23

top

 37:15

tournament

 36:5

toxicology

 94:18

track

 83:19

tradition

 11:25

 37:17

traditional

 37:14

train

 20:1,18

 21:16

trainer

 23:23

training

 20:6,9

 21:19

 76:16

 77:12,21

transcript

 98:19

transfer

 13:17

traumatized

 96:20

traumatizin

g

 88:16

 97:6

travel

 42:18

trespass-

 53:20

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: teach..trespass800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

trespassing

 53:20

triggered

 40:10

true

 97:24

truthfully

 7:16

 10:15

 11:1

turned

 79:10

tux

 55:25

TV

 17:21

TVS

 17:24

type

 32:24

 34:25

 35:5 69:9

 77:9

 90:12,20

U

u-h-m

 27:8

uh-huh

 5:21 6:23

 8:12

 11:14

 13:6,15

 15:5

 16:10

 20:3,13

 21:25

 22:7,11,

 18 23:14

 24:5

 26:23

 27:1,2

 29:1

 31:24

 32:15

 35:15

 40:16

 41:22

 42:17

 45:8,21

 46:9

 47:1,6

 49:23

 50:13

 54:6,11

 56:17

 57:9,12

 58:1,3

 61:16

 63:19

 69:20

 70:6

 71:25

 72:8

 76:17

 77:17

 78:19

 83:16

Uh-uh

 79:18

unaware

 71:21

 76:14

underneath

 93:15

understand

 7:8,10

 10:14,22

 11:4 40:4

 57:4,18

 92:3,4,6

 96:1

understanda

bly

 96:21

understandi

ng

 57:16

 59:5

 97:10

understood

 7:14

universitie

s

 34:25

unlawful

 78:4

upbringing

 34:19

upset

 40:2,8

 54:10

V

V-I-N-C-EN-T

 50:2

vacation

 22:3

venue

 51:5

venues

 50:22

verbal

 7:22,25

verge

 91:21

versa

 42:10

 48:23

version

 35:10

vice

 42:10

 48:23

video

 7:21

 87:14,15

 97:7

videotape

 87:8

videotapes

 10:1

Vincent

 49:25

violence

 71:18

 72:22

 73:4,11

visit

 26:6,8,9

 32:13

 49:1

 62:16,17

 66:1

 69:21

 80:18

 83:17,18

visited

 41:9

 70:11

 79:17

 82:14

visiting

 48:17

vividly

 32:20

W

wait

 92:17

walk

 56:1

wanted

 6:13 12:4

 13:1,24

 14:4

 35:19,20

 36:6

 40:4,5

 44:12,14,

 19,22

 48:12

 49:20

 50:23,25

 51:5

 55:18,22

 56:5,11

 69:1

 80:18

 90:12,20

wanting

 56:7

warehouse

 21:2

watch

 87:10,16,

 17 97:7

ways

 34:15

wear

 88:13

wedding

 22:13

 50:18,21

 51:1,4

 63:17

 66:4

weed

 52:11,17

week

 22:4,22

 38:16,25

 41:3,4

 42:3,4,24

 43:2,3

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: trespassing..week

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com
MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com

 69:19

weekend

 70:2

 72:17

weeks

 18:17

welcoming

 65:10

west

 51:15

Westview

 43:12

wife

 9:12

 23:11

 26:4

 46:3,5

 86:2

wife's

 9:13

Williams

 5:7

withdrawn

 52:5

 53:6,7

word

 7:20

work

 11:21

 12:5,6,9,

 19 13:12

 14:3

 15:6,11,

 13,15,16,

 19 16:18

 17:9,25

 19:10,16

 20:2

 42:22

 45:11,16,

 17,24

 85:6,7,

 15,21,23

worked

 13:13,15

 14:8,10

 15:9,22

 16:5,11

 44:25

 68:16

 69:7,8

working

 12:16

 13:25

 14:1,16

 16:14,15

 23:20

 34:2

 44:24

 45:5,6,

 15,19

 46:20

 47:15

 85:6

works

 19:19

 23:12,16,

 20

worried

 79:2

 85:18

wrong

 85:11,17

Y

year

 11:16

 12:22

 13:7

 21:24

 23:3 26:2

 40:17

 44:11,17

 45:2,4,25

 46:12

 47:9,10,

 20 59:8

 73:21

 78:14

yearly

 48:2

years

 12:18

 43:15,18

 46:1,13

 47:20

 48:4,9

 53:11

 54:4

 62:10

 68:14

 80:2 81:4

 83:6

 84:14

 91:16

Yesterday

 9:3

York

 34:12

young

 27:23

 28:6

 29:10

 32:1

 34:3,14

 58:22

 61:4

younger

 11:22

Youtube

 87:14

 97:6

Youtubing

 87:13

Z

Z-H-A-N-E

 9:16 50:2

Zarinah

 24:21

 30:11,12,

 16 31:1,

 3,5,7,9,

 12,16,21

 32:13,17

 58:4

 59:21

 62:6

 63:10,20

 64:4,6,

 15,24

 84:1

Zhane

 9:14

 49:25

MUHAMMAD MUHAYMIN

MUHAYMIN vsCITY OF PHOENIX

December 06, 2019

Index: weekend..Zhane

800.211.DEPO (3376)

EsquireSolutions.com